Induction of muscle genes in neural cells

The regulation of skeletal muscle genes was examined in heterokaryons formed by fusing differentiated chick skeletal myocytes to four different rat neural cell lines. Highly enriched populations of heterokaryons isolated using irreversible biochemical inhibitors were labeled with [35S]methionine and analyzed on two-dimensional gels. Rat skeletal myosin light chains were induced in three of the four cell combinations. The one exception, the S-20 cholinergic cell line, not only failed to synthesize rat muscle proteins but also suppressed chick myogenic functions. Experiments with heterokaryons between chick myocytes and cells from whole embryonic rat brain cultures demonstrated that rat skeletal myosin light chains are inducible in normal diploid neural cells as well as in established neural cell lines. In contrast, dividing cell hybrids between rat myoblasts and rat glial cells were nonmyogenic. These results demonstrate that although neural cells may contain factors that prevent the decision to differentiate along myogenic lines in cell hybrids, most neural cell lines do not dominantly suppress the expression of muscle structural genes in heterokaryons. Furthermore, the skeletal myosin light chain genes in most neural cell lines are regulated by a mechanism that permits them to respond to putative chick skeletal myocyte-inducing factors. The "open" state of these myogenic genes may explain many of the reports of apparent "transdifferentiation" to muscle in neural cultures and neural tumors.     

Synthesis of rat myosin light chains in heterokaryons formed between undifferentiated rat myoblasts and chick skeletal myocytes

The control of gene expression during terminal myogenesis was explored in heterokaryons between differentiated and undifferentiated myogenic cells by analyzing the formation of species specific myosin light chains of chick and rat skeletal muscle. Dividing L6 rat myoblasts served as the biochemically undifferentiated parent. The differentiated parental cells were mononucleated muscle cells (myocytes) that were obtained from primary cultures of embryonic chick thigh muscle by blocking myotube formation with EGTA and later incubating the postimitotic cells in cytochalasin B. Heterokaryons were isolated by the selective rescue of fusion products between cells previously treated with lethal doses of different cell poisons. 95-99% pure populations of heterokaryons formed between undifferentiated rat myoblasts and differentiated chick myocytes were obtained. The cells were labeled with [35S]methionine, and whole cell extracts were analyzed on two-dimensional polyacrylamide gels. These heterokaryons synthesize the light chain of chick myosin and both embryonic and adult light chains of rat skeletal myosin. Control homokaryons formed by fusing undifferentiated cells to themselves did not synthesize skeletal myosin light chains. Control heterokaryons formed between undifferentiated rat myoblasts and chick fibroblasts also failed to synthesize myosin light chains. These results indicate that differentiated chick muscle cells provide some factor that induces L6 myoblasts to synthesize rat myosin light chains. This system provides a model for investigating the processes by which differentiated cell functions are induced.     

The suppression of myogenic functions in heterokaryons formed by fusing chick myocytes to diploid rat fibroblasts

Heterokaryons were formed by fusing differentiated chick skeletal myocytes to fibroblasts derived from skin, lung or heart cultures. The heterokaryons were analyzed for the synthesis of skeletal myosin light chains, acetylcholine receptor, total CPK activity and the ability to spontaneously fuse to form myotubes. Whereas all of the above myogenic functions were expressed in control heterokaryons formed between myocytes and myoblasts, all were extinguished in the crosses between myocytes and fibroblasts. These results confirm that the suppression of myogenic functions previously observed in cell hybrids involving fibroblastoid tumor cells also occurs in heterokaryons isolated using biochemical inhibitors between diploid fibroblasts and chick skeletal myocytes.     

Expression of differentiated functions in heterokaryons between skeletal myocytes,adrenal cells,fibroblasts and glial cells

The regulation of both muscle and adrenal functions was examined in heterokaryons formed by fusing differentiated chick skeletal myocytes to Y1 mouse adrenal cells. Mouse fast skeletal myosin light chain one (LC1) synthesis was induced and acetylcholine receptor expression was maintained at muscle control levels. Steroid secretion, although reduced compared with Y1 × Y1 adrenal homokaryon control fusions, was nonetheless maintained at relatively high levels. Steroid secretion in the myocyte × adrenal heterokaryons was constitutively expressed and was not increased by exposure to either adrenocorticotrophic hormone or db-cAMP. The population of heterokaryons was thus simultaneously expressing both muscle and adrenal functions. The steroid secretion in these heterokaryons was compared to that in heterokaryons formed by fusing Y1 adrenal cells to either chick skin fibroblasts or rat C6 glial cells. Both of these sets of heterokaryons exhibited low baseline levels of steroid secretion that were inducible to control values by ACTH. These results extend previous observations showing that heterokaryons are functionally very different than cell hybrids, and exhibit a variety of phenotypic interactions. Although fibroblasts suppress muscle functions in heterokaryons, they are permissive for adrenal functions. C6 glial cells are permissive for both adrenal and muscle functions, and along with several other neurectodermal derivatives contain an inducible skeletal myosin light chain gene. Finally, myocytes and Y1 adrenal cells are mutually permissive for their differentiated functions, and Y1 adrenal cells contain an inducible myosin light chain gene.     

Regulation of rat myosin light-chain synthesis in heterokaryons between 5-bromodeoxyuridine-blocked rat myoblasts and differentiated chick myocytes

Terminal cell differentiation in a variety of model systems is inhibited by the thymidine analogue 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR). We investigated the mode of action of BUdR by forming heterokaryons between undifferentiated BUdR-blocked rat myoblasts and differentiated chick skeletal myocytes. We analyzed newly synthesized proteins on two- dimensional polyacrylamide gels. The induction of rat skeletal myosin light-chain synthesis was reduced fivefold, as compared with controls, when chick myocytes were fused to BUdR-blocked rat myoblasts. This indicates that plasma membrane effects cannot be the proximate cause for the inhibition of myogenesis by BUdR, since BUdR is able to block the effect of chick inducing factors even when a differentiated chick myocyte is in direct cytoplasmic continuity with the BUdR-blocked rat nucleus. The observation that chick cells required an 80% substitution of BUdR for thymidine to block myogenesis, whereas L6 rat myoblasts required only a 20% substitution led to a hypothesis involving a DNA- mediated action of BUdR. This model yielded three testable predictions: (a) putative chick inducing molecules should be present in limiting quantities, (b) exploiting gene-dosage effects to increase the quantity of putative chick inducing factors might overcome the inhibition produced in the rat myoblasts by a 35% BUdR for thymidine substitution, and (c) these gene-dosage effects should be abolished by increasing the level of BUdR substitution in the rat myoblast to 60-80%. All three of these predictions have been verified, providing strong indirect evidence that the inhibition of myogenesis produced by BUdR is a direct result of its incorporation into cellular DNA.     

Induction of myosin light chain synthesis in heterokaryons between normal diploid cells

Summary Quail myoblasts were maintained in an undifferentiated state by first blocking differentiation with 5-bromodeoxyuridine and then reversing the block in the presence of phorbol-12-myristate-13-acetate. The synthesis of quail skeletal myosin light chain 1 is induced in heterokaryons formed by fusing these undifferentiated quail myoblasts to differentiated chick myocytes. These results extend observations previously obtained using an established line of rat myoblasts and indicate that the induction is a result of regulatory interactions present in normal diploid cells. This work was supported by grants from the Muscular Dystrophy Association and the National Institutes of Health.     

Analysis of muscle protein expression in polyethylene glycol-induced chicken: rat myoblast heterokaryons

Heterokaryons derived from polyethylene glycol-mediated fusion of myoblasts at different stages of development were used to investigate the transition of cells in the skeletal muscle lineage from the determined to the differentiated state. Heterokaryons were analyzed by immunofluorescence, using rabbit antibodies against the skeletal muscle isoforms of chicken creatine kinase and myosin, and a mouse monoclonal antibody that cross-reacts with chicken and rat skeletal muscle myosin. When cytochalasin B-treated rat L8(E63) myocytes (Konieczny S.F., J. McKay, and J. R. Coleman, 1982, Dev. Biol., 91:11-26) served as the differentiated parental component and chicken limb myoblasts from stage 23-26 or 10-12-d embryos were used as the determined, undifferentiated parental cell, heterokaryons exhibited a progressive extinction of rat skeletal muscle myosin during a 4-6-d culture period, and no precocious expression of chicken differentiated gene products was detected. In the reciprocal experiment, 85-97% of rat myoblast X chicken myocyte heterokaryons ceased expression of chicken skeletal muscle myosin and the M subunit of chicken creatine kinase within 7 d of culture. Extinction was not observed in heterokaryons produced by fusion of differentiated chicken and differentiated rat myocytes and thus is not due to species incompatibility or to the polyethylene glycol treatment itself. The results suggest that, when confronted in a common cytoplasm, the regulatory factors that maintain myoblasts in a proliferating, undifferentiated state are dominant over those that govern expression of differentiated gene products.     

Phenotypic expression in chick erythrocyte X rat myoblast hybrids and in chick myoblast X rat myoblast hybrids

Attempts were made to reprogram chick erythrocyte nuclei to specify the synthesis of chick myosin. Chick erythrocytes were fused with rat myogenic cells with the aid of UV-inactivated Sendai virus. In the heterokaryons and hybrid myotubes which resulted from this fusion, the erythrocyte nuclei resumed RNA synthesis and formed nucleoli. Although some new chick antigens developed in those myotubes which contained fully reactivated chick erythrocyte nuclei, accumulation of chick myosin could not be detected by immunological methods. Neither small heterokaryons nor large hybrid myotubes which were actively synthesizing rat myosin reacted with antibodies directed against chick myosin. A small number of mononucleated cells, believed to be synkaryons formed by mitotic division of heterokaryons, did, however, react strongly with antibodies directed against chick myosin and showed a cross striation typical of skeletal muscle. The frequency of such cells was too low, however, to permit karyological analysis or further characterization of the antigen. Hybrids between chick myoblasts and rat myoblasts produced both chick and rat myosin thus indicating that simultaneous translation of chick and rat mRNA for myosin in a common cytoplasm was possible. In summary the evidence obtained suggested that reprogramming of chick erythrocyte nuclei, if it did occur in the present system, was a rare phenomenon.The possibility that hybrids between chick erythrocytes and rat myoblasts expressed markers typical of an erythroid phenotype was examined by immune staining with antibodies directed against chick haemoglobin. The results suggested that haemoglobin was introduced into hybrid cells by erythrocytes which failed to lyse before fusion. The intensity of this immune fluorescence decreased with increasing time after fusion. The rate at which this decrease occurred was not affected by inhibition of RNA synthesis. Thus, there was no evidence for the accumulation of haemoglobin in the hybrid cells.     

Control of differentiation in heterokaryons and hybrids involving differentiation-defective myoblast variants

Clones of differentiation-defective myoblasts were isolated by selecting clones of L6 rat myoblasts that did not form myotubes under differentiation-stimulating conditions. Rat skeletal myosin light chain synthesis was induced in heterokaryons formed by fusing these defective myoblasts to differentiated chick skeletal myocytes. This indicates that the structural gene for this muscle protein was still responsive to chick inducing factors and that the defective myoblasts were not producing large quantities of molecules that dominantly suppressed the expression of differentiated functions. The regulation of the decision to differentiate was then examined in hybrids between differentiation- defective myoblasts and differentiation-competent myoblasts. Staining with antimyosin antibodies showed that the defective myoblasts and homotypic hybrids formed by fusing defective myoblasts to themselves could in fact differentiate, but did so more than a thousand times less frequently than the 64% differentiation achieved by competent L6 myoblasts or homotypic competent X competent L6 hybrids. Heterotypic hybrids between differentiation-defective myoblasts and competent L6 cells exhibited an intermediate behavior of approximately 1% differentiation. A theoretical model for the regulation of the commitment to terminal differentiation is proposed that could explain these results by invoking the need to achieve threshold levels of secondary inducing molecules in response to differentiation-stimulating conditions. This model helps explain many of the stochastic aspects of cell differentiation.     

Pattern of chick gene activation in chick erythrocyte heterokaryons

The reactivation of chicken erythrocyte nuclei in chick-mammalian heterokaryons resulted in the activation of chick globin gene expression. However, the level of chick globin synthesis was dependent on the mammalian parental cell type. The level of globin synthesis was high in chick erythrocyte-rat L6 myoblast heterokaryons but was 10-fold lower in chick erythrocyte-mouse A9 cell heterokaryons. Heterokaryons between chick erythrocytes and a hybrid cell line between L6 and A9 expressed chick globin at a level similar to that of A9 heterokaryons. Erythrocyte nuclei reactivated in murine NA neuroblastoma, 3T3, BHK and NRK cells, or in chicken fibroblasts expressed less than 5% chick globin compared with the chick erythrocyte-L6 myoblast heterokaryons. The amount of globin expressed in heterokaryons correlated with globin mRNA levels. Hemin increased beta globin synthesis two- to threefold in chick erythrocyte-NA neuroblastoma heterokaryons; however, total globin synthesis was still less than 10% that of L6 heterokaryons. Distinct from the variability in globin expression, chick erythrocyte heterokaryons synthesized chick constitutive polypeptides in similar amounts independent of the mammalian parental cell type. Approximately 40 constitutive chick polypeptides were detected in heterokaryons after immunopurification and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The pattern of synthesis of these polypeptides was similar in heterokaryons formed by fusing chicken erythrocytes with rat L6 myoblasts, hamster BHK cells, or mouse neuroblastoma cells. Three polypeptides synthesized by non-erythroid chicken cells but less so by embryonic erythrocytes were conspicuous in heterokaryons. Two abundant erythrocyte polypeptides were insignificant in non-erythroid chicken cells and in heterokaryons.     

Extinction of muscle-specific properties in somatic cell heterokaryons

In studies of gene regulation using somatic cell fusion techniques, the analysis of heterokaryons circumvents several problematic aspects of the more traditional approach utilizing proliferating hybrid cells. We have analyzed the expression of muscle specific properties in heterokaryons between muscle and nonmuscle cells in order to investigate whether differentiating cells contain regulatory factors that repress the expression of alternative developmental pathways. Heterokaryons and cybrids were derived from polyethylene glycol-mediated fusion of differentiated mononucleate chicken myocytes with mouse melanoma cells, mouse melanoma cytoplasts, chicken fibroblasts, or other chicken myocytes. Our results demonstrate that fusion of a myocyte with a nonmyogenic cell generally results in extinction of muscle-specific properties in the immediate fusion product. Myocyte X melanoma heterokaryons ceased to express the skeletal muscle forms of myosin, desmin and creatine kinase, reinitiated DNA synthesis, and showed a loss of spontaneous fusion competence within 96 hr after their formation. Although chicken myocyte X mouse melanoma heterokaryons showed extinction of muscle specific properties, they continued to synthesize protein and to incorporate [3H]hypoxanthine, presumably due to the continued production of constitutive chicken HPRT. That presence of the melanoma nucleus was required for extinction to be observed was demonstrated by the continued expression of muscle proteins in cybrids between chicken myocytes and melanoma cytoplasts. Significantly, heterokaryons between chicken myocytes and chicken fibroblasts also exhibited extinction of muscle proteins, demonstrating for the first time that extinction is not restricted to fusions in which at least one parental cell type was derived from an established cell line. Our results strongly support the notion that extinction reflects cell-type specific gene regulatory mechanisms operative during development.     

Preparation and characterization of chick erythrocyte nuclei from heterokaryons

A method for the isolation of reactivated chick erythrocyte nuclei from heterokaryons was developed. The heterokaryons were produced by fusing chick erythrocytes with HeLa or L cells in the presence of inactivated Sendai virus. At various time intervals after fusion nuclei were isolated directly from the monolayer by treatment with an acidic detergent solution. Chick erythrocyte nuclei were then separated from other nuclei (HeLa or L cell) by centrifugation on sucrose gradients. The purified preparation of reactivated chick erythrocyte nuclei was shown to be free from other nuclei and cytoplasmic contamination. By using L cells which had been labelled with ³H-leucine before fusion or heterokaryons labelled after fusion it was demonstrated that labelled mouse proteins migrate from the cytoplasm of the heterokaryons into the reactivating chick erythrocyte nuclei. ³H-uridine labelling of heterokaryons made by fusing UV-irradiated chick erythrocytes with L cells failed to reveal any significant migration of mouse RNA into the chick erythrocyte nuclei.     

Intracellular antigen migration in interspecific myoblast heterokaryons

Intracellular migration of species-specific nuclear antigens was studied in chick-rat heterokaryons. These cells were produced by virus-induced or spontaneous fusion of different chick cells with rat myoblasts or myotubes. Chick erythrocyte nuclei introduced into rat myogenic cells increased in volume and were reactivated to synthesize RNA. As the chick erythrocyte nuclei enlarged, they rapidly accumulated rat nuclear antigens. Rat nucleolar and nucleoplasmic antigens assumed a distribution in the chick nuclei corresponding to that in rat nuclei. In hybrid myotubes formed by the spontaneous fusion of chick myoblasts and rat myoblasts antigen exchange was at a much lower level. Some exchange of both rat and chick nuclear antigens could, however, be detected also in this system. Thus chick nuclear envelope and nucleolar antigens migrated into the rat myoblast nuclei and assumed an intranuclear localization analogous to that in chick nuclei. On the basis of these results it appears that antigenic nuclear macromolecules are constantly exchanged between the rat and chick nuclear compartments and the cytoplasm of the heterokaryon. During the rapid nuclear swelling which occurs when chick erythrocyte nuclei are activated in rat myoblast heterokaryons, the inward migration of rat nuclear antigens into the chick erythrocyte nucleus is more impressive than the migration of chick antigens into the rat nuclei.     

Ultrastructure of chick erythrocyte nuclei undergoing reactivation in heterokaryons and enucleated cells

The reactivation of chick erythrocyte nuclei after Sendai virus induced fusion of chick erythrocytes with intact or anucleate rat myoblasts or rat epithelial cells was studied by electron microscopy. Both in heterokaryons and in reconstituted cells formed by the fusion of chick red cells with anucleate rat L6 myoblasts the amount of highly condensed chromatin in the chick nuclei decreased with time after fusion at the same time as the proportion of dispersed chromatin increased. Nuclear organelles, typical of active nuclei but absent in the nuclei of unfused erythrocytes, appeared during reactivation. The percentage of chick nuclei containing a nucleolus was low 24 h after fusion but increased so that almost all nuclei contained one or more nucleoli 120 h after fusion. In reconstituted cells the frequency of nucleoli was much lower than in heterokaryons. In other respects, the erythrocyte nuclei introduced into anucleate rat cells underwent a normal reactivation and appeared to be well integrated with the cytoplasm. Thus, the nuclear envelope consisted of two normal leaflets in direct contact with the cytoplasm. Nuclear pores were observed in front of interchromatin channels. A normal cytoplasmic geometry appeared to be re-established since the Golgi apparatus occupied a position close to the poles of the chick nucleus.     

Nucleo-cytoplasmic protein migration during the activation of chick erythrocyte nuclei in heterokaryons

The reactivation of the chick erythrocyte nucleus was studied after erythrocytes were induced to fuse with rat epithelial cells in the presence of Sendai virus. The chick nucleus swells, shows an increase in dry mass and protein content and resumes RNA synthesis. Nucleoplasmic antigens characteristic of the rat cell are found to migrate into the erythrocyte nucleus. The rate of uptake of these molecules, which are believed to be proteins, appears to be directly related to increases in nuclear size, ³H-uridine incorporation and RNA polymerase activity. The polymerase activity which increases during the first days after cell fusion is sensitive to α-amanitin but relatively resistant to actinomycin D. At later time points there is an increase in α-amanitin resistant polymerase activity which probably reflects the appearance of ribosomal RNA synthesis.When heterokaryons containing different proportions of rat: chick nuclei are compared, reactivation is found to proceed most rapidly in those containing a high rat: chick nuclear ratio. As the number of erythrocyte nuclei in heterokaryons increases, the rate of reactivation in the individual nuclei is progressively reduced suggesting that the erythrocyte nuclei compete with each other for macromolecules of specific importance for the activation process.     

Heterokaryon analysis of muscle differentiation: regulation of the postmitotic state

MM14 mouse myoblasts withdraw irreversibly from the cell cycle and become postmitotic within a few hours of being deprived of fibroblast growth factor (Clegg, C. H., T. A. Linkhart, B. B. Olwin, and S. D. Hauschka, 1987, J. Cell Biol., 105:949-956). To examine the mechanisms that may regulate this developmental state of skeletal muscle, we tested the mitogen responsiveness of various cell types after their polyethylene glycol-mediated fusion with post-mitotic myocytes. Heterokaryons containing myocytes and quiescent nonmyogenic cells such as 3T3, L cell, and a differentiation-defective myoblast line (DD-1) responded to mitogen-rich medium by initiating DNA synthesis. Myonuclei replicated DNA and reexpressed thymidine kinase. In contrast, (myocyte x G1 myoblast) heterokaryons failed to replicate DNA in mitogen-rich medium and became postmitotic. This included cells with a nuclear ratio of three myoblasts to one myocyte. Proliferation dominance in (myocyte x 3T3 cell) and (myocyte x DD-1) heterokaryons was conditionally regulated by the timing of mitogen treatment; such cells became postmitotic when mitogen exposure was delayed for as little as 6 h after cell fusion. In addition, (myocyte x DD-1) heterokaryons expressed a muscle-specific trait and lost epidermal growth factor receptors when they became postmitotic. These results demonstrate that DNA synthesis is not irreversibly blocked in skeletal muscle; myonuclei readily express proliferation-related functions when provided with a mitogenic signal. Rather, myocyte-specific repression of DNA synthesis in heterokaryons argues that the postmitotic state of skeletal muscle is regulated by diffusible factors that inhibit processes of cellular mitogenesis.     

Haemoglobin synthesis in fused cells.

When primitive erythroid cells from 5-day-old chick embryos are exposed to inactivated Sendai virus they do not undergo haemolysis but fuse with other cells by the normal process of cytoplasmic coalescence. In this way cells actively engaged in the synthesis of haemoglobin may be fused with others that are not. In heterokaryons formed by the fusion of such erythroid cells with cells from established mouse or hamster lines, haemoglobin synthesis initially continues at a high level, but then declines and ceases altogether within a period of about 60 h. This decline affects the synthesis of both haem and globin and reflects the activity of specific regulatory mechanism, for under these conditions other chick proteins continue to be synthesized. The haemoglobin synthesized in the heterokaryons is entirely chick, and not mouse or hamster, haemoglobin.