Conformational restrictions in the active site of unliganded human caspase-3

Caspases are cysteine proteases that play a critical role in the initiation and regulation of apoptosis. These enzymes act in a cascade to promote cell death through proteolytic cleavage of intracellular proteins. Since activation of apoptosis is implicated in human diseases such as cancer and neurodegenerative disorders, caspases are targets for drugs designed to modulate their action. Active caspases are heterodimeric enzymes with two symmetrically arranged active sites at opposite ends of the molecule. A number of crystal structures of caspases with peptides or proteins bound at the active sites have defined the mechanism of action of these enzymes, but molecular information about the active sites before substrate engagement has been lacking. As part of a study of peptidyl inhibitors of caspase-3, we crystallized a complex where the inhibitor did not bind in the active site. Here we present the crystal structure of the unoccupied substrate-binding site of caspase-3. No large conformational differences were apparent when this site was compared with that in enzyme-inhibitor complexes. Instead, the 1.9 A structure reveals critical side chain movements in a hydrophobic pocket in the active site. Notably, the side chain of tyrosine204 is rotated by approximately 90 degrees so that the phenol group occupies the S2 subsite in the active site. Thus, binding of substrate or inhibitors is impeded unless rotation of this side chain opens the area. The positions of these side chains may have important implications for the directed design of inhibitors of caspase-3 or caspase-7.     

Crystal structure of a procaspase-7 zymogen: mechanisms of activation and substrate binding.

Apoptosis is primarily executed by active caspases, which are derived from the inactive procaspase zymogens through proteolytic cleavage. Here we report the crystal structures of a caspase zymogen, procaspase-7, and an active caspase-7 without any bound inhibitors. Compared to the inhibitor-bound caspase-7, procaspase-7 zymogen exhibits significant structural differences surrounding the catalytic cleft, which precludes the formation of a productive conformation. Proteolytic cleavage between the large and small subunits allows rearrangement of essential loops in the active site, priming active caspase-7 for inhibitor/substrate binding. Strikingly, binding by inhibitors causes a 180 degrees flipping of the N terminus in the small subunit, which interacts with and stabilizes the catalytic cleft. These analyses reveal the structural mechanisms of caspase activation and demonstrate that the inhibitor/substrate binding is a process of induced fit.     

Proteases for cell suicide: functions and regulation of caspases.

Caspases are a large family of evolutionarily conserved proteases found from Caenorhabditis elegans to humans. Although the first caspase was identified as a processing enzyme for interleukin-1beta, genetic and biochemical data have converged to reveal that many caspases are key mediators of apoptosis, the intrinsic cell suicide program essential for development and tissue homeostasis. Each caspase is a cysteine aspartase; it employs a nucleophilic cysteine in its active site to cleave aspartic acid peptide bonds within proteins. Caspases are synthesized as inactive precursors termed procaspases; proteolytic processing of procaspase generates the tetrameric active caspase enzyme, composed of two repeating heterotypic subunits. Based on kinetic data, substrate specificity, and procaspase structure, caspases have been conceptually divided into initiators and effectors. Initiator caspases activate effector caspases in response to specific cell death signals, and effector caspases cleave various cellular proteins to trigger apoptosis. Adapter protein-mediated oligomerization of procaspases is now recognized as a universal mechanism of initiator caspase activation and underlies the control of both cell surface death receptor and mitochondrial cytochrome c-Apaf-1 apoptosis pathways. Caspase substrates have bene identified that induce each of the classic features of apoptosis, including membrane blebbing, cell body shrinkage, and DNA fragmentation. Mice deficient for caspase genes have highlighted tissue- and signal-specific pathways for apoptosis and demonstrated an independent function for caspase-1 and -11 in cytokine processing. Dysregulation of caspases features prominently in many human diseases, including cancer, autoimmunity, and neurodegenerative disorders, and increasing evidence shows that altering caspase activity can confer therapeutic benefits.     

A class of allosteric caspase inhibitors identified by high-throughput screening

Caspase inhibition is a promising approach for treating multiple diseases. Using a reconstituted assay and high-throughput screening, we identified?a group?of nonpeptide caspase inhibitors. These inhibitors share common chemical scaffolds, suggesting the same mechanism of action. They can inhibit apoptosis in various cell types induced by multiple stimuli; they can also inhibit caspase-1-mediated interleukin generation in macrophages, indicating potential anti-inflammatory application. While these compounds inhibit all the tested caspases, kinetic analysis indicates they do not compete for the catalytic sites of the enzymes. The cocrystal structure of one of these compounds with caspase-7 reveals that it binds to the dimerization interface of the caspase, another common structural element shared by all active caspases. Consistently, biochemical analysis demonstrates that the compound abates caspase-8 dimerization. Based on these kinetic, biochemical, and structural analyses, we suggest that these compounds are allosteric caspase inhibitors that function through binding to the dimerization interface of caspases.     

Use of fluorescently labeled caspase inhibitors as affinity labels to detect activated caspases

Activation of caspases is the key event of apoptosis and different approaches were developed to assay it. To detect their activation in situ, we applied fluorochrome labeled inhibitors of caspases (FLICA) as affinity labels of active centers of these enzymes. The FLICA ligands are fluorescein or sulforhodamine conjugated peptide-fluoromethyl ketones that covalently bind to enzymatic centers of caspases with 1:1 stoichiometry. The specificity of FLICA towards individual caspases is provided by the peptide sequence of amino acids. Exposure of live cells to FLICA results in uptake of these ligands and their binding to activated caspases; unbound FLICA is removed by cell rinse. Cells labeled with FLICA can be examined by fluorescence microscopy or subjected to quantitative analysis by cytometry. Intracellular binding sites of FLICA are consistent with known localization of caspases. Covalent binding of FLICA allowed us to identify the labeled proteins by immunoblotting: the proteins that bound individual FLICAs had molecular weight between 17 and 22 kDa, which corresponds to large subunits of the caspases. Detection of caspases activation by FLICA can be combined with other markers of apoptosis or cell cycle for multiparametric analysis. Because FLICA are caspase inhibitors they arrest the process of apoptosis preventing cell disintegration. The stathmo-apoptotic method was developed, therefore, that allows one to assay cumulative apoptotic index over long period of time and estimate the rate of cell entry into apoptosis for large cell populations. FLICA offers a rapid and convenient assay of caspases activation and can also be used to accurately estimate the incidence of apoptosis.     

Short peptide tools for monitoring caspase and proteasome activities in embryonal and adult rat brain lysates: an approach for the differential identification of proteases

The numerous caspase-like activities present in nervous tissue can be investigated with labelled peptides. However, the cross-reactivities of peptides with both proteasomes and caspases complicate the analysis of protease activity. The pharmacological features of substrates and inhibitors specific for either caspases or proteasome caspase-like proteases in rat brain lysates were similar or identical to the profiles of commercially purified proteasome preparations. Caspase inhibitors bind directly to active proteasome centres, thus competing with selective antagonists of proteasomes. Separation of lysates by molecular weight does not separate active caspases from proteasomes because these enzymes co-localize under native electrophoresis. The addition of ATP or its analogues is associated with the differential modulation of proteasomal activity, which also leads to ambiguity in the data. However, induced caspase activity could be successfully differentiated from proteasome activity in embryonal brain lysates with the non-selective caspase inhibitors Z-VAD-FMK and Q-VD-OPh and the proteasome inhibitor AdaAhx(3)L(3)VS that are not cross-reactive. This strategy is proposed for the simultaneous examination of caspases and proteasomes using proteolysis experiments. The present study reveals that all of the caspase-like activities in the tissue lysates of non-injured adult rat brains were related to proteasomal caspase-like activities.     

Reactive-site cleavage residues confer target specificity to baculovirus P49, a dimeric member of the P35 family of caspase inhibitors

Baculovirus proteins P49 and P35 are potent suppressors of apoptosis in diverse organisms. Although related, P49 and P35 inhibit initiator and effector caspases, respectively, during infection of permissive insect cells. The molecular basis of this novel caspase specificity is unknown. To advance strategies for selective inhibition of the cell death caspases, we investigated biochemical differences between these baculovirus substrate inhibitors. We report here that P49 and P35 use similar mechanisms for stoichiometric inhibition that require caspase cleavage of their reactive site loops (RSL) and chemical contributions of a conserved N-terminal cysteine to stabilize the resulting inhibitory complex. Our data indicated that P49 functions as a homodimer that simultaneously binds two caspases. In contrast, P35 is a monomeric, monovalent inhibitor. P49 and P35 also differ in their RSL caspase recognition sequences. We tested the role of the P₄-P₁ recognition motif for caspase specificity by monitoring virus-induced proteolytic processing of Sf-caspase-1, the principal effector caspase of the host insect Spodoptera frugiperda. When P49's TVTD recognition motif was replaced with P35's DQMD motif, P49 was impaired for inhibition of the initiator caspase that cleaves and activates pro-Sf-caspase-1 and instead formed a stable inhibitory complex with active Sf-caspase-1. In contrast, the effector caspase specificity of P35 was unaltered when P35's DQMD motif was replaced with TVTD. We concluded that the TVTD recognition motif is required but not sufficient for initiator caspase inhibition by P49. Our findings demonstrate a critical role for the P₄-P₁ recognition site in caspase specificity by P49 and P35 and indicate that additional determinants are involved in target selection.     

Mechanism of zinc-mediated inhibition of caspase-9

Zinc-mediated inhibition is implicated in global caspase regulation, with relief of zinc-mediated inhibition central to both small-molecule and natively induced caspase activation. As an initiator, caspase-9 regulates the upstream stages of the apoptotic caspase cascade, making it a critical control point. Here we identify two distinct zinc-binding sites on caspase-9. The first site, composed of H237, C239, and C287, includes the active site dyad and is primarily responsible for zinc-mediated inhibition. The second binding site at C272 is distal from the active site. Given the amino-acid conservation in both regions, these sites appear to be present across the caspase family underscoring the importance of zinc-mediated regulation of this class of enzymes.     

A caspase active site probe reveals high fractional inhibition needed to block DNA fragmentation

Apoptotic markers consist of either caspase substrate cleavage products or phenotypic changes that manifest themselves as a consequence of caspase-mediated substrate cleavage. We have shown recently that pharmacological inhibitors of caspase activity prevent the appearance of two such apoptotic manifestations, alphaII-spectrin cleavage and DNA fragmentation, but that blockade of the latter required a significantly higher concentration of inhibitor. We investigated this phenomenon through the use of a novel radiolabeled caspase inhibitor, [(125)I]M808, which acts as a caspase active site probe. [(125)I]M808 bound to active caspases irreversibly and with high sensitivity in apoptotic cell extracts, in tissue extracts from several commonly used animal models of cellular injury, and in living cells. Moreover, [(125)I]M808 detected active caspases in septic mice when injected intravenously. Using this caspase probe, an active site occupancy assay was developed and used to measure the fractional inhibition required to block apoptosis-induced DNA fragmentation. In thymocytes, occupancy of up to 40% of caspase active sites had no effect on DNA fragmentation, whereas inhibition of half of the DNA cleaving activity required between 65 and 75% of active site occupancy. These results suggest that a high and persistent fractional inhibition will be required for successful caspase inhibition-based therapies.     

Caspase inhibitors of the P35 family are more active when purified from yeast than bacteria

Many insect viruses express caspase inhibitors of the P35 superfamily, which prevent defensive host apoptosis to enable viral propagation. The prototypical P35 family member, AcP35 from Autographa californica M nucleopolyhedrovirus, has been extensively studied. Bacterially purified AcP35 has been previously shown to inhibit caspases from insect, mammalian and nematode species. This inhibition occurs via a pseudosubstrate mechanism involving caspase-mediated cleavage of a "reactive site loop" within the P35 protein, which ultimately leaves cleaved P35 covalently bound to the caspase's active site. We observed that AcP35 purifed from Saccharomyces cerevisae inhibited caspase activity more efficiently than AcP35 purified from Escherichia coli. This differential potency was more dramatic for another P35 family member, MaviP35, which inhibited human caspase 3 almost 300-fold more potently when purified from yeast than bacteria. Biophysical assays revealed that MaviP35 proteins produced in bacteria and yeast had similar primary and secondary structures. However, bacterially produced MaviP35 possessed greater thermal stability and propensity to form higher order oligomers than its counterpart purified from yeast. Caspase 3 could process yeast-purified MaviP35, but failed to detectably cleave bacterially purified MaviP35. These data suggest that bacterially produced P35 proteins adopt subtly different conformations from their yeast-expressed counterparts, which hinder caspase access to the reactive site loop to reduce the potency of caspase inhibition, and promote aggregation. These data highlight the differential caspase inhibition by recombinant P35 proteins purified from different sources, and caution that analyses of bacterially produced P35 family members (and perhaps other types of proteins) may underestimate their activity.     

Activation and substrate specificity of caspase-14

Caspase-14 is a developmentally regulated and tissue restricted member of the caspase family present in mammals. It is mainly found in epidermal keratinocytes and has been hypothesized to be involved in a tissue-specific form of cell senescence, leading to the differentiation of keratinocytes that form the cornified cell layer. However, the substrate specificity, activation mechanism, and function of this caspase have yet to be revealed. We report that caspase-14, in contrast to other caspases, is not produced in active form following expression in Escherichia coli but can be activated by high concentrations of kosmotropic salts. Moreover, proteolytic cleavage is also required since the kosmotropic salts were only effective on the cleaved enzyme. We propose that caspase-14 requires proteolytic cleavage within the catalytic domain, followed by dimerization and ordering of mobile active site loops, to generate a competent enzyme. In the presence of kosmotropic salt, we were able to determine the substrate specificities of mouse and human caspase-14. Surprisingly, the substrate preferences for the human and mouse enzyme are dissimilar. The results obtained with human caspase-14 classify this enzyme as a cytokine activator, but the mouse enzyme shows preferences similar to apical apoptotic caspases.     

Allosteric peptides bind a caspase zymogen and mediate caspase tetramerization

The caspases are a family of cytosolic proteases with essential roles in inflammation and apoptosis. Drug discovery efforts have focused on developing molecules directed against the active sites of caspases, but this approach has proved challenging and has not yielded any approved therapeutics. Here we describe a new strategy for generating inhibitors of caspase-6, a potential therapeutic target in neurodegenerative disorders, by screening against its zymogen form. Using phage display to discover molecules that bind the zymogen, we report the identification of a peptide that specifically impairs the function of caspase-6 in vitro and in neuronal cells. Remarkably, the peptide binds at a tetramerization interface that is uniquely present in zymogen caspase-6, rather than binding into the active site, and acts via a new allosteric mechanism that promotes caspase tetramerization. Our data illustrate that screening against the zymogen holds promise as an approach for targeting caspases in drug discovery.     

Regulation of interferon and retinoic acid-induced cell death activation through thioredoxin reductase

Interferons (IFNs) and retinoids are potent biological response modifiers. The IFN-beta and all-trans-retinoic acid combination, but not these single agents individually, induces death in several tumor cell lines. To elucidate the molecular basis for these actions, we have employed an antisense knockout approach to identify the gene products that mediate cell death and isolated several genes associated with retinoid-IFN-induced mortality (GRIMs). One of the GRIM cDNAs, GRIM-12, was identical to human thioredoxin reductase (TR). To define the functional relevance of TR to cell death and to define its mechanism of death-modulating functions, we generated mutants of TR and studied their influence on the IFN/RA-induced death regulatory functions of caspases. Wild-type TR activates cell death that was inhibited in the presence of caspase inhibitors or catalytically inactive caspases. A mutant TR, lacking the active site cysteines, inhibits the cell death induced by caspase 8. IFN/all-trans-retinoic acid-induced cytochrome c release from the mitochondrion was promoted in the presence of wild type and was inhibited in the presence of mutant TR. We find that TR modulates the activity of caspase 8 to promote death. This effect is in part caused by the stimulation of death receptor gene expression. These studies identify a new mechanism of cell death regulation by the IFN/all-trans-retinoic acid combination involving redox enzymes.     

The viral nucleocapsid protein of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus (TGEV) is cleaved by caspase-6 and -7 during TGEV-induced apoptosis

The transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus (TGEV), like many other viruses, exerts much of its cytopathic effect through the induction of apoptosis of its host cell. Apoptosis is coordinated by a family of cysteine proteases, called caspases, that are activated during apoptosis and participate in dismantling the cell by cleaving key structural and regulatory proteins. We have explored the caspase activation events that are initiated upon infection of the human rectal tumor cell line HRT18 with TGEV. We show that TGEV infection results in the activation of caspase-3, -6, -7, -8, and -9 and cleavage of the caspase substrates eIF4GI, gelsolin, and alpha-fodrin. Surprisingly, the TGEV nucleoprotein (N) underwent proteolysis in parallel with the activation of caspases within the host cell. Cleavage of the N protein was inhibited by cell-permeative caspase inhibitors, suggesting that this viral structural protein is a target for host cell caspases. We show that the TGEV nucleoprotein is a substrate for both caspase-6 and -7, and using site-directed mutagenesis, we have mapped the cleavage site to VVPD(359) downward arrow. These data demonstrate that viral proteins can be targeted for destruction by the host cell death machinery.     

Phage display and structural studies reveal plasticity in substrate specificity of caspase‐3a from zebrafish

The regulation of caspase‐3 enzyme activity is a vital process in cell fate decisions leading to cell differentiation and tissue development or to apoptosis. The zebrafish, Danio rerio, has become an increasingly popular animal model to study several human diseases because of their transparent embryos, short reproductive cycles, and ease of drug administration. While apoptosis is an evolutionarily conserved process in metazoans, little is known about caspases from zebrafish, particularly regarding substrate specificity and allosteric regulation compared to the human caspases. We cloned zebrafish caspase‐3a (casp3a) and examined substrate specificity of the recombinant protein, Casp3a, compared to human caspase‐3 (CASP3) by utilizing M13 bacteriophage substrate libraries that incorporated either random amino acids at P5‐P1′ or aspartate fixed at P1. The results show a preference for the tetrapeptide sequence DNLD for both enzymes, but the P4 position of zebrafish Casp3a also accommodates valine equally well. We determined the structure of zebrafish Casp3a to 2.28Å resolution by X‐ray crystallography, and when combined with molecular dynamics simulations, the results suggest that a limited number of amino acid substitutions near the active site result in plasticity of the S4 sub‐site by increasing flexibility of one active site loop and by affecting hydrogen‐bonding with substrate. The data show that zebrafish Casp3a exhibits a broader substrate portfolio, suggesting overlap with the functions of caspase‐6 in zebrafish development.     

Crystal structure of an invertebrate caspase

Caspases play an essential role in the execution of apoptosis. These cysteine proteases are highly conserved among metazoans and are translated as inactive zymogens, which are activated by proteolytic cleavages to generate the large and small subunits and remove the N-terminal prodomain. The 2.3 A resolution crystal structure of active Sf-caspase-1, the principal effector caspase of the insect Spodoptera frugiperda, is presented here. The structure represents the first nonhuman caspase to be resolved. The structure of the cleaved and active protease was determined with the tetrapeptide inhibitor N-acetyl-Asp-Glu-Val-Asp-chloromethylketone covalently bonded to the active site cysteine. As expected, the overall fold of Sf-caspase-1 is exceedingly similar to that of the five active caspases from humans solved to date. The overall structure and active site arrangement of Sf-caspase-1 is most comparable with that of the human effector caspases, with which it shares highest sequence homology. The most prominent structural difference with Sf-caspase-1 is the position of the N-terminal region of the large subunit. Unlike the N terminus of human caspases, the N terminus of Sf-caspase-1 originates from the active site side where it interacts with active site loop L2 and then extends to the backside of the heterodimer. This unusual structural arrangement raises the possibility that the N-terminal prodomain plays a regulatory role during effector caspase activation or enzyme activity in insects.     

Purification and catalytic properties of human caspase family members.

Members of the caspase family of cysteine proteases are known to be key mediators of mammalian inflammation and apoptosis. To better understand the catalytic properties of these enzymes, and to facilitate the identification of selective inhibitors, we have systematically purified and biochemically characterized ten homologues of human origin (caspases 1 - 10). The method used for production of most of these enzymes involves folding of active enzymes from their constituent subunits which are expressed separately in E. coli, followed by ion exchange chromatography. In cases where it was not possible to use this method (caspase-6 and -10), the enzymes were instead expressed as soluble proteins in E. coli, and partially purified by ion exchange chromatography. Based on the optimal tetrapeptide recognition motif for each enzyme, substrates with the general structure Ac-XEXD-AMC were used to develop continuous fluorometric assays. In some cases, enzymes with virtually identical tetrapeptide specificities have kcat/Km values for fluorogenic substrates that differ by more than 1000-fold. Using these assays, we have investigated the effects of a variety of environmental factors (e.g. pH, NaCl, Ca2+) on the activities of these enzymes. Some of these variables have a profound effect on the rate of catalysis, a finding that may have important biological implications.     

Effect of phosphorylation and single nucleotide polymorphisms on caspase substrates processing

Posttranslational modifications that involve either reversible covalent modification of proteins or irreversible proteolysis are central to the regulation of key cellular mechanisms, including apoptosis, cell-cycle regulation and signal transduction. There is mounting evidence suggesting cross-talk between proteases and kinases. For instance: caspases, a class of proteases involved in programmed cell death—apoptosis, cleave a large set of various types of proteins. Simultaneously, kinases restrict caspase activity by phosphorylating their protein substrates in the vicinity of cleavage site. In addition, the caspase cleavage pattern in target proteins may be modified as a result of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the coding gene. This may either create a novel cleavage site, or increase/decrease the cleavage efficiency of a substrate. Such point mutations are often associated with the onset of disease. In this study, we predicted how phosphorylation and SNPs affect known human caspase proteolytic events collected in the CASBAH and Degrabase databases by applying Random Forest caspases’ substrates prediction method, as implemented in the CaspDB, and the molecular dynamics free energy simulations approach. Our analysis confirms several experimental observations. Phosphorylation could have both positive or negative regulatory effects depending on its position with respect to the caspase cleavage site. For instance, we demonstrate that phosphorylation at P1′ is the most detrimental for proteolytic efficiency of caspases. Phosphorylation at the P2 and P2′ positions also negatively affect the cleavage events. In addition, we uncovered SNPs in 11 caspase substrates capable of completely abolishing the cleavage site due to polymorphism at the P1 position. The findings presented here may be useful for determining the link between aberrant proteolysis and disease.     

Protease Activation in Apoptosis Induced by MAL

The proteolytic caspase cascade plays a central role in the signaling and execution steps of apoptosis. This study investigated the activation of different caspases in apoptosis induced by MAL (a folding variant of human alpha-lactalbumin) isolated from human milk. Our results show that the caspase-3-like enzymes, and to a lesser extent the caspase-6-like enzymes, were activated in Jurkat and A549 cells exposed to MAL. Activated caspases subsequently cleaved several protein substrates, including PARP, lamin B, and alpha-fodrin. A broad-range caspase inhibitor, zVAD-fmk, blocked the caspase activation, the cleavage of proteins, and DNA fragmentation, indicating an important role for caspase activation in MAL-induced apoptosis. Since an antagonistic anti-CD95 receptor antibody, ZB4, did not influence the MAL-induced killing, we conclude that this process does not involve the CD95-mediated pathway. While MAL did not directly activate caspases in the cytosol, it colocalized with mitochondria and induced the release of cytochrome c. Thus, these results demonstrate that caspases are activated and involved in apoptosis induced by MAL and that direct interaction of MAL with mitochondria leads to the release of cytochrome c, suggesting that this release is an important step in the initiation and/or amplification of the caspase cascade in these cells.