Correlation of reaction-center chlorophyll (P-700) oxidation and bound iron-sulfur protein photoreduction in chloroplast Photosystem I at low temperatures

The extent of P-700 photooxidation at 18 °K has been followed in three different chloroplast preparations (unfractionated chloroplasts and two preparations enriched in Photosystem I). More than 90% of P-700⁺ formation in all preparations was eliminated by the addition of sodium dithionite at pH 10. Photoreduction of a bound chloroplast iron-sulfur protein was also decreased by at least 90% under similar conditions. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of the chloroplast preparations in the presence of dithionite showed chemical reduction of bound iron-sulfur protein under conditions where primary photochemistry is eliminated. These results indicate that P-700 photooxidation is concomitant with photoreduction of a bound iron-sulfur protein and that this iron-sulfur protein functions as the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I.     

Kinetics of appearance and disappearance of light-induced EPR signals of P700 and iron-sulfur protein(s) at low temperature

Light-induced changes of EPR signals in Photosystem-I subchloroplast particles at temperatures between 225 and 13 °K showed that the rates of onset of photooxidation of P700 and photoreduction of iron-sulfur protein(s) are identical and instantaneous within the limits of resolution of our instruments. The fraction of the P700⁺ EPR signal that appears reversibly decreased with decreasing temperature down to 13 °K when the photoreaction was completely irreversible. At temperatures below 225 °K, the reversible fraction consists of two approximately equal portions with decay halftimes of approx. 3 and 75 s, respectively. Light-induced absorption changes due to P700 photooxidation at low temperatures monitored at 700 nm showed a similar kinetic pattern.

Since the reduced iron-sulfur protein signals can only be detected at very low temperature, their decay kinetics cannot be continuously monitored at higher temperatures. Therefore, exposure at appropriate temperatures and reaction times were selected according to the decay kinetics of P700⁺, after which decay was stopped by lowering the temperature to 13 °K and the P700⁺ and reduced iron-sulfur protein signals were recorded and compared. In the temperature range (225-13 °K) studied, the decay of P700⁺ and reduced iron-sulfur protein signals appears identical, suggesting that the two oppositely charged species recombine in the dark. These experiments support the view that iron-sulfur protein(s) is the reaction partner of P700 in the primary photochemical act of Photosystem I.     

Flash photolysis electron spin resonance studies of the electron acceptor species at low temperatures in photosystem I of spinach subchloroplast particles.

The light-induced electron spin resonance signals of Photosystem I spinach subchloroplast particles have been studied at approximately 6 degrees K. Using the technique of flash photolysis-electron spin resonance with actinic illumination at 647 nm, a kinetic analysis of the previously observed bound ferredoxin ESR signals was carried out. Signal I (P700+) exhibits a partial light-reversible behavior at 6 degrees K so it was expected that if the bound ferredoxin is the primary acceptor of Photosystem I, it should also exhibit a partial reversible behavior. However, none of the bound ferredoxin ESR signals showed any such light reversible behavior. A search to wider fields revealed two components which did exhibit the expected kinetic behavior. These components are very broad (about 80 G) and are centered at g equals to 1.75 and g equals to 2.07. These two components exhibit the expected characteristics of the primary electron acceptor. A model is presented to account for the reversible and irreversible photochemical changes in Photosystem I. The possible identity of the primary acceptor responsible for these two new components, is discussed in terms of the available information. The primary acceptor may be an iron-sulfur protein, but not of the type characteristic of the bound or water-soluble ferredoxins found so far in chloroplasts.     

Evidence for the identity of P430 of Photosystem I and chloroplast-bound iron-sulfur protein

The EPR spectrum of Photosystem-I subchloroplast particles, which had been pre-illuminated in the presence of methyl viologen, showed a large P700⁺ signal whereas bound iron-sulfur proteins were not detected. This observation is consistent with a “one-way” electron discharge by the primary electron acceptor, P430⁻, subsequent to the primary photochemical charge separation, and an accumulation of photooxidized P700⁺. Subsequent illumination of the same sample at 77 °K did not change the EPR spectrum. However, if the pre-illuminated subchloroplast particles were allowed to recover at room temperature by standing in the dark for 10 min or by addition of a chemical reductant, subsequent illumination of the sample at 77 °K yielded an EPR spectrum consisting of signals due to both P700⁺ and reduced iron-sulfur protein.     

Flash photolysis electron spin resonance studies of the electron acceptor species at low temperatures in Photosystem I of spinach subchloroplast particles

The light-induced electron spin resonance signals of Photosystem I spinach subchloroplast particles have been studied at approximately 6 °K. Using the technique of flash photolysis-electron spin resonance with actinic illumination at 647 nm, a kinetic analysis of the previously observed bound ferredoxin ESR signals was carried out. Signal I (P700⁺) exhibits a partial light-reversible behavior at 6 °K so it was expected that if the bound ferredoxin is the primary acceptor of Photosystem I, it should also exhibit a partial reversible behavior. However, none of the bound ferredoxin ESR signals showed any such light reversible behavior. A search to wider fields revealed two components which did exhibit the expected kinetic behavior. These components are very broad (about 80 G) and are centered at g = 1.75 and g = 2.07. These two components exhibit the expected characteristics of the primary electron acceptor. A model is presented to account for the reversible and irreversible photochemical changes in Photosystem I. The possible identity of the primary acceptor responsible for these two new components, is discussed in terms of the available information. The primary acceptor may be an iron-sulfur protein, but not of the type characteristic of the bound or water-soluble ferredoxins found so far in chloroplasts.     

Primary photochemistry of Photosystem I in chloroplasts. Dynamics of reversible charge separation in open reaction centers at 25 K

The reduction rate of oxidized reaction center chlorophyll of Photosystem I after laser-flash excitation at 25 K has been determined for D-144 subchloroplast fragments and chloroplasts. A maximum of 40% of Photosystem I reaction centers undergo irreversible charge separation (P-700, Cluster A: P-700⁺, Cluster A^?) at 25 K, a percentage which is independent of laser-flash intensity. The remaining reaction centers in chloroplasts and D-144 fragments undergo reversible charge separation with biphasic recombination. Similar amplitudes and time constants (chloroplasts, 49 μs (61%); D-144 fragments, 90 μs (67%)) were obtained for the fast component, while the slower component differed considerably in time (chloroplasts, 2.9 ms; D-144 fragments, 170 ms). It is known that Fe-S Cluster A is photoreduced in less than 1 ms at 25 K. Data obtained support a model for Photosystem I involving a single intermediate in the decay path between the reduced primary electron acceptor (A^?₁) and P-700⁺ and a second intermediate in the decay path between a reduced secondary electron acceptor and P-700⁺. Dual laser-flash experiments to determine rate constants for these processes are included.     

Photochemical properties of a photosystem I subchloroplast fragment.

Treatment of spinach chloroplast fragments with the detergent lauryl dimethylamine oxide, followed by column chromatography on DEAE-cellulose, leads to the isolation of a Subchloroplast fragment that is enriched in Photosystem I. The spectrum of the lauryl dimethylamine oxide fragments, characterized by maxima at 418, 435, and 671 nm, shows the absence of chlorophyll b. The fragments contain 1 molecule of P700 per 40 chlorophyll molecules but have no cytochromes. The P700 in the fragments is photochemically active at both room temperature and liquid helium temperature. The fragments contain the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I, as evidenced by the low-temperature photoreduction of a bound iron-sulfur protein. The fragments are able to catalyze noncyclic electron transfer from ascorbate to oxygen but not to the electron acceptor NADP.     

Photoreduction of ferredoxin-NADP in the presence and absence of ferredoxin-reducing substance (FRS)

Preparations of ferredoxin-reducing substance (FRS) were obtained from spinach chloroplasts within the elution volume range and with the spectral characteristics described by Yocum and San Pietro (8). However, no support was found for the view that FRS is the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I. The FRS-depleted chloroplast fragments retained their Photosystem I activity, which was not enhanced by the addition of FRS. No evidence was found for a prior photoreduction of FRS by chloroplasts followed by a dark reduction of ferredoxin and NADP by reduced FRS. The FRS-depleted chloroplast fragments were found to retain and to photoreduce bound ferredoxin upon illumination by Photosystem I light at 25°K. These results suggest that the role of a primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I ascribed to FRS may belong to bound ferredoxin.     

PRoperties of the low-temperature photosystem I primary reaction in the P-700-chlorophyll alpha-protein.

The Photosystem I primary reaction, as measured by electron paramagnetic resonance changes of P-700 and a bound iron-sulfur center, has been studied at 15 degrees K in P-700-chlorophyll alpha-protein complexes isolated from a blue-green alga. One complex, prepared with sodium dodecyl sulfate shows P-700 photooxidation only at 300 degrees K, whereas a second complex, prepared with Triton X-100, is photochemically active at 15 degrees K as well as at 300 degrees K. Analysis of these two preparations shows that the absence of low-temperature photoactivity in the sodium dodecyl sulfate complex reflects a lack of bound iron-sulfur centers in this preparation and supports the assignment of an iron-sulfur center as the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I.     

Properties of the low-temperature Photosystem I primary reaction in the P-700-chlorophyll a-protein

The Photosystem I primary reaction, as measured by electron paramagnetic resonance changes of P-700 and a bound iron-sulfur center, has been studied at 15°K in P-700-chlorophyll a-protein complexes isolated from a blue-green alga. One complex, prepared with sodium dodecyl sulfate shows P-700 photooxidation only at 300°K, whereas a second complex, prepared with Triton X-100, is photochemically active at 15°K as well as at 300°K. Analysis of these two preparations shows that the absence of low-temperature photoactivity in the sodium dodecyl sulfate complex reflects a lack of bound iron-sulfur centers in this preparation and supports the assignment of an iron-sulfur center as the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I.     

Photochemical properties of a Photosystem II subchloroplast fragment

1. The Photosystem II fraction (D-10) obtained by incubation of spinach chloroplasts with digitonin was further purified by incubation with Triton X-100. The resulting Photosystem II subchloroplast fragment (DT-10) contained 1 mole of cytochrome b-559 per 170 moles of chlorophyll. It lacked cytochrome f and cytochrome b₆ and its content of P700 was low.

2. The DT-10 fragment showed only traces of photochemical activity with water as electron donor, but it was active in a Photosystem II reaction with 2,6-dichlorophenolindophenol as electron acceptor and diphenyl carbazide as donor. Photoreduction of NADP⁺ with diphenyl carbazide as donor was negligible. There was some photoreduction of NADP⁺ with ascorbate plus 2,6 dichlorophenolindophenol as donor but this activity could be accounted for by contamination with Photosystem I. These results are consistent with the Z-scheme of photosynthesis with Photosystems I and II operating in series for the reduction of NADP⁺ from water. DT-10 subchloroplast fragments showed a light-induced rise in fluorescence yield at 20 °C in the presence of diphenyl carbazide. A light-induced fluorescence increase also was observed at 77 °K.

3. During the preparation of the DT-10 fragment, the high potential form of cytochrome b-559 was largely converted to a form of lower potential and C-550 was converted to the reduced state. A photoreduction of C-550 was observed at liquidnitrogen temperature, provided the C-550 was oxidised with ferricyanide prior to cooling. Some photooxidation of cytochrome b-559 was obtained at 77 °K if the preparation was reduced prior to cooling, but the degree of photooxidation was variable with different preparations. C-550 does not appear to be identical with the primary fluorescence quencher, Q.

4. Photosystem I subchloroplast fragments (D-144) released by the action of digitonin were compared with Photosystem I fragments (DT-144) released from D-10 fragments by Triton X-100. There were no significant differences between D-144 and DT-144 fragments either in chlorophyll a/b ratio or in P700 content.     

Redox titration of the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I in spinach chloroplasts

The midpoint potential of the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I in spinach chloroplasts was titrated using the photooxidation of P₇₀₀ at −196 °C as an index of the amount of primary acceptor present in the oxidized state. The redox potential of the chloroplast suspension was established by the reducing power of hydrogen gas (mediated by clostridial hydrogenase and 1,1′-trimethylene-2,2′-dipyridylium dibromide) at specific pH values at 25 °C. Samples were frozen to −196 °C and the extent of the photooxidation of P₇₀₀ was determined from light-minus-dark difference spectra. This titration indicated a midpoint potential of −0.53 V for the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I.     

Evidence for the role of a bound ferredoxin as the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I in spinach chloroplasts

The presence of a bound electron transport component in spinach chloroplasts with an EPR spectrum characteristic of a ferredoxin has been confirmed. The ferredoxin is photoreduced at 77 °K or at room temperature, it is not reduced in the dark by Na₂S₂O₄. The distribution of the ferredoxin in subchloroplast particles has been investigated. The ferredoxin is enriched in Photosystem I particles and it is proposed that it functions as primary electron acceptor for Photosystem I.

The EPR spectra indicate the presence of two components which are photoreduced sequentially. It is proposed that they may represent two active centres of a single protein.     

Carboxymethylation of methionine residues in bovine pituitary luteinizing hormone and its subunits. Effects on the binding activity with receptor sites and interactions between subunits.

The properties of the component 'X' identified as the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I in spinach was investigated by electron-paramagnetic-resonance spectroscopy and the complete spectrum obtained for the first time. Component 'X' has gx = 1.78, gy = 1.88 and gz = 2.08; it can be observed only at very low temperatures (8--13K) and high microwave powers. Component X was identified in Photosystem I particles prepared with the French press or with Triton X-100. In samples reduced with ascorbate, illumination at low temperatures results in the photo-oxidation of P700 and reduction of a bound iron-sulphur protein; this is irreversible at low temperature. In samples in which the iron-sulphur proteins are reduced by sodium dithionite, illumination at low temperature results in the oxidation of P700 and the reduction of component 'X'; this is reversible at low temperature. The light-induced P700 signal is the same size with either ascorbate or dithionite as reducing agent, showing that all of the P700 involved in reduction of bound ferredoxin also functions in the reduction of component 'X'.     

Enrichment of Photosystem I reaction center chlorophyll from spinach chloroplasts

The reaction center chlorophyll of Photosystem I in spinach chloroplasts was highly enriched. Preparations having 5–9 chlorophylls per 1 P700 were obtained by treating the Photosystem I particles prepared by digitonin treatment of chloroplasts with wet diethyl ether. All P700 present in the extracted particles was found to be photoactive, undergoing oxidation upon illumination.     

The oxidation-reduction potential of the reaction-centre chlorophyll (P700) in Photosystem I. Evidence for multiple components in electron-paramagnetic-resonance signal 1 at low temperature.

The oxidation-reduction potential of the reaction-centre chlorophyll of Photosystem I (P700) in spinach chloroplasts was determined by using the ability of the reaction centre to photoreduce the bound ferredoxin and to photo-oxidize P700 on illumination at 20K as an indicator of the oxidation state of P700. This procedure shows that P700 is oxidized with Em (pH8.0)(mid-point redox potential at pH8.0)congruent to +375mV. Further oxidation of the chloroplast preparations by high concentrations of K3Fe(CN)6(10mM) in the presence of mediating dyes leads to the appearance of a large radical signal with an apparent Em congruent to +470mVA second, light-inducible, radical also appears over the same potential range. We propose that these signals are due to bulk chlorophyll oxidation and not, as was previously thought [Knaff & Malkin (1973) Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 159, 555-562], to reaction-centre oxidation. A number of optical techniques were used to determine Em of P700. Dual-wavelength spectroscopy (697-720nm) indicates Em congruent to +460-+480mV. The spectrum of the sample during the titration showed a large contribution to the signal by bulk chlorophyll oxidation, in agreement with the electron-paramagnetic-resonance results and those of Ke, Sugahara & Shaw [(1975) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 408, 12-25]. The light-induced absorbance change at 435 nm, usually attributed to P700, showed a potential dependence similar to that of bulk chlorophyll oxidation. Determination of Em of P700 on the basis of the appearance of the P700 signal in oxidized-versus-reduced difference spectra showed Em (pH8.0) congruent to +360mV. Measurements of the effect of potential on the irreversible photo-oxidation of P700 at 77K showed that P700 became oxidized in this potential range. We conclude that the reaction-centre chlorophyll of Photosystem I has Em (pH8.0) congruent to +375mV.     

Location of the iron-sulfur clusters FA and FB in photosystem I: an electron paramagnetic resonance study of spin relaxation enhancement of P700+.

Photosystem I (PS I) mediates electron-transfer from plastocyanin to ferredoxin via a photochemically active chlorophyll dimer (P700), a monomeric chlorophyll electron acceptor (A0), a phylloquinone (A1), and three [4Fe-4S] clusters (FX/A/B). The sequence of electron-transfer events between the iron-sulfur cluster, FX, and ferredoxin is presently unclear. Owing to the presence of a 2-fold symmetry in the PsaC protein to which the iron-sulfur clusters F(A) and F(B) are bound, the spatial arrangement of these cofactors with respect to the C2-axis of symmetry in PS I is uncertain as well. An unequivocal determination of the spatial arrangement of the iron-sulfur clusters FA and FB within the protein is necessary to unravel the complete electron-transport chain in PS I. In the present study, we generate EPR signals from charge-separated spin pairs (P700+-FredX/A/B) in PS I and characterize them by progressive microwave power saturation measurements to determine the arrangement of the iron-sulfur clusters FX/A/B relative to P700. The microwave power at half saturation (P1/2) of P700+ is greater when both FA and FB are reduced in untreated PS I than when only FA is reduced in mercury-treated PS I. The experimental P1/2 values are compared to values calculated by using P700-FA/B crystallographic distances and assuming that either FA or FB is closer to P700+. On the basis of this comparison of experimental and theoretical values of spin relaxation enhancement effects on P700+ in P700+ [4Fe-4S]- charge-separated pairs, we find that iron-sulfur cluster FA is in closer proximity to P700 than the FB cluster.     

Appearance of Membrane-bound Iron-Sulfur Centers and the Photosystem I Reaction Center during Greening of Barley Leaves

Dark-grown barley (Hordeum vulgare) etioplasts were examined for their content of membrane-bound iron-sulfur centers by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy at 15K. They were found to contain the high potential iron-sulfur center characterized (in the reduced state) by an electron paramagnetic resonance g value of 1.89 (the “Rieske” center) but did not contain any low potential iron-sulfur centers. Per mole of cytochrome f, dark-grown etioplasts and fully developed chloroplasts had the same content of the Rieske center. During greening of etioplasts under continuous light, low potential bound iron-sulfur centers appear. In addition, the photosystem I reaction center, as measured by the photooxidation of P700 at 15K, also became functional; during greening the appearance of a photoreducible low potential iron-sulfur center paralleled the appearance of P700 photoactivity.     

Orientation of Photosystem-I pigments: low temperature linear dichroism spectroscopy of a highly-enriched P700 particle isolated from spinach

The linear dichroism of Photosystem I particles containing 10 chlorophylls per P700 has been investigated at 10 K. The particles were oriented by uniaxial squeezing of polyacrylamide gels. The oxidation state of P700 was altered either by incubation of the gels with redox mediators or by low temperature illumination. The Q_Y transitions of the primary electron donor P700, of the remaining unoxidized chlorophyll in P700⁺ and of a chlorophyll molecule absorbing at 686 nm, which presumably corresponds to the primary electron acceptor A₀, are all preferentially oriented perpendicular to the gel squeezing direction. The Q_Y transition of the chlorophyll forms absorbing at 670 and 675 nm appear tilted at 40 ± 5° from this orientation axis. This orientation of the various chlorophylls is compared to that previously reported for more native Photosystem I particles.Abbreviations PSI Photosystem I - P700 primary electron donor of PSI - A₀ primary electron acceptor of PSI     

Light-induced absorbance changes in chloroplasts mediated by Photosystem I and Photosystem II at low temperature

Stable light-induced absorbance changes in chloroplasts at −196 °C were measured across the visible spectrum from 370 to 730 nm in an effort to find previously undiscovered absorbance changes that could be related to the primary photochemical activity of Photosystem I or Photosystem II. A Photosystem I mediated absorbance increase of a band at 690 nm and a Photosystem II mediated absorbance increase of a band at 683 nm were found. The 690-nm change accompanied the oxidation of P₇₀₀ and the 683-nm increase accompanied the reduction of C-550. No Soret band was detected for P₇₀₀.

A specific effort was made to measure the difference spectrum for the photooxidation of P₆₈₀ under conditions (chloroplasts frozen to −196 °C in the presence of ferricyanide) where a stable, Photosystem II mediated EPR signal, attributed to P₆₈₀⁺ has been reported. The difference spectra, however, did not show that P₆₈₀⁺ was stable at −196 °C under any conditions tested. Absorbance measurements induced by saturating flashes at −196 °C (in the presence or absence of ferricyanide) indicated that all of the P₆₈₀⁺ formed by the flash was reduced in the dark either by a secondary electron donor or by a backreaction with the primary electron acceptor. We conclude that P₆₈₀⁺ is not stable in the dark at −196 °C: if the normal secondary donor at −196 °C is oxidized by ferricyanide prior to freezing, P₆₈₀⁺ will oxidize other substances.