Determination of specific monoclonal antibody secretion rate during very slow hybridoma growth

A total cell recycling suspension perfusion reactor has been constructed for investigation of specific monoclonal antibody secretion rate of the 9.2.27 murine hybridoma under conditions of a very low growth rate. By rapidly recycling hybridoma cells using a thermostated tangential flow filter, 3.6 mg cell dry weight/cm³ could be maintained at growth rate of <0.05 _max for over 250 h. Under these conditions, secretion of lactate, ammonia and l-alanine were directly related to the rate of l-glutamine supply. Monoclonal antibody accumulated in the reactor to levels in excess of 1400 g/ cm³. Surprisingly, as specific growth rate decreased, the specific immunoglobulin secretion rate remained constant, implying that monoclonal antibody synthesis could be uncoupled from growth.List of Symbols CMF cm³/(min · cm²) cross membrane flow rate - D h^–1 dilution rate - DOT % air saturation dissolved oxygen tension - F _R cm³/min perfusion rate - GlcPR mg/min glucose provision rate - GlnPR mg/min l-glutamine provision rate - N _A mmoles O₂/(dm³ · h) oxygen transfer rate - q _ala mmoles/h l-alanine secretion rate - q _MAB mg MAB · 10^–8 viable cells ^–1 · day^–1 specific MAB secretion rate by viable cells - ¯q _MAB (dimensionless) ¯q _MAB/¯q _{MAB MAX} - ¯q _{NH 3} mmoles/h ammonia secretion rate - S _R mg/cm³ limiting substrate concentration - h^–1 specific growth rate - _app h^–1 apparent growth rate - ¯ (dimensionless) / _MAX - VC cells/cm³ viable cell number     

Media for hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production

For the economical production of monoclonal antibodies (MAbs), the cell-culture medium must be optimized for three different phases: growth of the hybridomas, MAb productivity of the hybridomas, and MAb purification or downstream processing. Medium improvements are necessary to meet these requirements for large-scale MAb production. Information bearing on this issue is being addressed in two research areas, cell biology and biochemical engineering, and is reviewed in this article.     

Relationship between hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production.

Factors affecting cell growth and antibody production in a mouse hybridoma were investigated. Antibody was produced during the growth and decline phases of a batch culture with an increase in the specific rate of antibody production during the decline phase. The specific rate of antibody production was also increased in cells arrested by 2 mM thymidine, suggesting that cell proliferation and antibody production can be uncoupled. Reduced serum concentrations resulted in lower cell growth rates but increased antibody production rates. However, this trend was reversed in hybridomas which had been arrested by thymidine, since the highest antibody production rate was associated with high serum concentrations. Likewise, in proliferating cells, the optimum pH for antibody production (pH 6.8) was lower than the optimum pH for cell growth (pH 7.2), whereas in thymidine-blocked cells, the highest antibody production rate was at pH 7.2. High antibody production rates and product yields were also associated with low growth rates in continuous cultures. The possibility that antibody was under cell cycle control was investigated in synchronized hybridoma cultures. Antibody production occurred during G1 and G2 with a decline in the M phase and evidence of a further decline in the S phase. Thus antibody production was not restricted to the G1 and S phase in this hybridoma.     

Electrical stimulation of hybridoma cells producing monoclonal antibody to cAMP

Electrical stimulation was applied to hybridoma cells in order to activate metabolic activities and increase the monoclonal antibody production. Hybridoma cells that produce monoclonal antibody to adenosine 3':5'-cyclic monophosphate were placed on a transparent glass electrode immersed in medium and subjected to electric pulses (pulse shape, alternating rectangular; field strength, 4 X 10(3) V X m-1; frequency, 5 kHz; pulse mode, 0.5 min application and 4.5 min pause). After 48 h of incubation, the concentration of lactic acid in the medium reached 8.4 mM, approx. 30% higher than that obtained without electric stimulation. Similarly, cell growth rate was promoted by the electric stimulation, reaching a maximum stimulation after 40 h. When the hybridoma was cultured for 48 h with electrical stimulation, the antibody concentration in the medium reached 22.3 microgram X ml-1, approx. 10% higher than the control, with a concomitant 16% increase in cell concentration. Longer periods of electric pulse application, however, caused an inhibitory effect on the hybridoma growth. The most probable cause of the inhibition are reactive oxygen species such as superoxide and hydrogen peroxide, which are inevitably generated by electrolysis. The presence of superoxide dismutase (EC 1.15.1.1) reduced the inhibitory effects. In conclusion, metabolic activities including monoclonal antibody production were activated by the electrical stimulation.     

Regulation of antibody secretion by hybridoma cells. I. Suppression of antibody secretion by coculture of hybridoma cells with idiotype-induced suppressor cells

In this study, we have demonstrated that antibody secretion by hybridoma cell lines can be down-regulated by idiotype-specific immune spleen cells or by nylon wool nonadherent spleen cells. This suppression of antibody secretion can be abolished by treating the idiotype-specific immune spleen cells with anti-Thy 1.2 plus complement. The hybridoma we used for most of our experiments secretes IgM specific for the cross-reacting haptens 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) and 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP). Suppression was achieved by direct coculture of hybridoma cells with immune cells from animals which were injected with affinity-purified hybridoma antibody-coupled syngeneic spleen cells. The suppressed and control cultures contained similar numbers of viable hybridoma cells, suggesting that a simple cytotoxic effect is not responsible. Idiotype specificity was established in experiments showing that two idiotype immune animals immunized with antibody from two different IgM anti-TNP hybridomas could suppress the hybridoma to which they were immunized but could not affect the other hybridoma. Immune spleen cells required 3-4 days of coculture with hybridoma cells before maximum suppression was achieved. The kinetics of the response suggest that the final effector suppressor cell is generated during the coculture period and that a second signal, perhaps a product of the hybridoma cells, may be required.     

A flow-cytometric analysis of hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production

A flow cytometric kinetic study of hybidoma growth and monoclonal antibody production is presented, along with the influence of glutamine on intracellular responses such as (relative) cell size, and cell RNA and total protein content. Specific findings are: (1) RNA content remained constant throughout the growth phase, then fell drastically as the cells entered the stationary phase. Also, in stationary phase, RNA content of antibody-producing cells was higher than for those not secreting antibody. (2) The cell size was constant and maximal throughout exponential phase, and diminished monotonically during later stages. (3) Average protein and antibody cellular content declined dramatically upon glutamine exhaustion. Thus, relative RNA levels and cell size provided quantitative determinants of both cell growth state and antibody secretion conditions. These results encourge consideration of structured kinetic studies which recognize the quality of the biophase.     

Effects of peptone on hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody formation

Hybridoma WuT3 secreting a monoclonal antibody against T lymphocytes was grown in RPMI 1640 medium supplemented with 1% human serum. The effect of the concentration of peptone, as an additive, was investigated on cell growth, monoclonal antibody formation, and cell metabolism over 0–10 g l^–1 range. It was found that 1–5 g l^–1 peptone can significantly promote the growth of cells and increase the formation of monoclonal antibody, especially at 3–5 g l^–1, when both the accumulating level and secretion rate of monoclonal antibody are higher than that at other peptone concentrations. Based on glucose, lactate and ammonia analysis data, the efficiency of glycolysis was assessed and the utilization of amino acids was more efficient at 3–5 g l^–1 peptone. The cell growth and monoclonal antibody formation were inhibited at higher peptone concentrations, e.g. 10 g l^–1.     

A model of interorganelle monoclonal antibody transport and secretion in mouse hybridoma cells

A three compartment model (ER --> Golgi --> extracellular medium) is used here to describe the interorganelle transport and final secretion of an IgG(2a) monoclonal antibody (MAb) in 9.2.27 murine hybridoma cells. Model simulations of pulse-chase and continuous labeling experiments are used to gain a better understanding of the kinetics of MAb interorganelle traffic. Simulation results for the continuous labeling case compare well with experimental data obtained during continuous labeling of 9.2.27 hybridoma cells. Incorporation of this compartmental transport model into our previously developed model of MAb synthesis and assembly can provide a useful tool for analyzing the dynamics and regulation of the complete antibody secretory pathway under different growth and/or nutritional conditions.     

Continuous hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production in hollow fiber reactors-separators

Growth of a hybridoma culture, along with production of monoclonal antibody, was demonstrated over extended periods in polysulfone hollow fiber membrane modules. The molecular weight cutoffs of the membranes were 70,000, 50,000, and 100,000 daltons. The hybridoma cell line, designated 65/26, produced IgG (2b/kappa) directed at mouse thymus cell surface antigen, TL.1. Cell growth occurred in the shell space of the reactor, using supplemented RPMI 1640 (20% fetal bovine serum) supplied from a separate reservoir vessel through the hollow fiber lumen. The reservoir contained 125 mL media, which was changed every 4 days. Concentrations of immunoglobulin were determined by an enzyme immunoassay (using protein A and alkaline phosphatase-labeled antibody conjugate). For the 10K, 50K, and 100K hollow fiber membrane modules, the maximum IgG concentrations detected in the 2.5-mL shell space were 47.5-80, 510, and 740 mug/mL, respectively. In the 125-mL reservoir for the 100K hollow fiber membrane module, the IgG concentration was measured at 260 mug/mL These values compare with an IgG concentration of 1 mug/mL when grown in a standard tissue culture flask and 3.2-7.6 mug/mL when grown in 100 ml media in a spinner flask. In addition, 10K and 50K hollow fiber membrane modules were run in a mode that decreased the fetal bovine serum supplement with time. Differences between these systems suggest that it is possible to obtain high IgG accumulation rates, both during and after the exponential growth phase of the hybridoma population.     

Monoclonal antibody metabolism during the growth of hybridoma cells

Metabolism of monoclonal antibodies (MAb) during the growth of mouse hybridoma, producing MAb to phage lambda, has been studied. It was shown that the specific production of MAb decreased by 25-35% in the stationary phase of growth in comparison with the middle of the exponential growth phase, which was associated with the decrease in the rate of MAb synthesis. The secretion kinetics of MAb did not change during the growth of hybridoma cells. MAb did not degrade inside the cells and in the culture medium after being secreted. The ratio of the synthesis rate of MAb to that of cellular proteins increased from 7-10% in the exponential growth phase to 14-18% in the stationary phase, which points to a specific regulation of MAb synthesis in comparison with cellular proteins. Possible regulation mechanisms for synthesis of MAb and cellular proteins during the growth of hybridoma cells are discussed.     

Transient kinetics of hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production in serum-limited cultures

A quantitative study of the influence of initial serum concentration on hybridoma growth rate, maximum viable and total cell yield, and specific antibody production rate is presented. The specific growth rate varied in a Monod fashion with initial serum levels (2-10% FCS), giving K(m) = 1.6 v/v% and mu(max) = 0.92 d(-1). The maximum cell yields (total and viable) were linear with initial serum level, indicating stoichiometric as well as kinetic limitation by serum component(s). The specific antibody production rate for each individual run fitted well to a non-growth-associated model. However, the non-growth-associated parameter varied monotonically with initial serum concentration, suggesting the catalytic role of serum component(s) in antibody production. Also, glutamine was utilized inefficiently, with at least a third of it secreted back into the culture supernate in the form of glutamate. While very simple model equations describe the specific growth and product formation rate for an individual batch run, the larger picture indicates need for a more detailed unstructured or structured model.     

Kinetic analysis of hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production in semicontinuous culture

Hybridoma I.13.17 was grown in semicontinuous culture in an attempt to investigate the steady-state concentrations of key components of monoclonal antibody (MAb) synthesis (e.g., intracellular MAb, IgG messenger RNAs) at different dilution rates between 0.008 and 0.055 h(-1). There was a general trend of increasing steady-state levels of total cytoplasmic RNA, total cell-associated MAb or cytoplasmic MAb, DNA synthesis rate, cellular metabolic activity, heavy (H-) and light (L-) chain IgG mRNAs with the increase in dilution rates. Increase in the half-lives of H- and L-chain mRNAs with increase in dilution rates may be sufficient to account for their increasing levels found under the same conditions. The specific growth rate was profoundly affected by the dilution rate, particularly near the lower end of the dilution rate range. Linear relationships were observed between the steady-state amounts of total cell-associated MAb and the relative levels of H- and L-chain mRNAs. Material balances on intracellular MAb demonstrated an increasing percentage of antibody not released into the growth medium (e.g., stored within the cell or anchored to the cell membrane) with increasing dilution rate. The MAb production rate per cell decreased significantly with the increase in dilution rates. No correlation was found between the relative levels of H- or L-chain mRNAs and the specific MAb production rate. Possible implications of rate-limiting steps in MAb synthesis and secretion are discussed.     

The influence of cyclic nucleotides on hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production

Summary The influence of cyclic AMP and cyclic GMP, known regulatory mediators of cellular response, on hybridoma growth and monoclonal antibody production is studied. The cGMP-treated cells exhibited 41% higher specific antibody secretion rate, resulting in 52% higher antibody yields. Addition of 1 mM cAMP inhibited cellular growth but enhanced the specific production rate by 37%.     

Mechanisms and kinetics of monoclonal antibody synthesis and secretion in synchronous and asynchronous hybridoma cell cultures.

The kinetics of monoclonal antibody synthesis and secretion have been studied in synchronous and asynchronous mouse hybridoma cell cultures. Pulse-labelling of IgG followed by immunoprecipitation and quantitation of synthesized and secreted IgG in synchronous cultures show maximum production during G1/S phases. Secretion takes place through exocytotic release of vesicle contents. Pulse-chase experiments show that 71% of the synthesized IgG is secreted within 8 h of the pulsing period and only a further 4% is secreted by 22 h. Higher specific antibody production (QA) is obtained if (a) cells are arrested and then maintained in G1/S phases, (b) viability is decreased during the death phase of batch culture, (c) the dilution rate is decreased in continuous culture or (d) cells are subjected to hydrodynamically induced stress. The increase in QA in all these cases is mainly due to the passive release of the accumulated intracellular antibody. DNA and protein synthetic activity peak during the early exponential phase and decline rapidly during mid and late exponential and death phases. Metabolic activity however peaks up to 20 h after the peak in DNA synthesis, and declines similarly during the death phase. The data are consistent with the idea that slow growth and higher death rates increase QA and that Ig secretion is probably subject to complex intracellular control.     

Effect of initial cell density on hybridoma growth, metabolism, and monoclonal antibody production.

A murine hybridoma cell line (167.4G5.3) was cultivated in batch mode with varying inoculum cell densities using IMDM media of varying fetal bovine serum concentrations. It was observed that maximum cell concentrations as well as the amount of monoclonal antibody attainable in batch mode were dependent on the inoculum size. Specifically, cultures with lower inoculum size resulted in lower cell yield and lower antibody concentrations. However, in the range of 10(2) to 10(5) cells per ml, the initial cell density affected the initial growth rate by a factor of only 20%. Furthermore, specific monoclonal antibody production rates were independent of initial cell density and the serum concentration. Glutamine was the limiting nutrient for all the cultures, determining the extent of growth and the amount of antibody produced. Serum was essential for cell growth and cultures with initial cell concentrations up to 10(6) cells per ml could not grow without serum. However, when adapted, the cells could grow in a custom-made serum-free medium containing insulin, transferrin, ethanolamine, and selenium (ITES) supplements. The cells adapted to the ITES medium could grow with an initial growth rate slightly higher than in 1.25% serum and the growth rate showed an initial density dependency-inocula at 10(3) cells per ml grew 30% slower than those at 10(4) or 10(5). This difference in growth rate was decreased to 10% with the addition of conditioned ITES medium. The addition of conditioned media, however, did not improve the cell growth for serum-containing batches.     

Mathematical modeling and analysis of monoclonal antibody production by hybridoma cells

An attempt has been made to mathematically describe and analyze monoclonal antibody (MAB) productivity of hybridoma cells, with particular emphasis on continuous cultures under unsteady-state conditions. A simple and unstructured general kinetic model that takes account of productivity loss during long-term cultivation, cell proliferation, and the effects of nutrients and toxic products is proposed. The model is verified with data of continuous culture from five different cell lines under a wide range of experimental conditions. Analysis of these results showed that for a reliable assessment of effects of different factors and for comparison of kinetic data on MAB production it is important to consider possible loss of MAB productivity, the time dependence of which can be modeled by an exponential function plus a constant term. Variations of nutrient concentration, particularly that of glucose, glutamine, and serum, can significantly alter MAB production under certain conditions. These effects can be described in terms of saturation kinetic and/or noncompetitive inhibition kinetics. (c) 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Improvement of monoclonal antibody production in hybridoma cells by dimethyl sulfoxide

Hybridoma cultures are routinely used as a source for monoclonal antibody (mAb) production necessary for preclinical evaluation. However, these cultures typically have low volumetric and specific productivities. In this article, we examined the use and the timing of addition of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) as a medium additive to improve mAb production in our hybridoma clone 19 (c19) cultures. From shake flask studies, we defined the optimal DMSO concentration and time of addition for improved productivity. This timing coordinated with high cell viability and density. Hybridoma cultures treated with DMSO up to 0.3% (v/v) possessed cell densities and viabilities comparable to untreated control. We demonstrated that 0.2% (v/v) DMSO added to shake flask cultures at their maximal viable cell densities resulted in a 2-fold increase in specific mAb production. This procedure was scaleable up to 20 L Cellbags (Wave Bioreactors) with similar titer improvement. Moreover, DMSO treatment did not affect the bioactivity or glycosylation profiles of the mAb.     

Observations consistent with autocrine stimulation of hybridoma cell growth and implications for large-scale antibody production

Existence of autocrine growth factors (aGFs) may influence the serum requirement for growth of hybridoma cells and thus significantly influence process economics. For the murine hybridoma cell line S3H5/2bA2, critical inoculum density (cID) and serum requirement for growth were inversely related for cultivation in both T flasks and spinner flasks. In spinner flasks, an inoculum density of 10⁶ cells/ml was necessary for the cells to grow in RPMI 1640 medium without serum supplement, and an inoculum density of 10³ cell/ml was necessary in RPMI 1640 medium with 10% serum. In T flasks, where the local cell density is higher than in spinner flasks, an inoculum density of 10⁶ cells/ml was necessary for the cells to grow in RPMI 1640 medium without serum supplement, and an inoculum density of 1 cell/ml was also necessary in RPMI 1640 medium with 10% serum. Further, immobilized cells at high local cell density could grow under conditions where cells in T flasks at corresponding overall cell density could not grow. The cells at high inoculum density were less sensitive to shear induced by mechanical agitation than the cells at low inoculum density. Taken together these observations support the existence of secreted aGF(s) by the hybridoma cell line used. Since the specific MAb production rate was independent of cultivation method and inoculum density, the existence of autocrine growth factors would suggest that the use of immobilized cells should improve the economics of MAb production.