Diversity and Complexity of Ceramide Signalling in Apoptosis

Sphingolipid ceramide has emerged as a lipid messenger of cell functions including differentiation and apoptosis. Diverse kinds of stresses (ultraviolet, irradiation, heat shock and hypoxia) and biological factors (TNF-, IFN-γ and Fas antibody) require ceramide generation to execute apoptosis. The review summarises the diversity and complexity of up- and downstream of ceramide signalling in apoptosis and clinical implications of ceramide-induced apoptosis.     

Sphingolipid-mediated apoptotic signaling pathways

Various sphingolipids are being viewed as bioactive molecules and/or second messengers. Among them, ceramide (or N-acylsphingosine) and sphingosine generally behave as pro-apoptotic mediators. Indeed, ceramide mediates the death signal initiated by numerous stress agents which either stimulate its de novo synthesis or activate sphingomyelinases that release ceramide from sphingomyelin. For instance, the early generation of ceramide promoted by TNF is mediated by a neutral sphingomyelinase the activity of which is regulated by the FAN adaptor protein, thereby controlling caspase activation and the cell death programme. In addition, the activity of this neutral sphingomyelinase is negatively modulated by caveolin, a major constituent of some membrane microdomains. The enzyme sphingosine kinase also plays a crucial role in apoptosis signalling by regulating the intracellular levels of two sphingolipids having opposite effects, namely the pro-apoptotic sphingosine and the anti-apoptotic sphingosine 1-phosphate molecule. Ceramide and sphingosine metabolism therefore appears as a pivotal regulatory pathway in the determination of cell fate.     

Exploring the link between ceramide and ionizing radiation

The aim of radiotherapy is to eradicate cancer cells with ionizing radiation; tumor cell death following irradiation can be induced by several signaling pathways, most of which are triggered as a consequence of DNA damage, the primary and major relevant cell response to radiation. Several lines of evidence demonstrated that ceramide, a crucial sensor and/or effector of different signalling pathways promoting cell cycle arrest, death and differentiation, is directly involved in the molecular mechanisms underlying cellular response to irradiation. Most of the studies strongly support a direct relationship between ceramide accumulation and radiation-induced cell death, mainly apoptosis; for this reason, defining the contribution of the multiple metabolic pathways leading to ceramide formation and the causes of its dysregulated metabolism represent the main goal in order to elucidate the ceramide-mediated signaling in radiotherapy. In this review, we summarize the current knowledge concerning the different routes leading to ceramide accumulation in radiation-induced cell response with particular regard to the role of the enzymes involved in both ceramide neogenesis and catabolism. Emphasis is placed on sphingolipid breakdown as mechanism of ceramide generation activated following cell irradiation; the functional relevance of this pathway, and the role of glycosphingolipid glycohydrolases as direct targets of ionizing radiation are also discussed. These new findings add a further attractive point of investigation to better define the complex interplay between sphingolipid metabolism and radiation therapy.     

Cannabinoids and ceramide: two lipids acting hand-by-hand

Cannabinoids, the active components of Cannabis sativa (marijuana) and their endogenous counterparts, exert their effects by binding to specific G-protein-coupled receptors that modulate adenylyl cyclase and ion channels. Recent research has shown that the CB1 cannabinoid receptor is also coupled to the generation of the lipid second messenger ceramide via two different pathways: sphingomyelin hydrolysis and ceramide synthesis de novo. Sustained ceramide accumulation in tumor cells mediates cannabinoid-induced apoptosis, as evidenced by in vitro and in vivo studies. This effect seems to be due to the impact of ceramide on key cell signalling systems such as the extracellular signal-regulated kinase cascade and the Akt pathway. These findings provide a new conceptual view on how cannabinoids act, and raise interesting physiological and therapeutic questions.     

Sphingomyelin-degrading pathways in human cells role in cell signalling

The ubiquitous sphingophospholipid sphingomyelin (SM) can be hydrolysed in human cells to ceramide by different sphingomyelinases (SMases). These enzymes exert a dual role, enabling not only the turnover of membrane SM and the degradation of exogenous (lipoprotein) SM, but also the signal-induced generation of the lipid second messenger ceramide. This review focuses on the function(s) of the different SMases in living cells. While both lysosomal and non-lysosomal pathways that ensure SM hydrolysis in intact cells can be distinguished, the precise contribution of each of these SM-cleaving enzymes to the production of ceramide as a signalling molecule remains to be clarified.     

Ceramide as a TLR4 agonist; a putative signalling intermediate between sphingolipid receptors for microbial ligands and TLR4

Mucosal Toll-like receptors (TLRs) respond to pathogens, but remain inert to the indigenous flora, suggesting that the TLRs can receive pathogen-specific signals. For example, TLR4 signalling is activated in CD14-negative epithelial cells by P-fimbriated, uropathogenic Escherichia coli, but not by lipopolysaccharide. The fimbriae use glycosphingolipids as recognition receptors and there is release of ceramide, which is the membrane-anchoring domain of the receptors. In this study, ceramide was identified as a TLR4 agonist and as a putative signalling intermediate between the glycosphingolipid recognition receptors and TLR4. Exogenous ceramide activated a TLR4-dependent epithelial cell response, as shown by exposing stably transfected TLR4-positive or -negative human embryonal kidney cells to C2 and C6 ceramide. A similar, TLR4-dependent response occurred after deliberate release of endogenous long-chained ceramide with sphingomyelinase. Microbial ligands with glycosphingolipid specificity (P fimbriae or the B subunit of Shiga toxin) were shown to increase the levels of ceramide and to trigger a TLR4-dependent response in epithelial cells. The results show that ceramide activates TLR4 signalling and suggest that this mechanism might allow pathogens to elicit mucosal TLR4 responses by perturbing sphingolipid receptors for virulence ligands like P fimbriae.     

Ceramide pathways modulate ethanol-induced cell death in astrocytes

We showed previously that alcohol exposure during in vivo brain development induced astroglial damage and caused cell death. Because ceramide modulates a number of biochemical and cellular responses to stress, including apoptosis, we now investigate whether ethanol-induced cell death in astrocytes is mediated by ceramide signalling pathways triggering apoptosis. Here we show that both ethanol and ceramide are able to induce apoptotic death in cultured astrocytes, in a dose-dependent manner, and that C2-ceramide addition potentiates the apoptotic effects of ethanol. Cell death induced by ethanol is associated with stimulation of neutral and acidic sphingomyelinase (SMase) and ceramide generation, as well as with activation of stress-related kinases, c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK), p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (p38) and extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) pathways. We also provide evidence for the participation of JNK and p38 in ethanol-induced cell death, because pharmacological inhibitors of these kinases largely prevent the apoptosis induced by ethanol or by ethanol and C2-ceramide. Furthermore, we show that ethanol-induced ERK activation triggers the stimulation of cyclo-oxygenase-2 (COX-2) and the release of prostaglandin E2, and that blockade of the mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase (MEK)/ERK pathway by PD98059 abolishes the up-regulation of COX-2 induced by ethanol plus ceramide, and decreases the ethanol-induced apoptosis. These results strongly suggest that ethanol is able to stimulate the SMase-ceramide pathway, leading to the activation of signalling pathways implicated in cell death. These findings provide an insight into the mechanisms involved in ethanol-induced astroglial cell death during brain development.     

Fluorescent annexin A1 reveals dynamics of ceramide platforms in living cells

Upon its genesis during apoptosis, ceramide promotes gross reorganization of the plasma membrane structure involving clustering of signalling molecules and an amplification of vesicle formation, fusion and trafficking. The annexins are a family of proteins, which in the presence of Ca(2+), bind to membranes containing negatively charged phospholipids. Here, we show that ceramide increases affinity of annexin A1-membrane interaction. In the physiologically relevant range of Ca(2+) concentrations, this leads to an increase in the Ca(2+)sensitivity of annexin A1-membrane interaction. In fixed cells, using a ceramide-specific antibody, we establish a direct interaction of annexin A1 with areas of the plasma membrane enriched in ceramide (ceramide platforms). In living cells, the intracellular dynamics of annexin A1 match those of plasmalemmal ceramide. Among proteins of the annexin family, the interaction with ceramide platforms is restricted to annexin A1 and is conveyed by its unique N-terminal domain. We demonstrate that intracellular Ca(2+)overload occurring at the conditions of cellular stress induces ceramide production. Using fluorescently tagged annexin A1 as a reporter for ceramide platforms and annexin A6 as a non-selective membrane marker, we visualize ceramide platforms for the first time in living cells and provide evidence for a ceramide-driven segregation and internalization of membrane-associated proteins.     

4-HPR-mediated leukemia cell cytotoxicity is triggered by ceramide-induced mitochondrial oxidative stress and is regulated downstream by Bcl-2

We have previously reported that, in leukemia cells, the cytotoxicity of the anticancer agent N-(4-hydroxyphenyl)retinamide (4-HPR) is mediated by mitochondria-derived reactive oxygen species (ROS) and cardiolipin peroxidation. Here, we have analyzed at greater depth the 4-HPR-triggered molecular events, demonstrating that 4-HPR induces an early (15 min) increase in ceramide levels by sphingomyelin hydrolysis and later (from 1 h) by de novo synthesis. Using specific inhibitors of both pathways, we demonstrate that ceramide accumulation is responsible for early ROS generation, which act as apoptotic signalling intermediates leading to conformational activation of Bak and Bax, loss of mitochondrial membrane potential (ΔΨm), mitochondrial membrane permeabilization (MMP) and cell death. Enforced expression of Bcl-2 has no effect on 4-HPR-induced oxidative stress, but notably prevents mitochondrial alterations and apoptosis, indicating that Bcl-2 functions by regulating events downstream of ROS generation. In conclusion, our study delineates for the fist time the sequence and timing of the principal events induced by 4-HPR in leukemia cells and points to the potential use of modulators of ceramide metabolism as enhancers in 4-HPR-based therapies.     

4-HPR-mediated leukemia cell cytotoxicity is triggered by ceramide-induced mitochondrial oxidative stress and is regulated downstream by Bcl-2

We have previously reported that, in leukemia cells, the cytotoxicity of the anticancer agent N-(4-hydroxyphenyl)retinamide (4-HPR) is mediated by mitochondria-derived reactive oxygen species (ROS) and cardiolipin peroxidation. Here, we have analyzed at greater depth the 4-HPR-triggered molecular events, demonstrating that 4-HPR induces an early (15 min) increase in ceramide levels by sphingomyelin hydrolysis and later (from 1 h) by de novo synthesis. Using specific inhibitors of both pathways, we demonstrate that ceramide accumulation is responsible for early ROS generation, which act as apoptotic signalling intermediates leading to conformational activation of Bak and Bax, loss of mitochondrial membrane potential (ΔΨm), mitochondrial membrane permeabilization (MMP) and cell death. Enforced expression of Bcl-2 has no effect on 4-HPR-induced oxidative stress, but notably prevents mitochondrial alterations and apoptosis, indicating that Bcl-2 functions by regulating events downstream of ROS generation. In conclusion, our study delineates for the fist time the sequence and timing of the principal events induced by 4-HPR in leukemia cells and points to the potential use of modulators of ceramide metabolism as enhancers in 4-HPR-based therapies.     

Molecular mechanisms of ceramide-mediated CD95 clustering.

Receptor clustering has been suggested as a crucial mechanism to initiate receptor signaling. Here we show that ceramide in sphingolipid-rich membrane rafts mediates clustering of CD95. Neutralization of surface ceramide or inhibition of its endogenous generation prevented CD95 clustering. Furthermore, application of ceramide at the cell surface triggered clustering of active but not inactive CD95. Apoptosis was inhibited by neutralization of surface ceramide or inhibition of ceramide release in vitro and in vivo. Thus, we conclude that surface ceramide mediates CD95 clustering, which is required for initiation of apoptosis, at least in some cell types.     

Sphingolipid signalling domains floating on rafts or buried in caves?

Ceramide is a novel lipid mediator involved in regulating cell growth, cell differentiation and cell death. Many studies have focused on characterizing the stimulus-induced production of ceramide and identifying putative downstream molecular targets. However, little remains known about the localization of the regulated production of ceramide through sphingomyelin metabolism in the plasma membrane. Additionally, it is unclear whether a localized increase in ceramide concentration is necessary to facilitate downstream signalling events initiated by this lipid. Recent studies have suggested that detergent-insoluble plasma membrane domains may be highly localized sites for initiating signal transduction cascades by both tyrosine kinase and sphingolipid signalling pathways. These domains are typically enriched in both sphingolipids and cholesterol and have been proposed to form highly ordered lipid rafts floating in a sea of glycerophospholipids. Alternatively, upon integration of the cholesterol binding protein caveolin, these domains may also form small cave-like structures called caveolae. Emerging evidence suggests that the enhanced sphingomyelin content of these lipid domains make them potential substrate pools for sphingomyelinases to produce a high local concentration of ceramide. The subsequent formation of ceramide microdomains in the plasma membrane may be a critical factor in regulating downstream signalling through this lipid messenger.     

Involvement of sphingomyelinases in TNF signaling pathways

Sphingomyelin (N-acylsphingosin-1-phosphorylcholine) is a phospholipid preferentially found in the plasma membrane of mammalian cells. Signaling through the sphingomyelin pathway is associated with generation of ceramide, which acts as a second messenger in activating a variety of cellular functions. Ceramide belongs to the group of sphingosine-based lipid second messenger molecules that are critically involved in the regulation of signal transduction of diverse cell surface membrane receptors. The emerging picture suggests that coupling of ceramide to specific signaling cascades is both stimulus- and cell type-specific and depends on the subcellular topology of its production. Following membrane receptor triggering, neutral and acid isoforms of sphingomyelinases are rapidly activated generating ceramide through sphingomyelin hydrolysis. Here the molecular mechanisms of TNF-induced activation of sphingomyelinases and the functional consequences of ceramide generation will be discussed.     

Molecular mechanisms of ionizing radiation-induced apoptosis.

Ionizing radiation activates not only signalling pathways in the nucleus as a result of DNA damage, but also signalling pathways initiated at the level of the plasma membrane. Proteins involved in DNA damage recognition include poly(ADP ribose) polymerase (PARP), DNA-dependent protein kinase, p53 and ataxia- telangiectasia mutated (ATM). Many of these proteins are inactivated by caspases during the execution phase of apoptosis. Signalling pathways outside the nucleus involve tyrosine kinases such as stress-activated protein kinase (SAPK)/c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK), protein kinase C, ceramide and reactive oxygen species. Recent evidence shows that tumour cells resistant to ionizing radiation-induced apoptosis have defective ceramide signalling. How these signalling pathways converge to activate the caspases is presently unknown, although in some cell types a role for calpain has been suggested.     

Sphingolipids and cellular cholesterol homeostasis. Effect of ceramide on cholesterol trafficking and HMG CoA reductase activity

We previously showed that degradation of cellular sphingomyelin (SM) by SMase C results in a greater stimulation of cholesterol translocation to endoplasmic reticulum, compared to its degradation by SMase D. Here we investigated the hypothesis that the effect of SMase C is partly due to the generation of ceramide, rather than due to depletion of SM alone. Inhibition of hydroxymethylglutaryl CoA reductase (HMGCR) activity was used as a measure of cholesterol translocation. Treatment of fibroblasts with SMase C resulted in a 90% inhibition of HMGCR, whereas SMase D treatment inhibited it by 29%. Treatment with exogenous ceramides, or increasing the endogenous ceramide levels also inhibited HMGCR by 60-80%. Phosphorylation of HMGCR was stimulated by SMase C or exogenous ceramide. The effects of ceramide and SMase D were additive, indicating the independent effects of SM depletion and ceramide generation. These results show that ceramide regulates sterol trafficking independent of cellular SM levels.     

The targeting of plasmalemmal ceramide to mitochondria during apoptosis

Ceramide is a key lipid mediator of cellular processes such as differentiation, proliferation, growth arrest and apoptosis. During apoptosis, ceramide is produced within the plasma membrane. Although recent data suggest that the generation of intracellular ceramide increases mitochondrial permeability, the source of mitochondrial ceramide remains unknown. Here, we determine whether a stress-mediated plasmalemmal pool of ceramide might become available to the mitochondria of apoptotic cells. We have previously established annexin A1--a member of a family of Ca(2+) and membrane-binding proteins--to be a marker of ceramide platforms. Using fluorescently tagged annexin A1, we show that, upon its generation within the plasma membrane, ceramide self-associates into platforms that subsequently invaginate and fuse with mitochondria. An accumulation of ceramide within the mitochondria of apoptotic cells was also confirmed using a ceramide-specific antibody. Electron microscopic tomography confirmed that upon the formation of ceramide platforms, the invaginated regions of the plasma membrane extend deep into the cytoplasm forming direct physical contacts with mitochondrial outer membranes. Ceramide might thus be directly transferred from the plasma membrane to the mitochondrial outer membrane. It is conceivable that this "kiss-of-death" increases the permeability of the mitochondrial outer membrane thereby triggering apoptosis.     

The sphingolipid salvage pathway in ceramide metabolism and signaling

Sphingolipids are important components of eukaryotic cells, many of which function as bioactive signaling molecules. Of these, ceramide is a central metabolite and plays key roles in a variety of cellular responses, including regulation of cell growth, viability, differentiation, and senescence. Ceramide is composed of the long-chain sphingoid base, sphingosine, in N-linkage to a variety of acyl groups. Sphingosine serves as the product of sphingolipid catabolism, and it is mostly salvaged through reacylation, resulting in the generation of ceramide or its derivatives. This recycling of sphingosine is termed the “salvage pathway”, and recent evidence points to important roles for this pathway in ceramide metabolism and function. A number of enzymes are involved in the salvage pathway, and these include sphingomyelinases, cerebrosidases, ceramidases, and ceramide synthases. Recent studies suggest that the salvage pathway is not only subject to regulation, but it also modulates the formation of ceramide and subsequent ceramide-dependent cellular signals. This review focuses on the salvage pathway in ceramide metabolism, its regulation, its experimental analysis, and emerging biological functions.     

Biochemical mechanisms of the generation of endogenous long chain ceramide in response to exogenous short chain ceramide in the A549 human lung adenocarcinoma cell line. Role for endogenous ceramide in mediating the action of exogenous ceramide

Treatment of A549 cells with C(6)-ceramide resulted in a significant increase in the endogenous long chain ceramide levels, which was inhibited by fumonisin B1 (FB1), and not by myriocin (MYR). The biochemical mechanisms of generation of endogenous ceramide were investigated using A549 cells treated with selectively labeled C(6)-ceramides, [sphingosine-3-(3)H]d-erythro-, and N-[N-hexanoyl-1-(14)C]d-erythro-C(6)-ceramide. The results demonstrated that (3)H label was incorporated into newly synthesized long chain ceramides, which was inhibited by FB1 and not by MYR. Interestingly, the (14)C label was not incorporated into long chain ceramides. Taken together, these results show that generation of endogenous ceramide in response to C(6)-ceramide is due to recycling of the sphingosine backbone of C(6)-ceramide via deacylation/reacylation and not due to the elongation of its fatty acid moiety. Moreover, the generation of endogenous long chain ceramide in response to C(6)-ceramide was completely blocked by brefeldin A, which causes Golgi disassembly, suggesting a role for the Golgi in the metabolism of ceramide. In addition, the generation of endogenous ceramide in response to short chain exogenous ceramide was induced by d-erythro- but not l-erythro-C(6)-ceramide, demonstrating the stereospecificity of this process. Interestingly, several key downstream biological activities of ceramide, such as growth inhibition, cell cycle arrest, and modulation of telomerase activity were induced by d-erythro-C(6)-ceramide, and not l-erythro-C(6)-ceramide (and inhibited by FB1) in A549 cells, suggesting a role for endogenous long chain ceramide in the regulation of these responses.     

CD95(Fas/APO-1) signals ceramide generation independent of the effector stage of apoptosis

Although numerous studies document caspase-independent ceramide generation preceding apoptosis upon environmental stress, the molecular ordering of ceramide generation during cytokine-induced apoptosis remains uncertain. Here, we show that CD95-induced ceramide elevation occurs during the initiation phase of apoptosis. We titrated down the amount of FADD transfected into HeLa and 293T cells until it was insufficient for apoptosis, although cycloheximide (CHX) still triggered the effector phase. Even in the absence of CHX, ceramide levels increased rapidly, peaking at 2.7 +/- 0.2-fold of control 8 h post-transfection. Dominant negative FADD failed to confer ceramide generation or CHX-mediated apoptosis. Ceramide generation induced by FADD was initiator caspase-dependent, being blocked by crmA. Limited pro-caspase 8 overexpression also increased ceramide levels 2.7 +/- 0.2-fold, yet failed, without CHX, to initiate apoptosis. Expression of membrane-targeted oligomerized CD-8 caspase 8 induced apoptosis without CHX, yet elevated ceramide only to a level equivalent to limited pro-caspase 8 transfection. Ceramide elevations were detected concurrently by diacylglycerol kinase and electrospray tandem mass spectrometry. These investigations provide evidence that ceramide generation is initiator caspase-dependent and occurs prior to commitment to the effector phase of apoptosis, definitively ordering ceramide as proximal in CD95 signaling.     

Principles of bioactive lipid signalling: lessons from sphingolipids

It has become increasingly difficult to find an area of cell biology in which lipids do not have important, if not key, roles as signalling and regulatory molecules. The rapidly expanding field of bioactive lipids is exemplified by many sphingolipids, such as ceramide, sphingosine, sphingosine-1-phosphate (S1P), ceramide-1-phosphate and lyso-sphingomyelin, which have roles in the regulation of cell growth, death, senescence, adhesion, migration, inflammation, angiogenesis and intracellular trafficking. Deciphering the mechanisms of these varied cell functions necessitates an understanding of the complex pathways of sphingolipid metabolism and the mechanisms that regulate lipid generation and lipid action.