Identification of collagen fibril fusion during vertebrate tendon morphogenesis. The process relies on unipolar fibrils and is regulated by collagen-proteoglycan interaction

The synthesis of an extracellular matrix containing long (approximately mm in length) collagen fibrils is fundamental to the normal morphogenesis of animal tissues. In this study we have direct evidence that fibroblasts synthesise transient early fibril intermediates (approximately 1 micrometer in length) that interact by tip-to-tip fusion to generate long fibrils seen in older tissues. Examination of early collagen fibrils from tendon showed that two types of early fibrils occur: unipolar fibrils (with carboxyl (C) and amino (N) ends) and bipolar fibrils (with two N-ends). End-to-end fusion requires the C-end of a unipolar fibril. Proteoglycans coated the shafts of the fibrils but not the tips. In the absence of proteoglycans the fibrils aggregated by side-to-side interactions. Therefore, proteoglycans promote tip-to-tip fusion and inhibit side-to-side fusion. This distribution of proteoglycan along the fibril required co-assembly of collagen and proteoglycan prior to fibril assembly. The study showed that collagen fibrillogenesis is a hierarchical process that depends on the unique structure of unipolar fibrils and a novel function of proteoglycans.     

Is the tendon embryogenesis process resurrected during tendon healing?

The process of embryonic tendon development, including the nature and purpose of collagen fibril segments, is reviewed. It is proposed that tendon fibrillogenesis of repair is related to the fibrillogenesis of tendon embryonic development. The assembly of collagen fibril segment units into longer fibers occurs on the surface of tendon fibroblasts in embryonic tendon development. The biochemist's view of tendon healing, whereby the spontaneous polymerization of tropocollagen monomers regenerates lost tendon collagen fibers, needs to be reconsidered. Furthermore, the importance of direct fibroblast involvement in collagen fiber reassembly during tendon healing needs to be studied in tendon intrinsic regenerative repair.     

Extracellular compartments in tendon morphogenesis: collagen fibril, bundle, and macroaggregate formation

The formation of collagen fibrils, fibril bundles, and tissue-specific collagen macroaggregates by chick embryo tendon fibroblasts was studied using conventional and high voltage electron microscopy. During chick tendon morphogenesis, there are at least three extracellular compartments responsible for three levels of matrix organization: collagen fibrils, bundles, and collagen macroaggregates. Our observations indicate that the initial extracellular events in collagen fibrillogenesis occur within narrow cytoplasmic recesses, presumably under close cellular regulation. Collagen fibrils are formed within these deep, narrow recesses, which are continuous with the extracellular space. Where these narrow recesses fuse with the cell surface, it becomes highly convoluted with folds and processes that envelope forming fibril bundles. The bundles laterally associate and coalesce, forming aggregates within a third cell-defined extracellular compartment. Our interpretation is that this third compartment forms as cell processes retract and cytoplasm is withdrawn between bundles. These studies define a hierarchical organization within the tendon, extending from fibril assembly to fascicle formation. Correlation of different levels of extracellular compartmentalization with tissue architecture provides insight into the cellular controls involved in collagen fibril and higher order assembly and a better understanding of how collagen fibrils are collected into structural groups, positioned, and woven into functional tissue-specific collagen macroaggregates.     

COMP acts as a catalyst in collagen fibrillogenesis

We have previously reported that COMP (cartilage oligomeric matrix protein) is prominent in cartilage but is also present in tendon and binds to collagens I and II with high affinity. Here we show that COMP influences the fibril formation of these collagens. Fibril formation in the presence of pentameric COMP was much faster, and the amount of collagen in fibrillar form was markedly increased. Monomeric COMP, lacking the N-terminal coiled-coil linker domain, decelerated fibrillogenesis. The data show that stimulation of collagen fibrillogenesis depends on the pentameric nature of COMP and not only on collagen binding. COMP interacts primarily with free collagen I and II molecules, bringing several molecules to close proximity, apparently promoting further assembly. These assemblies further join in discrete steps to a narrow distribution of completed fibril diameters of 149 +/- 16 nm with a banding pattern of 67 nm. COMP is not found associated with the mature fibril and dissociates from the collagen molecules or their early assemblies. However, a few COMP molecules are found bound to more loosely associated molecules at the tip/end of the growing fibril. Thus, COMP appears to catalyze the fibril formation by promoting early association of collagen molecules leading to increased rate of fibrillogenesis and more distinct organization of the fibrils.     

Coalignment of plasma membrane channels and protrusions (fibripositors) specifies the parallelism of tendon

The functional properties of tendon require an extracellular matrix (ECM) rich in elongated collagen fibrils in parallel register. We sought to understand how embryonic fibroblasts elaborate this exquisite arrangement of fibrils. We show that procollagen processing and collagen fibrillogenesis are initiated in Golgi to plasma membrane carriers (GPCs). These carriers and their cargo of 28-nm-diam fibrils are targeted to previously unidentified plasma membrane (PM) protrusions (here designated "fibripositors") that are parallel to the tendon axis and project into parallel channels between cells. The base of the fibripositor lumen (buried several microns within the cell) is a nucleation site of collagen fibrillogenesis. The tip of the fibripositor is the site of fibril deposition to the ECM. Fibripositors are absent at postnatal stages when fibrils increase in diameter by accretion of extracellular collagen, thereby maintaining parallelism of the tendon. Thus, we show that the parallelism of tendon is determined by the late secretory pathway and interaction of adjacent PMs to form extracellular channels.     

Differential expression of lumican and fibromodulin regulate collagen fibrillogenesis in developing mouse tendons

Collagen fibrillogenesis is finely regulated during development of tissue-specific extracellular matrices. The role(s) of a leucine-rich repeat protein subfamily in the regulation of fibrillogenesis during tendon development were defined. Lumican-, fibromodulin-, and double-deficient mice demonstrated disruptions in fibrillogenesis. With development, the amount of lumican decreases to barely detectable levels while fibromodulin increases significantly, and these changing patterns may regulate this process. Electron microscopic analysis demonstrated structural abnormalities in the fibrils and alterations in the progression through different assembly steps. In lumican-deficient tendons, alterations were observed early and the mature tendon was nearly normal. Fibromodulin-deficient tendons were comparable with the lumican-null in early developmental periods and acquired a severe phenotype by maturation. The double-deficient mice had a phenotype that was additive early and comparable with the fibromodulin-deficient mice at maturation. Therefore, lumican and fibromodulin both influence initial assembly of intermediates and the entry into fibril growth, while fibromodulin facilitates the progression through growth steps leading to mature fibrils. The observed increased ratio of fibromodulin to lumican and a competition for the same binding site could mediate these transitions. These studies indicate that lumican and fibromodulin have different developmental stage and leucine-rich repeat protein specific functions in the regulation of fibrillogenesis.     

Collagen fibril assembly and deposition in the developing dermis: segmental deposition in extracellular compartments

The hierarchy of extracytoplasmic compartmentalization and fibrillar organization as well as the assembly and deposition of collagen fibrils was characterized in the 15-day chick embryo dermis using transmission electron microscopy. At least two levels of extracellular compartmentalization are recognizable at this stage of dermal development. The first compartment consists of a series of narrow channels containing single or small groups (less than 5) of collagen fibrils. These channels course deep within the cell and are open to the extracellular space. The second extracellular compartment consists of fibrils grouped as small bundles in close association with the cell surface and is most often defined by a single fibroblast. A third level of fibril organization and compartmentalization is sometimes apparent at this stage of dermal development consisting of laterally associated bundles, more characteristic of the mature dermis. This compartment is associated with the fibroblast surface, but is less well defined than the fibril channels or bundle-forming compartments. Dermal collagen fibrils within bundles are discontinuous. Numerous fibrils ends are identified from serial sections and the ends gradually taper. These data indicate that the dermal fibroblast compartmentalizes the extracellular space and deposits collagen fibril segments during dermal morphogenesis. A model for the genesis of the extracellular compartments and their role in collagen fibrillogenesis and development of regularly arranged connective tissues, tendon, and cornea has been proposed. Dermal development conforms to this model and we suggest that extracytoplasmic compartmentalization of the steps in matrix assembly and segmental deposition of collagen fibrils are important mechanisms in the development of a wide variety of connective tissues.     

Collagen fibril assembly by corneal fibroblasts in three-dimensional collagen gel cultures: small-diameter heterotypic fibrils are deposited in the absence of keratan sulfate proteoglycan.

Extracellular matrix assembly is a multistep process and the various steps in collagen fibrillogenesis are thought to be influenced by a number of factors, including other noncollagenous matrix molecules. The synthesis and deposition of extracellular matrix by corneal fibroblasts grown within three-dimensional collagen gel cultures were examined to elucidate the factors important in the establishment of tissue-specific matrix architecture. Corneal fibroblasts in collagen gel cultures form layers and deposit small-diameter collagen fibrils (approximately 25 nm) typical of the mature corneal stroma. The matrix synthesized contains type VI collagen in a filamentous network and type I and type V collagen assembled as heterotypic fibrils. The amount of type V collagen synthesized is relatively high and comparable to that seen in the corneal stroma. This matrix is deposited between cell layers in a manner reminiscent of the secondary corneal stroma, but is not deposited as densely or as organized as would be found in situ. No keratan sulfate proteoglycan, a proteoglycan found only in the corneal stroma, was synthesized by the fibroblasts in the collagen gel cultures. The assembly and deposition of small-diameter fibrils with a collagen composition and structure identical to that seen in the corneal stroma in the absence of proteoglycans typical of the secondary corneal stroma imply that although proteoglycan-collagen interactions may function in the establishment of interfibrillar spacing and lamellar organization, collagen-collagen interactions are the major parameter in the regulation of fibril diameter.     

Dysfunctional tendon collagen fibrillogenesis in collagen VI null mice

Tendons are composed of fibroblasts and collagen fibrils. The fibrils are organized uniaxially and grouped together into fibers. Collagen VI is a non-fibrillar collagen expressed in developing and adult tendons. Human collagen VI mutations result in muscular dystrophy, joint hyperlaxity and contractures. The purpose of this study is to determine the functional roles of collagen VI in tendon matrix assembly. During tendon development, collagen VI was expressed throughout the extracellular matrix, but enriched around fibroblasts and their processes. To analyze the functional roles of collagen VI a mouse model with a targeted inactivation of Col6a1 gene was utilized. Ultrastructural analysis of Col6a1−/− versus wild type tendons demonstrated disorganized extracellular micro-domains and associated collagen fibers in the Col6a1−/− tendon. In Col6a1−/− tendons, fibril structure and diameter distribution were abnormal compared to wild type controls. The diameter distributions were shifted significantly toward the smaller diameters in Col6a1−/− tendons compared to controls. An analysis of fibril density (number/μm²) demonstrated a ~ 2.5 fold increase in the Col6a1−/− versus wild type tendons. In addition, the fibril arrangement and structure were aberrant in the peri-cellular regions of Col6a1−/− tendons with frequent very large fibrils and twisted fibrils observed restricted to this region. The biomechanical properties were analyzed in mature tendons. A significant decrease in cross-sectional area was observed. The percent relaxation, maximum load, maximum stress, stiffness and modulus were analyzed and Col6a1−/− tendons demonstrated a significant reduction in maximum load and stiffness compared to wild type tendons. An increase in matrix metalloproteinase activity was suggested in the absence of collagen VI. This suggests alterations in tenocyte expression due to disruption of cell-matrix interactions. The changes in expression may result in alterations in the peri-cellular environment. In addition, the absence of collagen VI may alter the sequestering of regulatory molecules such as leucine rich proteoglycans. These changes would result in dysfunctional regulation of tendon fibrillogenesis indirectly mediated by collagen VI.     

Collagen fibrillogenesis: fibronectin, integrins, and minor collagens as organizers and nucleators

Collagens are triple helical proteins that occur in the extracellular matrix (ECM) and at the cell-ECM interface. There are more than 30 collagens and collagen-related proteins but the most abundant are collagens I and II that exist as D-periodic (where D=67nm) fibrils. The fibrils are of broad biomedical importance and have central roles in embryogenesis, arthritis, tissue repair, fibrosis, tumor invasion, and cardiovascular disease. Collagens I and II spontaneously form fibrils in vitro, which shows that collagen fibrillogenesis is a selfassembly process. However, the situation in vivo is not that simple; collagen I-containing fibrils do not form in the absence of fibronectin, fibronectin-binding and collagen-binding integrins, and collagen V. Likewise, the thin collagen II-containing fibrils in cartilage do not form in the absence of collagen XI. Thus, in vivo, cellular mechanisms are in place to control what is otherwise a protein self-assembly process. This review puts forward a working hypothesis for how fibronectin and integrins (the organizers) determine the site of fibril assembly, and collagens V and XI (the nucleators) initiate collagen fibrillogenesis.     

Macromolecular specificity of collagen fibrillogenesis: fibrils of collagens I and XI contain a heterotypic alloyed core and a collagen I sheath

Suprastructures of the extracellular matrix, such as banded collagen fibrils, microfibrils, filaments, or networks, are composites comprising more than one type of macromolecule. The suprastructural diversity reflects tissue-specific requirements and is achieved by formation of macromolecular composites that often share their main molecular components alloyed with minor components. Both, the mechanisms of formation and the final macromolecular organizations depend on the identity of the components and their quantitative contribution. Collagen I is the predominant matrix constituent in many tissues and aggregates with other collagens and/or fibril-associated macromolecules into distinct types of banded fibrils. Here, we studied co-assembly of collagens I and XI, which co-exist in fibrils of several normal and pathologically altered tissues, including fibrous cartilage and bone, or osteoarthritic joints. Immediately upon initiation of fibrillogenesis, the proteins co-assembled into alloy-like stubby aggregates that represented efficient nucleation sites for the formation of composite fibrils. Propagation of fibrillogenesis occurred by exclusive accretion of collagen I to yield composite fibrils of highly variable diameters. Therefore, collagen I/XI fibrils strikingly differed from the homogeneous fibrillar alloy generated by collagens II and XI, although the constituent polypeptides of collagens I and II are highly homologous. Thus, the mode of aggregation of collagens into vastly diverse fibrillar composites is finely tuned by subtle differences in molecular structures through formation of macromolecular alloys.     

Matricellular hevin regulates decorin production and collagen assembly

Matricellular proteins such as SPARC, thrombospondin 1 and 2, and tenascin C and X subserve important functions in extracellular matrix synthesis and cellular adhesion to extracellular matrix. By virtue of its reported interaction with collagen I and deadhesive activity on cells, we hypothesized that hevin, a member of the SPARC gene family, regulates dermal extracellular matrix and collagen fibril formation. We present evidence for an altered collagen matrix and levels of the proteoglycan decorin in the normal dermis and dermal wound bed of hevin-null mice. The dermal elastic modulus was also enhanced in hevin-null animals. The levels of decorin protein secreted by hevin-null dermal fibroblasts were increased by exogenous hevin in vitro, data indicating that hevin might regulate both decorin and collagen fibrillogenesis. We also report a decorin-independent function for hevin in collagen fibrillogenesis. In vitro fibrillogenesis assays indicated that hevin enhanced fibril formation kinetics. Furthermore, cell adhesion assays indicated that cells adhered differently to collagen fibrils formed in the presence of hevin. Our observations support the capacity of hevin to modulate the structure of dermal extracellular matrix, specifically by its regulation of decorin levels and collagen fibril assembly.     

The roles of types XII and XIV collagen in fibrillogenesis and matrix assembly in the developing cornea

Corneal transparency depends on the architecture of the stromal extracellular matrix, including fibril diameter, packing, and lamellar organization. The roles of collagen types XII and XIV in regulation of corneal fibrillogenesis and development were examined. The temporal and spatial expression patterns were analyzed using semi-quantitative RT-PCR, in situ hybridization, Western analysis, and immunohistochemistry. Expression of types XII and XIV collagens in cornea development demonstrated that type XII collagen mRNA levels are constant throughout development (10D-adult) while type XIV mRNA is highest in early embryonic stages (10D-14D), decreasing significantly by hatching. The spatial expression patterns of types XII and XIV collagens demonstrated a homogeneous signal in the stroma for type XIV collagen, while type XII collagen shows segregation to the sub-epithelial and sub-endothelial stroma during embryonic stages. The type XII collagen in the anterior stroma was an epithelial product during development while fibroblasts contributed in the adult. Type XIV collagen expression was highest early in development and was absent by hatching. Both types XII and type XIV collagen have different isoforms generated by alternative splicing that may alter specific interactions important in fibrillogenesis, fibril-fibril interactions, and higher order matrix assembly. Analysis of these splice variants demonstrated that the long XII mRNA levels were constant throughout development, while the short XII NC3 mRNA levels peaked early (12D) followed by a decrease. Both type XIV collagen NC1 splice variants are highest during early stages (12D-14D) decreasing by 17D of development. These data suggest type XII collagen may have a role in development of stromal architecture and maintenance of fibril organization, while type XIV collagen may have a role in regulation of fibrillogenesis.     

Electron microscopy in cell-matrix research

Tissue development in multicellular animals relies on the ability of cells to synthesise an extracellular matrix (ECM) containing spatially-organised fibrous assemblies, the most widespread of which is based on collagen fibrils whose length greatly exceeds that of individual cells. The importance of the correct regulation of fibril deposition is exemplified in diseases such as osteogenesis imperfecta (caused by mutations in collagen genes), fibrosis (caused by ectopic accumulation of collagen) and cardiovascular disease (which involves cells and macromolecules binding to collagen in the vessel wall). Much is known about the molecular biology of collagens but less is known about collagen fibril structure and how the fibrils are formed (fibrillogenesis). This is explained in part by the fact that the fibrils are non-crystalline, extensively cross-linked, and very large, which makes them refractory to study by conventional biochemical and high-resolution structure-determination techniques. Electron microscopy has become established as the method of choice for studying collagen fibril structure and assembly, and this article describes the electron microscope methods most often used.     

Deficiency of tenascin-X causes a decrease in the level of expression of type VI collagen

Tenascin-X (TNX) is an extracellular matrix glycoprotein. We previously demonstrated that TNX-null fibroblasts exhibit decreased cell-matrix and cell-cell adhesion. In this study, we used a differential display technique to determine the genes involved in this process. Differential display analysis of wild-type and TNX-null fibroblasts revealed that mRNA expression level of type VI collagen alpha3 is predominantly decreased in TNX-null fibroblasts. Expression levels of mRNAs of other subunits of type VI collagen, alpha2 and alpha3 chains, were also remarkably decreased in TNX-null fibroblasts. The protein level of alpha3 chain of type VI collagen was also reduced in TNX-null fibroblasts. However, the organization of type VI collagen in the extracellular matrix of TNX-null fibroblasts was similar to that of wild-type fibroblasts. Transient expression of TNX in Balb3T3 cells caused an increase in the level of mRNA of type VI collagen compared with that in vector control and increased the promoter activity of type VI collagen alpha1 subunit gene. In addition, the expression levels of type I collagen and other collagen fibril-associated molecules such as type XII and type XIV collagens, decorin, lumican and fibromodulin in wild-type and TNX-null fibroblasts were compared. It was found that the mRNA expression levels of type I collagen and collagen fibril-associated molecules other than decorin were decreased and that the expression level of decorin was increased in TNX-null fibroblasts. The results suggest the possibility that TNX mediates not only cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions but also fibrillogenesis via collagen fibril-associated molecules.     

Proteomic analysis of Col11a1-associated protein complexes

Cartilage plays an essential role during skeletal development within the growth plate and in articular joint function. Interactions between the collagen fibrils and other extracellular matrix molecules maintain structural integrity of cartilage, orchestrate complex dynamic events during embryonic development, and help to regulate fibrillogenesis. To increase our understanding of these events, affinity chromatography and liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry were used to identify proteins that interact with the collagen fibril surface via the amino terminal domain of collagen α1(XI) a protein domain that is displayed at the surface of heterotypic collagen fibrils of cartilage. Proteins extracted from fetal bovine cartilage using homogenization in high ionic strength buffer were selected based on affinity for the amino terminal noncollagenous domain of collagen α1(XI). MS was used to determine the amino acid sequence of tryptic fragments for protein identification. Extracellular matrix molecules and cellular proteins that were identified as interacting with the amino terminal domain of collagen α1(XI) directly or indirectly, included proteoglycans, collagens, and matricellular molecules, some of which also play a role in fibrillogenesis, while others are known to function in the maintenance of tissue integrity. Characterization of these molecular interactions will provide a more thorough understanding of how the extracellular matrix molecules of cartilage interact and what role collagen XI plays in the process of fibrillogenesis and maintenance of tissue integrity. Such information will aid tissue engineering and cartilage regeneration efforts to treat cartilage tissue damage and degeneration.     

Collagen fibril morphology and organization: implications for force transmission in ligament and tendon.

Connective tissue mechanical behavior is primarily determined by the composition and organization of collagen. In ligaments and tendons, type I collagen is the principal structural element of the extracellular matrix, which acts to transmit force between bones or bone and muscle, respectively. Therefore, characterization of collagen fibril morphology and organization in fetal and skeletally mature animals is essential to understanding how tissues develop and obtain their mechanical attributes. In this study, tendons and ligaments from fetal rat, bovine, and feline, and mature rat were examined with scanning electron microscopy. At early fetal developmental stages, collagen fibrils show fibril overlap and interweaving, apparent fibril ends, and numerous bifurcating/fusing fibrils. Late in fetal development, collagen fibril ends are still present and fibril bundles (fibers) are clearly visible. Examination of collagen fibrils from skeletally mature tissues, reveals highly organized regions but still include fibril interweaving, and regions that are more randomly organized. Fibril bifurcations/fusions are still present in mature tissues but are less numerous than in fetal tissue. To address the continuity of fibrils in mature tissues, fibrils were examined in individual micrographs and consecutive overlaid micrographs. Extensive microscopic analysis of mature tendons and ligaments detected no fibril ends. These data strongly suggest that fibrils in mature ligament and tendon are either continuous or functionally continuous. Based upon this information and published data, we conclude that force within these tissues is directly transferred through collagen fibrils and not through an interfibrillar coupling, such as a proteoglycan bridge.     

Procollagen intermediates during tendon fibrillogenesis

The purpose of this study was to correlate ultrastructural features of tendon collagen fibrils at various stages of development with the presence of procollagen, pN-collagen, pC-collagen, and the free amino propeptides and carboxyl propeptide of type I procollagen. Tendons from 10-, 14-, and 18-day chicken embryos reveal small, well-defined intercellular compartments containing collagen fibrils with diameters showing a unimodal distribution. At 21 days (hatching) and 9 days (post hatching) and at 5 weeks (post hatching), the compartments are larger, less well-defined, and there is multimodal distribution of tendon fibril diameters. Procollagen and the intermediates pN-collagen and pC-collagen are present in tendons up to 18 days. Thereafter there is a marked reduction in procollagen, whereas the intermediates persist throughout all stages of development. Similarly, free amino propeptides and carboxyl propeptides of type I procollagen were found at all stages. The amino propeptide of type III procollagen was restricted to the peritendineum until 7 weeks post hatching. At that time, a network of fibrils containing the amino propeptide of type III procollagen was seen delineating well-circumscribed compartments of collagen fibrils throughout the entire tendon. This study supports the notion that pN- and pC-collagen have an extracellular role and participate in collagen fibrillogenesis.     

Collagen V localizes to pericellular sites during tendon collagen fibrillogenesis

During tendon development collagen fibrillogenesis occurs in extracellular micro-domains defined by the tenocytes. This permits cellular regulation of the extracellular steps involved in the tissue-specific matrix assembly required for function. The hypothesis tested here is that collagen V associates with the tenocyte surface where it functions in regulation of collagen assembly and cell-directed fibril deposition. The in vitro and in vivo data demonstrate that collagen V is a quantitatively minor component of the tendon. It is preferentially localized on the tenocyte surface as distinct foci in tendons and in cell culture. In vitro data indicate that this interaction with the tenocyte is not HSPG GAG-dependent. Collagen V is present as the mature, processed form, is absent from the media, and is a significant part of the detergent-insoluble cell layer, presumably as part of a membrane-associated complex. In contrast, procollagen I is not efficiently processed and is found predominantly in the culture media. Our data suggest that the regulatory role of collagen V requires collagen V to occupy a different cellular niche from the structural collagen I. In monolayer cultures, the conversion to the tissue form of collagen V and its deposition with the cell layer suggest efficient engagement of procollagen V with pericellular receptors and processing enzymes. The secretion of collagen I into the media and inefficient processing of procollagen I suggest reduced accessibility to these pericellular molecules due to disengagement from the cell surface. This all points to differential spatial localization of collagen V as a mechanism to optimize its regulatory roles during the cell-surface directed steps in tendon collagen fibril assembly.