Potential of promotion of alleles by genome editing to improve quantitative traits in livestock breeding programs

Background

Genome editing (GE) is a method that enables specific nucleotides in the genome of an individual to be changed. To date, use of GE in livestock has focussed on simple traits that are controlled by a few quantitative trait nucleotides (QTN) with large effects. The aim of this study was to evaluate the potential of GE to improve quantitative traits that are controlled by many QTN, referred to here as promotion of alleles by genome editing (PAGE).

Methods

Multiple scenarios were simulated to test alternative PAGE strategies for a quantitative trait. They differed in (i) the number of edits per sire (0 to 100), (ii) the number of edits per generation (0 to 500), and (iii) the extent of use of PAGE (i.e. editing all sires or only a proportion of them). The base line scenario involved selecting individuals on true breeding values (i.e., genomic selection only (GS only)-genomic selection with perfect accuracy) for several generations. Alternative scenarios complemented this base line scenario with PAGE (GS + PAGE). The effect of different PAGE strategies was quantified by comparing response to selection, changes in allele frequencies, the number of distinct QTN edited, the sum of absolute effects of the edited QTN per generation, and inbreeding.

Results

Response to selection after 20 generations was between 1.08 and 4.12 times higher with GS + PAGE than with GS only. Increases in response to selection were larger with more edits per sire and more sires edited. When the total resources for PAGE were limited, editing a few sires for many QTN resulted in greater response to selection and inbreeding compared to editing many sires for a few QTN. Between the scenarios GS only and GS + PAGE, there was little difference in the average change in QTN allele frequencies, but there was a major difference for the QTN with the largest effects. The sum of the effects of the edited QTN decreased across generations.

Conclusions

This study showed that PAGE has great potential for application in livestock breeding programs, but inbreeding needs to be managed.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12711-015-0135-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

High-throughput assessment of mutations generated by genome editing in induced pluripotent stem cells by high-resolution melting analysis

Background and aimsGenome editing of induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) holds great potential for both disease modeling and regenerative medicine. Although clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/CRISPR-associated protein 9 provides an efficient and precise genome editing tool, iPSCs are especially difficult to transfect, resulting in a small percentage of cells carrying the desired correction. A high-throughput method to identify edited clones is required to reduce the time and costs of such an approach.MethodsHere we assess high-resolution melting analysis (HRMA), a simple and efficient real-time polymerase chain reaction-based method, and compare it with more commonly used assays.Results and conclusionsOur data show that HRMA is a robust and highly sensitive method, allowing the cost-effective and time-saving screening of genome-edited iPSCs. Samples can be prepared directly from 96-well microtiter plates for high-throughput analysis, and amplicons can be further analyzed with downstream techniques for further confirmation, if needed.     

人工核酸内切酶介导的新一代基因组编辑技术进展

对基因组特定位置进行针对性修饰的实验方法称为基因组编辑技术。近年出现的ZFN、TALEN、CRISPR/Cas等一系列人工核酸内切酶逐渐形成了新一代基因组编辑技术,极大地促进了基因组靶向修饰技术的发展,并在基因功能研究、基因治疗等领域开始发挥巨大作用。文中对这一技术的基本原理、发展历程和应用方式进行了简要总结。     

Consumer acceptance of food crops developed by genome editing

One of the major problems regarding consumer acceptance of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) is the possibility that their transgenes could have adverse effects on the environment and/or human health. Genome editing, represented by the CRISPR/Cas9 system, can efficiently achieve transgene-free gene modifications and is anticipated to generate a wide spectrum of plants. However, the public attitude against GMOs suggests that people will initially be unlikely to accept these plants. We herein explored the bottlenecks of consumer acceptance of transgene-free food crops developed by genome editing and made some recommendations. People should not pursue a zero-risk bias regarding such crops. Developers are encouraged to produce cultivars with a trait that would satisfy consumer needs. Moreover, they should carefully investigate off-target mutations in resultant plants and initially refrain from agricultural use of multiplex genome editing for better risk–benefit communication. The government must consider their regulatory status and establish appropriate regulations if necessary. The government also should foster communication between the public and developers. If people are informed of the benefits of genome editing-mediated plant breeding and trust in the relevant regulations, and if careful risk–benefit communication and sincere considerations for the right to know approach are guaranteed, then such transgene-free crops could gradually be integrated into society.     

Efficient genome editing in Caenorhabditis elegans by CRISPR-targeted homologous recombination

Cas9 is an RNA-guided double-stranded DNA nuclease that participates in clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-mediated adaptive immunity in prokaryotes. CRISPR–Cas9 has recently been used to generate insertion and deletion mutations in Caenorhabditis elegans, but not to create tailored changes (knock-ins). We show that the CRISPR–CRISPR-associated (Cas) system can be adapted for efficient and precise editing of the C. elegans genome. The targeted double-strand breaks generated by CRISPR are substrates for transgene-instructed gene conversion. This allows customized changes in the C. elegans genome by homologous recombination: sequences contained in the repair template (the transgene) are copied by gene conversion into the genome. The possibility to edit the C. elegans genome at selected locations will facilitate the systematic study of gene function in this widely used model organism.     

植物基因组编辑检测方法

以CRISPR/Cas9技术为代表的基因组编辑在生物领域的革命性应用使得生命科学研究迈入新篇章。该技术以其灵活性、易用性且扩展性强等优势,大大加快了基因工程研究,也加速了植物分子育种的步伐。但是,遗传转化过程中产生大量潜在的基因编辑植株,使得早期高通量快速筛选和检测目标编辑植株面临很大挑战。本文综述了近年来植物基因组编辑检测的各种方法,比较了其优缺点和适用范围;同时,还对近几年植物基因组编辑检测方法的发展趋势进行了深入分析和展望,以期对基因组编辑技术在植物中的应用提供参考。     

Global developments of genome editing in agriculture

Genome editing, particularly using of site-directed nucleases such as the CRISPR system, has spread rapidly through the biological sciences. Genome editing in crops could significantly speed up the progress of breeding programs. It could drive the development of traits in new crops and allow improvements in yield and pest resistance, adaptation to climate change, and industrial and pharmaceutical applications. However biofortification is a key challenge to satisfy nutritional needs in vitamins for developing countries and new consumer’s needs for developed countries. China and the USA lead scientific research in crop editing. Nigeria, being headquarters to numerous research consortia, is the most involved country in Africa. Genome editing in animals including pig, cattle, sheep, and carp, has not merely accelerated research but has made possible research that was previously unfeasible. It has been used to increase disease resistance, to make livestock better adapted to farming or environmental conditions, to increase fertility and growth, and to improve animal welfare. The USA, the UK and China are the most involved countries in animal genome editing. Global food production needs to increase as much as 70 per cent to support the growing population. Genome editing could contribute improving the efficiency of food distribution and reducing waste. Depending on the regulatory conditions, genome editing could open up the field to smaller companies and public labs.

     

Homology-based repair induced by CRISPR-Cas nucleases in mammalian embryo genome editing

Recent advances in genome editing, especially CRISPR-Cas nucleases, have revolutionized both laboratory research and clinical therapeutics. CRISPR-Cas nucleases, together with the DNA damage repair pathway in cells, enable both genetic diversification by classical non-homologous end joining (c-NHEJ) and precise genome modification by homology-based repair (HBR). Genome editing in zygotes is a convenient way to edit the germline, paving the way for animal disease model generation, as well as human embryo genome editing therapy for some life-threatening and incurable diseases. HBR efficiency is highly dependent on the DNA donor that is utilized as a repair template. Here, we review recent progress in improving CRISPR-Cas nuclease-induced HBR in mammalian embryos by designing a suitable DNA donor. Moreover, we want to provide a guide for producing animal disease models and correcting genetic mutations through CRISPR-Cas nuclease-induced HBR in mammalian embryos. Finally, we discuss recent developments in precise genome-modification technology based on the CRISPR-Cas system.Supplementary InformationThe online version of this article (10.1007/s13238-021-00838-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Making ends meet: targeted integration of DNA fragments by genome editing

Targeted insertion of large pieces of DNA is an important goal of genetic engineering. However, this goal has been elusive since classical methods for homology-directed repair are inefficient and often not feasible in many systems. Recent advances are described here that enable site-specific genomic insertion of relatively large DNA with much improved efficiency. Using the preferred repair pathway in the cell of nonhomologous end-joining, DNA of up to several kb could be introduced with remarkably good precision by the methods of HITI and ObLiGaRe with an efficiency up to 30–40%. Recent advances utilizing homology-directed repair (methods of PITCh; short homology arms including ssODN; 2H2OP) have significantly increased the efficiency for DNA insertion, often to 40–50% or even more depending on the method and length of DNA. The remaining challenges of integration precision and off-target site insertions are summarized. Overall, current advances provide major steps forward for site-specific insertion of large DNA into genomes from a broad range of cells and organisms.     

Applications of multiplex genome editing in higher plants

Multiplex genome editing in plants is typically carried out using the CRISPR/Cas9 system because it is more amenable to multiplexing than any other platform. A single gRNA can be used to target multiple alleles of the same gene (A1, A2) or homeoalleles from different ancestral genomes in a polyploid plant (A1, A2, B1, B2). A single gRNA can also be used to target multiple genes (X, Y, Z) if they contain a conserved region (C). Multiple gRNAs can be used to target unrelated sites in the same gene or in conserved sequences such as homeoalleles or members of the same gene family. Multiple gRNAs can also be used to target completely unrelated genes (D, E, F).

1. Download : Download high-res image (99KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Characterization and acceleration of genome shuffling and ploidy reduction in synthetic allopolyploids by genome sequencing and editing

Polyploidy and the subsequent ploidy reduction and genome shuffling are the major driving forces of genome evolution. Here, we revealed short-term allopolyploid genome evolution by sequencing a synthetic intergeneric hybrid (Raphanobrassica, RRCC). In this allotetraploid, the genome deletion was quick, while rearrangement was slow. The core and high-frequency genes tended to be retained while the specific and low-frequency genes tended to be deleted in the hybrid. The large-fragment deletions were enriched in the heterochromatin region and probably derived from chromosome breaks. The intergeneric translocations were primarily of short fragments dependent on homoeology, indicating a gene conversion origin. To accelerate genome shuffling, we developed an efficient genome editing platform for Raphanobrassica. By editing Fanconi Anemia Complementation Group M (FANCM) genes, homoeologous recombination, chromosome deletion and secondary meiosis with additional ploidy reduction were accelerated. FANCM was shown to be a checkpoint of meiosis and controller of ploidy stability. By simultaneously editing FLIP genes, gene conversion was precisely introduced, and mosaic genes were produced around the target site. This intergeneric hybrid and genome editing platform not only provides models that facilitate experimental evolution research by speeding up genome shuffling and conversion but also accelerates plant breeding by enhancing intergeneric genetic exchange and creating new genes.     

Translational enhancement by base editing of the Kozak sequence rescues haploinsufficiency

A variety of single-gene human diseases are caused by haploinsufficiency, a genetic condition by which mutational inactivation of one allele leads to reduced protein levels and functional impairment. Translational enhancement of the spare allele could exert a therapeutic effect. Here we developed BOOST, a novel gene-editing approach to rescue haploinsufficiency loci by the change of specific single nucleotides in the Kozak sequence, which controls translation by regulating start codon recognition. We evaluated for translational strength 230 Kozak sequences of annotated human haploinsufficient genes and 4621 derived variants, which can be installed by base editing, by a high-throughput reporter assay. Of these variants, 149 increased the translation of 47 Kozak sequences, demonstrating that a substantial proportion of haploinsufficient genes are controlled by suboptimal Kozak sequences. Validation of 18 variants for 8 genes produced an average enhancement in an expression window compatible with the rescue of the genetic imbalance. Base editing of the NCF1 gene, whose monoallelic loss causes chronic granulomatous disease, resulted in the desired increase of NCF1 (p47^phox) protein levels in a relevant cell model. We propose BOOST as a fine-tuned approach to modulate translation, applicable to the correction of dozens of haploinsufficient monogenic disorders independently of the causing mutation.     

Agricultural applications of genome editing in farmed animals

Animal husbandry is believed to predate farming of crops, and remains a core component of most agricultural systems. Historic breeding strategies were based largely on visual observation, crossing animals that were perceived to display enhanced merit. Advances in sequencing capacity coupled with reduced costs have allowed genomic selection tools to deliver significant contribution to breeding regimes. The application of genome editors to make specific changes to livestock genomes has the potential to deliver additional benefits.

     

Advances in detecting and reducing off-target effects generated by CRISPR-mediated genome editing

CRISPR-mediated genome editing is a revolutionary technology for genome manipulation that uses the CRISPR-Cas systems and base editors.Currently,poor efficiency and off-target problems have impeded the application of CRISPR systems.The on-target efficiency has been improved in several advanced versions of CRISPR systems,whereas the off-target detection still remains a key challenge.Here,we outline the different versions of CRISPR systems and off-target detection strategies,discuss the merits and limitations of off-target detection methods,and provide potential implications for further gene editing research.     

New traits in crops produced by genome editing techniques based on deletions

One of the most promising New Plant Breeding Techniques is genome editing (also called gene editing) with the help of a programmable site-directed nuclease (SDN). In this review, we focus on SDN-1, which is the generation of small deletions or insertions (indels) at a precisely defined location in the genome with zinc finger nucleases (ZFN), TALENs, or CRISPR-Cas9. The programmable nuclease is used to induce a double-strand break in the DNA, while the repair is left to the plant cell itself, and mistakes are introduced, while the cell is repairing the double-strand break using the relatively error-prone NHEJ pathway. From a biological point of view, it could be considered as a form of targeted mutagenesis. We first discuss improvements and new technical variants for SDN-1, in particular employing CRISPR-Cas, and subsequently explore the effectiveness of targeted deletions that eliminate the function of a gene, as an approach to generate novel traits useful for improving agricultural sustainability, including disease resistances. We compare them with examples of deletions that resulted in novel functionality as known from crop domestication and classical mutation breeding (both using radiation and chemical mutagens). Finally, we touch upon regulatory and access and benefit sharing issues regarding the plants produced.