Thermodynamic cooperativity and kinetic proofreading in DNA damage recognition and repair

In humans UV-induced cyclobutane thymine dimers are excised by the joint action of six repair factors, RPA, XPA, XPC, TFIIH, XPG, and XPF.ERCC1. Yet, in vitro assays show that none of these six factors is capable of detectably discriminating thymine dimer-containing DNA from undamaged DNA. We show how two elementary principles in macromolecular recognition, (1). cooperativity and (2). kinetic proofreading, are utilized to confer specificity to the repair system where none exists at the individual repair factor level and enable human cells to excise thymine dimers with a physiologically relevant specificity and at a biologically acceptable rate.     

The kinetics of thymine dimer excision in ultraviolet-irradiated human cells

We have investigated the kinetics of the loss of thymine dimers from the acid-insoluble fraction of several ultraviolet (UV)-irradiated cultured human cell lines. Our results show that UV fluences between 10 and 40 J/m2 produce an average of 21-85 x 10(5) thymine dimers per cell and an eventual maximal loss per cell of 12-20 x 10(5) thymine dimers. The time for half-maximal loss of dimers ranged from 12-22 h after UV irradiation. In contrast, the time for half-maximal repair synthesis of DNA measured by autoradiography was 4.5 h. This figure agrees well with reported half-maximal repair synthesis times, which range from 0.5 to 3.6 h based on our analysis. The discrepancy in the kinetics of the loss of thymine dimers from DNA and repair synthesis is discussed in terms of possible molecular mechanisms of thymine dimer excision in vivo and in terms of possible experimental artifacts.     

Effects of temperature on the photoreactivation of ultraviolet-b–induced dna damage in Palmaria palmata (Rhodophyta)

The accumulation of DNA damage (thymine dimers and 6-4 photoproducts) induced by ultraviolet-B radiation was studied in Palmaria palmata (L.) O. Kuntze under different light and temperature conditions, using specific monoclonal antibodies and subsequent chemiluminescent detection. Both types of damage were repaired much faster under ultraviolet-A radiation (UVAR) plus photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) than in darkness, which indicates photoreactivating activity. At 12° C, all thymine dimers were repaired after 2 h irradiation with UVAR plus PAR, whereas 6-4 photoproducts were almost completely repaired after 4 h. After 19 h of darkness, almost complete repair of 6-4 photoproducts was found, and 67% of the thymine dimers were repaired. In a second set of experiments, repair of DNA damage under UVAR plus PAR was compared at three different temperatures (0, 12, and 25° C). Again, thymine dimers were repaired faster than 6-4 photoproducts at all three temperatures. At 0° C, significant repair of thymine dimers was found but not of 6-4 photoproducts. Significant repair of both thymine dimers and 6-4 photoproducts occurred at 12 and 25° C. Optimal repair efficiency was found at 25° C for thymine dimers but at 12° C for 6-4 photoproducts, which suggests that the two photorepair processes have different temperature characteristics.     

The interplay of supercoiling and thymine dimers in DNA

Thymine dimers are a major mutagenic photoproduct induced by UV radiation. While they have been the subject of extensive theoretical and experimental investigations, questions of how DNA supercoiling affects local defect properties, or, conversely, how the presence of such defects changes global supercoiled structure, are largely unexplored. Here, we introduce a model of thymine dimers in the oxDNA forcefield, parametrized by comparison to melting experiments and structural measurements of the thymine dimer induced bend angle. We performed extensive molecular dynamics simulations of double-stranded DNA as a function of external twist and force. Compared to undamaged DNA, the presence of a thymine dimer lowers the supercoiling densities at which plectonemes and bubbles occur. For biologically relevant supercoiling densities and forces, thymine dimers can preferentially segregate to the tips of the plectonemes, where they enhance the probability of a localized tip-bubble. This mechanism increases the probability of highly bent and denatured states at the thymine dimer site, which may facilitate repair enzyme binding. Thymine dimer-induced tip-bubbles also pin plectonemes, which may help repair enzymes to locate damage. We hypothesize that the interplay of supercoiling and local defects plays an important role for a wider set of DNA damage repair systems.     

Identification of oligothymidylates as new simple substrates for Escherichia coli DNA photolyase and their use in a rapid spectrophotometric enzyme assay

Escherichia coli DNA photolyase exhibits the same turnover number (3.4 min-1) for the repair of dimers in oligothymidylates [oligo(dT)n] containing 4-18 thymine residues. This rate is identical with that observed with polythymidylate and with native DNA. The enzyme exhibits a similar high affinity with oligomers containing seven or more thymine residues. A decrease in affinity is detectable with oligo(dT)n when n = 4-6. The enzyme is active with oligo(dT)3, but no evidence for saturation was obtained at dimer concentrations up to 15 microM where the observed repair rate is 43% of the turnover number observed with the higher homologues. Nearly quantitative (90-100%) repair is observed with oligo(dT)n when n is greater than or equal to 9. Photolyase can repair internal dimers and dimers at a 5' end where the terminal ribose is phosphorylated but not at unphosphorylated 5' or 3' ends. The latter can explain a progressive decrease in the extent of repair observed with short-chain oligomers. The observed specificity can also explain why the enzyme is inactive with oligo(dT)2 [p(dT)2] since the only dimer possible in oligo(dT)2 involves an unphosphorylated 3' end. That the enzyme can repair dimers in short-chain, single-stranded analogues for DNA suggests that in catalysis with DNA recognition of the dimer itself is important as opposed to recognition of the deformation in DNA structure produced by the dimer. Dimer repair with oligo(dT)n is detected by the increase in absorbance at 260 nm, a feature which is used as the basis for a rapid spectrophotometric assay with a lower detection limit around 150 pmol of dimer repaired.     

Mechanisms of targeted frameshift mutations: Insertions arising during error-prone or SOS synthesis of DNA containing cis-syn cyclobutane thymine dimers

It is still unclear how frameshift mutations arise at cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers. The polymerase model is commonly used to explain the mechanisms of various mutations. An alternative polymerase-tautomer model was developed for UV-induced mutagenesis. A mechanism was proposed for targeted insertions caused by cis-syn cyclobutane thymine dimers. Targeted insertions are frameshift mutations due to addition of one or more nucleotides in a DNA sequence opposite to a lesion capable of stopping DNA synthesis. Among other factors, cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers can cause targeted insertions. UV irradiation can change the tautomeric form of DNA bases. Five rare tautomeric forms are possible for thymine, and they are stable when the thymine is a component of a cyclobutane dimer. A structural analysis showed that none of the canonical nucleotides can be added opposite to a specific rare thymine tautomer so that hydrogen bonds form between the two bases. A single nucleotide gap is consequently left in the corresponding site of the nascent strand when a specialized or modified DNA polymerase drives SOS or error-prone DNA synthesis on a template containing cis-syn cyclobutane thymine dimers with a base occurring in the rare tautomeric form. If the DNA composition is homogenous within the region, the end of the growing DNA strand may slip to form a complementary pair with the nucleotide adjacent to the dimer according to the Streisinger model, thus producing a loop. A targeted insertion is thereby generated to make the daughter strand longer. Targeted insertions were for the first time assumed to result from the cis-syn cyclobutane thymine dimers wherein one or both of the bases occur in the specific tautomeric form that does not allow the addition and hydrogen bonding of any canonical nucleotide in the opposite position. A model was developed to explain how targeted insertions of one or more nucleotides are caused by cis-syn cyclobutane thymine dimers. Thus, the polymerase-tautomer model can explain the nature and formation of targeted frameshift mutations in addition to hot and cold spots or targeted or untargeted nucleotide substitutions.     

Mechanisms and implications of the age-associated decrease in DNA repair capacity.

Skin cancer incidence is clearly linked to UV irradiation and increases exponentially with age. We studied the rate of removal of thymine dimers and (6-4) photoproducts in UV-irradiated human dermal fibroblasts derived from donors of different ages. There was a significant decrease with aging in the repair rates of both thymine dimers and (6-4) photoproducts (P<0.001). In addition, there was an age-associated decrease in the protein levels of ERCC3, PCNA, RPA, XPA, and p53 that participate in nucleotide excision repair. Moreover, the mRNA levels of XPA, ERCC3, and PCNA were significantly reduced with aging, suggesting that these decreases are often regulated at the mRNA level. Furthermore, with age induction of p53 after UV irradiation was significantly reduced. Taken together, our data suggest that the age-associated decrease in the repair of UV-induced DNA damage results at least in part from decreased levels of proteins that participate in the repair process.     

Towards elucidation of the mechanism of UV1C, a deoxyribozyme with photolyase activity

Among the unexpected chemistries that can be catalyzed by nucleic acid enzymes is photochemistry. We have reported the in vitro selection of a small, cofactor-independent deoxyribozyme, UV1C, capable of repairing thymine dimers in a DNA substrate, most optimally with light at a wavelength of >300 nm. We hypothesized that a guanine quadruplex functioned both as a light antenna and an electron source for the repair of the substrate within the enzyme-substrate complex. Here, we report structural and mechanistic investigations of that hypothesis. Contact-crosslinking and guanosine to inosine mutational studies reveal that the thymine dimer and the guanine quadruplex are positioned close to each other in the deoxyribozyme-substrate complex, and permit us to refine the structure and topology of the folded deoxyribozyme. In exploring the substrate utilization capabilities of UV1C, we find it to be able to repair uracil dimers as well as thymine dimers, as long as they are present in an overall deoxyribonucleotide milieu. Some surprising similarities with bacterial CPD photolyase enzymes are noted.     

Detection of thymine [2+2] photodimer repair in DNA: selective reaction of KMnO4.

The specific reaction of potassium permanganate with thymine in single-stranded DNA was employed to analyze thymine [2+2] dimer repair in DNA and in DNA/peptide nucleic acid hybrid duplexes. This simple and highly sensitive chemical assay is convenient for monitoring repair of thymine dimers in oligonucleotides.     

On the recognition and cleavage mechanism of Escherichia coli endodeoxyribonuclease V, a possible DNA repair enzyme

Escherichia coli endodeoxyribonuclease V acts at many sites of damage in duplex DNA, including apurinic/apyrimidinic sites, lesions induced by ultraviolet light which are not pyrimidine dimers, adducts of 7-bromomethylbenz[a]anthracene, and, as demonstrated earlier (Gates, F. T., and Linn, S. (1977a) J. Biol. Chem. 252. 1647-1653), it degrades uracil-containing duplex DNA most efficiently. The cleavage rate increases with increasing substitution of uracil for thymine in T5 DNA, with a replacement of one-eight of thymine generating the apparent maximum cleavage rate. However, the apparent reaction limit with DNA containing 3.8% of thymine replaced by uracil corresponds to cleavage at only 6% of the dUMP residues. Evidently, the enzyme recognizes some peculiarities of abnormal DNA structure, but not simply distortions, since some lesions, including pyrimidine dimers, are not substrates. Endonuclease V generates double strand breaks in a constant ratio to single strand nicks, regardless of the substrate. It degrades DNA processively, completing the digestion of one substrate molecule before proceeding to the next. The enzyme also appears to act cooperatively. Cleavage at methylbenz[a]anthracene adducts is usually or always 5' to the lesion. Endonuclease V seems well suited to act as a DNA repair enzyme, surveying the genome for structural distortions generated by lesions for which specific repair systems might not exist.     

A new mechanism for repairing oxidative damage to DNA: (A)BC excinuclease removes AP sites and thymine glycols from DNA

Escherichia coli (A)BC excinuclease is the major enzyme responsible for removing bulky adducts, such as pyrimidine dimers and 6-4 photoproducts, from DNA. Mutants deficient in this enzyme are extremely sensitive to UV and UV-mimetic agents, but not to oxidizing agents, or ionizing radiation which damages DNA in part by generating active oxygen species. DNA glycosylases and AP1 endonucleases play major roles in repairing oxidative DNA damage, and thus it has been assumed that nucleotide excision repair has no role in cellular defense against damage by ionizing radiation and oxidative damage. In this study we show that the E. coli nucleotide excision repair enzyme (A)BC excinuclease removes from DNA the two major products of oxidative damage, thymine glycol and the baseless sugar (AP site). We conclude that nucleotide excision repair is an important cellular defense mechanism against oxidizing agents.     

Establishment of a monoclonal antibody recognizing cyclobutane-type thymine dimers in DNA: a comparative study with 64M-1 antibody specific for (6-4)photoproducts

We obtained a monoclonal antibody (TDM-1) binding to 313-nm UV-irradiated DNA in the presence of acetophenone. The binding of TDM-1 to 254-nm UV-irradiated DNA was not reduced with the subsequent irradiation of 313-nm UV. Furthermore, the treatment of UV-irradiated DNA with photolyase from E. coli and visible light exposure reduced both the antibody binding and the amount of thymine dimers in the DNA. A competitive inhibition assay revealed that the binding of TDM-1 to UV-irradiated DNA was inhibited with photolyase, but not with 64M-1 antibody specific for (6-4)photoproducts. These results suggest that TDM-1 antibody recognizes cyclobutane-type thymine dimers in DNA. Using TDM-1 and 64M-1 antibodies, we differentially measured each type of damage in DNA extracted from UV-irradiated mammalian cells. Repair experiments confirm that thymine dimers are excised from UV-irradiated cellular DNA more slowly than (6-4)photoproducts, and that the excision rates of thymine dimers and (6-4)photoproducts are lower in mouse NIH3T3 cells than in human cells.     

Induction of unscheduled DNA synthesis by the carcinogen 7-bromomethylbenz(a)anthracene and its removal from the DNA of normal and xeroderma pigmentosum lymphocytes

The carcinogen 7-bromomethylbenz(a)anthracene (BBA), which can bind strongly to DNA, induces unscheduled DNA synthesis (DNA repair) in normal lymphocytes but almost none in lymphocytes from patients with Xeroderma pigmentosum (XP), and inherited disease known to be defective in excision repair of ultraviolet-damaged DNA. We studied [³H]BBA's ability to bind to DNA of normal and XP lymphocytes, its influence on unscheduled DNA synthesis, and its removal from the DNA of both cell types. We found that 20–30% of the BBA is bound to macromolecules other than DNA and that its binding to DNA is essentially complete after 30 min. The induction of unscheduled DNA synthesis by the carcinogen in XP lymphocytes was approximately 10% of that induced in normal lymphocytes. While 15–20% of the BBA was removed from the DNA of normal cells 6 h after treatment, only 1–2% was removed from the DNA of XP cells. Thus, XP cells not only are defective in repairing ultraviolet-damaged DNA and excising thymine dimers but also fail to repair DNA damaged by certain carcinogens, and, most importantly, fail to remove the DNA-bound carcinogen, BBA.     

Formation of cyclobutane thymine dimers photosensitized by pyridopsoralens: quantitative and qualitative distribution within DNA

As after irradiation with 254-nm UV light, exposure of thymidine and three isomeric pyridopsoralen derivatives to UVA radiation, in the dry state, leads to the formation of the six diastereomers of cyclobutadithymidine as the predominant reaction. This unexpected photosensitized reaction, which also gives rise to both 5R* and 5S* diastereomers of 5,6-dihydro-5-(alpha-thymidylyl)thymidine (or "spore" photoproduct), is selective since [2 + 2] dimerization of 2'-deoxycytidine was not detected under the same experimental conditions. The cis-syn isomer of cyclobutadithymine was also found to be produced within isolated DNA following UVA irradiation in aqueous solutions containing 7-methylpyrido[3,4-c]psoralen. Quantitatively, this photoproduct represents about one-fifth of the overall yield of the furan-side pyridopsoralen [2 + 2] photocycloadducts to thymine. DNA sequencing methodology was used to demonstrate that pyridopsoralen-photosensitized DNA is a substrate for T4 endonuclease V and Escherichia coli photoreactivating enzyme, two enzymes acting specifically on cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers. Furthermore, the dimerization reaction of thymine is sequence dependent, with a different specificity from that mediated by far-UV irradiation as inferred from gel sequencing experiments. Interestingly, adjacent thymine residues are excellent targets for 7-methylpyrido[3,4-c]psoralen-mediated formation of cyclobutadithymine in TTTTA and TTAAT sites, which are also the strongest sites for photoaddition. The formation of cyclobutane thymine dimers concomitant to that of thymine-furocoumarin photoadducts and their eventual implication in the photobiological effects of the pyridopsoralens are discussed.     

The timing of UV mutagenesis in yeast: continuing mutation in an excision-defective (rad1-1) strain.

Summary Mutation induction by ultraviolet light was studied in excision-defective (rad1-1) strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Information about the timing of mutations in relation to postirradiation DNA replication was obtained. The experimental system involved pedigree analysis of G1 diploid cells and subsequent tetrad analysis of the mitotic segregants to detect mutations.The mutation pattern of rad1-1 strains differed from that of wild type in two respects: (1) few or none of the mutations affected both strands of the DNA, (2) mutations appeared as frequently in the second postirradiation mitotic generation as in the first.The data have led to the following conclusions about the mutation process in excision-defective (rad1-1) yeast: (a) Mutations are not fixed prior to the first postirradiation round of DNA replication. (b) Unexcised thymine dimers persist as mutagenic lesions through repeated postirradiation cell divisions. (c) Heteroduplex repair is involved in the mutation process. (d) Overlapping daughter-strand gaps are not a prerequisite for mutation. (e) The results provide no evidence that error-prone repair in this strain is inducible rather than constitutive. The data also show that (f) all 2-strand mutations (whole-colony mutants) induced in yeast by exposure to low levels of ultraviolet light are associated with excision repair, and that (g) essentially all lesions induced in excision-proficient strains have been excised at the time of the second round of postirradiation DNA synthesis.On leave of absence from the Department of Genetics, University of Edinburgh, West Mains Road, Edinburgh, Scotland EH9 3JN     

Characterization of a wide range base-damage-endonuclease activity of mammalian rpS3

Mammalian rpS3, a ribosomal protein S3 with a DNA repair endonuclease activity, nicks heavily UV-irradiated DNA and DNA containing AP sites. RpS3 calls for a novel endonucleolytic activity on AP sites generated from pyrimidine dimers by T4 pyrimidine dimer glycosylase activity. This study revealed that rpS3 cleaves the lesions including AP sites, thymine glycols, and other UV damaged lesions such as pyrimidine dimers. This enzyme does not have a glycosylase activity as predicted from its amino acid sequence. However, it has an endonuclease activity on DNA containing thymine glycol, which is exactly overlapped with UV-irradiated or AP DNAs, indicating that rpS3 cleaves phosphodiester bonds of DNAs containing altered bases with broad specificity acting as a base-damage-endonuclease. RpS3 cleaves supercoiled UV damaged DNA more efficiently than the relaxed counterpart, and the endonuclease activity of rpS3 was inhibited by MgCl2 on AP DNA but not on UV-irradiated DNA.     

No detectable DNA excision repair in UV-exposed hepatocytes from two catfish species

DNA repair is a critical process in protecting cellular genetic information from mutation. Nucleotide excision repair (NER) is a mechanism by which cells correct DNA damage caused by agents that form bulky covalent adducts and UV photoproducts such as thymine dimers and 6-4 photoproduct. NER, sometimes called dark repair, is generally accepted as being low in fish compared to mammals. This study was designed to quantitate NER in two related catfish species that have known differential sensitivities to liver carcinomas. The original hypothesis was that the more cancer resistant species, channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus), would have more efficient DNA repair compared to the more sensitive brown bullhead (Ameriurus nebulosus). In order to measure NER, primary cultured hepatocytes of both species were exposed to UV light (10-40 J/m2) and collected at 0, 24, 48 and 72 h after exposure. Total DNA was extracted from the cells and incubated with T4 endonuclease V. Using alkaline gel electrophoresis, endonuclease sensitive sites (ESS) were quantified. Results from the ESS assay indicated there was a UV dose-response increase in thymine dimers from 0 to 40 J/m2. However, no repair (decrease in number of ESS) occurred in either fish species over a 72-h time period. When cells were exposed to photoreactivating fluorescent light, repair was detected. These studies highlight the difficulty of measuring NER in fish and are consistent with the low levels of NER reported by other researchers in fish.     

Loss of thymine dimers from mammalian cell DNA. The kinetics for antibody-binding sites are not the same as that for T4 endonuclease V sites

Antiserum specific for thymine-containing dimers was used to assay DNA isolated from ultraviolet-irradiated cells following different repair periods. A 50% loss in antibody-binding sites was evident 1 h post-irradiation, and within 4 h 80% of the sites were removed. This result contrasts with data obtained with dimer-specific T4 endonuclease V and does not appear to be due to masking of the dimers by repair enzymes. T4 endonuclease V treatment of ultraviolet-irradiated DNA at 0 degree C resulted in conversion of the thymine dimers to apyrimidinic sites. This did not result in loss of antigenicity in either PM2 or CHO cell DNA. Likewise, treatment of ultraviolet-irradiated CHO cell DNA with T4 endonuclease at 37 degrees C did not change its antigenicity. These results suggest that aglycosylation of the dimers is not responsible for their inability to bind dimer-specific antibody 2-4 h post-irradiation. The possibility that T4 endonuclease V and the antiserum have different specificities for different dimers is discussed.     

The Ultraviolet Photochemistry and Photobiology of Vegetative Cells and Spores of Bacillus megaterium

The ultraviolet (UV) photochemistry and photobiology of spores and vegetative cells of Bacillus megaterium have been studied. The response of vegetative cells of B. megaterium appears qualitatively similar to those of Escherichia coli, Micrococcus radiodurans, and Bacillus subtilis with respect to photoproduct formation and repair mechanisms. UV irradiation, however, does not produce cyclobutane-type thymine dimers in the DNA of spores, although other thymine photo-products are produced. The photoproducts do not disappear after photoreactivation, but they are eliminated from the DNA by a dark-repair mechanism different from that found for dimers in vegetative cells. Irradiations performed at three wavelengths produce the same amounts of spore photoproduct and give the same survival curves. Variation of the sporulation medium before irradiation results in comparable alterations in the rate of spore photoproduct production and in survival.