Protein partitioning in aqueous two-phase systems composed of a pH-responsive copolymer and poly(ethylene glycol)

The effect of pH and salt concentration on the partitioning behavior of bovine serum albumin (BSA) and cytochrome c in an aqueous two-phase polymer system containing a novel pH-responsive copolymer that mimics the structure of proteins and poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) was investigated. The two-phase system has low viscosity. Depending on pH and salt concentration, the cytochrome c was found to preferentially partition into the pH-responsive copolymer-rich (bottom) phase under all conditions of pH and salt concentrations considered in the study. This was caused by the attraction between the positively charged protein and negatively charged copolymer. BSA partitioning showed a more complex behavior and partitioned either to the PEG phase or copolymer phase depending on the pH and ionic strength. Extremely high partitioning levels (partition coefficient of 0.004) and very high separation ratios of the two proteins (up to 48) were recorded in the new systems. This was attributed to strong electrostatic interactions between the proteins and the charged copolymer.     

The effect of KSCN on the partition of proteins in polyethylene glycol/(NH4)2SO4 aqueous two-phase system

The effect of potassium thiocyanate on the partitioning of lysozyme and BSA in polyethylene glycol 2000/ammonium sulfate aqueous two-phase system has been investigated. As a result of the addition of potassium thiocyanate to the PEG/ammonium sulfate system, the PEG/mixed salts aqueous two-phase system was formed. It was found that the potassium thiocyanate could alter the pH difference between the two phases, and, thus, influence the partition coefficients of the differently charged proteins. The relationship between partition coefficient of the proteins and pH difference between two phases has been discussed. It was proposed that the pH difference between two phases could be employed as the measurement of electrostatic driving force for the partitioning of charged proteins in polyethylene 2000/ammonium sulfate aqueous two-phase system.     

Conformational and electrostatic properties of unoccupied and liganded estrogen receptors determined by aqueous two-phase partitioning

The technique of aqueous two-phase partitioning (ATPP) has been used to characterize conformational and electrostatic properties of unoccupied and liganded rat uterine estrogen receptors. The adaptation of the hydroxylapatite receptor assay with ATPP systems has permitted estrogen receptor (ER) partition coefficients to be accurately determined, even when the partitioning process results in significant loss of ER binding capacity. The pH and salt dependences of estrogen receptor partition coefficients indicate that the theory governing partitioning behavior can be accurately applied to partitioning data obtained with crude cytosols. This technique has revealed a ligand-induced change in the properties of the unoccupied receptor that precedes the process of heat-induced transformation in vitro. The difference in partitioning behavior between unoccupied and nontransformed estrogen receptor is observed in all combinations of buffers and salts tested and is of equal magnitude as the difference between partition coefficients of nontransformed and transformed ER. The partition coefficients of both unoccupied and nontransformed ER are constant over the ER concentration range in which binding cooperativity has been previously demonstrated. The combined effects of salt and pH on ER partition coefficients indicate a pI of approximately 5.5 for both unoccupied and nontransformed estrogen receptors. However, the partition coefficients at the pI differ. It is concluded that estradiol binding to its unoccupied receptor results in a change in surface properties of the ER monomer that is independent of receptor transformation and makes the receptor less hydrophobic.     

Predicting the partition coefficients of a recombinant cutinase in polyethylene glycol/phosphate aqueous two-phase systems

A model for the prediction of protein partition coefficients in aqueous two-phase systems has been developed. This model accounts for both charge-independent and electrostatic effects. The determination of nonelectrostatic effects was based on the model of Eiteman and Gainer for uncharged solutes while the electrostatic contribution was computed using TITRA, a program that uses a continuum electrostatic model to treat charge interactions in proteins and considers the effect of pH and ionic strength. The partition coefficients of Fusarium solani pisi recombinant cutinase have been satisfactorily predicted in polyethylene glycol (PEG) 1000 and phosphate aqueous two-phase systems at a pH range of 6.0-9.0. The model failed to predict the enzyme partitioning behavior at pH 4.5. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 56: 248-257, 1997.     

Ion-exchange properties of cell walls of red seaweed Phyllophora crispa

Research into ion-exchange properties of cell walls isolated from thallus of red seaweed Phyllophora crispa was carried out. Ion-exchange capacity and the swelling coefficient of the red alga cell walls were estimated at various pH values (from 2 to 12) and at constant ionic strength of a solution (10 mM). It was established that behavior of cell walls as ion-exchangers is caused by the presence in their matrix of two types of cation-exchange groups and amino groups. The amount of the functional group of each type was estimated, and the corresponding values of pK(a) were calculated. It can be assumed that ionogenic groups with pK(a) -5 are carboxyl groups of uronic acids, and ionogenic groups with pK(a) -7.5 are carboxyl groups of the proteins. Intervals of pH in which cation-exchange groups are ionized and can take part in exchange reactions with cations in the environment are defined. It was found that protein was a major component of cell wall polymeric matrix because its content was 36%.     

Affinity-repulsion chromatography. Principle and application to lectins

The interactions of proteins with their immobilized ligands in an electrically charged microenvironment were studied. The binding of lectins to erythrocytes and to affinity matrices was used as a model system. Lectins bind and agglutinate erythrocytes in the presence of at least 10 mM NaCl or 1 mM CaCl2, but not in deionized water. The salt dependence of the agglutination process is due to the ability of salts to provide counterions neutralizing the forces of repulsion between the electrostatic charges of similar sign present on the erythrocyte cell surface and on the lectins. The same salt dependence is observed for the binding of lectins to affinity matrices. These observations are the basis of a protein separation process coined affinity-repulsion chromatography in which the electrostatic charges present, or purposely introduced, on affinity matrices are exploited and allow the elution, by electrostatic repulsion, of proteins carrying electrostatic charges of the same sign as that of the matrix. In this process, proteins are loaded on the affinity matrix in a salt solution and eluted with deionized water. Affinity-repulsion chromatography has been successfully applied here to the isolation of several lectins. Its physicochemical basis, merits, and potential applications are discussed.     

Purification and aqueous two-phase partitioning properties of recombinant Vitreoscilla hemoglobin.

Soluble recombinant Vitreoscilla hemoglobin was purified from E. coli lysate by sequential two-phase extraction techniques. Extraction of lysate containing VHb in PEG/dextran gave a 3.6-fold increase in VHb purity in the PEG-rich phase via a size exclusion mechanism. Further extraction of the recovered PEG phase in PEG/sodium sulfate gave an additional 2.0-fold increase in purity in the PEG-rich phase due to an electrostatic mechanism. Final extraction of the PEG phase in PEG/magnesium sulfate gave an additional 1.3-fold increase in VHb purity in the magnesium sulfate-rich phase. The final yield from the extractive purification was 47% with purity of VHb estimated to be greater than 95%. Yields from the sulfate salt extractions are essentially quantitative due to the extreme partitioning behavior of VHb in these systems. VHb partition coefficients as large as 46 in PEG/sodium sulfate and as small as 0.06 in PEG/magnesium sulfate were observed. Similar small partition coefficients were obtained with PEG/manganese sulfate extractions. This dramatic effect of divalent cation content on the partition coefficient of VHb in PEG/sulfate salt systems was investigated by pH and magnesium ion titration experiments. Results show the effect to be largest and nearly constant for pH values greater than 6.0 and diminished at lower pH values. A model based on magnesium ion binding to negatively charged amino acids is shown to correlate with the data well. Based on model formulation and the partitioning behavior of contaminant proteins, the observed effect is expected to be applicable to other proteins.     

The application of aqueous two-phase systems to the purification of pharmaceutical proteins from transgenic sheep milk

Transgenic sheep milk containing the protein human₁-Antitrypsin (AAT) was partitioned in Poly(ethyleneglycol) (PEG)-Sulphate and PEG-Phosphate biphasic systems. Individual partition coefficients for AAT and some of the milk proteins were determined in these systems. The effects of PEG molecular weight, pH and the inclusion of NaCl on the partitioning of the proteins were also studied. It was found that increasing the concentration of NaCl and decreasing the molecular weight of the PEG resulted in an increase of the partition coefficients of the proteins to the upper (PEG) phase. This partitioning effect was greater for the more hydrophobic proteins and particularly in systems having a pH close to the isoelectric point of the protein. Solubilities of the proteins in increasing concentrations of ammonium sulphate were measured in order to investigate the effects of hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions on the partitioning of these proteins in aqueous two-phase systems. Those proteins that precipitated at low levels of ammonium sulphate showed an increase in partition coefficient at low concentrations of NaCl, or they were precipitated at the interface of the phases at low concentrations of NaCl. Proteins that had low salting out constants in ammonium sulphate solutions were relatively unaffected by NaCl in ATPS. It is probable however that conformational changes and the state of aggregation of proteins are also important and should be invoked in describing the partitioning behavior observed for -Lg for example. Comparison of theoretical and experimental values for AAT yield and purity showed clearly that partition coefficients are influenced by the degree of purity and values obtained with purified standards are not necessarily the same as for the same protein present in a complex mixture. Under the most favourable conditions using a 4% w/w loading of transgenic ovine milk, we obtained a 91% yield of AAT in the PEG phase with a purity of 73%.This revised version was published online in October 2005 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Surfactant structure effects in protein separations using nonionic microemulsions

In this article, the extraction of cytochrome c utilizing various nonionic surfactant microemulsions has been tested to determine the effect of surfactant structure on protein partitioning. Surfactants tested include a linear alcohol ethoxylate (Neodol 91-2.5), two alkyl phenol ethoxylates (lgepal CO-520, Trycol 6985), and a series of alkyl sorbitan esters that are either ethoxylated (Tweens) or un-ethoxylated (Spans). Initial attempts to extract hemoglobin into Neodol 91-2.5 Winsor II microemulsions (oil-continuous) appeared successful based on heme estimation. Careful analysis showed that the hemoglobin had dissociated prior to extraction and that only the heme was extracted with false positive results. In fact, Neodol 91-2.5 microemulsions were unable to extract a variety of proteins with differing biophysical properties. Among all the other nonionic surfactant microemulsions tested only those made using sorbitan esters extracted significant amounts of cytochrome c. The partition coefficients achieved in this study are more than an order of magnitude higher than that seen previously in the literature for comparable sorbitan systems. However, this partition coefficient is extremely sensitive to ionic strength. At an ionic strength as low as 0.001 M, the partition coefficient is reduced to that seen in previous studies. We have found that protein partitioning in sorbitan ester microemulsions is not a function of water content. In addition, extraction is not a function of either alkyl chain length, or polyethylene oxide molecular weight. Hence, the sorbitan group appears to have an important role in extraction, possibly through a weak electrostatic protein-surfactant interaction. (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Purification of glucagon by subunit exchange chromatography

Glucagon was immobilized onto Sepharose matrices activated with CNBr or tresyl chloride, as a function of several parameters including pH of coupling, concentration of added polypeptide, and presence or absence of urea. The hormone was linked to the matrix through a single point per molecule, namely, the epsilon -amino group of Lys(12) when the coupling was carried out at alkaline pH, or the imidazole group of His(1) when the coupling was carried out at acidic pH. Glucagon immobilized at alkaline pH interacted specifically with soluble glucogon. The extent of self-association was similar to that of free glucagon, which exists in solution in a monomer-trimer equilibrium whose association constant is highly dependent on the characteristics of the buffer (pH, ionic strength, and nature of anions). The immobilized hormone proved to be suitable for the purification of the free one from a pancreatic extract. After a preliminary treatment with charcoal-dextran, the extract was percolated on a glucagon-Sepharose column under associating conditions (high concentrations of salting out anions and alkaline pH) and then, following a washing to remove extraneous compounds, the specifically bound hormone was eluted under dissociating conditions (low ionic strength). The subunit exchange chromatography of the extract gave a ca. 90% pure product. The overall recovery of the process was ca. 66%. The leakage of immobilized hormone was 40% in the case of CNBr activation of Sepharose and 15% in the case of tresyl chloride activation, after an eight-day treatment under working conditions.     

Partitioning features of bovine trypsin and alpha-chymotrypsin in polyethyleneglycol-sodium citrate aqueous two-phase systems

The partitioning of bovine trypsin and alpha-chymotrypsin--proteases of similar physico-chemical properties--in different polyethyleneglycol/sodium citrate aqueous two-phase systems was investigated. The effect of different factors such as polyethyleneglycol molecular weight, pH, tie line length, temperature and the presence of an inorganic salt on the protein partition coefficient were analysed. Both a decrease in PEG molecular weight and an increase in pH led to a higher partition coefficient for both enzymes. Aqueous two-phase systems formed by PEG of molecular weight 3350 and citrate pH 5.2 showed the best separation capability which was enhanced in presence of sodium chloride 3%. The transfer of both proteins to the top phase was associated with negative enthalpic and entropic changes.     

Protein partition between the different phases comprising poly(ethylene glycol)-salt aqueous two-phase systems, hydrophobic interaction chromatography and precipitation: a generic description in terms of salting-out effects

The solution behaviour of selected proteins has been studied under conditions promoting precipitation, binding to mildly hydrophobic adsorbents or partition. Solvophobic theory may be used to describe these forms of protein partition. The tendency of a protein to partition therein is dependent upon surface properties of the protein solute mediated by the concentration and nature of added salts. As applied to partitioning in poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG)-salt systems this implies that linear (Brönsted) relationships apply only to proteins partitioned close to the critical point. At longer tie-line lengths protein partitioning is increasingly influenced by salting-out forces. This is confirmed by the observed behaviour of the proteins. The point at which this behaviour changes has been unambiguously defined enabling the direct comparison of phase transition of proteins during partition in all systems. The results obtained show that phase transition during adsorption and partition occur at similar concentrations of salt. This is less than that required to promote precipitation. It appears, from these limited studies, that top-phase preferring proteins are partitioned at salt concentrations above those required to cause adsorption. Proteins preferring the lower phase are partitioned at salt concentrations close to or below those required for adsorption. This raises questions regarding the solvated molecular form of the partitioned proteins and the definition of the partition coefficient.     

Ionic control of immobilized enzymes. Kinetics of acid phosphatase bound to plant cell walls.

When an enzyme is bound to an insoluble polyelectrolyte it may acquire novel kinetic properties generated by Donnan effects. It the enzyme is homogeneously distributed within the matrix, a variation of the electrostatic partition coefficient, when substrate concentration is varied, mimics either positive or negative co-operativity. This type of non-hyperbolic behaviour may be distinguished from true co-operativity by an analysis of the Hill plots. If the enzyme is heterogeneously distributed within the polyelectrolyte matrix, an apparent negative co-operativity occurs, even if the electrostatic partition coefficient does not vary when substrate concentration is varied in the bulk phase. If the partition coefficient varies, mixed positive and negative co-operativities may occur. All these effects must be suppressed by raising the ionic strength in the bulk phase. Attraction of cations by fixed negative charges of the polyanionic matrix may be associated with a significant decrease of the local pH. The magnitude of this effect is controlled by the pK of the fixed charges groups of the Donnan phase. The local pH cannot be much lower than the value of this pK. This effect may be considered as a regulatory device of the local pH. Acid phosphatase of sycamore (Acer pseudoplatanus) cell walls is a monomeric enzyme that displays classical Michaelis-Menten kinetics in free solution. However, when bound to small cell-wall fragments or to intact cells, it has an apparent negative co-operativity at low ionic strength. Moreover a slight increase of ionic strength apparently activates the bound enzymes and tends to suppress the apparent co-operativity. At I0.1, or higher, the bound enzyme has a kinetic behavior indistinguishable from that of the purified enzyme in free solution. These results are interpreted in the light of the Donnan theory. Owing to the repulsion of the substrate by the negative charges of cell-wall polygalacturonates, the local substrate concentration in the vicinity of the bound enzyme is smaller than the corresponding concentration in bulk solution. The kinetic results obtained are consistent with the view that there exist at least three populations of bound enzyme with different ionic environments: a first population with enzyme molecules not submitted to electrostatic effects, and two other populations with molecules differently submitted to these effects. The theory allows one to estimate the proportions of enzyme belonging to these populations, as well as the local pH values and the partition coefficients within the cell walls.     

Analysis of steric partition behavior of molecules in membranes using statistical physics. Application to gel chromatography and electrophoresis.

The principles of statistical physics are used to formulate general expressions for the steric partition behavior of molecules in both random and ordered membrane structures that may be applied to any shape of the solute and/or the volume-excluding element of the membrane. These expressions fully define partitioning in terms of the volume excluded to point molecules and to finite-sized molecules. The mean effective exclusion volume for a molecule is calculated as a function of a global interaction energy, which varies with position, conformation, and orientation of the molecule. It allows consideration of electrostatic and other nonsteric factors. To test the model, specific partition functions are derived for several simple geometries describing the membrane and solute. Frequently, the derived expressions agree with past analyses; however, a new expression describing partitioning within an random network of fibers is derived. It agrees with past results only in the limit of low exclusion volumes. With greater volume exclusions, past results greatly overestimate the partition function. It is applied to gel electrophoresis and chromatography and survives testing with available experimental data. Unlike past analyses, it predicts nonlinear Ferguson plots for agarose gel electrophoresis. In addition, an analytical expression predicting the minimum radius of a sphere excluded from a random fiber matrix is derived, tested, and found to agree with experimental data.     

Bovine serum albumin partitioning in an aqueous two-phase system: Effect of pH and sodium chloride concentration

The partitioning of bovine serum albumin (BSA) in a polyethylene glycol 3350 (8% w/w)–dextran 37 500 (6% w/w)–0.05 M phosphate aqueous two-phase was investigated at different pHs, at varying concentrations of sodium chloride at 20°C. The effect of NaCl concentration on the partition coefficient of BSA was studied for the PEG–dx systems with initial pH values of 4.2, 5.0, 7.0, 9.0, and 9.8. The NaCl concentrations in the phase systems with constant pH value were 0.06, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, and 0.34 M. It was observed that the BSA partition coefficient decreased at concentrations smaller than 0.2 M NaCl and increased at concentrations greater than 0.2 M NaCl for all systems with initial pHs of 4.2, 5.0, 7.0, 9.0, and 9.8. It was also seen that the partition coefficient of BSA decreased as the pH of the aqueous two-phase systems increased at any NaCl salt concentration studied.     

The effects of pH and ionic strength on the partitioning of four proteins in reverse micelle systems

Four proteins with different physicochemical properties have been partitioned in reversed micelle systems: thaumatin, ribonuclease A, soybean trypsin inhibitor, and alpha-lactalbumin. The organic phase was formed by sodium salt (AOT) in isooctane, and the aqueous phase contained KCl, KBr, MgCl(2), or NaCl. Aqueous phase pH was varied between 2 and 13 and ionic strength from 0.1 to 1.0 M. Small changes in pH [around the isoelecric point (pl)] were found to influence the solubilization of ribonuclease A and trypsin inhibitor, but for thaumatin the pH change necessary to affect partition was much greater as a consequence of the difference in net charge (titration curves) of these protein molecules as pH changes. The type of ions present in the system was also a determining factor for partition; the larger ions (K(+)) produced more electrostatic screening and hence less protein solubilization than the smaller ions (Na(+)). With changes in ionic strength surface hydrophobicity was a dominant factor affecting solubilization of thaumatin in NaCl-containing systems at high pH. Charge distribution and hydrophobicity are thought to be important parameters when partitioning the protein alpha-lactalbumin. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase partitioning in two-phase aqueous mixed (nonionic/cationic) micellar systems

The enzyme glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) plays an important role in maintaining the level of NADPH and in producing pentose phosphates for nucleotide biosynthesis. It is also of great value as an analytical reagent, being used in various quantitative assays. In searching for new strategies to purify this enzyme, the partitioning of G6PD in two-phase aqueous mixed (nonionic/cationic) micellar systems was investigated both experimentally and theoretically. Our results indicate that the use of a two-phase aqueous mixed micellar system composed of the nonionic surfactant C(10)E(4) (n-decyl tetra(ethylene oxide)) and the cationic surfactant C(n)TAB (alkyltrimethylammonium bromide, n = 8, 10, or 12) can improve significantly the partitioning behavior of G6PD relative to that obtained in the two-phase aqueous C(10)E(4) micellar system. This improvement can be attributed to electrostatic attractions between the positively charged mixed (nonionic/cationic) micelles and the net negatively charged enzyme G6PD, resulting in the preferential partitioning of G6PD to the top, mixed micelle-rich phase of the two-phase aqueous mixed micellar systems. The effect of varying the cationic surfactant tail length (n = 8, 10, and 12) on the denaturation and partitioning behavior of G6PD in the C(10)E(4) /C(n)TAB/buffer system was investigated. It was found that C(8)TAB is the least denaturing to G6PD, followed by C(10)TAB and C(12)TAB. However, the C(10)E(4)/C(12)TAB/buffer system generated stronger electrostatic attractions with the net negatively charged enzyme G6PD than the C(10)E(4)/C(10)TAB/buffer and the C(10)E(4)/C(8)TAB/buffer systems, when using the same amount of cationic surfactant. Overall, the two-phase aqueous mixed (C(10)E(4)/C(10)TAB) micellar system yielded the highest G6PD partition coefficient of 7.7, with a G6PD yield in the top phase of 71%, providing the optimal balance between the denaturing effect and the electrostatic attractions for the three cationic surfactants examined. A recently developed theoretical framework to predict protein partition coefficients in two-phase aqueous mixed (nonionic/ionic) micellar systems was implemented, and the theoretically predicted G6PD partition coefficients were found to be in reasonable quantitative agreement with the experimentally measured ones.     

Development of metal affinity-immobilized liposome chromatography and its basic characteristics

Metal affinity-immobilized liposome chromatography (MA-ILC) was newly developed as a chromatographic technique to separate and analyze peptides. The MA-ILC matrix gel was first prepared by immobilizing liposomes modified with functional ligands. The functional ligand used to adsorb metal ions was N-hexadecyl iminodiacetic acid (HIDA), which is obtained by attaching a long alkyl chain to an iminodiacetic acid (IDA). Cu(II) ion was first adsorbed on the gel matrix through its complex formation with the HIDA on the surface of the immobilized liposome. Synthetic peptides of various types ranging in size from 5 to 40 residues were then used, and their retention properties on the MA-ILC were evaluated. The retention property of peptides on the MA-ILC by using a usual imidazole elution was compared with the retention property in the case of the immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) and an immobilized liposome chromatography (ILC). It was found that the retention property of peptides on the MA-ILC has the features of both the IMAC and the ILC; the retention ability of peptides depends on both the number of histidine residues in peptides and the liposome membrane affinity of the peptides. Histidine and tryptophan residues among amino acid residues in peptides indicated a high contribution coefficient for the peptide retention on the MA-ILC, probably due to their metal ion and membrane interaction properties, respectively.     

Partitioning of Proteins using a Hydrophobically Modified Ethylene Oxide/SDS Aqueous Two-phase System

Summary A novel aqueous two-phase system containing hydrophobically modified ethylene oxide (HM-EO) and sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) was developed to enhance the selectivity of protein partitioning in two phases. Phase diagrams of HM-EO/H₂O and HM-EO/SDS/H₂O were measured, and the mechanism of interaction between HM-EO polymer and the anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulphate (SDS) was also discussed. It was found that the improvement of selectivity of protein partitioning was related to the increase of electrostatic potential difference between the two phases because of the charged network formed by mixed micelles of HM-EO and SDS in the bottom phase. With bovine serum albumin (BSA) and lysozyme as model proteins, some factors, such as pH, SDS concentration, conductivity and temperature of the system, were investigated for the influences of protein partition in HM-EO/SDS/H₂O systems. The results showed that the addition of SDS not only changed the phase behaviour, but also played an important role in protein partitioning.