Mutations in a signal sequence for the thylakoid membrane identify multiple protein transport pathways and nuclear suppressors

The apparatus that permits protein translocation across the internal thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts is completely unknown, even though these membranes have been the subject of extensive biochemical analysis. We have used a genetic approach to characterize the translocation of Chlamydomonas cytochrome f, a chloroplast-encoded protein that spans the thylakoid once. Mutations in the hydrophobic core of the cytochrome f signal sequence inhibit the accumulation of cytochrome f, lead to an accumulation of precursor, and impair the ability of Chlamydomonas cells to grow photosynthetically. One hydrophobic core mutant also reduces the accumulation of other thylakoid membrane proteins, but not those that translocate completely across the membrane. These results suggest that the signal sequence of cytochrome f is required and is involved in one of multiple insertion pathways. Suppressors of two signal peptide mutations describe at least two nuclear genes whose products likely describe the translocation apparatus, and selected second-site chloroplast suppressors further define regions of the cytochrome f signal peptide.     

Two nuclear mutations disrupt distinct pathways for targeting proteins to the chloroplast thylakoid.

Results of in vitro experiments have suggested the existence of at least three pathways by which nuclear-encoded proteins are targeted to the chloroplast thylakoid membrane. However, few components of the targeting machinery have been identified and the relationship between the three pathways is not clear. To investigate mechanisms underlying thylakoid protein targeting, we identified nuclear mutations in maize that cause targeting defects. We found two mutations, tha1 and hcf106, that disrupt the localization of different sets of proteins to the thylakoid lumen. The tha1 mutation interferes with the targeting of one chloroplast-encoded protein, cytochrome f, and three nuclear-encoded proteins, plastocyanin, the psaF gene product and the 33 kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex. The hcf106 mutation interferes with the targeting of the 16 and 23 kDa subunits of the oxygen-evolving complex. The tha1 and hcf106 phenotypes provide the first in vivo evidence supporting the existence of two distinct thylakoid-targeting pathways. Their phenotypes also provide evidence that one chloroplast-encoded protein, cytochrome f, engages the 'tha1' pathway, indicating that nuclear- and chloroplast-encoded proteins can be targeted via common machinery.     

The presequence of a chimeric construct dictates which of two mechanisms are utilized for translocation across the thylakoid membrane: evidence for the existence of two distinct translocation systems.

The translocation of plastocyanin across the thylakoid membrane in Pisum sativum has been studied in reconstitution assays and using chimeric constructs. The reconstitution assays demonstrate that plastocyanin translocation is absolutely dependent on the presence of a stromal factor(s) and nucleotide triphosphates (NTPs), whereas neither element is required for the translocation of the 23 or 16 kDa proteins of the oxygen-evolving complex. Previous studies had revealed that the transthylakoidal delta pH is essential for translocation of the 23 and 16 kDa proteins but unnecessary for plastocyanin translocation. The basis for these mechanistic differences has been tested by analysing the translocation of a chimeric construct consisting of the presequence of the 23 kDa protein linked to the mature plastocyanin sequence. This construct is efficiently imported into thylakoids in the absence of stromal extracts or NTPs and translocation across the thylakoid membrane within intact chloroplasts is totally inhibited by the uncoupler nigericin: the translocation requirements are thus identical to those of the pre-23 kDa protein and diametrically opposite to those of pre-plastocyanin. Transport across the thylakoid membrane of a second fusion protein, consisting of the presequence of the 16 kDa protein linked to mature plastocyanin, is also dependent on a delta pH. The data suggest that two distinct systems are involved in the translocation of proteins across the thylakoid membrane, with each system recognizing specific signals within the presequences of a subset of lumenal protein precursors.     

One signal is enough: Stepwise transport of two distinct passenger proteins by the Tat pathway across the thylakoid membrane

The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway, one of four protein transport pathways operating at the thylakoid membrane of chloroplasts, shows remarkable substrate flexibility. Here, we have analyzed the thylakoid transport of chimeric tandem substrates that are composed of two different passenger proteins fused to a single Tat transport signal. The chimera 23/23-EGFP in which the reporter protein EGFP is connected to the C-terminus of the OEC23 precursor shows that a single Tat transport signal is sufficient to mediate transport of two distinct passenger proteins in a row. Replacing the transit peptide of OEC23 in 23/23-EGFP by its homolog from OEC16 yields the chimera 16/23-EGFP, which can likewise be fully translocated by the Tat pathway across the thylakoid membrane. However, transport of 16/23-EGFP is retarded at specific steps in the transport process leading to the temporary and consecutive accumulation of three translocation intermediates with distinct membrane topology. They are associated with two oligomeric membrane complexes presumably representing TatBC-receptor complexes. The composition of the translocation intermediates as determined by immunoprecipitation experiments suggests that the two passenger proteins are translocated in a stepwise manner across the membrane.     

Electron transfers amongst cytochrome f, plastocyanin and photosystem I: kinetics and mechanisms

The review covers the theory and practice of the determination of kinetic constants for the electron transfer reactions in chloroplast thylakoid membranes between plastocyanin and cytochrome f in cytochrome bf complexes, and between plastocyanin and the reaction centre of photosystem I. Effects of ionic strength and pH are featured. The contribution of mutant studies is included. It is concluded that nearly all data from in vitro experiments can be interpreted with a reaction scheme in which an encounter complex between donor and acceptor is formed by long-range electrostatic attraction, followed by rearrangement during which metal centres become close enough for rapid intra-complex electron transfer. In vivo experiments so far cast doubt on this particular sequence, but their interpretation is not straightforward. Means of modelling the bimolecular complex between cytochrome f and plastocyanin are outlined, and two likely structures are illustrated. The complex formed by plastocyanin and photosystem I in higher plants involves the PsaF subunit, but its structure has not been fully determined.     

Amino-terminal and hydrophobic regions of the Chlamydomonas reinhardtii plastocyanin transit peptide are required for efficient protein accumulation in vivo

Nucleus-encoded chloroplast proteins of vascular plants are synthesized as precursors and targeted to the chloroplast by stroma-targeting domains in N-terminal transit peptides. Transit peptides in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii are considerably shorter than those in vascular plants, and their stroma-targeting domains have similarities to both mitochondrial and chloroplast targeting sequences. To examine Chlamydomonas transit peptide function in vivo, deletions were introduced into the transit peptide coding region of the petE gene, which encodes the thylakoid lumen protein plastocyanin (PC). The mutant petE genes were introduced into a plastocyanin-deficient Chlamydomonas strain, and transformants that accumulated petE mRNA were analyzed for PC accumulation. The most profound defects were observed with deletions at the N-terminus and those that extended into the hydrophobic region in the C-terminal half of the transit peptide. PC precursors were detected among pulse-labeled proteins in transformants with N-terminal deletions, suggesting that these precursors cannot be imported and are degraded in the cytosol. Intermediate PC species were observed in a transformant deleted for part of the hydrophobic region, suggesting that this protein is defective in lumen translocation and/or processing. Thus, despite its shorter length, the bipartite nature of the Chlamydomonas PC transit peptide appears similar to that of lumen-targeted proteins in vascular plants. Analysis of the synthesis, stability, and accumulation of PC species in transformants bearing deletions in the stroma-targeting domain suggests that specific regions probably have distinct roles in vivo. Abbreviations: cyt, cytochrome; ECL, enhanced chemiluminescence; LSU, large subunit; PC, plastocyanin; TP, transit peptide     

Full-length plastocyanin precursor is translocated across isolated thylakoid membranes

In higher plants, the chloroplastic protein plastocyanin is synthesized as a transit peptide-containing precursor by cytosolic ribosomes and posttranslationally transported to the thylakoid lumen. En route to the lumen, a plastocyanin precursor is first imported into chloroplasts and then further directed across the thylakoid membrane by a second distinct transport event. A partially processed form of plastocyanin is observed in the stroma during import experiments using intact chloroplasts and has been proposed to be the translocation substrate for the second step (Smeekens, S., Bauerle, C., Hageman, J., Keegstra, K., and Weisbeek, P. (1986) Cell 46, 365-375). To further characterize this second step, we have reconstituted thylakoid transport in a system containing in vitro-synthesized precursor proteins and isolated thylakoid membranes. This system was specific for lumenal proteins since stromal proteins lacking the appropriate targeting information did not accumulate in the thylakoid lumen. Plastocyanin precursor was taken up by isolated thylakoids, proteolytically processed to mature size, and converted to holo form. Translocation was temperature-dependent and was stimulated by millimolar levels of ATP but did not strictly require the addition of stromal factors. We have examined the substrate requirements of thylakoid translocation by testing the ability of different processed forms of plastocyanin to transport in the in vitro system. Interestingly, only the full-length plastocyanin precursor, not the partially processed intermediate form, was competent for transport in this in vitro system.     

Assembly of cytochrome f into the cytochrome bf complex in isolated pea chloroplasts.

Structural features of cytochrome f necessary for assembly into the cytochrome bf complex were examined in isolated pea chloroplasts following import of (35)S-labelled chimeric precursor proteins, consisting of the presequence of the small subunit of Rubisco fused to the turnip cytochrome f precursor. Assembly was detected by nondenaturing gel electrophoresis of dodecyl maltoside-solubilized thylakoid membranes. A cytochrome f polypeptide unable to bind haem because of mutagenesis of Cys21 and Cys24 to alanine residues was assembled into the complex and had similar stability to the wild-type polypeptide. This indicates that covalent haem binding to cytochrome f is not necessary for assembly of the protein into the cytochrome bf complex. A truncated protein lacking the C-terminal 33 amino acid residues, including the transmembrane span and the stroma-exposed region, was translocated across the thylakoid membrane, had a similar stability to wild-type cytochrome f but was not assembled into the complex. This indicates that the C-terminal region of cytochrome f is important for assembly into the complex. A mutant cytochrome f unable to bind haem and lacking the C-terminal region was also translocated across the thylakoid membrane but was extremely labile, indicating that, in the absence of the C-terminal membrane anchor, haem-less cytochrome f is recognized by a thylakoid proteolytic system.     

Protein Import into and Sorting inside the Chloroplast Are Independent Processes

Plastocyanin is a nuclear-encoded chloroplast thylakoid lumen protein that is synthesized in the cytoplasm with a large N-terminal extension (66 amino acids). Transport of plastocyanin involves two steps: import across the chloroplast envelope into the stroma, followed by transfer across the thylakoid membrane into the lumen. During transport the N-terminal extension is removed in two parts by two different processing proteases. In this study we examined the functions of the two cleaved parts, C1 and C2, in the transport pathway of plastocyanin. The results show that C1 mediates import into the chloroplast. C1 is sufficient to direct chloroplast import of mutant proteins that lack C2. It is also sufficient to direct import of a nonplastid protein and can be replaced functionally by the transit peptide of an imported stromal protein. C2 is a prerequisite for intraorganellar routing but is not required for chloroplast import. Deletions in C2 result in accumulation of intermediates in the stroma or on the outside of the thylakoids. The fact that C1 is functionally equivalent to a stromal-targeting transit peptide shows that plastocyanin is imported into the chloroplast by way of the same mechanism as stromal proteins, and that import into and routing inside the chloroplasts are independent processes.     

Protein targeting towards the thylakoid lumen of chloroplasts: proper localization of fusion proteins is only observed in vivo.

Routeing of fusion proteins to the thylakoid lumen of the chloroplast was compared in vitro and in vivo. The Escherichia coli protein beta-lactamase was used as a passenger to study this intraorganellar sorting process. The first step, translocation of beta-lactamase into the chloroplast stroma, occurs properly both in vitro and in vivo and is dependent on the presence of a transit peptide in the protein construct. The second step, targeting towards the thylakoid lumen, is more complicated as was also observed previously when other passenger proteins were used. In vitro, the presence of a thylakoid transfer domain is not enough for routeing and proper processing. Only when the complete thylakoid lumen precursor plastocyanin was fused to beta-lactamase was the fusion protein processed adequately, but routeing was still incomplete. However, in vivo, the information present in the thylakoid transfer domain was the only requirement for proper transport towards the thylakoid lumen. These data show that in vivo, the only requirement for targeting of passenger proteins towards the thylakoid lumen is the presence of a transit peptide and a thylakoid transfer domain. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the in vitro import system does not necessarily reflect the in vivo situation with respect to intraorganellar sorting.     

Protein-specific energy requirements for protein transport across or into thylakoid membranes. Two lumenal proteins are transported in the absence of ATP.

Cytosolically synthesized thylakoid proteins must be translocated across the chloroplast envelope membranes, traverse the stroma, and then be translocated into or across the thylakoid membrane. Protein transport across the envelope requires ATP hydrolysis but not electrical or proton gradients. The energy requirements for the thylakoid translocation step were studied here for the light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b protein (LHCP), an integral membrane protein, and for several thylakoid lumen-resident proteins: plastocyanin and OE33, OE23, and OE17 (the 33-, 23-, and 17-kDa subunits of the oxygen-evolving complex, respectively). Dissipation of the thylakoid protonmotive force during an in organello protein import assay partially inhibited the thylakoid localization of LHCP and OE33, totally inhibited localization of OE23 and OE17, and had no effect on localization of plastocyanin. We used reconstitution assays for LHCP insertion and for OE23 and OE17 transport into isolated thylakoids to investigate the energy requirements in detail. The results indicated that LHCP insertion absolutely requires ATP hydrolysis and is enhanced by a transthylakoid delta pH and that transport of OE23 and OE17 is absolutely dependent upon a delta pH. Surprisingly, OE23 and OE17 transport occurred maximally in the complete absence of ATP. These results establish the thylakoid membrane as the only membrane system in which a delta pH can provide all of the energy required to translocate proteins across the bilayer. They also demonstrate that the energy requirements for integration into or translocation across the thylakoid membranes are protein-specific.     

HCF153, a novel nuclear-encoded factor necessary during a post-translational step in biogenesis of the cytochrome bf complex

We have isolated the nuclear photosynthetic mutant hcf153 which shows reduced accumulation of the cytochrome b(6)f complex. The levels and processing patterns of the RNAs encoding the cytochrome b(6)f subunits are unaltered in the mutant. In vivo protein labeling experiments and analysis of polysome association revealed normal synthesis of the large chloroplast-encoded cytochrome b(6)f subunits. The mutation resulted from a T-DNA insertion and the affected nuclear gene was cloned. HCF153 encodes a 15 kDa protein containing a chloroplast transit peptide. Sequence similarity searches revealed that the protein is restricted to higher plants. A HCF153-Protein A fusion construct introduced into hcf153 mutant plants was able to substitute the function of the wild-type protein. Fractionation of intact chloroplasts from these transgenic plants suggests that most or all of the fusion protein is tightly associated with the thylakoid membrane. Our data show that the identified factor is a novel protein that could be involved in a post-translational step during biogenesis of the cytochrome b(6)f complex. It is also possible that HCF153 is necessary for translation of one of the very small subunits of the cytochrome b(6)f complex.     

Structure of the complex between plastocyanin and cytochrome f from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 as determined by paramagnetic NMR. The balance between electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions within the transient complex determines the relative orientation of the two proteins

The complex between cytochrome f and plastocyanin from the cyanobacterium Nostoc has been characterized by NMR spectroscopy. The binding constant is 16 mM(-1), and the lifetime of the complex is much less than 10 ms. Intermolecular pseudo-contact shifts observed for the plastocyanin amide nuclei, caused by the heme iron, as well as the chemical-shift perturbation data were used as the sole experimental restraints to determine the orientation of plastocyanin relative to cytochrome f with a precision of 1.3 angstroms. The data show that the hydrophobic patch surrounding tyrosine 1 in cytochrome f docks the hydrophobic patch of plastocyanin. Charge complementarities are found between the rims of the respective recognition sites of cytochrome f and plastocyanin. Significant differences in the relative orientation of both proteins are found between this complex and those previously reported for plants and Phormidium, indicating that electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions are balanced differently in these complexes.     

HCF164 Encodes a Thioredoxin-Like Protein Involved in the Biogenesis of the Cytochrome b6f Complex in Arabidopsis

To understand the biogenesis of the plastid cytochrome b(6)f complex and to identify the underlying auxiliary factors, we have characterized the nuclear mutant hcf164 of Arabidopsis and isolated the affected gene. The mutant shows a high chlorophyll fluorescence phenotype and is severely deficient in the accumulation of the cytochrome b(6)f complex subunits. In vivo protein labeling experiments indicated that the mutation acts post-translationally by interfering with the assembly of the complex. Because of its T-DNA tag, the corresponding gene was cloned and its identity confirmed by complementation of homozygous mutant plants. HCF164 encodes a thioredoxin-like protein that possesses disulfide reductase activity. The protein was found in the chloroplast, where it is anchored to the thylakoid membrane at its lumenal side. HCF164 is closely related to the thioredoxin-like protein TxlA of Synechocystis sp PCC6803, most probably reflecting its evolutionary origin. The protein also shows a limited similarity to the eubacterial CcsX and CcmG proteins, which are required for the maturation of periplasmic c-type cytochromes. The putative roles of HCF164 for the assembly of the cytochrome b(6)f complex are discussed.     

Plastocyanin is indispensable for photosynthetic electron flow in Arabidopsis thaliana

Plastocyanin is a soluble copper-containing protein present in the thylakoid lumen, which transfers electrons to photosystem I. In the chloroplast of the flowering plant Arabidopsis thaliana, a cytochrome c6-like protein is present, which was recently suggested to function as an alternative electron carrier to plastocyanin. We show that Arabidopsis plants mutated in both of the two plastocyanin-coding genes and with a functional cytochrome c6 cannot grow photoautotrophically because of a complete block in light-driven electron transport. Even increased dosage of the gene encoding the cytochrome c6-like protein cannot complement the double mutant phenotype. This demonstrates that in Arabidopsis only plastocyanin can donate electrons to photosystem I in vivo.     

Cytochrome f: Structure,function and biosynthesis

Cytochrome f is an intrinsic membrane component of the cytochrome bf complex, transferring electrons from the Rieske FeS protein to plastocyanin in the thylakoid lumen. The protein is held in the thylakoid membrane by a single transmembrane span located near its C-terminus with a globular hydrophilic domain extending into the lumen. The globular domain of the turnip protein has recently been crystallised, offering the prospect of a detailed three-dimensional structure. Reaction with plastocyanin involves localised positive charges on cytochrome f interacting with the acidic patch on plastocyanin and electron transfer via the surface-exposed tyrosine residue (Tyr83) of plastocyanin. Apocytochrome f is encoded in the chloroplast genome and is synthesised with an N-terminal presequence which targets the protein to the thylakoid membrane. The synthesis of cytochrome f is coordinated with the synthesis of the other subunits of the cytochrome bf complex.     

Tip loci: six Chlamydomonas nuclear suppressors that permit the translocation of proteins with mutant thylakoid signal sequences.

Mutations within the signal sequence of cytochrome f (cytf) in Chlamydomonas inhibit thylakoid membrane protein translocation and render cells nonphotosynthetic. Twenty-seven suppressors of the mutant signal sequences were selected for their ability to restore photoautotrophic growth and these describe six nuclear loci named tip1 through 6 for thylakoid insertion protein. The tip mutations restore the translocation of cytf and are not allele specific, as they suppress a number of different cytf signal sequence mutations. Tip5 and 2 may act early in cytf translocation, while Tip1, 3, 4, and 6 are engaged later. The tip mutations have no phenotype in the absence of a signal sequence mutation and there is genetic interaction between tip4, and tip5 suggesting an interaction of their encoded proteins. As there is overlap in the energetic, biochemical and genetic requirements for the translocation of nuclear and chloroplast-encoded thylakoid proteins, the tip mutations likely identify components of a general thylakoid protein translocation apparatus.     

Cytochrome f and plastocyanin kinetics in Chlorella pyrenoidosa. II. Reduction kinetics and electric field increase in the 10 ms range

On dark-adapted Chlorella, after one flash, plastocyanin (PC) undergoes reduction with a half-time of 7 ms. After 4 or 5 flashes, the reduction of PC+ in the 10 ms range is suppressed, and the level of oxidized plastocyanin increases during the next few flashes before reaching a stationary value. Cytochrome f exhibits approximately the same pattern. The reduction of PC+ and cytochrome f+ in the 10 ms range is correlated with an increase of the electrice field named phase b (Joliot, P. and Delosme, R., Biochim. Biophys. Acta 357 (1974) 267-284). Both need the presence of a compound R' in the reduced state. A dark electron transfer involving a carrier of electrons across the membrane, a proton carrier, R' as terminal reducant, PC+ and cytochrome f+ as terminal oxidants, would account for this field generation. Cooperation between the electron transfer chains is implied at the level of plastocyanin oxidation. An equilibrium constant of about 2 is observed between cytochrome f and plastocyanin before 1 ms and after 500 ms after the photochemical reactions. We observe that cytochrome f and plastocyanin are not connected from 1 to 100 ms after a photochemical reaction. The equilibrium constant between plastocyanin and P-700 remains large [20] under these conditions.