Hormonally mediated epigenetic changes to steroid receptors in the developing brain: Implications for sexual differentiation

The establishment of sex-specific neural morphology, which underlies sex-specific behaviors, occurs during a perinatal sensitive window in which brief exposure to gonadal steroid hormones produces permanent masculinization of the brain. In the rodent, estradiol derived from testicular androgens is a principal organizational hormone. The mechanism by which transient estradiol exposure induces permanent differences in neuronal anatomy has been widely investigated, but remains elusive. Epigenetic changes, such as DNA methylation, allow environmental influences to alter long-term gene expression patterns and therefore may be a potential mediator of estradiol-induced organization of the neonatal brain. Here we review data that demonstrate sex and estradiol-induced differences in DNA methylation on the estrogen receptor α (ERα), estrogen receptor β (ERβ), and progesterone receptor (PR) promoters in sexually dimorphic brain regions across development. Contrary to the overarching view of DNA methylation as a permanent modification directly tied to gene expression, these data demonstrate that methylation patterns on steroid hormone receptors change across the life span and do not necessarily predict expression. Although further exploration into the mechanism and significance of estradiol-induced alterations in DNA methylation patterns in the neonatal brain is necessary, these results provide preliminary evidence that epigenetic alterations can occur in response to early hormone exposure and may mediate estradiol-induced organization of sex differences in the neonatal brain.     

Inhibition of DNA Methylation in the Developing Rat Brain Disrupts Sexually Dimorphic Neurobehavioral Phenotypes in Adulthood

Accumulating evidence indicates a critical implication of DNA methylation in the brain development. We aim to determine whether the disruption of DNA methylation patterns in the developing brain adversely affects neurobehavioral phenotypes later in life in a sex-dependent manner. 5-Aza-2′-deoxycytidine (5-Aza), a DNA methylation inhibitor, was administered in newborn rats from postnatal day 1 to 3. Neurobehavioral outcomes were analyzed at 3 months of age. 5-Aza treatment significantly inhibited DNA methyltransferase activity and decreased global DNA methylation levels in neonatal rat brains, resulting in asymmetric growth restriction with the increased brain to body weight ratio in both male and female rats at 14 days and 3 months of age. Compared with the saline control, 5-Aza treatment significantly improved performance of male rats on the rotarod test, and 5-Aza-treated female rats demonstrated less anxiety, less depression-like behaviors, and enhanced spatial learning performance. Of importance, neonatal 5-Aza treatment eliminated the sexually dimorphic differences in several neurobehavioral tests in adult rats. In addition, 5-Aza treatment decreased promoter methylation of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) gene and significantly increased BDNF mRNA and protein abundance in the prefrontal cortex and hippocampus of female rats in a sex-dependent manner. Thus, brain DNA methylation appears to be essential for sexual differentiations of the brain and neurobehavioral functions. Inhibition of DNA methylation in the developing brain of early life induces aberrant neurobehavioral profiles and disrupts sexually dimorphic neurobehavioral phenotypes in adulthood, of which altered BDNF signaling pathway may be an important mediator.     

Hormonal control of behaviour: steroid action in the brain

There have recently been significant advances in our understanding of the cellular action of steroids on brain mechanisms of behaviour. Brain cells contain steroid metabolizing enzymes whose activity is modified by environmental stimuli. Steroids have rapid effects on neurotransmitter receptors via cell membranes and modify the distribution of neuropeptide receptors in areas controlling behaviour. It has been known for some time that oestrogens have an effect on brain structure that can be related to behaviour in the sexually dimorphic avian song system. Recent work suggests that oestrogen may have a similar effect on the developing sexually dimorphic nuclei of the mammalian brain.     

Intracerebral Sex Differences in the Vasotocin System in Birds: Possible Implication in Behavioral and Autonomic Functions

The brain vasotocinergic system demonstrates clear sexual dimorphism in birds investigated so far. This paper examines the evidence obtained in studies on gallinaceous (domestic fowl, Japanese quail) and passerine (canary, junco, zebra finch) birds. Vasotocin (VT)-immunoreactive parvocellular neurons are present in the nucleus of stria terminalis of males, but they are less abundant or absent in the corresponding structure of females. A similar difference has been observed in the dorsal paraventricular area of domestic fowl. Sex-related differences in VT-gene expression have been confirmed byin situhybridization. Moreover, overall brain content of VT mRNA in cockerels is about twice that of hens, suggesting that VT synthesis may also be sexually dimorphic in other brain areas where morphological sex differences have not yet been revealed. The vasotocinergic system in birds is implicated in body fluid homeostasis, and during ontogeny it starts to respond to osmotic challenges in a sexually dimorphic way. Photoperiod, aging, or castration—all associated with changes in circulating testosterone levels—affect sexually dimorphic VT pathways and cell clusters. Sexually dimorphic vasotocinergic circuits are distributed in regions containing steroid-concentrating cells and are closely intermingled with aromatase-containing neurons that may mediate activational effects of gonadal steroids on this peptidergic system. However, it remains undetermined whether the observed neuroanatomical sex differences are related to sexually dimorphic autonomic and behavioral effects induced by VT. Most likely, VT in birds has a modulatory rather than a specific regulatory function in control of male sexual behavior and vocalization.     

Leagues of their own: sexually dimorphic features of meiotic prophase I

Meiosis is a conserved cell division process that is used by sexually reproducing organisms to generate haploid gametes. Males and females produce different end products of meiosis: eggs (females) and sperm (males). In addition, these unique end products demonstrate sex-specific differences that occur throughout meiosis to produce the final genetic material that is packaged into distinct gametes with unique extracellular morphologies and nuclear sizes. These sexually dimorphic features of meiosis include the meiotic chromosome architecture, in which both the lengths of the chromosomes and the requirement for specific meiotic axis proteins being different between the sexes. Moreover, these changes likely cause sex-specific changes in the recombination landscape with the sex that has the longer chromosomes usually obtaining more crossovers. Additionally, epigenetic regulation of meiosis may contribute to sexually dimorphic recombination landscapes. Here we explore the sexually dimorphic features of both the chromosome axis and crossing over for each stage of meiotic prophase I in Mus musculus, Caenorhabditis elegans, and Arabidopsis thaliana. Furthermore, we consider how sex-specific changes in the meiotic chromosome axes and the epigenetic landscape may function together to regulate crossing over in each sex, indicating that the mechanisms controlling crossing over may be different in oogenesis and spermatogenesis.

     

Sexual dimorphism of rat liver nuclear proteins: regulatory role of growth hormone

Many genes are expressed in mammalian liver in a sexually dimorphic manner. DNA microarray analysis has shown that growth hormone (GH) and its sex-dependent pattern of pituitary secretion play a major role in establishing the sexually dimorphic patterns of liver gene expression. However, GH may exert effects on protein post-translational modification and nuclear localization that are not reflected at the mRNA level. To investigate these potential effects of GH, we used two-dimensional gel electrophoresis followed by LC-MS/MS to: 1) identify rat liver nuclear proteins whose abundance or state of post-translational modification displays sex-dependent differences; and 2) determine the role of the plasma GH profile in establishing these differences. Nuclear extracts prepared from livers of individual male (n=9) and female (n=5) adult rats, and from males given GH by continuous infusion for 7 days to feminize liver gene expression (n=5 rats), were resolved by two-dimensional electrophoresis. Image analysis of SYPRO Ruby-stained gels revealed 165 sexually dimorphic protein spots that differ in normalized volume between male and female groups by >1.5-fold at p<0.05. Sixty of these proteins exhibited female-like changes in spot abundance following continuous GH treatment. Comparison of male and GH-treated male groups revealed 130 proteins that displayed >1.5-fold differences in abundance, with 60 of these GH-responsive spots being sexually dimorphic. Thus, GH plays an important role in establishing the sex-dependent differences in liver nuclear protein content. Twenty-eight of the sexually dimorphic and/or GH-regulated protein spots were identified by LC-MS/MS. Proteins identified include regucalcin, nuclear factor 45, and heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoproteins A3, D-like, and K, in addition to proteins such as GST, normally associated with cytosolic extracts but also reported to be localized in the nucleus.     

Post-translational histone modifications and their interaction with sex influence normal brain development and elaboration of neuropsychiatric disorders

Sex differences in the risk for and expression of various brain disorders have been known for some time. Yet, the molecular underpinnings of these sex differences as well as how sex modifies normal brain development are still poorly understood. It has recently become known that epigenetic mechanisms play an essential role in establishing and maintaining sex differences in neurodevelopment and disease susceptibility. Epigenetic mechanisms such as post-translational modifications of histones (histone PTMs) integrate various hormonal and external environmental influences to affect genomic output, and this appears to occur in a sex-dependent manner. The present review aims to highlight current understanding of the role of histone PTMs in the sexual differentiation of the brain under normal conditions and how sex-specific modulation of histone PTMs may be involved in psychiatric conditions including autism spectrum disorder (ASD), schizophrenia, and major depressive disorder (MDD). The role of sex chromosome genes as sex-specific histone modifiers and their importance in sexually differentiating the brain will be discussed. Further, the contribution of sex-specific histone PTM marks in the placenta in programming the sexually dimorphic developmental course of the brain and susceptibility to diseases/disorders will be reviewed. Prenatal programming may have a long-lasting effect on the adult brain and behavior but due to the interaction of histone PTMs and its modifiers with fluctuating hormone levels and external influences over the lifespan, the process remains dynamic. Although a few studies indicate an association between sex and histone PTM-related mechanisms in ASD, schizophrenia, and MDD, more research is needed to fully appreciate the interactive effects of histone PTMs and sex in the development and manifestation of these disorders. Understanding the interactions between sex and histone PTMs will advance our understanding of psychiatric disorders and potentially guide development of future treatments tailored specifically to each sex.     

Sex chromosomes and brain gender

In birds and mammals, differences in development between the sexes arise from the differential actions of genes that are encoded on the sex chromosomes. These genes are differentially represented in the cells of males and females, and have been selected for sex-specific roles. The brain is a sexually dimorphic organ and is also shaped by sex-specific selection pressures. Genes on the sex chromosomes probably determine the gender (sexually dimorphic phenotype) of the brain in two ways: by acting on the gonads to induce sex differences in levels of gonadal secretions that have sex-specific effects on the brain, and by acting in the brain itself to differentiate XX and XY brain cells.     

Sperm competition and sexually size dimorphic brains in birds

Natural selection may favour sexually similar brain size owing to similar selection pressures in males and females, while sexual selection may lead to sexually dimorphic brains. For example, sperm competition involves clear-cut sex differences in behaviour, as males display, mate guard and copulate with females, while females choose among males, and solicit or reject copulations. These behaviours may require fundamentally different neural government in the two sexes leading to sex-dependent brain evolution. Using two phylogenetic approaches in a comparative study, we tested for roles of both natural and sexual-selection pressures on brain size evolution of birds. In accordance with the natural-selection theory, relative brain size of males coevolved with that of females, which may be the result of adaptation to similar environmental constraints such as feeding innovation. However, the mode of brain size evolution differed between the sexes, and factors associated with sperm competition as reflected by extra-pair paternity may give rise to sexually size dimorphic brains. Specifically, species in which females have larger brains than males were found to have a higher degree of extra-pair paternity independently of potentially confounding factors, whereas species in which males have relatively larger brains than females appeared to have lower rates of extra-pair paternity. Hence, the evolution of sperm competition may select for complex behaviours together with the associated neural substrates in the sex that has a higher potential to control extra-pair copulations at the observed levels. Brain function may thus be affected differently in males and females by sexual selection.     

Mercury‐associated DNA hypomethylation in polar bear brains via the LUminometric Methylation Assay: a sensitive method to study epigenetics in wildlife

In this paper we describe a novel approach that may shed light on the genomic DNA methylation of organisms with non‐resolved genomes. The LUminometric Methylation Assay (LUMA) is permissive for genomic DNA methylation studies of any genome as it relies on the use of methyl‐sensitive and ‐insensitive restriction enzymes followed by polymerase extension via Pyrosequencing technology. Here, LUMA was used to characterize genomic DNA methylation in the lower brain stem region from 47 polar bears subsistence hunted in central East Greenland between 1999 and 2001. In these samples, average genomic DNA methylation was 57.9% ± 6.69 (SD; range was 42.0 to 72.4%). When genomic DNA methylation was related to brain mercury (Hg) exposure levels, an inverse association was seen between these two variables for the entire study population (P for trend = 0.17). After dichotomizing animals by gender and controlling for age, a negative trend was seen amongst male animals (P for trend = 0.07) but no associations were found in female bears. Such sexually dimorphic responses have been found in other toxicological studies. Our results show that genomic DNA methylation can be quantitatively studied in a highly reproducible manner in tissue samples from a wild organism with a non‐resolved genome. As such, LUMA holds great promise as a novel method to explore consequential questions across the ecological sciences that may require an epigenetic understanding.     

Gonadal hormones and sex differences in nonreproductive behaviors in rodents: organizational and activational influences

Sex differences in many nonreproductive behaviors have been described in rodents. Among the behaviors that are sexually dimorphic in the rat are activity, aggression, pain, and taste sensitivity, food intake and body weight regulation, the learning and retention of certain kinds of mazes, avoidance responses, taste aversion, and performance on certain schedules of reinforcement. Gonadal hormones seem to be responsible, in part, for sex differences in these behaviors, but their contribution varies greatly with the behavior in question. Frequently, these sexually dimorphic behaviors are influenced both by organizational and activational actions of sex hormones. In other instances (e.g., maze learning and the acquisition of shuttle-box avoidance responses) organizational influences predominate. And while there is no sexually dimorphic behavior surveyed that can be shown to be influenced only by activational effects, wheel-running activity is clearly more strongly subject to activational than to organizational effects of the gonadal hormones. In general, only rudimentary information exists regarding the temporal limits of the period in development when organizational influences on nonsexual behaviors occur. The suggestion can be made that organizational influences often occur outside of the critical period for differentiation of the neuroendocrine system regulating cyclic release of gonadotrophins. Even for behaviors where organizational effects usually occur during a roughly delimited period of development, data for other behavioral systems suggest that the time limits during which organizational effects can occur are not rigidly fixed. Very little information exists regarding biochemical or neural mechanisms by which organizational or activational effects on sexually dimorphic nonreproductive behaviors are expressed. It is important to recognize for many of the sexually dimorphic behaviors in the rat that differences between the sexes are neither large nor absolute. This is especially true of several kinds of learning situations where groups of males and females typically differ in average levels of performance. Ostensibly minor variations in test procedure can abolish or accentuate the average difference in performance between the sexes. We are a long way from an adequate understanding of what factors are important, but such information could be quite helpful in estimating whether sex differences in certain laboratory learning tasks have any adaptive significance.Sex differences in nonreproductive behaviors may be influenced by many factors other than hormonal status. This greatly complicates a comparative analysis, but such an analysis will ultimately be necessary. What limited data exist on rodents suggest that: (1) Sexually dimorphic responses in the rat are often not similarly differentiated in the hamster, the gerbil, or the mouse; and (2) major differences exist among rodent species in hormonal effects on such responses.Over the last decade it has become clear that the behavioral effects of deliberate neurological insult are not necessarily the same in male and female rats (or in one case, in rhesus monkeys). Sex differences in the behavioral effects of ventromedial hypothalamic, lateral hypothalamic, septal, and striatal lesions in the rat and of orbital prefrontal cortex lesions in the monkey have been described. While information regarding hormonal modulation of these differences in response to brain damage is very limited, available data suggest both organizational and activational effects of sex hormones may be involved. It is too early to tell where this line of research may ultimately lead, but rather striking sex differences in the incidence of certain neurological disorders in humans suggest that further research may have both practical and theoretical significance.     

Patterns of coordinated anatomical change in human cortical development: a longitudinal neuroimaging study of maturational coupling

Understanding of human structural brain development has rapidly advanced in recent years, but remains fundamentally "localizational" in nature. Here, we use 376 longitudinally acquired structural brain scans from 108 typically developing adolescents to conduct the first study of coordinated anatomical change within the developing cortex. Correlation in rates of anatomical change was regionally heterogeneous, with fronto-temporal association cortices showing the strongest and most widespread maturational coupling with other cortical areas, and lower-order sensory cortices showing the least. Canonical cortical systems with rich structural and functional interconnectivity showed significantly elevated maturational coupling. Evidence for sexually dimorphic maturational coupling was found within a frontopolar-centered prefrontal system involved in complex decision-making. By providing the first link between cortical connectivity and the coordination of cortical development, we reveal a hitherto unseen property of healthy brain maturation, which may represent a target for neurodevelopmental disease processes, and a substrate for sexually dimorphic behavior in adolescence.     

Role of cell death in the formation of sexual dimorphism in the Drosophila central nervous system

Currently, sex differences in behavior are believed to result from sexually dimorphic neural circuits in the central nervous system (CNS). Drosophila melanogaster is a common model organism for studying the relationship between brain structure, behavior, and genes. Recent studies of sex‐specific reproductive behaviors in D. melanogaster have addressed the contribution of sexual differences in the CNS to the control of sex‐specific behaviors and the development of sexual dimorphism. For example, sexually dimorphic regions of the CNS are involved in the initiation of male courtship behavior, the generation of the courtship song, and the induction of male‐specific muscles in D. melanogaster. In this review, I discuss recent findings about the contribution of cell death to the formation of sexually dimorphic neural circuitry and the regulation of sex‐specific cell death by two sex determination factors, Fruitless and Doublesex, in Drosophila.     

Sex differences in androgen-regulated expression of cytochrome P450 aromatase in the rat brain

The basis of functional gender differences in adult responsiveness to testosterone (T) is not yet understood. Conversion of T to estradiol by cytochrome P450 aromatase in the medial preoptic area is required for the full expression of male sexual behavior in rats. High levels of aromatase are found in the medial preoptic nucleus (MPN) and in an interconnected group of sexually dimorphic nuclei which mediate masculine sexual behavior. Within this neural circuit, aromatase is regulated by T, acting through an androgen receptor (AR)-mediated mechanism. This arrangement constitutes a feedforward system because T is both the regulator and the major substrate of aromatase. Preoptic aromatase is thus more active in adult males than in females because of normal sex differences in circulating androgen levels. However, the mechanism of enzyme induction also appears to be sexually dimorphic because equivalent physiological doses of T stimulate aromatase to a greater extent in males than in females. Dose-response studies indicate that the sex difference is apparent over a range of circulating T concentrations and constitute a gender difference in T efficacy, but not potency. Sex differences in aromatase correlate with sex differences in nuclear AR concentrations in most regions of the sexually dimorphic neural circuit, but not in MPN. These results suggest that males may have larger populations of target cells in which aromatase is regulated by androgen, but the lack of a gender difference in AR levels in the MPN suggests that differences in post-receptor mechanisms could also be involved. Measurements of aromatase mRNA in androgen-treated gonadectomized rats demonstrate that sex difference in regulation is exerted pretranslationally. Taken together these results demonstrate a sexually dimorphic mechanism that could potentially limit the action of T in females, and may relate to the enhanced expression of T-stimulated sexual behaviors in males.