Conjugational Recombination in Escherichia Coli: Genetic Analysis of Recombinant Formation in Hfr X F(-) Crosses

The formation of recombinants during conjugation between Hfr and F(-) strains of Escherichia coli was investigated using unselected markers to monitor integration of Hfr DNA into the circular recipient chromosome. In crosses selecting a marker located ~500 kb from the Hfr origin, 60-70% of the recombinants appeared to inherit the Hfr DNA in a single segment, with the proximal exchange located >300 kb from the selected marker. The proportion of recombinants showing multiple exchanges increased in matings selecting more distal markers located 700-2200 kb from the origin, but they were always in the minority. This effect was associated with decreased linkage of unselected proximal markers. Mutation of recB, or recD plus recJ, in the recipient reduced the efficiency of recombination and shifted the location of the proximal exchange (s) closer to the selected marker. Mutation of recF, recO or recQ produced recombinants in which this exchange tended to be closer to the origin, though the effect observed was rather small. Up to 25% of recombinant colonies in rec(+) crosses showed segregation of both donor and recipient alleles at a proximal unselected locus. Their frequency varied with the distance between the selected and unselected markers and was also related directly to the efficiency of recombination. Mutation of recD increased their number by twofold in certain crosses to a value of 19%, a feature associated with an increase in the survival of linear DNA in the absence of RecBCD exonuclease. Mutation of recN reduced sectored recombinants in these crosses to ~1% in all the strains examined, including recD. A model for conjugational recombination is proposed in which recombinant chromosomes are formed initially by two exchanges that integrate a single piece of duplex Hfr DNA into the recipient chromosome. Additional pairs of exchanges involving the excised recipient DNA, RecBCD enzyme and RecN protein, can subsequently modify the initial product to generate the spectrum of recombinants normally observed.     

Gene Transmission Among Strains of Erwinia amylovora

Stable donor strains of Erwinia amylovora were obtained from strain EA178R(1) (harboring an Escherichia coli F'lac) by selection for clones resistant to curing by acridine orange. These donor strains (EA178R(1)-99 and EA178R(1)-111) transfer chromosomal markers (arg, cys, gua, ilv, met, pro, ser, trp); the frequency of the appearance of recombinants prototrophic for Cys, Gua, Met, Ser, and Trp is highest (> 10(-5)), followed by recombinants prototrophic for Arg, Ilv, and Pro (10(-7) to 10(-5)). The results of interrupted matings, as well as the frequency of transmission of various markers, suggest that cys is transferred as an early marker by both donor strains. The Hfr state of these donor strains is rather likely on the basis of the following observations. The donor strains exhibit a relatively efficient and possibly oriented chromosome transfer; the Lac(+) character is not cured by acridine orange in these donor strains; and these donor strains do not transfer F.     

Interaction between colicinogenic factor V and the integrated F factor in an Hfr strain of Escherichia coli

Kahn, Phyllis L. (Princeton University, Princeton, N.J.), and Donald R. Helinski. Interaction between colicinogenic factor V and the integrated F factor in an Hfr strain of Escherichia coli. J. Bacteriol. 90:1276-1282. 1965.-The production of colicin V by strains of Escherichia coli is determined by a colicinogenic factor, colV. The colV factor possesses a genetic determinant of fertility, F(v). V(+)F(v) (+) cells are characteristically susceptible to a male-specific phage, mu, and able to transfer the colV factor and chromosomal markers to recipient cells. The present work describes an interaction of the colV factor with the chromosome of the Hfr strain, HfrH. A colV-containing HfrH strain, designated HfrHV(+)F(v) (+)(l), was isolated and shown to be insensitive to phage mu and impaired in its fertility properties. Loss of the colV factor by this strain, either spontaneous or induced by acridine orange, resulted in a further 10(3)- or 10(4)-fold loss in fertility. This additional loss of fertility was restored by reinfection of these strains with the colV factor. The colV interaction with the HfrH chromosome also can result in defects in the fertility properties of the colV factor. Altered colV factors were found in recombinants isolated from a cross between the HfrHV(+)F(v) (+)(l) strain and F(-) recipients. It is postulated that in the HfrHV(+)F(v) (+)(l) strain an interaction of the colV episome with the integrated F region of the chromosome occurs, with a resulting modification of the fertility properties of the HfrH strain. This interaction can also result in a defect in certain properties of the colV factor.     

Inhibition of Replication of an F′lac Episome in Hfr Cells of Escherichia coli

Hfr strains of Escherichia coli K-12 were found capable of accepting a F'lac episome during mating, with a frequency approximating that of F(-) strains. However, the F'lac episome was unable to replicate in the Hfr cells, and was diluted out during the growth of the culture. The lac(+) gene of the episome can be "rescued" by recombination into the host chromosome, as shown by the appearance of variegated recombinant colonies on a lactose-fermentation indicator medium. In recA Hfr strains, however, no lac(+) offspring were obtained in crosses with F'lac donors. The induced synthesis of beta-galactosidase in F'lac(+) x Hfr zygotes was studied. Rates of enzyme synthesis were approximately constant with respect to time as expected from unilinear inheritance of the F'lac episome. However, the rate of synthesis eventually increased, presumably due to integration of the lac(+) gene in some of the zygotes. In F'lac(+) x recA Hfr zygotes the rate of beta-galactosidase synthesis remained constant with respect to time, as expected.     

Recombinant F′ Factors from Escherichia coli K-12 Strains Carrying recB or recC

The frequency of genetic exchanges between F' factors and the bacterial chromosome was studied in recombination-deficient Escherichia coli mutants under conditions in which the recombinant F' factors were immediately transferred to new hosts. In a series of double matings, F101-1 thr(+)leu(-) episomes were first transferred into each of four intermediate F(-)thr(-)leu(+) strains carrying various rec alleles. After the original F' donors were killed with phage T6, the F101-1 episomes were then transferred from the intermediate cells to F(-)thr(-)leu(-)Str(R)recA(-) females. Recipients of nonrecombinant episomes formed Thr(+) (Str(R)) colonies, and recipients of recombinant episomes formed Leu(+)(Str(R)) colonies. A comparison of the numbers of Leu(+)(Str(R)) and Thr(+)(Str(R)) colonies shows that recB(-) males formed 18 to 21% and recC(-) formed 47 to 60% of the wild-type level of recombinant episomes that could be detected after transfer. No recombinant episomes were detected using a recA(-) intermediate strain. If the intermediate strains harboring the F101 episomes were purified, allowed to grow for 50 generations, and then mated with the recA(-) recipient, recombinant episomes were transferred at 8% of the wild-type level for recB(-) and 13% for recC(-). In contrast, only 0.4 and 0.6% of the normal number of recombinants were obtained from crosses between Hfr Cavalli donors and the same recB(-) and recC(-) strains. Recombinant episomes were detected with greater frequency among newly formed rec(+), recB(-), and recC(-) partial diploids than in those which were 50 generations old.     

Fertility of Salmonella typhimurium Crosses with Escherichia coli

At least one factor that causes low fertility of Salmonella typhimurium LT2 strains in crosses with Escherichia coli K-12 Hfr's can be inhibited by growing the female strains in supplemented minimal salts medium rather than in nutrient broth and by incubating the female strains at 50 C immediately before mating with the Hfr. These pretreatments can enhance the recovery of prototrophic recombinants for markers injected early by the Hfr by a factor of as much as 10(4). The heat treatment is effective only on the female in intergeneric crosses and gradually loses (within 50 min) its effectiveness after return of heat-treated cells to 37 C. It is concluded that the restriction system of the female is heat-sensitive. Since markers injected late by the male enter females in which the heat-impaired restriction system has recovered, few recombinants for late markers are found. The presence of the leading end of an E. coli Hfr in an S. typhimurium-E. coli hybrid enhances by up to sevenfold the frequency of lac(+) recombinants in subsequent crosses with an E. coli Hfr if the E. coli segment is integrated into the chromosome of the hybrid; the effect is less marked if the E. coli segment is not integrated.     

Incompatibility of Integrated Sex Factors in Double Male Strains of ESCHERICHIA COLI

Several strains of Escherichia coli K-12 harboring two F factors were isolated from Hfr x Hfr crosses. These strains were transiently capable of initiating chromosome transfer from two separate points of origin, and of transferring two different sex factors as integrated chromosomal markers. Each strain tested invariably reverted to a simple Hfr by loss of one of the inherited F factors. The F factor persisting in the revertant was, in nearly every case, that which had been inherited from the recipient Hfr parent.     

Linkage distortion following conjugational transfer of sbcC+ to recBC sbcBC strains of Escherichia coli.

Conjugational recombination in Escherichia coli depends normally on RecBCD enzyme, a multifunctional nuclease and DNA helicase produced by the recB, recC, and recD genes. However, recombination can proceed efficiently without RecBCD in recB or recC strains carrying additional mutations in both the sbcB and sbcC genes. Recombination in these strains, sometimes referred to as the RecF pathway, requires gene products that are not essential in the RecBCD-dependent process predominating in the wild type. It has also been reported to produce a different spectrum of recombinant genotypes in crosses with Hfr donors. However, the sbcC+ gene was unknowingly transferred to the recipient strain in some of these crosses, and this may have affected the outcome. This possibility was examined by conducting parallel crosses with Hfr donors that were either wild type or mutant for sbcC. Transfer of sbcC+ from an Hfr donor is shown to alter the frequency of recombinant genotypes recovered. There is a severe reduction in progeny that inherit donor markers linked to the sbcC+ allele and an increase in the incidence of multiple exchanges. Colonies of mixed genotype for one or more of the unselected proximal markers are also much more prevalent. Since the yield of recombinants is lower than normal, these changes are attributed to the reduced viability of recombinants that inherit sbcC+ from the Hfr donor. When the Hfr donor used is also mutant for sbcC, the yield of recombinants is greater and the frequencies of the different genotypes recovered are similar to those obtained in crosses with a rec+ sbc+ recipient, in which transfer of sbcC+ has no apparent effect. Earlier studies are re-examined in light of these findings. It is concluded that, while recombination in recBC sbcBC strains involves different enzymes, the underlying molecular mechanism is essentially the same as that in the wild type.     

Isolation of a hybrid F' factor-carrying Escherichia coli lactose region and Salmonella typhimurium histidine region, F42-400 (F' ts114 lac+, his+): its partial characterization and behavior in Salmonella typhimurium.

Episome F' ts114 lac+ (F42-114) was transferred into Salmonella typhimurium carrying an F'his+ (FS400) episome, and fused episome F' ts114 lac+, his+ (F42-400) was obtained. Episome F42-400 could be transferred to S. typhimurium, Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae. Identification of the episome was based on: (i) temperature sensitivity of the Lac+ and His+ phenotypes; (ii) the fact that F- segregants, obtained after temperature curing or acridine orange curing, were simultaneously Lac- and His-; and (iii) linkage of lac+ with his+ in episomal transfers to E. coli and S. typhimurium. The frequency of episome transfer was influenced by the genotype of the donor. Plasmid LT2, prevalent in S. typhimurium LT2 strains, was suggested to be responsible for the low fertility of S. typhimurium donors. Episome F42-400 was capable of chromosome mobilization, and the extent of chromosome mobilization was not influenced by the presence or absence of the histidine region on the donor chromosome. Growth in a defined medium with acridine orange was able to cure F42-400. The frequency of curing was increased (the frequency of His+ cells was 0.0001%) if the cells were grown at 40 C in the presence of acridine orange. Selection for temperature-resistant Lac+, His+ derivatives in a strain without histidine deletion yielded Hfr strains. However, similar and stronger selections in strains without the chromosomal histidine region failed to yield Hfr strains. Our inability to obtain Hfr's in strains without the chromosomal histidine region was explained by assuming that the episome F42-400 has lost the F sites involved in integration into the S. typhimurium chromosome.     

Interaction (integration and excision) of the pRP19.6 plasmid, a derivative of the RP1 plasmid containing duplicated sequence IS21, with the chromosome of Escherichia coli K12

A pRP19.6 plasmid is the derivative of the temperature sensitive RPlts12 plasmid and contains a duplicated IS21 (IS8) element. Using temperature sensitive pRP19.6 replication, Hfr strains have been obtained by integration of the plasmid into the chromosome of E. coli rec+ and recA- cells and their properties were studied. According to the results obtained, pRP19.6 insertion into the genome of the rec+ bacteria IS reversible, and its integration into the chromosome of the recA- bacteria produced the stable Hfr strains. To elucidate the mechanism of pRP19.6 excision from the bacterial chromosome, plasmids of R+ transconjugates generated with a low frequency in the crosses between the stable Hfr strains and the rec+ recipients were analyzed. It was shown that the stable Hfr clones might produce stable R1 plasmids as well as a family of deletion KmsTra- derivatives of the pRP19.6. The structure of the KmsTra- was investigated and the mechanism of their formation was proposed. In the light of the data obtained, prospects of pRP19.6 practical application are discussed.     

Effect of Rec− Mutations on the Activity of Colicinogenic Factors

The effect of two Rec(-) mutations (AB2463 and JC1553) on the ability of a cell to accept, maintain, and express the colicinogenic factors ColE(1), ColE(2), and ColV was examined in Escherichia coli. These mutations had no observable effect on the colicinogenic properties of the ColV factor, but prevented the spontaneous and induced production of colicins E(1) and E(2) which are determined by the ColE(1) and ColE(2) factors, respectively. The two Rec(-) mutations had no apparent effect on the ability of the cells to acquire, maintain, or transfer the ColE(1) and ColE(2) factors. These mutations did not affect the expression of immunity by any of the three Col factors. ColE(1) and ColE(2) were also shown to be indirectly induced by mating F(-) cells carrying these Col factors with ultraviolet-irradiated, non-colicinogenic, Hfr and F(+) cells. Indirect induction of colicin production occurred when either an irradiated F(+) Rec(+) or F(+) Rec(-) strain was employed as the donor strain.     

Mutation of recF, recJ, recO, recQ, or recR improves Hfr recombination in resolvase-deficient ruv recG strains of Escherichia coli.

The formation of recombinants in Hfr crosses was studied in Escherichia coli strains carrying combinations of genes known to affect recombination and DNA repair. Mutations in ruv and recG eliminate activities that have been shown to process Holliday junction intermediates by nuclease cleavage and/or branch migration. Strains carrying null mutations in both ruv and recG produce few recombinants in Hfr crosses and are extremely sensitive to UV light. The introduction of additional mutations in recF, recJ, recO, recQ, or recR is shown to increase the yield of recombinants by 6- to 20-fold via a mechanism that depends on recBC. The products of these genes have been linked with the initiation of recombination. We propose that mutation of recF, recJ, recO, recQ, or recR redirects recombination to events initiated by the RecBCD enzyme. The strains constructed were also tested for sensitivity to UV light. Addition of recF, recJ, recN, recO, recQ, or recR mutations had no effect on the survival of ruv recG strains. The implications of these findings are discussed in relation to molecular models for recombination and DNA repair that invoke different roles for the branch migration activities of the RuvAB and RecG proteins.     

The effect of a drug-resistance factor on recombination and repair of DNA in Escherichia coli K12.

The presence in recipient strains of Escherichia coli K12 of the plasmid R46 greatly reduced the yield of recombinants from crosses with several Hfr strains and virtually abolished the formation of recombinants by PI transduction without, however, significantly affecting the transfer of the F prime from a strain carrying Fgal. The R46 plasmid had paradoxical effects on mutability: it appeared to enhance the yield of mutants following irradiation with ultraviolet ligh but it reduced the number of mutants detectable in unirradiated cultures. The effects of this plasmid on ultraviolet survival of the wild type and several mutants defective for recombination and repair have been measured and the results, in the main, confirm similar observation by Tweats et al. (1976). Not only is the survival of the strain habouring R46 greater than that of the parent strain in all the cases studied, but the survival of ultraviolet irradiated bacteriophage lambda is also greater.     

Genetic exchange between Escherichia coli strains in the mouse intestine

Germ-free mice contaminated with selected Escherichia coli strains were used for experiments designed to demonstrate gene transfer and recombinant formation in vivo. The well-characterized conjugation system of E. coli K-12 was examined in these experiments. Contamination of germ-free mice with a polyauxotrophic F(-) strain followed by the addition of isogenic Hfr, F', or F(+) strains resulted in the appearance of all recombinant classes at frequencies that would be expected from an in vitro mating experiment. Inheritance of unselected donor markers occurred at frequencies that were dependent on linkage relationships established in experiments in vitro. The presence of Lactobacillus had no influence on gene transfer and recombinant formation in an F' x F(-) in vivo mating. The R factor ROR-1 was transferred from E. coli strain M7-18 to an E. coli F(-) strain in the mouse intestine.     

Structure of Recombinants from Conjugational Crosses between Escherichia Coli Donor and Mismatch-Repair Deficient Salmonella Typhimurium Recipients

To get more insight into the control of homologous recombination between diverged DNA by the Mut proteins of the long-patch mismatch repair system, we have studied interspecies Escherichia coli/Salmonella typhimurium recombination. Knowing that the same recombination pathway (RecABCD) is responsible for intraspecies and interspecies recombination, we have now studied the structure (replacement vs. addition-type or other rearrangement-type recombinants) of 81 interspecies recombinants obtained in conjugational crosses between E. coli donor and mutL, mutS, mutH, mutU or mut(+) S. typhimurium recipients. Taking advantage of high interspecies sequence divergence, a physical analysis was performed on one third of the E. coli Hfr genome, which was expected to be transferred to S. typhimurium F(-) recipients during 40 min before interruption of the mating. Probes specific for each species were hybridized on dot blots of genomic DNA, or on colonies, and the composition of the rrn operons was determined from purified genomic DNA. With very few exceptions, the structure of these interspecies recombinants corresponds to replacements of one continuous block of the recipient genome by the corresponding region of the donor genome.     

Plasmid control of recombination in E. coli K 12

Summary The recombination proficiency of three recipient strains of Escherichia coli K 12 carrying different plasmids was investigated by conjugal mating with Hfr Cavalli. Some plasmids (e.g. R1drd 19, R6K) caused a marked reduction in the yield of recombinants formed in crosses with Hfr but did not reduce the ability of host strains to accept plasmid F104. The effect of plasmids on recombination was host-dependent. In Hfr crosses with AB1157 (R1-19) used as a recipient the linkage between selected and unselected proximal markers of the donor was sharply decreased. Plasmid R1-19 also decreased the yield of recombinants formed by recF, recL, and recB recC sbcA mutants, showed no effect on the recombination proficiency of recB recC sbcB mutant, and increased the recombination proficiency of recB, recB recC sbcB recF, and recB recC sbcB recL mutants. An ATP-dependent exonuclease activity was found in all tested recB recC mutants carrying plasmid R1-19, while this plasmid did not affect the activity of exonuclease I in strain AB1157 and its rec ^– derivatives. The same plasmid was also found to protect different rec ^– derivatives of the strain AB1157 against the lethal action of UV light. We suppose that a new ATP-dependent exonuclease determined by R1-19 plays a role in both repair and recombination of the host through the substitution of or competition with the exoV coded for by the genes recB and recC.     

Enhancement of the viability of irradiated bacteria by chromosome transfer

The effect of x-irradiating recipient cells of Escherichia coli K-12 before mating on the formation of recombinants and on the distribution of parental genetic material among recombinants was investigated in both the wild-type (Rec+) and a recombination-deficient (Rec-) mutant. In crosses involving Rec- recipients, recombinants selected for a late donor marker were formed in almost normal numbers. Rec- cells exposed to otherwise lethal doses of x-rays were still able to form viable recombinants for a distal male marker. These recombinants had inherited almost all the transferred donor chromosome, as evidenced by the preponderance of male markers in the recombinants. In contrast, the recombinant-forming ability was about as x-ray-sensitive as the colony-forming ability in Rec+ cells. No preference for donor chromosomal material was observed in recombinants from crosses involving x-irradiated Rec+ cells.     

Spontaneous Lethal Sectoring, a Further Feature of Escherichia coli Strains Deficient in the Function of rec and uvr Genes

Eight recombination-deficient (Rec(-)) mutants of Escherichia coli were studied. Progeny lines were obtained on solid media, by means of micromanipulation, and the colony-forming ability of individual cells was analyzed. Cells of all eight strains gave rise to colony-forming as well as non-colony-forming descendants ("lethal sectoring"). Lethal sectors, i.e., groups of non-colony-forming cells which originate from a common ancestor, appeared with frequencies per generation ranging between 4 and 20% in Rec(-) strains, whereas lethal sectors were rare in Rec(+) strains (less than 1%). A strain carrying a mutation (uvrA6) in one of the genes involved in pyrimidine dimer excision from deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) showed twice as many lethal sectors per generation as a strain with the genotype uvrA(+). Similarly, a double mutant (AB2480, uvrA6, recA13) showed twice as much spontaneous lethal sectoring as the corresponding Rec(-) strain (uvrA(+), recA13). The kinetics of growth curves obtained in nutrient broth and the frequency of non-colony-forming units in stationary-phase broth cultures indicate clearly that lethal sectors occur in liquid cultures too. The causes for spontaneous lethal sectoring are unknown at present. It seems reasonable to assume that gene uvrA and the rec genes are somehow involved in the repair of spontaneously occurring DNA lesions, since a deficiency in this type of repair may cause lethal sectors. The extent to which spontaneous lethal sectoring (observed in all Rec(-) strains of E. coli studied) may contribute indirectly to the failure to form recombinants is discussed.     

Spontaneous emergence of an Hfr strain with a cit plasmid from natural isolates of citrate-positive Escherichia coli bovine origin.

From citrate-utilizing (Cit+) Escherichia coli strain C53 of bovine origin, strains C53A and C53B were obtained. Upon mating with recA+ but not with recA mutant recipients of K-12, C53A produced chromosomal recombinants at quite high frequencies, leading to the following conclusions: (i) C53A is an Hfr strain; (ii) the site of integration of the Cit plasmid (IncH1) is between metA (89 min) and ara (1 min); (iii) the direction of chromosome transfer is clockwise; and (iv) the plasmid-associated determinants are transferred as the terminal markers. A transductant of a dnaA(Ts) strain, CRT46, which acquired Cit determinants from a recombinant, SG13, was also an Hfr strain similar to SG13, and thermoresistant due to suppressive integration. On the other hand, unstable C53B did not produce recombinants, but the frequency of RecA-independent transfer of the Cit plasmid was high, indicating that the Cit plasmid (IncH1) exists autonomously in C53B. Attempts to isolate an Hfr strain from C53B failed.     

Mapping nonselectable genes of Escherichia coli by using transposon Tn10: location of a gene affecting pyruvate oxidase.

Mutants of Escherichia coli K-12 deficient in pyruvate oxidase were isolated by screening for the production of 14CO2 from [1-14C]pyruvate by the method of Tabor et al. (J. Bacteriol. 128:485-486, 1976). One of these lesions (designated poxA) decreased the pyruvate oxidase activity to 10 to 15% of the normal level but grew well. To map this nonselectable mutation, we isolated strains having transposon Tn10 inserted into the chromosome close to the poxA locus and mapped the transposon. These insertions were isolated by the following procedure: (i) pools of Tn10 insertions into the chromosomes of two different Hfr strains were prepared by transposition from a lambda::Tn10 vector; (ii) these Tn10-carrying strains were then mated with a poxA recipient strain, and tetracycline-resistant (Tetr) recombinants were selected; (iii) the Tetr recombinants were then screened for 14CO2 production from [1-14C]pyruvate. This method was shown to give a greater than 40-fold enrichment of insertions of Tn10 near the poxA gene as compared with transduction. Calculations indicate that a similar enrichment should be expected for other genes. The enrichment is due to the much greater map interval over which strong linkage between selected and unselected markers is found in conjugational crosses as compared with transductional crosses. The use of Hfr conjugative transfer allows isolation of transposon insertions closely linked to a nonselectable gene by scoring hundreds rather than thousands of colonies. Using a Tn10 insertion greater than 98% cotransduced with the poxA locus, we mapped the poxA gene on the E. coli genetic map. The poxA locus is located at 94 min, close to the psd locus. The clockwise gene order is ampA, poxA, psd, purA. The poxA mutation is recessive and appears to be a regulatory gene.