Crystallization of complexes of EcoRV endonuclease with cognate and non-cognate DNA fragments

Complexes of the type II restriction endonuclease EcoRV with a variety of short, selfcomplementary deoxyoligonucleotides have been crystallized. The best crystals diffract to about 2.7 A resolution and consist of 1:1 complexes between endonuclease dimers and duplexes of the cognate decamer GGGATATCCC containing the hexameric RV recognition sequence GATATC. Crystals with the non-cognate DNA octamer duplexes CGAGCTCG and CGAATTCG diffract to 3.0 and 3.5 A resolution, respectively, and contain two DNA duplexes per enzyme dimer.     

Non-cognate enzyme-DNA complex: structural and kinetic analysis of EcoRV endonuclease bound to the EcoRI recognition site GAATTC

The crystal structure of EcoRV endonuclease bound to non-cognate DNA at 2.0 angstroms resolution shows that very small structural adaptations are sufficient to ensure the extreme sequence specificity characteristic of restriction enzymes. EcoRV bends its specific GATATC site sharply by 50 degrees into the major groove at the center TA step, generating unusual base-base interactions along each individual DNA strand. In the symmetric non-cognate complex bound to GAATTC, the center step bend is relaxed to avoid steric hindrance caused by the different placement of the exocyclic thymine methyl groups. The decreased base-pair unstacking in turn leads to small conformational rearrangements in the sugar-phosphate backbone, sufficient to destabilize binding of crucial divalent metal ions in the active site. A second crystal structure of EcoRV bound to the base-analog GAAUTC site shows that the 50 degrees center-step bend of the DNA is restored. However, while divalent metals bind at high occupancy in this structure, one metal ion shifts away from binding at the scissile DNA phosphate to a position near the 3'-adjacent phosphate group. This may explain why the 10(4)-fold attenuated cleavage efficiency toward GAATTC is reconstituted by less than tenfold toward GAAUTC. Examination of DNA binding and bending by equilibrium and stopped-flow florescence quenching and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) methods demonstrates that the capacity of EcoRV to bend the GAATTC non-cognate site is severely limited, but that full bending of GAAUTC is achieved at only a threefold reduced rate compared with the cognate complex. Together, the structural and biochemical data demonstrate the existence of distinct mechanisms for ensuring specificity at the bending and catalytic steps, respectively. The limited conformational rearrangements observed in the EcoRV non-cognate complex provide a sharp contrast to the extensive structural changes found in a non-cognate BamHI-DNA crystal structure, thus demonstrating a diversity of mechanisms by which restriction enzymes are able to achieve specificity.     

Specificity from the synapsis of DNA elements by the Sfi I endonuclease.

The synapsis of DNA sites is a prerequisite for the reactions of many proteins that act at specific DNA sequences. The requirement for synapsis was investigated by analysing the reactions of Sfi I, a tetrameric restriction enzyme that cleaves DNA only after interacting with two recognition sites. In the presence of Mg2+, oligonucleotide duplexes with the cognate recognition sequence were cleaved rapidly, with cooperative kinetics, while non-cognate duplexes were not cleaved. In the absence of Mg2+, the primary complex formed by Sfi I with cognate DNA contained two duplexes synapsed by the tetramer: a secondary complex containing one duplex was seen only at elevated Sfi I concentrations. In contrast, the principal complex with non-cognate DNA contained one duplex bound to Sfi I. Pairs of non-cognate duplexes, or one cognate and one non-cognate duplex, generally failed to form synaptic complexes. On adding Mg2+to complexes with cognate DNA, cleavage occurred much more rapidly in the synaptic complex than in the secondary complex. DNA synapsis thus acts to enhance the specificity of Sfi I for its recognition sequence, by demanding two cognate sites for a catalytically active complex and by excluding non-cognate sites from the synaptic complex.     

Cross-linking of SsoII restriction endonuclease to cognate and non-cognate DNAs

Specific and non-specific interactions SsoII restriction endonuclease (R·SsoII) were probed by the method of covalent attachment to modified DNA containing an active monosubstituted pyrophosphate internucleotide bond instead of a phosphodiester one. R·SsoII with six N-terminal His residues was shown to be cross-linked to duplexes with this type of modification, either containing or not the recognition sequence. Competition experiments with covalent attachment of R·SsoII to activated DNAs demonstrated the similar affinity of the enzyme to cognate and non-cognate DNAs in the absence of cofactor, Mg²⁺ ions.     

Communications between catalytic sites in the protein-DNA synapse by the SfiI endonuclease

The SfiI endonuclease is a tetrameric protein with two DNA-binding clefts. It has to bind two copies of its recognition sequence, one at each cleft, before it cleaves DNA. While SfiI binds cooperatively to two cognate sites, it binds only one non-cognate DNA molecule at a time and the resultant complex is precluded from binding cognate DNA at the vacant cleft. To examine the communications between separate binding sites in a protein that synapses two segments of DNA, SfiI was tested with oligonucleotide duplexes containing its recognition sequence but with either R(p) or S(p) phosphorothioate linkages at the scissile bonds. Though SfiI has low activity on the R(p) and none against the S(p) diastereoisomer, it bound these duplexes in the same cooperative manner as oxyester duplexes, though with a reduced affinity for the S(p) derivative. It also formed complexes with one phosphorothioate-duplex and one oxyester-duplex but, when Mg(2+) was added to the hybrid complexes, the phosphorothioate moiety at one DNA-binding cleft prevented the enzyme from cleaving the oxyester duplex at the other cleft. SfiI is thus restrained from catalytic action until it recognises the correct nucleotide sequence at two DNA loci and the correct phosphodiester functions at both loci.     

Fidelity of DNA sequence recognition by the SfiI restriction endonuclease is determined by communications between its two DNA-binding sites

The SfiI restriction endonuclease is a tetramer in which two subunits form a dimeric unit that contains one DNA binding cleft and the other two subunits contain a second cleft on the opposite side of the protein. Full activity requires both clefts to be filled with its recognition sequence: SfiI has low activity when bound to one site. The ability of SfiI to cleave non-cognate sites, one base pair different from the true site, was initially tested on substrates that lacked specific sites but which contained either one or multiple non-cognate sites. No cleavage of the DNA with one non-cognate site was detected, while a small fraction of the DNA with multiple sites was nicked. The alternative sequences were, however, cleaved in both strands, albeit at low levels, when the DNA also carried either a recognition site for SfiI or the termini generated by SfiI. Further tests employed a mutant of SfiI, altered at the dimer interface, which was known to be more active than wild-type SfiI when bound to a single site. This mutant similarly failed to cleave DNA with one non-cognate site, but cleaved the substrates with multiple non-cognate sites more readily than did the native enzyme. To cleave additional sites, SfiI thus needs to interact concurrently with either two non-cognate sites or one non-cognate and one cognate site (or the termini thereof), yet this arrangement is still restrained from cleaving the alternative site unless the communication pathway between the two DNA-binding clefts is disrupted.     

The td intron endonuclease I-TevI makes extensive sequence-tolerant contacts across the minor groove of its DNA target.

I-TevI, a double-strand DNA endonuclease encoded by the mobile td intron of phage T4, has specificity for the intronless td allele. Genetic and physical studies indicate that the enzyme makes extensive contacts with its DNA substrate over at least three helical turns and around the circumference of the helix. Remarkably, no single nucleotide within a 48 bp region encompassing this interaction domain is essential for cleavage. Although two subdomains (DI and DII) contain preferred sequences, a third domain (DIII), a primary region of contact with the enzyme, displays much lower sequence preference. While DII and DIII suffice for recognition and binding of I-TevI, all three domains are important for formation of a cleavage-competent complex. Mutational, footprinting and interference studies indicate predominant interactions of I-TevI across the minor groove and phosphate backbone of the DNA. Contacts appear not to be at the single nucleotide level; rather, redundant interactions and/or structural recognition are implied. These unusual properties provide a basis for understanding how I-TevI recognizes T-even phage DNA, which is heavily modified in the major groove. These recognition characteristics may increase the range of natural substrates available to the endonuclease, thereby extending the invasive potential of the mobile intron.     

DNA determinants important in sequence recognition by Eco RI endonuclease

Alkylation interference and protection methods (Siebenlist, U., and Gilbert, W., (1980) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 77, 122-126) have been utilized to deduce potential DNA contacts involved in specific complex formation between Eco RI endonuclease and its recognition sequence. The endonuclease protected the N7 position (major groove) of the dG and the N3 position (minor groove) of both dA residues within the Eco RI sequence against alkylation by dimethylsulfate, d(GpApApTpTpC), suggesting the presence of poly-peptide in both grooves in the vicinity of affected nitrogens. Results of methylation interference analysis suggest that the N7 of the Eco RI site dG and the N3 of the central dA, d(GpApApTpTpC), are utilized as contacts by the enzyme. The failure to observe interference upon methylation of the 5'-penultimate dA within the sequence implies that the endonuclease does not bond to the N3 of this residue, despite the fact that it is protected against alkylation by the protein. Ethylation interference patterns suggest four major phosphate contacts between endonuclease and each DNA strand. Two of these phosphates are 5'-external to the Eco RI sequence, d(pNpGpApApTpTpC), suggesting involvement of outside phosphates in electrostatic interactions. Moreover, alkylation protection and interference effects on the two DNA strands display perfect 2-fold symmetry. Thus, the endonuclease interacts with a minimum of 10 nucleotide pairs to yield a DNA-protein complex characterized by elements of symmetry. In contrast, specific alkylation effects were not observed in comparable experiments with the endonuclease and a DNA which had been previously methylated by the Eco RI modification enzyme.     

The elastic network model reveals a consistent picture on intrinsic functional dynamics of type II restriction endonucleases

The vibrational dynamics of various type II restriction endonucleases, in complex with cognate/non-cognate DNA and in the apo form, are investigated with the elastic network model in order to reveal common functional mechanisms in this enzyme family. Scissor-like and tong-like motions observed in the slowest modes of all enzymes and their complexes point to common DNA recognition and cleavage mechanisms. Normal mode analysis further points out that the scissor-like motion has an important role in differentiating between cognate and non-cognate sequences at the recognition site, thus implying its catalytic relevance. Flexible regions observed around the DNA-binding site of the enzyme usually concentrate on the highly conserved β-strands, especially after DNA binding. These β-strands may have a structurally stabilizing role in functional dynamics for target site recognition and cleavage. In addition, hot spot residues based on high-frequency modes reveal possible communication pathways between the two distant cleavage sites in the enzyme family. Some of these hot spots also exist on the shortest path between the catalytic sites and are highly conserved.     

Binding kinetics and footprinting of TaqI endonuclease: effects of metal cofactors on sequence-specific interactions.

Restriction endonucleases achieve sequence-specific recognition and strand cleavage through the interplay of base, phosphate backbone, and metal cofactor interactions. In this study, we investigate the binding kinetics of TaqI endonuclease using the wild-type enzyme and a binding proficient, catalysis deficient mutant TaqI-D137A both in the absence of a metal cofactor and in the presence of Mg2+ or Ca2+. As demonstrated by gel mobility shift analyses, TaqI endonuclease requires a metal cofactor for achieving high-affinity specific binding to its cognate sequence, TCGA. In the absence of a metal cofactor, the enzyme binds all DNA sequences (TaqI cognate site, star site, and nonspecific site) with essentially equal affinity, thereby exhibiting little discrimination. The dissociation constant of the cognate sequence in the presence of Mg2+ at 60 degrees C is 0. 26 nM, a value comparable to our previously reported Km of 0.5 nM measured under steady-state conditions. The TaqI-TCGA-Mg2+ complex is stable, with a half-life of 21 min at 60 degrees C. The boundary of the protein-DNA interface is approximated to be about 18 bp as determined by DNase I footprinting. Data from this study support the notion that a metal cofactor plays a critical role for achieving sequence-specific discrimination in a subset of nucleases, including TaqI, EcoRV, and others.     

Mechanism of DNA Recognition by the Restriction Enzyme EcoRV

EcoRV, a restriction enzyme in Escherichia coli, destroys invading foreign DNA by cleaving it at the center step of a GATATC sequence. In the EcoRV-cognate DNA crystallographic complex, a sharp kink of 50° has been found at the center base-pair step (TA). Here, we examine the interplay between the intrinsic propensity of the cognate sequence to kink and the induction by the enzyme by performing all-atom molecular dynamics simulations of EcoRV unbound and interacting with three DNA sequences: the cognate sequence, GATATC (TA); the non-cognate sequence, GAATTC (AT); and with the cognate sequence methylated on the first adenine GA_CH3TATC (TA-CH₃). In the unbound EcoRV, the cleft between the two C-terminal subdomains is found to be open. Binding to AT narrows the cleft and forms a partially bound state. However, the intrinsic bending propensity of AT is insufficient to allow tight binding. In contrast, the cognate TA sequence is easier to bend, allowing specific, high-occupancy hydrogen bonds to form in the complex. The absence of cleavage for this methylated sequence is found to arise from the loss of specific hydrogen bonds between the first adenine of the recognition sequence and Asn185. On the basis of the results, we suggest a three-step recognition mechanism. In the first step, EcoRV, in an open conformation, binds to the DNA at a random sequence and slides along it. In the second step, when the two outer base pairs, GAxxTC, are recognized, the R loops of the protein become more ordered, forming strong hydrogen-bonding interactions, resulting in a partially bound EcoRV-DNA complex. In the third step, the flexibility of the center base pair is probed, and in the case of the full cognate sequence the DNA bends, the complex strengthens and the protein and DNA interact more closely, allowing cleavage.     

Sequence-specific recognition of DNA in the nucleosome by pyrrole-imidazole polyamides

The ability of DNA-binding proteins to recognize their cognate sites in chromatin is restricted by the structure and dynamics of nucleosomal DNA, and by the translational and rotational positioning of the histone octamer. Here, we use six different pyrrole-imidazole polyamides as sequence-specific molecular probes for DNA accessibility in nucleosomes. We show that sites on nucleosomal DNA facing away from the histone octamer, or even partially facing the histone octamer, are fully accessible and that nucleosomes remain fully folded upon ligand binding. Polyamides only failed to bind where sites are completely blocked by interactions with the histone octamer. Removal of the amino-terminal tails of either histone H3 or histone H4 allowed these polyamides to bind. These results demonstrate that much of the DNA in the nucleosome is freely accessible for molecular recognition in the minor groove, and also support a role for the amino-terminal tails of H3 and H4 in modulating accessibility of nucleosomal DNA.     

Dissecting the Molecular Origins of Specific Protein-Nucleic Acid Recognition: Hydrostatic Pressure and Molecular Dynamics

The fundamental processes by which proteins recognize and bind to nucleic acids are critical to understanding cellular function. To explore the factors involved in protein-DNA recognition, we used hydrostatic pressure to perturb the binding of the BamHI endonuclease to cognate DNA, both in experiment and in molecular dynamic simulations. A new technique of high-pressure gel mobility shift analysis was used to test the effects of elevated hydrostatic pressure on the binding of BamHI to its cognate recognition sequence. Upon application of a pressure of 500 bar, the equilibrium dissociation constant of BamHI binding to the cognate site was found to increase nearly 10-fold. A challenge has been to link this type of pure thermodynamic measurement to functional events occurring at the molecular level. Thus, we used molecular dynamic simulations at both ambient and elevated pressures to reveal details of the direct and water-mediated interactions between BamHI and cognate DNA, which allow explanation of the effects of pressure on site-specific protein-DNA binding and complex stability.     

Recognition of a TG mismatch: the crystal structure of very short patch repair endonuclease in complex with a DNA duplex

The crystal structure of very short patch repair (Vsr) endonuclease, in complex with Mg2+ and with duplex DNA containing a TG mismatch, has been determined at 2.3 A resolution. In E. coli, the enzyme recognizes a TG mismatched base pair, generated after spontaneous deamination of methylated cytosines, and cleaves the phosphate backbone on the 5' side of the thymine. Extensive interactions between the DNA and the protein characterize a novel recognition mechanism, where three aromatic residues intercalate from the major groove into the DNA to strikingly deform the base pair stacking. With the presence of a cleaved DNA intermediate in the active center, the structure of the Vsr/DNA complex provides detailed insights into the catalytic mechanism for endonuclease activity.     

Investigation of the complexes of EcoRI endonuclease with decanucleotides containing canonical and modified recognition sequences using fluorescence and optical detection of magnetic resonance spectroscopy

The binding of EcoRI endonuclease to the oligonucleotides d(GCGAATTCGC) and d(GCGAA) (5BrdU) (5BrdU) d(CGC) has been investigated to determine whether stacking interactions occur between tryptophan residues and the DNA bases. Fluorescence binding isotherms show that the decamer containing the canonical and that containing the modified recognition sequence bind with comparable affinity. Optically detected magnetic resonance spectra show limited perturbations of the Trp zero-field splitting parameters, which are assigned to electrical field effects. No evidence for Trp stacking interactions has been found.     

High resolution footprinting of EcoRI and distamycin with Rh(phi)2(bpy)3+, a new photofootprinting reagent.

The complex bis(phenanthrenequinone diimine)(bipyridyl)rhodium(III), Rh(phi)2(bpy)3+, cleaves DNA efficiently in a sequence-neutral fashion upon photoactivation so as to provide a novel, high resolution, chemical photofootpring reagent. Photofootprinting of two crystallographically characterized DNA-binding agents, distamycin, a small natural product which binds to DNA in the minor groove, and the endonuclease EcoRI, which binds in the major groove, gave respectively a 5-7 base pair footprint for the drug at its A6 binding site and a 10-12 base pair footprint for the enzyme centered at its recognition site (5'-GAATTC-3'). Both footprints agree closely with the crystallographic results. The photocleavage reaction can be performed using either a high intensity lamp or, conveniently, a simple transilluminator box, and the photoreaction is not inhibited by moderate concentrations of reagents which are sometimes required for examining interactions of molecules with DNA. When compared with other popular footprinting agents, the rhodium complex shows a number of distinct advantages: sequence-neutrality, high resolution, ability to footprint major as well as minor groove-binding ligands, applicability in the presence of additives such as Mg2+ or glycerol, ease of handling, and a sharply footprinted pattern. Light activated footprinting reactions furthermore offer the possibility of examining DNA-binding interactions with time resolution and within the cell.     

The recognition domain of the BpuJI restriction endonuclease in complex with cognate DNA at 1.3-A resolution

Type IIS restriction endonucleases recognize asymmetric DNA sequences and cleave both DNA strands at fixed positions downstream of the recognition site. The restriction endonuclease BpuJI recognizes the asymmetric sequence 5′-CCCGT; however, it cuts at multiple sites in the vicinity of the target sequence. BpuJI consists of two physically separate domains, with catalytic and dimerization functions in the C-terminal domain and DNA recognition functions in the N-terminal domain. Here we report the crystal structure of the BpuJI recognition domain bound to cognate DNA at 1.3-Å resolution. This region folds into two winged-helix subdomains, D1 and D2, interspaced by the DL subdomain. The D1 and D2 subdomains of BpuJI share structural similarity with the similar subdomains of the FokI DNA-binding domain; however, their orientations in protein-DNA complexes are different. Recognition of the 5′-CCCGT target sequence is achieved by BpuJI through the major groove contacts of amino acid residues located on both the helix-turn-helix motifs and the N-terminal arm. The role of these interactions in DNA recognition is also corroborated by mutational analysis.     

Crystal structure of restriction endonuclease BglI bound to its interrupted DNA recognition sequence.

The crystal structure of the type II restriction endonuclease BglI bound to DNA containing its specific recognition sequence has been determined at 2.2 A resolution. This is the first structure of a restriction endonuclease that recognizes and cleaves an interrupted DNA sequence, producing 3' overhanging ends. BglI is a homodimer that binds its specific DNA sequence with the minor groove facing the protein. Parts of the enzyme reach into both the major and minor grooves to contact the edges of the bases within the recognition half-sites. The arrangement of active site residues is strikingly similar to other restriction endonucleases, but the co-ordination of two calcium ions at the active site gives new insight into the catalytic mechanism. Surprisingly, the core of a BglI subunit displays a striking similarity to subunits of EcoRV and PvuII, but the dimer structure is dramatically different. The BglI-DNA complex demonstrates, for the first time, that a conserved subunit fold can dimerize in more than one way, resulting in different DNA cleavage patterns.     

Macromolecular hydration changes associated with BamHI binding and catalysis

In this report, the effects of osmotic pressure on BamHI cognate binding and catalysis were investigated and compared with a previous study on EcoRI (Robinson, C. R. and Sligar, S. G. (1998) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 95, 2186-2191). Our observation of the dependence of binding and catalytic parameters on osmotic pressure has allowed for the comparison of hydration changes associated with site-specific DNA recognition for both endonucleases. Over a large range of osmotic pressures (pi), the dependence of BamHI on osmotic stress during cognate binding and catalysis was very different from that of the related endonuclease EcoRI. The binding of EcoRI to cognate DNA was dominated by a dehydration of the endonuclease-DNA complex, whereas binding by BamHI to its cognate sequence was accompanied by a solvent release corresponding to some 125 fewer waters. Catalytic analysis at elevated osmotic pressures indicated that both endonucleases had undergone a net hydration of the complex with BamHI displaying a much greater dependence on osmotic stress than EcoRI. Although the enzymes shared core structural motifs, comparisons of high resolution x-ray structures revealed many different secondary structural features of the complexed endonucleases. The large difference in hydration changes by both BamHI and EcoRI could be attributed to these dissimilar secondary structural features, as well as the functional differences of the two endonucleases during site-specific DNA recognition.