How cells deploy ubiquitin and autophagy to defend their cytosol from bacterial invasion

Autophagy serves as a cell-autonomous effector mechanism of innate immunity in the cytosol. Autophagy restricts bacterial proliferation by separating bacteria from the nutrient-rich cytosol and delivering them into bactericidal autolysosomes. Autophagy also restricts inflammation by enclosing the membrane remnants of vacuoles from which bacteria have escaped. In contrast to starvation-induced autophagy, which engulfs cytosol nonspecifically, antibacterial autophagy is receptor-mediated and selective. Several distinct pathways of antibacterial autophagy have been identified recently, which can be triggered by either bacterial PAMPs, host-mediated modifications of bacteria-containing vacuoles, or cytosolic bacteria that have become decorated with ubiquitin. Ubiquitin-coated bacteria are sensed by p62, a promiscuous autophagy receptor required for the uptake of a variety of ubiquitin-marked autophagy substrates, and by NDP52, an autophagy receptor that, by associating with the immunoregulatory kinase TBK1, may serve a dedicated function in cytosolic immunity.     

NDP52, a novel autophagy receptor for ubiquitin-decorated cytosolic bacteria

Autophagy functions as a cell-autonomous effector mechanism of innate immunity by separating bacteria from cytosolic resources and delivering them for lysosomal destruction. How cytosolic bacteria are targeted for autophagy is incompletely understood. We recently discovered that Salmonella enterica serotype Typhimurium and Streptococcus pyogenes are detected by NDP52 (nuclear dot protein 52kDa), after these bacteria enter the cytosol of human cells and become decorated with poly-ubiquitinated proteins. NDP52 binds the bacterial ubiquitin coat as well as ATG8/LC3 and delivers cytosolic bacteria into autophagosomes. In the absence of NDP52 ubiquitin-coated bacteria accumulate outside ATG8/LC3⁺ autophagosomes. Cells lacking NDP52 fail to restrict bacterial proliferation, as do cells depleted of TBK1, an IKK family kinase colocalizing with NDP52 at the bacterial surface. Our findings demonstrate the existence of a receptor for the selective autophagy of cytosolic bacteria, suggesting that cells are able to differentiate between anti-bacterial and other forms of autophagy.     

Autophagy controls Salmonella infection in response to damage to the Salmonella-containing vacuole

Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. Typhimurium) is a facultative intracellular pathogen that causes disease in a variety of hosts. S. Typhimurium actively invade host cells and typically reside within a membrane-bound compartment called the Salmonella-containing vacuole (SCV). The bacteria modify the fate of the SCV using two independent type III secretion systems (TTSS). TTSS are known to damage eukaryotic cell membranes and S. Typhimurium has been suggested to damage the SCV using its Salmonella pathogenicity island (SPI)-1 encoded TTSS. Here we show that this damage gives rise to an intracellular bacterial population targeted by the autophagy system during in vitro infection. Approximately 20% of intracellular S. Typhimurium colocalized with the autophagy marker GFP-LC3 at 1 h postinfection. Autophagy of S. Typhimurium was dependent upon the SPI-1 TTSS and bacterial protein synthesis. Bacteria targeted by the autophagy system were often associated with ubiquitinated proteins, indicating their exposure to the cytosol. Surprisingly, these bacteria also colocalized with SCV markers. Autophagy-deficient (atg5-/-) cells were more permissive for intracellular growth by S. Typhimurium than normal cells, allowing increased bacterial growth in the cytosol. We propose a model in which the host autophagy system targets bacteria in SCVs damaged by the SPI-1 TTSS. This serves to retain intracellular S. Typhimurium within vacuoles early after infection to protect the cytosol from bacterial colonization. Our findings support a role for autophagy in innate immunity and demonstrate that Salmonella infection is a powerful model to study the autophagy process.     

Avoiding death by autophagy: Interactions of Listeria monocytogenes with the macrophage autophagy system

Autophagy restricts the growth of a variety of intracellular pathogens. However, cytosol-adapted pathogens have evolved ways to evade restriction by this innate immune mechanism. Listeria monocytogenes is a Gram-positive bacterial pathogen that utilizes a cholesterol-dependent pore-forming toxin, listeriolysin O (LLO), to escape from the phagosome. Autophagy targets L. monocytogenes in LLO-damaged phagosomes and also in the cytosol under some experimental conditions. However, this bacterium has evolved multiple mechanisms to evade restriction by autophagy, including actin-based motility in the cytosol and an as yet undefined mechanism mediated by bacterial phospholipases C’s (PLCs). A population of L. monocytogenes with inefficient LLO activity forms Spacious Listeria-containing Phagosomes (SLAPs), which are autophagosome-like compartments that do not mature, allowing slow bacterial growth within enlarged vesicles. SLAPs may represent a stalemate between bacterial LLO action and the host autophagy system, resulting in persistent infection.

Addendum to: Birmingham CL, Canadien V, Gouin E, Troy EB, Yoshimori T, Cossart P, Higgins DE, Brumell JH. Listeria monocytogenes evades killing by autophagy during colonization of host cells. Autophagy 2007; 3:442-51.andBirmingham CL, Canadien V, Kaniuk NA, Steinberg BE, Higgins DE, Brumell JH. Listeriolysin O allows Listeria monocytogenes replication in macrophage vacuoles. Nature 2008; 451:350-4.     

Listeria monocytogenes evades killing by autophagy during colonization of host cells

Listeria monocytogenes is an intracellular pathogen that is able to colonize the cytosol of macrophages. Here we examined the interaction of this pathogen with autophagy, a host cytosolic degradative pathway that constitutes an important component of innate immunity towards microbial invaders. L. monocytogenes infection induced activation of the autophagy system in macrophages. At 1 h post infection (p.i.), a population of intracellular bacteria ( approximately 37%) colocalized with the autophagy marker LC3. These bacteria were within vacuoles and were targeted by autophagy in an LLO-dependent manner. At later stages in infection (by 4 h p.i.), the majority of L. monocytogenes escaped into the cytosol and rapidly replicated. At these times, less than 10% of intracellular bacteria colocalized with LC3. We found that ActA expression was sufficient to prevent autophagy of bacteria in the cytosol of macrophages. Surprisingly, ActA expression was not strictly necessary, indicating that other virulence factors were involved. Accordingly, we also found a role for the bacterial phospholipases, PI-PLC and PC-PLC, in autophagy evasion, as bacteria lacking phospholipase expression were targeted by autophagy at later times in infection. Together, our results demonstrate that L. monocytogenes utilizes multiple mechanisms to avoid destruction by the autophagy system during colonization of macrophages.     

Avoiding death by autophagy: interactions of Listeria monocytogenes with the macrophage autophagy system

Autophagy restricts the growth of a variety of intracellular pathogens. However, cytosol-adapted pathogens have evolved ways to evade restriction by this innate immune mechanism. Listeria monocytogenes is a Gram-positive bacterial pathogen that utilizes a cholesterol-dependent pore-forming toxin, listeriolysin O (LLO), to escape from the phagosome. Autophagy targets L. monocytogenes in LLO-damaged phagosomes and also in the cytosol under some experimental conditions. However, this bacterium has evolved multiple mechanisms to evade restriction by autophagy, including actin-based motility in the cytosol and an as yet undefined mechanism mediated by bacterial phospholipases C (PLCs). A population of L. monocytogenes with inefficient LLO activity forms Spacious Listeria-containing Phagosomes (SLAPs), which are autophagosome-like compartments that do not mature, allowing slow bacterial growth within enlarged vesicles. SLAPs may represent a stalemate between bacterial LLO action and the host autophagy system, resulting in persistent infection.     

Autophagy and bacterial clearance: a not so clear picture

Autophagy, an intracellular degradation process highly conserved from yeast to humans, is viewed as an important defence mechanism to clear intracellular bacteria. However, recent work has shown that autophagy may have different roles during different bacterial infections that restrict bacterial replication (antibacterial autophagy), act in cell autonomous signalling (non‐bacterial autophagy) or support bacterial replication (pro‐bacterial autophagy). This review will focus on newfound interactions of autophagy and pathogenic bacteria, highlighting that, in addition to delivering bacteria to the lysosome, autophagy responding to bacterial invasion may have a much broader role in mediating disease outcome.     

The Francisella O‐antigen mediates survival in the macrophage cytosol via autophagy avoidance

Autophagy is a key innate immune response to intracellular parasites that promotes their delivery to degradative lysosomes following detection in the cytosol or within damaged vacuoles. Like Listeria and Shigella, which use specific mechanisms to avoid autophagic detection and capture, the bacterial pathogen Francisella tularensis proliferates within the cytosol of macrophages without demonstrable control by autophagy. To examine how Francisella evades autophagy, we screened a library of F. tularensis subsp. tularensis Schu S4 HimarFT transposon mutants in GFP‐LC3‐expressing murine macrophages by microscopy for clones localized within autophagic vacuoles after phagosomal escape. Eleven clones showed autophagic capture at 6 h post‐infection, whose HimarFT insertions clustered to fourgenetic loci involved in lipopolysaccharidic and capsular O‐antigen biosynthesis. Consistent with the HimarFT mutants, in‐frame deletion mutants of two representative loci, FTT1236 and FTT1448c (manC), lacking both LPS and capsular O‐antigen, underwent phagosomal escape but were cleared from the host cytosol. Unlike wild‐type Francisella, the O‐antigen deletion mutants were ubiquitinated, and recruited the autophagy adaptor p62/SQSTM1 and LC3 prior to cytosolic clearance. Autophagy‐deficient macrophages partially supported replication of both mutants, indicating that O‐antigen‐lacking Francisella are controlled by autophagy. These data demonstrate the intracellular protective role of this bacterial surface polysaccharide against autophagy.     

Listeria and autophagy escape: involvement of InlK, an internalin-like protein

Autophagy is a cell-autonomous mechanism of innate immunity that protects the cytosol against bacterial infection. Invasive bacteria, including Listeria monocytogenes, have thus evolved strategies to counteract a process that limits their intracellular growth. ActA is a surface protein produced by L. monocytogenes to polymerize actin and mediate intra- and intercellular movements, which plays a critical role in autophagy escape. We have recently investigated the role of another L. monocytogenes surface protein, the internalin InlK, in the infection process. We showed that in the cytosol of infected cells, InlK interacts with the Major Vault Protein (MVP), the main component of cytoplasmic ribonucleoprotein particles named vaults. Although MVP has been implicated in a variety of key cellular process, its role remains elusive. We demonstrated that L. monocytogenes is able, via InlK, to decorate its surface with MVP in order to escape autophagic recognition. Strikingly, this new strategy used by L. monocytogenes to avoid autophagy is independent of ActA, suggesting that InlK-MVP interactions and actin polymerization are two processes that favor in the same manner the infection process. Understanding the role of MVP may provide new insights into bacterial infection and autophagy.     

The perplexing role of autophagy in plant innate immune responses

Autophagy is a major intracellular process for the degradation of cytosolic macromolecules and organelles in the lysosomes or vacuoles for the purposes of regulating cellular homeostasis and protein and organelle quality control. In complex metazoan organisms, autophagy is highly engaged during the immune responses through interfaces either directly with intracellular pathogens or indirectly with immune signalling molecules. Studies over the last decade or so have also revealed a number of important ways in which autophagy shapes plant innate immune responses. First, autophagy promotes defence‐associated hypersensitive cell death induced by avirulent or related pathogens, but restricts unnecessary or disease‐associated spread of cell death. This elaborate regulation of plant host cell death by autophagy is critical during plant immune responses to the types of plant pathogens that induce cell death, which include avirulent biotrophic pathogens and necrotrophic pathogens. Second, autophagy modulates defence responses regulated by salicylic acid and jasmonic acid, thereby influencing plant basal resistance to both biotrophic and necrotrophic pathogens. Third, there is an emerging role of autophagy in virus‐induced RNA silencing, either as an antiviral collaborator for targeted degradation of viral RNA silencing suppressors or an accomplice of viral RNA silencing suppressors for targeted degradation of key components of plant cellular RNA silencing machinery. In this review, we summarize this important progress and discuss the potential significance of the perplexing role of autophagy in plant innate immunity.     

DRAM1 promotes the targeting of mycobacteria to selective autophagy

Autophagy provides an important defense mechanism against intracellular bacteria, such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the causative agent of tuberculosis disease (TB). We recently reported that pathogen recognition and antibacterial autophagy are connected by the induction of the DNA damage-regulated autophagy modulator DRAM1 via the toll-like receptor (TLR)-MYD88-NFKB innate immunity signaling pathway. Having shown that DRAM1 colocalizes with Mtb in human macrophages, we took advantage of a zebrafish model for TB to investigate the function of DRAM1 in autophagic host defense in vivo. We found that DRAM1 protects the zebrafish host from infection with Mycobacterium marinum (Mm), a close relative of Mtb. Overexpression of DRAM1 increases autophagosome formation and promotes autophagic flux by a mechanism dependent on the cytosolic DNA sensor TMEM173/STING and the ubiquitin receptor SQSTM1/p62. Here we summarize and discuss the implications of these findings.     

Autophagy limits Listeria monocytogenes intracellular growth in the early phase of primary infection

Autophagy has been recently proposed to be a component of the innate cellular immune response against several types of intracellular microorganisms. However, other intracellular bacteria including Listeria monocytogenes have been thought to evade the autophagic cellular surveillance. Here, we show that cellular infection by L. monocytogenes induces an autophagic response, which inhibits the growth of both the wild-type and a DeltaactA mutant strain, impaired in cell-to-cell spreading. The onset of early intracellular growth is accelerated in autophagy-deficient cells, but the growth rate once bacteria begin to multiply in the cytosol does not change. Moreover, a significant fraction of the intracellular bacteria colocalize with autophagosomes at the early time-points after infection. Thus, autophagy targets L. monocytogenes during primary infection by limiting the onset of early bacterial growth. The bacterial expression of listeriolysin O but not phospholipases is necessary for the induction of autophagy, suggesting a possible role for permeabilization of the vacuole in the induction of autophagy. Interestingly, the growth of a DeltaplcA/B L. monocytogenes strain deficient for bacterial phospholipases is impaired in wild-type cells, but restored in the absence of autophagy, suggesting that bacterial phospholipases may facilitate the escape of bacteria from autophagic degradation. We conclude that L. monocytogenes are targeted for degradation by autophagy during the primary infection, in the early phase of the intracellular cycle, following listeriolysin O-dependent vacuole perforation but preceding active multiplication in the cytosol, and that expression of bacterial phospholipases is necessary for the evasion of autophagy.     

Mechanisms and consequences of bacterial targeting by the autophagy pathway

Autophagy is a key component of our immune response to invading pathogens. Autophagic targeting of intracellular bacteria within vacuolar compartments or the cytosol helps to control bacterial replication in the host cell. The mechanism by which these invading pathogens are selectively targeted for degradation is of particular interest. Recently, several signaling factors have been shown to play roles in the specific targeting of bacteria by the autophagy pathway including: pattern recognition receptors, reactive oxygen species, ubiquitin and diacylglycerol. Here, we discuss these signaling factors and the consequences of bacterial targeting by autophagy during infection of host cells.     

DRAM1 promotes the targeting of mycobacteria to selective autophagy

Autophagy provides an important defense mechanism against intracellular bacteria, such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the causative agent of tuberculosis disease (TB). We recently reported that pathogen recognition and antibacterial autophagy are connected by the induction of the DNA damage-regulated autophagy modulator DRAM1 via the toll-like receptor (TLR)-MYD88-NFKB innate immunity signaling pathway. Having shown that DRAM1 colocalizes with Mtb in human macrophages, we took advantage of a zebrafish model for TB to investigate the function of DRAM1 in autophagic host defense in vivo. We found that DRAM1 protects the zebrafish host from infection with Mycobacterium marinum (Mm), a close relative of Mtb. Overexpression of DRAM1 increases autophagosome formation and promotes autophagic flux by a mechanism dependent on the cytosolic DNA sensor TMEM173/STING and the ubiquitin receptor SQSTM1/p62. Here we summarize and discuss the implications of these findings.     

The ubiquitin-binding adaptor proteins p62/SQSTM1 and NDP52 are recruited independently to bacteria-associated microdomains to target Salmonella to the autophagy pathway

Autophagy is an innate immune defense against bacterial invasion. Recent studies show that two adaptor proteins, p62 and NDP52, are required for autophagy of the bacterial pathogen Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. typhimurium). However, it is not known why two different adaptors are required to target the same bacterial cargo to autophagy. Here we show that both adaptors are recruited to bacteria with similar kinetics, that they are recruited to bacteria independently of each other, and that depletion of either adaptor leads to impairment of antibacterial autophagy. Depletion of both adaptors does not synergistically impair autophagy, indicating they act in the same pathway. Remarkably, we observed that these adaptors do not colocalize, but rather form non-overlapping microdomains surrounding bacteria. We conclude that p62 and NDP52 act cooperatively to drive efficient antibacterial autophagy by targeting the protein complexes they coordinate to distinct micro-domains associated with bacteria.     

An essential role for the ATG8 ortholog LC3C in antibacterial autophagy

Autophagy defends the mammalian cytosol against bacterial invasion. Efficient bacterial engulfment by autophagy requires cargo receptors that bind (a) homolog(s) of the ubiquitin-like protein Atg8 on the phagophore membrane. The existence of multiple ATG8 orthologs in higher eukaryotes suggests that they may perform distinct functions. However, no specific role has been assigned to any mammalian ATG8 ortholog. We recently discovered that the autophagy receptor CALCOCO2/NDP52, which detects cytosol-invading Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. Typhimurium), preferentially binds LC3C. The CALCOCO2/NDP52-LC3C interaction is essential for cell-autonomous immunity against cytosol-exposed S. Typhimurium, because cells lacking either protein fail to target bacteria into the autophagy pathway. The selectivity of CALCOCO2/NDP52 for LC3C is determined by a novel LC3C interacting region (CLIR), in which the lack of the key aromatic residue of canonical LIRs is compensated by LC3C-specific interactions. Our findings provide a new layer of regulation to selective autophagy, suggesting that specific interactions between autophagy receptors and the ATG8 orthologs are of biological importance.     

Listeria monocytogenes Evades Killing by Autophagy During Colonization of Host Cells

Listeria monocytogenes is an intracellular pathogen that is able to colonize the cytosol of macrophages. Here we examined the interaction of this pathogen with autophagy, a host cytosolicdegradative pathway that constitutes an important component of innate immunity towards microbial invaders. L. monocytogenes infection induced activation of the autophagy system in macrophages. At 1 h post infection (p.i.), a population of intracellular bacteria (~37%) colocalized with the autophagy marker LC3. These bacteria were within vacuoles and were targeted by autophagy in an LLO-dependent manner. At later stages in infection (by 4 h p.i.), the majority of L. monocytogenes escaped into the cytosol and rapidly replicated. At these times, less than 10% of intracellular bacteria colocalized with LC3. We found that ActA expression was sufficient to prevent autophagy of bacteria in the cytosol of macrophages. Surprisingly, ActA expression was not strictly necessary, indicating that other virulence factors were involved. Accordingly, we also found a role for the bacterial phospholipases, PI-PLC and PC-PLC, in autophagy evasion, as bacteria lacking phospholipase expression were targeted by autophagy at later times in infection. Together, our results demonstratethat L. monocytogenes utilizes multiple mechanisms to avoid destruction by the autophagy system during colonization of macrophages.     

Interactions of pathogenic bacteria with autophagy systems

Autophagy is a conserved cellular degradative pathway that is now established to be a vital part of the host immune response to microbial infection. Autophagy can directly eliminate intracellular pathogens by mediating their delivery to lysosomes. Canonical autophagy is characterized by the formation of a double-membrane autophagosome and the involvement of over 35 autophagy-related proteins (Atgs), including a commonly used autophagosome marker in mammalian cells, LC3. Recent studies have shown that a subset of autophagy components can lead to LC3 conjugation onto phagosomes. This process of LC3-associated phagocytosis (LAP) results in the degradation of the cargo by promoting phagosome fusion with lysosomes. Other components of the autophagy machinery also play roles in immunity that are distinct from the canonical autophagy and LAP pathways. This minireview highlights the complicated relationship between autophagy components and intracellular bacteria, including bacterial targeting mechanisms and the interaction between autophagy and effectors/toxins secreted by bacteria.     

The ubiquitin-binding adaptor proteins p62/SQSTM1 and NDP52 are recruited independently to bacteria-associated microdomains to target Salmonella to the autophagy pathway

Autophagy is an innate immune defense against bacterial invasion. Recent studies show that two adaptor proteins, p62 and NDP52, are required for autophagy of the bacterial pathogen Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium (S. Typhimurium). However, it is not known why two different adaptors are required to target the same bacterial cargo to autophagy. Here we show that both adaptors are recruited to bacteria with similar kinetics, that they are recruited to bacteria independently of each other, and that depletion of either adaptor leads to impairment of antibacterial autophagy. Depletion of both adaptors does not synergistically impair autophagy, indicating they act in the same pathway. Remarkably, we observed that these adaptors do not colocalize, but rather form non-overlapping microdomains surrounding bacteria. We conclude that p62 and NDP52 act cooperatively to drive efficient antibacterial autophagy by targeting the protein complexes they coordinate to distinct microdomains associated with bacteria.     

Autophagosome formation in response to intracellular bacterial invasion

Autophagy is an intracellular bulk degradation system in which double‐membrane vesicles, called autophagosomes, engulf cytoplasmic components and later fuse with lysosomes to degrade the autophagosome content. Although autophagy was initially thought a non‐selective process, recent studies have clarified that it can selectively target intracellular bacteria and function as an intracellular innate immune system that suppresses bacterial survival. A key mechanism for the recognition of cytosol‐invading bacteria is ubiquitination, and the recognition of the ubiquitinated target by the autophagy machinery can be accomplished multiple ways. In this review, we discuss recent findings regarding the induction of autophagosome formation in response to intracellular bacterial invasion.