Clonal analysis of the late stages of erythroleukemia induced by two distinct strains of Friend leukemia virus.

We observed striking differences between the tumorigenic colony-forming cells present in the spleens of mice late after infection with the anemia-inducing strain of Friend leukemia virus (strain FV-A) and those present after infection with the polycythemia-inducing strain (strain FV-P). Cells within primary colonies derived from FV-A- and FV-P-transformed cells (CFU-FV-A and CFU-FV-P, respectively) contained hemoglobin and spectrin, indicating that the CFU-FV-A and CFU-FV-P were transformed erythroid progenitor cells. The proportion of cells containing hemoglobin was relatively high (> 25%) in newly isolated cell lines derived from CFU-FV-P colonies, whereas cell lines derived from CFU-FV-A colonies had only low levels (0 to 2%) of hemoglobin-containing cells. A high proportion of the cell lines derived from CFU-FV-A colonies responded to pure erythropoietin and accumulated spectrin and hemoglobin, whereas the cell lines derived from CFU-FV-P colonies did not. A cytogenetic analysis indicated that primary CFU-FV-P colony cells were diploid, whereas chromosomal aberrations were observed in the immediate progeny of CFU-FV-A. The presence of unique chromosomal markers in the majority of the cells within individual colonies derived from CFU-FV-A suggested that these colonies originated from single cells. Finally, leukemic progenitor cells transformed by strain FV-A appeared to have an extensive capacity to self-renew (i.e., form secondary colonies in methylcellulose), whereas a significant proportion of the corresponding cells transformed by strain FV-P did not. In addition, the self-renewal capacity of both CFU-FV-A and CFU-FV-P increased as the disease progressed. From these observations, we propose a model for the multistage nature of Friend disease; this model involves clonal evolution and expansion from a differentiating population with limited proliferative capacity to a population with a high capacity for self-renewal and proliferation.     

Crucial role of phosphatase CD45 in determining signaling and proliferation of human myeloma cells

In multiple myeloma, a large number of growth factors (IL-6, IGF-1, FGF, HGF and HB-EGF) are involved in promoting myeloma cell growth. In the present study, a serum-free, cytokine-free, collagen-based assay, which does not allow the generation of spontaneous myeloma colonies, was used to identify the clonogenic growth factors for fourteen myeloma cell lines. IL-6 is the only clonogenic factor able to stimulate both CD45+ and CD45- myeloma cell lines, generating myeloma colonies from 10 out of 14 myeloma cell lines. Using a pharmacological Erk inhibitor, we show that the Erk/MAPK pathway is involved in IL-6-induced clonogenicity of CD45+, but not CD45- myeloma cell lines. In contrast to IL-6, the other growth factors (IGF-1, FGF, HGF and HB-EGF) stimulate only some myeloma cell lines, but always CD45-, and less effectively than IL-6. Among them, IGF-1 is the most potent, generating myeloma colonies from five out of eight CD45- myeloma cell lines. Finally, the capacity of IGF-1 and FGF to stimulate the clonogenicity of CD45- myeloma cells correlates with their ability to stimulate the Erk/MAPK pathway. We conclude that CD45 expression plays a crucial role in determining signaling and proliferation of human myeloma cell responses to IL-6, IGF-1 and other growth factors. The poor outcome of CD45- myeloma patients could be related to the capacity of CD45-myeloma cells to take advantage of multiple growth factors.     

A kinetic and clonal analysis of heterogeneity in K562 cells

Expression of markers of differentiation was measured in a clone of the continuous cell line K562, derived originally from the cells of a patient with leukemia. Three of the markers were lineage specific, R18 for erythropoiesis and 80H.5 and My-1 for granulopoiesis. The fourth marker was the self-renewal capacity of clonogenic cells. The markers were measured as a function of time in pooled colonies from day 2 to day 12, and at a point of time in individual colonies. Evidence of an orderly pattern of marker appearance and disappearance was not seen. Rather, their expression appeared to occur at random during growth.     

Clonogenicity of human endometrial epithelial and stromal cells

The human endometrium regenerates from the lower basalis layer, a germinal compartment that persists after menstruation to give rise to the new upper functionalis layer. Because adult stem cells are present in tissues that undergo regeneration, we hypothesized that human endometrium contains small populations of epithelial and stromal stem cells responsible for cyclical regeneration of endometrial glands and stroma and that these cells would exhibit clonogenicity, a stem-cell property. The aims of this study were to determine 1) the clonogenic activity of human endometrial epithelial and stromal cells, 2) which growth factors support this clonogenic activity, and 3) determine the cellular phenotypes of the clones. Endometrial tissue was obtained from women undergoing hysterectomy. Purified single- cell suspensions of epithelial and stromal cells were cultured at cloning density (300-500/cm(2)) in serum medium or in serum- free medium supplemented with one of eight growth factors. Small numbers of epithelial (0.22%) and stromal cells (1.25%) initiated colonies in serum-containing medium. The majority of colonies were small, containing large, loosely arranged cells, and 37% of epithelial and 1 in 60 of stromal colonies were classified as large, comprising small, densely packed cells. In serum-free medium, transforming growth factor-alpha (TGF alpha), epidermal growth factor (EGF), platelet-derived growth factor-BB (PDGF-BB) strongly supported clonogenicity of epithelial cells, while leukemia-inhibitory factor (LIF), hepatocyte growth factor (HGF), stem-cell factor (SCF), insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF- I) were weakly supportive, and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) was without effect. TGF alpha, EGF, PDGF-BB, and bFGF supported stromal cell clonogenicity, while HGF, SCF, LIF, and IGF- I were without effect. Small epithelial colonies expressed three epithelial markers but not stromal markers; however, large epithelial colonies showed little reactivity for all markers except alpha(6)-integrin. All stromal colonies contained fibroblasts, expressing stromal markers, and in some colonies, myofibroblasts were also identified. This analysis of human endometrium has demonstrated the presence of rare clonogenic epithelial and stromal cells with high proliferative potential, providing the first evidence for the existence of putative endometrial epithelial and stromal stem cells.     

Individual Cell Movement, Asymmetric Colony Expansion, Rho-Associated Kinase, and E-Cadherin Impact the Clonogenicity of Human Embryonic Stem Cells

Clonality is, at present, the only means by which the self-renewal potential of a given stem cell can be determined. To assess the clonality of human embryonic stem cells (hESC), a protocol involving seeding wells at low cell densities is commonly used to surmount poor cloning efficiencies. However, factors influencing the accuracy of such an assay have not been fully elucidated. Using clonogenic assays together with time-lapse microscopy, numerical analyses, and regulated gene expression strategies, we found that individual and collective cell movements are inherent properties of hESCs and that they markedly impact the accuracy of clonogenic assays. Analyses of cell motility using mean-square displacement and paired migration correlation indicated that cell movements become more straight-line or ballistic and less random-walk as separation distance decreases. Such motility-induced reaggregation (rather than a true clone) occurs ∼70% of the time if the distance between two hESCs is <6.4 μm, and is not observed if the distance is >150 μm. Furthermore, newly formed small hESC colonies have a predisposition toward the formation of larger colonies through asymmetric colony expansion and movement, which would not accurately reflect self-renewal and proliferative activity of a true hESC clone. Notably, inhibition of Rho-associated kinase markedly upregulated hESC migration and reaggregation, producing considerable numbers of false-positive colonies. Conversely, E-cadherin upregulation significantly augmented hESC clonogenicity via improved survival of single hESCs without influencing cell motility. This work reveals that individual cell movement, asymmetric colony expansion, Rho-associated kinase, and E-cadherin all work together to influence hESC clonogenicity, and provides additional guidance for improvement of clonogenic assays in the analysis of hESC self-renewal.     

Delayed reproductive death and ROS levels in the progeny of irradiated melanoma cells

The cell death and survival of proliferating (clonogenic) cells were investigated in two human melanoma cell lines to assess the optimal conditions for preparation of apoptotic bodies from melanoma cells. After 50 J/m2 UVB+UVC the maximal levels of apoptotic cells assayed by Trypan blue staining, nucleosomal DNA fragmentation, MTT, and TUNEL tests were observed within 2-3 d of radiation. In 100 Gy gamma-irradiated cultures these apoptosis indicators were delayed for up to 3 weeks. In addition, clonogenic cells were observed only in exponentially growing cultures irradiated with UV at high cell density but not in gamma-irradiated cultures. The response of melanoma cultures after high UV radiation doses contrasted to the response in lethally gamma-irradiated cultures. UV-irradiated melanoma cultures were recovered within two weeks. Most of the clonogenic cells in the recovered colonies contained micronuclei. ROS levels determined by DCF fluorescence and a modified MTT test were also normalized obviously due to the extensive antioxidant defense system of melanoma cells. UV radiation of tumor cells might be the preferential method for preparation of apoptotic bodies. The presence of clonogenic cells in the suspension of apoptotic bodies from melanoma cells used for pulsing of dendritic cells with tumor antigens might compromise this protocol for preparation of cell vaccines.     

Rapid decline of clonogenic hemopoietic progenitors in semisolid cultures of bone marrow samples derived from patients with chronic myeloid leukemia

Bone marrow samples, from newly diagnosed patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) and normal individuals, were grown in methylcellulose and serially recultured under identical conditions. Specimens derived from normal individuals gave rise to multilineage and megakaryocyte colonies for one to two sequential cultures. Erythroid bursts and granulocyte-macrophage colonies were observed for three to five sequential cultures. Cultures initiated from samples of patients with CML showed a rapid decline of all types of colonies. Colonies were rarely seen for more than two sequential cultures. When pooled colonies and background cells were recloned separately, secondary colonies were mainly seen in cultures of background cells. This observation is consistent with the view that secondary colonies are more likely to arise from dormant clonogenic progenitors, rather than through cells that have formed primary colonies through a self-renewal process.     

Haemopoietic spleen colony growth: a versatile, parsimonious, predictive model

Abstract. Substantial support has been obtained for the stochastic model for stem cell differentiation first proposed by Till, McCulloch & Siminovitch (1964), over 20 years ago. By adding a cell maturation pathway, it is possible to predict (by computer simulation) the total number of cells and consequently the time at which individual colonies appear and disappear.
Only a few uncontroversial assumptions are required to predict that cells, uniform with respect to self-renewal, are capable of producing the high proportions of late disappearing and late appearing colonies observed experimentally in the spleens of irradiated mice that have been injected with normal haemopoietic cells. It is shown that differences in stem cell self-renewal only slightly influence the time of appearance of colonies; whereas changes in the kinetics of the maturing cells, by changing the size of colonies, has a marked effect on the time of appearance and disappearance of colonies and on the average doubling-time of colony-forming cells per colony (but not the doubling-time of individual colonies).
These results (1) seriously question the prevailing view that spleen colonies scored at 8 days measure a separate population (without the capacity for self-renewal), from those scored at 12 days; (2) argue against the existence of multiple sub-populations of stem cells with differing self-renewal and toxicity to cytotoxic agents; (3) help to identify those experiments for which it is obligatory to postulate heterogeneity, and (4) are consistent with self-renewal being regulated by a feedback control of stem cell differentiation, to which only proliferating stem cells can respond and where the stimulus for differentiation decreases at a time when the bone marrow is known to be depleted.     

A stochastic model of self-renewal and commitment to differentiation of the primitive hemopoietic stem cells in culture

We recently identified a murine hemopoietic stem cell colony which consists of undifferentiated (blast) cells and appears to be more primitive than CFU-GEMM in the stem cell hierarchy. The progenitors for the colony which we termed “stem cell colony” possess an extensive self-renewal capacity and the ability to generate many secondary multipotential hemopoietic colonies in culture. We replated a total of 68 stem cell colonies from cultures of murine spleen cells and analyzed the number of stem cell–and granulocyte(neutrophil)-erythrocyte-macrophage-megakaryocyte (GEMM) colony-forming cells in individual stem cell colonies. Of the 68 stem cell colonies, 35 contained progenitors (abbreviated as “S”-cells) for stem cell colonies. The distributions of S-cells and CFU-GEMM in individual stem cell colonies were extremely heterogeneous. Neither the frequency distributions of S-cells nor CFU-GEMM in stem cell colonies could be fitted well by Poisson distribution. Rather, the frequency distribution of the s-cells could be approximated by a geometric distribution and that of CFU-GEMM by an exponential distribution, both of which are variates of the gamma distribution. Our observations are in agreement with those on the distributions of CFU-S in individual spleen colonies and provided support for a stochastic model for stem cell self-renewal and commitment in culture. Application of the theory of the branching process to the distribution of S-cells revealed a distributional parameter “p” of 0.589 which is also in agreement with the earlier report on the p value for reproduction of CFU-S.     

Neonatal mouse gonocyte proliferation assayed by an in vitro clonogenic method

Survival and proliferation of mouse gonocytes was studied using a single cell clonogenic assay in vitro. The effect of growth factors and extracellular matrix on clonogenic development was quantitated. Fundamental requirements for growth of neonatal gonocytes included addition of fetal calf serum and coating culture wells with collagen IV alone or with added fibronectin. After 4-5 days, colonies ranged in size from four to > 128 cells, and some contained very elongated cells indicating migratory behaviour. Soluble stem cell factor did not have any effect on clonogenicity, although STO (subline of SIM mouse fibroblasts) cells, which produce membrane-bound stem cell factor, reduced colony formation from 79 +/- 5.9% to 20 +/- 3.3% without added growth factor. The majority of gonocytes and type A spermatogonia express the c-kit receptor according to in situ hybridization studies. However, the results indicate that the receptor may not be functional in neonatal gonocytes and their immediate progeny. The current assay for gonocytes can be extended to test new growth factors or proliferation-inducing agents directly, as well as to study cell-cell interactions. This assay and long-term propagation of neonatal germ cells will provide the much needed resources to enable greater understanding of the early development of germ cells.     

Human CD34+ HLA-DR- bone marrow cells contain progenitor cells capable of self-renewal, multilineage differentiation, and long-term in vitro hematopoiesis.

Human bone marrow cells expressing CD34 but not HLA-DR were isolated by immunofluorescence flow cytometric cell sorting. These cells contained a hematopoietic cell (CFU-B1) capable of producing, in an in vitro semisolid culture system, blast-cell-containing colonies, which possessed the capacity for self-renewal and commitment to multipotential differentiation. In addition, CD34+ HLA-DR- marrow cells contained primitive megakaryocyte progenitor cells, the burst-forming unit-megakaryocyte (BFU-MK). A subset of CD34+ HLA-DR- marrow cells lacking the expression of CD15 and CD71 was obtained by flow cytometric cell sorting and was capable of sustaining in vitro hematopoiesis in suspension culture for up to 8 weeks in the absence of a preestablished adherent marrow cell layer. The combination of IL-3 + IL-1 alpha and IL-3 + IL-6 sustained proliferation of these cells for 8 weeks, induced maximal cellular expansion, and increased the numbers of assayable progenitor cells. These studies demonstrate that human CD34+ HLA-DR- marrow cells and their subsets contain primitive multipotential hematopoietic cells capable of self-renewal and of differentiation into multiple hematopoietic lineages.     

Regulation of self-renewal of human T lymphocyte colony-forming units (TL-CFUs)

Formation of human T lymphocyte colonies in semisolid medium from T lymphocyte colony-forming units (TL-CFUs) under stimulation of phytohemagglutinin (PHA) has been reported by several authors. These TL-CFUs were present in unsensitized lymphocyte populations. We report here that such TL-CFUs are capable of renewing themselves. This was observed when colony cells from primary T cell colonies that developed in the presence of PHA were replated in methylcellulose medium containing irradiated autologous leukocytes and PHA. We have also been able to demonstrate serial transfer of TL-CFU for up to six passages. At each passage, colony-forming frequency was determined from the proportional relationship between the number of new colonies obtained and the number of colony cells plated. Examination of the number of new colonies derived from each individual T cell colony ("burst size of TL-CFU") showed that most colonies contained very few new TL-CFU and only a very small number of colonies contained many new TL-CFU. The distribution of burst sizes could be well fitted to a gamma distribution, in agreement with prediction from a stochastic model. We have identified an activity that enhanced the mean TL-CFU burst size three to ten times. This work provides the first evidence in vitro that self-renewal of human T lymphocyte progenitor cells can be stimulated by specific regulatory proteins.     

Proliferative kinetics and differentiation of murine blast cell colonies in culture: Evidence for variable G0 periods and constant doubling rates of early pluripotent hemopoietic progenitors

Several investigators have described hemopoietic colonies expressing multilineage differentiation in culture. We recently identified a class of murine hemopoletic progenitors which form blast cell colonies with very high replating efficiencies. In order to clarify further the relationship between progenitors for blast cell colonies and progenitors for the multilineage hemopoietic colonies in culture, we carried out analyses of kinetic and differentiation properties of murine blast cell colonies. Serial observations of the development of blast cell colonies into multilineage (and single lineage) colonies in cultures of spleen cells obtained from 5-fluorouracil (5-FU)-treated mice confirmed the transitional nature of the murine blast cell colonies. The data also suggested that the early pluripotent progenitors are in G₀ for variable periods, and that when triggered into cell cycle, they proliferate at relatively constant doubling rates during the early stages of differentiation. The notion that some of the pluripotent progenitors are in G₀ was also supported by long-term thymidine suicide studies in which spleen cells were exposed to ³H-thymidine with high specific activity for 5 days in culture, washed, and assayed for surviving progenitors. Comparison of replating abilities of day-7 and day-16 blast cell colonies from normal as well as 5-FU-treated mice indicated that some of the day-7 blast cell colonies are derived from maturer populations of progenitors which are sensitive to 5-FU. In contrast, progenitors for the day-16 blast cell colonies are dormant in cell cycle and were not affected by 5-FU treatment. Previously we reported that progenitors for day-16 blast cell colonies have a significant capacity for self-renewal. These observations suggest the hypothesis that the capability for self-renewal is accompanied by long periods of G₀, and that once commitment to differentiation takes place, then active cell division occurs.     

The cellular composition of hemopoietic spleen colonies

The cellular composition of individual hemopoietic spleen colonies has been studied using techniques which tested primarily for cell function rather than cell morphology. Erythroblastic cells were recognized by their capacity to incorporate radioiron, granulocytic cells by their content of peroxidase-positive material, and hemopoietic stem cells by their ability to form spleen colonies in irradiated hosts. It was found that, 14 days after the initiation of spleen colonies, the distribution of these cell types among individual colonies was very heterogeneous, but that most colonies contained detectable numbers of erythroblasts, granulocytes and colony-forming cells. An appreciable proportion of the cells in the colonies could not be identified as any of these three cell types. No strong correlations between numbers of erythroblasts, granulocytes and colony-forming cells in individual colonies were observed, though there was a tendency for colonies containing a high proportion of erythroblasts to contain a low proportion of granulocytes, and for colonies containing a high proportion of granulocytes to contain a higher proportion of colony-forming cells. An analysis of colonies which contained cells bearing radiation-induced chromosomal markers indicated that 83–98% of the dividing cells within 14-day spleen colonies were derived from single precursors.     

The characteristics of an anchorage-independent clonal agar assay for primary explanted bovine granulosa cells

Normal, primary explanted, bovine granulosa cells grow reproducibly in agar culture as anchorage-independent clones. Epidermal growth factor (EGF) and rat erythrocytes are effective stimulators of colony formation, and when both are added to the culture medium at optimal concentrations, there is an enhancement of colony numbers and colony size, indicative of an independent, and operationally additive, mode of action for the two factors. The ability of cells propagated from agar clones to secrete progesterone, and to augment progesterone secretion 4-fold in the presence of 1 mM dbcAMP is proof that colonies originate from and are composed of functional granulosa cells. Maximal colony numbers are present at day 10 of incubation, and colony forming cells undergo self-renewal as assessed by the ability of cells from primary colonies to reclone in agar. Absolute cloning efficiency, however, is dependent on a number of factors. Inherent variability exists in cloning efficiency of granulosa cells from individual follicles. Quantitative and qualitative clonal growth was improved at an osmolality of less than 300 mOsm when compared with higher osmolalities. Cl-1 medium and the alpha modification of Eagle's medium were equally effective in supporting agar clonogenic growth, whereas both Ham's F12 and NCTC 135 media exhibited poor clonogenic growth supporting properties. The substitution of agarose for agar did not affect colony numbers but colonies grown in the presence of agarose tended to be smaller and more uniform in size.     

Self-renewal and commitment to differentiation of human leukemic promyelocytic cells (HL-60)

More than 80% of cells from a human promyelocytic leukemic cell line (HL-60) possess the capacity for self-renewal as evidenced by their ability to form large primary colonies in semisolid medium and the presence within these colonies of cells capable of subsequent colony formation. Colony development is independent of the normal regulator-the myeloid colony stimulating factor. The observed autostimulation suggests the production of specific growth promoters by the cells. Differentiation either to mature granulocytes or macrophages, induced by various agents, was associated with reduced cloning potential. Nevertheless, colonies containing differentiated cells could be developed either by cloning cells in the presence of suboptimal concentrations of inducer or by adding inducers over colonies developed in its absence. Upon differentiation, there was a morphological change from compact to diffused colony morphology due to cell mobility in the semisolid medium. Even at suboptimal concentrations of inducer more than 95% of the colonies became diffused, indicating clonaI homogeneity of the population with respect to differentiation capacity. The loss of self-renewal was found to be one of the early properties which changed following the initiation of differentiation. The loss preceded not only the overt expression of maturation-specific functions but also cellular commitment to terminal differentiation; shorter contact with the inducer was required to cause loss of self-renewal than to induce an irreversible transition to differentiation. This resulted in cells that lost their self-renewal potential without being able to complete their program of differentiation.     

Isolation of mouse mammary epithelial progenitor cells with basal characteristics from the Comma-Dbeta cell line

A mouse mammary epithelial cell line with morphogenetic properties in vivo, Comma-Dbeta, was used to isolate and to characterize mammary progenitor cells. We found that a homogeneous cell population expressing high surface levels of stem cell antigen 1 (Sca-1) was able to give rise in vivo to ductal and alveolar structures comprising luminal secretory and basal myoepithelial cells. Unlike the Sca-1(high), the Sca-1(neg/low) cell population displayed a reduced morphogenetic potential. The Sca-1(high) cells presented moderate CD24, high CD44 and alpha6 integrin surface levels, expressed basal cell markers p63, keratins 5 and 14, but no luminal and myoepithelial lineage markers. In culture, the Sca-1(high) cells generated identical daughter cells that retained their in vivo developmental potential, indicating that these cells were maintained by self-renewal. Plated at clonogenic density in Matrigel, Sca-1(high) cells formed spheroids that included luminal and myoepithelial cells. Thus, the isolated Sca-1(high) basal cells possess several features of stem/progenitor cells, including specific markers, self-renewal capacity, and the ability to generate the two major mammary lineages, luminal and myoepithelial. These data provide evidence for the existence of basal-type mouse mammary progenitors able to participate in the morphogenetic processes characteristic of mammary gland development.