Stationary phase-induction of G-->T mutations in Escherichia coli

A series of Escherichia coli mutants, constructed originally by Cupples and Miller [C.G. Cupples, J.H. Miller, A set of lacZ mutations in Escherichia coli that allow rapid detection of each of the six base substitutions, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 86 (1989) 5345-5349], provides a unique system for quantifying base-change mutations, and the repair processes that limit their establishment, in bacteria under selective and non-selective conditions. We focussed on one strain in which a T-->G replacement inactivates the lacZ gene. Reversions of this strain can occur through oxidation of G, leading to G-->T transversions. We show that spontaneous reversions occurred both in lactose (selective) and glucose (non-selective) medium. The number of revertants per viable cell was much greater in medium containing lactose or both sugars than glucose alone. In glucose medium, the rate of reversion was highest below 0.6% glucose and strongly inhibited at and above that level. Evidence that reversions occurred through G-->T transversions in both lactose and glucose media came from two observations: by sequence analysis of a series of revertants and by comparing the reversion rates in strains possessing and lacking the mutM gene (encoding formamidopyrimidine DNA glycosylase, FPG). However, the rate of reversion was stimulated by reducing O2 to 1% and inhibited or delayed by increasing O2 to 90%. In mutM- cells grown on glucose medium, the proportion of revertants increased over a 5-day period. In contrast, in mutM+ cells, revertants appeared primarily during the first 2-3 days after plating; few new revertants appeared in the following days. These data imply that base excision repair initiated by FPG was less effective in the first 2 days and more effective later in stationary phase.     

An Examination of Adaptive Reversion in Saccharomyces Cerevisiae

Reversion to Lys+ prototrophy in a haploid yeast strain containing a defined lys2 frameshift mutation has been examined. When cells were plated on synthetic complete medium lacking only lysine, the numbers of Lys+ revertant colonies accumulated in a time-dependent manner in the absence of any detectable increase in cell number. An examination of the distribution of the numbers of early appearing Lys+ colonies from independent cultures suggests that the mutations to prototrophy occurred randomly during nonselective growth. In contrast, an examination of the distribution of late appearing Lys+ colonies indicates that the underlying reversion events occurred after selective plating. No accumulation of Lys+ revertants occurred when cells were starved for tryptophan, leucine or both lysine and tryptophan prior to plating selectively for Lys+ revertants. These results indicate that mutations accumulate more frequently when they confer a selective advantage, and are thus consistent with the occurrence of adaptive mutations in yeast.     

A Search for a General Phenomenon of Adaptive Mutability

The most prominent systems for the study of adaptive mutability depend on the specialized activities of genetic elements like bacteriophage Mu and the F plasmid. Searching for general adaptive mutability, we have investigated the behavior of Salmonella typhimurium strains with chromosomal lacZ mutations. We have studied 30 revertible nonsense, missense, frameshift, and insertion alleles. One-third of the mutants produced >=10 late revertant colonies (appearing three to seven days after plating on selective medium). For the prolific mutants, the number of late revertants showed rank correlation with the residual β-galactosidase activity; for the same mutants, revertant number showed no correlation with the nonselective reversion rate (from fluctuation tests). Leaky mutants, which grew slowly on selective medium, produced late revertants whereas tight nongrowing mutants generally did not produce late revertants. However, the number of late revertants was not proportional to residual growth. Using total residual growth and the nonselective reversion rate, the expected number of late revertants was calculated. For several leaky mutants, the observed revertant number exceeded the expected number. We suggest that excess late revertants from these mutants arise from general adaptive mutability available to any chromosomal gene.     

Interferon-induced revertants of ras-transformed cells: resistance to transformation by specific oncogenes and retransformation by 5-azacytidine.

Prolonged alpha/beta interferon (IFN-alpha/beta) treatment of NIH 3T3 cells transformed by a long terminal repeat-activated Ha-ras proto-oncogene resulted in revertants that maintained a nontransformed phenotype long after IFN treatment had been discontinued. Cloned persistent revertants (PRs) produced large amounts of the ras-encoded p21 and were refractile to transformation by EJras DNA and by transforming retroviruses which carried the v-Ha-ras, v-Ki-ras, v-abl, or v-fes oncogene. Transient treatment either in vitro or in vivo with cytidine analogs that alter gene expression by inhibiting DNA methylation resulted in transformation of PR, but not of NIH 3T3, cells. The PR retransformants reverted again with IFN, suggesting that DNA methylation is involved in IFN-induced persistent reversion.     

Plasmid-dosage effects on ultraviolet, visible light and methyl methanesulfonate mutagenesis in Salmonella typhimurium

Salmonella typhimurium LT2 strains bearing plasmids pKM101, R64 or pColIb-P9 demonstrated enhanced UV survival when compared with strains not bearing plasmids. A strain of S. typhimurium bearing both pKM101 and pColIb-P9 survived UV irradiation slightly better than either of the single-plasmid strains. Spontaneous reversion of the hisG46 and trpE8 missense alleles was enhanced in each single-plasmid strain, and for the dual-plasmid strain containing pKM101 and pColIb-P9 enhancement represented a near additivity of the response seen for the single-plasmid strains. Following exposure to UV or visible-light irradiation, reversion of hisG46 and trpE8 was also enhanced in each single-plasmid strain, but quantitatively greater in the dual-plasmid strain and was equal to or slightly greater than additive the responses of the single-plasmid strains. In contrast to visible-light irradiation, UV exposure resulted in two phenotypic Trp+-revertant classes. One Trp+ class, having normal colony size (2.0 mm) and similar in number to His+ revertants, was comprised of intragenic revertants of trpE8, while the predominant Trp+ class, having smaller colony size (0.8 mm), represented intergenic suppressor revertants, illuminating the differences in mutation and/or repair specificity for UV and visible-light exposure. Methyl methane-sulfonate (MMS)-induced reversion of hisG46 was similar in effect to that seen with UV or visible-light irradiation. Plasmids pKM101 or pColIb-P9 enhanced the frequency of hisG46 reversion, while a more than additive response was seen in a strain with both plasmids. Furthermore, MMS-induced reversion of hisG46 was also observed to be greatest in a strain bearing plasmid R64 (incompatibility group I alpha) and pKM101, when compared with single-plasmid strains bearing either R64 or pKM101.     

Transformation of Neurospora crassa with the cloned am (glutamate dehydrogenase) gene.

We used DNA containing the am gene of Neurospora crassa, cloned in the lambda replacement vector lambdaL-47 (this clone is designated lambdaC-10), and plasmid vector subclones of this DNA to transform am deletion and point mutant strains. By means of subcloning, all sequences required for transformation to am prototrophy and expression of glutamate dehydrogenase have been shown to reside on a 2.5-kilobase BamHI fragment. We also characterized several am+ strains that were obtained after transformation with lambdaC-10. These strains showed Mendelian segregation of the am+ gene, although less than 50% of the transformed strains showed the normal linkage relationship of am with inl. In all cases tested, the strains had incorporated lambda DNA as well. The lambda DNA also showed a Mendelian segregation pattern. In one case, the incorporation of am DNA in a novel position was associated with a mutagenic event producing a strain with a very tight colonial morphology. In all cases in which the am+ gene had become the resident of a new chromosome, glutamate dehydrogenase was produced to only 10 to 20% of the wild-type levels.     

Deletion induction in bacteria. I. The role of mutagens and cellular error-prone repair

The amber mutation trpD28 of Salmonella typhimurium shows a complex reversion pattern on anthranilate (AA)-supplemented minimal medium. Under such conditions it is possible to recover revertants of two phenotypes, prototrophs (MM+) and anthranilate utilizers (AA+), each phenotype brought about by several mutational events. Since one class of AA+ revertants is caused by deletion of the trpD28 mutation, this constitutes a useful system for quantitative studies of the effects of mutagenic agents and cellular factors on the production of deletions. In the present study we have tried to assess the relative contribution of chemical mutagens vs. cellular mutator factors in causing this class of mutations. Strains of S. typhimurium in which the spontaneous reversion rate of trpD28 was modified by pKM101, (strain SO1007), mutL (strain SO1018) and both (strain SO1008), as well as the wild type (strain SO939) were treated with nitrous acid (HNO2) and mitomycin C (MC), mutagens reported to induce deletions in bacteria. The results showed that while the absolute frequency of deletions increased exponentially with dose of mutagen in parallel with the total reversion frequency, the relative frequency (percent) of these mutations was characteristic for each strain and for the most part unaffected by the dose of mutagen. It appears that deletions, spontaneous or induced, occur as a fixed percentage of total mutations and are brought about by the cells' own repair capacity and characteristic DNA metabolism. Perhaps these mutations are the result of untargeted events during SOS misrepair.     

Homologous recombination between overlapping thymidine kinase gene fragments stably inserted into a mouse cell genome.

We have constructed a substrate to study homologous recombination between adjacent segments of chromosomal DNA. This substrate, designated lambda tk2 , consists of one completely defective and one partially defective herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (tk) gene cloned in bacteriophage lambda DNA. The two genes have homologous 984-base-pair sequences and are separated by 3 kilobases of largely vector DNA. When lambda tk2 DNA was transferred into mouse LMtk- cells by the calcium phosphate method, rare TK+ transformants were obtained that contained many (greater than 40) copies of the unrecombined DNA. Tk- revertants, which had lost most of the copies of unrecombined DNA, were isolated from these TK+-transformed lines. Two of these Tk- lines were further studied by analysis of their reversion back to the Tk+ phenotype. They generated ca. 200 Tk+ revertants per 10(8) cells after growth in nonselecting medium for 5 days. All of these Tk+ revertants have an intact tk gene reconstructed by homologous recombination; they also retain various amounts of unrecombined lambda tk2 DNA. Southern blot analysis suggested that at least some of the recombination events involve unequal sister chromatid exchanges. We also tested three agents, mitomycin C, 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate, and mezerein, that are thought to stimulate recombination to determine whether they affect the reversion from Tk- to Tk+. Only mitomycin C increased the number of Tk+ revertants.     

Genetic transformation of rifampicin resistance in Lactobacillus acidophilus

Lactobacillus acidophilus strain 100-33, originally isolated from swine faeces, was transformed to rifampicin resistance with DNA from spontaneous rifampicin-resistant mutants derived from it. Cells of the recipient strain were treated with lysozyme and mutanolysin, mixed with donor DNA and polyethylene glycol and grown on a regeneration medium overnight. After 48 h incubation, the numbers of rifampicin-resistant cells in the populations of regenerated cells were estimated from numbers of colonies. Efficiency of the lysozyme/mutanolysin treatment (the ratio of the number of osmotically fragile cells after the enzyme treatment to the initial cell number) was about 99%. The regeneration frequency of the enzyme-treated cells varied from 5 to 67%. The transformation frequency varied from about 0.2 X 10(-8) to 8.0 X 10(-8) transformants per regenerated cell per microgram DNA. To our knowledge, this method for genetic transformation is the first to be reported for a Lactobacillus strain.     

Modulation of mutagenesis involving precise excision of transposon Tn10

Precise excision of transposon Tn10 results in reversion of the Trp- phenotype to Trp+ in a trp-1014::Tn10 strain of Salmonella typhimurium, and also occurs at a markedly higher frequency in a strain carrying the temperature-sensitive polA7 allele. The frequency with which precise excision events occurs can be modified by the plating medium, results indicating that the great majority of mutants which arise on broth-supplemented or tryptophan-supplemented minimal media actually arise on the selective plating medium. Trp+ revertants (1000) arising from excision of Tn10 were purified by re-streaking for single colonies; none were found to retain the Tn10 encoded resistance to tetracycline. Yields of Trp+ revertants of the polA7 strain were consistently higher when glycerol rather than glucose was used as sole carbon source in the selective medium. Clean excision of Tn10 can also be increased by ultraviolet irradiation in (R) plasmid-free strains, and is further increased in strains carrying an N-group plasmid (R205, R46 or pKM101). Ultraviolet-induced precise excision of Tn10 also occurs at a much enhanced frequency in a strain with a deletion through the uvrB gene; in this case, however, the addition of plasmid pKM101 leads to a decrease in yields of ultraviolet-induced precise excision events.     

UV-light induction of "true" revertants to adenine independence in Bacillus subtilis cells]

The UV-irradiation of Bacillus subtilis Mu5u8u16 (met5 leu8 purA) induces with relatively high frequency the revertants to adenine independence (Ade+) which form the rapidly growing morphologically uniform colonies on the solid selective medium. The genetic analysis of a portion of UV-induced Ade+ revertants (crosses in transformation system) has cleared up that their DNA does not contain the original mutation ade16. This means that they arise as the result of "true" reversions. This reversion in purA gene can serve as a good model for the study of UV-induced mutagenesis in a proximal structural locus of Bac. subtilis chromosome.     

Transfer of nitrate reductase genes of the cyanobacterium Nostoc muscorum into Rhizobium japonicum

Transformation of Rhizobium japonicum CB1809 was studied using DNA from the cyanobacterium Nostoc muscorum ATCC 27893. A spontaneous nitrate reductase deficient (Nar-) mutant (NR-6) of R. japonicum CB1809 was isolated with a frequency of 8.4 X 10(-7). Streptomycin (Sm) and Neomycin (Neo) resistance markers were introduced into strain NR-6, and the resulting strain was designated NR-6 SmR NeoR. Experiments with cyanobacterial DNA and live cells of strain NR-6 SmR NeoR indicated transformation of nitrate reductase (nar) genes of N. muscorum into this strain. This conclusion was supported by the reversion frequency of strain NR-6 SmR NeoR to Nar+ and the transformation frequency when recipient cells were exposed to N. muscorum DNA (with heat-treated DNA as control). Comparisons of growth, nitrate uptake, assimilatory nitrate reductase activity and nodulation of parent CB1809, NR-6 SmR NeoR and five transformant clones (Nar+) suggest that there may be considerable homology between the nar genes of R. japonicum CB1809 and N. muscorum.     

RecA-independent mutagenesis in Escherichia coli may be subject to glucose repression

The frameshift mutagen 9-aminoacridine (9AA) causes DNA damage via a recA+-independent mechanism in Escherichia coli. In this study we have exposed E. coli cells carrying the lacZ19124 frameshift marker to 9AA in defined minimal media, washed them, and plated to score for Lac+ revertants. Our results show that 9AA-induced reversion to Lac+ occurs in the absence of any exogenous carbon source and when cells are plated on media which do not allow much, if any, cell replication prior to expression of the revertant phenotype. When glycerol (1% w/v) was added to the liquid treatment medium, the number of Lac+ E. coli revertants was similar to that obtained when no carbon source was present. By contrast the addition of glucose (1% w/v) during the mutagenesis treatment caused a significant decrease in the number of revertants. Further experiments indicate that the repressing effects of glucose may be due to a reduction in cAMP concentration, since 9AA mutagenesis was abolished in a cya strain in which no adenylate cyclase is produced. These results are consistent with (but do not prove) the notion that at least one part of the process leading to 9AA mutagenesis is subject to catabolite repression.     

Reversibility of malignant transformation as affected by the oncogenic virus SV40. II. The characteristics of virus-induced revertant clones

Fifteen revertant clones exhibiting contact inhibition, one of the typical characteristics of normal cells, were studied after treatment of spontaneously transformed Chinese hamster fibroblasts with SV40. The clones proved to be partial revertants, as regards to other properties of the normal phenotype--loss of the ability to grow in a medium with a low serum content and anchorage-dependence. Viral DNA was detected in all revertant clones. The expression of T-antigen--the product of viral oncogene, was observed in 13 of 15 revertants analyzed. The study of SV40 "rescued" from several revertants in permissive monkey cells has shown that the virus is non-defective. In 7 clones, reversion was accompanied with polyploidization. In the cases, reversion could be due to changes in the balance between oncogenes and suppressor genes (anti-oncogenes). The possibility of induction by SV40 of mutations in anti-oncogenes suppressing the expression of both cellular and viral oncogenes is discussed. It is suggested that reversion to the normal phenotype in clones with a near-diploid karyotype could result from such virus-induced suppressor mutations.     

Biochemical characterization of the hamster thy mutator gene and its revertants

The thy- mutator phenotype of Chinese hamster ovary cells is distinguished by increased intracellular levels of dCTP, auxotrophy for thymidine, and elevated spontaneous mutational rates. To determine the biochemical lesion responsible for this complex phenotype, enzymes responsible for the synthesis of dCTP and dTTP were investigated. Levels of ribonucleotide reductase and dCMP deaminase were identical in mutant and wild type strains. In contrast, CTP synthetase activity in extracts from thy- strains was consistently altered in that 50% of enzyme activity was resistant to feedback inhibition by CTP. Additionally, thy- strains obtained by DNA transfection also had CTP-resistant CTP synthetase. Thy+ revertants lost the resistant enzyme, and total activity was reduced. CTP-resistant CTP synthetase was regained in thy- mutants reselected from thy+ revertants, but in these strains all activity was resistant. These experiments demonstrate that the thy- mutator phenotype is a consequence of a mutation of CTP synthetase and suggest that one pathway of reversion to the wild type state is by loss or inactivation of the mutant allele rendering the revertants hemizygous for the gene.     

A novel pleiotropic mutation in Escherichia coli K12 which affects transduction, transformation and rates of mutation.

A mutant strain of Escherichia coli K12, R2721, has been shown to differ from its parent strain, S491, in four associated phenotypic characters as a result of a single mutation. This strain did not give recombinants with DNA transduced by bacteriophage PI or bacteriophage Mu, nor transformats after exposure to R factor DNA: lysates of bacteriophage PI grown on this strain did not appear to contain any transducing particles when tested on normal recipients. Moreover, the reversion rates, both spontaneous and ultraviolet-induced, for two auxotrophic markers were reduced. The frequency of revertants was at least two orders of magnitude lower in cultures of R2721 than in cultures of S491I. Many of the rare revertants for one or other of the auxotrophic markers were found to have regained normal reversion frequencies for the other marker and for the capacity to be transduced. In all other respects, recombination in R2721 appeared normal, the frequency of chromosomal mobilization by and F' factor was unaffected and normal yields of recombinants were obtained from matings with Hfr strains. The only circumstance in which transduction of R2721 was observed was when the capacity to ferment galactose was selected and PI had been grown on a strain carrying lambdadgal when, presumably, integration was effected by the phage-coded gene products. The mutation has been located on the E. coli chromosone map between tonA and pro and has been given the symbol tdi (transduction inhibition). Double mutants, (tdi recA) and (tdi recB), have been isolated and show no unexpected properties.     

Characterization of flat revertant cells isolated from simian virus 40-transformed mouse and rat cells which contain multiple copies of viral genomes.

Eight clones of flat revertants were isolated by negative selection from simian virus 40 (SV40)-transformed mouse and rat cell lines in which two and six viral genome equivalents per cell were integrated, respectively. These revertants showed either a normal cell phenotype or a phenotype intermediate between normal and transformed cells as to cellular morphology and saturation density and were unable to grow in soft agar medium. One revertant derived from SV40-transformed mouse cells was T antigen positive, whereas the other seven revertants were T antigen negative. SV40 could be rescued only from the T-antigen-positive revertant by fusion with permissive monkey cells. The susceptibility of the revertants to retransformation by wild-type SV40 was variable among these revertants. T-antigen-negative revertants from SV40-transformed mouse cells were retransformed at a frequency of 3 to 10 times higher than their grandparental untransformed cells. In contrast, T-antigen-negative revertants from SV40-transformed rat cells could not be retransformed. The arrangement of viral genomes was analyzed by digestion of cellular DNA with restriction enzymes of different specificity, followed by detection of DNA fragments containing a viral sequence and rat cells were serially arranged within the length of about 30 kilobases, with at least two intervening cellular sequences. A head-to-tail tandem array of unit length viral genomes was present in at least one insertion site in the transformed rat cells. All of the revertants had undergone a deletion(s), and only a part of the viral genome was retained in T-antigen-negative revertants. A relatively high frequency of reversion in the transformed rat cells suggests that reversion occurs by homologous recombination between the integrated viral genomes.     

Transformation-defective virus mutants in a class of morphologic revertants of sarcoma virus transformed nonproducer cells

In studies of the viral and cellular functions involved in expression of transformation by murine sarcoma virus, selective methods have led to the isolation of morphologic revertants following mitomycin C mutagenization of nonproductively transformed mouse cells. The revertants exhibit normal growth properties, yet still contain the sarcoma virus. Further, they are as susceptible as normal cells to exogenous sarcoma virus infection. In the present studies, these revertants are shown to contain levels of sarcoma viral RNA quantitatively and qualitatively indistinguishable from that present in the parental transformed clone. Following rescue with helper leukemia virus, they release low levels of wild-type transforming virus and a large excess of transformation-defective sarcoma virus as measured by molecular hybridization. The defective viruses can be transmitted to new cells in the absence of morphologic alteration. These results provide strong evidence that the revertants contain mutant viruses defective in transforming functions. The release of wild-type sarcoma virus by cells in a revertant culture appears to occur concomitantly with the spontaneous appearance of retransformed cells. This suggests that the reversion of mutant virus to wild-type within the cell occurs as a result of reversion of a point mutation in the integrated sarcoma viral genome. The present sarcoma virus mutants appear to be the first obtained by spontaneous or chemically-induced genetic alteration of stably integrated virus in eucaryotic cells.     

Establishment of a dose-response relationship for reverse mutation at the HPRT (hypoxanthine guanine phosphoribosyl transferase) locus in L5178Y mouse lymphoma cells

L5178 mouse lymphoma cells were treated with the mismatching agent 6-hydroxy-aminopurine (HAP), a base analogue known to produce forward and reverse mutations in bacteria. Mutants with the phenotype deficient in hypoxanthine guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) were selected in 6-thioguanine (TG)-containing medium and isolated. Reverse mutations to Hhe HPRT-proficient phenotype oc occuredd both spontaneously and after treatment with ethyl nitrosourea (ENU), which suggested that the initial HAP treatment had induced point mutations at the HPRT locus.

Reconstruction experiments, in which a small number of wild-type cells together with different numbers of mutant cells were seeded in HAT medium, indicated that densities up to 10⁶ cells per ml can be used for the selection of revertants. Optimal expression of induced revertants was obtained two days after treatment.

The dose-response relationship for induction of reverse mutations by ENU appears not to deviate from linearity. The highest revertant frequency observed was 3.3 × 10⁻⁵ at an ENU concentration of 1 mM. The spontaneous reversion frequency per generation — based on 3 spontaneous revertants — was estimated to be 1.3 × 10⁻⁹. All revertants were indistinguishable from the parental wild-type line with respect to the activity as well as the electrophoretic mobility of HPRT.