RNA mutagenesis yields highly diverse mRNA libraries for <Emphasis Type="Italic">in vitro</Emphasis>protein evolution

Background  

In protein drug development, in vitro molecular optimization or protein maturation can be used to modify protein properties. One basic approach to protein maturation is the introduction of random DNA mutations into the target gene sequence to produce a library of variants that can be screened for the preferred protein properties. Unfortunately, the capability of this approach has been restricted by deficiencies in the methods currently available for random DNA mutagenesis and library generation. Current DNA based methodologies generally suffer from nucleotide substitution bias that preferentially mutate particular base pairs or show significant bias with respect to transitions or transversions. In this report, we describe a novel RNA-based random mutagenesis strategy that utilizes Qβ replicase to manufacture complex mRNA libraries with a mutational spectrum that is close to the ideal.     

A computer program for the estimation of protein and nucleic acid sequence diversity in random point mutagenesis libraries

A computer program for the generation and analysis of in silico random point mutagenesis libraries is described. The program operates by mutagenizing an input nucleic acid sequence according to mutation parameters specified by the user for each sequence position and type of point mutation. The program can mimic almost any type of random mutagenesis library, including those produced via error-prone PCR (ep-PCR), mutator Escherichia coli strains, chemical mutagenesis, and doped or random oligonucleotide synthesis. The program analyzes the generated nucleic acid sequences and/or the associated protein library to produce several estimates of library diversity (number of unique sequences, point mutations, and single point mutants) and the rate of saturation of these diversities during experimental screening or selection of clones. This information allows one to select the optimal screen size for a given mutagenesis library, necessary to efficiently obtain a certain coverage of the sequence-space. The program also reports the abundance of each specific protein mutation at each sequence position, which is useful as a measure of the level and type of mutation bias in the library. Alternatively, one can use the program to evaluate the relative merits of preexisting libraries, or to examine various hypothetical mutation schemes to determine the optimal method for creating a library that serves the screen/selection of interest. Simulated libraries of at least 10⁹ sequences are accessible by the numerical algorithm with currently available personal computers; an analytical algorithm is also available which can rapidly calculate a subset of the numerical statistics in libraries of arbitrarily large size. A multi-type double-strand stochastic model of ep-PCR is developed in an appendix to demonstrate the applicability of the algorithm to amplifying mutagenesis procedures. Estimators of DNA polymerase mutation-type-specific error rates are derived using the model. Analyses of an alpha-synuclein ep-PCR library and NNS synthetic oligonucleotide libraries are given as examples.     

Scanning mutagenesis using T4 DNA ligase and short degenerate DNA oligonucleotides containing tri-nucleotide mismatches

Scanning mutagenesis is an attractive tool for protein structure-function correlation analysis. With one round of this method it is possible to obtain a library containing all possible single-residue mutants of the protein of interest. The practical application of this approach is currently limited by the large number and cost of the required 30-35mer oligonucleotides. As an alternative, we studied the ligation of shorter DNA oligonucleotides (6-11mer) containing a degenerate binding site and a desired mutation mismatch to a nested set of megaprimers annealed to the gene of interest. T4 DNA ligase was able to perform this task, and the obtained ligation products were elongated by DNA polymerase. The effectiveness of ligation depends on the length of the random binding site of the mutagenic oligonucleotide, on its molar excess over the template-primer complex and on the position of the mismatching tri-nucleotide insert with respect to the joining site. The secondary structure of the DNA template close to the joining site also influences the ligation yield. Mismatching oligonucleotides, protected by a 3'-phosphate group, were joined to a nested set of megaprimers, the latter being obtained by a novel procedure called reversible chain termination, i.e., termination of the dsDNA synthesis with ddNTP followed by the subsequent removal of the incorporated ddNMP with exonuclease III. T7 sequenase 2.0 DNA polymerase elongated the ligation products after the 3'-phosphate protection group was removed with T4 polynucleotide kinase, resulting in the incorporation of a specific tri-nucleotide mismatch into dsDNA. This sequence of reactions serves as the basis for a novel scanning mutagenesis procedure.     

Circular polymerase extension cloning for high-throughput cloning of complex and combinatorial DNA libraries

High-throughput genomics, proteomics and synthetic biology studies require ever more efficient and economical strategies to clone complex DNA libraries or variants of biological modules. In this paper, we provide a protocol for a sequence-independent approach for cloning complex individual or combinatorial DNA libraries, and routine or high-throughput cloning of single or multiple DNA fragments. The strategy, called circular polymerase extension cloning (CPEC), is based on polymerase overlap extension and is therefore free of restriction digestion, ligation or single-stranded homologous recombination. CPEC is highly efficient, accurate and user friendly. Once the inserts and the linear vector have been prepared, the CPEC reaction can be completed in 10 min to 3 h, depending on the complexity of the gene libraries.     

A rapid method for site-specific mutagenesis and directional subcloning by using the polymerase chain reaction to generate recombinant circles

Site-specific mutagenesis and directional subcloning were accomplished by using the polymerase chain reaction to generate products that can recombine to form circular DNA. This DNA was transfected into E. coli without phosphorylation of primers, restriction enzyme digestion or ligation. Specifically, the polymerase chain reaction was used to generate products that when combined, denatured and reannealed, form double-stranded DNA with discrete, cohesive single-stranded ends. The generation of these cohesive ends of DNA permits the formation of precise, directional DNA joints without dependence on enzyme restriction sites. The primers were designed such that these cohesive single-stranded ends annealed to form circular DNA. The recombinant of interest was generated following only 14 amplification cycles. These recombinant circles of DNA were directly transfected into E. coli. In the mutagenesis protocol, the desired mutant was obtained at 83%-100% efficiency. Unwanted mutations were not detected, indicating a less than 0.025% nucleotide misincorporation frequency. In the directional subcloning protocol, inserts were positioned precisely in the recipient plasmid and were in the correct orientation. One unwanted mutation was detected after sequencing 900 bases, indicating a 0.11% nucleotide misincorporation frequency. Each manipulation, from setting up for the DNA amplification to transfection into E. coli. can easily be accomplished in one day.     

Polishing the craft of genetic diversity creation in directed evolution

Genetic diversity creation is a core technology in directed evolution where a high quality mutant library is crucial to its success. Owing to its importance, the technology in genetic diversity creation has seen rapid development over the years and its application has diversified into other fields of scientific research. The advances in molecular cloning and mutagenesis since 2008 were reviewed. Specifically, new cloning techniques were classified based on their principles of complementary overhangs, homologous sequences, overlapping PCR and megaprimers and the advantages, drawbacks and performances of these methods were highlighted. New mutagenesis methods developed for random mutagenesis, focused mutagenesis and DNA recombination were surveyed. The technical requirements of these methods and the mutational spectra were compared and discussed with references to commonly used techniques. The trends of mutant library preparation were summarised. Challenges in genetic diversity creation were discussed with emphases on creating “smart” libraries, controlling the mutagenesis spectrum and specific challenges in each group of mutagenesis methods. An outline of the wider applications of genetic diversity creation includes genome engineering, viral evolution, metagenomics and a study of protein functions. The review ends with an outlook for genetic diversity creation and the prospective developments that can have future impact in this field.     

Improving the Efficiency of Transposon Mutagenesis in Salmonella Enteritidis by Overcoming Host-Restriction Barriers

Transposon mutagenesis using transposome complex is a powerful method for functional genomics analysis in diverse bacteria by creating a large number of random mutants to prepare a genome-saturating mutant library. However, strong host restriction barriers can lead to limitations with species- or strain-specific restriction-modification systems. The purpose of this study was to enhance the transposon mutagenesis efficiency of Salmonella Enteritidis to generate a larger number of random insertion mutants. Host-adapted Tn5 DNA was used to form a transposome complex, and this simple approach significantly and consistently improved the efficiency of transposon mutagenesis, resulting in a 46-fold increase in the efficiency as compared to non-adapted transposon DNA fragments. Random nature of Tn5 insertions was confirmed by high-throughput sequencing of the Tn5-junction sequences. The result based on S. Enteritidis in this study should find broad applications in preparing a comprehensive mutant library of other species using transposome complex.     

One-step random mutagenesis by error-prone rolling circle amplification

In vitro random mutagenesis is a powerful tool for altering properties of enzymes. We describe here a novel random mutagenesis method using rolling circle amplification, named error-prone RCA. This method consists of only one DNA amplification step followed by transformation of the host strain, without treatment with any restriction enzymes or DNA ligases, and results in a randomly mutated plasmid library with 3–4 mutations per kilobase. Specific primers or special equipment, such as a thermal-cycler, are not required. This method permits rapid preparation of randomly mutated plasmid libraries, enabling random mutagenesis to become a more commonly used technique.     

Random mutagenesis of CSF-1 receptor (FMS) reveals multiple sites for activating mutations within the extracellular domain.

Retroviral vectors containing human FMS protooncogene cDNA were reconfigured to allow single-step excision and reinsertion of restriction fragments encoding short segments of the extracellular domain of the colony-stimulating factor 1 receptor (CSF-1R). Fragments ligated into M13 bacteriophages were subjected to random chemical mutagenesis on both strands and recloned into the parental vector to create libraries of FMS genes containing mutations restricted to predefined target cassettes. Transfection of retroviral vector libraries into NIH/3T3 cells gave rise to transformed foci from which cellular DNA was amplified by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), using primers flanking the mutagenized target sequences. Amplified fragments from individual primary transformants were recloned into intact FMS vector plasmids, and those with transforming activity were subjected to nucleotide sequence analysis. Alternatively, retroviruses rescued from transformed cells by superinfection with helper virus were used to generate secondary transformants containing unique copies of proviral DNA, whose sequences were determined after PCR amplification. Novel activating mutations were identified within sequences separating the third and fourth immunoglobulin-like loops, as well as within non-covalently stabilized loop 4 of the CSF-1R extracellular domain. Thus, FMS mutations able to convert human CSF-1R to an active oncoprotein are not restricted to those previously identified at codon 301. This approach should be generally applicable for defining activating mutations in related growth factor receptors, including those for platelet-derived growth factor and Steel factor (KIT ligand), in which ligand-independent oncoprotein variants have not been identified.     

Primer extension mutagenesis powered by selective rolling circle amplification

Primer extension mutagenesis is a popular tool to create libraries for in vitro evolution experiments. Here we describe a further improvement of the method described by T.A. Kunkel using uracil-containing single-stranded DNA as the template for the primer extension by additional uracil-DNA glycosylase treatment and rolling circle amplification (RCA) steps. It is shown that removal of uracil bases from the template leads to selective amplification of the nascently synthesized circular DNA strand carrying the desired mutations by phi29 DNA polymerase. Selective RCA (sRCA) of the DNA heteroduplex formed in Kunkel's mutagenesis increases the mutagenesis efficiency from 50% close to 100% and the number of transformants 300-fold without notable diversity bias. We also observed that both the mutated and the wild-type DNA were present in at least one third of the cells transformed directly with Kunkel's heteroduplex. In contrast, the cells transformed with sRCA product contained only mutated DNA. In sRCA, the complex cell-based selection for the mutant strand is replaced with the more controllable enzyme-based selection and less DNA is needed for library creation. Construction of a gene library of ten billion members is demonstrated with the described method with 240 nanograms of DNA as starting material.     

Thermostable DNA Ligase-Mediated PCR Production of Circular Plasmid (PPCP) and Its Application in Directed Evolution via In situ Error-Prone PCR

Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is a powerful method to produce linear DNA fragments. Here we describe the Tma thermostable DNA ligase-mediated PCR production of circular plasmid (PPCP) and its application in directed evolution via in situ error-prone PCR. In this thermostable DNA ligase-mediated whole-plasmid amplification method, the resultant DNA nick between the 5′ end of the PCR primer and the extended newly synthesized DNA 3′ end of each PCR cycle is ligated by Tma DNA ligase, resulting in circular plasmid DNA product that can be directly transformed. The template plasmid DNA is eliminated by ‘selection marker swapping’ upon transformation. When performed under an error-prone condition with Taq DNA polymerase, PPCP allows one-step construction of mutagenesis libraries based on in situ error-prone PCR so that random mutations are introduced into the target gene without altering the expression vector plasmid. A significant difference between PPCP and previously published methods is that PPCP allows exponential amplification of circular DNA. We used this method to create random mutagenesis libraries of a xylanase gene and two cellulase genes. Screening of these libraries resulted in mutant proteins with desired properties, demonstrating the usefulness of in situ error-prone PPCP for creating random mutagenesis libraries for directed evolution.     

Half-site editing: an in vitro mutagenesis procedure for truncating a DNA fragment and introducing a new restriction site

Half-site editing is an in vitro mutagenesis procedure designed for use in making precise plasmid constructions. Like many in vitro mutagenesis techniques, this procedure involves hybridization of a mutagenic oligonucleotide primer to single-stranded template DNA followed by polymerization with DNA polymerase I (Klenow). Half-site editing differs from other techniques in two main ways. First, T4 DNA polymerase treatment truncates the target DNA at a point determined by the primer and repairs any mismatches to the sequence specified by the primer. Second, a blunt-end ligation step is included. This ligation exploits the symmetry inherent in most restriction sites to create a desired restriction site at the truncated end of the target DNA fragment. Half-site editing has been used to place ClaI restriction sites at the 3' end of the yeast pyruvate kinase promoter and at two positions at the 5' end of the yeast acetolactate synthase coding sequence.     

Site-directed mutagenesis by overlap extension using the polymerase chain reaction

Overlap extension represents a new approach to genetic engineering. Complementary oligodeoxyribonucleotide (oligo) primers and the polymerase chain reaction are used to generate two DNA fragments having overlapping ends. These fragments are combined in a subsequent 'fusion' reaction in which the overlapping ends anneal, allowing the 3' overlap of each strand to serve as a primer for the 3' extension of the complementary strand. The resulting fusion product is amplified further by PCR. Specific alterations in the nucleotide (nt) sequence can be introduced by incorporating nucleotide changes into the overlapping oligo primers. Using this technique of site-directed mutagenesis, three variants of a mouse major histocompatibility complex class-I gene have been generated, cloned and analyzed. Screening of mutant clones revealed at least a 98% efficiency of mutagenesis. All clones sequenced contained the desired mutations, and a low frequency of random substitution estimated to occur at approx. 1 in 4000 nt was detected. This method represents a significant improvement over standard methods of site-directed mutagenesis because it is much faster, simpler and approaches 100% efficiency in the generation of mutant product.     

Creating random mutagenesis libraries using megaprimer PCR of whole plasmid

The conventional method for cloning a DNA fragment is to insert it into a vector and ligate it. Although this method is commonly used, it is labor intensive because the ratio and concentrations of the DNA insert and the vector need optimizing. Even then, the resultant library is often plagued with unwanted plasmids that have no inserts or multiple inserts. These species have to be eradicated to avoid tedious screening, especially when producing a mutant gene library. To overcome these problems, we modified the QuikChange protocol so that each plasmid carries a single insert. Although the QuikChange was originally developed for site-directed mutagenesis using complementary mutagenic oligonucleotide primers in whole plasmid PCR, we found that the protocol also worked for megaprimers consisting of hundreds of nucleotides. Based on this discovery, we used insert fragments, which we wanted to clone, as the primers in the QuikChange reaction. The resultant libraries were virtually free from species with no inserts or multiple inserts. The present method, which we designated MEGAWHOP (megaprimer PCR of whole plasmid), is thus ideal for creating random mutagenesis megalibraries.     

Construction of DNA-shuffled and incrementally truncated libraries by a mutagenic and unidirectional reassembly method: changing from a substrate specificity of phospholipase to that of lipase

A method of mutagenic and unidirectional reassembly (MURA) that can generate libraries of DNA-shuffled and randomly truncated proteins was developed. The method involved fragmenting the template gene(s) randomly by DNase I and reassembling the small fragments with a unidirectional primer by PCR. The MURA products were treated with T4 DNA polymerase and subsequently with a restriction enzyme whose site was located on the region of the MURA primer. The N-terminal-truncated and DNA-shuffled library of a Serratia sp. phospholipase A(1) prepared by this method had an essentially random variation of truncated size and also showed point mutations associated with DNA shuffling. After high-throughput screening on triglyceride-emulsified plates, several mutants exhibiting absolute lipase activity (NPL variants) were obtained. The sequence analysis and the lipase activity assay on the NPL variants revealed that N-terminal truncations at a region beginning with amino acids 61 to 71, together with amino acid substitutions, resulted in the change of substrate specificity from a phospholipase to a lipase. We therefore suggest that the MURA method, which combines incremental truncation with DNA shuffling, can contribute to expanding the searchable sequence space in directed evolution experiments.     

Alternative approach to generate shRNA from cDNA

Short hairpin RNA (shRNA) synthesized from vector-based expression is as effective as short interfering RNA (siRNA) synthesized in vitro for suppressing the expression of their corresponding genes. Recently, three groups independently reported a new technology to construct an shRNA library from cDNA, providing great hope for genome-wide functional screens in many biological systems. In the present study, we report an alternative approach to generate shRNA from cDNA. A major improvement was to use a nicking enzyme to open up the double-stranded DNA so that the loop region remains single-stranded while the rest of the DNA fragment is double-stranded at an elevated temperature (e.g., 72 degrees C). The single-stranded DNA was then converted into double-stranded DNA by Taq DNA polymerase using the existing strand in the double-stranded region as a primer. Thus, the extended product carried a palindromic structure of 19 bp separated by a loop. Finally, the DNA fragment was cloned into a vector that carries an H1 promoter at the upstream region and ends with 5Ts, a terminator for the Pol III polymerase, at the downstream region. To prove the principle, we constructed shRNA from green fluorescent protein (GFP) cDNA and successfully suppressed GFP expression. Consequently, this simplified approach provides a better alternative to generate shRNA libraries from cDNA. Such shRNA libraries can be used to identify potential siRNA target sequences and study gene functions by a variety of selection methods.     

Gene splicing and mutagenesis by PCR-driven overlap extension

Extension of overlapping gene segments by PCR is a simple, versatile technique for site-directed mutagenesis and gene splicing. Initial PCRs generate overlapping gene segments that are then used as template DNA for another PCR to create a full-length product. Internal primers generate overlapping, complementary 3' ends on the intermediate segments and introduce nucleotide substitutions, insertions or deletions for site-directed mutagenesis, or for gene splicing, encode the nucleotides found at the junction of adjoining gene segments. Overlapping strands of these intermediate products hybridize at this 3' region in a subsequent PCR and are extended to generate the full-length product amplified by flanking primers that can include restriction enzyme sites for inserting the product into an expression vector for cloning purposes. The highly efficient generation of mutant or chimeric genes by this method can easily be accomplished with standard laboratory reagents in approximately 1 week.     

Steering directed protein evolution: strategies to manage combinatorial complexity of mutant libraries

How to explore protein sequence space efficiently and how to generate high-quality mutant libraries that allow to identify improved variants with current screening technologies are key questions for any directed protein evolution experiment. High-quality mutant libraries can be generated through improved random mutagenesis methodologies and by restricting diversity generation through computational methods to residues which have high success probabilities. Advances in mutant library design and computational tools to focus diversity generation are summarized in this minireview and discussed from an experimentalist point of view in the context of directed protein evolution.     

A method for generation of arbitrary peptide libraries using genomic DNA

Random peptide libraries can be constructed either by in vitro synthesis of random peptides, or through translation of DNA sequences from synthetic random oligonucleotides. Here we describe an alternative way of making arbitrary peptide libraries with high diversity that can be used in screening as random peptide libraries. Genomic DNA digested with a frequent-cutting restriction enzyme recognizing four nucleotides will theoretically consist of small DNA pieces with average length of 256 nucleotides, and on average around 10⁷ fragments can be generated from a genome of 3 × 10⁹ bases. A peptide library translated from these fragments will have sufficient diversity for some protein interaction screening experiments. Moreover, the same genome digested with a different four-cutter enzyme or ligated into different reading frames will result in different nonoverlapping libraries. A series of such libraries could be generated with genomic DNAs from different species. In this study, human genomic DNA was digested with four-cutter restriction enzymes DpnII and Tsp509I, respectively, and cloned into yeast expression vector pGADT7 to generate arbitrary peptide libraries. These libraries were used in yeast two-hybrid assays to screen for binding motifs of the PDZ domain containing protein synectin. Our results showed that in addition to various native carboxy-terminal tails, synectin could also bind to many artificial ones, some of which contained a consensus sequence—(S/T)XC-COOH.