Synergistic toxicity between arsenic and methylated selenium compounds

Arsenite has been known for half a century to have a protective effect against selenium poisoning. Paradoxically, arsenite inhibits the conversion of inorganic selenium salts to methylated excretory products, although methylation has long been regarded as a detoxification mechanism for selenium. Moreover, there is evidence for a pronounced synergistic toxicity between arsenite and methylated selenium metabolites. We investigated the effect of arsenite on the acute toxicity of a variety of methylated or nonmethylated selenium compounds, as well as methylated forms of sulfur and tellurium. Adult male rats were injected with sodium arsenite (4 mg As/kg bw, s.c.) 10 min prior to injection of the test compounds; at the doses employed, none of the test compounds caused mortality, nor did arsenite, when given alone. When given with arsenite, the following methylated compounds produced toxic signs and high morality at the indicated dosages (mg Se/kg): Methylseleninic acid (2), dimethylselenoxide (2), trimethylselenonium chloride (3), selenobetaine (2), selenobetaine methylester (2, also 1 and 0.5), and Se-methylselenocysteine (2). Toxic signs but not mortality occurred when arsenite was given with selenomethionine (2 mg Se/kg). No enhancement of toxic signs or mortality occurred when arsenite was given with sulfobetaine (0.8 mg S/kg), dimethylsulfide (320 mg S/kg), or the following (nonmethylated) forms of selenium: sodium selenite (2), selenocystine (2), and phenylselenol (2). Arsenite also increased the toxicity of trimethyltelluronium chloride (4.8 mg Te/kg). Like arsenite, periodate-oxidized adenosine (100 mumoles/kg), which is known to inhibit the formation of dimethylselenide and trimethylselenonium ion in vivo, caused increased 24 h mortality when given with various methylated selenium compounds.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Interaction between some common genotoxic agents

The clastogenic effects of arsenic, lead and sulphur dioxide and the protective effect of selenium were studied in short-term lymphocyte cultures. The three agents selected are the major toxic substances in emissions from copper smelters. Cells from non-smoking, healthy individuals were exposed to individual agents and combinations of the four agents (sodium arsenite, lead acetate, sodium sulphite and sodium selenite) and the cells were analysed for chromosome aberrations and sister chromatide exchanges. Selenium showed an antagonistic (protective) effect against the other agents. No synergistic effects were found, and the interactions between arsenic, lead and sulphur dioxide were mainly antagonistic. These rather unexpected findings indicate that mixed exposure from copper smelters, and other mixed exposures where arsenic, lead and sulphur dioxide are involved, may cause less genetic damage than expected and that an adequate dietary supplement of selenium may reduce the genotoxic effects of these agents.     

Arsenic suppresses necrosis induced by selenite in human leukemia HL-60 cells

Selenium, an essential trace element for humans, has been shown to have anticancer effects. Arsenic, a possibly essential ultratrace element for humans, has been used in the treatment of leukemia. Anticancer effects of selenium and arsenic have been related to their ability to induce apoptosis. Because humans are exposed to diverse trace elements simultaneously, it is important to learn their interrelationship. In this study, we demonstrate that sodium selenite (Na₂SeO₃) causes apoptosis at 3 μM and necrosis at high concentrations (>3 μM) in HL-60 cells. Similarly, both sodium arsenite (NaAsO₂) at 50 μM and sodium arsenate (Na₂HAsO₄) induce apoptosis at 500 μM and necrosis at higher concentrations (>50 μM and >500 μM, respectively) in HL-60 cells. Arsenite/arsenate, but not selenite, enhances AP-1 DNA-binding activity. This finding indicates different mechanisms through which apoptosis is induced by these two elements. Interestingly, we observed that HL-60 cell necrosis induced by a high concentration (>3 μM) of selenite was essentially inhibited by arsenic (50 μM of NaAsO₂ or 500 μM of Na₂HAsO₄), which resulted in a net effect of apoptosis. Because AP-1 DNA-binding activity was not induced in the presence of a combination of necrotic amount of selenite and apoptotic amount of arsenite/arsenate, the observed apoptosis apparently was through the mechanism used by selenite. Our results suggest, for the first time, that the toxic necrotic effect of selenite can be neutralized by arsenite/arsenate at the cellular level. The U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Northern Plains Area, is an equal opportunity/affirmative action employer and all agency services are available without discrimination. Mention of a trademark or proprietary product does not constitute a guarantee or warranty of the product by the U.S. Department of Agriculture and does not imply its approval to the exclusion of other products that may also be suitable.     

Selenium antagonizes the induction of human heme oxygenase by arsenite and cadmium ions.

Effects of selenium compounds on the induction of heme oxygenase in human cells exposed to sodium arsenite or cadmium chloride have been investigated by an immunoblotting technique. Exposure of HeLa cells to arsenite or cadmium ions caused a marked increase in the synthesis of heme oxygenase, and the presence of sodium selenite suppressed the induction. DL-Selenocystine was an effective suppressor, and sodium selenate was less effective. DL-Selenomethionine had no effect. Northern blot analysis showed that selenite abolished the induction of heme oxygenase mRNA in the cells exposed to arsenite or cadmium ions. These results indicated that selenium antagonizes the induction of heme oxygenase by heavy metals ions.     

Comparison of clastogenic effects of inorganic selenium salts in mice in vivo as related to concentrations and duration of exposure

Inorganic selenium compounds in the diet have been known to protect against cancer in laboratory animals, but were harmful in high concentrations. In the present work, the relative effects of two salts, sodium selenite and sodium selenate, administered to mice in vivo, in different concentrations and durations of exposure, were compared. Aqueous solutions of each salt (7, 14, 21 and 28 mg Kg^–1 bw) were fed by gavaging to mice matched in age and sex. The animals were sacrificed at intervals of 6, 12, 18 and 24 h and chromosome preparations were made following the usual schedule of colchicine-hypotonic-fixative-airdrying-Giemsa staining. The endpoints screened were chromosomal aberrations (CA) and damaged cells (DC). Both salts affected chromosome structure and spindle formation, sodium selenite being more cytotoxic than sodium selenate. The frequencies of aberrations induced were directly proportional to the concentrations used and duration of exposure.     

Biological effects of a nano red elemental selenium.

A novel selenium form, nano red elemental selenium (Nano-Se) was prepared by adding bovine serum albumin to the redox system of selenite and glutathione. Nano-Se has a 7-fold lower acute toxicity than sodium selenite in mice (LD(50) 113 and 15 mg Se/kg body weight respectively). In Se-deficient rat, both Nano-Se and selenite can increase tissue selenium and GPx activity. The biological activities of Nano-Se and selenite were compared in terms of cell proliferation, enzyme induction and protection against free racial-mediated damage in human hepatoma HepG2 cells. Nano-Se and selenite are similarly cell growth inhibited and stimulated synthesis of glutathione peroxidase (GPx), phospholipid hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidase (PHGPx) and thioredoxin reductase (TR). When HepG2 cells were co-treated with selenium and glutathione, Nano-Se showed less pro-oxidative effects than selenite, as measured by cell growth. These results demonstrate that Nano-Se has a similar bioavailability in the rat and antioxidant effects on cells.     

Influence of antimonite, selenite, and mercury on the toxicity of arsenite in primary rat hepatocytes

The long-term toxicity of arsenic (As) as a result of exposure to contaminated drinking water might be modified by coinciding exposures to elements like selenium, antimony, or mercury. In this study the influence of tetravalent selenite, trivalent antimonite, and divalent mercury was investigated in vitro using cultured primary rat hepatocytes. The cell vitality was assessed in the 3-[4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide] (MTT), assay with concurrent exposures of the cells to up to 50 microM sodium arsenite(III) and a potential modifier [50 microM sodium(IV) selenite, 10 microM antimony(III) chloride, 25 microM mercuric(II) chloride], which indicated an additive increase in the combined cytotoxicity. Sodium arsenite was tested for genotoxicity in the micronucleus test in a concentration range of 0.25 up to 7.5 microM. In this range, the MTT conversion was at least 80%, indicating high cell viability. Adose-dependent induction of micronuclei was observed. The lowest concentration causing a significantly elevated frequency of micronuclei was 1 microM As (p < 0.05). A significant influence (i.e., reduction of the combined genotoxicity as a result of the presence of a potential modifier) was only observed for 10 and 25 microM antimony chloride (p < 0.05, Fisher's exact test). The metabolic methylation of arsenite was not affected by concurrent incubation with any of the potential modifiers.     

Extracellular production of hydrogen selenide accounts for thiol-assisted toxicity of selenite against Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Administration of selenium in humans has anticarcinogenic effects. However, the boundary between cancer-protecting and toxic levels of selenium is extremely narrow. The mechanisms of selenium toxicity need to be fully understood. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, selenite in the millimolar range is well tolerated by cells. Here we show that the lethal dose of selenite is reduced to the micromolar range by the presence of thiols in the growth medium. Glutathione and selenite spontaneously react to produce several selenium-containing compounds (selenodiglutathione, glutathioselenol, hydrogen selenide, and elemental selenium) as well as reactive oxygen species. We studied which compounds in the reaction pathway between glutathione and sodium selenite are responsible for this toxicity. Involvement of selenodiglutathione, elemental selenium, or reactive oxygen species could be ruled out. In contrast, extracellular formation of hydrogen selenide can fully explain the exacerbation of selenite toxicity by thiols. Indeed, direct production of hydrogen selenide with D-cysteine desulfhydrase induces high mortality. Selenium uptake by S. cerevisiae is considerably enhanced in the presence of external thiols, most likely through internalization of hydrogen selenide. Finally, we discuss the possibility that selenium exerts its toxicity through consumption of intracellular reduced glutathione, thus leading to severe oxidative stress.     

Toxicity,bioavailability and metal speciation

1. Environmental toxicology emphasizes the difference from traditional toxicology in which pure compounds of interest are added to purified diets, or injected into the test animals. When the objective is to study the fate and effects of trace elements in the environment, knowledge of the speciation of the elements and their physico-chemical forms is important.2. Cadmium salts such as the sulfides, carbonates or oxides, are practically insoluble in water. However, these can be converted to water-soluble salts in nature under the influence of oxygen and acids. Chronic exposure to Cd is associated with renal toxicity in humans once a critical body burden is reached.3. The solubility of As(III) oxide in water is fairly low, but high in either acid or alkali. In water, arsenic is usually in the form of the arsenate or arsenite. As(III) is systemically more poisonous than the As(V), and As(V) is reduced to the As(III) form before exerting any toxic effects. Organic arsenicals also exert their toxic effects in vivo in animals by first metabolizing to the trivalent arsenoxide form. Some methyl arsenic compounds, such as di- and trimethylarsines, occur naturally as a consequence of biological activity. The toxic effect of arsenite can be potentiated by dithiols, while As has a protective effect against the toxicity of a variety of forms of Se in several species.4. Selenium occurs in several oxidation states and many selenium analogues of organic sulfur compounds exist in nature. Selenium in selenate form occurs in alkaline soils, where it is soluble and easily available to plants. Selenite binds tightly to iron and aluminum oxides and thus is quite insoluble in soils. Hydrogen selenide is a very toxic gas at room temperature. The methylated forms of Se are much less toxic for the organism than selenite. However, the methylated Se derivatives have strong synergistic toxicity with other minerals such as arsenic.5. Aquatic organisms absorb and retain Hg in the tissues, as methylmercury, although most of the environmental Hg to which they are exposed is inorganic. The methylmercury in fish arises from the bacterial methylation of inorganic Hg. Methylmercury in the human diet is almost completely absorbed into the bloodstream. The nervous system is the principal target tissue affected by methylmercury in adult human beings, while kidney is the critical organ following the ingestion of Hg(II) salts.     

Mechanisms of arsenic-induced cell transformation

Arsenic is a well-established carcinogen in humans, but there is little evidence for its carcinogenicity in animals and it is inactive as an initiator or tumor promoter in two-stage models of carcinogenicity in mice. Studies with cells in culture have provided some possible mechanisms by which arsenic and arsenical compounds may exert a carcinogenic activity. Sodium arsenite and sodium arsenate were observed to induce morphological transformation of Syrian hamster embryo cells in a dose-dependent manner. The trivalent sodium arsenite was greater than tenfold more potent than the pentavalent sodium arsenate. The compounds also exhibited toxicity; however, transformation was observed at nontoxic as well as toxic doses. At low doses, enhanced colony forming efficiency of the cells was observed. To understand the mechanism of arsenic-induced transformation, the genetic effects of the two arsenicals were examined over the same doses that induced transformation. No arsenic-induced gene mutations were detected at two genetic loci. However, cell transformation and cytogenetic effects, including endoreduplication, chromosome aberrations, and sister chromatid exchanges, were induced by the arsenicals with similar dose responses. These results support a possible role for chromosomal changes in arsenic-induced transformation. The two arsenic salts also induced another form of mutation-gene amplification. Both sodium arsenite and sodium arsenate induced a high frequency of methotrexate-resistant 3T6 cells, which were shown to have amplified copies of the dihydrofolate reductase gene. The ability of arsenic to induce gene amplification may relate to its carcinogenic effects in humans since amplification of oncogenes is observed in many human tumors. Epidemiological studies suggest that arsenic acts late in the carcinogenic process in humans and oncogene amplification correlates with the progression of tumors. These observations lead us to propose the hypothesis that arsenic acts as a tumor progressor, rather than a tumor initiator or tumor promoter. Arsenic-induced chromosome aberrations or gene amplifications may play a role in tumor progression.     

Selenoprotein expression is regulated at multiple levels in prostate cells

Selenium supplementation in a population with low basal blood selenium levels has been reported to decrease the incidence of several cancers including prostate cancer. Based on the clinical findings, it is likely that the antioxidant function of one or more selenoproteins is responsible for the chemopreventive effect, although low molecular weight seleno-compounds have also been posited to selectively induce apoptosis in transformed cells. To address the effects of selenium supplementation on selenoprotein expression in prostate cells, we have undertaken an analysis of antioxidant selenoprotein expression as well as selenium toxicity in non-tumorigenic prostate epithelial cells （RWPE- 1 ） and prostate cancer cells （LNCaP and PC-3）. Our results show that two of the glutathione peroxidase family members （GPX1 and GPX4） are highly induced by supplemental selenium in prostate cancer cells but only slightly induced in RWPE-1 cells. In addition, GPX 1 levels are dramatically lower in PC-3 cells as compared to RWPE- 1 or LNCaP cells. GPX2 protein and mRNA, however, are only detectable in RWPE-1 cells. Of the three selenium compounds tested （sodium selenite, sodium selenate and selenomethionine）, only sodium selenite shows toxicity in a physiological range of selenium concentrations. Notably and in contrast to previous studies, RWPE-1 cells were significantly more sensitive to selenite than either of the prostate cancer cell lines. These results demonstrate that selenoproteins and selenium metabolism are regulated at multiple levels in prostate cells.     

Effect of vitamin E supplementation on arsenic induced alteration in blood biochemical profile,oxidant/antioxidant status,serum cortisol level and retention of arsenic and selenium in goats

Arsenic (As) exerts oxidative stress with depletion of body selenium in monogastric animals. But in ruminants this fact is not yet verified. Vitamin E is an effective dietary antioxidant. Thus, in this experiment, the protective effect of vitamin E against arsenic toxicity induced by sodium arsenite (60 mg As/kg diet) was investigated in goat kids. For this, 21 male kids were divided into three equal groups and fed either basal diet as such (control), or supplemented with 60 mg As/kg diet and 60 mg As/kg diet + 250 IU vitamin E/kg diet for 180 days. Vitamin E supplementation alleviated the toxic effects caused by arsenic on serum alanine aminotransferase and aspartate aminotransferase and lipid peroxidation. It also prevented the depletion of reduced glutathione content and reduction in activity of catalase, superoxide dismutase and glutathione-s-transferase in erythrocytes resulted from arsenic intoxication. The elevated levels of arsenic and reduced levels of selenium in the serum and tissues in arsenic treated animals were attenuated by vitamin E supplementation, though not completely. However, serum cortisol level was not affected by arsenic. It was concluded that arsenic exerts cortisol independent stressor mechanism and supplementation of vitamin E at a level of 250 IU/kg diet was partially effective in reducing tissue accumulation of arsenic in the body and protect the kids from oxidative stress induced by arsenic.     

Toxicity of selenium to Lemna minor in relation to sulfate concentration

The aquatic plant Lemna minor L. was treated with sodium selenite or sodium selenate to test the toxicity of these salts in relation to high or low levels of sulfate in the culture medium. Several morphophysiological aspects, such as multiplication rate (MR), ratio of the number of fronds to number of colonies (Nfr/Ncol), frond size, cell ultrastructure, pigment content and guaiacol peroxidase (EC 1.11.1.7) activity were evaluated. Their variations might be an indirect means of evaluating the degree of susceptibility or tolerance of this plant to selenium (Se). Sodium selenite or sodium selenate treatments at concentrations ranging from 1 to 256 μ M generally decreased the investigated parameters. Moreover, the sulfate concentration influenced the toxicity of both Se salts. In general, with treatments in a medium containing a high sulfate (HS) content, sodium selenite appeared more toxic than sodium selenate, whereas in a low sulfate (LS) medium, sodium selenate seemed more toxic. MR was significantly increased at 1–4 μ M selenite and LS or 8 μ M selenate and HS levels, suggesting that Se may be an essential nutrient for this plant.     

培养方式对富硒产朊假丝酵母性能的影响

在摇瓶和5 L发酵罐水平上分别考察亚硒酸钠浓度及其添加方式对高性能(高有机硒含量和高谷胱甘肽含量)富硒产朊假丝酵母制备的影响.结果表明:亚硒酸钠添加质量浓度为15 mg/L时,产朊假丝酵母具有较好的富硒效果,但一次性添加对酵母细胞有较大的毒害作用.采用分批次添加亚硒酸钠的方法获得了较好的制备高性能富硒产朊假丝酵母的培养方式:发酵起始添加L-蛋氨酸10 mmol/L,并在发酵过程的12和15 h分别添加亚硒酸钠10和5 mg/L.在此培养方式下,产朊假丝酵母胞内谷胱甘肽和有机硒含量分别达到172.3 mg/L和1194 μg/g.     

Arsenite induces apoptosis in chinese hamster ovary cells by generation of reactive oxygen species

Arsenic, a human carcinogen, possesses a serious environmental threat but the mechanism of its toxicity remains unclear. Knowledge of how arsenic induces cell death and how cells escape the death path may help to understand arsenic carcinogenesis. We have investigated the nature of sodium arsenite-induced cell death in Chinese hamster ovary K1 cells. Following phosphate-citric acid buffer extraction, apoptotic cells with lower DNA content than the G1 cells were detected by flow cytometry. Immediately after 4 h of 40 μM arsenite treatment, no appreciable fraction of cells with sub-G1 DNA content was detected; however, the sub-G1 cell fraction increased with postarsenite incubation time, and detectable increase started at 8 h of incubation, whereas the intracellular peroxide level as measured by the fluorescent intensity of 2′,7′-dichlorofluorescein increased immediately following a 4-h arsenite treatment. Simultaneous treatment with arsenite plus antioxidant (N-acetyl-cysteine, Trolox, and Tempo); copper ion chelator (neocuproine); protein kinase inhibitor (H-7) or protein synthesis inhibitor (cycloheximide) reduced the fraction of sub-G1 cell and internucleosomal DNA degradation. Trolox, neocuproine, or cycloheximide given after arsenite treatment also effectively reduced apoptosis. These results lead to a working hypothesis that arsenite-induced apoptosis in CHO-K1 cells is triggered by the generation of hydrogen peroxide, followed by a copper-mediated Fenton reaction that catalyzes the production of hydroxyl radicals, which selectively activates protein kinase through de novo synthesis of macromolecules. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The Decrease of Relative Weight,Lesions, and Apoptosis of Bursa of Fabricius Induced by Excess Dietary Selenium in Chickens

Selenium is an essential trace element possessing immune-stimulatory properties. The purpose of this 42-day study was to investigate the effects of excess dietary sodium selenite on immune function by determining morphological changes and apoptosis of bursa of Fabricius. Three hundred 1-day-old Avian broilers were fed on a basic diet (0.2 ppm selenium) or the same diet amended to contain 1, 5, 10, and 15 ppm selenium supplied as sodium selenite (n = 60/group). Relative weight of bursa was significantly decreased in the 1, 5, 10, and 15 ppm groups at 28 days of age, when compared with that of 0.2 ppm group. Pathological lesions were progressed with the dietary Se level increased. The gross lesions of bursa involved obvious atrophy with decreased volume and pale color. Histopathologically, decreased number of lymphocytes and loosely packed lymphocytes appeared in the medulla and cortex in the follicles. Ultrastructurally, mitochondria injury and increased apoptotic cells with condensed nuclei were observed. In comparison to that of control group, excess Se (5, 10, and 15 ppm) intake increased the percentage of Annexin V positive cells, as measured by flow cytometry. Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase 2′-deoxyuridine 5′-triphosphate nick end-labeling assay showed that there were increased frequencies of apoptotic cells in 10 and 15 ppm selenium groups. These data suggest that Se supplementation with sodium selenite should be carefully evaluated as excess selenium (more than 5 ppm) intake could cause profound immunologic inhibition.     

Selenite or selenomethionine interaction with methylmercury on uptake and toxicity showing a weak selenite protection: studies on cultured K-562 cells

Selenium and methylmercuric chloride (MMC) interactions regarding cellular uptake and selenium protection on MMC toxicity have been studied. Human K-562 cells were pretreated or simultaneously treated with either selenite (5 or 50 μM) or selenomethionine (10 or 50 μM) together with (3.5 or 5 μM) MMC. Cells simultaneously treated with selenite or selenomethionine and 3.5 μM MMC showed a decreased mercury concentration with increased selenium dose especially seen in the selenite combinations. The simultaneous selenite and MMC 3.5 μM combinations showed growth curves with an increasing number of viable cells with increased selenite dose. All combinations with 5 μM MMC were toxic to the cells. Interactions between selenite or selenomethionine and MMC regarding cellular uptake of mercury and selenium were observed and indications of selenite protection against MMC toxicity in human K-562 cells were noticed.     

Effect of dietary copper on selenium toxicity in Fischer 344 rats

The purpose of this study was to investigate the ameliorating effects of dietary copper supplementation on selenium toxicity. Nine groups (n = 6) of weanling Fischer 344 female rats were randomly assigned to treatment groups and fed diets containing nontoxic levels of copper as CuCl2 and/or selenium as selenite or selenocystamine. Weight gain, liver and spleen weights, plasma lipid peroxidation, and liver selenium and copper content were analyzed after the 6-wk treatment period. Concentrations of up to 10 times the daily lethal dose of dietary selenium were well tolerated in rats supplemented with dietary copper. As the dietary level of selenium was increased, the ratio of selenium to copper measured in the liver decreased. In the groups of rats in which dietary copper supplementation was absent and dietary selenium was supplemented, copper stores in the liver remained unchanged from control values. Copper's protective effects from dietary selenium toxicity may come from the formation of a copper-selenide complex that renders both selenium and copper metabolically unavailable and nontoxic.     

Plasmid-determined resistance to arsenic and antimony inPseudomonas aeruginosa

Resistance to arsenic salts in aPseudomonas aeruginosa clinical isolate was shown to be determined by a 100 kb transferable plasmid. The resistance pattern included arsenate, arsenite, and antimonate ions. Arsenate and arsenite resistances were inducible by previous exposure of cultures to subinhibitory amounts of either of the two ions. Phosphate ions protectedP. aeruginosa cells from the toxic effects of arsenate but did not alter arsenite toxicity.