Exploration of empirical Bayes hierarchical modeling for the analysis of genome-wide association study data

In the analysis of genome-wide association (GWA) data, the aim is to detect statistical associations between single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and the disease or trait of interest. These SNPs, or the particular regions of the genome they implicate, are then considered for further study. We demonstrate through a comprehensive simulation study that the inclusion of additional, biologically relevant information through a 2-level empirical Bayes hierachical model framework offers a more robust method of detecting associated SNPs. The empirical Bayes approach is an objective means of analyzing the data without the need for the setting of subjective parameter estimates. This framework gives more stable estimates of effects through a reduction of the variability in the usual effect estimates. We also demonstrate the consequences of including additional information that is not informative and examine power and false-positive rates. We apply the methodology to a number of genome-wide association (GWA) data sets with the inclusion of additional biological information. Our results agree with previous findings and in the case of one data set (Crohn's disease) suggest an additional region of interest.     

A variational Bayes algorithm for fast and accurate multiple locus genome-wide association analysis

Background  

The success achieved by genome-wide association (GWA) studies in the identification of candidate loci for complex diseases has been accompanied by an inability to explain the bulk of heritability. Here, we describe the algorithm V-Bay, a variational Bayes algorithm for multiple locus GWA analysis, which is designed to identify weaker associations that may contribute to this missing heritability.     

Pathway analysis of genome-wide association study for bone mineral density

The aim of this study was to identify the candidate causal single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and candidate causal mechanisms that contribute to bone mineral density (BMD) and to generate a SNP to gene to pathway hypothesis using an analytical pathway-based approach. We used hip BMD GWAS data of the genotypes of 301,019 SNPs in 5,715 Europeans. ICSNPathway (identify candidate causal SNPs and pathways) analysis was applied to the BMD GWAS dataset. The first stage involved the pre-selection of candidate causal SNPs by linkage disequilibrium analysis and the functional SNP annotation of the most significant SNPs found. The second stage involved the annotation of biological mechanisms for the pre-selected candidate causal SNPs using improved-gene set enrichment analysis. ICSNPathway analysis identified seven candidate SNPs, eight candidate pathways, and seven hypothetical biological mechanisms. Eight pathways are as follows; gamma-hexachlorocyclohexane degradation (nominal p-value < 0.001, false discovery rate (FDR) <0.001), regulation of the smoothened signaling pathway (nominal p-value < 0.001, FDR = 0.016), TACI and BCMA stimulation of B cell immune response (nominal p-value < 0.001, FDR = 0.021), endonuclease activity (nominal p-value = 0.001, FDR = 0,026), regulation of defense response to virus (nominal p-value = 0.001, FDR = 0.028), serine_type_endopeptidase_inhibitor_activity (nominal p-value = 0.001, FDR = 0.044), endoribonuclease activity (nominal p-value = 0.002, FDR = 0.045), and myeloid leukocyte differentiation (nominal p-value = 0.001, FDR = 0.050). The most significant causal pathway was gamma-hexachlorocyclohexane degradation. CYP3A5, PON2, PON3, CMBL, PON1, ALPL, CYP3A43, CYP3A7, ACP6, ACPP, and ALPI (p < 0.05) are involved in the pathway of gamma-hexachlorocyclohexane degradation. Further examination of the gene contents revealed that DBR1, DICER1, EXO1, FEN1, POP1, POP4, RPP30, and RPP38 were involved in 2 of the 8 pathways (p < 0.05). By applying ICSNPathway analysis to BMD GWAS data, we identified seven candidate SNPs and eight pathways involving gamma-hexachlorocyclohexane degradation, which may contribute to low BMD.     

全基因组关联研究通路分析方法现状

全基因组关联研究(genome-wide association study, GWAS)自2005年首次发表以来已不断增进人们对疾病遗传机制的认识,结合系统生物学并改进统计分析方法是对GWAS数据进行深度挖掘的重要途径。通路分析(pathway analysis)将GWAS所检测的遗传变异根据一定的生物学含义组合为集合进行分析,有利于发现对疾病单独效应小却在通路中相互关联的遗传变异,更有利于进行生物学解释。当前通路分析在GWAS数据上已有较为广泛的应用并取得初步成果。与此同时,通路分析的统计方法仍在不断发展。本文旨在介绍现有直接以SNP为对象的GWAS通路分析算法,根据方法中是否采用核函数分为非核算法和核算法两大类,其中非核算法主要包括基因功能富集分析(gene set enrichment analysis, GSEA)和分层贝叶斯优取(hierarchical Bayes prioritization, HBP),核算法包括线性核(linear kernel, LIN)、状态认证核(identity-by-status kernel, IBS)和尺度不变核(powered exponential kernel)。通过介绍这些方法的计算原理和优缺点,以期为新算法的构建提供更好的思路,为GWAS领域研究方法的选择提供参考。     

Pathway analysis of a genome-wide association study in schizophrenia

Objective

The aim of this study was to identify the candidate single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and candidate mechanisms that contribute to schizophrenia susceptibility and to generate a SNP to gene to pathway hypothesis using an analytical pathway-based approach.

Methods

We used schizophrenia GWAS data of the genotypes of 660,259 SNPs in 1378 controls and 1351 cases of European descent after quality control filtering. ICSNPathway (Identify candidate Causal SNPs and Pathways) analysis was applied to the schizophrenia GWAS dataset. The first stage involved the pre-selection of candidate SNPs by linkage disequilibrium analysis and the functional SNP annotation of the most significant SNPs found. The second stage involved the annotation of biological mechanisms for the pre-selected candidate SNPs using improved-gene set enrichment analysis.

Results

ICSNPathway analysis identified fifteen candidate SNPs, ten candidate pathways, and nine hypothetical biological mechanisms. The most strongly associated potential pathways were as follows. First, rs1644731 and rs1644730 to RDH8 to estrogen biosynthetic process (p < 0.001, FDR < 0.001). The genes involved in this pathway are RDH8 and HSD3B1 (p < 0.05). All-trans-retinol dehydrogenase (RDH8) is a visual cycle enzyme that reduces all-trans-retinal to all-trans-retinol in the presence of NADPH. The chemical reactions and pathways involved result in the formation of estrogens, which are C18 steroid hormones that can stimulate the development of female sexual characteristics. Second, rs1146031 to ACVR1 to mesoderm formation and activin binding (p < 0.001, FDR = 0.032, 0.034). Two of 15 candidate genes are known genes associated with schizophrenia: KCNQ2 and APOL2. One of the 10 candidate pathways, estrogen biosynthetic process, is known to be associated with schizophrenia (p < 0.001, FDR < 0.001). However, 13 of candidate genes (RDH8, ACVR1, PSMD9, KCNAB1, SLC17A3, ARCN1, COG7, STAB2, LRPAP1, STAB1, CXCL16, COL4A4, EXOSC3) and 9 of candidate pathways were novel.

Conclusion

By applying ICSNPathway analysis to schizophrenia GWAS data, we identified candidate SNPs, genes like KCNQ2 and APOL2 and pathways involving the estrogen biosynthetic process may contribute to schizophrenia susceptibility. Further analyses are needed to validate the results of this analysis.     

全基因组关联研究现状

在过去的5年中, 全基因组关联研究(Genome-wide association study, GWAS)方法已被证明是研究复杂疾病和性状遗传易感变异的一种有效手段。目前, 各国科学家在多种复杂疾病和性状中开展了大量的GWAS, 对肿瘤、糖尿病、心脏病、神经精神疾病、自身免疫及免疫相关疾病等复杂疾病以及一些常见性状(如身高、体重、血脂、色素等)的遗传易感基因研究取得了重大成果。截止到2010年9月11日, 运用GWAS开展了对近200种复杂疾病/性状的研究, 发现了3 000多个疾病相关的遗传变异。文章就GWAS的发展及其在复杂疾病/性状中的应用做一综述。     

全基因组关联研究的深度分析策略

2005年至今,全基因组关联研究(Genome-wide association study,GWAS)发现了大量复杂疾病/性状相关变异。近来,科学家们关注的焦点又集中在了如何利用GWAS数据进行深入分析,期待发现更多复杂疾病/性状的易感基因。一些新的策略和方法已经被尝试应用到复杂疾病/性状GWAS的后续研究中,例如深入分析GWAS数据;鉴定新的复杂疾病/性状易感基因/位点;国际合作和Meta分析;易感区域精细定位及测序;多种疾病共同易感基因研究;以及基因型填补,基于通路的关联分析,基因-基因、基因-环境交互作用和上位研究等。这些策略和方法的应用弥补了经典GWAS的一些不足之处,进一步推动了人类对复杂疾病/性状遗传机制的认识。文章对上述研究的策略、方法以及所面临的问题和挑战进行了综述,为读者描绘了GWAS后期工作的一个简要框架。     

SNP-based pathway enrichment analysis for genome-wide association studies

Background  

Recently we have witnessed a surge of interest in using genome-wide association studies (GWAS) to discover the genetic basis of complex diseases. Many genetic variations, mostly in the form of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), have been identified in a wide spectrum of diseases, including diabetes, cancer, and psychiatric diseases. A common theme arising from these studies is that the genetic variations discovered by GWAS can only explain a small fraction of the genetic risks associated with the complex diseases. New strategies and statistical approaches are needed to address this lack of explanation. One such approach is the pathway analysis, which considers the genetic variations underlying a biological pathway, rather than separately as in the traditional GWAS studies. A critical challenge in the pathway analysis is how to combine evidences of association over multiple SNPs within a gene and multiple genes within a pathway. Most current methods choose the most significant SNP from each gene as a representative, ignoring the joint action of multiple SNPs within a gene. This approach leads to preferential identification of genes with a greater number of SNPs.     

A prioritization analysis of disease association by data-mining of functional annotation of human genes

Complex diseases result from contributions of multiple genes that act in concert through pathways. Here we present a method to prioritize novel candidates of disease-susceptibility genes depending on the biological similarities to the known disease-related genes. The extent of disease-susceptibility of a gene is prioritized by analyzing seven features of human genes captured in H-InvDB. Taking rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and prostate cancer (PC) as two examples, we evaluated the efficiency of our method. Highly scored genes obtained included TNFSF12 and OSM as candidate disease genes for RA and PC, respectively. Subsequent characterization of these genes based upon an extensive literature survey reinforced the validity of these highly scored genes as possible disease-susceptibility genes. Our approach, Prioritization ANalysis of Disease Association (PANDA), is an efficient and cost-effective method to narrow down a large set of genes into smaller subsets that are most likely to be involved in the disease pathogenesis.     

Pathway analysis of genome-wide association study on serum prostate-specific antigen levels

The wide application of prostate-specific antigen (PSA) has contributed to the early diagnosis and improved management of prostate cancer (PCa). Accumulating evidence has suggested the involvement of genetic components in regulating serum PSA levels, and several single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) have been identified by genome-wide association studies (GWASs). However, the GWASs' results have the limited power to identify the causal variants and pathways. After the quality control filters, a total of 330,540 genotyped SNPs from one GWAS with 657 PCa-free Caucasian males were included for the identify candidate causal SNPs and pathways (ICSNPathway) analysis. In addition, the genotype–phenotype association analysis has been conducted with the data from HapMap database. Overall, a total of four SNPs in three genes and six pathways were identified by ICSNPathway analysis, which in total provided three hypothetical mechanisms. First, CYP26B1 rs2241057 polymorphism (nonsynonymous coding) which leads to a Leu-to-Ser amino acid shift at position 264, was implicated in the pathways including meiosis, proximal/distal pattern formation, and M phase of meiotic cell cycle. Second, CLIC5 rs3734207 and rs11752816 polymorphisms (regulatory region) to the 2 iron, 2 sulfur cluster binding pathway through regulating expression levels of CLIC5 mRNA. Third, rs4819522 polymorphism (nonsynonymous coding) leads to a Thr-to-Met transition at position 350 of TBX1 and involves in the pathways about gland and endocrine system development. In summary, our results demonstrated four candidate SNPs in three genes (CYP26B1 rs2241057, CISD1 rs2251039, rs2590370, and TBX1 rs4819522 polymorphisms), which were involved in six potential pathways to influence serum PSA levels.     

ProbABEL package for genome-wide association analysis of imputed data

Background  

Over the last few years, genome-wide association (GWA) studies became a tool of choice for the identification of loci associated with complex traits. Currently, imputed single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) data are frequently used in GWA analyzes. Correct analysis of imputed data calls for the implementation of specific methods which take genotype imputation uncertainty into account.     

Multiple-trait genome-wide association study based on principal component analysis for residual covariance matrix

Given the drawbacks of implementing multivariate analysis for mapping multiple traits in genome-wide association study (GWAS), principal component analysis (PCA) has been widely used to generate independent ‘super traits'' from the original multivariate phenotypic traits for the univariate analysis. However, parameter estimates in this framework may not be the same as those from the joint analysis of all traits, leading to spurious linkage results. In this paper, we propose to perform the PCA for residual covariance matrix instead of the phenotypical covariance matrix, based on which multiple traits are transformed to a group of pseudo principal components. The PCA for residual covariance matrix allows analyzing each pseudo principal component separately. In addition, all parameter estimates are equivalent to those obtained from the joint multivariate analysis under a linear transformation. However, a fast least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO) for estimating the sparse oversaturated genetic model greatly reduces the computational costs of this procedure. Extensive simulations show statistical and computational efficiencies of the proposed method. We illustrate this method in a GWAS for 20 slaughtering traits and meat quality traits in beef cattle.     

Commonality of functional annotation: a method for prioritization of candidate genes from genome-wide linkage studies

Linkage studies of complex traits frequently yield multiple linkage regions covering hundreds of genes. Testing each candidate gene from every region is prohibitively expensive and computational methods that simplify this process would benefit genetic research. We present a new method based on commonality of functional annotation (CFA) that aids dissection of complex traits for which multiple causal genes act in a single pathway or process. CFA works by testing individual Gene Ontology (GO) terms for enrichment among candidate gene pools, performs multiple hypothesis testing adjustment using an estimate of independent tests based on correlation of GO terms, and then scores and ranks genes annotated with significantly-enriched terms based on the number of quantitative trait loci regions in which genes bearing those annotations appear. We evaluate CFA using simulated linkage data and show that CFA has good power despite being conservative. We apply CFA to published linkage studies investigating age-of-onset of Alzheimer's disease and body mass index and obtain previously known and new candidate genes. CFA provides a new tool for studies in which causal genes are expected to participate in a common pathway or process and can easily be extended to utilize annotation schemes in addition to the GO.     

Practical aspects of genome-wide association interaction analysis

Large-scale epistasis studies can give new clues to system-level genetic mechanisms and a better understanding of the underlying biology of human complex disease traits. Though many novel methods have been proposed to carry out such studies, so far only a few of them have demonstrated replicable results. Here, we propose a minimal protocol for genome-wide association interaction (GWAI) analysis to identify gene–gene interactions from large-scale genomic data. The different steps of the developed protocol are discussed and motivated, and encompass interaction screening in a hypothesis-free and hypothesis-driven manner. In particular, we examine a wide range of aspects related to epistasis discovery in the context of complex traits in humans, hereby giving practical recommendations for data quality control, variant selection or prioritization strategies and analytic tools, replication and meta-analysis, biological validation of statistical findings and other related aspects. The minimal protocol provides guidelines and attention points for anyone involved in GWAI analysis and aims to enhance the biological relevance of GWAI findings. At the same time, the protocol improves a better assessment of strengths and weaknesses of published GWAI methodologies.     

Joint analysis for genome-wide association studies in family-based designs

In family-based data, association information can be partitioned into the between-family information and the within-family information. Based on this observation, Steen et al. (Nature Genetics. 2005, 683-691) proposed an interesting two-stage test for genome-wide association (GWA) studies under family-based designs which performs genomic screening and replication using the same data set. In the first stage, a screening test based on the between-family information is used to select markers. In the second stage, an association test based on the within-family information is used to test association at the selected markers. However, we learn from the results of case-control studies (Skol et al. Nature Genetics. 2006, 209-213) that this two-stage approach may be not optimal. In this article, we propose a novel two-stage joint analysis for GWA studies under family-based designs. For this joint analysis, we first propose a new screening test that is based on the between-family information and is robust to population stratification. This new screening test is used in the first stage to select markers. Then, a joint test that combines the between-family information and within-family information is used in the second stage to test association at the selected markers. By extensive simulation studies, we demonstrate that the joint analysis always results in increased power to detect genetic association and is robust to population stratification.     

GenABEL: an R library for genome-wide association analysis

Here we describe an R library for genome-wide association (GWA) analysis. It implements effective storage and handling of GWA data, fast procedures for genetic data quality control, testing of association of single nucleotide polymorphisms with binary or quantitative traits, visualization of results and also provides easy interfaces to standard statistical and graphical procedures implemented in base R and special R libraries for genetic analysis. We evaluated GenABEL using one simulated and two real data sets. We conclude that GenABEL enables the analysis of GWA data on desktop computers. Availability: http://cran.r-project.org.