Topological testing of the mechanism of homology search promoted by RecA protein

To initiate homologous recombination, sequence similarity between two DNA molecules must be searched for and homology recognized. How the search for and recognition of homology occurs remains unproven. We have examined the influences of DNA topology and the polarity of RecA–single-stranded (ss)DNA filaments on the formation of synaptic complexes promoted by RecA. Using two complementary methods and various ssDNA and duplex DNA molecules as substrates, we demonstrate that topological constraints on a small circular RecA–ssDNA filament prevent it from interwinding with its duplex DNA target at the homologous region. We were unable to detect homologous pairing between a circular RecA–ssDNA filament and its relaxed or supercoiled circular duplex DNA targets. However, the formation of synaptic complexes between an invading linear RecA–ssDNA filament and covalently closed circular duplex DNAs is promoted by supercoiling of the duplex DNA. The results imply that a triplex structure formed by non-Watson–Crick hydrogen bonding is unlikely to be an intermediate in homology searching promoted by RecA. Rather, a model in which RecA-mediated homology searching requires unwinding of the duplex DNA coupled with local strand exchange is the likely mechanism. Furthermore, we show that polarity of the invading RecA–ssDNA does not affect its ability to pair and interwind with its circular target duplex DNA.     

Structure of helical RecA-DNA complexes. II. Local conformational changes visualized in bundles of RecA-ATP gamma S filaments

Complexes of RecA-DNA filaments, formed in the presence of a non-hydrolyzable ATP analog, ATP gamma S, aggregate together into regular bundles in the presence of Mg2+. Electron micrographs of several different forms of RecA-double-stranded DNA bundles have been analyzed: bundles of six supercoiled filaments at two different concentrations of Mg2+, and bundles of three supercoiled filaments at a single concentration of Mg2+. The bundles are all characterized by a regular left-handed supercoiling of the component filaments arising from the non-integral number of RecA subunits per turn of the RecA helix in these aggregates, about 6.15 units/turn. When single-stranded DNA is used instead of double-stranded DNA, regular aggregates composed of many filaments are formed. These aggregates do not supercoil, consistent with a symmetry of the component filaments of close to 6.0 units/turn. These different structures have provided a strong confirmation of the analysis of isolated RecA filaments. Since different RecA protomers within the component filaments of these aggregates are in different environments, they have provided a direct view of different conformations that RecA subunits may adopt within the same filament as a result of nonequivalent contacts. The conformational changes we have visualized are quite large, with apparent movements of mass over distances greater than 2 nm. The RecA-mediated strand exchange reaction is a highly dynamic process, which involves both the unwinding and stretching of DNA, in addition to the physical movement of DNA strands. It is quite likely, therefore, that the different conformations of RecA subunits seen in these aggregates represent different states of RecA during its enzymatic strand exchange activity.     

RecA protein-promoted homologous pairing between duplex molecules: functional role of duplex regions of gapped duplex DNA

RecA protein promotes homologous pairing and symmetrical strand exchange between partially single-stranded duplex DNA and fully duplex molecules. We constructed circular gapped DNA with a defined gap length and studied the pairing reaction between the gapped substrate and fully duplex DNA. RecA protein polymerizes onto the single-stranded and duplex regions of the gapped DNA to form a nucleoprotein filament. The formation of such filaments requires a stoichiometric amount of RecA protein. Both the rate and yield of joint molecule formation were reduced when the pairing reaction was carried out in the presence of a sub-saturating amount of RecA protein. The amount of RecA protein required for optimal pairing corresponds to the binding site size of RecA protein at saturation on duplex DNA. The result suggests that in the 4-stranded system the single-stranded as well as the duplex regions are involved in pairing. By using fully duplex DNA that shares different lengths and regions of homology with the gapped molecule, we directly showed that the duplex region of the gapped DNA increased both the rate and yield of joint molecule formation. The present study indicates that even though strand exchange in the 4-stranded system must require the presence of a single-stranded region, the pairing that occurs in duplex regions between DNA molecules is functionally significant and contributes to the overall activity of the gapped DNA.     

Homologous pairing and the formation of nascent synaptic intermediates between regions of duplex DNA by RecA protein

The RecA protein from E. coli gains access to duplex DNA, by nucleation from a short single-stranded gap, to form a spiral nucleoprotein filament that is capable of interaction with homologous duplex DNA. The observations described here demonstrate that any part of the nucleoprotein filament, whether it contains single- or double-stranded DNA, is capable of pairing with homologous duplex DNA. Homologous contacts between regions of duplex DNA lead to an increase in the initial rate and final extent of joint molecule formation. The experiments indicate that pairing is facilitated by the formation of nascent synaptic intermediates between duplex DNA sequences. Using chimeric form I DNA, which is incapable of forming an inter-wound or plectonemic joint with the gapped DNA due to the presence of flanking heterologous sequences, we show that these duplex-duplex pairing reactions involve extensive underwinding of the double helix.     

Three-stranded paranemic joints: architecture, topological constraints and movement

The RecA and SSB proteins will catalyze the joining of two DNA molecules containing homologous sequences but lacking homologous ends in a reaction termed paranemic joining. The absence of homologous ends can be achieved by (1) pairing two circular DNAs or (2) using linear DNA(s) with ends lacking homology to the pairing partner. Here we have used electron microscopy (EM) to examine such pairings. Circular M13 single-stranded (ss) DNA enveloped by RecA protein into a presynaptic filament was paired with linear M13mp7 double-stranded (ds) DNA containing non-M13 sequences at its ends. Joint complexes were frequently seen in which the dsDNA was joined with the presynaptic filament over several kilobase (10(3) bases) lengths of the dsDNA. In this region, the presynaptic filament appeared disorganized as contrasted to the customary helical structure of the filament containing only a single strand of DNA. The same ultrastructure, but with greater detail, was observed when the samples were prepared for EM without fixation using a new method of fast-freezing and freeze-drying. EM immunogold staining demonstrated the presence of SSB protein in the disorganized region containing all three strands, but not in the regular helically arranged region. Psoralen photo-crosslinking of the DNA in the joint complexes revealed that the three DNA strands were in close proximity only over a single short (200 to 300 base-pairs) region. The joining of nicked circular M13 dsDNA and presynaptic filaments containing circular M13 ssDNA resulted in the intertwining of the dsDNA about the circular presynaptic filament. The joints produced in this case were short, as was the single region of psoralen photo-crosslinking of the three DNA strands. A model of how these long three-stranded joints form is presented involving the movement of a short "true" paranemic joint along the presynaptic filament.     

By searching processively RecA protein pairs DNA molecules that share a limited stretch of homology

RecA protein promotes homologous pairing by a reaction in which the protein first binds stoichiometrically to single-stranded DNA in a slow presyn-aptic step, and then conjoins single-stranded and duplex DNA, thereby forming a ternary complex. RecA protein did not pair molecules that shared only 30 bp homology, but, with full efficiency, it paired circular single-stranded and linear duplex molecules in which homology was limited to 151 bp at one end of the duplex DNA. The initial rate of the pairing reaction was directly related to the length of the heterologous part of the duplex DNA, which we varied from 0 to 3060 base pairs. Since interactions involving the heterologous part of a molecule speed the location of a small homologous region, we conclude that RecA protein promotes homologous alignment by a processive mechanism involving relative motion of conjoined molecules within the ternary complex.     

The pairing activity of stable nucleoprotein filaments made from recA protein, single-stranded DNA, and adenosine 5'-(gamma-thio)triphosphate

Under conditions that diminish secondary structure in single-stranded DNA, stable presynaptic filaments can be formed by recA protein in the presence of the nonhydrolyzable analog ATP gamma S, without the need for Escherichia coli single strand binding protein. Such stable presynaptic filaments resemble those formed in the presence of ATP and pair efficiently with homologous duplex DNA. Since this kind of stable filament does not displace a strand from the duplex molecule, it provides a model substrate to study synapsis independent of the earlier and later stages of the recA reaction. Even though detectable strand displacement did not occur in the presence of ATP gamma S, both single strand and double strand breaks in duplex DNA stimulated homologous pairing. These and related observations support the view that the presynaptic nucleoprotein filament and naked duplex DNA intertwine to form a nascent joint in which the duplex DNA is partially unwound, i.e. in which the pitch of the involved duplex segment is reduced.     

Purification and characterization of the human Rad51 protein, an analogue of E. coli RecA.

In bacteria, genetic recombination is catalysed by RecA protein, the product of the recA gene. A human gene that shares homology with Escherichia coli recA (and its yeast homologue RAD51) has been cloned from a testis cDNA library, and its 37 kDa product (hRad51) purified to homogeneity. The human Rad51 protein binds to single- and double-stranded DNA and exhibits DNA-dependent ATPase activity. Using a topological assay, we demonstrate that hRad51 underwinds duplex DNA, in a reaction dependent upon the presence of ATP or its non-hydrolysable analogue ATP gamma S. Complexes formed with single- and double-stranded DNA have been observed by electron microscopy following negative staining. With nicked duplex DNA, hRad51 forms helical nucleoprotein filaments which exhibit the striated appearance characteristic of RecA or yeast Rad51 filaments. Contour length measurements indicate that the DNA is underwound and extended within the nucleoprotein complex. In contrast to yeast Rad51 protein, human Rad51 forms filaments with single-stranded DNA in the presence of ATP/ATP gamma S. These resemble the inactive form of the RecA filament which is observed in the absence of a nucleotide cofactor.     

Underwinding of DNA associated with duplex-duplex pairing by RecA protein

Homologous pairing between gapped circular and partially homologous form I DNA, catalyzed by Escherichia coli RecA protein, leads to the formation of nascent synaptic joints between regions of duplex DNA. These duplex-duplex interactions result in underwinding of the form I DNA, as detected by a topoisomerase assay. Underwound DNA species have been studied with regard to their formation, stability, and topological requirements. The synaptic joints are short-lived and of low frequency compared with those formed between single-stranded and duplex DNA. Measurement of the degree of underwinding indicates joints 300-400 base pairs in length, in which the two DNA molecules are presumed to be interwound within the RecA-nucleoprotein filament. Underwound DNA was not detected in reactions between gapped DNA and partially homologous nicked circular or relaxed covalently closed DNA. We have also investigated the requirements for the initiation of strand exchange. Previous results have shown that strand exchange requires a homologous 3'-terminus complementary to the gapped region. We now show that the minimum length of overlap required for efficient initiation of strand exchange is one to two turns of DNA within the RecA-DNA nucleoprotein filament.     

Right or left turn? RecA family protein filaments promote homologous recombination through clockwise axial rotation

The RecA family proteins mediate homologous recombination, a ubiquitous mechanism for repairing DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) and stalled replication forks. Members of this family include bacterial RecA, archaeal RadA and Rad51, and eukaryotic Rad51 and Dmc1. These proteins bind to single-stranded DNA at a DSB site to form a presynaptic nucleoprotein filament, align this presynaptic filament with homologous sequences in another double-stranded DNA segment, promote DNA strand exchange and then dissociate. It was generally accepted that RecA family proteins function throughout their catalytic cycles as right-handed helical filaments with six protomers per helical turn. However, we recently reported that archaeal RadA proteins can also form an extended right-handed filament with three monomers per helical turn and a left-handed protein filament with four monomers per helical turn. Subsequent structural and functional analyses suggest that RecA family protein filaments, similar to the F1-ATPase rotary motor, perform ATP-dependent clockwise axial rotation during their catalytic cycles. This new hypothesis has opened a new avenue for understanding the molecular mechanism of RecA family proteins in homologous recombination.     

The RecF protein antagonizes RecX function via direct interaction

The RecX protein inhibits RecA filament extension, leading to net filament disassembly. The RecF protein physically interacts with the RecX protein and protects RecA from the inhibitory effects of RecX. In vitro, efficient RecA filament formation onto single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB)-coated circular single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) in the presence of RecX occurs only when all of the RecFOR proteins are present. The RecOR proteins contribute only to RecA filament nucleation onto SSB-coated single-stranded DNA and are unable to counter the inhibitory effects of RecX on RecA filaments. RecF protein uniquely supports substantial RecA filament extension in the presence of RecX. In vivo, RecF protein counters a RecX-mediated inhibition of plasmid recombination. Thus, a significant positive contribution of RecF to RecA filament assembly is to antagonize the effects of the negative modulator RecX, specifically during the extension phase.     

The efficiency of strand invasion by Escherichia coli RecA is dependent upon the length and polarity of ssDNA tails

RecA protein is essential for homologous recombination and the repair of DNA double-strand breaks in Escherichia coli. The protein binds DNA to form nucleoprotein filaments that promote joint molecule formation and strand exchange in vitro. RecA polymerises on ssDNA in the 5'-3' direction and catalyses strand exchange and branch migration with a 5'-3' polarity. It has been reported previously, using D-loop assays, in which ssDNA (containing a heterologous block at one end) invades supercoiled duplex DNA that 3'-homologous ends are reactive, whereas 5'-ends are inactive. This polarity bias was thought to be due to the polarity of RecA filament formation, which results in the 3'-ends being coated in RecA, whereas 5'-ends remain naked. Using a range of duplex substrates containing ssDNA tails of various lengths and polarities, we now demonstrate that when no heterologous block is imposed, 5'-ends are just as reactive as 3'-ends. Moreover, using short-tailed substrates, we find that 5'-ends form more stable D-loops than 3'-ends. This bias may be a consequence of the instability of short 3'-joints. With more physiological substrates containing long ssDNA tails, we find that RecA shows no intrinsic preference for 5' or 3'-ends and that both form D-loop complexes with high efficiency.     

The mechanism of the search for homology promoted by recA protein. Facilitated diffusion within nucleoprotein networks

recA protein promotes the homologous pairing of single strands with duplex DNA by polymerizing on the single strands to make presynaptic nucleoprotein filaments which are polyvalent with respect to duplex DNA and which consequently form large networks or coaggregates when duplex DNA is added. Previous work has shown that efficient homologous pairing occurs within these networks. In the experiments described here, we observed that the length of the duplex DNA determined the stability of coaggregates, their steady state level, and the yield of joint molecules. Correspondingly, heterologous duplex DNA when preincubated with presynaptic filaments excluded subsequently added homologous duplex DNA from coaggregates and inhibited homologous pairing; the extents of exclusion and inhibition were determined by the length of the heterologous duplex DNA. On the other hand, long heterologous duplex DNA when added together with short homologous duplex DNA was capable of stimulating the absorption of the homologous molecules into coaggregates and increasing the rate of homologous pairing. In reactions involving short duplex molecules, polyamines exerted comparable effects on coaggregation and homologous pairing. We conclude that coaggregates are instrumental in homologous pairing, that they constitute distinct domains that are responsible for the processive or first order character of the pairing reaction, and that they act by concentrating DNA and facilitating diffusion.     

Synapsis and the formation of paranemic joints by E. coli RecA protein

E. coli RecA protein promotes the homologous pairing of a single strand with duplex DNA even when certain features of the substrates, such as circularity, prohibit the true intertwining of the newly paired strands. The formation of such nonintertwined or paranemic joints does not require superhelicity, and indeed can occur with relaxed closed circular DNA. E. coli topoisomerase I can intertwine the incoming single strand in the paranemic joint with its complement, thereby topologically linking single-stranded DNA to all of the duplex molecules in the reaction mixture. The efficiency of formation of paranemic joints, the time course, and estimates of their length, all suggest that they represent true synaptic intermediates in the pairing reaction promoted by RecA protein.     

Organized unidirectional waves of ATP hydrolysis within a RecA filament

The RecA protein forms nucleoprotein filaments on DNA, and individual monomers within the filaments hydrolyze ATP. Assembly and disassembly of filaments are both unidirectional, occurring on opposite filament ends, with disassembly requiring ATP hydrolysis. When filaments form on duplex DNA, RecA protein exhibits a functional state comparable to the state observed during active DNA strand exchange. RecA filament state was monitored with a coupled spectrophotometric assay for ATP hydrolysis, with changes fit to a mathematical model for filament disassembly. At 37 °C, monomers within the RecA-double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) filaments hydrolyze ATP with an observed k_cat of 20.8 ± 1.5 min⁻¹. Under the same conditions, the rate of end-dependent filament disassembly (k_off) is 123 ± 16 monomers per minute per filament end. This rate of disassembly requires a tight coupling of the ATP hydrolytic cycles of adjacent RecA monomers. The relationship of k_cat to k_off infers a filament state in which waves of ATP hydrolysis move unidirectionally through RecA filaments on dsDNA, with successive waves occurring at intervals of approximately six monomers. The waves move nearly synchronously, each one transiting from one monomer to the next every 0.5 s. The results reflect an organization of the ATPase activity that is unique in filamentous systems, and could be linked to a RecA motor function.     

Structural polymorphism of the RecA protein from the thermophilic bacterium Thermus aquaticus.

The Escherichia coli RecA protein has served as a model for understanding protein-catalyzed homologous recombination, both in vitro and in vivo. Although RecA proteins have now been sequenced from over 60 different bacteria, almost all of our structural knowledge about RecA has come from studies of the E. coli protein. We have used electron microscopy and image analysis to examine three different structures formed by the RecA protein from the thermophilic bacterium Thermus aquaticus. This protein has previously been shown to catalyze an in vitro strand exchange reaction at an optimal temperature of about 60 degrees C. We show that the active filament formed by the T. aquaticus RecA on DNA in the presence of a nucleotide cofactor is extremely similar to the filament formed by the E. coli protein, including the extension of DNA to a 5.1-A rise per base pair within this filament. This parameter appears highly conserved through evolution, as it has been observed for the eukaryotic RecA analogs as well. We have also characterized bundles of filaments formed by the T. aquaticus RecA in the absence of both DNA and nucleotide cofactor, as well as hexameric rings of the protein formed under all conditions examined. The bundles display a very large plasticity of mass within the RecA filament, as well as showing a polymorphism in filament-filament contacts that may be important to understanding mutations that affect surface residues on the RecA filament.     

Magnesium ion-dependent activation of the RecA protein involves the C terminus

Optimal conditions for RecA protein-mediated DNA strand exchange include 6-8 mm Mg(2+) in excess of that required to form complexes with ATP. We provide evidence that the free magnesium ion is required to mediate a conformational change in the RecA protein C terminus that activates RecA-mediated DNA strand exchange. In particular, a "closed" (low Mg(2+)) conformation of a RecA nucleoprotein filament restricts DNA pairing by incoming duplex DNA, although single-stranded overhangs at the ends of a duplex allow limited DNA pairing to occur. The addition of excess Mg(2+) results in an "open" conformation, which can promote efficient DNA pairing and strand exchange regardless of DNA end structure. The removal of 17 amino acid residues at the Escherichia coli RecA C terminus eliminates a measurable requirement for excess Mg(2+) and permits efficient DNA pairing and exchange similar to that seen with the wild-type protein at high Mg(2+) levels. Thus, the RecA C terminus imposes the need for the high magnesium ion concentrations requisite in RecA reactions in vitro. We propose that the C terminus acts as a regulatory switch, modulating the access of double-stranded DNA to the presynaptic filament and thereby inhibiting homologous DNA pairing and strand exchange at low magnesium ion concentrations.     

Electron microscopic visualization of RecA-DNA filaments: Evidence for a cyclic extension of duplex DNA

As visualized by electron microscopy, RecA protein binds in a highly cooperative manner to single-stranded fd DNA in solutions of 0.01 M Tris (pH 7.5). The resulting nucleoprotein filament loops are 1.25 μm in length, have a fiber diameter of 12 nm and show an indication of a 4.5 nm repeat along the axis of the compact fibers. RecA binds to linear duplex fd DNA in solutions of 0.01 M Tris (pH 7.5) to yield chains of beads which, in the presence of Mg²⁺ and ATP, coalesce into smooth filaments with a length of 1.9 μm (the length of protein-free fd duplex DNA) and have a fiber diameter of 12 nm. In solutions containing Mg²⁺ and ATP-γ-S, however, RecA binds to duplex DNA in a highly cooperative manner to yield rigid filaments 3.0 μm in length. These filaments are 12 nm in diameter and show a very clear 7.5 nm axial repeat. This extension of DNA to 150% of its usual length in the apparent absence of any single-stranded components suggests that the DNA helix must also be highly unwound and provides new insights into the mode of RecA action.     

Homologous pairing in duplex DNA regions and the formation of four-stranded paranemic joints promoted by RecA protein. Effects of gap length and negative superhelicity

RecA protein catalyzes homologous pairing of partially single-stranded duplex DNA and fully duplex DNA to form stable joint molecules. We constructed circular duplex DNA with various defined gap lengths and studied the pairing reaction between the gapped substrate with fully double-stranded DNA. The reaction required a stoichiometric amount of RecA protein, and the optimal reaction was achieved at a ratio of 1 RecA monomer per 4 base pairs. The length of the gap, ranging from 141 to 1158 nucleotides, had little effect on the efficiency of homologous pairing. By using a circular gapped duplex DNA prepared from the chimeric phage M13Gori1, we were able to show the formation of nonintertwined or paranemic joints in duplex regions between the gapped and fully duplex molecules. The formation of such paranemic joints occurred efficiently and included nearly all of the DNA in the reaction mixture. The reaction required negative superhelicity, and pairing was greatly reduced with linear or nicked circular DNA. We conclude that one functional role of the single-stranded gap is for facilitating the binding of RecA protein to the duplex region of the gapped DNA. Once the nucleoprotein filament is formed, homologous pairing between the gapped and fully duplex DNA can take place anywhere along the length of the nucleoprotein complex.