Biochemical approaches for discovering protein-protein interactions

Protein–protein interactions or protein complexes are integral in nearly all cellular processes, ranging from metabolism to structure. Elucidating both individual protein associations and complex protein interaction networks, while challenging, is an essential goal of functional genomics. For example, discovering interacting partners for a 'protein of unknown function' can provide insight into actual function far beyond what is possible with sequence-based predictions, and provide a platform for future research. Synthetic genetic approaches such as two-hybrid screening often reveal a perplexing array of potential interacting partners for any given target protein. It is now known, however, that this type of anonymous screening approach can yield high levels of false-positive results, and therefore putative interactors must be confirmed by independent methods. In vitro biochemical strategies for identifying interacting proteins are varied and time-honored, some being as old as the field of protein chemistry itself. Herein we discuss five biochemical approaches for isolating and characterizing protein–protein interactions in vitro : co-immunoprecipitation, blue native gel electrophoresis, in vitro binding assays, protein cross-linking, and rate-zonal centrifugation. A perspective is provided for each method, and where appropriate specific, trial-tested methods are included.     

Multidimensional proteomic analysis of photosynthetic membrane proteins by liquid extraction-ultracentrifugation-liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry

The membrane protein components of photosystem I (PSI) and II (PSII) from different species were prefractionated by liquid extraction and sucrose gradient ultracentrifugation and subsequently analyzed by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (RP-HPLC-ESI-MS) using poly-(styrene-divinylbenzene)-based monolithic capillary columns. The analytical method was shown to be very flexible and enabled the identification of antenna proteins as well as most of the proteins of the reaction center from PSI and PSII in various plant species with few RP-HPLC-ESI-MS analyses necessitating only minor adaptations in the gradients of acetonitrile in 0.05% aqueous trifluoroacetic acid. The membrane proteins, ranging in molecular mass (Mr) from 4196 (I protein) to more than 80,000 (PSI A/B) as well as isoforms were identified on the basis of their intact Mr and comparison with Mr deduced from known DNA or protein sequences. High quality mass spectra enabled the identification and quantitation of the nonphosphorylated and phosphorylated reaction center subunits D1, D2, and CP43 of PSII, containing five to seven membrane-spanning alpha-helices. Because of its high flexibility and suitability for proteins having a very wide range of Mr and hydrophobicities, the method is generally applicable to the analysis of complex mixtures of membrane proteins.     

ptx1, a nonphototactic mutant of Chlamydomonas, lacks control of flagellar dominance

A new mutant strain of Chlamydomonas, ptx1, has been identified which is defective in phototaxis. This strain swims with a rate and straightness of path comparable with that of wild-type cells, and retains the photoshock response. Thus, the mutation does not cause any gross defects in swimming ability or photoreception, and appears to be specific for phototaxis. Calcium is required for phototaxis in wild- type cells, and causes a concentration-dependent shift in flagellar dominance in reactivated, demembranated cell models. ptx1-reactivated models are defective in this calcium-dependent shift in flagellar dominance. This indicates that the mutation affects one or more components of the calcium-dependent axonemal regulatory system, and that this system mediates phototaxis. The reduction or absence of two 75-kD axonemal proteins correlates with the nonphototactic phenotype. Axonemal fractionation studies, and analysis of axonemes from mutant strains with known structural defects, failed to reveal the structural localization of the 75-kD proteins within the axoneme. The proteins are not components of the outer dynein arms, two of the three types of inner dynein arms, the radial spokes, or the central pair complex. Because changes in flagellar motility ultimately require the regulation of dynein activity, cell models from mutant strains defective in specific dynein arms were reactivated at various calcium concentrations. Mutants lacking the outer arms, or the I1 or I2 inner dynein arms, retain the wild-type calcium-dependent shift in flagellar dominance. Therefore, none of these arms are the sole mediators of phototaxis.     

A conserved structural motif for lipopolysaccharide recognition by procaryotic and eucaryotic proteins

BACKGROUND: Lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a lipoglycan from the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria, is an immunomodulatory molecule that stimulates the innate immune response. High levels of LPS cause excessive release of inflammatory mediators and are responsible for the septic shock syndrome. The interaction of LPS with its cognate binding proteins has not, as yet, been structurally elucidated. RESULTS: The X-ray crystallographic structure of LPS in complex with the integral outer membrane protein FhuA from Escherichia coli K-12 is reported. It is in accord with data obtained using mass spectroscopy and nuclear magnetic resonance. Most of the important hydrogen-bonding or electrostatic interactions with LPS are provided by eight positively charged residues of FhuA. Residues in a similar three-dimensional arrangement were searched for in all structurally known proteins using a fast template-matching algorithm, and a subset of four residues was identified that is common to known LPS-binding proteins. CONCLUSIONS: These four residues, three of which form specific interactions with lipid A, appear to provide the structural basis of pattern recognition in the innate immune response. Their arrangement can serve to identify LPS-binding sites on proteins known to interact with LPS, and could serve as a template for molecular modeling of a LPS scavenger designed to reduce the septic shock syndrome.     

Identifying Protein-protein Interaction Sites Using Peptide Arrays

Protein-protein interactions mediate most of the processes in the living cell and control homeostasis of the organism. Impaired protein interactions may result in disease, making protein interactions important drug targets. It is thus highly important to understand these interactions at the molecular level. Protein interactions are studied using a variety of techniques ranging from cellular and biochemical assays to quantitative biophysical assays, and these may be performed either with full-length proteins, with protein domains or with peptides. Peptides serve as excellent tools to study protein interactions since peptides can be easily synthesized and allow the focusing on specific interaction sites. Peptide arrays enable the identification of the interaction sites between two proteins as well as screening for peptides that bind the target protein for therapeutic purposes. They also allow high throughput SAR studies. For identification of binding sites, a typical peptide array usually contains partly overlapping 10-20 residues peptides derived from the full sequences of one or more partner proteins of the desired target protein. Screening the array for binding the target protein reveals the binding peptides, corresponding to the binding sites in the partner proteins, in an easy and fast method using only small amount of protein.In this article we describe a protocol for screening peptide arrays for mapping the interaction sites between a target protein and its partners. The peptide array is designed based on the sequences of the partner proteins taking into account their secondary structures. The arrays used in this protocol were Celluspots arrays prepared by INTAVIS Bioanalytical Instruments. The array is blocked to prevent unspecific binding and then incubated with the studied protein. Detection using an antibody reveals the binding peptides corresponding to the specific interaction sites between the proteins.     

Functional maps of protein complexes from quantitative genetic interaction data

Recently, a number of advanced screening technologies have allowed for the comprehensive quantification of aggravating and alleviating genetic interactions among gene pairs. In parallel, TAP-MS studies (tandem affinity purification followed by mass spectroscopy) have been successful at identifying physical protein interactions that can indicate proteins participating in the same molecular complex. Here, we propose a method for the joint learning of protein complexes and their functional relationships by integration of quantitative genetic interactions and TAP-MS data. Using 3 independent benchmark datasets, we demonstrate that this method is >50% more accurate at identifying functionally related protein pairs than previous approaches. Application to genes involved in yeast chromosome organization identifies a functional map of 91 multimeric complexes, a number of which are novel or have been substantially expanded by addition of new subunits. Interestingly, we find that complexes that are enriched for aggravating genetic interactions (i.e., synthetic lethality) are more likely to contain essential genes, linking each of these interactions to an underlying mechanism. These results demonstrate the importance of both large-scale genetic and physical interaction data in mapping pathway architecture and function.     

High throughput screening of disulfide‐containing proteins in a complex mixture

The formation of disulfide bonds between cysteine residues is crucial for the stabilization of native protein structures and, thus, determination of disulfide linkages is an important facet of protein structural characterization. Nonetheless, the identification of disulfide bond linkages remains a significant analytical challenge, particularly in large proteins with complex disulfide patterns. Herein, we have developed a new LC/MS strategy for rapid screening of disulfides in an intact protein mixture after a straightforward reduction step with tris(2‐carboxyethyl)phosphine. LC/MS analysis of reduced and nonreduced protein mixtures quickly revealed disulfide‐containing proteins owing to a 2 Da mass increase per disulfide reduction and, subsequently, the total number of disulfide bonds in the intact proteins could be determined. We have demonstrated the effectiveness of this method in a protein mixture composed of both disulfide‐containing and disulfide‐free proteins. Our method is simple (no need for proteolytic digestion, alkylation, or the removal of reducing agents prior to MS analysis), high throughput (fast on‐line LC/MS analysis), and reliable (no S–S scrambling), underscoring its potential as a rapid disulfide screening method for proteomics applications.     

Spiked-in Pulsed in Vivo Labeling Identifies a New Member of the CCN Family in Regenerating Newt Hearts

The newt Notophthalmus viridescens , which belongs to the family of salamanders (Urodela), owns remarkable regenerative capacities allowing efficient scar-free repair of various organs including the heart. Salamanders can regrow large parts of the myocardium unlike mammals, which cannot replace lost cardiomyocytes efficiently. Unfortunately, very little is known about the molecules and the regulatory circuits facilitating efficient heart regeneration in newts or salamanders. To identify proteins that are involved in heart regeneration, we have developed a pulsed SILAC-based mass spectrometry method based on the detection of paired peptide peaks after (13)C(6)-lysine incorporation into proteins in vivo. Proteins were identified by matching mass spectrometry derived peptide sequences to a recently established normalized newt EST library. Our approach enabled us to identify more than 2200 nonredundant proteins in the regenerating newt heart. Because of the pulsed in vivo labeling approach, accurate quantification was achieved for 1353 proteins, of which 72 were up- and 31 down-regulated with a (|log 2 ratio| > 1) during heart regeneration. One deregulated member was identified as a new member of the CCN protein family, showing a wound specific activation. We reason that the detection of such deregulated newt-specific proteins in regenerating hearts supports the idea of a local evolution of tissue regeneration in salamanders. Our results significantly improve understanding of dynamic changes in the complex protein network that underlies heart regeneration and provides a basis for further mechanistic studies.     

Structure-templated predictions of novel protein interactions from sequence information

The multitude of functions performed in the cell are largely controlled by a set of carefully orchestrated protein interactions often facilitated by specific binding of conserved domains in the interacting proteins. Interacting domains commonly exhibit distinct binding specificity to short and conserved recognition peptides called binding profiles. Although many conserved domains are known in nature, only a few have well-characterized binding profiles. Here, we describe a novel predictive method known as domain–motif interactions from structural topology (D-MIST) for elucidating the binding profiles of interacting domains. A set of domains and their corresponding binding profiles were derived from extant protein structures and protein interaction data and then used to predict novel protein interactions in yeast. A number of the predicted interactions were verified experimentally, including new interactions of the mitotic exit network, RNA polymerases, nucleotide metabolism enzymes, and the chaperone complex. These results demonstrate that new protein interactions can be predicted exclusively from sequence information.     

Assignment of protein interactions from affinity purification/mass spectrometry data

The combination of affinity purification with mass spectrometry analysis has become the method of choice for protein complex characterization. With the improved performance of mass spectrometry technology, the sensitivity of the analyses is increasing, probing deeper into molecular interactions and yielding longer lists of proteins. These identify not only core complex subunits but also the more inaccessible proteins that interact weakly or transiently. Alongside them, contaminant proteins, which are often abundant proteins in the cell, tend to be recovered in affinity experiments because they bind nonspecifically and with low affinity to matrix, tag, and/or antibody. The challenge now lies in discriminating nonspecific binders from true interactors, particularly at the low level and in a larger scale. This review aims to summarize the variety of methods that have been used to distinguish contaminants from specific interactions in the past few years, ranging from manual elimination using heuristic rules to more sophisticated probabilistic scoring approaches. We aim to give awareness on the processing that takes place before an interaction list is reported and on the different types of list curation approaches suited to the different experiments.     

Phosphorylation of membranes from the rat gastric mucosa

Gastric mucosal membranes derived primarily from parietal cells were found to contain endogenous protein kinase systems as well as several phosphate-accepting substrates. One specific membrane protein with a molecular weight of 88 000 was phosphorylated only in the presence of calcium, while the degree of phosphorylation of three other membrane proteins was similarly increased. The activity of the calcium-dependent protein kinase was found to be totally inhibited in the presence of trifluoperazine, a phenothiazine known to specifically inactivate calmodulin. These results suggest that a calmodulin- and calcium-dependent phosphorylation system may be a component of the parietal cell membrane. Phosphorylation of the membrane proteins was not affected by either cyclic AMP or cyclic GMP. The heat-stable inhibitor protein of cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase did not inhibit the endogenous protein kinase activity suggesting that the membrane enzyme is not similar to the cytosolic protein kinase. However, the catalytic subunit of the soluble enzyme was capable of phosphorylating a number of membrane proteins indicating that after maximal autophosphorylation of the gastric membranes, phosphate-acceptor sites are still available to the cytosolic cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase.     

A model for the hierarchical structure of the human epidermal cornified cell envelope

The epidermal cornified cell envelope (CE) is a 15 nm thick layer of highly insoluble protein that is assembled on the intracellular surface of the cell membrane during terminal differentiation, and comprises about 10% of the mass of the cornified dead layers of the tissue. The CE consists of a complex amalgam of several known proteins that are crosslinked by isodipeptide bonds formed by the action of transglutaminases, but little is known about their order of accretion during CE assembly, or how they are crosslinked. In this paper, CEs purified from human foreskin epidermis were examined by immunogold electron microscopy before and after digestion with proteases.The mass fractions of the proteins remaining in CE remnants during digestion were estimated from the amino acid compositions by mathematical modelling. Together, the data support a new model for the complex hierachical structure of the CE. The cytoplasmic surface of intact purified CEs consists of filaggrin, loricrin, SPRs and keratin intermediate filaments. The bulk of the CE consists of a mixture of loricrin (75%) and SPRs (5%). Following removal of most of these, the novel protein elafin is exposed, which contributes about 6% of CE mass. The protein material on the inner CE 'core' adjacent or attached to the lipid envelope consists of cystatin alpha (5%), involucrin (2%), keratin filaments (3%) and possibly other as yet unidentified protein(s)(2-5%). This model supports but considerably extends an earlier extant hypotheis for CE structure, and thus provides the basis for further detailed biochemical and ultra-structural studies.     

On the calculation of electrostatic interactions in proteins

In this paper we present a classical treatment of electrostatic interactions in proteins. The protein is treated as a region of low dielectric constant with spherical charges embedded within it, surrounded by an aqueous solvent of high dielectric constant, which may contain a simple electrolyte. The complete analysis includes the effects of solvent screening, polarization forces, and self energies, which are related to solvation energies. Formulae, and sample calculations of forces and energies, are given for the special case of a spherical protein. Our analysis and model calculations point out that any consistent treatment of electrostatic interactions in proteins should account for the following. Solvent polarization is an important factor in the calculation of pairwise electrostatic interactions. Solvent polarization substantially affects both electrostatic energies and forces acting upon charges. No simple expression for the effective dielectric constant, Deff, can generally be valid, since Deff is a sensitive function of position. Solvent screening of pairwise interactions involving dipolar groups is less effective than the screening of charges. In fact for many interactions involving dipoles, solvent screening can be essentially ignored. The self energy of charges makes a large contribution to the total electrostatic energy of a protein. This must be compensated by specific interactions with other groups in the protein. Strategies for applying our analysis to proteins whose structures are known are discussed.     

Optimization of the isotope-coded affinity tag-labeling procedure for quantitative proteome analysis

The combination of isotope coded affinity tag (ICAT) reagents and tandem mass spectrometry constitutes a new method for quantitative proteomics. It involves the site-specific, covalent labeling of proteins with isotopically normal or heavy ICAT reagents, proteolysis of the combined, labeled protein mixture, followed by the isolation and mass spectrometric analysis of the labeled peptides. The method critically depends on labeling protocols that are specific, quantitative, general, robust, and reproducible. Here we describe the systematic evaluation of important parameters of the labeling protocol and describe optimized labeling conditions. The tested factors include the ICAT reagent concentration, the influence of the protein, SDS, and urea concentrations on the labeling reaction, and the reaction time. We demonstrate that using the optimized conditions specific and quantitative labeling was achieved on standard proteins as well as in complex protein mixtures such as a yeast cell lysate.     

A method for three-dimensional protein characterization and its application to a complex plant (corn) extract

Knowledge of host protein properties is critical for developing purification methods for recombinant proteins from a specific host, or for choosing suitable hosts and targeted expression tissues for a specific recombinant protein. A method to obtain a three-dimensional (3D) map (surface hydrophobicity (SH), isoelectric point (pI), and molecular weight (MW)), of a host's aqueous soluble protein properties was developed. The method consists of hydrophobic partitioning in a PEG 3350 (15.7%)-Na(2)SO(4) (8.9%)-NaCl (3%) aqueous two-phase (ATP) system followed by quantitative, 2D-electrophoretic characterization of the proteins of each equilibrium phase and the original extract. The pI and MW of host proteins were obtained directly through 2D electrophoresis. The partition coefficients of individual proteins were obtained by quantitative matching of protein spots in the top and bottom phase gels and calculating the protein partition coefficients from this information. Correlation of the partition coefficient to a SH scale was established by partitioning several model proteins with known surface hydrophobicities in the same ATP system. The inclusion of the extract gel provided for a spot selection criterion based on satisfactory mass balance closure. The method is illustrated by application to a mixture of model proteins and to complex mixtures, that is, corn germ proteins extracted at pH 7 and pH 4.     

The mixed xylem sap proteome of Fusarium oxysporum-infected tomato plants

Secreted proteins are known to play decisive roles in plant–fungus interactions. To study the molecular details of the interaction between the xylem-colonizing, plant-pathogenic fungus Fusarium oxysporum and tomato, the composition of the xylem sap proteome of infected tomato plants was investigated and compared with that of healthy plants. Two-dimensional gel separation and mass spectrometry yielded peptide masses and peptide sequences of 33 different proteins. Despite the absence of complete genome sequences of either tomato or F. oxysporum , 21 proteins were identified as tomato proteins and seven as fungal proteins. Thirteen of the tomato proteins were specific for infected plants. Sixteen tomato proteins were found in xylem sap for the first time, four of which were identified based on matches to expressed sequences only. Coding sequences for new proteins from F. oxysporum were identified through either direct matching to a database sequence, matching of peptide sequences to genome or expressed sequence tag databases of other Fusarium species, or PCR with degenerate primers on cDNA derived from infected plants followed by screening of a F. oxysporum BAC library. Together, these findings provide an excellent basis for further exploration of the interaction between xylem-colonizing pathogens and their hosts.     

A novel WD repeat protein component of the methylosome binds Sm proteins.

We have recently described a large (20 S) protein arginine methyltransferase complex, termed the methylosome, that contains the methyltransferase JBP1 (PRMT5) and the pICln protein. The methylosome functions to modify specific arginines to dimethylarginines in the arginine- and glycine-rich domains of several spliceosomal Sm proteins, and this modification targets these proteins to the survival of motor neurons (SMN) complex for assembly into small nuclear ribonucleoprotein (snRNP) core particles. Here, we describe a novel component of the methylosome, a 50-kilodalton WD repeat protein termed methylosome protein 50 (MEP50). We show that MEP50 is important for methylosome activity and binds to JBP1 and to a subset of Sm proteins. Because WD repeat proteins provide a platform for multiple protein interactions, MEP50 may function to mediate the interaction of multiple substrates with the methylosome. Interestingly, all of the known components of the methylosome bind Sm proteins, suggesting that in addition to producing properly methylated substrates for the SMN complex, the methylosome may be involved in Sm protein rearrangements or pre-assembly required for snRNP biogenesis.