Psychological implications of family studies by molecular biology. An example--muscular dystrophy

A dialogue between a geneticist and a M.D. trained in medical psychology has been established about problems arising in genetic counselling. A better knowledge of themselves allows them to increase the quality of genetic counselling by improving the communication techniques. The whole personality and not only the genetic disease of the individuals seeking genetic counselling is taken into account during the counselling process.     

Molecular genetic analysis of the GJB1 gene: a study of six mutations

Charcot-Marie-Tooth type X1 disease (CMTX1) is an X-dominant peripheral neuropathy caused by mutations in the GJB1 gene. Molecular genetic analysis of the GJB1 gene is crucial for CMTX1 diagnosis and for genetic counselling. To date, molecular genetic analysis of the GJB1 gene revealed 264 mutations in the GJB1 gene. In spite of the rising number of GJB1 gene mutations, family history was documented in only a few CMTX1 cases. The aim of this study was a molecular genetic analysis of the GJB1 gene in 7 families, performed in 19 CMTX1-affected patients and 13 healthy family members. Moreover, we attempted to report evidence of effects of 6 amino-acid substitutions described in this study. To the best of our knowledge, the G110D, V152D and K167E mutations are novel substitutions, which have not been reported so far.     

Prospective study of genetic counselling.

A prospective study was carried out on 200 consecutive subjects seen for counselling (consultands) for serious genetic disorders. Educational and social background of consultands and their knowledge and understanding of their particular problem were assessed before counselling, and their response was determined immediately afterwards and three months and two years later by an independent observer not concerned in the genetic counselling. The husband''s educational background was particularly important in influencing a couple''s comprehension of counselling. X-linked recessive and chromosomal disorders presented the most difficulties in comprehension. The counsellors'' assessment of comprehension was a good guide to the consultands'' comprehension as assessed at subsequent follow-up. The proportion deterred from having children increased with time and over a third had been sterilised within two years of counselling. It is suggested that follow-up after counselling should be routine, especially when the counsellor suspects that comprehension has not been good, in X-linked recessive and chromosomal disorders, and when the risks of having an affected child are considered to be high.     

Women's need for information before attending genetic counselling for familial breast or ovarian cancer: a questionnaire,interview, and observational study.

OBJECTIVES: To describe women''s information needs prior to genetic counselling for familial breast or ovarian cancer. DESIGN: Prospective study including semistructured telephone interviews before genetic counselling, observations of consultations, completion of postal questionnaires, and face-to face interviews within two months of counselling. SUBJECTS: 46 women attending genetic counselling for familial breast or ovarian cancer. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Subjects'' understanding of process and content of genetic counselling before attending and attitudes about their preparation for the counselling session. RESULTS: Although all women interviewed before the clinic expected to discuss their risk of developing cancer and risk management options, there was evidence of a lack of knowledge about the process and content of genetic counselling, 17 (37%) women said they did not know what else would happen. Most women interviewed after counselling viewed it positively, but 26 (65%) felt they had been inadequately prepared and 11 (28%) felt that their lack of preparation meant that they could not be given an accurate estimation of their risk of cancer. CONCLUSIONS: Some women felt that they did not obtain optimum benefit from genetic counselling because they were inadequately prepared for it. We suggest that cancer family history clinics should provide women with written information about the process and content of genetic counselling before their clinic attendance.     

Screening for Abnormal Haemoglobins: A Pilot Study

A pilot study has been made of the implication of screening for abnormal haemoglobins in immigrant schoolchildren. An abnormality was detected by capillary blood haemoglobin electrophoresis in 8·4% of 6,835 children and a haemoglobinopathy outpatient clinic had to be established to deal with the heavy work load which resulted. The clinic was also used to determine the value of investigating the remaining members of the family once an abnormality had been detected in one child.Healthy siblings with normal haemoglobin electrophoretic patterns and normal iron and folate levels were studied to determine a normal range for haemoglobin in relation to age for adequately nourished immigrant children. The lower limit of the normal range was close to the mean value minus 1½ S.D.; by using this definition 10·3% of 280 children were subsequently found to be anaemic.Population screening of this type is desirable, but further pilot studies of patient education, genetic counselling, organization of specimen collection, data processing, and follow-up health care facilities are required before screening is extended more widely in the United Kingdom.     

Carrier detection and genetic counselling in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: a follow-up study.

Assay of serum creatine kinase activity is useful in the detection of carriers of the X-linked gene for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). For genetic counselling this assay has been used in conjunction with pedigree analysis to improve estimates of the risk that a female relative of a DMD patient is a carrier. To measure the impact of the program, follow-up information was obtained from women who had received genetic counselling for DMD. Their responses showed that the risk of producing an affected son had been a major factor in their attitude toward family planning, and their reproductive performance correlated inversely with their genetic risk. The decision by the majority of proven carriers to prevent the birth of further male offspring was reflected in a recent decline in the frequency of a known family history of DMD among newly ascertained cases.     

Genetic counselling. I. Definition and present status (author's transl)]

Genetic counselling is a medical action which must be carried out by a M.D. specialized in genetics. Genetic counselling is peculiar in that couples rather than individuals are involved. Furthermore it is not concerned with the health of the consultants but with that of their expected children. Genetic counselling is not restricted to the statistical estimation of a risk; it raises important problems of psychology and behaviour. Finally, eugenic considerations about the diffusion of deleterious genes should not be taken into account in genetic counselling, which is given in the interest of individuals, not of the society. The increasing demand for genetic counselling is due to the change of the reproductive pattern. People do not want only to fix the size of their family, but also to avoid any accident of procreation.     

Social Effects of Genetic Counselling

In a follow-up study of 104 subjects referred for genetic counselling between 1965 and 1969 all were at risk of having children with a variety of serious genetic disorders. Most subjects were in social classes III and IV, were married, in their late 20s, and already had an affected child. Sixty-three per cent. were referred by hospital consultants, 27% by their general practitioners, and 10% were self-referrals. All of those counselled appeared to have appreciated the genetic implications, although four overestimated the risks and 11 underestimated the risks.Of those at high risk (greater than 1 in 10) of having an affected child 10 out of 55 couples “planned” further pregnancies despite the risks. In two this was because they had been unable to adopt a child, in four because they had no living children and the disorders in question usually resulted in stillbirth or death in infancy so that the “burden” of an affected child would be of relatively short duration, and one mother had had antenatal diagnosis and selective abortion. Most of the couples in the low-risk group (less than 1 in 20) were reassured and planned further pregnancies.     

Ascertainment and Prevention of Genetic Disease

A genetic register system has been developed for the ascertainment and prevention of genetic disease. Its potential value is illustrated with data collected from 478 families with serious genetic disorders which had been seen during the past five years. Of these 249 were referred specifically for genetic counselling, autosomal dominant disorders accounting for the largest group of families with individuals at high risk of becoming affected. Of 717 individuals at high risk of having affected children (or carrier daughters in the case of X-linked recessive disorders), only 101 were referred specifically for counselling. Many were referred only after the birth of an affected child which might otherwise have been prevented. A genetic register system linked to practitioner, hospital, and health department records could be a valuable means of preventing genetic disease.     

Polish Registry of Congenital Malformations - aims and organization of the registry monitoring 300 000 births a year

In 1997, the Polish Registry of Congenital Malformations (PRCM) was established, to fulfil epidemiological, prophylactic, socioeconomic and scientific functions. The PRCM is a population-based registry monitoring currently about 300 000 births a year in 13 provinces. Such a large area and population require a special organizational structure of the Registry. The PRCM Central Working Group and the computer database are located in the Department of Medical Genetics, University of Medical Sciences, Poznań. Here the data are collected, validated, encoded according to the ICD-10, and analysed. Provincial Working Groups are responsible for supervision of data collection in the given province. The PRCM staff has grown from about 250 members in 1997 to more than 400 members today. The PRCM collects information on structural defects diagnosed before the end of the second year of life. Minor anomalies are excluded from the registry. The main source of information is a registration form filled up by the physician diagnosing the anomaly. Since 2004 also electronic reporting has been possible. On 28 September 2005 there were 54 020 entries in the database concerning 33 729 children with at least one congenital malformation and 1261 control entries concerning children without malformations. The PRCM is also an important source of identification of families at genetic risk. Education of physicians and the community in the field of genetic counselling is also an important aim of the PRCM. Since 2001, the PRCM has been a member of the Eurocat. Detailed information on PRCM organization, electronic reporting, and results are available at the PRCM website (www.rejestrwad.pl).     

Cystic fibrosis carrier testing in early pregnancy by general practitioners.

OBJECTIVE--To assess the feasibility of genetic counselling in general practice by using cystic fibrosis carrier screening at the booking appointment as an integral part of routine antenatal care and as a paradigm for the wider participation of general practitioners in medical genetics. DESIGN--Maternal testing (male partner tested only if woman screens positive) and couple testing for cystic fibrosis carrier status in the antenatal population attending one general practice and, later, in a further six (outreach) practices also. SETTING--Two partner urban training practice (pilot practice) in south Manchester, and six north west practices (two inner city, three urban, one rural dispensing). SUBJECTS--Total practice population of 50,000 (pilot practice plus six outreach practices) with an estimated 500-800 pregnancies per year. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES--(a) Proportion of carriers of cystic fibrosis identified, counselled, and appropriately managed within the first trimester of pregnancy; (b) questionnaire and interview measures of patient satisfaction and stress. RESULTS--Eleven carriers of cystic fibrosis were detected including one carrier couple. This carrier couple, after extensive counselling, elected to have prenatal diagnosis by chorionic villus biopsy. The fetus was homozygous normal. CONCLUSIONS--General practitioners can successfully integrate genetic counselling and cystic fibrosis carrier screening into the first antenatal booking appointment. When a carrier couple is identified clinical geneticists can help with the discussion of reproductive options, and prenatal diagnosis by chorionic villus biopsy can be completed within the first trimester. The results suggest that general practitioners will have an increasingly important role in medical genetics, subject to continuing evaluation of patient acceptability and stress.     

Genetic counselling for pulmonary arterial hypertension: a matter of variable variability

We report three cases which highlight the complex considerations surrounding genetic counselling for pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH). The first counselee developed PAH symptoms shortly after his daughter’s death from PAH and was diagnosed with a delay of 1 year. An early diagnosis of familial PAH was established in the second counselee. Oral therapy was initiated immediately, and her functional status has since remained stable. The third counselee was a healthy woman who struggled to cope with her risk for familial PAH, having lost two siblings from the disease. These cases show that incomplete penetrance and variable expression need particular attention during clinical assessment and genetic counselling of heritable PAH patients and family members.     

The Southwest of Scotland Structural Chromosomal Abnormalities Database: an assessment of its contribution to genetic counselling in affected families

AIM: To assess the effect of establishing a genetic database on the provision of genetic counselling to individuals and families with structural chromosomal abnormalities. METHOD: For the four year period 1997-2000, we compared all cytogenetics laboratory records with entries on the database to determine its completeness. We assessed the extent to which families had been followed up, compared these findings with a previous four year period (1977-1980) and sought to discover why some families were not followed up. RESULTS: Of 215 probands identified during 1997-2000, 19 (9%) were not recorded on the register. Approximately one third of families were followed up completely, one third were partially followed up and one third had had no follow-up, for a variety of reasons. In this last group, there was evidence that some had received inadequate or incorrect genetic advice. There was no evidence that the database improved follow-up in families with structural chromosome abnormalities. Over 20 years, there has been a downward trend in the proportion of cases referred to the genetic clinic. CONCLUSIONS: Our register can be used to monitor trends in clinical practice but has had no direct effect on the service provided to patients and their families.     

Density of common complex ocular traits in the aging eye: analysis of secondary traits in genome-wide association studies

Genetic association studies are identifying genetic risks for common complex ocular traits such as age-related macular degeneration (AMD). The subjects used for discovery of these loci have been largely from clinic-based, case-control studies. Typically, only the primary phenotype (e.g., AMD) being studied is systematically documented and other complex traits (e.g., affecting the eye) are largely ignored. The purpose of this study was to characterize these other or secondary complex ocular traits present in the cases and controls of clinic-based studies being used for genetic study of AMD. The records of 100 consecutive new patients (of any diagnosis) age 60 or older for which all traits affecting the eye had been recorded systematically were reviewed. The average patient had 3.5 distinct diagnoses. A subset of 10 complex traits was selected for further study because they were common and could be reliably diagnosed. The density of these 10 complex ocular traits increased by 0.017 log-traits/year (P = 0.03), ranging from a predicted 2.74 at age 60 to 4.45 at age 90. Trait-trait association was observed only between AMD and primary vitreomacular traction (P = 0.0009). Only 1% of subjects age 60 or older had no common complex traits affecting the eye. Extrapolations suggested that a study of 2000 similar subjects would have sufficient power to detect genetic association with an odds ratio of 2.0 or less for 4 of these 10 traits. In conclusion, the high prevalence of complex traits affecting the aging eye and the inherent biases in referral patterns leads to the potential for confounding by undocumented secondary traits within case-control studies. In addition to the primary trait, other common ocular phenotypes should be systematically documented in genetic association studies so that adjustments for potential trait-trait associations and other bias can be made and genetic risk variants identified in secondary analyses.     

A genome-wide scan for primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG): the Barbados Family Study of Open-Angle Glaucoma

Primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) is characterized by damage to the optic nerve with associated loss of vision. Six named genetic loci have been identified as contributing to POAG susceptibility by genetic linkage analysis of mostly Caucasian families, and two of the six causative genes have been identified. The Barbados Family Study of Open-Angle Glaucoma (BFSG) was designed to evaluate the genetic component of POAG in a population of African descent. A genome-wide scan was performed on 1327 individuals from 146 families in Barbados, West Indies. Linkage results were based on models and parameter estimates derived from a segregation analysis of these families, and on model-free analyses. Two-point LOD scores >1.0 were identified on chromosomes 1, 2, 9, 10, 11, and 14, with increased multipoint LOD scores being found on chromosomes 2, 10, and 14. Fine mapping was subsequently carried out and indicated that POAG may be linked to intervals on chromosome 2q between D2S2188 and D2S2178 and chromosome 10p between D10S1477 and D10S601. Heterogeneity testing strongly supports linkage for glaucoma to at least one of these regions and suggests possible linkages to both. Although TIGR/myocilin and optineurin mutations have been shown to be causally linked to POAG in other populations, findings from this study do not support either of these as causative genes in an Afro-Caribbean population known to have relatively high rates of POAG.     

GRACILARIA FROM THE GULF OF MEXICO, WITH SPECIAL EMPHASIS ON GRACILARIA TIKVAHIAE BASED ON TWO MOLECULAR DATASETS

Dinoflagellates of the genus Dinophysis are agents of Diarrhetic Shellfish Poisoning (DSP). They occur along the French coast and affect shellfish exploitation during most of the year (during spring, summer and autumn). Because this species is difficult to cultivate, very little is known about this organism. The first problem is the species-delineation within this genus which is sometimes unclear based upon the solely on morphological features, in particular for the complex D. acuminata ( D. cf. acuminata,, D. cf. norvegica, D. cf.sacculus , and D. skagii ) or the complex D. sacculus ( D. sacculus and D. pavillardii ). The second problem is its detection in natural samples. French Dinophysis blooms have been reported to be toxic under 100 cells L⁻¹, a concentration which corresponds to less than 1 cell 10-mL⁻¹, as determined by the Utermöhl method of enumeration. Molecular tools may help to resolve these two kind of problems. During one year (spring 1999 to spring 2000), more than 100 fixed samples containing Dinophysis spp. cells were collected along the French coast by the French monitoring network (or REPHY; http://www. ifremer.fr). The genetic diversity of Dinophysis spp. was studied by sequencing and analysis of ribosomal DNA genes. We found that sequences were hightly conserved between species or within the D. acuminata or D. sacculus complex. Two oligonucleotide probes, specific to these complex groups, were designed. Their specificity and sensitivity are actually tested on natural samples by a PCR-based assay. Furthur investigation will include the development of standard molecular diagnostics due to their rapid and sensitive detection in natural samples.     

Human immunodeficiency virus and drug misuse: the Edinburgh experience.

During 1985 many drug abusers who lived in Edinburgh were found to be infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). As a result an alternative counselling and screening clinic for testing for antibodies to HIV was established for use by drug abusers. Four hundred and forty one patients were counselled in the first year, and over 60% were either drug abusers or their sexual contacts. One hundred and fourteen (26%) patients were positive for HIV antibody, and 100 (88%) of these were current or former drug abusers. The HIV seropositivity rate in drug abusers was 52% but was only 7% in their sexual contacts. Services were provided for these people as well as counselling before and after the test. The cost of this counselling service for the first year was 27,000 pounds or 61.22 pounds per patient. The unexpected mobility of 23% of the Edinburgh drug abusers, particularly to other areas of Britain, suggests that similar services need to be set up elsewhere.     

Chromosome 17 markers and von Recklinghausen neurofibromatosis: A genetic linkage study in a British population

A genetic linkage study of the RFLPs identified by nine DNA probes localized to the pericentromeric region and long arm of chromosome 17 has been undertaken in 16 families with von Recklinghausen neurofibromatosis (NF1). Close linkage has been shown with the markers CRI-L946 (D17S36), CRI-L581 (D17S37), p17H8 (D17Z1), and pA10-41 (D17S71). The ERBA1 and COL1A1 loci may also be closely linked, but the data are limited. The results for HOX2 and NGFR suggest only loose linkage with the NF1 gene, while no linkage was found between NF1 and the growth hormone locus. No suggestion of nonallelic heterogeneity of NF1 was found in this study.     

Molecular genetics in clinical practice: evolution of a DNA diagnostic service.

The development of a molecular genetics diagnostic service over a three year period was studied in a National Health Service region with a population of three million. Starting from a time when few diagnostic applications were possible, the number of disorders and the overall demand had grown rapidly. Conditions for which molecular genetic diagnosis had been provided included Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy, myotonic dystrophy, Huntington''s disease, and cystic fibrosis. Of 405 requests for diagnosis, 151 (37%) related to determination of carrier state, 187 (46%) to determining the feasibility of future prenatal diagnosis, and 67 (17%) were prenatal diagnostic biopsy samples, almost exclusively of first trimester chorion. DNA samples for future diagnostic use with a wide range of genetic disorders had also been banked. The study showed a need for close integration with clinical genetics services to allow satisfactory genetic counselling and interpretation of risks.     

Clinical findings and cytogenetic analysis of small supernumerary ring chromosomes 7: report of two new cases

Two new patients, mosaic for a small supernumerary ring chromosome 7 are described. There are only seven published reported concerning supernumerary ring chromosome 7 and we reviewed the previously reported cases in an attempt to establish genotype-phenotype correlations, which are particularly important for genetic counselling and clinical genetics. Our first case was a 20 months old girl who was referred for a mild motor developmental delay, an asymmetric facial appearance, a plagiocephaly and a short nose with anteverted nostrils. Our second case was a 9 years old boy who was referred for a IQ at the lower end of the normal range (? 80), obesity, hyperactivity and some dysmorphic features including hypertelorism and down slanting palpebral fissures. In both cases, chromosome analysis after G and R banding and FISH showed a small ring chromosome 7 in respectively 76% and 50% of consecutively scored metaphases. Both ring chromosomes were labelled by FISH using the Williams Syndrome locus probe (Elastin Gene D7S486). Comparison between these two cases and previously published cases allowed to delineate frequent clinical findings. A mild mental retardation was found in the majority of patients. which is an important data for genetic counselling.