Natural DNA sequences can form left-handed helices in low salt solution under conditions of topological constraint

The conformation of DNA that originates from association of complementary single-stranded circles (form V DNA) is investigated in solution at low salt concentration. It is shown that circular dichroism extended to the far ultraviolet region (down to 165 nm) represents a powerful tool for determination of the handedness of double helical DNAs in solution. The positive intense band at 186 nm followed by a strong negative band around 170 nm is characteristic of all right-handed helical forms (B,A) of DNA, whereas the circular dichroism spectrum of the Z form of poly[d(G-C)] of opposite helical sense represents a quasi inversion of these far ultraviolet bands. Thus, form V DNA is found to represent a co-existence of left-handed Z-type and right-handed B double helical stretches in addition to negative superturns. The Raman spectrum of form V DNA provides further support for the contribution of a left-handed double helical conformation, as shown by comparison to the high resolution Raman spectra of poly[d(G-C)] in the Z and B forms.The analysis of present spectroscopic data and the analysis of occurrence of alternating [d(G-C)] purine-pyrimidine sequences in the form V DNA used strongly suggest that in DNA of natural sequence, topological constraint may generate left-handed double helices, a conformation thought so far to be limited to the alternating [d(G-C)] sequences. Such structure could play a role in recognition and regulation of gene expression.     

Z-DNA crystallography

We review the effect of sequence on the structure of left-handed Z-DNA in single crystals. The various substituent groups that define a nucleotide base as guanine, cytosine, thymine, or adenine affect both the DNA conformation and the organization of solvent around the duplex. These are discussed in terms of their effect on the ability of sequences to adopt the unusual Z-DNA structure. In addition, the experimental and theoretical methods used to treat DNA hydration are discussed as they relate to the stability of Z-DNA. Finally, we argue that Z-DNA, as defined by the crystal conformation, is sufficient in itself to account for the physical properties of left-handed conformations observed in polymers and in genomic sequences. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biopoly 44: 65–90, 1997     

Theoretical prediction of base sequence effects in DNA. Experimental reactivity of Z-DNA and B-Z transition enthalpies

Molecular modeling is used to study the sequence dependence of conformation and stability within helically regular duplex Z-DNA. The variations of conformation that are found are sufficiently important to be classified as a new type of polymorphism within the Z family. It is also demonstrated that certain sequences can adopt more than one of these polymorphic forms. Comparison with experimental studies of chemical reactivity within a natural DNA fragment, forced into a left-handed conformation, suggests that the results of our modeling may be used to explain the chemical reactivity observed. Comparison of the Z results with similar studies of the B form allow enthalpies of transition to be calculated as a function of base sequence.     

Anti-Syn Conformational Range of Pyrimidines with Deoxyribofuranose

Abstract

The ability of pyrimidine bases to adopt the syn conformation in DNA has been investigated. The distances between atoms on the sugar and base and the resulting steric energies have been calculated as a function of glycosidic torsion angle for the principal sugar puckers of the deoxyribose of cytosine. The results indicate that pyrimidines can assume both the anti and syn conformations for the ³E, ₄E, ₁E, ²E, ₃E sugar puckers and syn for the ₂E sugar pucker. For these sugar puckers the difference between the minimum energies of the anti and syn conformations is in the range of 0.1–2.0 kcal/mole, with the minimum syn energy being lower in the case of the ₄E, ₁E and ²E sugar puckers. It is particularly significant that cytosine can assume the syn conformation for the ³E sugar pucker commonly observed for the syn nucleotides in Z-DNA with both alternating pyrimidine/purine (APP) and non-APP sequences. The results of this investigation confirm that steric interactions resulting from putting a pyrimidine nucleotide in the syn conformation are not a major factor in the preference for APP base sequences in Z-DNA.     

Left handed DNA in synthetic and topologically constrained form V DNA and its implications in protein recognition

We have investigated structural transitions in Poly(dG-dC) and Poly(dG-Me⁵dC) in order to understand the exact role of cations in stabilizing left-handed helical structures in specific sequences andthe biological role, if any, of these structures. From a novel temperature dependent Z ⇌ B transition it has been shown that a minor fluctuation in Na⁺ concentration at ambient temperature can bring about B to Z transition. Forthe first time, wehave observed a novel Z⇌B⇌Zuble transition in poly(dG-Me⁵dC) as the Na⁺ concentration is gradually increased. This suggests that a minor fluctuation in Na⁺ concentration in conjunction with methylation may transform small stretches of CG sequences from one conformational state to another. These stretches could probably serve as sites for regulation. Supercoiled formV DNA reconstituted from pBR322 and pβG plasmids have been studied as model systems, in order to understand the nature and role of left-handed helical conformation in natural sequences. A large portion of DNA in form V, obtained by reannealing the two complementary singlestranded circles is forced to adopt left-handed double helical structure due to topological constraints (L _k = 0). Binding studies with Z-DNA specific antibody and spectroscopic studies confirm the presence of left-handed Z-structure in the pβG and pβR322 form V DNA. Cobalt hexamine chloride, which induces Z-form in Poly(dG-dC) stabilizes the Z-conformation in form V DNA even in the non-alternating purine-pyrimidine sequences. A reverse effect is observed with ethidium bromide. Interestingly, both topoisomerase I and II (from wheat germ) act effectively on form V DNA to give rise to a species having an electrophoretic mobility on agarose gel similar to that of open circular (form II) DNA. Whether this molecule is formed as a result of the left-handed helical segments of form V DNA undergoing a transition to the right-handed B-form during the topoisomerase action remains to be solved.     

The structure of a full turn of an A-DNA duplex d(CGCGGGTACCCGCG)2

We report the 2.6 Å resolution crystal structure of the tetra-decamer d(CGCGGGTACCCGCG) in the tetragonal space group P4₃. This sequence contains the KpnI restriction site GGTACC in the centre which is flanked by alternating ‘CG’ sequences, and has a ‘TA’ step at the centre. These are features could favour the left-handed Z type helix. Despite this, overall the molecule has the A form. This is the first tetra-decamer crystallized in the A-DNA conformation, i.e. more than one full turn of the A helix. The crystallographic asymmetric unit consists of one tetra-decamer duplex. The helical twist and slide, as well as the base pair–base pair stacking interactions show alternations at the alternating pyrimidine–purine and purine–pyrimidine base steps. This variation is reminiscent of the dinucleotide repeat in left-handed Z-DNA helices. The crystal packing is unlike other A-DNA crystal structures, with each helix having a large number of contacts of many different types with symmetry-related neighbours.     

Interaction of the Zalpha domain of human ADAR1 with a negatively supercoiled plasmid visualized by atomic force microscopy

Interest to the left-handed DNA conformation has been recently boosted by the findings that a number of proteins contain the Zα domain, which has been shown to specifically recognize Z-DNA. The biological function of Zα is presently unknown, but it has been suggested that it may specifically direct protein regions of Z-DNA induced by negative supercoiling in actively transcribing genes. Many studies, including a crystal structure in complex with Z-DNA, have focused on the human ADAR1 Zα domain in isolation. We have hypothesized that the recognition of a Z-DNA sequence by the Zα_ADAR1 domain is context specific, occurring under energetic conditions, which favor Z-DNA formation. To test this hypothesis, we have applied atomic force microscopy to image Zα_ADAR1 complexed with supercoiled plasmid DNAs. We have demonstrated that the Zα_ADAR1 binds specifically to Z-DNA and preferentially to d(CG)_n inserts, which require less energy for Z-DNA induction compared to other sequences. A notable finding is that site-specific Zα binding to d(GC)₁₃ or d(GC)₂C(GC)₁₀ inserts is observed when DNA supercoiling is insufficient to induce Z-DNA formation. These results indicate that Zα_ADAR1 binding facilities the B-to-Z transition and provides additional support to the model that Z-DNA binding proteins may regulate biological processes through structure-specific recognition.     

Interaction between the Z-type DNA duplex and 1,3-propanediamine: crystal structure of d(CACGTG)2 at 1.2 A resolution

The crystal structure of a hexamer duplex d(CACGTG)(2) has been determined and refined to an R-factor of 18.3% using X-ray data up to 1.2 A resolution. The sequence crystallizes as a left-handed Z-form double helix with Watson-Crick base pairing. There is one hexamer duplex, a spermine molecule, 71 water molecules, and an unexpected diamine (Z-5, 1,3-propanediamine, C(3)H(10)N(2)) in the asymmetric unit. This is the high-resolution non-disordered structure of a Z-DNA hexamer containing two AT base pairs in the interior of a duplex with no modifications such as bromination or methylation on cytosine bases. This structure does not possess multivalent cations such as cobalt hexaammine that are known to stabilize Z-DNA. The overall duplex structure and its crystal interactions are similar to those of the pure-spermine form of the d(CGCGCG)(2) structure. The spine of hydration in the minor groove is intact except in the vicinity of the T5A8 base pair. The binding of the Z-5 molecule in the minor grove of the d(CACGTG)(2) duplex appears to have a profound effect in conferring stability to a Z-DNA conformation via electrostatic complementarity and hydrogen bonding interactions. The successive base stacking geometry in d(CACGTG)(2) is similar to the corresponding steps in d(CG)(3). These results suggest that specific polyamines such as Z-5 could serve as powerful inducers of Z-type conformation in unmodified DNA sequences with AT base pairs. This structure provides a molecular basis for stabilizing AT base pairs incorporated into an alternating d(CG) sequence.     

A computer aided thermodynamic approach for predicting the formation of Z-DNA in naturally occurring sequences.

The ease with which a particular DNA segment adopts the left-handed Z-conformation depends largely on the sequence and on the degree of negative supercoiling to which it is subjected. We describe a computer program (Z-hunt) that is designed to search long sequences of naturally occurring DNA and retrieve those nucleotide combinations of up to 24 bp in length which show a strong propensity for Z-DNA formation. Incorporated into Z-hunt is a statistical mechanical model based on empirically determined energetic parameters for the B to Z transition accumulated to date. The Z-forming potential of a sequence is assessed by ranking its behavior as a function of negative superhelicity relative to the behavior of similar sized randomly generated nucleotide sequences assembled from over 80,000 combinations. The program makes it possible to compare directly the Z-forming potential of sequences with different base compositions and different sequence lengths. Using Z-hunt, we have analyzed the DNA sequences of the bacteriophage phi X174, plasmid pBR322, the animal virus SV40 and the replicative form of the eukaryotic adenovirus-2. The results are compared with those previously obtained by others from experiments designed to locate Z-DNA forming regions in these sequences using probes which show specificity for the left-handed DNA conformation.     

In vivo assessment of the Z-DNA-forming potential of d(CA.GT)n and d(CG.GC)n sequences cloned into SV40 minichromosomes

Alternating repeated d(CA.GT)n and d(CG.GC)n sequences constitute a significant proportion of the simple repeating elements found in eukaryotic genomic DNA. These sequences are known to form left-handed Z-DNA in vitro. In this paper, we have addressed the question of the in vivo determination of the Z-DNA-forming potential of such sequences in eukaryotic chromatin. For this purpose, we have investigated the ability of a d(CA.GT)30 sequence and a d(CG.GC)5 sequence to form left-handed Z-DNA when cloned into simian virus 40 (SV40) minichromosomes at two different positions: the TaqI site, which occurs in the intron of the T-antigen gene, and the HpaII site, which is located in the late promoter region within the SV40 control region. Formation of Z-DNA at the inserted repeated sequences was analyzed through the change in DNA linkage associated with the B to Z transition. Our results indicate that regardless of: (1) the site of insertion (either TaqI or HpaII), (2) the precise moment of the viral lytic cycle (from 12 h to 48 h postinfection) and (3) the condition of incorporation of the SV40 recombinants to the host cells (either as minichromosomes or as naked DNA, relaxed or negatively supercoiled), neither the d(CA.GT)30 nor the d(CG.GC)5 sequence are stable in the left-handed Z-DNA conformation in the SV40 minichromosome. The biological relevance of these results is discussed.     

Underwound loops in self-renatured DNA can be diagnostic of inverted duplications and translocated sequences

DNA that contains inverted duplications separated by non-inverted sequences often can form characteristic “underwound loops” when it is denatured and reannealed. An underwound loop is a partially double-stranded, partially denatured segment between the inverted duplications and is produced as follows. During the early stages of the reannealing, intrastrand stem-loop structures form with first-order kinetics when the inverted duplications pair. In a slower second-order reaction, complementary strands (each with a stem-loop) reanneal. The stem-loop structures produce a cruciform in the hybrid. Because of the unpaired sequences in the loop, the cruciform is unstable. It can isomerize to a linear duplex by double-strand exchange of complementary sequences in the stems. This process requires co-ordinated axial rotation of the stems and the flanking duplexes as well as rotation of the loops. If, however, complementary sequences in the loops start to pair, axial rotation is prevented and the stem-loop structures are trapped in a metastable state. The strands of separate, closed rings cannot interwind when they pair. Consequently, the loops observed by electron microscopy have variable patterns of single-stranded denaturation bubbles and duplex segments with both right-handed and left-handed winding.We have used underwound loops to identify a short inverted duplication flanking the γδ recombination sequence of Escherichia coli F factor (isolated on φ80 d₃ilv⁺ transducing phage) and to study DNA from phages Mu and P1 in which the G segments are flanked by inverted duplications. When deproteinized adenovirus-2 DNA was denatured and reannealed, some underwound circles the length of the entire chromosome were observed by electron microscopy. These resulted from the restricted interaction of complementary single-stranded rings generated when pairing of the short inverted terminal duplications closed the ends of single strands. Another type of underwound loop was seen in heteroduplexes containing complementary insertion loops located at different positions in the hybridized strands, such as occurs with P1 cam DNAs. All these underwound structures are similar in appearance to the hybrids formed when topologically separate, complementary single-stranded circles of Colicin E₁ DNA were allowed to anneal.     

Antibodies to DNA

Antibodies that recognize specific conformational variations of DNA structure provide sensitive reagents for testing the extent to which such conformational heterogeneity occurs in nature. A most dramatic recent example has been the development and application of antibodies to left-handed Z-DNA. They provided the first identification of Z-DNA in fixed nuclei and chromosomes, and of DNA sequences that form Z-DNA under the influence of supercoiling. Antibodies have also been induced by chemically modified DNA and by synthetic polydeoxyribonucleotides that differ from the average B-DNA structure. These antibodies recognize only the features that differ from native DNA. In most experiments, native DNA itself is not immunogenic. Antibodies that do react with native DNA occur in sera of patients with autoimmune disease, but even monoclonal anti-DNA autoantibodies usually react with other polynucleotides as well. Anti-DNA antibodies, especially those of monoclonal origin, provide a model for the study of protein-nucleic acid recognition.     

Recognition of left-handed Z-DNA of short unmodified oligonucleotides under physiological ionic strength conditions

The left-handed Z-DNA form of the short unmodified alternating guanine-cytosine oligonucleotides, 5′-(dGdC)₂₄ and 5′-(dGdC)₁₈, was selectively detected under physiological ionic strength and pH conditions using the anionic nickel(II) porphyrin, NiTPPS. No spectroscopic signal was observed for NiTPPS with any right-handed oligonucleotides under identical conditions. The 48mer 5′-(dGdC)₂₄ Z-form was detected at concentrations as low as 100 nM. The binding of NiTPPS to the B- and Z-oligonucleotides was studied quantitatively by UV-vis absorption and circular dichroism spectroscopies. NiTPPS was found to be a universal DNA binder, with binding affinity and geometry depending on the ionic composition of the solution, rather than on the DNA helical twist. This is the first example of a successful spectroscopic detection of the Z-DNA of short unmodified oligonucleotides under physiological pH and ionic strength conditions.     

Supercoiled induced transition to the Z-DNA conformation affects the ability of a d(CG/GC)12 sequence to be organized into nucleosome-cores.

Nucleosome-cores were reconstituted by the salt-dialysis method onto closed circular pDHg16 DNA which contains a d(CG/GC)12 sequence. Alternating d(CG/GC)n sequences form left-handed Z-DNA readily when contained in negatively supercoiled DNA. We have investigated the ability of the d(CG/GC)12 sequence to be organized into nucleosome-cores when stabilized as Z-DNA through negative supercoiling. We have found that nucleosome assembly at the d(CG/GC)12 insert is prevented when the sequence is stable in the Z-conformation but it is not affected at all when the sequence adopts the right-handed B-form.     

Chemical detection of Z-DNA within the maize Adh1 promoter

Z-DNA is a left-handed helix which can form within tracts of alternating purines and pyrimidines. Tracts of potential Z-DNA identified by sequence inspection are often noted within regulatory portions of genes, but evidence that these tracts of sequence actually exist as Z-DNA is very limited, and not available for any plant gene. In this study, the chemical probes osmium tetroxide, diethylpyrocarbonate and hydroxylamine were used to show that a tract of alternating purines and pyrimidines in the Adh1 promoter (from -311 to -325) actually assumes a Z-DNA conformation under superhelical stress in vitro.     

Parallel-Stranded DNA with Natural Base Sequences

Noncanonical parallel-stranded DNA double helices (ps-DNA) of natural nucleotide sequences are usually less stable than the canonical antiparallel-stranded DNA structures, which ensures reliable cell functioning. However, recent data indicate a possible role of ps-DNA in DNA loops or in regions of trinucleotide repeats connected with neurodegenerative diseases. The review surveys recent studies on the effect of nucleotide sequence on preference of one or other type of DNA duplex. (1) Ps-DNA of mixed AT/GC composition was found to have conformational and thermodynamic properties drastically different from those of a Watson–Crick double helix. Its stability depends strongly on the specific sequence in a manner peculiar to the ps double helix, because of the energy disadvantage of the AT/GC contacts. The AT/GC boundary facilitated flipping of A and T out of the ps double helix. Proton acceptor groups of bases are exposed into both grooves of the ps-DNA and are accessible to solvent and ligands, including proteins. (2) DNA regions containing natural minor bases isoguanine and isomethylisocytosine were shown to form ps-DNA with transAT-, trans isoGC, and transiso^5meCG pairs exceeding in stability a related canonical duplex. (3) Nucleotide sequence dG(GT)₄G from yeast telomeres and microsatellites was demonstrated to form novel ps-DNA with GG and TT base pairing. Unlike d(GT) _n - and d(G _n T _m ) sequences able to form quadruplexes, the dG(GT)₄G sequence formed no alternative double- or multistranded structures in a wide range of experimental conditions, thus suggesting that the nucleotide context governs the observed structural polymorphism of the d(GT) _n sequence. The possible biological role of ps-DNA and the prospects of its study are discussed.