Recombination of S-peptide with S-protein during folding of ribonuclease S. II. Kinetic characterization of a stable folding intermediate shown by S-protein at pH 1.7.

At pH 1.7 S-peptide dissociates from S-protein but S-protein remains partly folded below 30 °C. A folded form of S-protein, labeled I₃, is detected and measured by its ability to combine rapidly with S-peptide at pH 6.8 and then to form native ribonuclease S. The second-order combination reaction (k = 0.7 × 10⁶m^?1s^?1 at 20 °C) can be monitored either by tyrosine absorbance or fluorescence emission; the subsequent first-order folding reaction (half-time, 68 ms; 20 °C) is monitored by 2′CMP ² binding. Combination with S-peptide and folding to form native RNAase S is considerably slower for both classes of unfolded S-protein (see preceding paper).I₃ shows a thermal folding transition at pH 1.7: it is completely unfolded above 32 °C and reaches a limiting low-temperature value of 65% below 10 °C. The 35% S-protein remaining at 10 °C is unfolded as judged by its refolding behavior in forming native RNAase S at pH 6.8. The folding transition of S-protein at pH 1.7 is a broad, multi-state transition. This is shown both by the large fraction of unfolded S-protein remaining at low temperatures and by the large differences between the folding transition curves monitored by I₃ and by tyrosine absorbance.The fact that S-protein remains partly folded after dissociation of S-peptide at pH 1.7 but not at pH 6.8 may be explained by two earlier observations. (1) Native RNAase A is stable in the temperature range of the S-protein folding transition at pH 1.7, and (2) the binding constant of S-protein for S-peptide falls steadily as the pH is lowered, by more than four orders of magnitude between pH 8.3 and pH 2.7, at 0 °C. The following explanation is suggested for why folding intermediates are observed easily in the transition of S-protein but not of RNAase A. The S-protein transition is shifted to lower temperatures, where folding intermediates should be more stable: consequently, intermediates in the folding of RNAase A which do not involve the S-peptide moiety and which are populated to almost detectable levels can be observed at the lower temperatures of the S-protein transition.     

Low-temperature 1H-NMR evidence of the folding of isolated ribonuclease S-peptide

The temperature (-7 degrees C to 45 degrees C, pH 5.4) and pH (0 degrees C) dependence of 1H chemical shifts of ribonuclease S-peptide (5 mM, 1 M NaCl) has been measured at 360 MHz. The observed variations evidence the formation of a partial helical structure, involving the fragment Thr-3-Met-13. Two salt-bridges stabilize the helix: those formed by Glu-9- ...His-12+ and Glu-2- ...Arg-10+. The structural features deduced from the 1H-NMR at low temperature for the isolated S-peptide are compatible with the structure shown by the same molecule in the ribonuclease S crystal.     

15N backbone dynamics of the S-peptide from ribonuclease A in its free and S-protein bound forms: toward a site-specific analysis of entropy changes upon folding.

Backbone 15N relaxation parameters (R1, R2, 1H-15N NOE) have been measured for a 22-residue recombinant variant of the S-peptide in its free and S-protein bound forms. NMR relaxation data were analyzed using the "model-free" approach (Lipari & Szabo, 1982). Order parameters obtained from "model-free" simulations were used to calculate 1H-15N bond vector entropies using a recently described method (Yang & Kay, 1996), in which the form of the probability density function for bond vector fluctuations is derived from a diffusion-in-a-cone motional model. The average change in 1H-15N bond vector entropies for residues T3-S15, which become ordered upon binding of the S-peptide to the S-protein, is -12.6+/-1.4 J/mol.residue.K. 15N relaxation data suggest a gradient of decreasing entropy values moving from the termini toward the center of the free peptide. The difference between the entropies of the terminal and central residues is about -12 J/mol residue K, a value comparable to that of the average entropy change per residue upon complex formation. Similar entropy gradients are evident in NMR relaxation studies of other denatured proteins. Taken together, these observations suggest denatured proteins may contain entropic contributions from non-local interactions. Consequently, calculations that model the entropy of a residue in a denatured protein as that of a residue in a di- or tri-peptide, might over-estimate the magnitude of entropy changes upon folding.     

Concentration-dependent hydrogen exchange kinetics of 3H-labeled S-peptide in ribonuclease S.

The hydrogen exchange kinetics of the S-peptide in ribonuclease S can be measured by first tritiating the S-peptide in the absence of S-protein and then allowing it to recombine rapidly with S-protein. Afterwards the exchange reactions of this specific segment of ribonuclease S can be studied. The exchange kinetics of bound S-peptide are complex, indicating that different protons exchange at markedly different rates. The terminal exchange reaction, involving at least five highly protected protons, has been studied as a function of pH.At low concentrations of ribonuclease S the exchange kinetics become concentration-dependent, owing to the dissociation of the S-peptide. Although the fraction of free S-peptide is always very small, its rate of exchange is several orders of magnitude faster than that of bound S-peptide, and the concentration dependence of the exchange kinetics is readily measurable. It provides a highly sensitive method for determining small dissociation constants (K_D). Values of K_D ranging from 10^?6m at pH 2.7, 0 °C, to 2 × 10^?10m at pH 7.0, 0 °C, are reported here. Our value for K_D at pH 7.0, 0 °C, confirms the data and extrapolation to 0 °C of Hearn et al. (1971).At high concentrations of ribonuclease S the terminal exchange reaction is independent of concentration. It probably results from a local unfolding reaction of the bound S-peptide. Above pH 4 the strong pH dependence of K_D closely resembles that of the apparent equilibrium constant for this local unfolding reaction. The latter may be one step in the dissociation process and we present such a model for ribonuclease S dissociation.Measurement of concentration-dependent exchange kinetics should provide a useful method of determining small dissociation constants in other systems: for example, in studies of protein-nucleic acid interactions.     

Nuclear-magnetic-resonance study of the histidine residues of S-peptide and S-protein and kinetics of 1H-2H exchange of ribonuclease A.

1H NMR spectroscopy at 100 MHz was used to determine the first-order rate constants for the 1H-2H exchange of the H-2 histidine resonances of RNase-A in 2H2O at 35 degrees C and pH meter readings of 7, 9, 10 and 10.5. Prolonged exposure in 2H2O at 35 degrees C and pH meter reading 11 caused irreversible denaturation of RN-ase-A. The rate constants at pH 7 and 9 agreed reasonably well with those obtained in 1H-3H exchange experiments by Ohe, J., Matsuo, H., Sakiyama, F. and Narita, K. [J. Biochem, (Tokyo) 75, 1197-1200 (1974)]. The rate data obtained by various authors is summarised and the reasons for the poor agreement between the data is discussed. The first-order rate constant for the exchange of His-48 increases rapidly from near zero at pH 9 (due to its inaccessibility to solvent) with increase of pH to 10.5 The corresponding values for His-119 show a decrease and those for His-12 a small increase over the same pH range. These changes are attributed to a conformational change in the hinge region of RNase-A (probably due to the titration of Tyr-25) which allows His-48 to become accessible to solvent. 1H NMR spectra of S-protein and S-peptide, and of material partially deuterated at the C-2 positions of the histidine residues confirm the reassignment of the histidine resonances of RNase-A [Bradbury, J. H. & Teh, J. S. (1975) Chem. Commun., 936-937]. The chemical shifts of the C-2 and C-4 protons of histidine-12 of S-peptide are followed as a function of pH and a pK' value of 6.75 is obtained. The reassignment of the three C-2 histidine resonances of S-protein is confirmed by partial deuteration studies. The pK' values obtained from titration of the H-2 resonances of His-48, His-105 and His-119 are 5.3, 6.5 and 6.0, respectively. The S-protein is less stable to acid than RNase-A since the former, but not the latter, shows evidence of reversible denaturation at pH 3 and 26 degrees C. His-48 in S-protein titrates normally and has a lower pK than in RN-ase-A probably because of the absence of Asp-14, which in RN-ase-A forms a a hydrogen bond with His-48 and causes it to be inaccessible to solvent, at pH values below 9.     

Kinetic coupling between protein folding and prolyl isomerization. II. Folding of ribonuclease A and ribonuclease T1.

The folding and unfolding kinetics within the transition region were measured for RNase A and for RNase T1. The data were used to evaluate the theoretical models for the influence of prolyl isomerization on the observed folding kinetics. These two proteins were selected, since the folding reaction of RNase A is faster than prolyl isomerization, whereas in RNase T1, folding is slower than isomerization in the transition region. Folding of RNase T1 was investigated for three variants with different numbers of cis prolyl residues. The results indicate that in the transition region the folding rates are indeed strongly dependent on the number of prolyl residues. The variant of RNase T1 that contains only one cis prolyl residue folds about ten times faster than two variants that contain two cis prolyl residues. For both RNase A and RNase T1, the apparent rates of folding and unfolding as well as the corresponding amplitudes depend on the concentration of denaturant in a manner that was predicted by the model calculations. When refolding was started from the fast-folding species, additional kinetic phases could be observed in the transition region for both proteins. The obtained values could be used to calculate the microscopic rate constants of folding and isomerization on the basis of theoretical models.     

Folding of ribonuclease T1. 2. Kinetic models for the folding and unfolding reactions

The slow refolding of ribonuclease T1 was investigated by different probes. Structural intermediates with secondary structure are formed early during refolding, as indicated by the rapid regain of a native-like circular dichroism spectrum in the amide region. This extensive structure formation is much faster than the slow steps of refolding, which are limited in rate by the reisomerization of incorrect proline isomers. The transient folding intermediates were also detected by unfolding assays, which make use of the reduced stability of folding intermediates relative to that of the native protein. The results of this and the preceding paper [Kiefhaber et al. (1990) Biochemistry (preceding paper in this issue)] were used to propose kinetic models for the unfolding and refolding of ribonuclease T1. The unfolding mechanism is based on the assumption that, after the structural unfolding step, the slow isomerizations of two X-Pro peptide bonds occur independently of each other in the denatured protein. At equilibrium a small amount of fast-folding species coexists with three slow-folding species: two with one incorrect proline isomer each and another, dominant species with both these prolines in the incorrect isomeric state. In the mechanism for refolding we assume that all slow-folding molecules can rapidly regain most of the secondary and part of the tertiary structure early in folding. Reisomerizations of incorrect proline peptide bonds constitute the slow, rate-limiting steps of refolding. A peculiar feature of the kinetic model for refolding is that the major unfolded species with two incorrect proline isomers can enter two alternative folding pathways, depending on which of the two reisomerizes first. The relative rates of reisomerization of the respective proline peptide bonds at the stage of the rapidly formed intermediate determine the choice of pathway. It is changed in the presence of prolyl isomerase, because this enzyme catalyzes these two isomerizations with different efficiency and consequently leads to a shift from the very slow to the intermediate refolding pathway.     

Folding of ribonuclease T1. 1. Existence of multiple unfolded states created by proline isomerization

It is our aim to elucidate molecular aspects of the mechanism of protein folding. We use ribonuclease T1 as a model protein, because it is a small single-domain protein with a well-defined secondary and tertiary structure, which is stable in the presence and absence of disulfide bonds. Also, an efficient mutagenesis system is available to produce protein molecules with defined sequence variations. Here we present a preliminary characterization of the folding kinetics of ribonuclease T1. Its unfolding and refolding reactions are reversible, which is shown by the quantitative recovery of the catalytic activity after an unfolding/refolding cycle. Refolding is a complex process, where native protein is formed on three distinguishable pathways. There are 3.5% fast-folding molecules, which refold within the millisecond time range, and 96.5% slow-folding species, which regain the native state in the time range of minutes to hours. These slow-folding molecules give rise to two major, parallel refolding reactions. The mixture of fast- and slow-folding molecules is produced slowly after unfolding by chain equilibration reactions that show properties of proline isomerization. We conclude that part of the kinetic complexity of RNase T1 folding can be explained on the basis of the proline model for protein folding. This is supported by the finding that the slow refolding reactions of this protein are accelerated in the presence of the enzyme prolyl isomerase. However, several properties of ribonuclease T1 refolding, such as the dependence of the relative amplitudes on the probes, used to follow folding, are not readily explained by a simple proline model.     

Conformational properties of the N-terminal residues of S-peptide. I. The ribonuclease S′ system

The contribution of the 1–6 N-terminal sequence to the conformational properties of the S-peptide (the 1–20 sequence of ribonuclease A) was assessed by determining in the ribonuclease S′ system the helical content and the binding capability of synthetic [Orn¹⁰]-S-peptide analogs, in which lysine¹, glutamic² and threonine³ were progressively deleted, alanine⁴ and alanine⁵were alternatively replaced by serine, and alanine⁶ was substituted by serine or proline. Both the deletion of the three N-terminal residues and the alanine⁶/proline replacement produces the loss of the helical structure up to lysine⁷. No or minor effects are found in all other cases. From the comparison of the binding data, the energy for the conformational stabilization of the N-terminal region was calculated to amount to 1.4 kcal/mol. The results are discussed in comparison with the known x-ray data of the enzyme, with some predictive rules of secondary structure which were applied to this region and with the known phylogenetic variance of the residues in this region.     

Hydrogen exchange from identified regions of the S-protein component of ribonuclease as a function of temperature,pH, and the binding of S-peptide

A medium resolution hydrogen exchange method (Rosa & Richards, 1979) has been used to measure the average rates of amide hydrogen exchange for known segments of the S-protein portion of ribonuclease-S. The analytical procedure permitted exchange rates to be monitored for seven S-protein fragments distributed throughout the structure, including regions of α-helix and β-sheet. Kinetics were measured as a function of pH, temperature and S-peptide binding.The pH dependence of exchange from isolated S-protein between pH 2·8 and pH 7·0 was found to deviate significantly from a first-order dependence on hydroxide ion concentration. The protection against exchange with increasing pH appeared to be closely related to the electrostatic stabilization of S-protein. It is suggested that such favorable electrostatic interactions result in increased energy barriers to the conformational fluctuations that provide solvent access to the time-average crystallographic structure. This explanation of the observed correlation between stability and exchange kinetics is also consistent with the calculated apparent activation energies for exchange from S-protein between 5·5 and 20 °C.S-peptide binding dramatically slows exchange from many S-protein sites, even those distant from the area of S-peptide contact. Interestingly, the effects of complex formation are not evenly propagated throughout S-protein. The most significantly perturbed sites (≥10³-fold reduction in exchange rate constants) lie within fragments derived from regions of secondary structure. Exchange from several other fragments is not significantly affected. The S-peptide—S-protein dissociation constant at neutral pH is so small that the measured exchange must have occurred from the complex and not from the dissociated parts.     

Intermediates in the refolding of ribonuclease at subzero temperatures. 3. Multiple folding pathways

The kinetics of refolding of ribonuclease A have been measured at -15 degrees C by monitoring the intrinsic fluorescence and absorbance signals from the six tyrosine residues. For each probe multiphasic kinetics were observed. The burial of tyrosine residues, as determined by the change in absorbance at 286 nm, revealed four phases, whereas the kinetics of refolding monitored by fluorescence revealed only two phases. The rates of the transients detected by fluorescence were independent of pH. One of the faster transients detected by delta A286 involved a decrease in absorbance, which is consistent with solvent exposure, rather than burial, and suggests the possibility of an abortive partially folded intermediate in the earlier stages of folding. Double-jump unfolding assays were used to follow the buildup and decay of an intermediate in the refolding reaction at -15 degrees C. At both pH* 3.0 and pH* 6.0 the maximum concentration of the intermediate was 25-30% of the total protein. The existence of a second pathway of slow folding was inferred from the difference in rate of formation of native enzyme and breakdown of the observed intermediate, and by computer simulations. In addition, the unfolding assay demonstrated that 20% of the unfolded protein was converted to native at a much faster rate, consistent with observations in aqueous solution that 80% of unfolded ribonuclease A consists of slow-folding species. Kinetics and amplitude data from these and other refolding experiments with different probes were used to develop possible models for the pathway of refolding. The simplest system consistent with the results for the slow-refolding species involves two parallel pathways with multiple intermediates on each of them. Several independent lines of evidence indicate that about 30% of the unfolded state refolds by the minor pathway, in which the slowest observed phase is attributed to the isomerization of Pro-93. The major pathway involves 50% of the unfolded state; the reason why it refolds slowly is not apparent. A native-like intermediate is formed considerably more rapidly in the major slow-refolding pathway, compared to the minor pathway.