共查询到20条相似文献,搜索用时 668 毫秒
1.
Emanuele Brambilla Pisoni Roberto Raccanelli Giovanni Dotelli Donatella Botta Paco Melià 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2009,14(3):248-256
Background, aim, and scope Many recent studies on waste management have described in detail the potential impacts of recycling and final treatment of
municipal waste. In public debates, the attention has also been focused on the choice of final disposal technologies (e.g.
landfilling vs. incineration). However, a comprehensive assessment of the impacts of waste collection and transport was still
lacking. In the present study, we use LCA to evaluate the potential impact of the provincial waste management plan of Varese
(northern Italy). Particular attention is devoted to the estimation of environmental impacts generated during waste transport.
Materials and methods A detailed Life Cycle Inventory was built for the transportation phase, based on primary data collected by interviewing the
agencies involved in waste collection. To model the recycling and final disposal phase we relied on the BUWAL 250 database.
Impacts were evaluated with the Eco-Indicator 99 method in its egalitarian formulation.
Results The results of our analysis reveal that the major potential impacts of the plan are associated with waste collection and transport.
These impacts are partially compensated by reduced resource consumption through recycling and energy recovery through incineration.
Discussion The outputs of the LCIA were compared with those obtained by using other ecoindicators (Eco-Indicator 99 hierarchist and individualist,
CML2, EPS2000). Although not comparable on a quantitative basis, they are qualitatively consistent.
Conclusions Neglecting the effects of collection and transport might result in a severe underestimation of the environmental impacts of
a waste management system, especially as refers to depletion of fossil fuels, emission of respiratory inorganics and climate
change. To reduce the environmental impact of waste management systems, an accurate optimisation of waste transport is required.
Recommendations and perspectives Effective waste management planning requires the explicit inclusion of waste collection and transport when comparing alternative
management policies. 相似文献
2.
Goal, Scope and Background The automotive industry has a long history in improving the environmental performance of vehicles - fuel economy and emission
improvements, introduction of recycled and renewable materials, etc. The European Union also aims at improving the environmental
performance of products by reducing, in particular, waste resulting from End-of-Life Vehicles (ELVs) for example. The European
Commission estimates that ELVs contribute to approximately 1 % of the total waste in Europe [9]. Other European Union strategies
are considering more life cycle aspects, as well as other impacts including resource or climate change. This article is summarizing
the results of a European Commission funded project (LIRECAR) that aims at identifying the environmental impacts and relevance
for combinations of recycling / recovery and lightweight vehicle design options over the whole life cycle of a vehicle - i.e.
manufacturing, use and recycling/recovery. Three, independent and scientific LCA experts reviewed the study according to ISO
14040. From the beginning, representatives of all Life Cycle Stakeholders have been involved (European materials & supplier
associations, an environmental Non-Governmental Organization, recycler’s association).
Model and System Definition The study compared 3 sets of theoretical vehicle weight scenarios: 1000 kg reference (material range of today’s end-of-life,
mid-sized vehicles produced in the early 1990’s) and 2 lightweight scenarios for 100 kg and 250 kg less weight based on reference
functions (in terms of comfort, safety, etc.) and a vehicle concept. The scenarios are represented by their material range
of a broad range of lightweight strategies of most European car manufacturers. In parallel, three End-of-Life (EOL) scenarios
are considered: EOL today and two theoretical extreme scenarios (100% recycling, respectively, 100% recovery of shredder residue
fractions that are disposed of today). The technical and economical feasibility of the studied scenarios is not taken into
consideration (e.g. 100% recycling is not possible).
Results and Discussion Significant differences between the various, studied weight scenarios were determined in several scenarios for the environmental
categories of global warming, ozone depletion, photochemical oxidant creation (summer smog), abiotic resource depletion, and
hazardous waste. However, these improvement potentials can be only realized under well defined conditions (e.g. material compositions,
specific fuel reduction values and EOL credits) based on case-by-case assessments for improvements over the course of the
life cycle. Looking at the studied scenarios, the relative contribution of the EOL phase represents 5% or less of the total
life cycle impact for most selected impact categories and scenarios. The EOL technology variations studied do not impact significantly
the considered environmental impacts. Exceptions include total waste, as long as stockpile goods (overburden, tailings and
ore/coal processing residues) and EOL credits are considered.
Conclusions and Recommendations LIRECAR focuses only on lightweight/recycling, questions whereas other measures (changes in safety or comfort standards, propulsion
improvements for CO2, user behavior) are beyond the scope of the study. The conclusions are also not necessarily transferable to other vehicle
concepts. However, for the question of end-of-life options, it can be concluded that LIRECAR cannot support any general recommendation
and/or mandatory actions to improve recycling if lightweight is affected. Also, looking at each vehicle, no justification
could be found for the general assumption that lightweight and recycling greatly influence the affected environmental dimension
(Global Warming Potential or resource depletion and waste, respectively). LIRECAR showed that this general assumption is not
true under all analyzed circumstances and not as significant as suggested. Further discussions and product development targets
shall not focus on generic targets that define the approach/technology concerned with how to achieve environmental improvement
(weight reduction [kg], recycling quota [%]), but on overall life cycle improvement). To enable this case-by-case assessment,
exchanges of necessary information with suppliers are especially relevant. 相似文献
3.
Ana Sofia Fonseca Maria Isabel Nunes Manuel Arlindo Matos Ana Paula Gomes 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2013,18(7):1374-1385
Purpose
In Portugal, the management of end-of-life vehicles (ELV) is set out in targets of the European Union policy for the year 2015, including 85 % recycling, 95 % recovery, and maximum of 5 % landfilling. These goals will be attained only through more efficient technologies for waste separation and recycling of shredder residues or higher rates of dismantling components. Focusing on this last alternative, a field experiment was carried out. There is potential for additional recycling/recovery of 10 %.Methods
Three scenarios were proposed for the management of ELV wastes: (1) scenario 1 corresponds to the baseline and refers to the current management, i.e., the 10 % of ELV wastes are shredded whereby some ferrous and non-ferrous metals are recovered and the remaining fraction, called automotive shredder residues (ASR), is landfilled, (2) scenario 2 wherein the ASR fraction is incinerated with energy recovery, and (3) scenario 3 includes the additional dismantling of components for recycling and for energy recovery through solid recovered fuel, to be used as a fuel substitute in the cement industry. The environmental performance of these scenarios was quantified by using the life cycle assessment methodology. Five impact categories were assessed: abiotic resource depletion, climate change, photochemical oxidant creation, acidification, and eutrophication.Results and discussion
Compared to the other scenarios, in scenario 1 no benefits for the impact categories of climate change and eutrophication were observed. Scenario 2 has environmental credits due to the recycling of ferrous and non-ferrous metals and benefits from energy recovery. However, this scenario has a significant impact on climate change due to emissions from thermal oxidation of polymeric materials present in the ASR fraction. A net environmental performance upgrading seems to be ensured by scenario 3, mainly due to replacing fossil fuel by solid recovered fuel.Conclusions
The proposed additional dismantling of ELV (scenario 3) not only brings environmental benefits but also meets the European recovery and recycling targets. The associated increase of dismantling costs can be compensated by the additional recycling material revenues as well as social benefits by a rise in employment. 相似文献4.
Rajesh Mehta Milad Golkaram Jack T. W. E. Vogels Tom Ligthart Eugene Someren Spela Ferjan Jelmer Lennartz 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2023,27(5):1266-1276
To achieve climate neutrality ambitions, greenhouse gas emissions from the transport sector need to be reduced by at least 90% by 2050. To support industry and policy makers on mitigating actions on climate goals it is important to holistically compare and reduce life cycle environmental impacts of road passenger vehicles. A web-based sustainability assessment tool named battery electric vehicle sustainability impact assessment model, BEVSIM, is developed to assess the environmental, circularity, and economic performance of the materials, sub-systems, parts, and individual components of battery electric vehicles and internal combustion engine vehicles. This tool allows to measure and compare impacts resulting from recycling technologies, end-of-life scenarios, and future scenarios resulting from changes in grid mixes. This paper explains the purpose of the tool, its functionality and design as well as the underlying assumptions. 相似文献
5.
Nellemieke Mohr Arjen Meijer Mark A. J. Huijbregts Lucas Reijnders 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2009,14(3):225-235
Background, aim, and scope The environmental burden of photovoltaic (PV) solar modules is currently largely determined by the cumulative input of fossil
energy used for module production. However, with an increased focus on limiting the emission of CO2 coming from fossil fuels, it is expected that renewable resources, including photovoltaics, may well become more important
in producing electricity. A comparison of the environmental impacts of PV modules in case their life cycle is based on the
use of PV electricity in contrast to conventional electricity can elucidate potential environmental drawbacks in an early
stage of development of a solar-based economy. The goal of this paper is to show for ten impact categories the environmental
consequences of replacing fossil electricity with solar electricity into the life cycle of two types of PV modules.
Materials and methods Using life cycle assessment (LCA), we evaluated the environmental impacts of two types of PV modules: a thin-film GaInP/GaAs
tandem module and a multicrystalline silicon (multi-Si) module. For each of the modules, the total amount of fossil electricity
required in the life cycle of the module was substituted with electricity that is generated by a corresponding PV module.
The environmental impacts of the modules on the midpoint level were compared with those of the same modules in case their
life cycle is based on the use of conventional electricity. The environmental impacts were assessed for Western European circumstances
with an annual solar irradiation of 1000 kWh/m2. For the GaInP/GaAs module, the environmental impacts of individual production steps were also analysed.
Results Environmental burdens decreased when PV electricity was applied in the life cycle of the two PV modules. The impact score
reductions of the GaInP/GaAs module were up to a factor of 4.9 (global warming). The impact score reductions found for the
multi-Si module were up to a factor of 2.5 (abiotic depletion and global warming). Reductions of the toxicity scores of both
module types were smaller or negligible. This is caused by a decreased use of fossil fuels, on the one hand, and an increased
consumption of materials for the production of the additional solar modules used for generating the required PV electricity
on the other. Overall, the impact scores of the GaInP/GaAs module were reduced more than the corresponding scores of the multi-Si
module. The contribution analysis of the GaInP/GaAs module production steps indicated that for global warming, the cell growth
process is dominant for supply with conventional electricity, while for the solar scenario, the frame becomes dominant. Regarding
freshwater aquatic ecotoxicity scores associated with the life cycle of the GaInP/GaAs module, the cell growth process is
dominant for supply with conventional electricity, while the reactor system for the cell growth with the associated gas scrubbing
system is dominant for the solar scenario.
Discussion There are uncertainties regarding the calculated environmental impact scores. This paper describes uncertainties associated
with the used economic allocation method, and uncertainties because of missing life cycle inventory data. For the GaInP/GaAs
module, it was found that the global warming impact scores range from −66% to +41%, and the freshwater aquatic ecotoxicity
scores (for an infinite time horizon) range from −40% to +300% compared to the default estimates. For both impact categories,
the choices associated with the allocation of gallium, with the electricity mix, with the conversion efficiency of the commercially
produced GaInP/GaAs cells, and with the yield of the cell growth process are most influential. For freshwater aquatic ecotoxicity,
the uncertainty concerning the lifetime of the reactor system for the GaInP/GaAs cell growth process and the gas scrubbing
system is particularly relevant.
Conclusions Use of PV electricity instead of fossil electricity significantly reduces the environmental burdens of the GaInP/GaAs and
the multi-Si module. The reductions of the toxicity scores, however, are smaller or negligible. Toxicity impacts of the GaInP/GaAs
cells can be reduced by improvement of the yield of the cell growth process, a reduced energy demand in the cell growth process,
reduction of the amount of stainless steel in the cell growth reactor system and the gas scrubbing system, and a longer lifetime
of these systems.
Recommendations and perspectives Because the greenhouse gas emissions associated with the production of fossil-fuel-based electricity have an important share
in global warming on a world-wide scale, switching to a more extensive use of solar power is helpful to comply with the present
international legislation on the area of global warming reduction. As reductions in toxicity impact scores are smaller or
negligible when fossil electricity is replaced by PV electricity, it is desirable to give specific attention to the processes
which dominantly contribute to these impact categories. Furthermore, in this study, a shift in ranking of several environmental
impacts of the modules has been found when PV electricity is used instead of fossil electricity. The results of a comparative
LCA can thus be dependent of the electricity mix used in the life cycles of the assessed products.
Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users. 相似文献
6.
Carles M. Gasol Ramon Farreny Xavier Gabarrell Joan Rieradevall 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2008,13(5):421-431
Goal, scope and background The industrial packages sector has great importance for the transport sector in Europe. These containers, mainly wooden pallets
and spools, are subject to European legislation, which promotes their reuse and recycling. This study uses life cycle assessment
(LCA) to assess the environmental impact of the current management system in this sector and the benefits and drawbacks of
different reuse intensities as a waste prevention strategy as opposed to the recycling option.
Materials and methods In this paper, four case studies located in Spain and representative of the wooden package sector in Europe are analysed:
high reuse pallet, low reuse pallet, low reuse spool and null reuse spool. For the LCA study cases, the functional unit is
that required to satisfy the transport necessity of 1,000 t by road. The impact and energy consumption assessment methods
used are CML 2 Baseline 2000 and Cumulative Energy Demand. Data are mostly provided by the leading enterprises and organisations
in this sector.
Results The paper provides, as a first result, a comprehensive inventory of the systems under study. Secondly, our assessment shows
that the systems with higher reuse intensity show a reduction in energy and wood consumption and all the environmental impact
categories except for the global warming potential from 34.0% to 81.0% in the pallet study cases and from 50.4% to 72.8% in
the spool ones. This reduction is at the expense of the maintenance stage, which on the contrary increases its impact, although
it is still relatively small—less than 7% in all the impact categories and flow indicators of the study cases. The highest
impact stages are transport, raw material extraction and the process chain. The final disposal and maintenance stages are
the lowest impact, contributing at most to less than 30% of the impact in the pallet study cases and 10% in the spool cases.
Discussion Wood consumption (WC), directly related to the number of containers needed to satisfy the functional unit, is the main factor
in determining the impact of the stages, especially in the raw materials extraction and process chain stages, assuming that
these are undertaken with the same technologies in all the case studies. Other variables, such as the management system, the
maintenance index and the final disposal scenario, affect the impact of the remaining stages: transport, maintenance and final
disposal. The global warming potential results obtained demonstrate the environmental benefits of using containers made of
a renewable resource such as wood instead of using other materials, but these results are not expected to prioritise the lower
reuse systems because of their better performance in this category.
Conclusions Reuse, a strategy capable of reducing the environmental impacts of the wooden container systems, is preferable to recycling,
while the package maintenance tasks are still feasible. Therefore, reuse, combined with recycling as final disposal, should
be encouraged to reduce the demand for natural resources and the waste generated.
Recommendations Based on these results, attention should be paid to the maintenance stage, which, being the lowest-impact one, could substantially
reduce the impact of the remaining stages. 相似文献
7.
Christoph Stallkamp Malte Hennig Rebekka Volk Frank Richter Britta Bergfeldt Salar Tavakkol Frank Schultmann Dieter Stapf 《Journal of Industrial Ecology》2023,27(5):1319-1334
Most automotive plastic waste (APW) is landfilled or used in energy recovery as it is unsuitable for high-quality product mechanical recycling. Chemical recycling via pyrolysis offers a pathway toward closing the material loop by handling this heterogeneous waste and providing feedstock for producing virgin plastics. This study compares chemical recycling and energy recovery scenarios for APW regarding climate change impact and cumulative energy demand (CED), assessing potential environmental advantages. In addition, an economic assessment is conducted. In contrast to other studies, the assessments are based on pyrolysis experiments conducted with an actual waste fraction. Mass balances and product composition are reported. The experimental data is combined with literature data for up- and downstream processes for the assessment. Chemical recycling shows a lower net climate change impact (0.57 to 0.64 kg CO2e/kg waste input) and CED (3.38 to 4.41 MJ/kg waste input) than energy recovery (climate change impact: 1.17 to 1.25 kg CO2e/kg waste input; CED: 6.94 to 7.97 MJ/kg waste input), while energy recovery performs better economically (net processing cost of −0.05 to −0.02€/kg waste input) compared to chemical recycling (0.05 to 0.08€/kg waste input). However, chemical recycling keeps carbon in the material cycle contributing to a circular economy and reducing the dependence on fossil feedstocks. Therefore, an increasing circularity of APW through chemical recycling shows a conflict between economic and environmental objectives. 相似文献
8.
Life cycle assessment of fuel ethanol from cassava in Thailand 总被引:2,自引:0,他引:2
Thu Lan T. Nguyen Shabbir H. Gheewala 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2008,13(2):147-154
Goal and Scope A well-to-wheel analysis has been conducted for cassava-based ethanol (CE) in Thailand. The aim of the analysis is to assess
the potentials of CE in the form of gasohol E10 for promoting energy security and reducing environmental impacts in comparison
with conventional gasoline (CG).
Method In the LCA procedure, three separate but interrelated components: inventory analysis, characterization and interpretation
were performed for the complete chain of the fuel life cycle. To compare gasohol E10 and CG, this study addressed their impact
potentials per gasoline-equivalent litre, taking into account the performance difference between gasohol and gasoline in an
explosion motor.
Results and Discussions The results obtained show that CE in the form of E10, along its whole life cycle, reduces certain environmental loads compared
to CG. The percentage reductions relative to CG are 6.1% for fossil energy use, 6.0% for global warming potential, 6.8% for
acidification, and 12.2% for nutrient enrichment. Using biomass in place of fossil fuels for process energy in the manufacture
of ethanol leads to improved overall life cycle energy and environmental performance of ethanol blends relative to CG.
Conclusions and Outlook The LCA brings to light the key areas in the ethanol production cycle that researchers and technicians need to work on to
maximize ethanol’s contribution to energy security and environmental sustainability
ESS-Submission Editor: Mark Goedkoop (goedkoop@pre.nl) 相似文献
9.
Ivan Muñoz Joan Rieradevall Xavier Domènech Cristina Gazulla 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2006,11(5):323-334
Goal, Scope and Background The new European legislation concerning End-of-Life Vehicles (ELVs) will allow, in 2015, the landfilling of only 5% of the
average vehicle weight, which means that the automotive industry must make a great effort in order to design their products
taking into account their recyclability when they become waste. In the present work, LCA is used to assess an existing automotive
component, a plastic door panel, and to compare it with a designed-for-recycling prototype panel, based on compatible polyolefins.
Main Features A \\\'cradle to grave\\\' LCA is carried out for the panel currently produced and the prototype. The following scenarios
are analyzed for plastic waste: landfilling (current practice in Spain), energy recovery in a MSW incinerator or in a cement
kiln, and mechanical recycling.
Results and Discussion The production and use phases together contribute more than 95% in most impact indicators. When the current and prototype
products are compared, a decrease in the environmental impact appears for the prototype in the production phase and also at
end-of-life if recycling is considered with full substitution of virgin polymers. The overall impact reduction ranges from
18% in the toxicity indicators to 80% in landfill use. Energy recovery in cement kilns appears as a good alternative to recycling
in some indicators, such as landfill use or resource depletion. A sensitivity analysis is performed on the quality of recycled
plastic, and the results suggest that the benefits of recycling are substantially reduced if full substitution is not achieved.
Conclusion LCA has been shown to be a very useful tool to validate from an environmental point of view a redesigned automotive component;
in addition, it has allowed one to identify not only the benefits from increased recyclability, but also improvements in other
life cycle phases which were not previously expected.
Recommendation and Perspective From this case study several recommendations to the company have been drawn in order to design environmentally friendly components
for car interiors, and ecodesign is expected to be introduced in the company procedures.
- Glossary
ABS: Acrilonitrile-butadiene-styrene; ASR: Automobile shredder residue; DEHP: Di(ethylhexyl)phtalate; ELV: End-of-life vehicles;
EPDM: Ethylene propylene diene monomer; MSW: Municipal solid waste; MSWI: Municipal solid waste incinerator; NEDC: New European
driving cycle; PA GF: Polyamide glass fiber reinforced; PE: Polyethylene; PES: Polyester; POM: Polyoxymethylene; PP T16: Polypropylene
16% talc filled; PUR: Polyurethane; PVC: Polyvinyl chloride; TPO: Thermoplastic olefin 相似文献
10.
Life cycle assessment of Australian automotive door skins 总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1
Prateek Puri Paul Compston Victor Pantano 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2009,14(5):420-428
Background, aim, and scope Policy initiatives, such as the EU End of Life Vehicle (ELV) Directive for only 5% landfilling by 2015, are increasing the
pressure for higher material recyclability rates. This is stimulating research into material alternatives and end-of-life
strategies for automotive components. This study presents a Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) on an Australian automotive component,
namely an exterior door skin. The functional unit for this study is one door skin set (4 exterior skins). The material alternatives
are steel, which is currently used by Australian manufacturers, aluminium and glass-fiber reinforced polypropylene composite.
Only the inputs and outputs relative to the door skin production, use and end-of-life phases were considered within the system
boundary. Landfill, energy recovery and mechanical recycling were the end-of-life phases considered. The aim of the study
is to highlight the most environmentally attractive material and end-of-life option.
Methods The LCA was performed according to the ISO 14040 standard series. All information considered in this study (use of fossil
and non fossil based energy resources, water, chemicals etc.) were taken up in in-depth data. The data for the production,
use and end-of-life phases of the door skin set was based upon softwares such as SimaPro and GEMIS which helped in the development
of the inventory for the different end-of-life scenarios. In other cases, the inventory was developed using derivations obtained
from published journals. Some data was obtained from GM-Holden and the Co-operative research Centre for Advanced Automotive
Technology (AutoCRC), in Australia. In cases where data from the Australian economy was unavailable, such as the data relating
to energy recovery methods, a generic data set based on European recycling companies was employed. The characterization factors
used for normalization of data were taken from (Saling et. al. Int J Life Cycle Assess 7(4):203–218 2002) which detailed the method of carrying out an LCA.
Results The production phase results in maximum raw material consumption for all materials, and it is higher for metals than for the
composite. Energy consumption is greatest in the use phase, with maximum consumption for steel. Aluminium consumes most energy
in the production phase. Global Warming Potential (GWP) also follows a trend similar to that of energy consumption. Photo
Oxidants Creation Potential (POCP) is the highest for the landfill scenario for the composite, followed by steel and aluminium.
Acidification Potential (AP) is the highest for all the end-of-life scenarios of the composite. Ozone Depletion Potential
(ODP) is the highest for the metals. The net water emissions are also higher for composite in comparison to metals despite
high pollution in the production phases of metallic door skins. Solid wastes are higher for the metallic door skins.
Discussion The composite door skin has the lowest energy consumption in the production phase, due to the low energy requirements during
the manufacturing of E-glass and its fusion with polypropylene to form sheet molding compounds. In general, the air emissions
during the use phase are strongly dependent on the mass of the skins, with higher emissions for the metals than for the composite.
Material recovery through recycling is the highest in metals due to efficient separation techniques, while mechanical recycling
is the most efficient for the composite. The heavy steel skins produce the maximum solid wastes primarily due to higher fuel
consumption. Water pollution reduction benefit is highest in case of metals, again due to the high efficiency of magnetic
separation technique in the case of steel and eddy current separation technique in the case of aluminium. Material recovery
in these metals reduces the amount of water needed to produce a new door skin set (water employed mainly in the ingot casting
stage). Moreover, the use of heavy metals, inorganic salts and other chemicals is minimized by efficient material recovery.
Conclusions The use of the studied type of steel for the door skins is a poor environmental option in every impact category. Aluminium
and composite materials should be considered to develop a more sustainable and energy efficient automobile. In particular,
this LCA study shows that glass-fiber composite skins with mechanical recycling or energy recovery method could be environmentally
desirable, compared to aluminium and steel skins. However, the current limit on the efficiency of recycling is the prime barrier
to increasing the sustainability of composite skins.
Recommendations and perspectives The study is successful in developing a detailed LCA for the three different types of door skin materials and their respective
recycling or end-of-life scenarios. The results obtained could be used for future work on an eco-efficiency portfolio for
the entire car. However, there is a need for a detailed assessment of toxicity and risk potentials arising from each of the
four different types of door skin sets. This will require greater communication between academia and the automotive industry
to improve the quality of the LCA data. Sensitivity analysis needs to be performed such as the assessment of the impact of
varying substitution factors on the life cycle of a door skin. Incorporation of door skin sets made of new biomaterials need
to be accounted for as another functional unit in future LCA studies.
Discussion contributions to this article from the readership would the highly welcome. The authors 相似文献
11.
Life cycle assessment of primary magnesium production using the Pidgeon process in China 总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1
Feng Gao Zuoren Nie Zhihong Wang Xianzheng Gong Tieyong Zuo 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2009,14(5):480-489
Background, aims, and scope China has been the largest primary magnesium producer in the world since year 2000 and is an important part of the global
magnesium supply chain. Almost all of the primary magnesium in China is produced using the Pidgeon process invented in the
1940s in Canada. The environmental problems of the primary magnesium production with the Pidgeon process have already attracted
much attention of the local government and enterprises. The main purposes of this research are to investigate the environmental
impacts of magnesium production and to determine the accumulative environmental performances of three different scenarios.
System boundary included the cradle-to-gate life cycle of magnesium production, including dolomite ore extraction, ferrosilicon
production, the Pidgeon process, transportation of materials, and emissions from thermal power plant. The life cycle assessment
(LCA) case study was performed on three different fuel use scenarios from coal as the overall fuel to two kinds of gaseous
fuels, the producer gas and coke oven gas. The burden use of gaseous fuels was also considered.
Methods The procedures, details, and results obtained are based on the application of the existing international standards of LCA,
i.e., the ISO 14040. Depletion of abiotic resources, global warming, acidification, and human toxicity were adopted as the
midpoint impact categories developed by the problem-oriented approach of CML to estimate the characterized results of the
case study. The local characterization and normalization factors of abiotic resources were used to calculate abiotic depletion
potential (ADP). The analytic hierarchy process was used to determine the weight factors. Using the Umberto version 4.0, the
emissions of dolomite ore extraction were estimated and the transportation models of the three scenarios were designed.
Results and conclusions The emissions inventory showed that both the Pidgeon process of magnesium production and the Fe–Si production were mainly
to blame for the total pollutant emissions in the life cycle of magnesium production. The characterized results indicated
that ADP, acidification potential, and human toxicity potential decreased cumulatively from scenarios 1 to 3, with the exception
of global warming potential. The final single scores indicated that the accumulative environmental performance of scenario
3 was the best compared with scenarios 1 and 2. The impact of abiotic resources depletion deserves more attention although
the types and the amount of mineral resources for Mg production are abundant in China. This study suggested that producer
gas was an alternative fuel for magnesium production rather than the coal burned directly in areas where the cost of oven
gas-produced coke is high. The utilization of “clean” energy and the reduction of greenhouse gases and acidic gases emission
were the main goals of the technological improvements and cleaner production of the magnesium industry in China.
Recommendation and perspective This paper has demonstrated that the theory and method of LCA are actually helpful for the research on the accumulative environmental
performance of primary magnesium production. Further studies with “cradle-to-cradle” scheme are recommended. Furthermore,
other energy sources used in magnesium production and the cost of energy production could be treated in further research. 相似文献
12.
Life cycle impact of emissions, energy requirements, and exergetic losses are calculated for a novel process for producing titanium dioxide nanoparticles from an ilmenite feedstock. The Altairnano hydrochloride process analyzed is tailored for the production of nanoscale particles, unlike established commercial processes. The life cycle energy requirements for the production of these particles is compared with that of traditional building materials on a per unit mass basis. The environmental impact assessment and energy analysis results both emphasize the use of nonrenewable fossil fuels in the upstream life cycle. Exergy analysis shows fuel losses to be secondary to material losses, particularly in the mining of ilmenite ore. These analyses are based on the same inventory data. The main contributions of this work are to provide life cycle inventory of a nanomanufacturing process and reveal potential insights from exergy analysis that are not available from other methods. 相似文献
13.
Recycling of aluminum can in terms of Life Cycle Inventory (LCI) 总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1
Jozeti Barbutti Gatti Guilherme de Castilho Queiroz Eloísa Elena Corrêa Garcia 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2008,13(3):219-225
Background, Aims and Scope Life Cycle Assessment is a technique for evaluating the environmental performance of a given product by: identifying and quantifying
the energy and raw materials used in its manufacturing process, as well as the emissions of pollutants to water, soil, and
air inherent in this production, use and disposal, and evaluating the environmental impact associated with the use of energy
and materials and the emissions of pollutants, thus identifying opportunities to improve the system in order to optimize the
environmental performance of the product. CETEA (Packaging Technology Center) has conducted a Life Cycle Assessment — LCA
study of aluminum can with emphasis in life cycle inventory, collecting data for the reference years 2000–2002. The goal of
this paper is to present part of this complete study, focusing the influence of aluminium recycling rate on the Life Cycle
Inventory (LCI) of aluminum beverage cans in Brazil.
Methods The adopted methodology was based on the recommendations of SETAC — Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry and
the ISO 14040 Standard, approved by the Sub-Committee 05 of the Environmental Administration Technical Committee, TC-207,
from ISO — INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION FOR STANDARDIZATION [1,2]. Data storage and modeling were performed by employing the
PIRA Environmental Management System — PEMS [3].
Results Taking into account the impact categories adopted in this study, it has been shown that recycling helps to improve the aluminium
can environmental profile measured as LCI data.
Discussion For the transformed aluminium products, the recycling rate affects the values of the environmental parameters inventoried,
but not in the same proportion, since the contribution of other stages of the product system life cycle and the recycling
process remain unchanged, including the yield of this process. In general, the recycling balance is always positive due to
the importance of the stages that precede the packaging production and the problem of increasing the municipal waste volume.
Conclusions The advantages of the recycling are obviously concentrated on the inventoried parameters related to the primary aluminum production
and to the package disposal. The verified benefits of the recycling increase with the recycling rate enhancement. However,
the effects on the inventory do not have the same magnitude of the recycling rate. This happens due to the relative contributions
of the other life cycle stages, such as the transportation and sheet or can production. In agreement with the presented results,
it is possible to conclude that the aluminum can recycling reduces part of the consumption of natural resources and the emissions
associated to the stages previous to the production of the packaging. The parameters specifically related to the stage of
aluminum production suffer reduction directly proportional to the increase of the recycling rate. In this way, all of the
efforts made to increase the recycling rate will have a positive contribution to the LCI of the aluminum can.
Recommendations It is worth pointing out that LCA studies are iterative and dynamic. The data can always be refined, substituted or complemented
with updated information in order to improve the representativeness of the analyzed sector.
Perspectives From this study, the aluminum sector in Brazil is able to quantify the benefits of future actions for environmental improvement
of the Brazilian aluminum industry, as well as to contribute technically to Environmental Labeling initiatives regarding aluminum
products.
ESS-Submission Editor: Alain Dubreuil (dubreuil@nrcan.gc.ca) 相似文献
14.
Warsen Jens Bauer Christian Schebek Liselotte 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2009,14(1):52-63
Background, aim and scope Renewable energy sources nowadays constitute an increasingly important issue in our society, basically because of the need
for alternative sources of energy to fossil fuels that are free of CO2 emissions and pollution and also because of other problems such as the diminution of the reserves of these fossil fuels,
their increasing prices and the economic dependence of non-producers countries on those that produce fossil fuels. One of
the renewable energy sources that has experienced a bigger growth over the last years is wind power, with the introduction
of new wind farms all over the world and the new advances in wind power technology. Wind power produces electrical energy
from the kinetic energy of the wind without producing any pollution or emissions during the conversion process. Although wind
power does not produce pollution or emissions during operation, it should be considered that there is an environmental impact
due to the manufacturing process of the wind turbine and the disposal process at the end of the wind turbine life cycle, and
this environmental impact should be quantified in order to compare the effects of the production of energy and to analyse
the possibilities of improvement of the process from that point of view. Thus, the aim of this study is to analyse the environmental
impact of wind energy technology, considering the whole life cycle of the wind power system, by means of the application of
the ISO 14040 standard [ISO (1998) ISO 14040. Environmental management—life cycle assessment—principles and framework. International Standard Organization,
Geneva, Switzerland], which allows quantification of the overall impact of a wind turbine and each of its component parts
using a Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) study.
Materials and methods The procedures, details, and results obtained are based on the application of the existing international standards of LCA.
In addition, environmental details and indications of materials and energy consumption provided by the various companies related
to the production of the component parts are certified by the application of the environmental management system ISO 14001
[ISO (2004) ISO 14001 Environmental management systems—requirements with guidance for use. International Standard Organization, Geneva,
Switzerland]. A wind turbine is analysed during all the phases of its life cycle, from cradle to grave, by applying this methodology,
taking into account all the processes related to the wind turbine: the production of its main components (through the incorporation
of cut-off criteria), the transport to the wind farm, the subsequent installation, the start-up, the maintenance and the final
dismantling and stripping down into waste materials and their treatment. The study has been developed in accordance with the
ISO 14044 standard [ISO (2006) ISO 14044: Environmental management—life cycle assessment—requirements and guidelines. International Standard Organization,
Geneva, Switzerland] currently in force.
Results The application of LCA, according to the corresponding international standards, has made it possible to determine and quantify
the environmental impact associated with a wind turbine. On the basis of this data, the final environmental effect of the
wind turbine after a lifespan of 20 years and its subsequent decommissioning have been studied. The environmental advantages
of the generation of electricity using wind energy, that is, the reduction in emissions and contamination due to the use of
a clean energy source, have also been evaluated.
Discussion This study concludes that the environmental pollution resulting from all the phases of the wind turbine (manufacture, start-up,
use, and dismantling) during the whole of its lifetime is recovered in less than 1 year.
Conclusions From the developed LCA model, the important levels of contamination of certain materials can be obtained, for instance, the
prepreg (a composite made by a mixture of epoxy resin and fibreglass). Furthermore, it has been concluded that it is possible
to reduce the environmental effects of manufacturing and recycling processes of wind turbines and their components.
Recommendations and perspectives In order to achieve this goal in a fast and effective way, it is essential to enlist the cooperation of the different manufacturers. 相似文献
15.
我国生活垃圾产量大但处理能力不足,产生多种环境危害,对其资源化利用能够缓解环境压力并回收资源。为探讨生活垃圾资源化利用策略,综合生命周期评价与生命周期成本分析方法,建立生态效率模型。以天津市为例,分析和比较焚烧发电、卫生填埋-填埋气发电、与堆肥+卫生填埋3种典型生活垃圾资源化利用情景的生态效率。结果表明,堆肥+卫生填埋情景具有潜在最优生态效率;全球变暖对总环境影响贡献最大,而投资成本对经济影响贡献最大。考虑天津市生活垃圾管理现状,建议鼓励发展生活垃圾干湿组分分离及厨余垃圾堆肥的资源化利用策略。 相似文献
16.
Julien Matheys Wout Van Autenboer Jean-Marc Timmermans Joeri Van Mierlo Peter Van den Bossche Gaston Maggetto 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2007,12(3):191-196
Goal, Scope and Background This paper describes the influence of the choice of the functional unit on the results of an environmental assessment of different
battery technologies for electric and hybrid vehicles. Battery, hybrid and fuel cell electric vehicles are considered as being
environmentally friendly. However, the batteries they use are sometimes said to be environmentally unfriendly. At the current
state of technology different battery types can be envisaged: lead-acid, nickel-cadmium, nickel-metal hydride, lithium-ion
and sodium-nickel chloride. The environmental impacts described in this paper are based on a life cycle assessment (LCA) approach.
One of the first critical stages of LCA is the definition of an appropriate and specific functional unit for electric and
hybrid vehicle application. Most of the known LCA studies concerning batteries were performed while choosing different functional
units, although this choice can influence the final results. An adequate functional unit, allowing to compare battery technologies
in their real life vehicle application should be chosen.
The results of the LCA are important as they will be used as a decision support for the end-of-life vehicles directive 2000/53/EC
(Official Journal of the European Communities L269/24 2000). As a consequence, a thorough analysis is required to define an
appropriate functional unit for the assessment of batteries for electric vehicles. This paper discusses this issue and will
mainly focus on traction batteries for electric vehicles.
Main Features An overview of the different parameters to be considered in the definition of a functional unit to compare battery technologies
for battery electric vehicle application is described and discussed. An LCA study is performed for the most relevant potential
functional units. SimaPro 6 is used as a software tool and Eco-indicator 99 as an impact assessment method. The influence
of the different selected functional units on the results (Eco-indicator Points) is discussed. The environmental impact of
the different electric vehicle battery technologies is described. A sensitivity analysis illustrates the robustness of the
obtained results.
Results and Discussion Five main parameters are considered in each investigated functional unit: an equal depth of discharge is assumed, a relative
number of batteries required during the life of the vehicle is calculated, the energy losses in the battery and the additional
vehicle consumption due to the battery mass is included and the same lifetime distance target is taken into account. On the
basis of the energy content, battery mass, number of cycles and vehicle autonomy three suitable functional units are defined:
‘battery packs with an identical mass’, ‘battery packs with an identical energy content’ and ‘battery packs with an identical
one-charge range’.
The results show that the differences in the results between these three functional units are small and imply less variation
on the results than the other uncertainties inherent to LCA studies. On the other hand, the results obtained using other,
less adequate, functional units can be quite different.
Conclusions When performing an LCA study, it’s important to choose an appropriate functional unit. Most of the time, this choice is unambiguous.
However, sometimes this choice is more complicated when different correlated parameters have to be considered, as it is the
case for traction batteries. When using a realistic functional unit, the result is not influenced significantly by the choice
of one out of the three suitable functional units.
Additionally, the life cycle assessment allowed concluding that three electric vehicle battery technologies have a comparable
environmental impact: lead-acid, nickel-cadmium and nickel-metal hydride. Lithium-ion and sodium-nickel chloride have lower
environmental impacts than the three previously cited technologies when used in a typical battery electric vehicle application.
Recommendations and Perspectives The article describes the need to consider all relevant parameters for the choice of a functional unit for an electric vehicle
battery, as this choice can influence the conclusions. A more standardised method to define the functional unit could avoid
these differences and could make it possible to compare the results of different traction battery LCA studies more easily. 相似文献
17.
Goal, Scope and Background Gipuzkoa is a department of the Vasque Country (Spain) with a population of about 700,000 people. By the year 2000 approximately
85% of municipal solid waste in this area was managed by landfilling, and only 15% was recycled. Due to environmental law
restrictions and landfill capacity being on its limit, a planning process was initiated by the authorities. LCA was used,
from an environmental point of view, to assess 7 possible scenarios arising from the draft Plan for the 2016 time horizon.
Main Features In each scenario, 9 waste flows are analysed: rest waste, paper and cardboard, glass containers, light packaging, organic-green
waste, as well as industrial/commercial wood, metals and plastics, and wastewater sludge. Waste treatments range from recycling
to energy recovery and landfilling.
Results Recycling of the waste flows separated at the source (paper and cardboard, glass, light packaging, organic-green waste, wood
packaging, metals and plastics) results in net environmental benefits caused by the substitution of primary materials, except
in water consumption. These benefits are common to the 7 different scenarios analysed. However, some inefficiencies are detected,
mainly the energy consumption in collection and transport of low density materials, and water consumption in plastic recycling.
The remaining flows, mixed waste and wastewater sludge, are the ones causing the major environmental impacts, by means of
incineration, landfilling of partially stabilised organic material, as well as thermal drying of sludge. With the characterisation
results, none of the seven scenarios can be clearly identified as the most preferable, although, due to the high recycling
rates expected by the Plan, net environmental benefits are achieved in 9 out of 10 impact categories in all scenarios when
integrated waste management is assessed (the sum of the 9 flows of waste). Finally, there are no relevant differences between
scenarios concerning the number of treatment plants considered. Nevertheless, only the effects on transportation impacts were
assessed in the LCA, since the plant construction stage was excluded from the system boundaries.
Conclusions The results of the study show the environmental importance of material recycling in waste management, although the recycling
schemes assessed can be improved in some aspects. It is also important to highlight the environmental impact of incineration
and landfilling of waste, as well as thermal drying of sludge using fossil fuels. One of the main findings of applying LCA
to integrated waste management in Gipuzkoa is the fact that the benefits of high recycling rates can compensate for the impacts
of mixed waste and wastewater sludge.
Recommendations and Outlook Although none of the scenarios can be clearly identified as the one having the best environmental performance, the authorities
in Gipuzkoa now have objective information about the future scenarios, and a multidisciplinary panel could be formed in order
to weight the impacts if necessary. In our opinion, LCA was successfully applied in Gipuzkoa as an environmental tool for
decision making. 相似文献
18.
Life cycle assessment of composite materials made of recycled thermoplastics combined with rice husks and cotton linters 总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1
Rosario Vidal Pilar Martínez Daniel Garraín 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2009,14(1):73-82
Background, aim, and scope The goal of this study is to analyze the environmental impact of new composite materials obtained from the combination of
recycled thermoplastics (polypropylene [PP] and high-density polyethylene [HDPE]) and biodegradable waste of little economic
value, namely, rice husks and recycled cotton. The environmental impact of these materials is compared to the impact of virgin
PP and HDPE using life cycle assessment.
Materials and methods From-cradle-to-grave life cycle inventory studies were performed for 1 kg of each of the three new composites: PP+cotton linters,
PP+rice husks, and HDPE+cotton linters. Inventory data for the recycling of thermoplastics and cotton were obtained from a
number of recycling firms in Spain, while environmental data concerning rice husks were obtained mainly from one rice-processing
company located in Spain. Life cycle inventory data for virgin thermoplastics were acquired from PlasticsEurope. Two different
scenarios—incineration and landfilling—were considered for the assessment of disposal phase. A quantitative impact assessment
was performed for four impact categories: global warming over a hundred years, nonrenewable energy depletion, acidification,
and eutrophication.
Results The composites subject to analysis exhibited a significantly reduced environmental impact during the materials acquisition
and processing phases compared to conventional virgin thermoplastics in all of the impact categories considered. The use of
fertilizers for rice cultivation, however, impaired the results of the rice husk composite in the eutrophication category
where it nevertheless outperformed its conventional counterparts. The compounding phase fundamentally implies an electric
consumption. The disposal phase was analyzed with regard to emissions in the global warming category.
Discussion Composites obtained from renewable sources are still in an incipient state of development in comparison with petroleum-derived
plastics. In the future, as mass production of these plastics becomes more widespread, their environmental impact can be expected
to reach lower levels than those obtained in our study. The new materials exhibited adequate mechanical performance for the
application analyzed (structures used in aquaculture).
Conclusions The composites subject to analysis exhibited a significantly reduced environmental impact compared to conventional virgin
thermoplastics using 1 kg of material as a functional unit.
Recommendations and perspectives In accordance with the International Organization for Standardization 14044:2006 standard, it would be advisable to avoid
impact allocation. This posed some difficulties, since rice husks are a coproduct of rice. Thus, some impact allocation was
done in our study on the basis of economic value. It would also be advisable to take the land use impact category into consideration
when performing comparative studies between composites and conventional plastics, albeit the definition of this category is
currently the subject of scientific debate. 相似文献
19.
Consumer choices affect sustainability of societal systems, and state governments increasingly are interested in environmental impacts of consumption. This article describes a Consumer Environmental Index (CEI) to track the impacts of product purchase, use, and disposal and applies this initial CEI to Washington State in the United States. CEI has modules for product and service use, upstream resource extraction and manufacturing, and downstream disposal. CEI uses hybrid life cycle assessment (LCA) methods, combined with purchasing data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Consumer Expenditure Survey. For Washington State, when human health and ecosystem toxicity impact was assessed with the TRACI/CalTOX methods, weighted aggregate and per consumer impacts in all categories increased during the 6 years from 2000 to 2005. For impacts per real dollar spent, only the CEI's climate change component declined, falling nearly 7% between 2000 and 2005. Purchasing details in the BLS expenditure surveys enable the CEI to track environmental impact details on 700 individual categories of products and services. For example, sugar, motor oil, and wood heat appear to have serious environmental impacts, whereas recycling of paper, cardboard, and food and beverage container discards can be as effective at reducing greenhouse gas emissions as cutting vehicle fuel usage nearly in half. Such results may serve to increase understanding of environmentally effective actions to reduce climate, human health, and ecosystem impacts of consumption. 相似文献
20.
Lucia Rigamonti Mario Grosso Maria Caterina Sunseri 《The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment》2009,14(5):411-419
Background, aim, and scope Life cycle assessment (LCA) applied to alternative waste management strategies is becoming a commonly utilised tool for decision
makers. This LCA study analyses together material and energy recovery within integrated municipal solid waste (MSW) management
systems, i.e. the recovery of materials separated with the source-separated collection of MSW and the energy recovery from
the residual waste. The final aim is to assess the energetic and environmental performance of the entire MSW management system
and, in particular, to evaluate the influence of different assumptions about recycling on the LCA results.
Materials and methods The analysis uses the method of LCA and, thus, takes into account that any recycling activity influences the environment not
only by consuming resources and releasing emissions and waste streams but also by replacing conventional products from primary
production. Different assumptions about the selection efficiencies of the collected materials and about the quantity of virgin
material substituted by the reprocessed material were made. Moreover, the analysis considers that the energy recovered from
the residual waste displaces the same quantity of energy produced in conventional power plants and boilers fuelled with fossil
fuels.
Results The analysis shows, in the expanded model of the material and energy recovering chain, that the environmental gains are higher
than the environmental impacts. However, when we reduce the selection efficiencies by 15%, the impact indicators worsen by
a percentage included between 10% and 26%. This phenomenon is even more evident when we consider a substitution ratio of 1:<1
for paper and plastic: The worsening is around 15–20% for all the impact indicators except for the global warming for which
the worsening is up to 45%.
Discussion Hypotheses about the selection efficiencies of the source-separated collected materials and about the substitution ratio have
a great influence on the LCA results. Consequently, policy makers have to be aware of the fact that the impacts of an integrated
MSW management system are highly dependent on the assumptions made in the modelling of the material recovery, as well as in
the modelling of the energy recovery.
Conclusions LCA allows to evaluate the impacts of integrated systems and how these impacts change when the assumptions made during the
modelling of the different single parts of the system are modified. Due to the significant impacts that hypotheses about material
recovery have in the results, they should be expressed in a very transparent way in the report of LCA studies, together with
the assumptions made about energy recovery.
Recommendations and perspectives The results suggest that the hypotheses about the value of the substitution ratio are very important, and the case of wood
should therefore be better analysed and a substitution ratio of 1:<1 should be used, as for paper and plastic. It seems that
the assumptions made about which material is replaced by the recycled one are very important too, and in this sense, more
research is needed about what the recycled plastic may effectively substitute, in particular the polyolefin mix. 相似文献