Comparison of droplet digital PCR with quantitative real-time PCR for determination of zygosity in transgenic maize

This study evaluated the applicability of droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) as a tool for maize zygosity determination using quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) as a reference technology. Quantitative real-time PCR is commonly used to determine transgene copy number or GMO zygosity characterization. However, its effectiveness is based on identical reaction efficiencies for the transgene and the endogenous reference gene. Additionally, a calibrator sample should be utilized for accuracy. Droplet digital PCR is a DNA molecule counting technique that directly counts the absolute number of target and reference DNA molecules in a sample, independent of assay efficiency or external calibrators. The zygosity of the transgene can be easily determined using the ratio of the quantity of the target gene to the reference single copy endogenous gene. In this study, both the qPCR and ddPCR methods were used to determine insect-resistant transgenic maize IE034 zygosity. Both methods performed well, but the ddPCR method was more convenient because of its absolute quantification property.     

Transgene copy number comparison in recombinant mammalian cell lines: critical reflection of quantitative real-time PCR evaluation

Nucleic acid quantification is a relevant issue for the characterization of mammalian recombinant cell lines and also for the registration of producer clones. Quantitative real-time PCR is a powerful tool to investigate nucleic acid levels but numerous different quantification strategies exist, which sometimes lead to misinterpretation of obtained qPCR data. In contrast to absolute quantification using amplicon- or plasmid standard curves, relative quantification strategies relate the gene of interest to an endogenous reference gene. The relative quantification methods also consider the amplification efficiency for the calculation of the gene copy number and thus more accurate results compared to absolute quantification methods are generated. In this study two recombinant Chinese hamster ovary cell lines were analysed for their transgene copy number using different relative quantification strategies. The individual calculation methods resulted in differences of relative gene copy numbers because efficiency calculations have strong impact on gene copy numbers. However, in context of comparing transgene copy numbers of two individual clones the influence of the calculation method is marginal. Therefore especially for the comparison of two cell lines with the identical transgene any of the relative qPCR methods was proven as powerful tool.     

Estimating the copy number of transgenes in transformed rice by real-time quantitative PCR

In transgenic plants, transgene copy number can greatly influence the expression level and genetic stability of the target gene, making estimation of transgene copy number an important area of genetically modified (GM) crop research. Transgene copy numbers are currently estimated by Southern analysis, which is laborious and time-consuming, requires relatively large amounts of plant materials and may involve hazardous radioisotopes. We report here the development of a sensitive, high-throughput real-time (RT)-PCR technique for estimating transgene copy number in GM rice. This system uses TaqMan quantitative RT-PCR and comparison to a novel rice endogenous reference gene coding for sucrose phosphate synthase (SPS) to determine the copy numbers of the exogenous beta-glucuronidase (GUS) and hygromycin phosphotransferase (HPT) genes in transgenic rice. The copy numbers of the GUS and HPT in primary rice transformants (T0) were calculated by comparing quantitative PCR results of the GUS and HPT genes with those of the internal standard, SPS. With optimized PCR conditions, we achieved significantly accurate estimates of one, two, three and four transgene copies in the T0 transformants. Furthermore, our copy number estimations of both the GUS reporter gene and the HPT selective marker gene showed that rearrangements of the T-DNA occurred more frequently than is generally believed in transgenic rice.     

Genomic DNA functions as a universal external standard in quantitative real-time PCR

Real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR) is a powerful tool for quantifying specific DNA target sequences. Although determination of relative quantity is widely accepted as a reliable means of measuring differences between samples, there are advantages to being able to determine the absolute copy numbers of a given target. One approach to absolute quantification relies on construction of an accurate standard curve using appropriate external standards of known concentration. We have validated the use of tissue genomic DNA as a universal external standard to facilitate quantification of any target sequence contained in the genome of a given species, addressing several key technical issues regarding its use. This approach was applied to validate mRNA expression of gene candidates identified from microarray data and to determine gene copies in transgenic mice. A simple method that can assist achieving absolute quantification of gene expression would broadly enhance the uses of real-time qPCR and in particular, augment the evaluation of global gene expression studies.     

Improvement of peanut (Arachis hypogaea L.) transformation efficiency and determination of transgene copy number by relative quantitative real-time PCR

The biolistic method is reliable for delivering genes of interest into various species, but low transformation efficiency can be a limiting factor in its application. To test various conditions that could improve peanut transformation via particle bombardment, embryogenic tissues of the peanut cultivar Georgia Green were co-bombarded with two plasmids: one containing a green fluorescent protein gene and one containing a gene of interest plus a selectable marker. The fluorescence in bombarded embryogenic tissues was measured to evaluate transformation efficiency. A 4.6-fold improvement of transformation efficiency was achieved in stably transformed peanut lines by introducing protamine instead of conventional spermidine in a bombardment mixture with 70 ng/shot plasmid DNA and 50 μg/shot gold. Unexpectedly, the reduction of plasmid DNA from 700 to 70 ng/shot produced transgenic lines with significantly increased numbers of transgene copies. To determine the transgene copy number during plantlet regeneration, relative quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) was established using fluorescently labeled universal library probes. A correlation of 95% was found for estimation of copy number between Southern blot and qPCR data. Given its speed and high-throughput nature, qPCR can be employed as an effective screening tool to separate high copy number events from low copy number events as early as the shoot formation stage of regeneration.     

Estimating transgene copy number in precocious trifoliate orange by TaqMan real-time PCR

Transgene copy number has a great impact on the expression level and stability of exogenous gene in transgenic plants, so transgene copy number analysis is identified as one most important task after obtaining transgenic plants. In this paper, TaqMan real-time PCR was used to estimate the copy number of exogenous MAC12.2 and NPTII genes in transgenic precocious trifoliate orange (Poncirus trifoliata [L.] Raf) in order to overcome the limitations of Southern blot analysis, which is labor-intensive, time-consuming, in considerable needs of DNA, etc. We developed a real-time PCR assay which permitted the determination of the copy number of transgene (MAC12.2 and NPTII), relative to a conserved endogenous gene (PtLTP) in transgenic lines. R value is 0.92 by comparing the results to that of Southern blot analysis, indicating a strong correlation coefficient between TaqMan real-time PCR assay and Southern blot method.     

REAL-TIME PCR方法测定转基因小麦中外源基因拷贝数

采用SYBR GreenⅠ real-time PCR方法检测7株转基因小麦中外源半夏凝集素基因的拷贝数。以小麦蜡质基因（wx012）作为内参基因,以未转基因小麦基因组DNA为内参基因标准品进行5倍梯度稀释得到内参基因CT值与起始模板量的相关性标准曲线：y=-0.2667x+6.98;以含半夏凝集素基因（pta）的质粒DNA为目的基的因标准品同样进行5倍梯度稀释,建立目的基因CT值与起始模板量的相关性标准曲线：y=-0.2118x+4.53。通过SYBR GreenⅠ real-time PCR分别获得每一样本中目的基因和内参基因的CT值,将CT值分别代入标准曲线计算该样本中内参基因和目的基因起始模板量,目的基因与内参基因起始模板量比值即是目的基因在该转基因植株中的拷贝数。计算结果为：单拷贝的有1株,2个拷贝1株,3拷贝和4拷贝的各有2株,其中有1株为假阳性植株。     

An evaluation of new and established methods to determine T‐DNA copy number and homozygosity in transgenic plants.

Stable transformation of plants is a powerful tool for hypothesis testing. A rapid and reliable evaluation method of the transgenic allele for copy number and homozygosity is vital in analysing these transformations. Here the suitability of Southern blot analysis, thermal asymmetric interlaced (TAIL‐)PCR, quantitative (q)PCR and digital droplet (dd)PCR to estimate T‐DNA copy number, locus complexity and homozygosity were compared in transgenic tobacco. Southern blot analysis and ddPCR on three generations of transgenic offspring with contrasting zygosity and copy number were entirely consistent, whereas TAIL‐PCR often underestimated copy number. qPCR deviated considerably from the Southern blot results and had lower precision and higher variability than ddPCR. Comparison of segregation analyses and ddPCR of T₁ progeny from 26 T₀ plants showed that at least 19% of the lines carried multiple T‐DNA insertions per locus, which can lead to unstable transgene expression. Segregation analyses failed to detect these multiple copies, presumably because of their close linkage. This shows the importance of routine T‐DNA copy number estimation. Based on our results, ddPCR is the most suitable method, because it is as reliable as Southern blot analysis yet much faster. A protocol for this application of ddPCR to large plant genomes is provided.     

1,2-propanediol-trehalose mixture as a potent quantitative real-time PCR enhancer

Background  

Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) is becoming increasingly important for DNA genotyping and gene expression analysis. For continuous monitoring of the production of PCR amplicons DNA-intercalating dyes are widely used. Recently, we have introduced a new qPCR mix which showed improved amplification of medium-size genomic DNA fragments in the presence of DNA dye SYBR green I (SGI). In this study we tested whether the new PCR mix is also suitable for other DNA dyes used for qPCR and whether it can be applied for amplification of DNA fragments which are difficult to amplify.     

High-throughput assessment of transgene copy number in sugarcane using real-time quantitative PCR

Accurate and timely detection of transgene copy number in sugarcane is currently hampered by the requirement to use Southern blotting, needing relatively large amounts of genomic DNA and, therefore, the continued growth and maintenance of bulky plants in containment glasshouses. In addition, the sugarcane genome is both polyploid and aneuploid, complicating the identification of appropriate genes for use as references in the development of a high-throughput method. Using bioinformatic techniques followed by in vitro testing, two genes that appear to occur once per base genome of sugarcane were identified. Using these genes as reference genes, a high-throughput assay employing RT-qPCR was developed and tested using a group of sugarcane plants that contained unknown numbers of copies of the nptII gene encoding kanamycin resistance. Using this assay, transgene copy numbers from 3 to more than 50 were identified. In comparison, Southern blotting accurately identified the number of transgene copies for one line and by inference for another, but was not able to provide an accurate estimation for transgenic lines containing numerous copies of the nptII gene. Using the reference genes identified in this study, a high-throughput assay for the determination of transgene copy number was developed and tested for sugarcane. This method requires much less input DNA, can be performed much earlier in the production of transgenic sugarcane plants and allows much more efficient assessment of numerous potentially transgenic lines than Southern blotting.     

An improved method for determination of gene copy numbers in transgenic mice by serial dilution curves obtained by real-time quantitative PCR assay

Precise characterization of transgene insertion is necessary for phenotype interpretation of transgenic animals. To check for the presence of deletions, estimate the number of inserted transgene copies, and in addition, identify the zygosity of transgenic mice, gene copy numbers were determined by real-time quantitative PCR. Instead of correlating tested samples to a single relative standard curve, serial dilution curves were constructed for every mouse sample. A novel statistical approach was designed in which mice with the same copy number were characterized by the adjusted group mean and standard deviation common to the target sequence. This enabled us to characterize the variability of the obtained results, statistically compare different groups of mice and estimate precision and limits of the applied method.     

Serious Overestimation in Quantitative PCR by Circular (Supercoiled) Plasmid Standard: Microalgal pcna as the Model Gene

Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) has become a gold standard for the quantification of nucleic acids and microorganism abundances, in which plasmid DNA carrying the target genes are most commonly used as the standard. A recent study showed that supercoiled circular confirmation of DNA appeared to suppress PCR amplification. However, to what extent to which different structural types of DNA (circular versus linear) used as the standard may affect the quantification accuracy has not been evaluated. In this study, we quantitatively compared qPCR accuracies based on circular plasmid (mostly in supercoiled form) and linear DNA standards (linearized plasmid DNA or PCR amplicons), using proliferating cell nuclear gene (pcna), the ubiquitous eukaryotic gene, in five marine microalgae as a model gene. We observed that PCR using circular plasmids as template gave 2.65-4.38 more of the threshold cycle number than did equimolar linear standards. While the documented genome sequence of the diatom Thalassiosira pseudonana shows a single copy of pcna, qPCR using the circular plasmid as standard yielded an estimate of 7.77 copies of pcna per genome whereas that using the linear standard gave 1.02 copies per genome. We conclude that circular plasmid DNA is unsuitable as a standard, and linear DNA should be used instead, in absolute qPCR. The serious overestimation by the circular plasmid standard is likely due to the undetected lower efficiency of its amplification in the early stage of PCR when the supercoiled plasmid is the dominant template.     

Rapid determination of transgene copy number in stably-transfected mammalian cells by competitive PCR

We describe here an application of the competitive PCR technique to the analysis of copy number of recombinant rat parathyroid hormone-related protein (rPTHrP) gene in stably-transfected murine erythroleukemia (MEL) cell lines. A single-copy reference gene (endogenous mouse PTHrP gene or mPTHrP) is used as an internal control. This control gene, present in the genome of MEL cells, shares the same primer binding sites as the rPTHrP cDNA but contains an internal PvuII site, which allows resolution of the amplified products after restriction enzyme digestion by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE). The transgene copy number is determined by the ratio of band intensity of the rPTHrP product to that of the mPTHrP product. Using this method, we have determined the copy number of the rPTHrP transgene from isolated genomic DNA, and compared the results with those obtained from Southern blot analysis. In addition, we have demonstrated that the procedure can be applied very simply to whole MEL cells without DNA extractions and that as few as 10⁴ cells are required for the analysis.     

Real-time PCR to determine transgene copy number and to quantitate the biolocalization of adoptively transferred cells from EGFP-transgenic mice

Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) is a sensitive technique for the detection and quantitation of specific DNA sequences. Here we describe a Taqman qPCR assay for quantification of tissue-localized, adoptively transferred enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-transgenic cells. A standard curve constructed from serial dilutions of a plasmid containing the EGFP transgene was (i) highly reproducible, (ii) detected as few as two copies, and (iii) was included in each qPCR assay. qPCR analysis of genomic DNA was used to determine transgene copy number in several mouse strains. Fluorescent microscopy of tissue sections showed that adoptively transferred vascular endothelial cells (VEC) from EGFP-transgenic mice specifically localized to tissue with metastatic tumors in syngeneic recipients. VEC microscopic enumeration of liver metastases strongly correlated with qPCR analysis of identical sections (Pearson correlation 0.81). EGFP was undetectable in tissue from control mice by qPCR. In another study using intra-tumor EGFP-VEC delivery to subcutaneous tumors, manual cell count and qPCR analysis of alternating sections also strongly correlated (Pearson correlation 0.82). Confocal microscopy of the subcutaneous tumor sections determined that visual fluorescent signals were frequently tissue artifacts. This qPCR methodology offers specific, objective, and rapid quantitation, uncomplicated by tissue autofluorescence, and should be readily transferable to other in vivo models to quantitate the biolocalization of transplanted cells.     

Using real-time PCR to determine transgene copy number in wheat

Transgene copy number is usually determined by means of Southern blot analysis which can be time consuming and laborious. In this study, quantitative real-time PCR was developed to determine transgene copy number in transgenic wheat. A conserved wheat housekeeping gene,puroindoline-b, was used as an internal control to calculate transgene copy number. Estimated copy number in transgenic lines using real-time quantitative PCR was correlated with actual copy number based on Southern blot analysis. Real-time PCR can analyze hundreds of samples in a day, making it an efficient method for estimating copy number in transgenic wheat.     

Accurate Determination of Zygosity in Transgenic Rice by Real-time PCR Does Not Require Standard Curves or Efficiency Correction

A number of quantitative, real-time PCR methods have been developed for determining transgene copy numbers in plants. Here, we demonstrate that the Roche LightCycler^TM system can be used to determine the zygosity of transgenic lines without the use of standard curves or efficiency correction calculations. We have developed a duplex PCR assay which permits the determination of zygosity, relative to a calibrator sample, in transgenic rice lines containing the gene for a viral glycoprotein. Our data demonstrate that unambiguous 2-fold discrimination of copy number can be attained by calculating relative copy number using the threshold crossing point (Ct) calculated by the LightCycler^TM software combined with delta delta Ct calculations, provided that the appropriate calibrator sample is included in each run. The method presented here is rapid, sensitive, robust and easy to optimise.     

Quantitative real-time PCR as a screening tool for estimating transgene copy number in WHISKERS™-derived transgenic maize

. Quantitative real-time PCR (qRT-PCR) was adapted to estimate transgene copy number in transgenic maize callus and plants. WHISKERS™-derived transgenic callus lines and plants were generated using two different gene constructs. These transgenic materials represented a range of copy number. A 'standard curve' was established by mixing plasmid DNA with non-transgenic genomic maize DNA using a calculated ratio of target gene to host genome size. 'Estimated' copy number in the callus lines and plants using qRT-PCR was correlated with the 'actual' copy number based on Southern blot analysis. The results indicated that there was a significant correlation between the two methods with both gene constructs. Thus, qRT-PCR represents an efficient means of estimating copy number in transgenic maize.     

Quantitative real-time PCR assay to detect transgene copy number in cotton (Gossypium hirsutum)

A TaqMan quantitative real-time PCR detection system was developed to examine transgene copy number in cotton. GhUBC1, a gene validated to be present as a single copy per haploid Gossypium hirsutum genome, was used as the endogenous reference to estimate copy number of GFP and selection marker NPTII in 28 T0 plants. This system was found to be more accurate than genomic Southern blot hybridization and could effectively tell homozygotes from heterozygotes in a T1 transgenic cotton population. Therefore it is suitable for efficient and cost effective early screening of transgenic seedlings and identifying transgene homozygotes in segregation populations.