Sexual selection and the evolution of sperm morphology in sharks

Post‐copulatory sexual selection, and sperm competition in particular, is a powerful selective force shaping the evolution of sperm morphology. Although mounting evidence suggests that post‐copulatory sexual selection influences the evolution of sperm morphology among species, recent evidence also suggests that sperm competition influences variation in sperm morphology at the intraspecific level. However, contradictory empirical results and limited taxonomic scope have led to difficulty in assessing the generality of sperm morphological responses to variation in the strength of sperm competition. Here, we use phylogenetically controlled analyses to explore the effects of sperm competition on sperm morphology and variance in sharks, a basal vertebrate group characterized by wide variation in rates of multiple mating by females, and consequently sperm competition risk. Our analyses reveal that shark species experiencing greater levels of sperm competition produce sperm with longer flagella and that sperm flagellum length is less variable in species under higher sperm competition risk. In contrast, neither the length of the sperm head and midpiece nor variation in sperm head and midpiece length was associated with sperm competition risk. Our findings demonstrate that selection influences both the inter‐ and intraspecific variation in sperm morphology and suggest that the flagellum is an important target of sexual selection in sharks. These findings provide important insight into patterns of selection on the ejaculate in a basal vertebrate lineage.     

Experimental evidence for the evolution of numerous,tiny sperm via sperm competition

Sperm competition, when sperm from different males compete to fertilize a female's ova, is a widespread and fundamental force in the evolution of animal reproduction. The earliest prediction of sperm competition theory was that sperm competition selected for the evolution of numerous, tiny sperm, and that this force maintained anisogamy. Here, we empirically test this prediction directly by using selective breeding to generate controlled and independent variance in sperm size and number traits in the cricket Gryllus bimaculatus. We find that sperm size and number are male specific and vary independently and significantly. We can therefore noninvasively screen individuals and then run sperm competition experiments between males that differ specifically in sperm size and number traits. Paternity success across 77 two-male sperm competitions (each running over 30-day oviposition periods) shows that males producing both relatively small sperm and relatively numerous sperm win competitions for fertilization. Decreased sperm size and increased sperm number both independently predicted sperm precedence. Our findings provide direct experimental support for the theory that sperm competition selects for maximal numbers of miniaturized sperm. However, our study does not explain why G. bimaculatus sperm length persists naturally at approximately 1 mm; we discuss possibilities for this sperm size maintenance.     

Sperm competition in the absence of fertilization in Caenorhabditis elegans

Hermaphrodite self-fertilization is the primary mode of reproduction in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. However, when a hermaphrodite is crossed with a male, nearly all of the oocytes are fertilized by male-derived sperm. This sperm precedence during reproduction is due to the competitive superiority of male-derived sperm and results in a functional suppression of hermaphrodite self-fertility. In this study, mutant males that inseminate fertilization-defective sperm were used to reveal that sperm competition within a hermaphrodite does not require successful fertilization. However, sperm competition does require normal sperm motility. Additionally, sperm competition is not an absolute process because oocytes not fertilized by male-derived sperm can sometimes be fertilized by hermaphrodite-derived sperm. These results indicate that outcrossed progeny result from a wild-type cross because male-derived sperm are competitively superior and hermaphrodite-derived sperm become unavailable to oocytes. The sperm competition assays described in this study will be useful in further classifying the large number of currently identified mutations that alter sperm function and development in C. elegans.     

Sperm competition in fishes: the evolution of testis size and ejaculate characteristics

Fishes show one of the widest ranges of sperm competition intensity of any animal group. Here we present a comparative study whose aim is to investigate the effect of relative intensity of sperm competition on investment in spermatogenesis and the number and size of sperm produced. We find that both the gonadosomatic index (GSI = [gonad weight/body weight] x 100) and sperm numbers increase with intensity of sperm competition across species but that sperm length decreases. These new findings are consistent with a raffle-based mode of sperm competition in fishes. Most of these results (positive correlation of the GSI and sperm number with sperm competition intensity) concur with the predictions of current sperm competition theory. However, we also find that sperm longevity decreases with sperm length across species. Current models for continuous fertilization suggest that if length increases a sperm's speed but decreases its longevity, sperm length should increase with sperm competition intensity, whereas models for instant fertilization suggest that sperm length should remain constant. The negative relationship found between sperm competition and sperm length therefore does not fit predictions of either model.     

Sperm competition and the evolution of the sperm hook in house mice

Sperm morphology varies considerably both between and within species. The sperm of many muroid rodents bear an apical hook at the proximal end of the head. The curvature of the sperm hook varies greatly across species, however the adaptive significance of the sperm hook is currently not known. In wood mice the apical hooks intertwine to form sperm ‘trains’, which exhibit faster swimming velocities than single cells. Thus, it has been suggested that if sperm ‘trains’ were advantageous in a competitive situation, then the apical sperm hook might be an evolutionary product of selection via sperm competition. A comparative study of rodent species provided support for the hypothesis, and showed that species with higher levels of sperm competition had more reflected sperm hooks. Here, we tested this hypothesis at the intraspecific level. We quantified sperm hook morphology from seven house mouse populations, and found that interpopulation variation in hook curvature was not explained by variation in sperm competition risk. Furthermore, observations of ejaculated sperm revealed that sperm groups are not a common characteristic of mouse ejaculates. We suggest that selection for sperm attachment to the oviduct epithelium, and thus better retainment of sperm fertilizing potential, may provide a more general explanation of the evolutionary relationship between sperm competition risk and the curvature of the sperm hook among rodents, and provide a phylogenetic comparison among rodent species that supports our hypothesis.     

Species specificity of hybridoma antibodies to surface antigens of guinea pig sperm

The species specificity of hybridoma antibodies to sperm surface antigens was studied. A collection of over 50 hybridoma antibodies that bind to the guinea pig sperm surface was tested for binding to mouse, rat, hamster, and human sperm by indirect immunofluorescence. None of the antibodies bind to mouse sperm. rat sperm, or human sperm. All but three of the antibodies also fail to bind to hamster sperm. AH-30, AH-31, and AH-1032, the three antibodies that crossreact with hamster sperm, show a different topographical localization on hamster sperm from that seen on guinea pig sperm. The three antibodies do not precipitate a ¹²⁵I surface-labeled antigen from hamster sperm extracts. However, from guinea pig sperm extracts, all three antibodies precipitate ¹²⁵I surface-labeled polypeptides with molecular weights (M_r) of 62,000, 52,000, and 38,000. This result suggests that the crossreacting antibodies may be recognizing different antigens on hamster and guinea pig sperm.     

Implications of diversity in sperm size and function for sperm competition and fertility

Sperm competition is now recognised as a potent selective force shaping many male reproductive traits. While the influence of sperm competition on sperm number is widely accepted, its effects upon sperm size remain controversial. It had been traditionally assumed that there is a trade-off between sperm number and sperm size, so that an increase in sperm number would result in a decrease in sperm size, under conditions of sperm competition. Contrary to this prediction, we proposed some time ago that sperm competition favours an increase in sperm size, because longer sperm swim faster and are more likely to win the race to fertilize ova. Comparative studies between species show that in many taxa such a relationship exists, but the consequences of an increase in sperm size may vary between taxa depending on the environment in which spermatozoa have to compete. We present new evidence showing that in mammals longer sperm swim at higher speeds. We also show that mean swimming speed is highly correlated with maximum swimming speed, so even if the fastest swimming sperm are more likely to fertilize, both measures are informative. When individuals of the same species are compared, ratios between the dimensions of different sperm components, as well as the shape of the head, seem better at explaining sperm swimming velocity. Finally, we show that mean and maximum sperm swimming speed determine male fertility. Other studies have shown that in competitive contexts, males with faster swimming sperm have higher fertilization success. We conclude that the available evidence supports our original hypothesis.     

The impact of ovulation mode on sperm quantity and quality in mammals

Ovulation generally takes two forms: spontaneous and induced. These two ovulatory modes are predicted to cause different levels of male–male competition due to differences in males’ ability to predict the timing of ovulation of females that use each mode. Ovulation mode has been shown to be correlated with differences in testis size, but it is not known whether ovulation type influences ejaculate traits, specifically sperm quantity (sperm concentration, ejaculate volume, total motile sperm per ejaculate) and/or sperm quality (% sperm motility, % normal sperm). Using a cross-species comparative analysis of 130 mammals, we found that sperm concentration and total motile sperm per ejaculate were significantly greater in spontaneous ovulators. In contrast, ejaculate volume, % sperm motility and % normal sperm were unrelated to ovulation type. These data show that ovulation alters sperm quantity by increasing sperm concentration but not ejaculate volume, and that sperm quality does not vary with ovulation mode.     

Determinants of Sperm Transfer by Males of the Noctuid Moth Heliothis virescens

Ejaculate composition can be an important determinant of male reproductive success in the face of sperm competition, which varies with the mating history of the female. Here we examine the effect of various male and female mating histories and morphological traits on ejaculate sperm numbers in the polyandrous moth Heliothis virescens. We show that when mating with nonvirgin females, males passed larger sperm packages (spermatophores) but did not alter either the sperm count or the ratio of nucleated-to-nonnucleated sperm. Males also passed fewer sperm in their second ejaculates. Finally, older males passed more sperm than did younger males. Earlier research found that females store more sperm from older males and that older males are more likely to gain sperm precedence over younger rivals. These earlier results, taken together with the present results, indicate that the advantage enjoyed by older males is due to an increased sperm count.     

Acrosomal status and motility of guinea pig spermatozoa during in vitro penetration of the cumulus oophorus

Previous studies have suggested that both acrosome-intact and acrosome-reacted guinea pig sperm are capable of binding to the zona pellucida of cumulus-free oocytes, but the acrosomal status of guinea pig sperm during penetration of the cumulus has not been reported. We made video recordings of the interaction between capacitated guinea pig sperm and cumulus-invested guinea pig oocytes. The videotapes were analysed to identify sperm with hyperactivated motility and to classify the acrosomal status of sperm during penetration of the cumulus and after binding to the zona pellucida. The resolution of the video recordings was not sufficient to recognise sperm with swollen acrosomes. However, sperm that had completed the acrosome reaction were easily identified. Acrosome-reacted sperm were found adherent to the outer boundary of the cumulus, but were never observed to penetrate the cumulus. The percentage of acrosome-intact, hyperactivated sperm was higher in the cumulus oophorus than in culture medium, suggesting that changes in motility were elicited in response to contact with the cumulus. Fully acrosome-reacted sperm were found adherent to the zona pellucida, and solubilised guinea pig zona pellucida was capable of inducing acrosome reactions in capacitated guinea pig sperm. Acrosome-intact sperm were also observed on the zona, but they were not tightly bound and did not have hyperactivated motility, suggesting that these sperm were not functionally capacitated. Our observations demonstrate that guinea pig sperm penetrate the cumulus matrix in an acrosome-intact state. Although we did not observe sperm undergoing the acrosome reaction, our observations and experimental data suggest that the acrosome reaction of guinea pig sperm is completed on or near the surface of the zona pellucida.     

Effect of hormone implantation on cryopreservation of Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus L.) sperm

Hormone implantation is widely applied in halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus L.) aquaculture to extend the sperm production season of broodstock males. The ability to combine this technique with cryopreservation would increase sperm availability, thereby improving reproduction success and facilitating gene management. In this paper, the cryopreservation ability of sperm from hormone-treated males was examined at three times post-implantation and compared with that of sperm from males that were not hormone-treated. All sperm samples were cryopreserved using the same method. The effectiveness of these techniques was assessed by examining the fertilization rate and motility of thawed sperm. The spermotocrit and concentration of fresh sperm samples were measured to reveal the effect of hormone implantation on sperm characteristics. The reported results indicate that hormone implantation did not affect cryopreservation efficiency. The fertilization rate resulting from thawed sperm of hormone-treated males showed no significant difference from that of untreated males or from fresh sperm. A significant positive relationship was demonstrated between the spermatocrit and concentration of sperm; and a significant decrease of spermatocrit was found in sperm collected from hormone-treated males 14days post-implantation. No significant linear relationship between spermotocrit and fertilization rate of thawed sperm was shown.     

The evolution of sperm-allocation strategies and the degree of sperm competition

The prevailing viewpoint in the study of sperm competition is that male sperm-allocation strategies evolve in response to the degree of sperm competition an ejaculate can expect to experience within a given mating. If males cannot assess the degree of sperm competition their ejaculate will face and/or they are unable to facultatively adjust sperm investment in response to perceived levels of competition, high sperm allocation (per mating) is predicted to evolve in the context of high sperm competition. An implicit assumption of the framework used to derive this result is that the degree of sperm competition is unaffected by changes in sperm-allocation strategies. We present theory based on an alternative perspective, in which the degree of sperm competition and the sperm-allocation strategy are coupled traits that coevolve together. Our rationale is that the pattern of sperm allocation in the population will, in part, determine the level of sperm competition by affecting the number of ejaculates per female in the population. In this setting, evolution in sperm-allocation strategies is driven by changes in underlying environmental parameters that influence both the degree of sperm competition and sperm allocation. This change in perspective leads to predictions that are qualitatively different from those of previous theory.     

No evidence of trade‐offs in the evolution of sperm numbers and sperm size in mammals

Post‐copulatory sexual selection, in the form sperm competition, has influenced the evolution of several male reproductive traits. However, theory predicts that sperm competition would lead to trade‐offs between numbers and size of spermatozoa because increased costs per cell would result in a reduction of sperm number if both traits share the same energetic budget. Theoretical models have proposed that, in large animals, increased sperm size would have minimal fitness advantage compared with increased sperm numbers. Thus, sperm numbers would evolve more rapidly than sperm size under sperm competition pressure. We tested in mammals whether sperm competition maximizes sperm numbers and size, and whether there is a trade‐off between these traits. Our results showed that sperm competition maximizes sperm numbers in eutherian and metatherian mammals. There was no evidence of a trade‐off between sperm numbers and sperm size in any of the two mammalian clades as we did not observe any significant relationship between sperm numbers and sperm size once the effect of sperm competition was taken into account. Maximization of both numbers and size in mammals may occur because each trait is crucial at different stages in sperm's life; for example size‐determined sperm velocity is a key determinant of fertilization success. In addition, numbers and size may also be influenced by diverse energetic budgets required at different stages of sperm formation.     

A model of constant random sperm displacement during mating: evidence from Scatophaga.

This paper extends the sperm displacement model of Parker et al. (Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 27, 55 (1990)), in which sperm displacement is viewed as a process in which one unit of sperm introduced displaces one unit of sperm from the female's sperm stores. Here this process is envisaged in terms of the change in density of sperm in the sperm stores. In matings with virgin females, only sperm store fluid is displaced at the start of sperm transfer, but if there is swift random mixing of seminal and sperm store fluid, the fluid displaced will contain sperm at the same average density as that in the sperm stores (random displacement). In mating of the same female by two or more males, the sperm density of the last male to mate is assumed to be independent of the presence of previous sperm; P2 (the proportion of eggs fertilized by the last male) thus equals the density of the last male's sperm divided by the current total density of sperm in the sperm stores. Once the sperm stores have reached the asymptotic density (equivalent to the input density, i.e. the density of sperm in the seminal fluid), the present model becomes equivalent to that of Parker et al. (1990). Predictions for this model are tested using all available data from the dung fly, Scatophaga stercoraria. They are based on the assumption that sperm are transferred at a constant rate with copulation time. The data concur with this model, and we conclude that it is better than various other simple alternatives for explaining P2 in Scatophaga.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Evolution of sperm size in nematodes: sperm competition favours larger sperm

In the free-living rhabditid nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, sperm size is a determinant of sperm competitiveness. Larger sperm crawl faster and physically displace smaller sperm to take fertilization priority, but not without a cost: larger sperm are produced at a slower rate. Here, we investigate the evolution of sperm size in the family Rhabditidae by comparing sperm among 19 species, seven of which are hermaphroditic (self-fertile hermaphrodites and males), the rest being gonochoristic (females and males). We found that sperm size differed significantly with reproductive mode: males of gonochoristic species had significantly larger sperm than did males of the hermaphroditic species. Because males compose 50% of the populations of gonochoristic species but are rare in hermaphroditic species, the risk of male-male sperm competition is greater in gonochoristic species. Larger sperm have thus evolved in species with a greater risk of sperm competition. Our results support recent studies contending that sperm size may increase in response to sperm competition.     

How the sperm lost its tail: the evolution of aflagellate sperm

The typical sperm is comprised of a head, midpiece and flagellum. Around this theme there is an enormous diversity of form--giant sperm, multi-flagellate sperm and also sperm that lack flagella entirely. Explaining this diversity in sperm morphology is a challenging question that evolutionary biologists have only recently engaged in. Nonetheless, one of the selective forces identified as being an important factor in the evolution of sperm form is sperm competition, which occurs when the sperm of two or more males compete to fertilize a female's ova. In species with a truly monandrous mating system, the absence of sperm competition means that the selection pressure on males to produce motile sperm may be relaxed. Potentially aflagellate sperm are less costly to produce, both in terms of energy and time. Thus, selection may therefore favour the loss of the sperm flagellum and any other motile mechanisms in monandrous taxa. A review of the literature revealed that 36 taxonomic groups, from red algae to fish, were found independently to have evolved aflagellate sperm. I review what is known about the mating systems of each of these taxa and their nearest sister taxa. A sister-group analysis using this information provided weak evidence suggesting that the evolution of aflagellate sperm could be linked to the removal of selective pressures generated by sperm competition.     

Effect of sex-sorting on the ability of fresh and cryopreserved bull sperm to undergo an acrosome reaction

Previous studies indicate that sex-sorted sperm exhibit different physiology, including fertilizing capacity, from non-sorted sperm. However, differences between X- and Y-bearing sperm in their ability to undergo an acrosome reaction have never been investigated. This study determined the ability of non-sorted and sex-sorted sperm to undergo the acrosome reaction prior to and after cryopreservation. Sperm were treated with dilauroylphosphatidylcholine (PC12) to induce the acrosome reaction and the percentages of live-acrosome-reacted sperm and dead sperm were evaluated. The X- and Y-bearing sperm reacted similarly to the PC12 treatment, regardless of whether sperm were assessed prior to or after cryopreservation. Fresh control sperm exhibited lower percentages of live sperm (60%) than either X- or Y- sorted sperm (69-74%, P<0.05). Percentages of live control sperm were also lower after thawing (29-35%) than sex-sorted sperm (55-58%, P<0.05). Control and sex-sorted fresh sperm responded similarly to PC12 treatment. However, sex-sorted cryopreserved sperm exhibited higher percentages of live-acrosome-reacted sperm (23%) than control sperm (9%, P<0.05) after 40 min without PC12 treatment. In addition, cryopreserved control sperm treated with 79 microM PC12 exhibited higher percentages of live-acrosome-reacted sperm than sex-sorted sperm. In conclusion, X- and Y-bearing sperm responded similarly to PC12 treatment. In addition, fresh sexed and non-sorted sperm responded similarly to PC12 treatment. However, cryopreserved sex-sorted sperm underwent an acrosome reaction more rapidly in the absence of PC12 (over a 40 min period) than the non-sorted sperm. Therefore, sex-sorting induced changes in sperm membranes that accelerated the acrosome reaction process in sperm after cryopreservation.     

An intermediate state of fertilization involved in internalization of sperm components

The pathway of sperm entry during sea urchin fertilization was analyzed by using sperm covalently labeled with fluorescent and radioactive tracers. Sperm that have been covalently labeled on their surfaces with fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) or a radioactive congener, diiodofluorescein isothiocyanate (¹²⁵IFC), transfer labeled components to the egg that persist throughout early development. In order to study the transfer of sperm components and their fate after fertilization, cytochalasin B-dependent inhibition of fertilization, previously shown to permit the cortical reaction of sea urchin eggs but block sperm pronuclear incorporation, was investigated. Under certain conditions cytochalasin B or D (CB or CD) results in about half of the activated eggs having both the sperm nucleus and the fluorescently labeled sperm components arrested apparently at the level of the egg plasma membrane. This arrest of internalization was reversed by removal of CB or CD, and the sperm derivatives entered the egg. When sperm were labeled noncovalently with ethidium bromide or rhodamine 123, fluorescence was transferred to the egg in the cytochalasin-inhibited state in a fashion similar to that found in normal fertilization; in both cases the sperm fluorescence disappeared within a few minutes of fertilization, due to the repartitioning of the noncovalent dyes into the egg cytoplasm. It is concluded that cytochalasin arrests fertilization at an intermediate step in which the sperm has fused with the egg to achieve cytoplasmic continuity, but in which the subsequent internalization of sperm components is inhibited. After removal of cytochalasins the fluorescent sperm components move from the egg surface to an internal site, a process that can be monitored by time-lapse video microscopy with an image intensifier to permit extended observations of sperm fluorescence. The cytoplasmic location of labeled sperm components was substantiated by autoradiography of early embryos fertilized with ¹²⁵IFC-labeled sperm; transfer of sperm components to an internal site was seen after fertilization of either sea urchin or mouse eggs. Taken together, the data suggest that the fate of the labeled sperm surface components, as well as that of the sperm nucleus, is to be transferred to the egg cytoplasm, and that this transfer is mediated by the actin-dependent cytoskeleton of the egg.     

Significance of peristaltic squeezing of sperm bundles in the silkworm, Bombyx mori: elimination of irregular eupyrene sperm nuclei of the triploid

Silkworm (Lepidoptera) males produce dimorphic sperm: nucleate eupyrene sperm and anucleate apyrene sperm. The eupyrene sperm are ordinary sperm to fertilise the eggs, while the function of apyrene sperm remains uncertain. After meiosis, 256 sperm cells are enclosed by a layer of cyst cells, forming a sperm bundle. We have previously documented that the nucleus of eupyrene sperm anchors to the head cyst cell, which locates at the anterior apex of the bundle, by an acrosome tubule-basal body assembly. Neither the basal body attachment to the nucleus nor the acrosome is seen in apyrene sperm, and the nuclei remain in the middle region of the bundle. Peristaltic squeezing starts from the anterior of the bundles in both types of sperm, and cytoplasmic debris of the eupyrene sperm, and both the nuclei and debris of apyrene sperm, are eliminated at the final stage of spermatogenesis. Since the irregularity of meiotic division in apyrene sperm is known, we used triploid silkworm males that show irregular meiotic division even in eupyrene spermatocytes and are highly sterile. The irregular nuclei of the triploid are discarded by the peristaltic squeezing just as those of the apyrene sperm. Transmission electron microscopic observations disclose the abnormality in the acrosome tubule and in the connection to the basal body. The peristaltic squeezing of sperm bundles in the silkworm appears to be the final control mechanism to eliminate irregular nuclei before they enter female reproductive organs.     

Variation in paternity in the field cricket Teleogryllus oceanicus: no detectable influence of sperm numbers or sperm length

Recent attention has focused on the role that sperm competitionmay play in the evolution of sperm morphology. Theoretical analysespredict increased sperm size, decreased sperm size, and no changein sperm size in response to sperm competition, depending onthe assumptions made concerning the life history and functionof sperm. However, although there is good evidence that spermmorphology varies widely within and between species, the adaptivesignificance of this variation has not been examined. Here wedocument significant intraspecific variation in sperm lengthin the field cricket, Teleogryllus oceanicus. Sperm length didnot influence the rate of migration of sperm from the spermatophoreto the female's spermatheca. We performed sperm competitiontrials in which we varied the numbers of sperm transferred byeach of two males that differed in the length of sperm theyproduced. Neither sperm length nor the number of sperm transferredinfluenced paternity. The same results were obtained using twodifferent methods for assigning paternity. The distributionof paternity across a female's mates was highly variable, withfrequently one, or more in the case of females mated to fourmales, principal sire. There were no mating order effects onpaternity. These data show that sperm do not mix randomly inthe female's spermatheca. We discuss several alternative explanationsfor the patterns of paternity observed.