Current advances in epigenetic modification and alteration during mammalian ovarian folliculogenesis

During the growth and development of mammalian ovarian follicles, the activation and deactivation of mass genes are under the synergistic control of diverse modifiers through genetic and epigenetic events. Many factors regulate gene activity and functions through epigenetic modification without altering the DNA sequence, and the common mechanisms may include but are not limited to: DNA methylation, histone modifications (e.g., acetylation, deacetylation, phosphorylation, methylation, and ubiquitination), and RNA-associated silencing of gene expression by noncoding RNA. Over the past decade, substantial progress has been achieved in studies involving the epigenetic alterations during mammalian germ cell development. A number of candidate regulatory factors have been identified. This review focuses on the current available information of epigenetic alterations (e.g., DNA methylation, histone modification, noncoding-RNA-mediated regulation) during mammalian folliculogenesis and recounts when and how epigenetic patterns are differentially established, maintained, or altered in this process. Based on different types of epigenetic regulation, our review follows the temporal progression of events during ovarian folliculogenesis and describes the epigenetic changes and their contributions to germ cell-specific functions at each stage (i.e., primordial folliculogenesis (follicle formation), follicle maturation, and follicular atresia).     

Expression and Preliminary Functional Profiling of the let-7 Family during Porcine Ovary Follicle Atresia

Most follicles in the mammalian ovary undergo atresia. Granulosa cell apoptosis is a hallmark of follicle atresia. Our previous study using a microRNA (miRNA) microarray showed that the let-7 microRNA family was differentially expressed during follicular atresia. However, whether the let-7 miRNA family members are related to porcine (Sus scrofa) ovary follicular apoptosis is unclear. In the current study, real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction showed that the expression levels of let-7 family members in follicles and granulosa cells were similar to our microarray data, in which miRNAs let-7a, let-7b, let-7c, and let-7i were significantly decreased in early atretic and progressively atretic porcine ovary follicles compared with healthy follicles, while let-7g was highly expressed during follicle atresia. Furthermore, flow cytometric analysis and Hoechst33342 staining demonstrated that let-7g increased the apoptotic rate of cultured granulosa cells. In addition, let-7 target genes were predicted and annotated by TargetScan, PicTar, gene ontology and Kyoto encyclopedia of genes and genomes pathways. Our data provide new insight into the association between the let-7 miRNA family in granulosa cell programmed death.     

miR-26b promotes granulosa cell apoptosis by targeting ATM during follicular atresia in porcine ovary

More than 99% of ovarian follicles undergo atresia in mammals, but the mechanism of follicular atresia remains to be elucidated. In this study, we explored microRNA (miRNA) regulation of follicular atresia in porcine ovary. A miRNA expression profile was constructed for healthy, early atretic, and progressively atretic follicles, and the differentially expressed miRNAs were selected and analyzed. We found that miR-26b, which was upregulated during follicular atresia, increased the number of DNA breaks and promoted granulosa cell apoptosis by targeting the ataxia telangiectasia mutated gene directly in vitro.     

Ovary genes and molecular pathology

In the ovary, primordial follicles have to pass different stages in order to become preovulatory follicles. In the past few years, new genes and therefore new proteins have been recognized as major players in folliculogenesis. Atm, kit ligand and its receptor c-kit are necessary for the maintenance of ovarian follicle pool. GDF-9, BMP15, originating from the oocyte play a major role in early folliculogenesis. Pro and antiapoptotic proteins such as Bax and Bcl2 complete in granulosa cells, in order to maintain or not the follicle alive. FSH receptor is necessary for final follicular maturation, from the preantral stage and beyond. LH receptor is necessary for follicle ovulation. However, new genes and their regulation need to be identified as many ovarian diseases such as premature ovarian failure are not yet clarified.     

Hyal-1 but not Hyal-3 deficiency has an impact on ovarian folliculogenesis and female fertility by altering the follistatin/activin/Smad3 pathway and the apoptotic process

Ovarian follicle development is a process regulated by various endocrine, paracrine and autocrine factors that act coordinately to promote follicle growth. However, the vast majority of follicles does not reach the pre-ovulatory stage but instead, undergo atresia by apoptosis. We have recently described a role for the somatic hyaluronidases (Hyal-1, Hyal-2, and Hyal-3) in ovarian follicular atresia and induction of granulosa cell apoptosis. Herein, we show that Hyal-1 but not Hyal-3 null mice have decreased apoptotic granulosa cells after the induction of atresia and an increased number of retrieved oocytes after stimulation of ovulation. Furthermore, young Hyal-1 null mice had a significantly higher number of primordial follicles than age matched wild-type animals. Recruitment of these follicles at puberty resulted in an increased number of primary and healthy preantral follicles in Hyal-1 null mice. Consequently, older Hyal-1 deficient female mice have prolonged fertility. At the molecular level, immature Hyal-1 null mice have decreased mRNA expression of follistatin and higher levels of phospho-Smad3 protein, resulting in increased levels of phospho-Akt in pubertal mice. Hyal-1 null ovarian follicles did not exhibit hyaluronan accumulation. For Hyal-3 null mice, compensation by Hyal-1 or Hyal-2 might be related to the lack of an ovarian phenotype. In conclusion, our results demonstrate that Hyal-1 plays a key role in the early phases of folliculogenesis by negatively regulating ovarian follicle growth and survival. Our findings add Hyal-1 as an ovarian regulator factor for follicle development, showing for the first time an interrelationship between this enzyme and the follistatin/activin/Smad3 pathway.     

Primordial follicle activation and follicular development in the juvenile rabbit ovary

Of all the stages of mammalian folliculogenesis, the primordial to primary follicle transition is the least understood. In order to gain new insights into this process, we have conducted a comprehensive morphological, morphometric and molecular study of ovarian organisation and early follicle development in the rabbit. The structure of ovaries collected from rabbits aged from 2–12 weeks (a period encompassing primordial follicle formation, activation and the first wave of folliculogenesis in this species) has been analysed by light microscopy and the follicles present have been measured and scored for their developmental stage. To establish useful molecular markers of activation, we have further classified follicles according to their expression of the proliferative marker, proliferating cell nuclear antigen, and the zona pellucida protein, ZPB. The activation of primordial follicles is initiated immediately following their formation in the rabbit ovary and is characterised by oocyte growth, granulosa cell morphogenesis and increased granulosa cell mitosis. Enhanced ZPB protein expression at the oolemma is also associated with follicle activation and development. Few primordial follicles in the juvenile rabbit ovary are lost by atresia, as assessed by the TUNEL assay. The appearance of apoptotic granulosa cells is however coincident with the development of antral follicles. This study thus describes the temporal and spatial regulation of early follicular development in the post-natal rabbit ovary and, for the first time, shows that the primordial to primary transition in the juvenile rabbit is a highly ordered process occurring within quantifiable parameters.K.J.H. was supported by the Pest Animal Control CRC and Post Graduate scholarships from the Australian National University.     

Requirement for ADAMTS-1 in extracellular matrix remodeling during ovarian folliculogenesis and lymphangiogenesis

Murine ovarian folliculogenesis commences after birth involving oocyte growth, somatic cell differentiation and structural remodeling of follicle stromal boundaries. The extracellular metalloproteinase ADAMTS-1 has activity against proteoglycans and collagen and is produced by the granulosa cells of ovarian follicles. Mice with ADAMTS-1 gene disruption are subfertile due to an unknown mechanism resulting in severely reduced ovulation. Here we show that ADAMTS-1 is necessary for structural remodeling during ovarian follicle growth. A significant reduction in the number of healthy growing follicles and corresponding follicle dysmorphogenesis commencing at the stage of antrum formation was identified in ADAMTS-1-/- ovaries. Morphological analysis and immunostaining of basement membrane components identified stages of follicle dysgenesis from focal disruption in ECM integrity to complete loss of follicular structures. Cells expressing the thecal marker Cyp-17 were lost from dysgenic regions, while oocytes and dispersed cells expressing the granulosa cell marker anti-mullerian hormone persisted in ovarian stroma. Furthermore, we found that the ovarian lymphatic system develops coincidentally with follicular development in early postnatal life but is severely delayed in ADAMTS-1-/- ovaries. These novel roles for ADAMTS-1 in structural maintenance of follicular basement membranes and lymphangiogenesis provide new mechanistic understanding of folliculogenesis, fertility and disease.     

Follicular populations, recruitment and atresia in the ovaries of different strains of mice

Follicular atresia is a key event in the selection of the ovulatory follicles and occurs during all developmental stages. The aims of the study were to evaluate the follicular population as well as the rates of follicular recruitment and atresia in different strains of mice. Ovaries were obtained from four strains of mice: G1/ Swiss, G2/ F1 Swiss×C57BL/6, G3/ inbred strain C57BL/6, and G4/ F1 C57BL/6×Swiss. All mice used in the study were 60 days old. Ovaries collected from the mice were fixed and processed for histological analysis. The G2 ovaries were also used to examine immunolocalization of active caspase-3. The pimordial follicle population was smaller in G3 mice than in G1, G2 and G4 groups (7 565±1 845 vs. 17 180±3 159, 14 785±3 319 and 13 325±2 685, respectively; p<0.05). The rate of follicular recruitment in G3, however, was higher than in the other groups (29.2% vs. 18.2%, 17.3% and 13.0% in G1, G2 and G4, respectively; p<0.05), resulting in a similar (p>0.05) number of antral follicles among groups. The small follicular pool in G3 mice was also associated with a lower rate of follicular atresia (11.4% vs. 17.2%, 16.7% and 13.6% for G3, G1, G2 and G4, respectively; p<0.05). The number of follicles stained with active caspase-3 was higher (p<0.05) during the final stage of preantral folliculogenesis than in other stages of follicular development suggesting that apoptosis in mice occurs earlier in comparison to large animals. Thus, it was concluded that differences in follicle reservoir among mice strains are compensated by an increased rate of follicular recruitment and a decreased rate of follicular atresia; and atresia occurs in mice mainly at the end of the preantral stage of folliculogenesis.     

p27kip1 (cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor 1B) controls ovarian development by suppressing follicle endowment and activation and promoting follicle atresia in mice

In humans, the molecular mechanisms underlying ovarian follicle endowment and activation, which are closely related to the control of female reproduction, occurrence of menopause, and related diseases such as premature ovarian failure, are poorly understood. In the current study, we provide several lines of genetic evidence that the cyclin-dependent kinase (Cdk) inhibitor 1B (commonly known as p27(kip1) or p27) controls ovarian development in mice by suppressing follicle endowment and activation, and by promoting follicle death. In p27-deficient (p27(-/-)) mice, postnatal follicle assembly was accelerated, and the number of endowed follicles was doubled as compared with p27(+/+) mice. Moreover, in p27(-/-) ovaries the primordial follicle pool was prematurely activated once it was endowed, and at the same time the massive follicular death that occurs before sexual maturity was rescued by loss of p27. In early adulthood, however, the overactivated follicular pool in p27(-/-) ovaries was largely depleted, causing premature ovarian failure. Furthermore, we have extensively studied the molecular mechanisms underlying the above-mentioned phenotypes seen in p27(-/-) ovaries and have found that p27 controls follicular development by several distinct mechanisms at different stages of development of the ovary. For example, p27 controls oocyte growth by suppressing the functions of Cdk2/Cdc2-cyclin A/E1 in oocytes that are arrested at the diplotene stage of meiosis I. This function of p27 is distinct from its well-known role as a suppressor of cell cycle progression. In addition, we have found that p27 activates the caspase-9-caspase-3-caspase-7-poly (ADP-ribose) polymeraseapoptotic cascade by inhibiting Cdk2/Cdc2-cyclin A/B1 kinase activities in follicles, thereby inducing follicle atresia. Our results suggest that the p27 gene is important in determining mammalian ovarian development. This study therefore provides insight into ovary-borne genetic aberrations that cause defects in folliculogenesis and infertility in humans.     

Gene expression of endothelin-1 in the porcine ovary: follicular development

We have investigated which follicular compartment and stage of follicular development are associated with endothelin-1 (ET-1) gene expression in the porcine ovary. The localization of mature ET-1 peptide and of its mRNA was determined by immunohistochemistry and by in situ hybridization. Stage of follicular development associated with ET-1 expression was investigated in terms of follicular class and occurrence of atresia. The latter was investigated by determining the occurrence of DNA fragmentation in apoptotic cells on adjacent sections to those used for ET-1 gene expression. Fifteen ovaries from 10 prepubertal pigs stimulated with gonadotropin were collected; a total of 1050 follicles were examined. Specific ET-1 immunoreactivity was restricted to the ovarian vasculature and to the granulosa cell compartment of antral follicles. The pattern of ET-1 mRNA expression was similar to that found for ET-1 immunoreactivity. Primordial, primary, and most secondary follicles did not express ET-1. The theca cell layer did not express ET-1 regardless of follicle developmental stage. ET-1 expression occurred with a significantly greater probability (P < 0.001 by the likelihood ratio test) in the granulosa cell compartment of antral follicles than in any other follicle class. Furthermore, in antral follicles, ET-1 expression occurred with a greater likelihood in large antral follicles than in small antral follicles (P < 0.001 by the likelihood ratio test). In small antral follicles, only 16.8% expressed ET-1; in contrast, 66.7% of large antral follicles exhibited ET-1 expression. It is interesting that in follicles in which ovulation had already occurred, intense ET-1 expression was found only in the prominent developing vasculature, the other cells present in the luteinized follicle did not display any ET-1 expression. The pattern of ET-1 gene expression observed in this study would be in agreement with our previous suggestion of a plausible physiological role for ET-1 in preventing premature progesterone production by granulosa cells of an antral follicle. The occurrence of atresia and expression of ET-1 in the same follicle was rare. Small and large antral follicles constituted 5.1% and 5.6%, respectively, of the examined follicles in this category. The majority of atretic follicles did not express ET-1 and, conversely, follicles that expressed ET-1 were not atretic. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report in which large, nonatretic follicles are clearly identified as the population of follicles expressing ET-1. The results of this study delineate the follicular developmental stage and the compartment of when and where ET-1 may be physiologically meaningful.     

Expression of follicle stimulating hormone and luteinizing hormone receptors during follicular growth in the domestic cat ovary

In order to better understand the pituitary regulation of follicular growth in the domestic cat, follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing hormone (LH) receptors (R) were localized and quantified in relation to follicle diameter and atresia using in situ ligand binding on ovarian sections. Expression of FSHR was homogeneous and restricted to follicle granulosa cells from the early antral stage onwards, whereas expression of LHR was heterogeneous on theca cells of all follicles from the early antral stage onward, and homogeneous on granulosa cells of healthy follicles larger than 800 microm in diameter and in corpora lutea. LHR were also widely expressed as heterogeneous aggregates in the ovarian interstitial tissue. Atretic follicles exhibited significantly reduced levels of both FSHR and LHR on granulosa cells, compared with healthy follicles whatever the follicular diameter, whereas levels of LHR on theca cells were lower only for atretic follicles larger than 1,600 microm in diameter. In healthy follicles, levels of FSHR and LHR in all follicular compartments increased significantly with diameter. Although generally comparable to that observed in other mammals, the expression pattern of gonadotropin receptors in the cat ovary is characterized by an early acquisition of LHR on granulosa cells of growing follicles and islets of LH binding sites in the ovarian interstitial tissue.     

In vivo effect of growth hormone on the expression of connexin-43 in bovine ovarian follicles

This study assessed the in vivo effects of recombinant growth hormone (rGH) administration on the expression of connexin-43 (Cx43) in bovine ovarian follicles. Two independent experiments were carried out using either estrous unsynchronized or synchronized multiparous Aberdeen Angus cows. rGH-treated animals were inoculated with a single dose of hormone (500 mg, intramuscular) while control animals were inoculated with hormone diluent. Five and 14 days after treatment (Experiments 1 and 2, respectively), ovarian Cx43 and apoptosis expression were assessed using immunohistochemistry. In both experiments primary, secondary, and tertiary follicles from rGH-treated and control groups distinctly expressed Cx43 protein. Primordial and atretic follicles were Cx43-negative. Interestingly, the number of Cx43 dots per granulosa cell did not show significant variation at different folliculogenesis stages neither in the rGH-treated nor in the control group. In unsynchronized animals, Cx43-positive follicles per total number of follicles ratio showed an interaction between stage of folliculogenesis and treatment due to significant differences between treatment groups in the early secondary follicle stage. In synchronized animals, there were significant differences between treatment groups and folliculogenesis stage. In both experiments, atretic follicles showed apoptosis-related DNA-fragmentation as determined by terminal uridin nick end labeling (TUNEL) assay. Tertiary follicles presented moderate TUNEL staining. Our results show significant increment in the number of ovarian follicles expressing the gap junction subunit Cx43 after in vivo rGH treatment. Therefore, we conclude that growth hormone can modulate in vivo gap junction assembly at early stages of folliculogenesis.