Suppressor T-cell activity induced as a result of thermal injury.

Many thermally injured patients survive their initial trauma only to succumb to infection at 2 to 4 weeks after the burn. Both clinical and experimental data have suggested that acute thermal insult compromises immune function. In this report we have sequentially examined the ability of thermally injured mice to generate a specific in vitro primary antibody-forming cell (AFC) response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) at various times after thermal injury. Thermally injured mice appear to lose the ability to generate de novo antibody-forming cells in vitro after thermal injury. The defect was dissected as to the involvement of macrophage (φ), thymus-derived cell (T-cell), or bursal equivalent (B-cell) defects. Murine B cells from burned animals exhibited normal immunological function in the in vitro AFC system. T cells from burned mice were demonstrated as not only dysfunctional in the generation of immune AFC, but also as able to suppress generation of an AFC response by syngeneic normal cells.     

Separation of functionally distinct subpopulations of Corynebacterium parvum-activated macrophages with predominantly stimulatory or suppressive effect on the cell-mediated cytotoxic T cell response.

Peritoneal cells (PEC) from mice injected ip with Corynebacterium parvum (CP) showed greatly enhanced suppressive activity on the growth of syngeneic tumor cells and on the generation of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vitro. On the other hand, CP-activated PEC exhibited increased immunostimulatory (accessory or A cell) activity as measured by the restoration of the CTL response of nonadherent spleen cells. After fractionation of the CP-activated PEC according to cell size by velocity sedimentation, the mutually antagonistic A cell and immunosuppressive activities were clearly separated and found to be associated with functionally distinct subpopulations of macrophages. Thus A cell function was detected in fractions rich in small and medium sized macrophages which were probably derived from recently arrived monocytes. Immunosuppressive (and anti-tumor) activity was associated with the largest macrophages which were almost devoid of A cell function and probably represented a highly activated and differentiated macrophage subpopulation.     

Suppression of natural killer (NK) cell activity of spleen cells by thymocytes

The in vitro influence of thymus cells on natural killer cell activity of spleen cells against prelabeled target cells (YAC-I and RL♂I) has been studied in syngeneic as well as in allogeneic murine models. In mixing experiments to demonstrate suppression, total thymocytes have been found to have no effect on NK activity of syngeneic or allogeneic spleen cells. Among several thymocyte fractions separated by velocity sedimentation, a relatively faster sedimenting fraction showed remarkable suppression of NK activity by spleen cells against two target cells. The suppressive effect of this particular fraction on NK activity was demonstrated to be proportional to the cell dose. The suppressive function was resistant to irradiation at 1000 or 2000 rad administered in vitro and was not restricted by the major histocompatibility complex. Moreover, the thymocyte fraction which induced suppression was not sensitive to NK-mediated cytolysi? by syngeneic spleen cells. The suppression of NK cytolysis in vitro by certain subpopulations of thymocytes as observed in the present studies may be consistent with a role for the thymus in regulating NK activity in vivo.     

Cell-mediated immune response to syngeneic UV induced tumors: I. The presence of tumor associated macrophages and their possible role in the in Vitro generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes

A primary in vitro sensitization system employing a chromium release assay was utilized to investigate reactivity of murine spleen cells toward syngeneic ultraviolet (uv) light induced fibrosarcomas. These tumors are immunologically rejected in vivo when implanted into normal syngeneic mice but grow progressivly when implanted into syngeneic mice that had previously been irradiated with subcarcinogenic levels of uv light. Following appropriate sensitization, spleen cells from both normal and uv irradiated mice are capable of developing cytotoxic lymphocytes in vitro against the uv induced tumors. It was subsequently discovered that in situ uv induced tumors all contained macrophages of host origin that became demonstrable only after enzymatic dissociation of the tumor tissue. These macrophages were immunologically active in vitro as their presence in the stimulator cell population was necessary to achieve an optimum anti-tumor cytotoxic response following in vitro sensitization. Anti-tumor reactivity generated by mixing spleen cells and tumor cells in the absence of tumor derived macrophages could be greatly enhanced by the addition of normal syngeneic peritoneal macrophages. When in vitro anti-tumor reactivity of spleen cells from normal and uv treated mice was compared under these conditions we again found no significant difference in the magnitude of the responses. In addition, the cytotoxic cells generated in response to uv induced tumors appeared to be highly cross reactive with respect to their killing potential. Cross reactive killing was observed between all uv induced tumors tested as well as with a syngeneic benz[a]pyrene (BP) induced fibrosarcoma. No cytotoxicity was observed against normal syngeneic PEC's even through these cells were shown to be susceptible to lysis by anti-H-2^k effector cells. It was concluded that: (a) A significant number of host-derived macrophages are present in uv tumor tissue. (b) These macrophages are important for the in vitro generation of tumor specific cytotoxicity. (c) Spleen cells from uv treated mice are capable of recognizing and responding against uv tumor associated antigens in vitro. Cytotoxic effector cells generated in response to uv induced tumors appear to have specificity for tumor associated antigens (TAA) present on all uv tumors tested as well as a syngeneic BP induced tumor. The relationship between in vivo and in vitro reactivity against uv tumors is discussed.     

Immunologic significance of nonspecific suppressor cells in spleens of tumor-bearing mice.

Spleen cells from mice bearing a progressively growing syngeneic tumor failed to respond to stimulation with mitogens in vitro. This lack of reactivity was due to the presence of nylon wool-adherent cells in the population that could inhibit the mitogen response of normal lymphocytes. Paradoxically, at times when strong suppressor cell activity could be detected in tumor-bearing mice, the animals responded normally to in vivo immunization with sheep erythrocytes and allogeneic tumors, and to in vitro sensitization with allogeneic tumor cells. Regression of a highly antigenic syngeneic tumor also was unaffected by the presence of these suppressor cells. Thus, the occurrence of nonspecific suppressor cells in the spleens of tumor-bearing mice did not influence the overall immunologic competence of these animals.     

The induction of cell-mediated immunity and tolerance to insulin with insulin coupled to syngeneic lymphoid cells

The induction of delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) and tolerance to DTH against bovine insulin in mice were explored. DTH was induced with insulin in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) and was assessed by ear swelling in vivo and by antigen-driven cell proliferation in vitro. Using the concept that thymus cell unresponsiveness is most easily accomplished via antigen on syngeneic membranes, tolerance was induced by iv injection of syngeneic lymphoid cells which had been coupled to insulin with carbodiimide. Mice tolerized with insulin-coupled cells and then sensitized with insulin-CFA had diminished ear swelling in vivo and decreased insulin-driven cell proliferation in vitro. This unresponsiveness was antigen specific but was also inconstant in degree with regard to suppression of ear swelling, most likely because of variability in coupling of insulin to cells. Proliferative responses were more uniformly suppressed, suggesting the possibility that two target cells were being tolerized. Thus, as with other proteins, the biologically active insulin can be used to induce tolerance.     

Cell-mediated immune response to syngeneic ultraviolet-induced tumors. II. The properties and antigenic specificities of cytotoxic T lymphocytes generated in vitro following removal from syngeneic tumor-immunized mice.

The immune responses of C3Hf mice to syngeneic fibrosarcomas induced with either ultraviolet light or methychlolanthrene (MCA) were measured in vitro by the ability of cytotoxic lymphocytes (CTL) from immunized animals to kill ⁵¹Cr-labeled tumor targets in a 6-hr assay. The CTL were generated by the in vitro culturing of draining popliteal lymph node (DLN) cells derived from animals that were footpad immunized 8 days previously. It was determined that CTL activity could be generated using DLN from both normal (uv tumorresistant) and uv-exposed (uv tumor-susceptible) C3H mice. The kinetics of CTL generation between these two groups, however, was different in that the lymphocytes from normal animals appeared to differentiate into CTL faster than the lymphocytes from the uv-irradiated mice. The in vitro generation of CTL activity was found to be extremely radiosensitive and was also inhibited by the presence of viable tumor cells within the cell culture. Once generated, it was observed that the CTL were extremely insensitive to the effects of gamma irradiation. It was also established that the CTL is a T lymphocyte that appears to be Ia^?. The CTL derived from mice immunized to syngeneic uv- or MCA-induced tumors were capable of expressing cross-reactive non-MHC-restricted killing of multiple tumor targets. Cold cell inhibition experiments confirmed the presence of cross-reactive determinants on various tumors and also established the presence within a single CTL preparation of effector cells with specificity for both the unique tumor specific transplantation antigens as well as the common (cross-reactive) tumor-associated antigens.     

Studies on the specificity of in vitro-induced lymphocytotoxicity to methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcoma cell lines

Cytotoxic effector lymphocytes were induced by in vitro immunization of lymph node and spleen cells from CS7B16(H2^b) and Balb/c(H2^d) mice to syngeneic or allogeneic methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcoma (MCAF) cell lines. The T cell-dependent cytotoxicity was specific to target cell lines to which the lymphocytes were immunized in vitro. Normal fibroblasts as stimulator cells did not induce lymphocytotoxicity to syngeneic MCAF cells or to normal syngeneic fibroblasts. The results indicate that the in vitro-immunized lymphocytes recognize individual specific tumor-associated antigens of the MCAF cells. In experiments in which the lymphocytes were immunized in vitro to allogeneic MCAF cells, cytotoxic reactions to alloantigens, but not to tumor-associated antigens, were detected. Incubation with phytohemagglutinin (PHA) during the sensitization period modified the specificity of the cell-mediated lysis of MCAF cells: Allogeneic as well as syngeneic target cells were destroyed by these effector cells. PHA induced a nonspecific cytotoxic effect which increased the specific lysis of target cells. The cytotoxicity of the in vitro-immunized lymphocytes was inhibited by incubation with membrane protein preparations from the syngeneic MCAF cell lines. In contrast to the specificity of the cytotoxic effect to the different syngeneic cell lines, the membrane extract of one individual syngeneic MCAF cell line was able to inhibit the lymphocytotoxicity to all other syngeneic cell lines. Membrane protein preparations from allogeneic MCAF cells or from normal syngeneic fibroblasts were not inhibitory. The in vitro-immunized cytotoxic lymphocytes did not impair the tumor growth in vivo as could be demonstrated by passive transfer of the lymphocytes in a Winn assay.     

Augmentation of specific immune response against a syngeneic SV40-induced sarcoma in mice by depletion of suppressor T cells with cyclophosphamide.

When cyclophosphamide was administered to mice before immunization with syngeneic SV40-transformed cells, the specific immune response elicited, as was measured by the tumor cell neutralization assay with a syngeneic SV40-induced sarcoma, was stronger and lasted longer as compared to the response generated in non-cyclophosphamide-treated mice. The augmentation effect of the drug was dependent on cyclophosphamide concentration, being optimal at 100 mg/kg, and on the time of drug administration in relation to antigen immunization, being optimal at 2–4 days before antigen administration. Transfer of T cells from normal syngeneic mice to drug-treated animals abolished the cyclophosphamide-induced augmentation of immune response. These results implied that cyclophosphamide-sensitive T cells suppressed the in vivo generation of specific effector T cells against SV40-induced sarcoma.     

The influence upon mitogenic and cellular immunologic reactive systems in vitro by poly(I:C) and BCG murine interferons induced in vivo.

We have previously reported that lymphocytes from W/Fu rats immunized with syngeneic (C58NT)D tumor cells were cytotoxic against these cells in a 4-hr ⁵¹Cr release assay. We have investigated the feasibility of cryopreserving lymphocytes and target cells and have selected freezing conditions which provide good yields of viable cells and functional activity. Lymphocytes from different animals had a recovery of 60–80% viability which resulted in a corresponding 55–75% recovery of cytotoxic activity. Repeated testing of lymphocyte cytotoxicity from a pool of frozen spleen cells against either fresh or frozen (C58NT)D cells gave reproducible cytotoxicity. In addition, recovery of high levels of lymphocyte function was also demonstrated when cryopreserved cells were employed in long-term cytotoxic assays, i.e., ³H-proline and ¹²⁵IUdR release assays, in the lymphoproliferative response to mitogens (PHA and Con A)³ or tumor cells (MLTI) as measured by ³H-thymidine incorporation, and in the in vitro generation of secondary cytotoxicity.By employing these cryoprotective techniques it is possible to have: 1) a population of lymphoid cells with known functional activity and 2) a pool of target cells with known susceptibility to lysis and antigenic content. Furthermore, the use of frozen cells as internal standards in each test also permits the analysis of assay variation as well as the study of variation in various cell types.     

Potentiation of the in vitro specific cytotoxic response to syngeneic lymphoma cells by PPD-stimulated tuberculin sensitive cells.

Spleen cells from rats immunized with the syngeneic (C58NT)D Gross virus-induced lymphoma have been shown to differentiate into cytotoxic effector cells following secondary in vitro stimulation with tumor cells. In the studies presented here, we evaluated whether cells specifically responding to PPD would increase the development of specific cytotoxic reactivity by a second cell population primed to lymphoma antigen. Mixtures of (C58NT)D-primed and BCG-primed responding cells generated cytotoxic activity to syngeneic lymphoma cells following cocultivation with mitomycin C-treated stimulating (C58NT)D cells; the addition of PPD to these mixtures produced a significant increase in cytotoxicity. The increased antitumor response resulted from an increase in specific cytotoxic activity from primed precursor cells. Responding cells activated with PPD alone in the absence of lymphoma antigen showed no lytic activity. Optimal numbers of tuberculin sensitive cells and concentration of PPD were determined. Evaluation of the kinetics of the generation of the cytotoxic response indicated that the addition of BCG-primed ceils and PPD increased the magnitude of cytotoxicity but did not alter the time course of the generation of cytotoxic activity. The addition of tuberculin sensitive cells and PPD to the in vitro secondary immune response also led to augmentation of generation of cells with antitumor activity detectable in vivo.     

Role of the H-2I region in the generation of an antiviral cytotoxic T-cell response in vitro

The participation of H-2I gene products in generating virus-specific proliferative and/or cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) responses was investigated. Spleen cells from mice infected with vaccinia virus were restimulated secondarily in vitro with syngeneic virus-infected peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) and then restimulated in tertiary cultures with virus-infected PEC from syngeneic and partially histoincompatible strains of mice. Based on the finding that comparable proliferative responses resulted when stimulating the responding cells were histocompatible at the H-2K, I, or D region of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), the additively enhanced, but not potentiated, proliferation caused by identity at two or three H-2 regions was analyzed. Enhancement of proliferation followed when the H-2K/D components plus virus and the H-2I components plus virus were either on the same, or alternatively on two, stimulating cells. This suggests that H-2K, D, and I plus virus trigger distinct T-cell subsets. A virus-specific CTL response was generated in vitro when spleen cells from virus-primed mice and even unprimed mice were stimulated with cells sharing only H-2K and/or H-2D of the MHC. Identity at the H-2I region did not stimulate a CTL response, nor did it influence the magnitude of the $\text{K}\text{D}$ restricted response. Nevertheless, the presence of anti-Ia antiserum in cultures of syngeneic stimulators and responders inhibited the cytotoxic response to a great extent. Therefore, H-2I region products seem to participate in the generation of virus-specific CTL in vitro.     

Helper factor(s) augment in vitro induction of tumor-specific immunity

Helper factor supernatants derived from alloantigen-activated murine lymphocytes augment the generation of cytolytic effector cells to syngeneic tumor cells. The effects are dose dependent and vary with the syngeneic tumor cell system studied. The effector cells are specific for the tumor-associated antigen(s) utilized for their induction, and are sensitive to lysis with anti-T-cell serum (Thy 1.2), but are insensitive to lysis with an allogeneic anti-NK-cell serum. The helper factor supernatants also augment the production of a “tissue-culture-induced” cytolytic cell (cultured NK cell), which is resistant to treatment with both anti-Thy 1.2 and anti-NK serum.     

Properties of reticulum cell sarcomas in SJL/J mice: II. Fate of labeled tumor cells in normal and irradiated syngeneic mice

Transplantable reticulum cell sarcoma (RCS) cells were labeled with ³H-uridine or ³H-thymidine in vitro and injected intravenously into normal and irradiated syngeneic SJL/J mice. RCS cells exhibited typical B cell migration characteristics in peripheral lymphoid organs in both normal and irradiated recipients, localizing in follicles in a pattern resembling that of labeled normal bone marrow cells. However, over the first 72 hr after transfer, RCS cells diluted their label much less in irradiated than in normal recipients, reflecting their inability to proliferate in the irradiated hosts. The presence of unlabeled tumor cells did not significantly affect the distribution of labeled normal bone marrow or lymph node cells in the recipients. Thus, RCS fails to grow in irradiated recipients in spite of undisturbed homing characteristics and in the absence of any evidence of cytotoxic influences from the host.     

Enhancement of tumor growth in mice: Evidence for the involvement of host macrophages

Intratumor host cells of methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcoma(s) were shown to enhance the in vivo outgrowth of syngeneic homologous tumors (MCIA, Mc2A, Mc2B) but not two heterologous T-lymphomas (EL4 and TLX9) in the Winn adoptive transfer assay. This enhancing activity was not restricted only to the latent period of tumor growth but was also observed during the period of active in vivo tumor proliferation. Tumor enhancement was mediated by a population of cells adherent to nylon wool and glass and insensitive to irradiation (with 850 rads) or to treatment with anti-Thy 1.2 serum and complement. Macrophages from peritoneal exudates of normal mice, used as control host cell population, showed similar tumor-enhancing activity. These findings suggest that tumor infiltrating host cells, predominantly macrophages appear to be the cell type responsible for tumor enhancement and active promotion of tumor growth (in vivo).     

MHC Class I Expression by Donor Hematopoietic Stem Cells Is Required to Prevent NK Cell Attack in Allogeneic,but Not Syngeneic Recipient Mice

NK cells resist engraftment of syngeneic and allogeneic bone marrow (BM) cells lacking major histocompatibility (MHC) class I molecules, suggesting a critical role for donor MHC class I molecules in preventing NK cell attack against donor hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs), and their derivatives. However, using high-resolution in vivo imaging, we demonstrated here that syngeneic MHC class I knockout (KO) donor HSPCs persist with the same survival frequencies as wild-type donor HSPCs. In contrast, syngeneic MHC class I KO differentiated hematopoietic cells and allogeneic MHC class I KO HSPCs were rejected in a manner that was significantly inhibited by NK cell depletion. In vivo time-lapse imaging demonstrated that mice receiving allogeneic MHC class I KO HSPCs showed a significant increase in NK cell motility and proliferation as well as frequencies of NK cell contact with and killing of HSPCs as compared to mice receiving wild-type HSPCs. The data indicate that donor MHC class I molecules are required to prevent NK cell-mediated rejection of syngeneic differentiated cells and allogeneic HSPCs, but not of syngeneic HSPCs.     

Immunoregulation in disseminated histoplasmosis: Characterization of splenic suppressor cell populations

Potent immunosuppressor cell activity was induced during the course of disseminated histoplasmosis in C3H/Anf mice. Spleen cells from infected mice severely suppressed the primary antibody response in vitro of normal syngeneic spleen cells to both a T-dependent antigen (sheep red blood cells) and a T-independent antigen (trinitrophenyl-lipopolysaccharide) at Weeks 1 and 3 of infection, respectively. Likewise, marked suppressor cell activity was present within lymph nodes. In a kinetic study, suppressor activity was detected first on Day 2 and increased to the maximum level on Day 4 after inoculation of Histoplasma capsulatum. Two populations of spleen cells express suppressor function in this model. One population, identified as T cells, was nonadherent to nylon wool columns; its suppressor capacity was abolished by anti-Thy 1 and reduced greatly by low-dosage X-irradiation (500 R). Cells of the second suppressor population had macrophage-like properties; although poorly adherent to plastic surfaces, they adhered to nylon wool columns and could be removed from spleen cell suspensions by carbonyl iron treatment; high-dosage X-irradiation (3000 R) and mitomycin C treatment failed to abrogate suppression by these cells.     

Prevention of macrophage tumoricidal activity by agents known to increase cellular cyclic AMP.

The concept of T-T cell interaction which was first suggested during cell-mediated immune response to alloantigens was evaluated in a syngeneic tumor system. The combination of lymph node and thymus cells from BALB/c mice immune against syngeneic tumor cells, mKSA, was shown to exhibit collaboration with respect to in vitro generation of effector cells capable of preventing growth of corresponding tumor cells in the tumor cell neutralization assay. While each cell population of either anatomical site did not prevent tumor growth when tested alone, combinations of both did. The antigen specificity of effector cells generated by synergizing cultures was similar to that of effectors derived from cultures containing optimal numbers of responding lymph node cells. The lymph node and thymus cell populations participating in synergy were found to be thymus dependent. These results suggest that we may be dealing with the same or similar T₁- and T₂-cell populations described before as displaying synergy in response to alloantigens in the graft versus host, mixed lymphocyte, and cell-mediated cytotoxicity reactions.     

Participation of three lymphoid cell types in the in vitro activation of cell-mediated immunity to a syngeneic gross virus-induced lymphoma in rats.

W/Fu rats inoculated with the syngeneic Gross-virus induced lymphoma, (C58NT)D, had transient lymphocyte-mediated specific cytotoxicity against the tumor cells at 7–15 days after tumor injection. Spleen cells 40 days after immunization (spleen 40) were unreactive by a direct 4-hr ⁵¹Cr release assay, but activity appeared after in vitro culture of these spleen eclls by themselves for 18–24 hr. The nature of the cells involved in the activation of cytotoxicity and the characteristics of the effector cells themselves were studied. Significant differences were seen in the cell types involved in the activation phase and the effector phase. Activation appeared to require the cooperation of three cell types. Induction of activity was lost by treatment of cells with ATS plus complement, by passage over an EAC-column, or by treatment with carbonyl iron. Thus, T cells, CRL and macrophages were necessary for full activation of cytotoxicity in spleen 40. In contrast, after activation, only CRL seemed to be required for cytotoxicity, and treatment wih ATS or carbonyl iron had little effect. The effector cell detected after in vitro activation was quite distinct from that seen in the direct cytotoxicity assay with spleen cells at 10 days after tumor cell inoculation. The early, direct cytotoxic reactivity was dependent on T cells, being eliminated by treatment with ATS and complement but not by EAC columns or carbonyl iron. It appears therefore that the in vitro activation is a separate mechanism for cytotoxicity against tumor cells, rather than a simple recovery of T cells from in vivo inhibition.     

Tumor-Specific Chromosome Mis-Segregation Controls Cancer Plasticity by Maintaining Tumor Heterogeneity

Aneuploidy with chromosome instability is a cancer hallmark. We studied chromosome 7 (Chr7) copy number variation (CNV) in gliomas and in primary cultures derived from them. We found tumor heterogeneity with cells having Chr7-CNV commonly occurs in gliomas, with a higher percentage of cells in high-grade gliomas carrying more than 2 copies of Chr7, as compared to low-grade gliomas. Interestingly, all Chr7-aneuploid cell types in the parental culture of established glioma cell lines reappeared in single-cell-derived subcultures. We then characterized the biology of three syngeneic glioma cultures dominated by different Chr7-aneuploid cell types. We found phenotypic divergence for cells following Chr7 mis-segregation, which benefited overall tumor growth in vitro and in vivo. Mathematical modeling suggested the involvement of chromosome instability and interactions among cell subpopulations in restoring the optimal equilibrium of tumor cell types. Both our experimental data and mathematical modeling demonstrated that the complexity of tumor heterogeneity could be enhanced by the existence of chromosomes with structural abnormality, in addition to their mis-segregations. Overall, our findings show, for the first time, the involvement of chromosome instability in maintaining tumor heterogeneity, which underlies the enhanced growth, persistence and treatment resistance of cancers.