Activation or suppression of bactericidal activity of macrophages during a graft-versus-host reaction against I-A and I-J-region differences, respectively

Systemic graft-versus-host reactions (GVHR) were induced in F1 heterozygous mice by injecting 10(8) parental lymphocytes. The Anti-Thy 1.2-sensitive, T-cell mediated activation of macrophages was assessed by their increased capacity to destroy a facultative intracellular bacterium Listeria monocytogenes. The difference in MHC regions causing a GVHR that induced high levels of macrophage activation mapped to I-A. In contrast, differences at K or D, in any of the other H-2 subregions or in the non-H-2 background, including Mls alone or in combination, did not induce a GVHR leading to macrophage activation, unless these differences were combined with a difference at I-A. The numbers of parental cells needed to activate macrophages via a GVHR caused by I-A vs. non-I-A differences, varied at least 30- to 100-fold. When parental cells were injected into F1 offspring of parents differing at I-J, growth of Listeria was enhanced significantly; this negative effect on macrophages was not seen when parental combinations differing at I-A alone were compared with those differing at I-A plus I-J or I-J plus other H-2 regions.     

A hierarchy of responsiveness and the production of nonprecipitating antibodies to F antigen

The immune response to F antigen by a variety of inbred strains and F₁ hybrids has been studied. All of the mice responding to appropriate preparations of F antigen share ak allele atH-2K orI-A. In F₁ hybrids, however, this permissive gene is sometimes expressed as dominant responsiveness, while in other combinations as dominant nonresponsiveness. There appears to be a hierarchy of responsiveness among the responder strains tested. Finally, some strains produce nonprecipitating antibodies against F antigen which may represent a genetically controlled restriction of the response to this antigen.     

Polygenic control of the immune response to F antigen

The ability to produce an autoimmune response to F antigen in mice is underH-2-linked and non-H- 2-linkedIr-gene control. There is an absolute requirement for ak allele atH-2K orI-A in order to produce anti-F antibodies. Low and high responsiveness is controlled by a non-H-2-linkedIr gene which behaves in a similar fashion toIr-3, in that as the dose of F-antigen is lowered, low responders behave as high responders and vice versa. This conversion from low to high responsiveness also occurs within a month after ATX.— Most F₁ hybrids derived from (responder x nonresponder) parents bearing identical F-types behave as dominant nonresponders. As a result of ATX, such F₁ mice convert to high responders. This conversion occurs if the animals are not immunized before day 90. If they receive F antigen prior to that time, they remain nonresponders for 7–9 months. One F₁ combination — AKD2 — behaves as a dominant high responder. Genetic analysis showed that in the presence of ak allele atH-2K orI-A, a non-H-2-linkedIr gene inherited from the AKR mice determined dominant responsivenss. No manipulation of the immune response or combination of genes converted nonresponders lacking ak allele into responders. Such complex genetic control suggests regulation by a number of independently segregating loci whose function it is to limit the autoimmune response to F antigen.     

Assessment of some genetic non-MHC differences with GVHR-induced anti-listeria activity of macrophages

Parental cells A injected into (A × B)F₁ heterozygotes induce a graftversus-host reaction (GVHR) which induces systemic activation of anti-Listeria-bactericidal capacity of host macrophages. When donor lymphocytes differ from parent A with respect to various non-H-2 genetic markers, they may or may not be able to induce a GVHR. Some, but not all, known and some unknown non-H-2 differences can be assessed by this method within nine to 12 days. The method is described and some of the following non-H-2 differences are shown to influence GVHR-induced macrophage activation: male H-Y antigen, H-3 or H-4 (but not H-1 or H-9), and as yet underlined differences that apparently exist between mouse substrains of the same or similar designation, but obtained from different breeding establishments.Abbreviations used in this paper: H histocompatibility - GVHR graft-versus-host reaction - MHC major histocompatibility gene complex - SCRF Scripps Clinic and Research Foundation - J Jackson Laboratory - St Strong Foundation - Cum Cumberland View Farm - Ola Olac - Gh Dr. G. Haughton, Chapel Hill - Sal Dr. M. Cohn, La Jolla.     

Activation of natural killer (NK) cells in vivo with H-2 and non-H-2 alloantigens

Intraperitoneal inoculation of allogeneic lymphoid cells rapidly activates cytotoxic cells in the peritoneum which are nonadherent and express the NK-1, asialo-GM₁, and Thy-1 antigens. Allogeneic spleen cells were very efficient at activating these natural killer (NK) cells, while allogeneic thymocytes were much less effective. Heat-killed allogeneic cells or sonicates also could augment NK activity. — Incompatibility atH-2K, H-2I-A, orH- 2D readily evoked NK cell activity, whileH-2S- andH-2I-E/C-associated disparities did not. Non-H- 2 differences also stimulated NK activity and augmentation was particularly evident inMls-disparate combinations. Thus, the same alloantigens which efficiently activate T cells also activate NK cells.     

The effect of H-21J disparity on induction of allotransplantation tolerance by Lentil Lectin

The effect of an H-21J disparity on skin graft survival was studied in 18 mouse donor-recipient strain combinations, in which the recipients were treated with an efficient immunosuppressant, lentil lectin (LCA). The simultaneous I-J disparity essentially had no (or a slightly adverse) effect on the graft survival times in strain combinations differing at the K and I-A loci or in the entire H-2 complex. In two strain combinations incompatible at the D locus, the simultaneous I-J disparity promoted graft survival. The disparity at the I-J locus therefore seems to have only a marginal effect on the survival of allografts in most of the LCA-treated recipients, but it may promote graft survival in some animals. A similar tolerance-promoting effect was also observed with D disparity.     

Sex-dependent effects of non-H-2 loci on lethal GVH reaction induced across an H-2 barrier

We have studied the influence of DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens on the lethal graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) developed across an H-2 barrier. (DBA/2 x B10.D2)F₁ x B10.D2 (H-2 ^d) backcross (BC) mice were typed for their allelic constitution at nine genetically independent chromosome markers and used as individual cell donors simultaneously for two to three (DBA/2 X B10.D2)F₁ recipients incompatible for DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens alone and two to three (DBA/2 x B10.BR)F₁ recipients incompatible for DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens and H-2^k. The results showed that, when compared with that developed in a control group incompatible for H-2 ^kalone [B10.D2(B10.D2xB10.BR)F₁], the GVHR mortality seen in the presence of an additional incompatibility for DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens [(DBA/2 X B10.BR)F₁recipients] is significantly delayed but only in female mice. An analysis of individual BC donors indicated that this protective effect of DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens correlates with incompatibility for gene(s) linked to the Pgm-1 chromosome marker. In contrast, incompatibility for gene(s) linked to Mod-1 and Es-3 markers accelerates GVHR mortality, but only in male mice. Finally, the results obtained with (DBA/2 x B10.D2)F₁ and (DBA/2 x B10.BR)F₁ recipients were compared; they showed that the intensity of the GVHR developed by cells from individual BC donors against a given set of DBA/2 non-H-2 antigens correlates well with that developed by the same BC donor against the same set of non-H-2 antigens plus H-2^k. We conclude that certain non-H-2 genes (and antigens) can modulate the intensity of the GVHR developed across an H-2 barrier. The number of such genes is probably great; their effects are strong and complex, and can be sex-dependent.     

Variable effect of anH-21 barrier on response to skin allografts in the mouse

(AQR×B10)F₁ mice were grafted with skin from donors differing in theK, I, KI, andISD regions of theH-2 complex. A dichotomy was observed in the fate of theH-2I-disparate grafts: either they were rejected acutely within the second week or were accepted indefinitely. Acceptances were much more common among male than female hosts. Acceptor status was limited to the I group, was unpredictable in occurrence, was not well-correlated with positive serum anti-Ia titers, and did not confer protection of grafts that were alike atH-2I but different atH-2K orH-2D. Since theH-2I barrier studied here elicited such divergent responses in genetically identical hosts, it is unlikely that any histocompatibility typing test could predict graft fate.Abbreviations used in this paper are MST median survival time - MHC major histocompatibility complex - CTL cytotoxic T lymphocyte - B10 C57 BL/10 - 6R BIO.T(6R) - B10.A BIO. ASn - H-2-Ia serologically detected antigens coded in theI region ofH-2 This term is used in preference toIa, since it has recently been shown that Ia-like alloantigens may be coded outside the MHC (Dickleret al. 1975).     

Two distinct high immune response phenotypes are both controlled byH-2 genes mapping inK orI-A

Murine responses to immunization with 2, 4, 6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) conjugated to autogenous mouse serum albumin (MSA) in complete Freund's adjuvant (CFA) are controlled by a gene(s) in theK orI-A region of theH-2 complex. High immune responses of bothH-2 ^d andH-2 ^b mice have been mapped to this region of the major histocompatibility complex. No modifying effects were observed from genes to the right ofI-A in either responder haplotype. High responsiveness controlled byK ^b orI-A ^b is inherited with complete or partial recessivity, depending on the route of immunization and the sex of the responder. However, high responsiveness controlled byK ^d orI-A ^d is inherited dominantly. This unusual pattern of inheritance of immune responsiveness to TNP-MSA is consistent with the genetic mapping toK orI-A. TNP-MSA-specific T-cell reactivity following immunization with TNP-MSA in vivo was examined utilizing a T-cell-dependent proliferation assay in vitro with cells obtained from high or low responder mice. Genetic mapping and mode of inheritance in this assay for antigen-specific T-cell reactivity corresponded with results obtained from a plaque-forming cell (PFC) assay measuring antibody production by B cells. Both the proliferative and PFC responses are probably under the sameIr gene control. Both gene dosage effects and Ir-gene-product interaction could influence the generation of specific immune responsiveness in F₁ hybrids between high and low responders to TNP-MSA.     

Lymphokine production in mouse mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR)

We have investigated alloantigen differences which stimulate lymphokine release and³H-TdR uptake in primary ‘one-way’ MLC among allogeneic mice. When mice differing at the wholeH-2 region were tested, MIF and immune IF release was observed, along with a marked³H-TdR uptake. Differences atK, D, orI-S-G regions stimulate both lymphokine release and³H-TdR uptake, though stronger immune IF and³H-TdR responses were observed with differences atI-S-G regions. On the other hand, when mice differing in their minor histocompatibility antigens, and notably at theMls locus, were tested, lymphokine release took place even in the absence of proliferation. Lastly, in MLC between mice differing at multiple minor loci, butH-2 andMls matched, MIF release only, and not immune IF and³H-TdR responses were observed in a few combinations. These findings show that T lymphocytes can recognize alloantigens by releasing lymphokines even without going through proliferation. Moreover, different levels of T-lymphocyte activation exist, depending on the kind of stimulating alloantigens present.     

Regulation by the H-2 gene complex of delayed type hypersensitivity

Identity at the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) was essential for successful transfer of delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) in mice. The regions of the MHC involved differed according to the antigen used for sensitization. In the case of fowl gamma globulin (FGG), identity atI-A was necessary, whereas with dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB), identity at theK, I, orD region was sufficient. These different genetic constraints probably reflect differences in the mechanisms by which antigens are presented to T lymphocytes. Cells from sensitized (CBA×C57BL)F₁ mice transferred DTH to FGG into parental-strain mice, but transfer was more effective in C57BL than in CBA with the same cell dose. This phenomenon is governed by the MHC, since there was better transfer intoH-2 ^b than intoH-2 ^k mice, regardless of their backgrounds. It may reflect the activity of an Ir gene-dependent process. Cells of one genotype (e.g., CBA), sensitized in chimeric mice derived from two MHC-incompatible strains (CBAC57BL), transferred DTH to both strains. These results do not support the notion that the genetic constraint observed in DTH transfer may be a result of the necessity for sensitized T and stimulator cells to match an identical MHC-coded cell interaction molecule. Rather, they favor the hypothesis that T cells recognize antigen, not as a naked determinant, but in close association with products of genes of the MHC.     

Cytotoxicity of autosensitized lymphocytes restricted to the H-2K end of targets

Lymphocytes from rodents cultured on syngeneic fibroblasts become cytotoxic against syngeneic but not against allogeneic target cells. We investigated whether known antigens are involved in the phenomenon and the data indicate that H-2 antigens must be shared between sensitizing fibroblasts and responder lymphocytes to generate autocytotoxic cells. Furthermore, the cytotoxicity of autosensitized lymphocytes is restricted to target cells identical with respect to theK and/orI regions. F₁ hybrid lymphocytes cultured on parental fibroblasts develop cytotoxicity towards sensitizing cells. In contrast, parental lymphocytes cultured on F₁ hybrid fibroblasts will not damage the F₁ cells, although they are cytotoxic against both syngeneic and allogeneic parental cells. In addition, parental or F₁ hybrid lymphocytes cultured on parental fibroblasts are not cytotoxic against F₁ hybrid target cells. Fibroblasts heterozygous for theK end only, are also resistant to the cytotoxic action of such lymphocytes. Thus it seems that H-2 antigens, specifically theK end, antigens have a significant role in the phenomenon of autosensitization.     

Genetics of graft-versus-host reactions

Intracardiac injection of lymph node cells into newborn allogeneic recipients incompatible with congenic donors at multiple loci within theH-2 complex (B10B10.A) led to GVH splenomegaly, retarded growth, and mortality. In contrast,H-2I region differences [B10.A(4R)B10.A(2R)] required fortyfold more cells to produce a comparable splenomegaly, and did not produce runting or GVH mortality despite a strong proliferative response in the spleen. However, when 4R donors were preimmunized with host lymphoid cells, 51 percent of 2R recipients died of allogeneic disease. GVHR was also observed in the reciprocal combination (2R4R), in contrast to previous reports. The phenotypic determinants governing GVHR in the 4R2R combination are probably coded for byI-C subregion genes. Disparities at theI-B orI-J subregions did not evoke detectable GVHR. The data indicate thatI-C subregion loci have the impact of so-called minor or moderate histocompatibility (MoH) loci. Possible implications for allogeneic human bone marrow transplantation are discussed.Portions of this work were presented at the 60th annual meeting of the Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology on April 13, 1976 in Anaheim, California     

Effects of fourH-2K mutations on virus-induced antigens recognized by cytotoxic T cells

Lysis of ectromelia- or LCM virus-infected macrophage target cells by virus-specific cytotoxic T cells from mice immunized with the homologous virus occurred only where donors of T cells and target cells shared eitherH-2K orH-2D genes. With both viruses, use of T cell or target cell donors bearing mutations (B6.C-H-2^ba, B6-H-2^bh, B6-H-2^bg1, and B6-H-2^bg2), all of which apparently occurred in the same single genetic element in theH-2K^b region, abolished (H-2^ba) or impaired (H-2^bh,H-2^bg1 andH-2^bg2) lysis in T cell-target cell combinations that shared (apart from the mutations) all other genes in theK, I-A, orI-B regions of theH-2 complex. The data suggest that virus-induced antigenic patterns on infected B6.C-H- 2^ba (mutant) cells are more different antigenically from those on C57BL/6 (wild type) cells than are those on infected cells from the other mutants -B6-H-2^bh, B6-H-2^bg1, and B6-H-2^bg2. (B6.C-H-2^ba× B6 -H-2^bh)F₁ mice behaved like B6-H-2^bh, indicating no complementation, and confirming that theH-2K gene(s) involved in recognition of virus-infected cells by virus-specific T cells behave as a single element. These findings are discussed in relation to the nature of virus-induced antigenic patterns that are recognized by virus-specific cytotoxic T cells.     

Immunosuppressive effect of graft-versus-host reaction

GVHR was elicited in adult F₁ hybrids by iv injection of parental spleen cells. The F₁ hybrids were then immunized with θ-AKR antigen. Plaque-forming cells (PFC) producing antibodies lytic for AKR thymocytes were enumerated in spleens of experimental animals using the method of cytolysis in agar-gel. The number of PFC found in spleens of animals grafted with parental cells was significantly lower than the number in spleens of animals grafted with syngeneic cells. The degree of suppression of immune response to θ-AKR depended on: (1) the duration of GVHR at the time of immunization, (2) the parental strain and the number of parental cells grafted to evoke GVHR, and (3) the source of cells grafted. Thymus and bone marrow cells when grafted together showed a synergistic effect in suppression of the host's immune response. Immunosuppression of the response to θ-AKR seems to be a more sensitive indicator of GVHR in adult F₁ hybrids than splenomegaly, which is commonly used as a means of assessment of GVHR. The possible role of immunosuppression in the pathogenesis of GVHR is briefly discussed.     

Evidence for a fifth (G) region in theH-2 complex of the mouse

Antisera (B10.129×A)F₁ anti-P and (B10×A)F₁ anti-B10.P contain antibodies that define, in the PVP hemagglutination test, an antigen originally described as G or H-2.7. Of the independentH-2 haplotypes, the H-2.7 antigen is present inf, j, k, p, ands. In addition, the antisera also contain a weak cytotoxic antibody, distinct from anti-H-2.7. The cytotoxic antibody reacts with antigens controlled by theK orI regions. The hemagglutinating H-2.7 antibody does not have cytotoxic activity. The genetic determinant coding for antigen H-2.7 can be mapped into the chromosomal segment between theS andD regions. The H-2.7 antigen thus serves as a marker for a new region of theH-2 complex. The locus coding for antigen H-2.7 is designatedH-2 G and the correspondingH-2 regionG. The H-2.7 antigen has a tissue distribution distinct from that of the H-2 antigens controlled by theK orD regions. So far it could be detected primarily on erythrocytes.     

The T-Cell factor specific for poly(Tyr,Glu)-Poly(Pro)-Poly(Lys) is an I-Region gene product

The nature of a T-cell factor specific for poly(Tyr,Glu)-poly(Pro)-poly(Lys) [(T,G)-pro-L] was established in the present study. The activity of the (T,G)-Pro-L-specific factor was not removed by anti-mouse immunoglobulin Sepharose columns, suggesting that it is not a classical immunoglobulin. On the other hand, the factor lost its activity after passage through immunoadsorbents prepared with anti-H-2 sera raised against theH-2 haplotypes of the mouse strains in which the factor was prepared. Furthermore, this factor was adsorbed byI region-specific antisera but not by antisera directed against theI-J andI-C subregions as well as theK andD regions of theH-2 complex. Thus, the (T,G)-Pro-L-specific T-cell factor is most probably anI-A subregion gene product.     

Immunological and genetic requirements for the parental hemopoietic takeover reaction in adult,H-2-incompatible parent-F1 hybrid parabiosis

Parabiosis of adult DBA/2J (H-2 ^d ) mice with adult (DBA/2J× CSH/HeJ)F₁ (H-2 ^d /H-2 ^k ) mice results in survival beyond 100 days in 44% of such pairs, induction ofin situ unresponsiveness to C3H/HeJ skin, and the complete takeover of the erythroid system of the F₁ by parental cells. However, in vitro responsiveness to C3H/HeJ cells remains. Dye exclusion cytotoxicity assays establish the absence ofF ₁ lymphoid cells in the spleens and bone marrow of both partners. The parental takeover of the erythroid system of the F₁ partner requires immune recognition of the hybrid's alloantigens, because this takeover is not seen with tolerant parental cells. PartialH-2 differences (on the C3H background) influence both survival and the takeover reaction when incorporated into parabioses with DBA/2J partners. When only theK andI subregions ofH-2 were targets of the parental response, 58% of parabionts survived, with complete parental hemopoietic takeover. When onlyH-2D was the target, 83% of parabionts survived, with incomplete hemopoietic takeover. Changing the non-H-2 background of the F₁ target did not significantly affect survival or takeover, while substituting a differentH-2 ^d parental strain (BALB/c) eliminated survival altogether.Thus the parabiont takeover reaction encompasses the lymphoid and hemopoietic systems, requires immunorecognition of the target alloantigens, and seems to require a strongH-2 difference for its induction.     

Xid-defective male (CBA/N x C57BL/6)F1 accessory cells present bovine insulin to long-term cultured F1-restricted T-cells

The reactivity of H-2^b-restricted murine T cells towards bovine insulin was reported to depend on the expression of Ia.W39, a private specificity of I-A^b, on antigen-presenting cells. Cells of male (CBA/N x B6)F₁ mice carrying the mutation xid on the X chromosome lack Ia.W39 on the cell surface. These cells are unable to present bovine insulin to primed T cells derived from female (CBA/N x B6)F₁ mice. We show here that spleen cells of male (CBA/N x B6)F₁ hybrids served perfectly as accessory cells for the insulin-dependent induction of a proliferative response of long-term cultured T cells with (B10 x B10.BR)F₁ genotype, restricted to recognizing insulin in the context of F₁-unique I-A determinants. The epitope on the insulin molecule essential for stimulation was determined to depend on the glutamic acid residue in position 4 of the A chain of insulin. This contrasts with the H-2^b-restricted response of B6 mice to bovine insulin, which appears to be directed at the A chain loop determinant (amino acids A8 and A10). These data suggest that distinct I-A^b-encoded structures, the expression of which is regulated independently, may serve as components of restriction elements for H-2^b and (H-2^b x H-2^k)F₁ restricted T cells, which are specific for different epitopes of bovine insulin.     

The role of Ia antigens and Fc receptor-bearing T-cells in the inhibition of macrophage receptors for cytophilic antibody induced by soluble immune complexes

Soluble antigen-antibody complexes composed of 3 M KCl-extracted L1210 antigens and alloantibody to L1210 given to C3H mice caused immunosuppression in the mice. This was reflected in part by the inhibition of cytophilic antibody receptors on macrophages which could be used as a measure of the suppression. Thymocytes or splenic T cells from mice treated with immune complexes could adoptively transfer the suppression to normal syngeneic mice. These cells, which we have termed suppressor inducers, were found to be Ia positive: specifically, I-A⁺, I-J^?. Thus, treatment of the inducers with anti-la or anti-I-A antibodies and complement in vitro abrogated their ability to transfer the suppression to normal mice. In contrast treatment with anti-I-J serum and complement had no effect. Through a similar approach, the cooperating (acceptor) T cells were found to be I-A⁺, I-J^?. Pretreatment of mice with anti-Ia or anti-I-A serum before the administration of antigen-antibody complexes prevented the inhibition of macrophages. This was due at least in part to steric hindrance of adjacent Fc receptors on the FcR⁺ T cells with which the complexes interacted. Early interaction of immune complexes with FcR⁺ T cells was in fact demonstrated directly by the inability of the complexes to induce suppression when FcR⁺ T cells were depleted. The thymocytes or splenic T cells from anti-Ia-pretreated mice failed to transfer the suppression to recipient mice. In contrast, treatment with either anti-Ia or anti-I-A after the immune complexes did not abrogate the generation of suppressor inducers. Treatment of normal recipient mice with anti-Ia serum in vivo before they received the suppressor inducer cells did not prevent cooperation between the two types of cells. By the same token, blocking of Ia antigens of the inducers in vitro with anti-Ia serum (without complement) also did not impair the cooperative interaction. These results indicate that antigen-antibody complexes generate I-A-positive, I-J-negative T-suppressor inducer cells from FcR⁺ naive T cells. These in turn interact with Ia-positive (I-A⁺ and I-J^?) normal thymocytes or spleen T cells. This interaction most likely generates the ultimate suppressor T cells that suppress cytophilic antibody receptors on macrophages in vivo. However, the I-region determined antigens did not appear to be directly involved in the T-T interaction of suppressor inducer and acceptor cells.