Dimer ribbons of ATP synthase shape the inner mitochondrial membrane

ATP synthase converts the electrochemical potential at the inner mitochondrial membrane into chemical energy, producing the ATP that powers the cell. Using electron cryo-tomography we show that the ATP synthase of mammalian mitochondria is arranged in long approximately 1-microm rows of dimeric supercomplexes, located at the apex of cristae membranes. The dimer ribbons enforce a strong local curvature on the membrane with a 17-nm outer radius. Calculations of the electrostatic field strength indicate a significant increase in charge density, and thus in the local pH gradient of approximately 0.5 units in regions of high membrane curvature. We conclude that the mitochondrial cristae act as proton traps, and that the proton sink of the ATP synthase at the apex of the compartment favours effective ATP synthesis under proton-limited conditions. We propose that the mitochondrial ATP synthase organises itself into dimer ribbons to optimise its own performance.     

A feature-guided,focused 3D signal permutation method for subtomogram averaging

Advances in electron microscope instrumentation, cryo-electron tomography data collection, and subtomogram averaging have allowed for the in-situ visualization of molecules and their complexes in their native environment. Current data processing pipelines commonly extract subtomograms as a cubic subvolume with the key assumption that the selected object of interest is discrete from its surroundings. However, in instances when the object is in its native environment, surrounding densities may negatively affect the subsequent alignment and refinement processes, leading to loss of information due to misalignment. For example, the strong densities from surrounding membranes may dominate the alignment process for membrane proteins. Here, we developed methods for feature-guided subtomogram alignment and 3D signal permutation for subtomogram averaging. Our 3D signal permutation method randomizes and filters voxels outside a mask of any shape and blurs the boundary of the mask that encapsulates the object of interest. The randomization preserves global statistical properties such as mean density and standard deviation of voxel density values, effectively producing a featureless background surrounding the object of interest. This signal permutation process can be repeatedly applied with intervening alignments of the 3D signal-permuted subvolumes, recentering of the mask, and optional adjustments of the shape of the mask. We have implemented these methods in a new processing pipeline which starts from tomograms, contains feature-guided subtomogram extraction and alignment, 3D signal-permutation, and subtomogram visualization tools. As an example, feature-guided alignment and 3D signal permutation leads to improved subtomogram average maps for a dataset of synaptic protein complexes in their native environment.     

Averaging of Viral Envelope Glycoprotein Spikes from Electron Cryotomography Reconstructions using Jsubtomo

Enveloped viruses utilize membrane glycoproteins on their surface to mediate entry into host cells. Three-dimensional structural analysis of these glycoprotein ‘spikes’ is often technically challenging but important for understanding viral pathogenesis and in drug design. Here, a protocol is presented for viral spike structure determination through computational averaging of electron cryo-tomography data. Electron cryo-tomography is a technique in electron microscopy used to derive three-dimensional tomographic volume reconstructions, or tomograms, of pleomorphic biological specimens such as membrane viruses in a near-native, frozen-hydrated state. These tomograms reveal structures of interest in three dimensions, albeit at low resolution. Computational averaging of sub-volumes, or sub-tomograms, is necessary to obtain higher resolution detail of repeating structural motifs, such as viral glycoprotein spikes. A detailed computational approach for aligning and averaging sub-tomograms using the Jsubtomo software package is outlined. This approach enables visualization of the structure of viral glycoprotein spikes to a resolution in the range of 20-40 Å and study of the study of higher order spike-to-spike interactions on the virion membrane. Typical results are presented for Bunyamwera virus, an enveloped virus from the family Bunyaviridae. This family is a structurally diverse group of pathogens posing a threat to human and animal health.     

Supramolecular organization of protein complexes in the mitochondrial inner membrane

The liquid state model that envisions respiratory chain complexes diffusing freely in the membrane is increasingly challenged by reports of supramolecular organization of the complexes in the mitochondrial inner membrane. Supercomplexes of complex III with complex I and/or IV can be isolated after solubilisation with mild detergents like digitonin. Electron microscopic studies have shown that these have a distinct architecture and are not random aggregates. A 3D reconstruction of a I1III2IV1 supercomplex shows that the ubiquinone and cytochrome c binding sites of the individual complexes are facing each other, suggesting a role in substrate channelling. Formation of supercomplexes plays a role in the assembly and stability of the complexes, suggesting that the supercomplexes are the functional state of the respiratory chain. Furthermore, a supramolecular organisation of ATP synthases has been observed in mitochondria, where ATP synthase is organised in dimer rows. Dimers can be isolated by mild detergent extraction and recent electron microscopic studies have shown that the membrane domains of the two partners in the dimer are at an angle to each other, indicating that in vivo the dimers would cause the membrane to bend. The suggested role in crista formation is supported by the observation of rows of ATP synthase dimers in the most curved parts of the cristae. Together these observations show that the mitochondrial inner membrane is highly organised and that the molecular events leading to ATP synthesis are carefully coordinated.     

Studying membrane modulation mechanisms by electron cryo-tomography

Membrane modulation is a key part of cellular life. Critical to processes like energy production, cell division, trafficking, migration and even pathogen entry, defects in membrane modulation are often associated with diseases. Studying the molecular mechanisms of membrane modulation is challenging due to the highly dynamic nature of the oligomeric assemblies involved, which adopt multiple conformations depending on the precise event they are participating in. With the development of electron cryo-tomography and subtomogram averaging, many of these challenges are being resolved as it is now possible to observe complex macromolecular assemblies inside a cell at nanometre to sub-nanometre resolutions. Here, we review the different ways electron cryo-tomography is being used to help uncover the molecular mechanisms used by cells to shape their membranes.     

Electron tomography of mitochondria after the arrest of protein import associated with Tom19 depletion

In a mutant form of Neurospora crassa, in which sheltered RIP (repeat induced point mutation) was used to deplete Tom19, protein transport through the TOM/TIM pathway is arrested by the addition of p-fluorophenylalanine (FPA). Using intermediate-voltage electron tomography, we have generated three-dimensional reconstructions of 28 FPA-treated mitochondria at four time points (0-32 h) after the addition of FPA. We determined that the cristae surface area and volume were lost in a roughly linear manner. A decrease in mitochondrial volume was not observed until after 16 h of FPA treatment. The inner boundary membrane did not appear to shrink or contract away from the outer membrane. Interestingly, the close apposition of these membranes remained over the entire periphery, even after all of the cristae had disappeared. The different dynamics of the shrinkage of cristae membrane and inner boundary membrane has implications for compartmentalization of electron transport proteins. Two structurally distinct types of contact sites were observed, consistent with recently published work. We determined that the cristae in the untreated (control) mitochondria are all lamellar. The cristae of FPA-treated mitochondria retain the lamellar morphology as they reduce in size and do not adopt tubular shapes. Importantly, the crista junctions exhibit tubular as well as slot-like connections to the inner boundary membrane, persisting until the cristae disappear, indicating that their stability is not dependent on continuous protein import through the complex containing Tom19.     

Row-like organization of ATP synthase in intact mitochondria determined by cryo-electron tomography

The fine structure of intact, close-to-spherical mitochondria from the alga Polytomella was visualized by dual-axis cryo-electron tomography. The supramolecular organization of dimeric ATP synthase in the cristae membranes was investigated by averaging subvolumes of tomograms and 3D details at ∼ 6 nm resolution were revealed. Oligomeric ATP synthase is composed of rows of dimers at 12 nm intervals; the dimers make a slight angle along the row. In addition, the main features of monomeric ATP synthase, such as the conically shaped F₁ headpiece, central stalk and stator were revealed. This demonstrates the capability of dual-axis electron tomography to unravel details of proteins and their interactions in complete organelles.     

Imaging of organelles by electron microscopy reveals protein-protein interactions in mitochondria and chloroplasts

Ongoing progress in electron microscopy (EM) offers now an opening to visualize cells at the nanoscale by cryo-electron tomography (ET). Large protein complexes can be resolved at near-atomic resolution by single particle averaging. Some examples from mitochondria and chloroplasts illustrate the possibilities with an emphasis on the membrane organization. Cryo-ET performed on non-chemically fixed, unstained, ice-embedded material can visualize specific large membrane protein complexes. In combination with averaging methods, 3D structures were calculated of mitochondrial ATP synthase at 6 nm resolution and of chloroplast photosystem II at 3.5 nm.     

Visualizing Individual RuBisCO and Its Assembly into Carboxysomes in Marine Cyanobacteria by Cryo-Electron Tomography

Cyanobacteria are photosynthetic organisms responsible for ~ 25% of the organic carbon fixation on earth. A key step in carbon fixation is catalyzed by ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (RuBisCO), the most abundant enzyme in the biosphere. Applying Zernike phase-contrast electron cryo-tomography and automated annotation, we identified individual RuBisCO molecules and their assembly intermediates leading to the formation of carboxysomes inside Syn5 cyanophage infected cyanobacteria Synechococcus sp. WH8109 cells. Surprisingly, more RuBisCO molecules were found to be present as cytosolic free-standing complexes or clusters than as packaged assemblies inside carboxysomes. Cytosolic RuBisCO clusters and partially assembled carboxysomes identified in the cell tomograms support a concurrent assembly model involving both the protein shell and the enclosed RuBisCO. In mature carboxysomes, RuBisCO is neither randomly nor strictly icosahedrally packed within protein shells of variable sizes. A time-averaged molecular dynamics simulation showed a semi-liquid probability distribution of the RuBisCO in carboxysomes and correlated well with carboxysome subtomogram averages. Our structural observations reveal the various stages of RuBisCO assemblies, which could be important for understanding cellular function.     

Electron tomography of plant thylakoid membranes

For more than half a century, electron microscopy has been a main tool for investigating the complex ultrastructure and organization of chloroplast thylakoid membranes, but, even today, the three-dimensional relationship between stroma and grana thylakoids, and the arrangement of the membrane protein complexes within them are not fully understood. Electron cryo-tomography (cryo-ET) is a powerful new technique for visualizing cellular structures, especially membranes, in three dimensions. By this technique, large membrane protein complexes, such as the photosystem II supercomplex or the chloroplast ATP synthase, can be visualized directly in the thylakoid membrane at molecular (4-5 nm) resolution. This short review compares recent advances by cryo-ET of plant thylakoid membranes with earlier results obtained by conventional electron microscopy.     

Mitochondrial cristae narrowing upon higher 2-oxoglutarate load

Hypoxia causes mitochondrial cristae widening, enabled by the ~20% degradation of Mic60/mitofilin, with concomitant clustering of the MICOS complex, reflecting the widening of crista junctions (outlets) (Plecitá-Hlavatá et al. FASEB J., 2016 30:1941–1957). Attempting to accelerate metabolism by the addition of membrane-permeant dimethyl-2-oxoglutarate (dm2OG) to HepG2 cells pre-adapted to hypoxia, we found cristae narrowing by transmission electron microscopy. Glycolytic HepG2 cells, which downregulate hypoxic respiration, instantly increased respiration with dm2OG. Changes in intracristal space (ICS) morphology were also revealed by 3D super-resolution microscopy using Eos-conjugated ICS-located lactamase-β. Cristae topology was resolved in detail by focused-ion beam/scanning electron microscopy (FIB/SEM). The spatial relocations of key cristae-shaping proteins were indicated by immunocytochemical stochastic 3D super-resolution microscopy (dSTORM), while analyzing inter-antibody-distance histograms: i) ATP-synthase dimers exhibited a higher fraction of shorter inter-distances between bound F₁-α primary Alexa-Fluor-647-conjugated antibodies, indicating cristae narrowing. ii) Mic60/mitofilin clusters (established upon hypoxia) decayed, restoring isotropic random Mic60/mitofilin distribution (a signature of normoxia). iii) outer membrane SAMM50 formed more focused clusters. Less abundant fractions of higher ATP-synthase oligomers of hypoxic samples on blue-native electrophoresis became more abundant fractions at the high dm2OG load and at normoxia. This indicates more labile ATP-synthase dimeric rows established at crista rims upon hypoxia, strengthened at normoxia or dm2OG-substrate load. Hypothetically, the increased Krebs substrate load stimulates the cross-linking/strengthening of rows of ATP-synthase dimers at the crista rims, making them sharper. Crista narrowing ensures a more efficient coupling of proton pumping to ATP synthesis. We demonstrated that cristae morphology changes even within minutes.     

Differential protein distributions define two sub-compartments of the mitochondrial inner membrane in yeast

The mitochondrial inner membrane exhibits a complex topology. Its infolds, the cristae membranes, are contiguous with the inner boundary membrane (IBM), which runs parallel to the outer membrane. Using live cells co-expressing functional fluorescent fusion proteins, we report on the distribution of inner membrane proteins in budding yeast. To this end we introduce the enlarged mitochondria of Deltamdm10, Deltamdm31, Deltamdm32, and Deltammm1 cells as a versatile model system to study sub-mitochondrial protein localizations. Proteins of the F(1)F(0) ATP synthase and of the respiratory chain complexes III and IV were visualized in the cristae-containing interior of the mitochondria. In contrast, proteins of the TIM23 complex and of the presequence translocase-associated motor were strongly enriched at the IBM. The different protein distributions shown here demonstrate that the cristae membranes and the IBM are functionally distinct sub-compartments.     

The cristal membrane of mitochondria is the principal site of oxidative phosphorylation

The inner membrane system of mitochondria us known to consist of two contiguous but distinct membranes: the inner boundary membrane, which apposes the outer membrane, and the cristal membrane, which forms tubules or lamellae in the interior. Using immunolabeling and transmission electron microscopy of bovine heart tissue, we have calculated that around 94% of both Complex III of the respiratory chain and the ATP synthase are located in the cristal membrane, and only around 6% of either is in the inner boundary membrane. When accounting for the topographical ratio of cristal membrane versus inner boundary membrane, we find that both complexes exist at a 2.2-2.6-fold higher concentration in the cristal membrane. The residual protein in the inner boundary membrane may be newly assembled complexes destined for cristal membranes. Our results argue for restricted diffusion of complexes through the cristal junctions and indicate that the mitochondrial cristae comprise a regulated submitochondrial compartment specialized for ATP production.     

In Situ Localization of N and C Termini of Subunits of the Flagellar Nexin-Dynein Regulatory Complex (N-DRC) Using SNAP Tag and Cryo-electron Tomography

Cryo-electron tomography (cryo-ET) has reached nanoscale resolution for in situ three-dimensional imaging of macromolecular complexes and organelles. Yet its current resolution is not sufficient to precisely localize or identify most proteins in situ; for example, the location and arrangement of components of the nexin-dynein regulatory complex (N-DRC), a key regulator of ciliary/flagellar motility that is conserved from algae to humans, have remained elusive despite many cryo-ET studies of cilia and flagella. Here, we developed an in situ localization method that combines cryo-ET/subtomogram averaging with the clonable SNAP tag, a widely used cell biological probe to visualize fusion proteins by fluorescence microscopy. Using this hybrid approach, we precisely determined the locations of the N and C termini of DRC3 and the C terminus of DRC4 within the three-dimensional structure of the N-DRC in Chlamydomonas flagella. Our data demonstrate that fusion of SNAP with target proteins allowed for protein localization with high efficiency and fidelity using SNAP-linked gold nanoparticles, without disrupting the native assembly, structure, or function of the flagella. After cryo-ET and subtomogram averaging, we localized DRC3 to the L1 projection of the nexin linker, which interacts directly with a dynein motor, whereas DRC4 was observed to stretch along the N-DRC base plate to the nexin linker. Application of the technique developed here to the N-DRC revealed new insights into the organization and regulatory mechanism of this complex, and provides a valuable tool for the structural dissection of macromolecular complexes in situ.     

Three-dimensional structure of basal body triplet revealed by electron cryo-tomography

Basal bodies and centrioles play central roles in microtubule (MT)‐organizing centres within many eukaryotes. They share a barrel‐shaped cylindrical structure composed of nine MT triplet blades. Here, we report the structure of the basal body triplet at 33 Å resolution obtained by electron cryo‐tomography and 3D subtomogram averaging. By fitting the atomic structure of tubulin into the EM density, we built a pseudo‐atomic model of the tubulin protofilaments at the core of the triplet. The 3D density map reveals additional densities that represent non‐tubulin proteins attached to the triplet, including a large inner circular structure in the basal body lumen, which functions as a scaffold to stabilize the entire basal body barrel. We found clear longitudinal structural variations along the basal body, suggesting a sequential and coordinated assembly mechanism. We propose a model in which δ‐tubulin and other components participate in the assembly of the basal body.     

Structures of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation supercomplexes and mechanisms for their stabilisation

Oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) is the main source of energy in eukaryotic cells. This process is performed by means of electron flow between four enzymes, of which three are proton pumps, in the inner mitochondrial membrane. The energy accumulated in the proton gradient over the inner membrane is utilized for ATP synthesis by a fifth OXPHOS complex, ATP synthase. Four of the OXPHOS protein complexes associate into stable entities called respiratory supercomplexes. This review summarises the current view on the arrangement of the electron transport chain in mitochondrial cristae. The functional role of the supramolecular organisation of the OXPHOS system and the factors that stabilise such organisation are highlighted. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Dynamic and ultrastructure of bioenergetic membranes and their components.     

The architecture of outer dynein arms in situ

Outer dynein arms, the force generators for axonemal motion, form arrays on microtubule doublets in situ, although they are bouquet-like complexes with separated heads of multiple heavy chains when isolated in vitro. To understand how the three heavy chains are folded in the array, we reconstructed the detailed 3D structure of outer dynein arms of Chlamydomonas flagella in situ by electron cryo-tomography and single-particle averaging. The outer dynein arm binds to the A-microtubule through three interfaces on two adjacent protofilaments, two of which probably represent the docking complex. The three AAA rings of heavy chains, seen as stacked plates, are connected in a striking manner on microtubule doublets. The tail of the alpha-heavy chain, identified by analyzing the oda11 mutant, which lacks alpha-heavy chain, extends from the AAA ring tilted toward the tip of the axoneme and towards the inside of the axoneme at 50 degrees , suggesting a three-dimensional power stroke. The neighboring outer dynein arms are connected through two filamentous structures: one at the exterior of the axoneme and the other through the alpha-tail. Although the beta-tail seems to merge with the alpha-tail at the internal side of the axoneme, the gamma-tail is likely to extend at the exterior of the axoneme and join the AAA ring. This suggests that the fold and function of gamma-heavy chain are different from those of alpha and beta-chains.     

HcRed, a genetically encoded fluorescent binary cross-linking agent for cross-linking of mitochondrial ATP synthase in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Genetically encoded fluorescent cross-linking agents represent powerful tools useful both for visualising and modulating protein interactions in living cells. The far-red fluorescent protein HcRed, which is fluorescent only in a dimer form, can be used to promote the homo-dimerisation of target proteins, and thereby yield useful information about biological processes. We have in yeast cells expressed HcRed fused to a subunit of mitochondrial ATP synthase (mtATPase). This resulted in cross-linking of the large multi-subunit mtATPase complex within the inner-membrane of the mitochondrion. Fluorescence microscopy revealed aberrant mitochondrial morphology, and mtATPase complexes isolated from mitochondria were recovered as fluorescent dimers under conditions where complexes from control mitochondria were recovered as monomers. When viewed by electron microscopy normal cristae were absent from mitochondria in cells in which mATPase complexes were cross-linked. mtATPase dimers are believed to be the building blocks that are assembled into supramolecular mtATPase ribbons that promote the formation of mitochondrial cristae. We propose that HcRed cross-links mATPase complexes in the mitochondrial membrane hindering the normal assembly/disassembly of the supramolecular forms of mtATPase.     

Vaccinia virus A11 is required for membrane rupture and viral membrane assembly

Although most enveloped viruses acquire their membrane from the host by budding or by a wrapping process, collective data argue that nucleocytoplasmic large DNA viruses (NCLDVs) may be an exception. The prototype member of NCLDVs, vaccinia virus (VACV) may induce rupture of endoplasmic‐reticulum‐derived membranes to build an open‐membrane sphere that closes after DNA uptake. This unconventional membrane assembly pathway is also used by at least 3 other members of the NCLDVs. In this study, we identify the VACV gene product of A11, as required for membrane rupture, hence for VACV membrane assembly and virion formation. By electron tomography, in the absence of A11, the site of assembly formed by the viral scaffold protein D13 is surrounded by endoplasmic reticulum cisternae that are closed. We use scanning transmission electron microscopy–electron tomography to analyse large volumes of cells and demonstrate that in the absence of A11, no open membranes are detected. Given the pivotal role of D13 in initiating VACV membrane assembly, we also analyse viral membranes in the absence of D13 synthesis and show that this protein is not required for rupture. Finally, consistent with a role in rupture, we show that during wild‐type infection, A11 localises predominantly to the small ruptured membranes, the precursors of VACV membrane assembly. These data provide strong evidence in favour of the unusual membrane biogenesis of VACV and are an important step towards understanding its molecular mechanism.     

Step-by-step guide to efficient subtomogram averaging of virus-like particles with Dynamo

Subtomogram averaging (STA) is a powerful image processing technique in electron tomography used to determine the 3D structure of macromolecular complexes in their native environments. It is a fast growing technique with increasing importance in structural biology. The computational aspect of STA is very complex and depends on a large number of variables. We noticed a lack of detailed guides for STA processing. Also, current publications in this field often lack a documentation that is practical enough to reproduce the results with reasonable effort, which is necessary for the scientific community to grow. We therefore provide a complete, detailed, and fully reproducible processing protocol that covers all aspects of particle picking and particle alignment in STA. The command line–based workflow is fully based on the popular Dynamo software for STA. Within this workflow, we also demonstrate how large parts of the processing pipeline can be streamlined and automatized for increased throughput. This protocol is aimed at users on all levels. It can be used for training purposes, or it can serve as basis to design user-specific projects by taking advantage of the flexibility of Dynamo by modifying and expanding the given pipeline. The protocol is successfully validated using the Electron Microscopy Public Image Archive (EMPIAR) database entry 10164 from immature HIV-1 virus-like particles (VLPs) that describe a geometry often seen in electron tomography.

This study presents a complete and detailed step-by-step guide for subtomogram averaging using Dynamo software, with a special focus on particle picking and particle averaging; this will enable efficient processing for all experience levels, and lays a foundation for user-specific projects.