Laboratory culture and taxonomy of two species ofDerbesia (Class Chlorophyceae) in Japan

Two species ofDerbesia (Class Chlorophyceae),D. marina andD. tenuissima, have been studied for the purpose of obtaining a better understanding of their morphological details and life histories, using preserved and living specimens as well as laboratory cultures. The life histories of both species were completed in the laboratory, starting from both zoospores and zygotes. Specimens were collected at Asamushi, Aomori-ken, and Shimoda, Shizuoka-ken. Their life history types are fundamentally identical, zoospores giving rise upon germination toa Halicystis-phase, while zygotes grow into aDerbesia-phase. The thallus of theHalicystis-phase which alternates withD. marina is the same as that ofH. ovalis which grows in the northern regions of Japan. On the other hand, the thallus of theHalicystis-phase alternating withD. tenuissima is the same as that ofH. parvula known to occur in the temperate to subtropical regions of Japan. These results coincide with those obtained withD. marina andD. tenuissima in Europe, where the type localities of both species are located. Specimens assignable to these two species were collected at several localities in Japan and, as a result of detailed examination of the morphology, they are believed to be identical with eitherD. marina orD. tenuissima.     

Zur Biochemie und Regulation des heteromorphen Generationswechsels der Grünalge Derbesia-Halicystis

Summary During the life cycle of the green marine alga Derbesia marina-Halicystix ovalis, a diploid filamentous sporophyte called Derbesia alternates with a haploid spherical gametophyte called Halicystis. Beside this wild type a so-called mutant and a parthenogenetic enogenetic form stand at our disposal. The mutant is a haploid form with a Derbesia-like morphology. The morphology of the parthenogenetic form is also very similar to that of Derbesia. Biochemically sporophyte and gametophyte are characterized by a different cell-wall composition and enzyme pattern. The main polysaccharide of the cell wall of the sporophyte (Derbesia) is a mannan, whereas the cell wall of the gametophyte is built up mainly of glucose- and xylose-containing polysaccharides. The cell wall composition of the mutant is nearly identical with that of the Derbesia wild type. On the other hand the parthogenetic form lies to a certain degree between Derbesia and Halicystis with respect to its cell wall composition. Differences in enzyme pattern exist especially in the enzymes of GDPM- and mannan synthesis. These enzymes are present in high activities in Derbesia, the mutant, and the parthogenetic form but are absent or present only with very small activities in Halicystis. From these results we conclude that the differences in morphology, cell wall composition and enzyme pattern between the sporophyte (Derbesia) and the gametophyte (Halicystis) are brought about by a relatively stable pattern of gene activity which is changed only during the formation or the out-growth of the zoospores and the formation or fusion of gametes (see discussion).

---

Abkürzungen ADPG-Pyr Adenosindiphosphat-glucose-Pyrophosphorylase E.C.2.7.7.b - F-6-P Fructose-6-phosphat - GDPM Guanosindiphosphat-mannose - GDPM-Pyr GDPM-Pyrophosphorylase E.C. 2.7.7.13 - Gluconat-6-P-DH Gluconat-6-phosphat-Dehydrogenase E.C-1.1.1.44 - G-1,6-P Glucose-1,6-diphosphat - G-6-P-DH Glucose-6-phosphat-Dehydrogenase E.C. 1.1.1.49 - M-1-P Mannose-1-phosphat - M-1,6-P Mannose-1,6-diphosphat - PGI Phosphoglucose-Isomerase E.C. 5.3.1.9 - PGM Phosphogluco-Mutase E.C. 2.7.5.1 - PMI Phosphomannose-Isomerase E.C. 5.3.1.8 - PMM Phosphomannose-Mutase - TRAP Triäthanolamin-Puffer - UDPG Uridindiphosphat-glucose - UDPG-DH UDPG-Dehydrogenase E.C. 1.1.1.22 - UDPG-4-Epi UDPG-4-Epimerase E.C. 5.1.3.2 - UDPG-Pyr UDPG-Pyrophosphorylase E.C. 2.7.7.9 - UDPXyl Uridindiphosphat-xylose     

REPRODUCTION AND SYSTEMATICS OF THE MARINE ALGA DERBESIA (CHLOROPHYCEAE) IN NEW ENGLAND1,2

The morphology, gross cytology, reproduction, and habitat ecology are described for Derbesia marina based on observations of New England field populations and laboratory cultures of this plant. These data, and additional observations on cultures of several other species of Derbesia from elsewhere and on type and other important collections, have been used to evaluate the systematic relationship of New England Derbesia with other species of this genus. The single Derbesia species in New England is referred to D. marina. The systematic criteria previously used to distinguish species within Derbesia are reviewed and interpreted within the context of the present investigation. In systematic studies, we stress the importance of the use of sporangial and chloroplast morphology, the presence or absence of pyrenoids, and reproductive history. Two types of life history are reported for D. marina in New England: (1) A form of D. marina collected at 20 m reproduces directly with stephanokontous zoospores growing into sporophytic plants of Derbesia morphologically identical to their parent thalli. (2) On the other hand, at least some New England, populations of D. marina have retained the genetic potential for producing a sexual generation (Halicystis ovalis), even though the latter is unknown for the coast of northeastern North America.³ Gametophytes (H. ovalis) were produced directly from enlargement and subsequent differentiation of uncleaved lateral sporangia in 2 cultured populations of New England D. marina. A single female and numerous male vesicles formed in this manner produced gametes, but neither fertilization nor parthenogenesis occurred; thus the entire life history was not completed in culture. The occurrence of the directly reproducing deep water form of D. marina is presented as evidence for speciation of a sporophyte (Derbesia) independent of its alternate gametophyte (Halicystis). An hypothesis is advanced to explain the source and means for expression of genetic variability necessary for speciation in a population of nonsexually reproducing Derbesia.     

Characterization of zoospore and cyst surface structure in saprophytic and fish pathogenicSaprolegnia species (oomycete fungal protists)

Summary The importance of the surface structure and chemistry in zoospores and cysts of oomycetes is briefly reviewed and the organelle systems associated with encystment described. The surface structure and chemistry of primary and secondary zoospores and cysts ofSaprolegnia diclina (a representative saprophytic species) andS. parasitica (a representative salmonid fish pathogen) were explored using the lectins concanavilin A (Con A) and wheat germ agglutinin (WGA) and monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) raised against a mixed zoospore and cyst suspension ofS. parasitica. The binding of lectins and antibodies to spores was determined using immunofluorescence microscopy with fluorescein isothiocyanate-labelled probes and with electron microscopy with gold-conjugated probes applied to spore suspensions post-fixation. In both species Con A, which is specific for glucose and mannose sugars, bound to both the surface of primary and secondary zoospores (the surface glycocalyx) and their cyst coats and readily induced zoospore encystment. The binding to the cysts appeared to be mainly associated with the matrix material released from the primary and secondary encystment vesicles and which appeared to diminish with time. No binding to germ tube walls was observed with this lectin. The MAb labelling showed a generally similar binding pattern to the primary and secondary cysts to that observed with Con A, although the binding to zoospores was more variable. Primary zoospores bound the antibodies but secondary zoospores appeared less reactive. It is suggested that the MAbs share a common epitope with one or more of the Con A-binding components. In both species WGA, which is specific for amongst other things the sugar N-acetyl glucosamine, bound to localised apical patches on the primary zoospores. This lectin also binds to the ventral groove region of secondary zoospores ofS. diclina, which were induced to encyst by this lectin. In contrast secondary zoospores ofS. parasitica were not induced to encyst by the addition of WGA and showed a patchy dorsal binding with this lectin. WGA also binds to both the inner wall of discharged primary cysts and the young germ tube walls of both species. These observations are discussed both in relation to other oomycete spores and to their possible functional and ecological significance.Abbreviations BSA bovine serum albumin - Con A Concanavalin A - DBA Dolichos biflorus agglutinin - ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay - EM electron microscope - EV encystment vesicles - FCS foetal calf serum - FITC Fluorescein isothiocyanate - FV peripheral fibrillar vesicles - G+F 0.2% glutaraldehyde and 2.0% formaldehyde primary fixative solution - 2G 2% glutaraldehyde primary fixative - LM light microscopy - MAbs monoclonal antibodies - LPV large peripheral vesicles - PBS phosphate buffered saline - PCV flattened peripheral cisternae - PEV primary encystment vesicle - PIPES piperazine-N,N1-bis(2-ethane sulfonic acid) - PNA Ricinus communis agglutinin - RAM-FITC/Au_10–20 Fluorescein isothiocyanate/gold (10 or 20 nm) labelled rabbit anti-mouse immunoglobulin - RCA Ricinus communis agglutinin - SEM scanning electron micrograph - SBA soybean agglutinin - SEV secondary encystment vesicles - TEM transmission electron micrograph - UEA I Ulex europaeus agglutinin - WGA wheat germ agglutinin     

Ultrastructure of chytridiomycete and oomycete zoospores using spray-freeze fixation

Summary The ultrastructure of zoospores of several zoosporic fungi was examined using a modified cryofixation technique. An atomizer was used to spray a zoospore suspension into the cold propane reservoir of a conventional plunge freeze-substitution apparatus. Spray-freeze fixation and freeze-substitution of zoospores porvided better fixation of vacuolar structures, membranes and the extracellular coat than that obtained with chemical fixation. The overall shape of cryofixed spores was closer to that seen in living zoospores. Two types of vacuoles were seen in cryofixed zoospores ofMonoblepharella andChytridium. One type of vacuole contained electron-opaque material within the lumen while the other type had no visible internal material in the lumen and appeared to be part of the water expulsion vacuole complex. Coated pits and coated vesicles were observed associated with both the water expulsion vacuoles and the plasma membrane inMonoblepharella andPhytophthora, suggesting that endocytosis of the plasma membrane and expulsion vacuoles is part of membrane recycling during osmoregulatory events. An extracellular coat was seen on the outer surface of cryofixed zoospores ofMonoblepharella sp.,Chytridium confervae andPhytophthora palmivora without the use of carbohydrate-specific stains. The spray-freeze method gave good and reproducible fixation of the wall-less spores in quantities greater than those obtained in previously described zoospore cryofixation studies. The technique is potentially useful for cell suspensions in that freeze damage from excess water is limited.Abbreviations ddH₂O deionized distilled water - PME Pipes/MgCl2/EGTA buffer - WEV water expulsion vacuole     

Comparative cytology and taxonomy of theUlvaphyceae II. Ulvalean characteristics of the stephanokont flagellar apparatus ofDerbesia tenuissima

Summary The stephanokont flagellar apparatus of the zoospores ofDerbesia tenuissima (De Not.) Crouan is examined and compared to the flagellar apparatuses of other green algae. The flagella ofDerbesia are attached to two of three bands which lie at the junction of the body and papilla. Serial longitudinal and cross sections reveal that the basal bodies are attached to the bands along their sides and at their proximal ends. The bands are not striated in any plane. The lack of striation in the bands and the partial covering of the proximal end of the basal bodies by one of the bands closely resemble the type of flagellar connection system described as the Bryopsis-type byMelkonian (1980). Zoospores of ulvalean green algae also possess these features, suggesting that green siphons are phylogenetically related to theUlvales. It is proposed that green siphons be tentatively classified in theUlvaphyceae rather than in theChlorophyceae orCharophyceae.This work supported by NSF Grant DEB 78-03554.     

THE ULTRASTRUCTURE OF MEIOSPORES OF COLEOCHAETE PULVINATA (CHAROPHYCEAE)1

In view of the relative importance of reproductive cell ultrastructure in phylogenetic and systematic studies of green algae, we investigated the fine structure of germinating zygotes and meiospores of Coleochaete pulvinata Braun. Meiospores have a flagellar apparatus very similar to that of zoospores and spermatozoids of the same species. Meiospores differ from zoospores and spermatozoids of C. pulvinata in having pyramidal body scales similar to those present on zoospores of C. scutata. Meiospores of C. pulvinata had as many as twice the number of spline microtubules as zoospores, and four times the number present in splines of spermatozoids of the same species. Developing meiospores of C.pulvinata, like those of other Coleochaete species, are individually surrounded by chamber walls. These differed from vegetative cell walls in lacking plasmodesmata. Moreover, the chamber walls in germinating zygotes of C.pulvinata stained a cobalt blue color with resorcinal blue, and fluoresced yellow in the presence of aniline blue, thus exhibiting the staining characteristics of callose. In location, morphology and presence of callose, chamberwalls resemble “special walls” of land plants, they may represent a charophycean spore development preadaptation useful in the evolution of walled spores characteristic of land     

Eine Mutation bei der siphonalen GrünalgeDerbesia marina

Zusammenfassung 1. In einer aus Zoosporen vonDerbesia marina entstandenen Gametophytengeneration trat eine einzelne Pflanze vom Habitus des Sporophyten auf. Ihre Fäden entsprangen einer zentralen kugeligen Anschwellung.2. Diese Mutante erzeugt aus geschlechtlich neutralen Schwärmern immer wieder gleichartige Generationen.3. Die Mutante ist haploid (vgl.Neumann 1969).4. Die Befunde bestätigenFeldmanns (1952) Hypothese der Entstehung neuer Arten durch Trennung und selbständige Entwicklung von Gliedern eines Lebenszyklus.

---

Mutation in the siphonaceous green algaDerbesia marina

Over 15 years the heteromorphous alternation of generations inDerbesia marina proved to be obligatory. Only once has a single sporophyte-like plant been found amidst hundreds of gametophytes. Unlike the normal sporophyte, the filaments of this mutant originated from a central globule. Its neutral zoospores re-created the special morphological character of the mother plant. 12Derbesia generations succeeded one another within two years. Characteristic features of theDerbesia mutant are haploidy (Neumann 1969) and absence of sexuality. The observation from the culture experiment is important for our understanding of taxonomic relationships within algal genera, confirmingFeldmann's (1952) hypothesis regarding the origin of new algal species by independent development of life cycle members.

---

---

Herrn Prof. Dr.A. Bückmann zum 70. Geburtstag gewidmet.     

Laboratory culture and taxonomy of two species ofPedobesia (Bryopsidales,Chlorophyceae) in Japan

The morphology ofPedobesia lamourouxii andDerbesia ryukyuensis, both collected in Shimoda and the adjacent areas in central Japan, was studied from field specimens and laboratory cultures. Specimens which had the same morphology as EuropeanP. lamourouxii produced stephanokont zoospores which developed into either prostrate filaments or expanded discoidal thalli similar to those described by Feldmann and Codomier (1974) and Feldmannet al. (1975). Erect filament identical with the thallus found in nature developed directly from prostrate filaments. The specimens which had morphology similar to that ofDerbesia ryukyuensis described by Yamada and Tanaka (1938) also produced stephanokont zoospores which developed similarly to those ofP. lamourouxii. This species is, therefore, a member ofPedobesia, and it is made a new combinationP. ryukyuensis (Yamada et Tanaka) Kobara et Chihara, comb. nov.     

The flagellar root system in the gamete ofAcetabularia mediterranea

Summary Ultrastructural investigation of the flagellar root system ofAcetabularia gametes reveals one type of organization for both male and female gametes. There is a modified cruciate system with four microtubular bands X-2-X-2, with X=4. A prominent distal striated fiber and a small proximal striated fiber connect the flagellar bases. A striated root fiber type I underlies the microtubular root type II, and a short striated root fiber type I underlies the microtubular root type I (terminology ofMelkonian 1980 b). This specific root system has some details in common with theChlamydomonas type, and others with theUlvaphyceae and the siphonalean algaeDerbesia andBryopsis. This might indicate the phylogenetic relationships.     

Ultrastructural observations of mature and encysting zoospores ofPythium proliferum de Bary

Summary The process of zoospore maturation and encystment inP. proliferum was studied by electron microscopy. General ultrastructural features of the mature, swimming zoospore were found to be similar to those previously described for other oomycetes in both the attachment and ultrastructure of the flagella as well as the type and distribution of cellular organelles. Associated with extensive areas of RER in the mature zoospores were unusual, electrondense, bar-like structures. These structures were found in the groove region of young zoospores and at the periphery of encysting zoospores. Their possible function is discussed. The five main types of vesicles observed during encystment, as seen grouped in this study, along with the vesicles described in previous studies of oomycete encystment, were in table form and individually discussed. Interesting correlations appear to exist in the types of vesicles that are present within the oomycetes studied thusfar.     

Microassay for biological and chemical control of infection of tobacco byPhytophthora parasitica var.nicotianae

We developed a simple, rapid, small-scale assay for infection of tobacco seedlings byPhytophthora parasitica var.nicotianae. One 7-day-old tobacco seedling was placed in each well of a 96-well microtiter plate and inoculated with 500 zoospores ofP. parasitica var.nicotianae. After 72 h all of the inoculated seedlings of the susceptible cultivar, KY14, were infected, and the pathogen had produced sporangia that were visible on the surfaces of the seedlings. Sporangia did not develop on seedlings that were inoculated simultaneously with zoospores and either 1 µg/mL of the chemical fungicide metalaxyl or 5 µL of filtrate of a sporulated culture of the biocontrol agent,Bacillus cereus UW85. Seedlings of tobacco cultivar KY17 were infected byP. parasitica var.nicotianae, although mature plants of this variety are resistant to the pathogen. This microassay may facilitate the rapid screening of potential biological and chemical control agents and may be useful for studying mechanisms of infection and control ofPhytophthora spp. under hydroponic conditions.     

Electron microscopy of primary zoosporogenesis inPlasmodiophora brassicae

Primary zoosporogenesis in resting sporangia ofPlasmodiophora brassicae that had been incubated for 14 d in culture solution containing turnip seedlings was examined by transmission electron microscopy. A single zoospore differentiated within each sporangium, the differentiation being initiated by the emergence, of two flagella in the tight space formed by invagination of the plasma membrane within the sporangium. The differentiazing zoospore was similar in intracellular aspects to sporangia within clubroot galls. Then a deep groove formed on the zoospore cell body by further invagination of the plasma membrane. Two flagella appeared to coil around the zoospore cell body in parallel along this groove. Thereafter, the cell body lost the groove and became rounded following the protoplasmic condensation (contraction of cell body) during late development, and assumed an irregular shape at the stage of maturation. Intracellular features in, developing and mature zoospores were complicated, being characterized by electron-dense nuclei and mitochondria, microbodies, cored vesicles and various unidentified cytoplasmic vesicles and granules. A nucleolus-like region was observed only in the nucleus of the mature zoospore. A partially opened germ, pore was also seem in the sporangium containing the mature zoospore.     

RELATIONSHIP OF TEMPERATURE TO ZOOSPORE PRODUCTION IN TETRASPORA GELATINOSA

A strain of Tetraspora gelatinosa was isolated from a field collection and a technique for measuring quantitatively the production of zoospores was devised. The method employed compound colonies grown on agar from zoospore suspensions. The effect of 3 temperatures on zoospore production was tested: no zoospores were produced by the colonies at 3 C; zoospores were produced at 11 and 23 C and the final yield of zoospores at the 2 temperatures was not significantly different. However, at 11 C the maximum density of zoospores produced, measured by cell count, occurred after IS hr, while the maximum density at 23 C occurred after 21 hr.     

The flagellar root system of zoospores of the green algaChlorosarcinopsis (Chlorosarcinales) as compared withChlamydomonas (Volvocales)

The flagellar root system of zoospores in two species ofChlorosarcinopsis (C. minuta andC. spec.) has been studied in detail. The biflagellate zoospores show a cruciate root system, two of the four microtubular roots containing two microtubules, the other two four microtubules. The flagellar apparatus is otherwise identical with that ofChlamydomonas reinhardi as described byRingo (1967). Evidence is presented that the genusChlamydomonas is characterized by a bilateral symmetric root system (4-2-4-2) rather than a system with four equally numbered roots (i.e. 4-4-4-4). It is suggested that a root system with four identical cruciate roots is not present in any biflagellate algal cell. The taxonomic significance of cruciate root systems in green algae is discussed refering to the identical root systems ofChlorosarcinopsis andChlamydomonas.     

Attraction and attachment of zoospores of the parasitic chytridRozella allomycis in response to host-dependent factors

Summary This study examined the behavior of populations of zoospores of the obligately parasitic, endobiotic chytridRozella allomycis towards young, vegetative thalli of various saprophytic fungi, in order to identify host-dependent factors which control the development ofRozella. An inverted microscope was employed for continuous observation of parasite-host interaction in petri dishes of broth or agar medium. Two factors appear to control the initial stages of invasion byRozella of both susceptible and resistant species of the host genus,Allomyces: (i) a soluble exudate which attractsRozella zoospores, (ii) a receptor on the cell-wall surface which causesRozella zoospores to adhere, and to encyst and to germinate immediately thereafter. A related, nonsusceptible species,Blastocladiella emersonii, also attractsRozella zoospores, but supports very limited attachment.Rozella zoospores neither accumulate around, nor adhere to young thalli of non-blastocladialean fungi. This host-specific behavior pattern is compared with that of saprophytic and facultatively parasitic Phycomycetes, whose zoospores show nonspecific chemotactic responses and require no receptor for attachment, encystment and germination.     

Ultrastructural,cytochemical, and enzymatic studies on the adhesive “plaques” of the brown algaeLaminaria saccharina (L.) lamour. andNereocystis luetkeana (nert.) post. et rupr. 1

Summary Newly settled zoospores of bothLaminaria saccharina andNereocystis luetkeana are surrounded by adhesive plaques. At this stage cell wall deposition has not occurred and similar structures cannot be detected in the cytoplasm. In free swimming zoospores, however, plaques are observed exclusively in small vesicles within the cytoplasm. Enzymatic extractions and cytochemical tests indicate that plaques are glycoproteid in nature. Studies on the influence of several enzymes on the attachment of zoospores show that plaques are involved in the adhesion of zoospores to the substratum.Project supported by NRC grant #A2288. Nereocystis data are part of a Ph.D. dissertation presented by this author to the University of British Columbia.     

POLAR GROWTH OF HORMOSIRA BÁNKSII ZYGOTES IN SHAKE CULTURE

Zygotes of the fucalean alga Hormosira banksii initiate rhizoidal outgrowths in stationary culture 15 hr after fertilization and are then recognizably polar. By 24 hr most embryos are two-celled, and a few are four-celled. In a dark-grown population orientation of the developmental axis, as indicated by the direction of the rhizoidal outgrowth, was random around the vertical axis. In a unilaterally illuminated population the rhizoid usually emerged on the shaded side. Zygotes grown in light or darkness in shake culture, where they were continuously reoriented, usually developed as polar embryos, indicating that gradients of environmental factors are not required for initiation of polar growth. Some apolar embryos developed in stationary and shake cultures, but they were most frequent in dark shake cultures.     

Production of monoclonal antibodies against peripheral-vesicle proteins in zoospores of Phytophthora nicotianae

Summary. A coimmunisation protocol using microsomal fractions from Phytophthora nicotianae cells has enhanced the production of monoclonal antibodies directed towards proteins produced during asexual sporulation. Over 40% of the antibodies targeted three categories of zoospore peripheral vesicles. Five antibodies label the contents of dorsal vesicles, with three of these reacting with two P. nicotianae polypeptides with a relative molecular mass of approximately 100 kDa. Two antibodies label the contents of large peripheral vesicles and react with two very high-molecular-weight polypeptides in extracts of P. nicotianae cells. These antibodies cross-react with the contents of large peripheral vesicles in P. cinnamomi zoospores. Ten antibodies label the contents of P. nicotianae zoospore ventral vesicles and react with a single polypeptide with a relative molecular mass of 230 kDa. A number of these antibodies against the contents of ventral vesicles in P. nicotianae zoospores cross-react with ventral-vesicle proteins in P. cinnamomi cells in immunofluorescence and immunoblot assays. The study illustrates the value of the coimmunisation protocol and has produced antibodies that could be instrumental in the cloning of genes encoding peripheral-vesicle proteins.Correspondence and reprints: Plant Cell Biology Group, Research School of Biological Sciences, Australian National University, GPO Box 475, Canberra, ACT 2601, Australia.     

Variable compatibility of clonedAlnus glutinosa ecotypes against ineffectiveFrankia strains

Nodulation tests onin-vitro propagated clones ofAlnus glutinosa ecotypes (forest ecotype, pioneer ecotype) withFrankia strains originating from both ecotypes indicated differences in host-plant compatibility. Inoculated plants of the pioneer ecotype clone were not infected by strains, that were unable to fix nitrogen in pure culture. Nodulation could only be induced on the clone of the forest ecotype, but no nitrogen-fixing activity could be detected. Ultra-structural observations of the nodules by SEM and TEM indicated that ineffectivity of these strains was correlated with the lack of vesicles in the infected cells. Cells were only filled with hyphae: neither sporangia nor vesicles could be detected. In contrast, effective nodules could be obtained on both alder clones after inoculation with an effective strain, showing normal development of vesicle clusters in infected cells. In pure culture the ineffective strains produced no vesicles; sporangia were found only during early stage of growth. The results demonstrate the existence ofFrankia strains which were either non-infective or ineffective on different clones ofAlnus glutinosa.