Physical basis for detection of DNA double-strand breaks using neutral filter elution

Results using neutral filter elution are difficult to explain if this method detects only DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). In an attempt to understand neutral filter elution, the size of DNA pieces eluted from filters was measured using pulsed-field gel electrophoresis. Contrary to expectation, the size of the pieces was independent of radiation dose and time of elution, and much smaller (approximately 460 kb) than anticipated based on the expected number of DSBs induced. Shearing of the DNA molecule, the presence of nonspecific nucleases, and the influence of DNA-associated proteins were examined but could not explain our results. Consequently, we propose that cell lysis causes swelling of the DNA gel, and the exposed fraction of DNA on the surface of the gel is then sheared as the elution solution flows through the filter. We suggest that the rate of DNA elution measured using neutral filter elution is dependent upon the number of DSBs present, the composition of the eluting solution, especially with regard to the presence of molecules which can influence chromatin swelling on the filter, and the conformation or "packaging" of DNA before lysis.     

X-ray-induced DNA double-strand breaks in mouse l1210 cells: a new computational method for analyzing neutral filter elution data

The aim of this article is to present a method for studying the shape of the dose and repair responses for X-ray-induced double-strand breaks (DSBs) as measured by neutral filter elution (NFE). The approach is closely related to a method we developed for the use of specific molecular size markers and used for determination of the absolute number of randomly distributed radiation-induced DSBs by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). Mouse leukemia L1210 cells were X-irradiated with 0-50 Gy. Samples were then evaluated both with PFGE and with NFE. Assuming that with both migration (PFGE) and elution (NFE), a heterogeneous population of double-stranded DNA fragments will start with the smallest fragments and proceed with increasingly larger fragments, it is possible to match the migration behavior of fractions of fragments smaller than a certain size to the fraction eluted at a specific time. This assumption does not exclude the possibility of DNA being sheared in the NFE filter. The yield, as determined by the size markers in PFGE, was used to find the corresponding elution times in the NFE experiment. These experimentally used elution times could then reversely be interpreted as size markers which finally were used to calculate DSBs/Mbp as a function of X-ray dose. The resulting lines were almost straight. The data were also plotted as relative elution and showed that, as expected, the dose response then appears with a more pronounced sigmoid shape.     

Measurement of double-strand breaks in Chinese hamster cell DNA by neutral filter elution: calibration by 125I decay

We labeled the DNA of Chinese hamster lung V79 cells with 125I in the form of iododeoxyuridine and subsequently measured the elution of the DNA through polycarbonate filters at pH 9.6 and pH 7.2. Since decay of incorporated 125I produces predominantly double-strand breaks (DSB) in DNA at a rate close to one DSB per 125I decay, this measurement provides an absolute calibration for the assay of DSBs by neutral filter elution. Neutral elution profiles are not first order with respect to elution time; thus we have examined the relationships between accumulated 125I decays and several functions of retention of DNA on the filter at various times during the elution process. At both pH 9.6 and pH 7.2 there were linear relationships between accumulated decays and certain retention functions. The retention function most closely correlated to 125I decays for both pH values was the logarithm of the ratio of the retention of control DNA to that of 125I-labeled DNA, both evaluated at the 9th fraction (13.5 h of elution). The linear relationship between this ratio and 125I decays allows DSB induction to be determined directly from retention values. The calibration was used to measure DSBs induced by X rays.     

Evidence from nondenaturing filter elution that induction of double-strand breaks in the DNA of Chinese hamster V79 cells by gamma radiation is proportional to the square of dose

We have used nondenaturing filter elution performed at both pH 7.2 and pH 9.6 to measure the induction of double-strand breaks (DSBs) in the DNA of Chinese hamster V79 cells by 60Co gamma-radiation doses between 10 and 120 Gy. The absolute DSB yields as measured by this assay were determined by using our recent calibration of the assay based upon disintegrations of 125I incorporated into the DNA. An analysis of the dose-response relationship for the induction of DSBs by 60Co gamma rays showed that the number of DSBs induced per dalton of DNA was proportional to the square of the applied dose throughout the dose range used. The contribution made by the dose to the first power was small at pH 9.6 and negligible at pH 7.2. These results suggest that DSB induction in cells by gamma rays may be entirely a two-hit event.     

Measurement of radiation-induced DNA damage using gel electrophoresis or neutral filter elution shows an increased frequency of DNA strand breaks after exposure to pH 9.6

The filter elution technique using nondenaturing conditions is widely used to assay DNA double-strand break (DSB) induction and repair. It has been reported that in the measurement of strand breaks higher rates of elution and of initial rejoining are obtained at pH 9.6 compared to pH 7.2. In the present experiments neutral elution at pH 7.2 and 9.6 were compared in the assay of damage to DNA induced by X rays, 125I decay, and restriction enzyme digestion, in an effort to explain this discrepancy and to determine whether the higher rate of elution observed at pH 9.6 corresponds to a greater number of DSBs. X-ray damage to cellular DNA resulted in significantly different elution profiles at the two pH values. In contrast the elution profiles of the DSB induced by intragenomic 125I decays or restriction endonuclease were independent of the pH of the elution buffer. When gamma-irradiated SV40 DNA was exposed to pH 7.2 or 9.6 elution buffer prior to analysis by gel electrophoresis, a significantly greater number of DNA DSBs were detected in the DNA exposed to pH 9.6. We conclude that X and gamma radiation produce lesions (pH 9.6-labile lesions), in proportion to dose, that have the potential of becoming measurable DSBs following incubation under the mildly alkaline condition of pH 9.6. The data suggest that these lesions may result from single-hit events.     

Incomplete rejoining of DNA double-strand breaks in unstimulated normal human lymphocytes

We investigated the repair kinetics of DNA single-strand breaks (SSBs) and double-strand breaks (DSBs) in unstimulated normal human peripheral blood lymphocytes (HPBL). SSBs and DSBs induced by gamma-irradiation (at 0 degree C) were assayed without radiolabel by alkaline and neutral filter elution, respectively. Incubation of irradiated cells at 37 degrees C for various lengths of time demonstrated that the percent DNA rejoined increased until it reached a plateau at approximately 60 min; this repair plateau underwent no substantial change when incubation continued for 20-24 h. The level of the plateau indicated how closely the elution profile of DNA from cells irradiated and incubated (experimental) resembled the elution profile of DNA from unirradiated cells (control). After 6 Gy and 60 min incubation, the alkaline elution profile of DNA from experimental cells from 5 donors was indistinguishable from that seen in DNA from control cells, suggesting that rejoining of SSBs was complete. In contrast after 100 Gy and 60 min incubation the neutral elution profile of DNA from cells from the same donors demonstrated that, compared to DNA from control cells, rejoining of DSBs was approximately two-thirds complete. In the range of 2-8 Gy, 85-104% of SSBs were rejoined after 60 min incubation; in the range of 30-120 Gy, 46-80% of DSBs were rejoined after 60 min incubation. These unexpected results stand in contrast to our previous studies with confluent normal human diploid fibroblasts (HDF), in which rejoining of both SSBs and DSBs was greater than 90% complete by 60 min repair incubation and 100% complete after 18-24 h.     

Detection of ionizing radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks by filter elution is affected by nuclear chromatin structure

Chinese hamster ovary cells were irradiated with 250 kVp X rays and analyzed for the presence of DNA double-strand breaks using either polycarbonate filter elution or pulsed-field agarose gel electrophoresis at neutral pH. Reduction in DNA length detected by filter elution was produced as a nonlinear function of increasing radiation dose, with a quasi-threshold at low total dose, and as a first-order function of increasing radiation dose as detected by gel electrophoresis. The quasi-threshold observed with filter elution was eliminated when nuclei were isolated from irradiated cells and their chromatin relaxed in a buffer containing low-molarity monovalent cation prior to analysis by filter elution. The results suggest either that the chemical structure of the DNA double-strand breaks produced by low-LET radiation necessitates a DNA relaxation step before they can be detected accurately by filter elution, or that at low total radiation dose a DNA complex forms on the polycarbonate filter.     

Investigation of the neutral filter elution technique I. Effects of pore density and pore diameter on elution rate at pH 9.6

To understand better the biophysical mechanism of neutral filter elution (pH 9.6), we eluted genomes of known size and shape: coliphage T4c (Mr 1.15 x 10(8), E. coli (Mr 2.7 x 10(9)), and Chinese hamster lung fibroblasts (V79, Mr 2-4 x 10(10)). DNA eluted through 15% sucrose atop the filter in a biphasic pattern. The elution rate of the initial component correlated (r greater than 0.97) exponentially with 1/Mr for monodisperse samples of DNA eluted through pore sizes 0.1-3.0 microns. Using this relationship between elution rate and Mr, we estimated Mn of polydisperse, X-irradiated (253 Gy) samples of DNA from E. coli or V79 cells to be 3.15 +/- 1.46 and 1.42 +/- 0.33, respectively, compared to expected values of 2.93 and 3.52 (10(8) Da). The best predictor of elution rate for DNA from T4c and intact and X-irradiated V79 cells was pore density, and pore diameter for DNA from X-irradiated E. coli. The rate of elution of DNA from unirradiated E. coli was unrelated to pore density or diameter. While the mechanism of neutral filter elution remains unknown, its use for linear DNAs with Mn ca. 10(8) Da appears to be valid quantitatively.     

Filter elution assays for DNA damage: practical and mechanistic significance of the DNA in the filter support wash.

The alkaline and neutral (or nondenaturing) filter elution assays are popular methods for the measurement of DNA strand breakage and its repair in eukaryotic cells. In both alkaline and neutral elution, it is recommended practice to wash the filter support after removal of the filter and to analyze the DNA recovered by this procedure together with that remaining on the filter as uneluted DNA, although it is not obvious why the DNA in the filter support wash should be so interpreted. We have observed that the sum of the DNA on the filter and that recovered in the filter support wash is approximately constant when the pH of the alkaline filter elution assay for total strand breaks is increased from 12.1 to 12.6, whereas the fraction on the filter itself is markedly smaller at the higher pH. This behavior characterized DNA elution from undamaged cells, as well as from cells treated with various DNA-damaging agents. These findings are consistent with the "tug-of-war" mechanism that has been proposed for alkaline elution, but are inconsistent with the simplest mechanism of the "sieve" class. In the neutral filter elution assay for double-strand breaks, by contrast, the distribution of DNA between the filter and the filter support wash is pH-independent. This suggests that single- and double-stranded DNA segments traverse a filter by different physical mechanisms. Our observations underscore the importance of carrying out the filter support wash and the analysis of the DNA it contains as uneluted DNA in alkaline elution, while indicating that a different analysis of this DNA might be appropriate for neutral elution.     

X-ray induced DNA double strand break production and repair in mammalian cells as measured by neutral filter elution.

This work presents a neutral filter elution method for detecting DNA double strand breaks in mouse L1210 cells after X-ray. The assay will detect the number of double strand breaks induced by as little as 1000 rad of X-ray. The rate of DNA elution through the filters under neutral conditions increases with X-ray dose. Certain conditions for deproteinization, pH, and filter type are shown to increase the assay's sensitivity. Hydrogen peroxide and Bleomycin also induce apparent DNA double strand breaks, although the ratios of double to single strand breaks vary from those produced by X-ray. The introduction of double strand cuts by HpA I restriction endonuclease in DNA lysed on filters results in a rapid rate of elution under neutral conditions, implying that the method can detect double strand breaks if they exist in the DNA. The eluted DNA bands with a double stranded DNA marker in cesium chloride. This evidence suggests that the assay detects DNA double strand breaks. L1210 cells are shown to rejoin most of the DNA double strand breaks induced by 5-10 krad of X-ray with a half-time of about 40 minutes.     

Elaboration of cellular DNA breaks by hydroperoxides.

Cellular damage produced by ionizing radiation and peroxides, hydrogen peroxide (HOOH) and the organic peroxides tert-butyl (tBuOOH) or cumene hydroperoxide (CuOOH) were compared. DNA breaks, toxicity, malondialdehyde production, and the rate of peroxide disappearance were measured in a human adenocarcinoma cell line (A549). The alkaline and neutral filter elution assays were used to quantitate the kinetics of single and double strand break formation and repair (SSB and DSB), respectively. Peroxides, at 0.01-1.0 mM, produce multiphasic dose response curves for both toxicity and DNA SSBs. Radiation, 1-6 Gy, produced a shouldered survival curve, and both DNA SSB and DSBs produced in cells x-rayed on ice were nearly linear with dose. The peroxides produced more SSBs than radiation at equitoxic doses. X-ray induced DNA single strand breaks were rejoined rapidly by cells at 37 degrees C with approximately 80% of initial damage repaired in 20 min. Peroxide induced SSBs were maximal after 15 min at 37 degrees C. Rejoining proceeded thereafter, but at a rate less than for x-ray induced strand breaks. Significant DNA DSBs could not be achieved by peroxides even at concentrations 50-fold higher than required to produce SSBs. HOOH treatment of DNA on filters following cell lysis and proteolysis produced SSBs. CuOOH and tBuOOH produced no SSBs in lysed cell DNA. None of the peroxides produced DSBs when incubated with lysed cell DNA. Malondialdehyde was released from cells incubated with organic hydroperoxides, but not HOOH, nor up to 40 Gy of x-rays. HOOH was metabolized three times faster than the organic peroxides. The overall results demonstrate the necessity for a metabolically active cell environment to elaborate maximal DNA strand breaks and cell death at hydroperoxide concentrations of 10(-4) or greater, but prevent strand breaks and stimulate cell growth at 10(-5) M.     

Radioprotection of cultured mammalian cells by the aminothiols WR-1065 and WR-255591: correlation between protection against DNA double-strand breaks and cell killing after gamma radiation

We compared the effects of the radioprotective aminothiols WR-1065 and WR-255591 on the induction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) and on the survival of aerated Chinese hamster ovary cells exposed to 60Co gamma radiation. DSBs were measured using the pH 9.6 neutral elution method. In agreement with earlier studies, protection factors for both drugs measured using the end point of clonogenic cell survival were significantly greater than the protection factors for DSB induction when DSBs were measured after gamma-ray doses ranging from 20 to 90 Gy. However, when DSBs and cell survival measurements were made on the same cell populations after low radiation doses (between 3 and 30 Gy) using the replicate plating method, there appeared to be a close correlation between the modification of DSB induction and the modification of cell survival produced by both drugs. The major influence accounting for the differences between these and previously obtained results appears to be the range of radiation doses used, suggesting that protection against DSB induction is radiation-dose dependent.     

Induction by H2O2 of DNA and interphase chromosome damage in plateau-phase Chinese hamster ovary cells.

The induction by H2O2 of DNA breaks, DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), and interphase chromatin damage and their relationship to cytotoxicity were studied in plateau-phase Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Damage in interphase chromatin was assayed by means of premature chromosome condensation (PCC); DNA DSBs were assayed by nondenaturing filter elution (pH 9.6), and DNA breaks by hydroxyapatite chromatography. Cells were treated with H2O2 in suspension at 0 degrees C for 30 min and treatment was terminated by the addition of catalase. Concentrations of H2O2 lower than 1 mM were not cytotoxic, whereas concentrations of 40 and 60 mM reduced cell survival to 0.1 and 0.004, respectively. An induction of DNA breaks that was dependent on H2O2 concentration was observed at low H2O2 concentrations that reached a maximum at approximately 1 mM; at higher H2O2 concentrations induction of DNA breaks either remained unchanged or decreased. Damage at the chromosome level was not evenly distributed among the cells, when compared to that expected based on a Poisson distribution. Three categories of cells were identified after exposure to H2O2: cells with intact, control-like chromosomes, cells showing chromosome fragmentation similar to that observed in cells exposed to ionizing radiation, and cells showing a loss in the ability of their chromatin to condense into chromosomes under the PCC reaction. The fraction of cells with fragmented chromosomes, as well as the number of excess chromosomes per cell, showed a dose response similar to that of DNA DSBs, reaching a maximum at 1 mM and decreasing at higher concentrations. The results indicate that induction of DNA and chromosome damage by H2O2 follows a complex dependence probably resulting from a depletion of reducing equivalents in the vicinity of the DNA. Reducing equivalents are required to recycle the transition metal ions that are needed to maintain a Fenton-type reaction. The absence of cell killing at H2O2 concentrations that yielded the maximum amount of DNA and chromosome damage suggests that this damage is nonlethal and repairable. It is suggested that lethal DNA and chromosome damage is induced at higher concentrations of H2O2 where cell killing is observed by an unidentified mechanism.     

A modified fluorimetric neutral filter elution method for analyzing radiation-induced double strand break and repair

Neutral filter elution assay is one of the methods used for detection of DNA double strand breaks (DSBs). However, it is laborious, expensive, and hazardous (radiolabeled precursors for DSB detection and scintillation counter for quantification), making it a less preferred method for DSB detection. In the present study, an attempt was made to improve the existing neutral filter elution assay by making use of fluorescent dye (PicoGreen) and microfiltration assembly for eluting the fragmented DNA, thereby reducing the cost and time required for the assay. We studied the effect of dye dilution, pH conditions, and cell number as a part of method standardization. X-ray dose–response and repair kinetics in lymphocytes as well as cell lines were studied for validating the sensitivity of the assay. A linear dose–response relationship for DSBs was observed at a cell number of 4 × 10⁵ cells, a dye dilution of 500-fold, and at pH 10. Repair kinetics revealed a time-dependent repair of DSBs up to 360 min of posttreatment, indicating its usefulness in DSB repair studies. In conclusion, the present modified method is more efficient (in terms of cell number), cost effective, less time-consuming, and less hazardous compared to the existing method.     

Evidence to support the existence of efficient DNA double-strand break rejoining in a radiosensitive mutant of V79-4 following irradiation with 250 kVp X-rays or neutrons

The repair of ionising-radiation-induced DNA double-strand break type damage was measured by Kohn neutral elution in an X-ray-sensitive mutant of V79-4, irs1. This was done in order to investigate further the likelihood that irs1 carries a defect which leads to error-prone repair of DNA damage, and not simply a reduced ability to rejoin DNA double-strand breaks. The mutant displayed an equal increase in sensitivity to the lethal effects of neutrons, as compared to X-rays. Both irs1 and V79-4 showed an increased sensitivity to the killing effects of neutrons of around 2 at 10% survival. irs1 also showed an exponential survival after either X-rays or neutrons. The induction of DNA double-strand breaks was measured in both cell lines over a dose range of 10-40 Gy using Kohn neutral filter elution. Induction of breaks by X-rays in irs1 seemed to increase slightly with dose, relative to induction in V79-4, so that at 40 Gy 1.5 times more DNA double-strand breaks were measured in irs1 cells than in V79-4. Neutron irradiation resulted in a more similar level of induction in either strain after 10-40 Gy. This difference in induction of damage may be due to a different cell-cycle composition in either cell line. The rejoining of X-ray induced double-strand breaks showed a very similar pattern (on a percentage rejoined basis) in both cell lines, although from the induction data at 40 Gy, the dose at which rejoining was measured, fewer breaks were rejoined in V79-4 but also fewer breaks remained unsealed. Neutron-induced breaks, however, were rejoined more efficiently in irs1 again on a percentage basis, but also in absolute terms since similar induction was seen after 40 Gy. This data, together with the differences seen in the rejoining of X-ray compared to neutron induced breaks, may indirectly support the proposal that irs1 is a misrepair mutant.     

Multisample parallel array fraction collector: application in DNA alkaline elution studies

A fraction collector designed specifically to be compatible with the analytical techniques of alkaline and neutral elution of DNA from carcinogen-treated cells is described. This apparatus, which is operated by microchip controls, permits simultaneous collection of as many as 20 eluted samples directly into standard- or small-size scintillation vials contained in manufacturer's shipping cartons. This instrument saves operator time, offers considerable flexibility, and has several fail-safe features.     

Detection of complex DNA damage in gamma-irradiated acute lymphoblastic leukemia Pre-b NALM-6 cells

Bistranded complex DNA damage, i.e., double-strand breaks (DSBs) and non-DSB oxidative clustered DNA lesions, is hypothesized to challenge the repair mechanisms of the cell and consequently the genomic integrity. The oxidative clustered DNA lesions may be persistent and may accumulate in human cancer cells for long times after irradiation. To evaluate the detection and possible accumulation of oxidative clustered DNA lesions in leukemia cells exposed to doses equivalent to those used in radiotherapy, we measured the induction of DSBs and three different types of oxidative clustered DNA lesions in NALM-6 cells, a human acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) pre-B cell line, after exposure to (137)Cs gamma rays. For the detection and measurement of DSBs and oxidative clustered DNA lesions, we used an adaptation of the neutral comet assay (single-cell gel electrophoresis) using E. coli repair enzymes (Endo IV, Fpg and Endo III) as enzymatic probes. We found a linear dose response for the induction of DSBs and oxidative clustered DNA lesions. Clustered DNA lesions were more prevalent than prompt DSBs. For each DSB induced by radiation, approximately 2.5 oxidative clustered DNA lesions were detected. To our knowledge, this is the first study to demonstrate the detection and linear induction of oxidative clustered DNA lesions with radiation dose in an ALL cell line. These results point to the biological significance of clustered DNA lesions.     

Age-dependent decline in rejoining of X-ray-induced DNA double-strand breaks in normal human lymphocytes

Unstimulated human peripheral blood lymphocytes (HPBL), separated by density centrifugation from anticoagulated whole blood, were X-irradiated (30 Gy) on ice and incubated in medium at 37 degrees C for repair times of 15, 30, and 120 min. Blood donors were 18 normotensive, non-smoking Caucasians aged 23-78, free from overt pathology and not taking any medications. Neutral filter elution was used to assay DNA double-strand break (DSB) induction and completeness of DSB rejoining (plus rejoining of any X-ray-induced alkali-labile sites converted to DSBs in vitro at pH 9.6). After 30 or 120 min repair incubation, the percentage of DSBs rejoined by cells from older donors (aged 66-78 years) was less than half the percentage of DSBs rejoined by cells from younger donors (aged 23-39 and 42-57). When data from the 3 age groups were pooled, the age-related decline in percent DSBs rejoined was significant for repair times 30 min (r = -0.63, p less than 0.005) and 120 min (r = -0.64, p less than 0.005) but not for 15 min (r = -0.04). These age-related declines were observed even though DNA from older donors sustained fewer strand breaks as demonstrated by the negative correlation between donor age and DSB induction (r = -0.65, p less than 0.005). These results suggest that the efficacy of X-ray-induced DSB repair diminishes with in vivo age in unstimulated HPBL.     

Comparative radiation tolerance based on the induction of DNA double-strand breaks in tobacco BY-2 cells and CHO-K1 cells irradiated with gamma rays

Higher plants are generally more tolerant to ionizing radiation than mammals. To explore the radiation tolerance of higher plants, the induction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) by gamma rays was investigated in tobacco BY-2 cells and compared with that in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO)-K1 cells as a reference. This is the first examination of radiation-induced DSBs in a higher plant cell. The resulting DNA fragments were separated by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis and stained with SYBR Green I. The initial yield of DSBs was then quantified from the fraction of DNA fragments shorter than 1.6 Mbp based on the assumption of random distribution of DSBs. The DSB yield in tobacco BY-2 cells (2.0 +/- 0.1 DSBs Gbp(-1) Gy(-1)) was only one-third of that in CHO-K1 cells. Furthermore, the calculated number of DSBs per diploid cell irradiated with gamma rays at the mean lethal dose was five times greater in BY-2 cells (263 +/- 13) than in CHO-K1 cells. These results suggest that the radiation tolerance of BY-2 cells appears to be due not only to a lower induction of DNA damage but also to a more efficient repair of the induced DNA damage.