P38 MAP kinase signaling is required for the conversion of CD4+CD25- T cells into iTreg

CD4+CD25+ regulatory T cells (Treg) are important mediators of immune tolerance. A subset of Treg can be generated in the periphery by TGF-beta dependent conversion of conventional CD4+CD25- T cells into induced Treg (iTreg). In chronic viral infection or malignancy, such induced iTreg, which limit the depletion of aberrant or infected cells, may be of pathogenic relevance. To identify potential targets for therapeutic intervention, we investigated the TGF-beta signaling in Treg. In contrast to conventional CD4+ T cells, Treg exhibited marked activation of the p38 MAP kinase pathway. Inhibition of p38 MAP kinase activity prevented the TGF-beta-dependent conversion of CD4+CD25- T cells into Foxp3+ iTreg in vitro. Of note, the suppressive capacity of nTreg was not affected by inhibiting p38 MAP kinase. Our findings indicate that signaling via p38 MAP kinase seems to be important for the peripheral generation of iTreg; p38 MAP kinase could thus be a therapeutic target to enhance immunity to chronic viral infection or cancer.     

Regulatory T cells and tumor immunity

Central deletion of self-reactive T cells has been the textbook paradigm for inducing self-tolerance in the periphery and the concept of a role of T cell-mediated suppression in this process has long been controversial. A decisive shift in the opinion on suppressor T cells has lately occurred with the observations of Sakaguchis group that linked a class of CD4+CD25+ T cells to the prevention of autoimmunity from neonatal thymectomy in mice. These CD4+CD25+ T cells have been named T regulatory (Treg) cells. They are believed to be selected in the thymus as an anti-self repertoire. Hence they were referred to as natural T regulatory (nTreg) cells. Presently, in addition to their role in autoimmunity, they are believed to exert regulatory function in infection, in transplantation immunity as well as in tumor immunity. In contrast to these nTreg cells, another class of CD4+ Treg cells also exercises regulatory function in the periphery. These Treg cells are also CD4+ T cells and after activation they also become phenotypically CD4+CD25+. They are, however induced in the periphery as Treg cells. Hence, they are termed as induced Treg (iTreg) cells. There are major differences in the biology of these two types of Treg cells. They differ in their requirements for activation and in their mode of action. Nonetheless, evidence indicates that both nTreg cells and iTreg cells are involved in the control of tumor immunity. The question of how to circumvent their regulatory constraints, therefore, has become a major challenge for tumor immunologists.     

Arthritogenic self-reactive CD4+ T cells acquire an FR4hiCD73hi anergic state in the presence of Foxp3+ regulatory T cells

Rheumatoid arthritis develops in association with a defect in peripheral CD4(+) T cell homeostasis. T cell lymphopenia has also been shown to be a barrier to CD4(+) T cell clonal anergy induction. We therefore explored the relationship between clonal anergy induction and the avoidance of autoimmune arthritis by tracking the fate of glucose-6-phosphate isomerase (GPI)-reactive CD4(+) T cells in the setting of selective T cell lymphopenia. CD4(+) T cell recognition of self-GPI peptide/MHC class II complexes in normal murine hosts did not lead to arthritis and instead caused those T cells to develop a Folate receptor 4(hi)CD73(hi) anergic phenotype. In contrast, hosts selectively depleted of polyclonal Foxp3(+)CD4(+) regulatory T cells could not make GPI-specific CD4(+) T cells anergic and failed to control arthritis. This suggests that autoimmune arthritis develops in the setting of lymphopenia when Foxp3(+)CD4(+) regulatory T cells are insufficient to functionally inactivate all autoreactive CD4(+) T cells that encounter self-Ag.     

Inhibition of cell cycle progression by rapamycin induces T cell clonal anergy even in the presence of costimulation

Costimulation (signal 2) has been proposed to inhibit the induction of T cell clonal anergy by either directly antagonizing negative signals arising from TCR engagement (signal 1) or by synergizing with signal 1 to produce IL-2, which in turn leads to proliferation and dilution of negative regulatory factors. To better define the cellular events that lead to the induction of anergy, we used the immunosuppressive agent rapamycin, which blocks T cell proliferation in late G1 phase but does not affect costimulation-dependent IL-2 production. Our data demonstrate that full T cell activation (signal 1 plus 2) in the presence of rapamycin results in profound T cell anergy, despite the fact that these cells produce copious amounts of IL-2. Similar to conventional anergy (induction by signal 1 alone), the rapamycin-induced anergic cells show a decrease in mitogen-activated protein kinase activation, and these cells can be rescued by culture in IL-2. Interestingly, the rapamycin-induced anergic cells display a more profound block in IL-3 and IFN-gamma production upon rechallenge. Finally, in contrast to rapamycin, full T cell activation in the presence of hydroxyurea (which inhibits the cell cycle in early S phase) did not result in anergy. These data suggest that it is neither the direct effect of costimulation nor the subsequent T cell proliferation that prevents anergy induction, but rather the biochemical events that occur upon progression through the cell cycle from G1 into S phase.     

Induction of anergy in Th1 cells associated with increased levels of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors p21Cip1 and p27Kip1

Th1 cells exposed to Ag and the G(1) blocker n-butyrate in primary cultures lose their ability to proliferate in Ag-stimulated secondary cultures. The ability of n-butyrate to induce anergy in Ag-stimulated, but not resting, Th1 cells was shown here to be blocked by cycloheximide. Subsequent experiments to delineate the nature of the protein apparently required for n-butyrate-induced Th1 cell anergy focused on the role of cyclin-dependent kinase (cdk) inhibitors p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1). Normally, entry into S phase by Th1 cells occurs around 24 h after Ag stimulation and corresponds with relatively low levels of both p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1). However, unlike control Th1 cells, anergic Th1 cells contained high levels of both p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1) when examined 24 h after Ag stimulation. The increase in p21(Cip1) observed in Ag-stimulated anergic Th1 cells appeared to be initiated in primary cultures. In contrast, the increase in p27(Kip1) observed in these anergic Th1 cells appears to represent a re-expression of the protein much earlier than control cells following Ag stimulation in secondary cultures. The anergic Th1 cells contained functionally active cdk inhibitors capable of inhibiting the activity of both endogenous and exogenous cdks. Consequently, it appears that n-butyrate-induced anergy in Th1 cells correlated with the up-regulation of p21(Cip1) and perhaps the downstream failure to maintain low levels of p27(Kip1). Increased levels of both p21(Cip1) and p27(Kip1) at the end of G(1) could prevent cdk-mediated entry into S phase, and thus help maintain the proliferative unresponsiveness found in the anergic Th1 cells.     

Fingerprints of anergic T cells

Peripheral T cell tolerance may result from activation-induced cell death [1], anergy [1], and/or immune response modulation by regulatory T cells [2]. In mice that express a transgenic receptor specific for peptide 111-119 of influenza hemagglutinin presented by E(d) class II MHC molecules as well as hemagglutinin under control of the immunoglobulin-kappa promoter, we have found that anergic T cells [3] can also have immunoregulatory function and secrete IL-10 [4]. In order to obtain information on molecular mechanisms involved in anergy and immunoregulation, we have compared expression levels of 1176 genes in anergic, naive, and recently activated CD4+ T cells of the same specificity by gene array analysis. The results provide a plausible explanation for the anergic phenotype in terms of proliferation, provide new information on the surface phenotype of in vivo-generated anergic CD4+ T cells, and yield clues with regard to new candidate genes that may be responsible for the restricted cytokine production of in vivo-anergized CD4+ T cells. The molecular fingerprints of such T cells should enable the tracking of this small population in the normal organism and the study of their role in immunoregulation.     

T cell effector function and anergy avoidance are quantitatively linked to cell division

We have shown previously that T cells activated by optimal TCR and CD28 ligation exhibit marked proliferative heterogeneity, and approximately 40% of these activated cells fail entirely to participate in clonal expansion. To address how prior cell division influences the subsequent function of primary T cells at the single cell level, primary CD4+ T cells were subjected to polyclonal stimulation, sorted based on the number of cell divisions they had undergone, and restimulated by ligation of TCR/CD28. We find that individual CD4+ T cells exhibit distinct secondary response patterns that depend upon their prior division history, such that cells that undergo more rounds of division show incrementally greater IL-2 production and proliferation in response to restimulation. CD4+ T cells that fail to divide after activation exist in a profoundly hyporesponsive state that is refractory to both TCR/CD28-mediated and IL-2R-mediated proliferative signals. We find that this anergic state is associated with defects in both TCR-coupled activation of the p42/44 mitogen-activated protein kinase (extracellular signal-related kinase 1/2) and IL-2-mediated down-regulation of the cell cycle inhibitor p27kip1. However, these defects are selective, as TCR-mediated intracellular calcium flux and IL-2R-coupled STAT5 activation remain intact in these cells. Therefore, the process of cell division or cell cycle progression plays an integral role in anergy avoidance in primary T cells, and may represent a driving force in the formation of the effector/memory T cell pool.     

Beta-catenin stabilization extends regulatory T cell survival and induces anergy in nonregulatory T cells

Beta-catenin is a central molecule in the Wnt pathway. Expression of a stable form of beta-catenin on CD4+CD25+ regulatory T (T(reg)) cells resulted in a marked enhancement of survival of these cells in vitro. Furthermore, stable beta-catenin-expressing CD4+CD25+ T(reg) cells outcompeted control T(reg) cells in vivo, and the number of T(reg) cells necessary for protection against inflammatory bowel disease could be substantially reduced when stable beta-catenin-expressing CD4+CD25+ T(reg) cells were used instead of control T(reg) cells. Expression of stable beta-catenin on potentially pathogenic CD4+CD25- T cells rendered these cells anergic, and the beta-catenin-mediated induction of anergy occurred even in Foxp3-deficient T cells. Thus, through enhanced survival of existing regulatory T cells, and through induction of unresponsiveness in precursors of T effector cells, beta-catenin stabilization has a powerful effect on the prevention of inflammatory disease.     

Clonal anergy is maintained independently of T cell proliferation

Ag encounter in the absence of proliferation results in the establishment of T cell unresponsiveness, also known as T cell clonal anergy. Anergic T cells fail to proliferate upon restimulation because of the inability to produce IL-2 and to properly regulate the G(1) cell cycle checkpoint. Because optimal TCR and CD28 engagement can elicit IL-2-independent cell cycle progression, we investigated whether CD3/CD28-mediated activation of anergic T cells could overcome G(1) cell cycle block, drive T cell proliferation, and thus reverse clonal anergy. We show here that although antigenic stimulation fails to elicit G(1)-to-S transition, anti-CD3/CD28 mAbs allow proper cell cycle progression and proliferation of anergic T cells. However, CD3/CD28-mediated cell division does not restore Ag responsiveness. Our data instead indicate that reversal of clonal anergy specifically requires an IL-2-dependent, rapamycin-sensitive signal, which is delivered independently of cell proliferation. Thus, by tracing proliferation and Ag responsiveness of individual cells, we show that whereas both TCR/CD28 and IL-2-generated signals can drive T cell proliferation, only IL-2/IL-2R interaction regulates Ag responsiveness, indicating that proliferation and clonal anergy can be independently regulated.     

Conversion of alloantigen-specific CD8+ T cell anergy to CD8+ T cell priming through in vivo ligation of glucocorticoid-induced TNF receptor

In this study, we investigated the effect of an agonistic mAb (DTA-1) against glucocorticoid-induced TNF receptor (GITR) in a murine model of systemic lupus erythematosus-like chronic graft-vs-host disease (cGVHD). A single dose of DTA-1 inhibited the production of anti-DNA IgG1 autoantibody and the development of glomerulonephritis, typical symptoms of cGVHD. DTA-1-treated mice showed clinical and pathological signs of acute GVHD (aGVHD), such as lymphopenia, loss of body weight, increase of donor cell engraftment, and intestinal damage, indicating that DTA-1 shifted cGVHD toward aGVHD. The conversion of cGVHD to aGVHD occurred because DTA-1 prevented donor CD8+ T cell anergy. Functionally active donor CD8+ T cells produced high levels of IFN-gamma and had an elevated CTL activity against host Ags. In in vitro MLR, anergic responder CD8+ T cells were generated, and DTA-1 stimulated the activation of these anergic CD8+ T cells. We further confirmed in vivo that donor CD8+ T cells, but not donor CD4+ T cells, were responsible for the DTA-1-mediated conversion of cGVHD to aGVHD. These results indicate that donor CD8+ T cell anergy is a restriction factor in the development of aGVHD and that in vivo ligation of GITR prevents CD8+ T cell anergy by activating donor CD8+ T cells that otherwise become anergic. In sum, our data suggest GITR as an important costimulatory molecule regulating cGVHD vs aGVHD and as a target for therapeutic intervention in a variety of related diseases.     

Loss of the surface antigen 3G11 characterizes a distinct population of anergic/regulatory T cells in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

T cell anergy is an important mechanism in the induction of peripheral tolerance against autoimmune diseases, yet no surface marker unique to anergic T cells in these diseases has been identified. In this study we induced in vivo anergy by i.v. tolerance against experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis in myelin basic protein TCR transgenic mice, and showed that the hyporesponsiveness of autoantigen-reactive T cells from tolerized mice was associated with a dramatic loss of 3G11, a cell surface molecule on the surface of CD4+ T cells. Purified 3G11-CD4+ T cells lost autoantigen-induced proliferation and IL-2 production, whereas 3G11+CD4+ T cells retained responsiveness. Furthermore, 3G11- T cells actively suppressed proliferation and Th1 cytokine production of 3G11+ T cells and splenocytes of nontolerized mice. Active suppression by 3G11- T cells was at least partially due to soluble immunoregulatory factors, including IL-10. The T regulatory property of 3G11- T cells was confirmed in vivo because the transfer of purified 3G11- T cells effectively suppressed clinical experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis. We conclude that loss of the surface molecule 3G11 characterizes a distinct population of anergic/regulatory T cells. This is the first demonstration of the ability to identify and purify anergic T cells by a distinct cell surface marker in an autoimmune disease and paves the way for a better understanding of the mechanism of tolerance in autoimmune diseases.     

Atorvastatin induces T cell anergy via phosphorylation of ERK1

Modulation of T cell response is a novel property of 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl (HMG)-CoA reductase inhibitors. Previously we reported the benefits of atorvastatin treatment in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis, the murine model of the T cell-mediated autoimmune disorder multiple sclerosis, in which a blockade of the T cell cycle by atorvastatin was attributed to an accumulation of the negative regulator p27(Kip1). We show in this report that, in line with the documented role of p27(Kip1) in T cell anergy, treatment with atorvastatin results in a deficient response to a second productive stimulus in human T cells. This effect of atorvastatin was dependent on HMG-CoA reduction and required IL-10 signaling. Importantly, atorvastatin induced an early and sustained phosphorylation of ERK1, but not ERK2, which was crucial for the induction of anergy. On the basis of the therapeutic impact of HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors, the present findings should pave the way for future therapeutic concepts related to tolerance induction in neuroinflammatory disorders such as multiple sclerosis.     

Autoreactive T cells persist in rats protected against experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis and can be activated through stimulation of innate immunity

Lewis rats can be rendered unresponsive to experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis by immunization with myelin basic protein (MBP), or MBP68-86, the dominant encephalitogenic MBP epitope for this strain, administered in IFA. However, protected rats harbor potentially encephalitogenic T cells, which are maintained in an inactive state. We investigated whether these quiescent effector cells could be activated in vitro. Although these T cells respond poorly to MBP68-86, they proliferate vigorously whether cocultured with MBP68-86 and either IL-2 or IL-12, suggesting that the T cells are in a state of anergy. Moreover, we could activate these anergic T cells with peptide and cytosine-guanine dinucleotide (CpG) oligonucleotide, but not control oligonucleotide, suggesting that products of the innate immune response are capable of activating anergic autoreactive T cells. The activated T cells produced the proinflammatory cytokine, IFN-gamma in response to IL-12, and IL-6 was secreted in response to CpG oligonucleotide. IL-6 has been reported to play a role in T cell activation by blocking T regulatory/suppressor (Treg) cell-mediated suppression through a Toll-like receptor-dependent pathway. However, anti-IL-6 mAb did not block CpG activation of the anergized cells. In contrast, anti-TGF-beta(1) Ab released the unresponsive T cells from the anergic state in the presence of MBP68-86, whereas TGF-beta(1) inhibited proliferation of MBP68-86- plus CpG-activated T cells. Because TGF-beta(1) has previously been implicated in Treg activity, this finding is consistent with a role for Treg cells in maintaining autoreactive T cells in the anergic state.     

A kinetic and dynamic analysis of Foxp3 induced in T cells by TGF-beta

TGF-beta induces Foxp3 expression in stimulated T cells. These Foxp3+ cells (induced regulatory T cells (iTreg)) share functional and therapeutic properties with thymic-derived Foxp3+ regulatory T cells (natural regulatory T cells (nTreg)). We performed a single-cell analysis to better characterize the regulation of Foxp3 in iTreg in vitro and assess their dynamics after transfer in vivo. TGF-beta up-regulated Foxp3 in CD4+Foxp3- T cells only when added within a 2- to 3-day window of CD3/CD28 stimulation. Up to 90% conversion occurred, beginning after 1-2 days of treatment. Foxp3 expression strictly required TCR stimulation but not costimulation and was independent of cell cycling. Removal of TGF-beta led to a loss of Foxp3 expression after an approximately 4-day lag. Most iTreg transferred into wild-type mice down-regulated Foxp3 within 2 days, and these Foxp3- cells were concentrated in the blood, spleen, lung, and liver. Few of the Foxp3- cells were detected by 28 days after transfer. However, some Foxp3+ cells persisted even to this late time point, and these preferentially localized to the lymph nodes and bone marrow. CXCR4 was preferentially expressed on Foxp3+ iTreg within the bone marrow, and CD62L was preferentially expressed on those in the lymph nodes. Like transferred nTreg and in contrast with revertant Foxp3- cells, Foxp3+ iTreg retained CD25 and glucocorticoid-induced TNFR family-related gene. Thus, Foxp3 expression in na?ve-stimulated T cells is transient in vitro, dependent on TGF-beta activity within a highly restricted window after activation and continuous TGF-beta presence. In vivo, a subset of transferred iTreg persist long term, potentially providing a lasting source for regulatory activity after therapeutic administration.