A fertile revertant from petaloid cytoplasmic male-sterile carrot has a rearranged mitochondrial genome

 A spontaneously derived fertile plant was recovered from a petaloid cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) carrot inbred line. Genetic analysis indicated a single nuclear gene was responsible for the restoration to fertility. Within a family segregating for the nuclear restorer in combination with the sterility-inducing cytoplasm, fertile plants were recovered that could not restore fertility when crossed to sterile genotypes. Genetic analysis indicated cytoplasmic reversion for fertility, and Southern analysis, comparing mtDNA organization of the fertile revertant and its CMS progenitor, identified mitochondrial genome rearrangements. Hybridization of cosmids representing a 108-kb subgenomic circle of the sterile line to DNA of a fertile maintainer and fertile revertant lines indicated a similar mtDNA organization for these genotypes that was distinct from that of the sterile line. Six restriction fragments totalling 43.2 kb were common to the fertile maintainer and revertant and absent in the sterile; other restriction fragments totalling 38.2 kb were present only for the sterile line. Unique fragments of low stoichiometry, two for the fertile maintainer and three for the revertant, distinguished these lines. The reversion to fertility in the sterile line could have resulted from the amplification of a mitochondrial submolar genome highly homologous to that found in the fertile maintainer line. Received: 4 October 1997/Accepted: 12 December 1997     

Genetic analysis and molecular mapping of a new fertility restorer gene Rf8 for Triticum timopheevi cytoplasm in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) using SSR markers

A study on mode of inheritance and mapping of fertility restorer (Rf) gene(s) using simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers was conducted in a cross of male sterile line 2041A having Triticum timopheevi cytoplasm and a restorer line PWR4099 of common wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). The F₁ hybrid was completely fertile indicating that fertility restoration is a dominant trait. Based on the pollen fertility and seed set of bagged spikes in F₂ generation, the individual plants were classified into fertile and sterile groups. Out of 120 F₂ plants, 97 were fertile and 23 sterile (based on pollen fertility) while 98 plants set ≥5 seeds/spike and 22 produced ≤4 or no seed. The observed frequency fits well into Mendelian ratio of 3 fertile: 1 sterile with χ² value of 2.84 for pollen fertility and 2.17 for seed setting indicating that the fertility restoration is governed by a single dominant gene in PWR4099. The three linked SSR markers, Xwmc503, Xgwm296 and Xwmc112 located on the chromosome 2DS were placed at a distance of 3.3, 5.8 and 6.7 cM, respectively, from the Rf gene. Since, no known Rf gene is located on the chromosome arm 2DS, the Rf gene in PWR4099 is a new gene and proposed as Rf8. The closest SSR marker, Xwmc503, linked to the Rf8 was validated in a set of Rf, maintainer and cytoplasmic male sterile lines. The closely linked SSR marker Xwmc503 may be used in marker-assisted backcross breeding facilitating the transfer of fertility restoration gene Rf8 into elite backgrounds with ease.     

Mitochondrial Plasmids in Sorghum: Presence of Linear Plasmids in Indian Male Sterile and Milo 296 Lines

The presence of plasm ids of sizes 5.8 kbp, 5.3 kbp, 2.3 kbp, 1.7 kbp and 1.36 kbp was detected in 3 Indian male sterile cytotypes viz. Maldandi, Guntur, Vizianagaram but not in their fertile maintainer lines. The 5.8 kbp and 5.3 kbp plasm ids do not possess any homology with the nuclear or chloroplastic DNA as also with the main mitochondrial genome of sterile and maintainer fertile lines. The detection of these plasm ids in the male sterile, maintainer fertile and fertility restored lines of 296 variety is surprising as the male sterile 296A and restored line possess a milo cytoplasm that has as yet not been shown to contain such plasmids. This observation suggests that plasm ids have no role to play in male sterility but their presence could be used as a marker for characterization/classification of certain cytoplasms especially the Indian cytoplasms.     

Genetics of fertility restoration in the C-group of cytoplasmic male sterility in maize

The genetics of fertility restoration of cms-C group cytoplasm of maize was studied using crosses involving stable maintainer lines and lines that restored full pollen fertility. Pollen fertility in the sources of cms-C sterile cytoplasms studied was restored by a single dominant restorer (Rf4) gene. The fertility restoration was sporophytic. Allelism tests among five restorer lines showed that they all apparently carried the same alleles (Rf4 Rf4). Similar tests also demonstrated that seven nonrestoring maintainer lines had apparently the same genotype (rf4 rf4), although a partial "late break" of fertility was observed at low levels in some maintainer crosses. Comparative studies among different cms-C sources (C, Bb, ES, PR and RB) indicated that similar inheritance of fertility restoration was involved. The data indicated that a single, dominant Rf gene is involved in the restoration of several C-group cytoplasms, at least in the lines studied here. This is the first single-gene, sporophytic restorer system described in maize to date.     

Mitochondrial plasmid-like molecules in fertile and male sterileVicia faba L

Biochemical analysis and electron microscopy showed that mitochondria of both the fertile and the male sterile 350 and 447 cytoplasms ofVicia faba. L. contain two small supercoiled DNA molecules of mean length of 1 700 and 1 420 base pairs in addition to the main mitochondrial DNA of high molecular weight. By agarose gel electrophoresis, the male sterile cytoplasm 350 is distinguished from the fertile cytoplasm and from the male sterile cytoplasm 447 by the presence of an additional supercoiled DNA molecule of approximately 1 540 bp.     

Mutations leading to nuclear restoration of fertility in S male-sterile cytoplasm in maize

Summary Among the offspring of crosses involving S male-sterile shrunken-2 inbred lines and their corresponding isogenic maintainer lines a number of exceptional male-fertile plants were identified. Some of these were plants with entirely fertile tassels but most were chimeras involving both sterile and fertile tassel elements. The majority of male-fertile exceptional plants, upon crossing with male-sterile testers, produced male-sterile test-cross progeny, indicating that the male-fertile trait is not pollen transmissible. However, there were four separate instances, involving three of the inbred lines, in which the crosses with S male-sterile testers produced male-fertile progeny, indicating that the newly arisen male-fertile trait is pollen transmissible. In three of these cases, the male fertility can be traced to a single plant in essentially male-sterile families. The fourth evidently involved a change in a maintainer plant whose progeny thereafter segregated for the ability to restore S sterile cytoplasm. In all cases, the results of progeny tests are consistent with the gametophytic pattern of restoration associated with S male-sterile cytoplasm.The male-fertile exceptions described here can be accounted for formally as mutations at one or more restorer gene loci in the nucleus. Taking account of the fact that mutations of restorer genes have not been reported previously in maize, and that four such changes were encountered in the same strains in which we have identified other male-fertile exceptions involving change in the cytoplasm, we have suggested a common basis for the two kinds of events. According to this scheme, given the first appearance, by whatever process, of the male-fertile element in sterile cytoplasm, it may become established and continue to propagate either in the cytoplasm or in the nucleus. In the former case, the change registers as cytoplasmic and the new strain has the characteristics of a maintainer which transmits the male-fertile trait through the egg, but not the sperm; in the latter case, the change occurs in the nucleus and the new strain, now behaving as a restorer, transmits male fertility through both egg and sperm.Dedicated to Dr. M. M. Rhoades on the occasion of his 70th birthday.Research supported in part by CSRS grant 177-15-04, PL 89–106, and by NSF GB 29488.     

A new fertility restorer locus linked closely to the Rfo locus for cytoplasmic male sterility in radish

In this study, we have investigated a new fertility restorer (Rf) locus for cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in radish. We have obtained a CMS-Rf system consisting of sterile line '9802A1', maintainer line '9802B1' and restorer line '9802H'. F(1) plants from cross between sterile line '9802A1' and restorer line '9802H' were all male fertile, self pollination of F(1) plants produced an F(2) segregating population consisting of 600 individuals. The segregating population was found to fit a segregation ratio 3:1 for male fertile and sterile types, indicating that male fertility is restored by a single dominant gene (termed Rfo2) in the CMS-Rf system. Based on the DNA sequence of Rfo/Rfk1 (AJ535623), just one full length gene in the sterile line '9802A1', in the restorer line '9802H' and in the male fertile line '2006H', was cloned, respectively. The three sequences correspond to the same gene with two alleles: Rfob in '9802H' and rfob in '9802A1' and '2006H'. These two alleles differ from Rfo/Rfk1 and rfk1 (AJ535624) alleles by two synonymous base substitutions, respectively. Based on the differences between the Rfob and rfob genes, one PCR-based marker was developed, and designated Marker 1, which is identical to the corresponding region of Rfob by sequence analysis. In the F(2) segregating population described above, the Marker 1 was present in 5 sterile plants and in 453 fertile plants, absent in 4 fertile plants and in 138 sterile plants, and was found to fit a segregation ratio 3:1 indicating that Rfob was single copy in '9802H'. Linkage analysis showed that the Rfo2 locus for our CMS-Rf system was distant from the Rfo locus by about 1.6 cM. The sterile line '9802A1' was pollinated by the male fertile line '2006H' and the resulting F(1) plants were all male fertile. These results indicated that the male fertility of radish CMS can be restored by a new Rf locus, which linked tightly to the Rfo locus.     

On the mechanism of cytoplasmic male sterility in the 447 line of Vicia faba

The trait of cytoplasmic male sterility, expressed in plants bearing the 447 cytoplasm of Vicia faba, is uniquely and positively correlated with the presence of a linear double-stranded RNA molecule (dsRNA) 16.7 kb in size. Restriction enzyme digestion profiles of mitochondrial DNA isolated from fertile and cytoplasmic malesterile (CMS) lines do show a limited number of specific differences in fragment intensities and mobilities. However, mitochondria isolated from the progeny of the cross CMS × Restorer line contain DNA with an identical restriction profile as the male-sterile parent: moreover, subsequent generations are completely and permanently fertile, even upon segregation of the nuclear restoration gene. Southern hybridizations, using cDNA clones as probes, reveal homology between the CMS-associated dsRNA and the nuclear genome of both sterile and fertile lines. The regions cloned, representing approximately 22% of the total dsRNA sequence, show no homology to organelle DNA. We have not been able to stably transmit the dsRNA to fertile lines of V. faba or any other plant species, using a variety of standard virological techniques.     

Studies on Genetic Male-Sterile Soybeans : IV. Effect of Male Sterility and Source of Nitrogen Nutrition on Accumulation, Partitioning, and Transport of Nitrogen

Soybean (Glycine max [L.] Merr.) germplasm, isogenic except for loci controlling male sterility (ms₁) and nodulation (rj₁), was used to investigate the effects of reproductive tissue development and source of nitrogen nutrition on accumulation, transport, and partitioning of nitrogen in a greenhouse experiment. Nodulated plants were supplied nitrogen-free nutrient solution, and nonnodulated plants were supplied nutrient solution containing 20 millimolar KNO₃. Plants were sampled from flowering until maturity (77 to 147 days after transplanting).

Accumulation rates of nitrogen in whole plants during reproductive growth were not significantly different among the four plant types. Nitrogen accumulation in the sterile, nonnodulated plants, however, ceased 2 weeks earlier than in fertile, nonnodulated or fertile and sterile, nodulated plants. This early cessation in nitrogen accumulation resulted in sterile, nonnodulated plants accumulating significantly less whole plant nitrogen by 133 days after transplanting (DAT) than fertile, nonnodulated plants. Thus, changing the site of nitrogen assimilation from nodules (N₂-fixing plants) to roots and leaves (NO₃-fed plants) resulted in similar whole-plant nitrogen accumulation rates in fertile and sterile plants, despite the absence of seed in the latter.

Leaflet and stem plus petiole tissues of both types of sterile plants had significantly higher nitrogen concentrations after 119 DAT than both types of fertile plants. Significantly higher concentrations and exudation rates of nonureide, reduced-nitrogen in xylem sap of sterile than of fertile plants after 105 DAT were observed. These latter results indicated possible cycling of nonureide, reduced-nitrogen from the downward phloem translocation stream to the upward xylem translocation stream in roots of sterile plants. Collectively, these results suggest a lack of sinks for nitrogen utilization in the shoots of sterile plants. Hence, comparison of nitrogen accumulation rates for sterile and fertile plants does not provide a definitive test of the hypothesis that reproductive tissue development limits photosynthate availability for support of N₂ fixation and nitrate assimilation in determinate soybeans.

Nitrogen assimilation during reproductive growth met a larger proportion of the reproductive-tissue nitrogen requirement of nitrate-dependent plants (73%) than of N₂-fixing plants (63%). Hence, vegetative-tissue nitrogen mobilization to reproductive tissue was a more prominent process in N₂-fixing than in nitrate-dependent plants. N₂-fixing plants partitioned nitrogen to reproductive tissue more efficiently than nitrate-dependent plants as the reproductive tissues of the former and latter contained 65 and 55%, respectively, of the whole-plant nitrogen at the time that nitrogen accumulation in reproductive parts had ceased (133 DAT).

     

A chimeric <Emphasis Type="Italic">Rfo</Emphasis> gene generated by intergenic recombination cosegregates with the fertility restorer phenotype for cytoplasmic male sterility in radish

In this work, we have identified a chimeric pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR)-encoding gene cosegregating with the fertility restorer phenotype for cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in radish. We have constructed a CMS-Rf system consisting of sterile line ‘9802A2’, maintainer line ‘9802B2’ and restorer line ‘2007H’. F₂ segregating population analysis indicated that male fertility is restored by a single dominant gene in the CMS-Rf system described above. A PPR gene named Rfoc was found in the restorer line ‘2007H’. It cosegregated with the fertility restorer in the F₂ segregating population which is composed of 613 fertile plants and 187 sterile plants. The Rfoc gene encodes a predicted protein 687 amino acids in length, comprising 16 PPR domains and with a putative mitochondrial targeting signal. Sequence alignment showed that recombination between the 5′ region of Rfob (EU163282) and the 3′ region of PPR24 (AY285675) resulted in Rfoc, indicating a recent unequal crossing-over event between Rfo and PPR24 loci at a distance of 5.5 kb. The sterile line ‘9802A2’ contains the rfob gene. In the F₂ population, Rfoc and rfob were observed to fit a segregation ratio 1:2:1 showing that Rfoc was allelic to Rfo. Previously we have reported that a fertile line ‘2006H’, which carries the recessive rfob gene, is able to restore the male fertility of CMS line ‘9802A1’ (Wang et al. in Theor Appl Genet 117:313–320, 2008). However, here when conducting a cross between the fertile line ‘2006H’ and CMS line ‘9802A2, the resulting plants were male sterile, which shows that sterile line ‘9802A2’ possesses a different nuclear background compared to ‘9802A1’. Based on these results, the genetic model of fertility restoration for radish CMS is also discussed.     

Cytoplasmic male sterility in Vicia faba L.

Summary In many higher plants, nucleo-cytoplasmic interactions lead to pollen abortion. In Vicia faba, cytoplasmic male sterility is unstable as the cytoplasm appears to shift from a sterile to a fertile state. In this report, five flower phenotypes are defined but the study is focussed on the progenies obtained from intermediate, semi-sterile plants with the same homozygous nuclear constitution during five successive generations. The results could be interpreted by quantitative modifications of at least four different kinds of cytoplasmic determinants.     

Inducing male sterility of tomato using two component system

Production of hybrid seeds and pursuing heterosis breeding of many crops have been accomplished using male sterile lines. However, not all crops have valuable male sterile lines due to instability of male sterility and absence of a restorer system. In this study, male sterile lines have been induced using a two-component system. The extracellular ribonuclease Barnase was cleaves into two inactive yet complementary fragments, designated as ??Bn-5?? and ??Bn-3??. Both components were controlled by a TA29 promoter. They were transferred into the tomato inbred line ??Yellow tomato?? by Agrobacterium method. Southern blotting identified that 11 transgenic Bn-5 plants (T₀) and 10 transgenic Bn-3 plants (T₀) were obtained. The vegetative phenotypes of all T₀ plants were similar to wild-type, and they were capable of producing viable pollen grains and normal fruit with seeds, indicating that Barnase had lost its function after it being split two partial fragments. After self-pollination, homozygous progenies (T₁) of transgenic Bn-5 and Bn-3 plants were chosen to cross each other, Barnase could be reconstituted and co-expressed in the same cell, which caused the hybrid plants to produce collapsed pollen grains with no viability and thus100?% male sterile plants were obtained. Stamens of male sterile plants were shorter than those of the wild type plants. PCR detection demonstrated that all male sterile plants contained Barnase, but male fertile plants did not. The male sterile plants were crossed with the male fertile inbred lines, and the result showed that hybrid (F₁) plants were capable of producing normal fruit with seeds, and their pollen grain fertility was restored. The co-segregation ratio of Bn-5 and Bn-3 fragments showed 1:1 among hybrid plants. In conclusion, the results verified that the male sterility could be generated by two component system and be used in hybrid seed production. The F₁ between the male sterile plant and the inbred line showed heterotic comparing to both parents. This system needs not breed restoration line.     

Mitochondrial Respiration Associated with Cytoplasmic Male Sterility in Pearl Millet

Respiratory activities in vegetative tissues and the isolated mitochondria of etiolated seedlings and reproductive tissues were studied in two cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) lines having the same A, cytoplasm with different nuclear backgrounds of pearl millet along with their maintainer, restorer and restored lines. In addition, the assays of cytochrome c oxidase and succinate dehydrogenase were performed in isolated mitochondria. Cyanide-sensitive, cyanide-insensitive and total respirations in vegetative tissues and isolated mitochondria were lower in both the CMS lines than their respective maintainers, restorers and restored hybrids. Except in CMS lines, uptake of 0₂ during anther development increased from premeiotic to postmeiotic stage in all the lines. Consumption of 0₂,however, declined from meiotic to postmeiotic stage in the anthers of CMS lines. Pure mitochondrial preparations were obtained which were 92-94% intact. Enzymes, cytochrome c oxidase (complex IV) and succinate dehydrogenase (complex II) showed lower activities in both the CMS lines than their respective maintainer, restorer and restored hybrids. The CMS lines also displayed lower levels of nuclear encoded enzymes, viz., alternative oxidase and succinate dehydrogenase.     

Identification of RAPD markers linked to a fertility restorer gene for theOgura radish cytoplasmic male sterility of rapeseed (Brassica napus L.)

Bulked segregant analysis was employed to identify random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers linked to the restorer gene (Rfo) used in theOgura radish cytoplasmic male sterility of rapeseed. A total of 138 arbitrary 10-mer oligonucleotide primers were screened on the DNA of three pairs of bulks, each bulk corresponding to homozygous restored and male sterile plants of three segregating populations. Six primers produced repeatable polymorphisms between paired bulks. DNA from individual plants of each bulk was then used as a template for amplification with these six primers. DNA polymorphisms generated by four of these primers were found to be completely linked to the restorer gene with the polymorphic DNA fragments being associated either with the fertility restorer allele or with the sterility maintainer allele. Pairwise cross-hybridization demonstrated that the four polymorphic DNA fragments did not share any homology. Southern hybridization of labelled RAPD fragments on digested genomic DNA from the same three pairs of bulks revealed fragments specific to either the male sterile bulks or to the restored bulks and a few fragments common to all bulks, indicating that the amplified sequences are low copy. The four RAPD fragments that were completely linked to the restorer locus have been cloned and sequenced to develop sequence characterized amplified regions (SCARs). This will facilitate the construction of restorer lines used in breeding programs and is the first step towards map-based cloning of the fertility restorer allele.     

Effect of the herbicide terbutryn on meiosis,yield and mitotic chromosomes in C2 plants ofVicia faba L.

The herbicide terbutryn induced up to 11.3 % chromosomal abnormalities in cells undergoing meiosis inVicia faba. The mean number of pods/plant and the mean number of seeds/pod were considerably reduced, but the average seed dry mass was not or was only slightly affected by this herbicide. In C₂ plants chromosomal abnormalities were observed in few but significant numbers of cells.     

Differential Mitochondrial Electron Transport through the Cyanide-Sensitive and Cyanide-Insensitive Pathways in Isonuclear Lines of Cytoplasmic Male Sterile, Male Fertile, and Restored Petunia

Three pairs of isonuclear lines of cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) and fertile Petunia cells (Petunia hybrida [Hook] Vilm. and Petunia parodii L.S.M.) grown in suspension culture were examined for sensitivity to inhibitors of respiratory electron transport at time-points after transfer into fresh media. Cells from CMS lines differed from cells of fertile lines in their utilization of the cyanide-insensitive oxidase pathway. Under our culture regime, after approximately 3 days of culture cells from the CMS lines exhibited much lower cyanide-insensitive, salicylhydroxamic acid-sensitive respiration than cells from the fertile lines. This respiratory difference was shown to be specific to the mitochondrial alternative oxidase pathway by using other characteristic inhibitors of mitochondrial electron transport in experiments with isolated mitochondria. Immature anthers from CMS plants also showed lower alternative oxidase activity relative to anthers from male fertile plants, but no such difference was detected in leaf tissue, ovary or perianth tissue, or anthers collected just prior to anthesis. A cell line from a fertile plant carrying a nuclear fertility restorer gene and the CMS cytoplasm exhibited increased activity of the alternative pathway compared with the CMS lines.     

Conversion of a rice CMS maintainer into a photo- or thermo-sensitive genetic male sterile line

A maintainer line of 3-line hybrid rice commonly presents a certain genetic distance to a 2-line restorer line, but in many cases, 2-line restorer lines present defects upon recovery of the object cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) line of the maintainer line, which impedes the utilization of their heterosis. Here, we report a strategy and an example of converting a maintainer into a photoperiod/temperature-sensitive genic male sterile (P/TGMS) line with an almost identical genetic background, thus maximizing the heterosis. Firstly, through treatment of maintainer line T98B with ⁶⁰C_O-γ irradiation, we identified the TGMS line T98S, which is sterile at higher temperatures and fertile at lower temperatures. Secondly, the T98S line was proven to be identical to T98B with regard to genetic background via an examination of 48 parental polymorphous SSR markers and exhibited excellent blossom traits similar to those of T98B, with an extensive forenoon flowering rate of 75.92% and a high exertion rate of 64.59%. Thirdly, in a combination test, three out of six hybrids from T98S crossed with 2-line restorer lines showed a yield increase of 6.70–15.69% for 2 consecutive years. These results demonstrated that the strategy can generate a new P/TGMS line with strong general combining ability (converted from a maintainer line), thus helping to increase the genetic diversity of male sterile heterotic groups.     

Molecular mapping of the fertility restorer gene for ms-CW-type cytoplasmic male sterility of rice

Cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) of rice (Oryza sativa L.) was first reported using the cytoplasm of a Chinese wild rice, Oryza rufipogon Griff. strain W1. However, it was not possible to characterize this ms-CW-type CMS in more detail until a restorer line had been developed due to the lack of restorer genes among cultivars thus far tested. The breeding of a restorer line (W1-R) was eventually achieved by transferring the restorer gene(s) of W1 to a cultivar. We report here the characterization of the ms-CW pollen grains and mapping of the restorer gene for ms-CW-type CMS. Pollen grains of the male-sterile plants appeared to be normal and viable based on the fluorochromatic reaction test, but they did not germinate on normal stigmas. The 1:1 segregation of fertile and sterile plants in a BC₁F₁ population from a cross between W1-R and a maintainer line demonstrated that fertility restoration is controlled by a single gene. The fertile seed set of all the F₂ plants examined indicated that the fertility restoration functions gametophytically. We designated the fertility restorer gene Rfcw. Using cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (CAPS) and simple sequence repeat (SSR) markers, we localized Rfcw to chromosome 4 with a genetic distance of 0.6 cM from the nearest SSR marker.     

Instability of s male-sterile cytoplasm in maize

A number of S male-sterile plants from several shrunken-2 inbred lines were crossed initially with an R138-TR inbred line pollinator carrying the nonrestoring genotype for S sterile cytoplasm. One such cross, involving a male-sterile female parent from inbred line M825, produced, unexpectedly, a number of male-fertile F₁ progeny, along with the expected male-sterile off-spring. Pollen records of plants in F₂, F₃ and F₄ progenies in the exceptional pedigree, and of a variety of testcross and backcross progenies from these male-fertile exceptions, indicate that the exceptional male fertility is not attributable to the action of either dominant or recessive nuclear restorer genes. They are, however, consistent with the hypothesis that the event responsible for the appearance of exceptional male-fertile offspring among progeny of the original cross involved a change from male-sterile to male-fertile condition in the cytoplasm of the male-sterile M825 plant involved as the female parent in this cross. It appears that this plant bore an ear in which there was a relatively early mutational event at the cytoplasmic level resulting in a chimera involving some kernels which carried S male-sterile cytoplasm, and others which carried the mutated fertile cytoplasmic condition. The finding of a number of additional ear chimeras supports this contention.—The evidence suggests that the change from sterile to fertile cytoplasm has occurred in a number of other instances. The male-sterile line M825 is especially prone to this change. These findings are of particular interest because it has heretofore been considered that both S and T types of male-sterile cytoplasm are highly stable.—The data presented here are not sufficient to support the notion that the exceptional event involves a qualitative change, analogous to gene mutation, in a cytoplasmic entity governing the expression of male fertility. It is equally plausible that the exceptional male fertility is the result of occasional transfer of normal cytoplasm through the male germ cells of maintainer parents.