Analysis of the idiotypic network in tumor immunity

Herein we have analyzed the expression of idiotopes associated with a monoclonal anti-tumor-associated antigen (TAA) antibody in DBA/2 mice which have progressively growing tumors or resist tumor growth. A panel of eight monoclonal antiidiotypic antibodies raised against a monoclonal antibody which reacts with a mouse mammary tumor virus cross-reactive qp52 envelope protein (TAA) of the L1210/GZL lymphoma was used to measure the expression of idiotopes in sera from different treatment groups. Significant correlations between the expression of certain idiotopes and the growth of the tumor or the establishment of anti-tumor immunity are seen. 1) Idiotypes detected by anti-idiotype D11 are high in anti-idiotype immunized progressor or tumor-susceptible mice and low or absent in regressor mice, i.e., the mice immunized with the protective 2F10 anti-idiotype; 2) the 3A4-detected idiotypes are less frequent or absent in irradiated tumor-immunized regressor mice than in untreated mice challenged with live tumor or progressor mice; 3) no difference in the anti-TAA titers is seen in mice in which the tumor growth is inhibited and in mice in which the tumor grows; 4) no difference in 11C1 idiotype + anti-TAA titer was observed between regressor and progressor mice; and 5) mice with normal or accelerated tumor growth have higher titers of idiotypes detected by a polyclonal anti-idiotype. These findings provide evidence for a regulatory idiotype network induced by the growing L1210/GZL tumor or by anti-idiotypic immunization. The titer of anti-TAA antibody does not correlate with the biology of tumor growth, but certain idiotopes correlate with either progressive or regressive tumor behavior. Therefore, the target of the idiotype regulation is likely to be anti-tumor T effector cells. Effective idiotype therapy of tumors must deal with the complexity of idiotype regulation induced by the tumor itself and is unlikely to be successful if anti-idiotypes are used only as internal mimicry of a TAA.     

Tumor-specific idiotype vaccines. I. Generation and characterization of internal image tumor antigen

The concept of idiotype vaccines against tumor-associated antigens (TAA) was tested in the DBA/2 L1210 lymphoma subline, L1210/GZL. Monoclonal antibodies against a TAA that cross-reacts with the envelope glycoprotein gp52 of the mammary tumor virus were used to make hybridoma anti-idiotype antibodies (Ab2). In this report we describe the characterization of monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies against the combining site of 11C1 (Ab1), which recognizes a shared determinant of gp52 of mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) and the TAA of L1210/GZL. Hybridomas expressing the internal image of gp52 were screened by an idiotype inhibition assay. Mice sensitized with radiated L1210/GZL cells produced specific delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) against the Ab2 hybridoma. Five Ab2 hybridomas were selected and were used to immunize DBA/2 mice. Such immunized animals showed specific DTH reaction against a challenge with the L1210/GZL tumor cells. Similar results were obtained in mice immunized with purified Ab2. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter analysis demonstrated that fluorescence staining of L1210/GZL cells by 11C1 can be completely inhibited with preabsorption on Ab2 hybridoma cells. Mice immunized with 2F10 and 3A4 coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) contained antibodies binding to MMTV. But only in mice immunized with 2F10-KLH was significant inhibition of L1210/GZL tumor growth observed. Collectively, these results indicate that certain anti-idiotypic antibodies can mimic the MMTV gp52 antigen, as well as the gp52-like epitope expressed on the L1210/GZL tumor cells. These properties of anti-idiotypic antibodies mimicking TAA could be exploited for making idiotype vaccines against tumors.     

Idiotypic intramolecular help. Induction of tumor-specific antibodies by monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody with the help of Fc-specific T helper clones

In this study, the mechanism of anti-Id vaccination was investigated by using cloned Th cells and an anti-idiotypic mAb. 2F10, an anti-idiotypic mAb derived from an Igh1-e allotype mouse strain, which induces protection against the L1210/GZL DBA/2 tumor, was used to prime DBA/2 mice. An Fc (Igh1-e)-specific syngeneic Th clone was cocultured in the presence of 2F10 anti-Id with 2F10-Fab-primed B cells. The Th clone responded with proliferation and also provided help for 2F10-Fab-primed B cells to produce antibodies that bind to L1210/GZL and not to P815 tumor cells. Intact 2F10 anti-Id was presented to Fc-specific Th cells by Fab (or Id) primed B cells more efficiently than the fragment mixture (Fab plus Fc) of 2F10 anti-Id, indicating that 2F10-Fab (or Id)-primed B cells capture 2F10 anti-Id through surface Ig receptors. Presenting B cells are sensitive to treatment with chloroquine and must come from H-2 matched mice, indicating that the Ag presentation by Fab-primed B cells to Fc-specific Th cells requires processing and is MHC restricted. Collectively these results outline a mechanism that may operate in anti-Id therapy of tumor-bearing animals by using tumor Ag mimicking anti-idiotypic antibodies. A similar mechanism could be effective in tumor patients immunized with xenogeneic anti-idiotypic antibodies operating under the "intra(Ag) molecular help."     

Tumor-specific idiotype vaccines. II. Analysis of the tumor-related network response induced by the tumor and by internal image antigens (Ab2 beta)

In this study the tumor-specific immuneresponse induced by irradiated tumor cells (L1210/GZL) and by anti-idiotype antibodies was analyzed. The anti-idiotype antibodies (Ab2) were made against the paratope of a monoclonal antitumor antibody (11C1) that recognizes a tumor-associated antigen which cross-reacts with the mouse mammary tumor virus-encoded envelope glycoprotein 52. Two Ab2, 2F10 and 3A4, induced idiotypes expressed by the monoclonal antitumor antibodies 11C1 and 2B2. Cytotoxic T cells, generated by immunization with irradiated tumor cells, lyse 2F10 and 3A4 hybridoma cells. Furthermore, immunization with Ab2 induces tumor-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes. The frequency of tumor-reactive cytotoxic T lymphocyte was found to be similar in mice immunized with Ab2 or irradiated tumor cells when examined at the precursor level. However, only 2F10 induces protective immunity against the growth of L1210/GZL tumor cells. The depletion of a L3T4+ T cell population from 2F10 immune mice was found to increase the effectiveness of transferred T cells to induce inhibition of tumor growth. The inability of 3A4 to induce antitumor immunity could be correlated with the presence of a population of Lyt2+ regulatory T cells. Collectively, these results demonstrate the existence of a regulatory network controlling the expression of effective tumor immunity. Our results demonstrate that selection of binding site-related Ab2 may not be a sufficient criteria for the development of an idiotype vaccine. A better understanding of the regulatory interactions induced by anti-idiotypes is needed for the design of effective antitumor immunotherapy.     

Tumor idiotype vaccines

In this study, the contribution of idiotype-positive antitumor antibodies (anti-Id) in protective tumor immunity was investigated. We have previously shown that among various anti-Id generated and typed as the internal-image Ab2 of the tumor-associated antibody (TAA) gp52, only 2F10 antibody induces protective immunity. Increase of the 2F10 idiotope in sera of tumor-bearing mice correlated with long-term survival, while in mice with short survival the circulating 2F10 idiotype decreased. 2F10⁺ Ig were purified from sera of tumor-bearing mice with longterm survival and the amount of 2F10⁺ anti-TAA antibodies was determined. Only about 3% of 2F10⁺ antibodies are 2F10⁺ anti-TAA⁺. Hybridomas were generated from a 2F10 high mouse with spontaneous tumor regression. Only 2 out of 52 tumor-specific hybridomas were 2F10⁺. These results suggest that the protective effect induced by 2F10 vaccination may not be directly mediated by 2F10⁺ antibodies but indirectly through the stimulation of a 2F10-specific cellular immune response.Supported in part by a grant from N.I.H. no. CA51434     

High idiotypic connectivity of the VH7183-encoded antibodies directed to a murine embryonic carbohydrate antigen, Lewis Y, as ascertained by syngenic anti-idiotype monoclonal antibodies

The Lewis Y Ag is a carbohydrate Ag which is closely related to a well-known murine embryonic Ag, the stage-specific embryonic Ag-1 (SSEA-1), in its biochemical structure. It is expressed at the surface of murine embryonic cells as well as many murine cancer cells. For the analysis of idiotopes carried by the anti-Lewis Y antibodies, we generated two syngenic anti-idiotypic mAb, Id-A1 and Id-B4 (both BALB/c IgG1), which are directed to the idiotypic determinants carried by the anti-Lewis Y mAb, AH-6 (BALB/c IgM). Both Id-A1 and Id-B4 (Ab2) recognized paratope-related idiotopes carried by the AH-6 antibody (Ab1); they specifically inhibited the binding of AH-6 to the Lewis Y Ag. The high idiotypic connectivity of anti-Lewis Y antibodies was noted; the polyclonal anti-idiotype antibody, produced in the sera of BALB/c mice by immunizing AH-6 antibody, cross-reacted with several anti-Lewis Y mAb which has been established in different laboratories. Id-B4 and Id-A1 seem to represent such cross-reactive anti-idiotypic antibodies. Id-A1 recognized an idiotope carried by two out of six panel Ab1 mAb directed to the Lewis Y Ag. Id-B4 reacted with four out of the six panel antibodies, and was considered to recognize a recurrent idiotope of anti-Lewis Y antibodies which occurs more commonly than the idiotope recognized by Id-A1. All of the anti-Lewis Y antibodies which carry idiotopes that react with Id-A1 or Id-B4 were encoded by the VH genes of the VH7183 family; the most D-J proximal VH gene family in BALB/c mice, which is known to be preferentially expressed in embryonic B cells. Immunization of BALB/c mice with keyhole limpet hemocyanin-conjugated Id-B4 and/or Id-A1 induced a significant titer of anti-Lewis Y antibodies (Ab1-like Ab3) in the sera.     

Ricin A-chain conjugated with monoclonal anti-L1210 antibody

Summary In studies of antitumor antibody-cytotoxic agent conjugates as potential antitumor agents with improved tumor specificity, the toxic subunit A-chain of ricin was conjugated with a monoclonal antibody to a tumor-associated antigen expressed weakly on murine leukemia L1210 cells and strongly on L1210/GZL cells, a guanazole-resistant subline of L1210, employing N-succinimidyl 3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate as cross-linking agent. The conjugate (anti-L1210 conjugate) exhibited a potent concentration-dependent cytotoxicity against cultured L1210/GZL cells, and inhibited cell growth at concentrations over 0.8 g/ml. The conjugate killed all L1210/GZL cells at a concentration of 100 g/ml. Neither nonimmune conjugate similarly prepared from mouse nonimmune IgG nor unconjugated anti-L1210 IgG alone showed cytotoxicity against L1210/GZL cells. When (BALB/c×DBA/2)F₁ mice inoculated with 1 × 10⁵ L1210/GZL cells were treated with IP injections of 27 g anti-L1210 conjugate 1 h and 5 days after tumor cell inoculation, a life-prolonging effect was observed. [Lifespan in treated animals as percentage of that in controls (T/C)=146%]. However, when the dose per injection was increased to 50 g per mouse, survival was the same as in the control group. Postmortem examination of mice that had been treated with 50 g anti-L1210 conjugate revealed lesions with necrosis and hemorrhage in the liver parenchyma and the intestinal epithelium, respectively. A similar toxic effect on the host mice was also observed with nonimmune conjugate.     

Induction of effective immunity to Moloney murine sarcoma virus using monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody as immunogen

We have isolated an anti-idiotypic mAb (RS1.1.3), which recognizes an idiotope present on several IgM mAb specific for Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV)-determined cell surface Ag. The binding of RS1.1.3 to idiotypic antibody could be inhibited by specific Ag. Intraperitoneal immunization of mice with purified RS1.1.3 antibody-induced effective immunity against Moloney murine sarcoma virus challenge. A single injection of RS1.1.3 7 days before virus challenge resulted in a 27% reduction in tumor load compared to non-immune control mice challenged with the same dose of virus, whereas multiple injections of RS1.1.3 before virus challenge resulted in a 75% reduction in tumor load. The protective effect of anti-idiotype immunization appeared to be T dependent, because immunization of athymic mice had no effect on their susceptibility to tumor virus challenge. Administration of the anti-idiotypic antibody after virus inoculation caused an increase in tumor load of nearly 50% compared to non-immune controls. BALB/c mice immunized with RS1.1.3 developed anti-anti-idiotypic antibodies, as well as M-MuLV Ag-specific antibodies. Analysis of sera from RS1.1.3-immune mice subsequently challenged with Moloney murine sarcoma virus indicated an inverse relationship between tumor load and M-MuLV-specific serum IgG titers induced by the RS1.1.3 immunization. These results indicate that anti-idiotypic mAb may be used as immunogen to induce Ag-specific antibody responses, and to cause effective immunity to a retro-virus-induced tumor.     

Impact of minimal tumor burden on antibody response to vaccination

Four randomized phase III trials conducted recently in melanoma patients in the adjuvant setting have been based in part on the correlation between antibody responses in immunized patients and improved survival. Each of these randomized trials demonstrated no clinical benefit, although again there was a significant correlation between antibody response after vaccination and disease free and overall survival. To better understand this paradox, we established a surgical adjuvant model targeting GD2 ganglioside on EL4 lymphoma cells injected into the foot pad followed by amputation at variable intervals. Our findings are (1) comparable strong therapeutic benefit resulted from treatment of mice after amputation with a GD2-KLH conjugate vaccine or with anti-GD2 monoclonal antibody 3F8. (2) The strongest correlation was between antibody induction in response to vaccination and prolonged survival. (3) Antibody titers in response to vaccination in tumor challenged mice as compared to unchallenged mice were far lower despite the absence of detectable recurrences at the time. (4) The half life of administered 3F8 monoclonal antibody (but not control antibody) in challenged mice administered was significantly shorter than the half life of 3F8 antibody in unchallenged controls. The correlation between vaccine-induced antibody titers and prolonged survival may reflect, at least in part, increased tumor burden in antibody-negative mice. Absorption of vaccine-induced antibodies by increased, although not detected tumor burden may also explain the correlation between vaccine-induced antibody titers and survival in the adjuvant clinical trials described above.     

Anti-idiotype antibodies: an alternative approach to tumor immunotherapy

Studies presented in this paper examined the tumor-specific cellular and humoral immunity induced by anti-idiotype antibodies (Ab2s) 2F10 and 3A4. A panel of Ab2s was made against a monoclonal anti-L1210/GZL lymphoma, 11C1. The Ab2s were screened for their ability to block 11C1 binding to tumor, to induce tumor-specific DTH and CTL responses and to induce an anti-tumor humoral response. Two Ab2s, 2F10 and 3A4, were found to have similar fine specificity and to induce similar cellular and humoral responses. These were then examined for their ability to elicit tumor-protective immunity. Only preimmunization with 2F10 Ab2 protected animals from live tumor challenge, and in this paper the possible causes of this difference in otherwise similar Ab2s is discussed.     

Idiotype vaccines against human T cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia. I. Generation and characterization of biologically active monoclonal anti-idiotopes

A murine monoclonal anti-tumor antibody termed SN2 (Ab1), isotype IgG1-kappa, that defines a unique human T cell leukemia-associated cell-surface glycoprotein, gp37 (m.w. 37,000), was used to generate monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies (Ab2) in syngeneic BALB/c mice. The Ab2 were screened on the basis of their binding to the F(ab')2 fragments of SN2 and not to the F(ab')2 of pooled normal BALB/c mice sera IgG1 or to an unrelated BALB/c monoclonal antibody of the same isotype. Fifteen Ab2, obtained from two fusions, were specific for the SN2 idiotope and not against isotype or allotype determinants. To find out whether these Ab2 are directed against the paratope of SN2, the binding of radiolabeled SN2 to leukemic MOLT-4 and JM cells which contain gp37 as a surface constituent was studied in the presence of these anti-idiotopes. Clone 4EA2 inhibited the binding 100% at a concentration of 50 ng and 4DC6 inhibited 90% at a concentration of 250 ng. A third clone 4DD6 gave about 50% inhibition. Similar was the inhibition of SN2 binding to insolubilized MOLT-4 antigen or cell membrane preparation. The binding of SN2 (Ab1) to 4EA2 and 4DC6 was also inhibited by semipurified preparation of gp37 antigen. These results demonstrate that at least two of the anti-idiotope antibodies are binding either at or near the binding site idiotope of SN2. Next, the purified Ab2 was used to immunize syngeneic mice to induce antibody binding to MOLT-4 cells or gp37. Sera from mice immunized with 4EA2 and 4DC6 coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin contained antibodies which bind to semipurified gp37 antigen and MOLT-4 cells. Immune sera inhibited the binding of iodinated Ab2 and Ab1 indicating that an anti-anti-idiotopic antibody (Ab3) in mice shares idiotopes with Ab1 (SN2). Also, the binding of iodinated Ab2 to Ab1 was inhibited by rabbit antisera specific for gp37. Collectively, these data suggest that anti-idiotype antibodies 4EA2 and 4DC6 may be useful in the generation of idiotype vaccines against human T cell leukemia.     

Mapping the idiotopes of a monoclonal anti-myoglobin antibody with syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies: detection of a common idiotope

A panel of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies was prepared by immunizing A.SW mice with keyhole limpet hemocyanin-coupled A.SW monoclonal anti-myoglobin (HAL 19, IgG1) and screening the cloned hybridomas for production of IgG2 binding to idiotype but not to certain other anti-myoglobin antibodies of the same subclass in an ELISA. With these antibodies, we identified three nonoverlapping idiotopes, based on three clusters of monoclonal anti-idiotopes that mutually inhibit within each cluster, but not between clusters (Cluster I: S2, S6, S8; Cluster II: S5, S7; Cluster III: S9). Only Cluster II antibodies block the binding of myoglobin to HAL 19 and so identify a binding site-related idiotope(s). Binding of both Cluster II monoclonals (S5 and S7) to Hal 19 is inhibited by a rabbit anti-idiotype that we previously reported detects a common cross-reactive anti-myoglobin idiotope in immune sera. However, only one of these, S7, and not S5, identifies an idiotope that is present on 20 to 30% of A.SW anti-myoglobin antibodies in immune sera and ascites. The panel of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies also detects new idiotopes not detected by the rabbit anti-idiotype. The development of a panel of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies to different clusters of idiotopes on the same antibody molecule, including one that identifies a major common idiotope in immune sera, should allow the analysis of possible idiotype network regulation in vivo and in vitro in a completely syngeneic system.     

Induction of neutralizing antibody in mice against poliovirus type II with monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody

Syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotope antibody Ab2,2-17C3SCC was raised against an idiotope on a protective monoclonal antibody with specificity for poliovirus type II. Ab2,2-17C3SCC detects a paratope-related interspecies IdX. Ab2,2-17C3SCC purified from supernatant fluids of hybridoma cells by protein A-Sepharose was injected into 4- to 6-wk-old BALB/c mice. The sera of the mice were screened for the expression of antibodies bearing the corresponding idiotope. Immunization of mice with Ab2,2-17C3SCC induced antibodies of complementary specificity. Furthermore, micro VN tests suggest that Ab2,2-17C3SCC can substitute for antigen in the induction of anti-polio neutralizing antibodies, and hence can function as a monoclonal anti-idiotypic vaccine.     

The occurrence of anti-3-fucosyllactosamine antibodies and their cross-reactive idiotopes in preimmune and immune mouse sera

The carbohydrate determinant 3-fucosyllactosamine (3-FL), Gal(beta 1-4)[Fuc alpha 1-3]GlcNAc-R, which is also known as SSEA-1 or as the X determinant, is very immunogenic in BALB/c mice. Many monoclonal antibodies directed against this structure have been obtained by immunization of mice with murine teratocarcinomas and human carcinomas and myeloid cells. We have undertaken an analysis of the regulation of these antibodies and of their idiotypic, structural, and genetic diversity. We have described previously the preparation of syngeneic monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies (6C4 and 6B1) that reacted with 50% of a panel of monoclonal anti-3-FL antibodies. In this study, we have examined the occurrence of anti-3-FL antibodies and their cross-reactive idiotopes in the sera of unimmunized and immunized mice. All BALB/c sera examined had more naturally occurring antibodies against 3-FL than against four other glycolipid antigens, and the 6C4 and 6B1 idiotopes were also detected in these sera. Approximately 25% of the anti-3-FL antibodies could be removed from a pool of BALB/c sera by a 6C4 affinity column, and the eluate from this column exhibited strong binding to 3-FL antigens. After a single i.v. injection of a 3-FL-positive glycolipid coated on Salmonella minnesota, anti-3-FL titers rose in BALB/c mice. The level of 6B1 idiotope rose in most mice, but the idiotope level showed no correlation with anti-3-FL titers. Naturally occurring antibodies against 3-FL were also noted in the sera of AKR, C3H/He, DBA/2, BALB/c-nu/nu, and CBA/CaHN mice but not in C57BL/6, SM, or CBA/N mice. A single i.v. injection of antigen elicited an antibody response in C3H/He mice but not in C57BL/6, SM, or DBA/2 mice. These data indicate that several strains of mice have more naturally occurring IgM antibodies against the 3-FL structure than against other glycolipids, and that this response may be genetically regulated. The 6C4 and 6B1 cross-reactive idiotopes that we have identified previously on monoclonal antibodies are also present in preimmune and immune sera. The existence of a population of B lymphocytes that are primed against the 3-FL determinant accounts in part for the immunogenicity of this structure.     

Analysis of anti-streptococcal group A carbohydrate idiotope levels in sera: correlation of magnitude of expression with idiotope position and VK haplotype

We have employed monoclonal anti-idiotopes to map the corresponding idiotopes on the variable domain of a prototype antibody specific for streptococcal group A carbohydrate (GAC). Idiotope variability, as assessed by direct and competitive binding assays, previously was shown to correlate with idiotope position; determinants farther from the binding site were less variable. We now describe a relationship between idiotope position and idiotope concentration in normal and GAC-immune sera from mice of several inbred and recombinant inbred strains. Employing sera as inhibitors in a competitive radioimmunoassay, we demonstrate that idiotopes farther from the binding site (more proximal) tend to be present at higher levels in GAC-hyperimmune sera. Only the most proximal idiotope was detected in normal serum, and this idiotope was present in normal sera from all 12 strains tested. Finally, significant interstrain differences in patterns of idiotope expression were observed, and some of these differences appear to be correlated with allelic differences at immunoglobulin structural gene loci.     

Tumor-specific idiotype vaccines. III. Induction of T helper cells by anti-idiotype and tumor cells

In a previous report, we have demonstrated the induction of tumor-specific immunity by monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies generated against a monoclonal anti-tumor antibody, 11C1, that also cross-reacts with mouse mammary tumor virus envelope glycoprotein gp52. Also, we showed that whereas one anti-idiotype antibody, 2F10, could induce protective immunity, another anti-idiotype antibody, 3A4, induced nonprotective immunity. Here we demonstrated the existence of T helper cells which recognize anti-idiotypes that exert differential controls on tumor growth. The qualitative nature of idiotype recognizing T cells generated in response to 2F10, 3A4, irradiated tumor, and progressively growing tumor was compared. The reactivity pattern of idiotype recognizing T cells obtained from 2F10 and irradiated tumor immunized mice were similar in nature in the sense that Lyt-2- T cells obtained from these immunized mice responded to both 2F10 and 3A4 as antigen, although T cells from tumor immunized mice responded better to 3A4 antigen. On the other hand, the idiotype-recognizing T cells obtained from 3A4-immunized mice showed a similar reactivity pattern to T cells isolated from mice during the early phase of tumor growth (within day 4 to 5 after the inoculation of 10(4) live tumor cells). Lyt-2- T cells isolated from mice immunized with 3A4 or during the early phase of tumor growth responded only to 3A4 antigen. The inability of Lyt-2- T cells, isolated from 4- to 5-day-old tumor in mice, to cooperate with 2F10-TNP is not due to the absence of 2F10 idiotype recognizing T cells as 2F10 id recognizing T cells are present when examined at the precursor level. These data on the idiotype specificity of T helper cells show a correlation with the presence of anti-tumor immunity. This information will help in the design and application of idiotype vaccine in tumor immunotherapy.     

Structural characterization of H chain-associated idiotopes of anti-p-azophenylarsonate monoclonal antibodies

The majority of antibodies directed against p-azophenylarsonate (Ars) protein conjugates elicited during secondary immune responses of A/J mice bear a heritable cross-reactive Id (CRIa or IdCR) which corresponds to the utilization of a unique combination of variable region gene segments that can differ by somatic mutations. One such monoclonal anti-Ars antibody, 44-10, bears IdCR as defined by rabbit antisera but does not react with two anti-idiotypic mAb, 5Ci and AD8, which react with all primary (unmutated) IdCR+ antibodies and some secondary response IdCR+ antibodies. We therefore determined the complete sequence of antibody 44-10, which differs from the germline encoded (unmutated) IdCR+ antibody 36-65 at four positions in the H chain V region (VH): position 55 in the second complementarity determining region, 100 and 107 (D-gene junctions) and 110 (in JH2). The 44-10 L chain is unmutated. Sequence analyses of five other secondary immune response anti-Ars IdCR+ antibodies chosen on the basis of sharing one or more of the amino acid substitutions found in 44-10, were correlated with idiotypic expression of this set of antibodies. The results suggest that the mutation at VH position 55 (Asn----Lys) is responsible for loss of the 5Ci idiotope. To substantiate this hypothesis, oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis of the germline encoded (unmutated) IdCR+ antibody was used to produce two mutants, one with VH Lys 55 and the other containing residues at positions 100, 107 and 110 identical to those found in 44-10. Id binding studies on these mutants confirm that 5Ci idiotope loss is due to conformational changes resulting from a mutation at VH position 55. This mutation also results in loss of the AD8 idiotope in the structural context of antibody 44-10.     

Fine specificity and idiotype diversity of a murine anti-HLA-DQw3 monoclonal antibody elicited with a syngeneic antiidiotypic monoclonal antibody

A total of 469 hybridomas was generated from a BALB/c mouse immunized with the syngeneic antiidiotypic mAb KO3-34 that recognizes an idiotope within the Ag-combining site of the immunizing syngeneic anti HLA-DQw3 mAb KS13. One of the hybridomas, named S2B154, was shown with a number of serologic and immunochemical assays to mimic the specificity of anti HLA-DQw3 mAb KS13. This result was unexpected, because the antiidiotypic mAb had been classified as gamma because of the lack of detection of anti-HLA-DQw3 antibodies in sera from BALB/c mice immunized with the antiidiotypic mAb KO3-34. The antiidiotypic mAb S2B154, an IgG1, displays a lower affinity constant to HLA-DQw3 Ag-bearing lymphoid cells than mAb KS13, an IgG2b, but a higher one to antiidiotypic mAb KO3-34. Testing with a panel of antiidiotypic mAb elicited with the mAb KS13 showed that both antiidiotypic mAb S2B154 and mAb KS13 express in their Ag-combining site the idiotopes recognized by the antiidiotypic mAb KO3-256, KO3-335, and R1-38. However, the antiidiotypic mAb S2B154 does not react with the mAb R18-9 that recognizes an idiotope outside the Ag-combining site of mAb KS13. The results we have presented question the validity of the classification of antiidiotypic antibodies based on their ability to inhibit the binding of the corresponding antibodies to Ag and on the specificity of antisera elicited with antiidiotypic antibodies. Furthermore, the hybridomas we have developed in this Id cascade provide us the opportunity to analyze the structural basis of idiotypic Ag mimicry and to evaluate the regulatory properties of antiidiotypic antibodies in the immune response to HLA class II Ag.     

Use of monoclonal antibodies in the assay of hepatitis B core antigen and antibody

Hybridoma cells secreting antibody against hepatitis B core antigen (HBc Ag) were prepared. BALB/c mice were immunized with 0.2 ml of purified HBc Ag, and their spleen cells were fused with mouse myeloma (P3U1) cells by means of polyethylene glycol 1000. Activities of antibodies against HBc Ag (anti-HBc) were tested by the immune adherence hemagglutination (IAHA) and reverse passive hemagglutination inhibition (RPHI) techniques. Hybridoma cells found to contain antibodies accounted for 26.5% by IAHA and 52.1% by RPHI, respectively. Among 32 monoclonal anti-HBc antibodies, 18 were found to be positive by both IAHA and RPHI, and the remaining 14 positive by RPHI only. After cloning, they were injected intraperitoneally into ascitic mice. The highest anti-HBc activity with an IAHA titer of 1:4 X 10(6) and with an RPHI titer of 1:1 X 10(5) was detected in this ascitic fluid. Enzyme immunoassay (EIA) and RPHI with monoclonal antibody containing the highest anti-HBc activity were developed. All the sera in which anti-HBc was detected by IAHA and RPHI with polyclonal antibody were positive in EIA. RPHI titers obtained with monoclonal antibody were in good agreement with usual IAHA and RPHI titers obtained with polyclonal antibody. These results indicate that monoclonal antibody can be used in the HBc Ag and anti-HBc assay system.     

Human immune response to group A streptococcal carbohydrate (A-CHO). II. Antigen-independent stimulation of IgM anti-A-CHO production in purified B cells by a monoclonal anti-idiotopic antibody

The paper describes the induction by a monoclonal anti-idiotopic antibody (anti-Id mAb) of specific antibody production to group A streptococcal carbohydrate (A-CHO) in purified human B cells of several unrelated individuals. The anti-Id mAb, designated 16F498 (anti-Id498), recognizes a recurrent idiotope (Id 498) associated with the combining site of human antibodies to N-acetyl-D-glucosamine (GlcNAc), the immunodominant group of A-CHO. Id498 is expressed on IgM anti-GlcNAc antibodies but does not occur on IgG antibodies with the same specificity. It occurs also on a minor population of IgM antibodies without specificity for A-CHO. Id498 was found in 19 of 27 sera from unselected healthy donors and thus seems to be frequently expressed within the adult B cell repertoire. The in vitro induction of anti-A-CHO antibodies was analyzed in human B cells extensively depleted for T cells. Specific antibody secretion required cross-linked anti-Id which was achieved by coupling the mAb to agarose beads. No antibody secretion could be induced by soluble anti-Id (1 and 10 micrograms/ml). An optimal response required soluble T cell-derived factors which were added as a mixture of recombinant interleukin 2 with a T cell hybridoma supernatant that augments B cell growth and differentiation. Under these conditions an antigen-independent specific increase of IgM anti-A-CHO production (2.6- to 10-fold, or up to 2000 ng/ml respectively) could be induced in blood B cell populations of four of six normal individuals expressing the Id498 at serum level.