Exploitation of the resistance to carrot fly in the wild carrot species Daucus capillifolius

Under field conditions a wild Daucus species from Libya, D. capillifolius, supported less than one tenth as many carrot flies (Psila rosae) as the susceptible carrot cultivar Danvers Half Long 126. Breeding lines developed from crosses between D. capillifolius and three different carrot types were grown in a series of field experiments at Wellesbourne between 1980 and 1989. Each year selections were made for agronomic quality and/or for increased resistance to carrot fly. The programme produced lines which for size, shape and colour represented most of the commercially-important carrot types. Some of these lines were also significantly more resistant to carrot fly than selections from the partially-resistant cv. Sytan. However, the best lines were not as resistant as the wild parent. The highest quality resistant lines were sold to seed companies for variety production.     

Relationship between root volatiles of some carrot cultivars and their resistance to the carrot fly, Psila rosae

Field experiments investigated the resistance of some carrot cultivars to Psila rosae. In addition, headspace vapour and steam distillate from the roots of resistant and susceptible varieties were compared by gas-liquid chromatography. The field data confirmed that resistance may operate by decreasing the numbers of eggs laid indicating a nonpreference by the female Psila. Root resistance to the larva was also confirmed but the mechanism was unclear. A new finding was that root resistance is independent of the effect of egg laying, some cultivars evincing one or the other effect and some such as Regulus Imperial displaying both. It was clear that root resistance to the larva is the crucial prerequisite in breeding resistant varieties.One consistent difference was detected by the chemical comparisons: intact roots of resistant varieties released substantially less volatiles. Specifically, Regulus released almost five times less of the volatiles already shown to positively influence host-finding behaviour by the larva.

---

Résumé La résistance à P. rosae de quelques cultivars de carotte a été étudiée en plein champ. Parallèlement, les substances volatiles diffusées et celles extraites par la vapeur des racines de variétés résistantes et sensibles, ont été comparées en chromatographie gaz-liquide (GLC). Les résultats en champ ont confirmé que la résistance peut être due à une diminution du nombre d'oeufs pondus, révélant une absence d'attractivité pour les femelles de P. rosae. La résistance des racines aux larves a été aussi confirmée, mais les raisons n'en étaient pas claires. Un aspect nouveau est que la résistance des racines est indépendante de l'effet de la ponte, quelques cultivars présentant l'un ou l'autreeffet et certains, comme Regulus Imperial, manifestant les deux. Il est net que la résistance racinaire aux larves est la condition essentielle pour la sélection de variétés résistantes. Une différence importante a été mise en évidence par les comparaisons chimiques: les racines intactes de variétés résistantes libèrent nettement moins de substances volatiles. Précisément, Regulus a libéré 5 fois moins de substances volatiles déjà connues comme influençant positivement le comportement de découverte de l'hôte par la larve.

     

Behavioural responses of the carrot fly larva, Psila rosae, to carrot root volatiles

ABSTRACT. The behaviour of the carrot fly larva, Psila rosae F. (Diptera, Psilidae), was investigated in the presence of six concentrations of thirty-four volatiles associated with carrot root and of trans -methyl-iso-eugenol, a constituent of carrot herb oil. Bomyl acetate, 2,4-dimethyl styrene, α-ionone, SbT-ionone and biphenyl were the most consistently preferred compounds. Klinotaxis and klinokinesis were the orientation responses near the stimulus source. Trans -2-nonenal was the most consistently avoided compound. Extracts derived by steam distillation of carrot roots and by concentration of vapour from roots were resolved, by gas liquid chromatography, into forty-five and twenty-two major constituents, respectively. The five preferred compounds are micro-components of these extracts, collectively representing 1% and 0.6% of root extract oil and vapour, respectively. It is suggested that these secondary plant constituents are specific host finding cues for the larva, and that frara-2-nonenal is a carrot defence compound.     

Development of carrot inbreds with resistance to carrot fly using a single seed descent programme

Two carrot cultivars, ‘Sytan’ and ‘Long Chantenay’, representing commercially important carrot types and selected for their partial resistance to the carrot fly (Psila rosae) were crossed as the basis for a single seed descent programme. The resulting F₁ progeny were mass pollinated to produce an F₂ generation and approximately 2000 plants were raised from this segregating family in the glasshouse in 1981. By careful choice of sowing date and glasshouse temperatures it was possible to stimulate the plants to flower within 10 months. Individual king umbels were enclosed within bags and pollinated with blowflies. Resulting seed was sown in pots in the following August and the process of seed production repeated in a 12 month cycle. Each inbred line was selfed in this way over three generations until the F₅ stage. Stocks of seed were then multiplied. A total of 753 inbreds were produced by 1987. The vigour of each inbred was evaluated in glasshouse tests and the level of chlorogenic acid was determined by a fluorescence technique. The most vigorous lines with the lowest levels of chlorogenic acid were tested in field experiments against carrot fly at Wellesbourne. Nine inbreds with promising agronomic quality and moderate resistance to carrot fly were selected and seeded. These nine lines were submitted to seed companies with the aim of developing new cultivars of carrot.     

Physical and chemical factors influencing landing and oviposition by the cabbage root fly on host-plant models

Various plant models were used in both choice and no-choice tests in the laboratory to assess landing and oviposition preferences of the cabbage root fly,Delia radicum (L.). The main factor governing the site most suitable for landing was the conspicuousness of the object and not its shape. Oviposition was influenced considerably by the pre-conditioning of the females. Deprived females laid eggs even when denied access to both host plant chemicals and host-plant models. The dominant role of contact chemical stimuli in host acceptance was reconfirmed, but only a combination of physical and chemical stimuli appeared capable of eliciting normal oviposition. The combination of contact chemical stimuli and the presence of a stem on the test model had a synergistic effect on the numbers of eggs laid in both choice and no-choice situations. In choice bioassays, female cabbage root flies distinguished between models of different shapes, heights and sizes. The size and shape of the models appeared to be perceived in part after the flies had landed.     

Effects of plant odor on oviposition by the black swallowtail butterfly,Papilio polyxenes (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae)

Black swallowtail females laid more eggs on plant models treated with contact stimulants and volatiles from carrot leaves than on models treated only with contact stimulants. The volatiles enhanced landing rates and females alighted more frequently on artificial leaves treated with host volatiles than on adjacent control leaves. Volatiles from cabbage, a nonhost, inhibited landing rates on artificial leaves treated with carrot contact stimulants. Examination of antennae revealed two major types of sensilla, believed to be olfactory in function. Electroantennogram preparations responded more strongly to carrot volatiles than to cabbage volatiles and several shared responses at particular retention times to carrot volatile components eluting from a gas chromatograph. Our results are consistent with a long-standing hypothesis that behavioral responses to essential oil components characteristic of the larval food plants have facilitated host shifts in the genus Papilio.