Fluorescence analysis of receptor-G protein interactions in cell membranes

The dynamics of G protein heterotrimer complex formation and disassembly in response to nucleotide binding and receptor activation govern the rate of responses to external stimuli. We use a novel flow cytometry approach to study the effects of lipid modification, isoform specificity, lipid environment, and receptor stimulation on the affinity and kinetics of G protein subunit binding. Fluorescein-labeled myristoylated Galpha(i1) (F-alpha(i1)) was used as the ligand bound to Gbetagamma in competition binding studies with differently modified Galpha subunit isoforms. In detergent solutions, the binding affinity of Galpha(i) to betagamma was 2 orders of magnitude higher than for Galpha(o) and Galpha(s) (IC50 of 0.2 nM vs 17 and 27 nM, respectively), while in reconstituted bovine brain lipid vesicles, binding was slightly weaker. The effects of receptor on the G protein complex were assessed in alpha(2A)AR receptor expressing CHO cell membranes into which purified betagamma subunits and F-alpha(i1) were reconstituted. These cell membrane studies led to the following observations: (1) binding of alpha subunit to the betagamma was not enhanced by receptor in the presence or absence of agonist, indicating that betagamma contributed essentially all of the binding energy for alpha(i1) interaction with the membrane; (2) activation of the receptor facilitated GTPgammaS-stimulated detachment of F-alpha(i1) from betagamma and the membrane. Thus flow cytometry permits quantiatitive and real-time assessments of protein-protein interactions in complex membrane environments.     

PAR1 thrombin receptor-G protein interactions. Separation of binding and coupling determinants in the galpha subunit

Signal transfer between the protease-activated PAR1 thrombin receptor and membrane-associated heterotrimeric G proteins is mediated by protein-protein interactions. We constructed a yeast signaling system that resolves domain-specific functions of binding from coupling in the Galpha subunit. The endogenous yeast Galpha subunit, Gpa1, does not bind to PAR1 and served as a null structural template. N- and C-terminal portions of mammalian G(i2) and G(16) were substituted back into the Gpa1 template and gain-of-function assessed. The C-terminal third of G(16), but not of G(i2), provides sufficient interactions for coupling to occur with PAR1. The N-terminal two-thirds of G(i2) also contains sufficient determinants to bind and couple to PAR1 and overcome the otherwise negative or missing interactions supplied by the C-terminal third of Gpa1. Replacement of the N-terminal alpha-helix of G(i2), residues 1-34, with those of Gpa1 abolishes coupling but not binding to PAR1 or to betagamma subunits. These data support a model that the N-terminal alphaN helix of the Galpha subunit is physically interposed between PAR1 and the Gbeta subunit and directly assists in transferring the signal between agonist-activated receptor and G protein.     

Defect of receptor-G protein coupling in human gallbladder with cholesterol stones

Human gallbladders with cholesterol stones (ChS) exhibit an impaired muscle contraction and relaxation and a lower CCK receptor-binding capacity compared with those with pigment stones (PS). This study was designed to determine whether there is an abnormal receptor-G protein coupling in human gallbladders with ChS using (35)S-labeled guanosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) ([(35)S]GTPgammaS) binding, (125)I-labeled CCK-8 autoradiography, immunoblotting, and G protein quantitation. CCK and vasoactive intestinal peptide caused significant increases in [(35)S]GTPgammaS binding to Galpha(i-3) and G(s)alpha, respectively. The binding was lower in ChS than in PS (P < 0.01). The reduced [(35)S]GTPgammaS binding in ChS was normalized after the muscles were treated with cholesterol-free liposomes (P < 0.01). Autoradiography and immunoblots showed a decreased optical density (OD) for CCK receptors, an even lower OD value for receptor-G protein coupling, and a higher OD for uncoupled receptors or Galpha(i-3) protein in ChS compared with PS (P < 0.001). G protein quantitation also showed that there were no significant differences in the Galpha(i-3) and G(s)alpha content in ChS and PS. We conclude that, in addition to an impaired CCK receptor-binding capacity, there is a defect in receptor-G protein coupling in muscle cells from gallbladder with ChS. These changes may be normalized after removal of excess cholesterol from the plasma membrane.     

Optimization of receptor-G protein coupling by bilayer lipid composition I: kinetics of rhodopsin-transducin binding.

The role of membrane composition in modulating the rate of G protein-receptor complex formation was examined using rhodopsin and transducin (G(t)) as a model system. Metarhodopsin II (MII) and MII-G(t) complex formation rates were measured, in the absence of GTP, via flash photolysis for rhodopsin reconstituted in 1-stearoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (18:0,18:1PC) and 1-stearoyl-2-docosahexaenoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (18:0,22:6PC) bilayers, with and without 30 mol% cholesterol. Variation in bilayer lipid composition altered the lifetime of MII-G(t) formation to a greater extent than the lifetime of MII. MII-G(t) formation was fastest in 18:0,22:6PC and slowest in 18:0,18:1PC/30 mol% cholesterol. At 37 degrees C and a G(t) to photolyzed rhodopsin ratio of 1:1 in 18:0,22:6PC bilayers, MII-G(t) formed with a lifetime of 0.6 +/- 0.06 ms, which was not significantly different from the lifetime for MII formation. Incorporation of 30 mol% cholesterol slowed the rate of MII-G(t) complex formation by about 400% in 18:0,18:1PC, but by less than 25% in 18:0,22:6PC bilayers. In 18:0,22:6PC, with or without cholesterol, MII-G(t) formed rapidly after MII formed. In contrast, cholesterol in 18:0,18:1PC induced a considerable lag time in MII-G(t) formation after MII formed. These results demonstrate that membrane composition is a critical factor in determining the temporal response of a G protein-coupled signaling system.     

Optimization of receptor-G protein coupling by bilayer lipid composition II: formation of metarhodopsin II-transducin complex.

The visual transduction system was used as a model to investigate the effects of membrane lipid composition on receptor-G protein coupling. Rhodopsin was reconstituted into large, unilamellar phospholipid vesicles with varying acyl chain unsaturation, with and without cholesterol. The association constant (K(a)) for metarhodopsin II (MII) and transducin (G(t)) binding was determined by monitoring MII-G(t) complex formation spectrophotometrically. At 20 degrees C, in pH 7.5 isotonic buffer, the strongest MII-G(t) binding was observed in 1-stearoyl-2-docosahexaenoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (18:0,22:6PC), whereas the weakest binding was in 1-stearoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (18:0,18:1PC) with 30 mol% cholesterol. Increasing acyl chain unsaturation from 18:0,18:1PC to 18:0,22:6PC resulted in a 3-fold increase in K(a). The inclusion of 30 mol% cholesterol in the membrane reduced K(a) in both 18:0,22:6PC and 18:0,18:1PC. These findings demonstrate that membrane compositions can alter the signaling cascade by changing protein-protein interactions occurring predominantly in the hydrophilic region of the proteins, external to the lipid bilayer. These findings, if extended to other members of the superfamily of G protein-coupled receptors, suggest that a loss in efficiency of receptor-G protein binding is a contributing factor to the loss of cognitive skills, odor and spatial discrimination, and visual function associated with n-3 fatty acid deficiency.     

Heterodimerization of mu- and delta-opioid receptors occurs at the cell surface only and requires receptor-G protein interactions

Homo- and heterodimerization of the opioid receptors with functional consequences were reported previously. However, the exact nature of these putative dimers has not been identified. In current studies, the nature of the heterodimers was investigated by producing the phenotypes of the 1:1 heterodimers formed between the constitutively expressed mu-opioid receptor (MOR) and the ponasterone A-induced expression of delta-opioid receptor (DOR) in EcR293 cells. By examining the trafficking of the cell surface-located MOR and DOR, we determined that these two receptors endocytosed independently. Using cell surface expression-deficient mutants of MOR and DOR, we observed that the corresponding wild types of these receptors could not rescue the cell surface expression of the mutants, whereas the antagonist naloxone could. Furthermore, studies with constitutive or agonist-induced receptor internalization also indicated that MOR and DOR endocytosed independently and could not "drag in" the corresponding wild types or endocytosis-deficient mutants. Additionally, the heterodimer phenotypes could be eliminated by the pretreatment of the EcR293 cells with pertussis toxin and could be modulated by the deletion of the RRITR sequence in the third intracellular loop that is involved in the receptor-G protein interaction and activation. These data suggest that MOR and DOR heterodimerize only at the cell surface and that the oligomers of opioid receptors and heterotrimeric G protein are the bases for the observed MOR-DOR heterodimer phenotypes.     

Specificity of receptor-G protein interactions. Discrimination of Gi subtypes by the D2 dopamine receptor in a reconstituted system

The selectivity of D2 dopamine receptor-guanine nucleotide-binding protein (G protein) coupling was studied by reconstitution techniques utilizing purified D2 dopamine receptors from bovine anterior pituitary and resolved G proteins from bovine brain, bovine pituitary, and human erythrocyte. Titration of a fixed receptor concentration with varying G protein concentrations revealed two aspects of receptor-G protein coupling. First, Gi2 appeared to couple selectively with the D2 receptor with approximately 10-fold higher affinity than any other tested Gi subtype. Second, the G proteins differed in the maximal receptor-mediated agonist stimulation of the intrinsic GTPase activity. Gi2 appeared to be maximally stimulated by agonist-receptor complex with turnover numbers of approximately 2 min-1. The other Gi subtypes, Gi1 and Gi3, could be only partially activated, resulting in maximal rates of GTPase of approximately 1 min-1. Agonist-stimulated GTPase activity was not detected in preparations containing Go from bovine brain. The differences in maximal agonist-stimulated GTPase rates observed among the Gi subtypes could be explained by differences in agonist-promoted guanyl nucleotide exchange. Both guanosine 5'-3-O-(thio)triphosphate (GTP gamma S) binding and GDP release parameters were enhanced 2-fold for the Gi2 subtype over the other Gi subtypes. These results suggest that even though several types of pertussis toxin substrate may exist in most tissues, a receptor may interact discretely with G proteins, thereby dictating signal transduction mechanisms.     

Galpha subunit Gpa2 recruits kelch repeat subunits that inhibit receptor-G protein coupling during cAMP-induced dimorphic transitions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

All eukaryotic cells sense extracellular stimuli and activate intracellular signaling cascades via G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR) and associated heterotrimeric G proteins. The Saccharomyces cerevisiae GPCR Gpr1 and associated Galpha subunit Gpa2 sense extracellular carbon sources (including glucose) to govern filamentous growth. In contrast to conventional Galpha subunits, Gpa2 forms an atypical G protein complex with the kelch repeat Gbeta mimic proteins Gpb1 and Gpb2. Gpb1/2 negatively regulate cAMP signaling by inhibiting Gpa2 and an as yet unidentified target. Here we show that Gpa2 requires lipid modifications of its N-terminus for membrane localization but association with the Gpr1 receptor or Gpb1/2 subunits is dispensable for membrane targeting. Instead, Gpa2 promotes membrane localization of its associated Gbeta mimic subunit Gpb2. We also show that the Gpa2 N-terminus binds both to Gpb2 and to the C-terminal tail of the Gpr1 receptor and that Gpb1/2 binding interferes with Gpr1 receptor coupling to Gpa2. Our studies invoke novel mechanisms involving GPCR-G protein modules that may be conserved in multicellular eukaryotes.     

Probing the activation-promoted structural rearrangements in preassembled receptor-G protein complexes

Activation of heterotrimeric G proteins by their cognate seven transmembrane domain receptors is believed to involve conformational changes propagated from the receptor to the G proteins. However, the nature of these changes remains unknown. We monitored the conformational rearrangements at the interfaces between receptors and G proteins and between G protein subunits by measuring bioluminescence resonance energy transfer between probes inserted at multiple sites in receptor-G protein complexes. Using the data obtained for the alpha(2A)AR-G alpha(i1) beta1gamma2 complex and the available crystal structures of G alpha(i1) beta1gamma2, we propose a model wherein agonist binding induces conformational reorganization of a preexisting receptor-G protein complex, leading the G alpha-G betagamma interface to open but not dissociate. This conformational change may represent the movement required to allow nucleotide exit from the G alpha subunit, thus reflecting the initial activation event.     

Cannabinoid receptor-G protein interactions: G(alphai1)-bound structures of IC3 and a mutant with altered G protein specificity

The structure of the C-terminal region of the third cytoplasmic loop (IC3) of the cannabinoid receptor one (CB1) bound to G(alphai1) has been determined using transferred nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs). The wild-type IC3 sequence is helical when associated with G(alphai1). In contrast, a peptide containing the amino-acid inversion, Ala(341)-Leu(342) adopts a single turn. These findings correlate with the attenuated G(i) association of CB1 with the Ala(341)-Leu(342) mutation previously observed in vivo and the diminished stimulation of G(alphai1) GTPase activity by the corresponding peptide demonstrated in vitro here. These results, the first to report the structure of a GPCR domain while associated with G protein, imply the C-terminus of CB1 IC3, a region with high-sequence conservation among G-protein coupled receptors, must be helical for efficient coupling and activation of the G(i) protein.     

Theoretical study of the electrostatically driven step of receptor-G protein recognition

This study proposes a theoretical model describing the electrostatically driven step of the alpha 1 b-adrenergic receptor (AR)-G protein recognition. The comparative analysis of the structural-dynamics features of functionally different receptor forms, i.e., the wild type (ground state) and its constitutively active mutants D142A and A293E, was instrumental to gain insight on the receptor-G protein electrostatic and steric complementarity. Rigid body docking simulations between the different forms of the alpha 1 b-AR and the heterotrimeric G alpha q, G alpha s, G alpha i1, and G alpha t suggest that the cytosolic crevice shared by the active receptor and including the second and the third intracellular loops as well as the cytosolic extension of helices 5 and 6, represents the receptor surface with docking complementarity with the G protein. On the other hand, the G protein solvent-exposed portions that recognize the intracellular loops of the activated receptors are the N-terminal portion of alpha 3, alpha G, the alpha G/alpha 4 loop, alpha 4, the alpha 4/beta 6 loop, alpha 5, and the C-terminus. Docking simulations suggest that the two constitutively active mutants D142A and A293E recognize different G proteins with similar selectivity orders, i.e., G alpha q approximately equal to G alpha s > G alpha i > G alpha t. The theoretical models herein proposed might provide useful suggestions for new experiments aiming at exploring the receptor-G protein interface.     

Assessment of striatal D1 and D2 dopamine receptor-G protein coupling by agonist-induced [35S]GTP gamma S binding

The dopamine receptor-mediated modulation of guanosine 5'-O-(gamma-[35S]thio)triphosphate ([35S]GTP gamma S) binding has been characterized in rat striatal membranes. In optimized experimental conditions, the potency of dopamine was 4.47 microM [3.02-6.61 microM] and a maximal response representing 54.8 +/- 4.5% increase above basal level was observed. Data obtained with different agonists and antagonists clearly revealed that the most important fraction of this response was reflecting D2 receptor activation. Further analysis with specific antagonists also supported evidence for the involvement of D1 dopamine receptors. The potencies of compounds interacting with D1 and D2 receptors were deduced from [35S]GTP gamma S binding experiments and compared with their binding affinities for these receptors measured in similar experimental conditions. A good correlation between these parameters was observed, supporting the applicability of this technique for the study of dopamine receptors in the central nervous system.     

Sequence specificity of protein-oligonucleotide interactions and protein isolation on sorptive media containing immobilized protein specific oligonucleotides

The sequence specificity of protein—oligonucleotide interactions based on the example of binase interaction with oligodeoxyribonucleotides immobilized in biochip gel elements has been studied. Constants of the preferable binding of binase to the selected nucleotide sequences were measured. The GAGAGAG and GAGAGAGAG oligodeoxyribonucleotides, which specifically bind to binase, were used as molecular probes to develop affine sorptive media for binase isolation and concentration from diluted water solutions. The volume capacity of affinity sorbents with immobilized oligodeoxyribonucleotides was found to be 2.6 and 2.3 mg of binase per 1 mL of sorbent for GAGAGAG and GAGAGAGAG, respectively. It was shown that, after affinity chromatography and elution from sorptive media, the oligonucleotide specificity of binase corresponds to the specificity of the initial sample.     

Sequence specificity of drug-DNA interactions

Methods for determining sequence specificities of anticancer drugs, carcinogens, and mutagens which interact with natural DNA's are presented. For drugs which nick or covalently bind to DNA and thus leave a permanent record of their residence position on the helix, the sequences important in drug action can be readily determined. For agents which interact with DNA in an equilibrium fashion, "footprinting" analysis, a technique used to investigate protein-DNA binding, has proved to be useful in studying drug-DNA interactions. The sequence specificities of a number of small ligands which interact with natural DNA's are also presented.     

Follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) induces G protein dissociation from FSH receptor-G protein complexes in reconstituted proteoliposomes

We have previously reported incorporation of Triton X-100-solubilized bovine calf testis membrane protein into liposomes. The resulting proteoliposomes responded to FSH by exchange of bound GDP for [3H]5'-guanylyl imidodiphosphate ([3H]Gpp(NH)p) and by activation of adenylate cyclase (AC) (Grasso, P., Dattatreyamurty, B. and Reichert, L.E., Jr. (1988) Mol. Endocrinol. 2, 420-430). This model system was utilized to study the effects of FSH on the quaternary structure of FSH receptor-associated GTP-binding protein by comparing the gel filtration profiles of proteoliposomes solubilized with Triton X-100 after exposure to [3H]Gpp(NH)p in the presence or absence of FSH. FSH caused a redistribution of radioactivity (due to bound [3H]Gpp(NH)p) from a high molecular weight fraction (Mr greater than 100,000) to a fraction of much lower molecular weight (Mr approximately 23,000). These results are interpreted to reflect an FSH-induced dissociation of [3H]Gpp(NH)p-bound G protein from its receptor-associated complex. The apparent Mr of approximately 23,000 for the FSH receptor-associated GTP-binding protein suggests that it may represent yet another member of a family of low molecular weight GTP-binding proteins, possibly a ras gene product, recently identified in various mammalian tissues.     

Alteration of the stereo- and regioselectivity of alkene monooxygenase based on coupling protein interactions

Alkene monooxygenase from Xanthobacter autotrophicus Py2 (XAMO) catalyses the asymmetric epoxidation of a broad range of alkenes. As well as the electron transfer components (a NADH-oxidoreductase and a Rieske-type ferredoxin) and the terminal oxygenase containing the binuclear non-haem iron active site, it requires a small catalytic coupling/effector protein, AamD. The effect of changing AamD stoichiometry and substitution with effector protein homologues on the regioselectivity of toluene hydroxylation and stereoselectivity of styrene epoxidation has been studied. At sub-optimal stoichiometries, there was a marked change in regioselectivity, but no significant change in epoxidation stereoselectivity. Recombinant coupling proteins from a number of phylogenetically related oxygenases were investigated for their ability to functionally replace AamD. Substitution of AamD with IsoD, the coupling protein from the closely related isoprene monooxygenase, changed the regioselectivity of toluene hydroxylation and stereoselectivity of styrene epoxidation, although this was accompanied by a high level of uncoupling. This indicates the importance of coupling protein interaction in controlling the catalytic specificity. Sequence analysis suggests that interaction between Asn34 and Arg57 is important for complementation specificity of the coupling proteins, providing a candidate for site-directed mutagenesis studies.     

Study and selection of in vivo protein interactions by coupling bimolecular fluorescence complementation and flow cytometry

We present a high-throughput approach to study weak protein-protein interactions by coupling bimolecular fluorescent complementation (BiFC) to flow cytometry (FC). In BiFC, the interaction partners (bait and prey) are fused to two rationally designed fragments of a fluorescent protein, which recovers its function upon the binding of the interacting proteins. For weak protein-protein interactions, the detected fluorescence is proportional to the interaction strength, thereby allowing in vivo discrimination between closely related binders with different affinity for the bait protein. FC provides a method for high-speed multiparametric data acquisition and analysis; the assay is simple, thousands of cells can be analyzed in seconds and, if required, selected using fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). The combination of both methods (BiFC-FC) provides a technically straightforward, fast and highly sensitive method to validate weak protein interactions and to screen and identify optimal ligands in biologically synthesized libraries. Once plasmids encoding the protein fusions have been obtained, the evaluation of a specific interaction, the generation of a library and selection of active partners using BiFC-FC can be accomplished in 5 weeks.