Thinking outside the crystal: complementary approaches for examining transporter conformational change

As the number of high-resolution structures of membrane proteins continues to rise, so has the necessity for techniques to link this structural information to protein function. In the case of transporters, function is achieved via coupling of conformational changes to substrate binding and release. Static structural data alone cannot convey information on these protein movements, but it can provide a high-resolution foundation on which to interpret lower resolution data obtained by complementary approaches. Here, we review selected biochemical and spectroscopic methods for assessing transporter conformational change. In addition to more traditional techniques, we present 1?F-NMR as an attractive method for characterizing conformational change in transporters of known structure. Using biosynthetic labeling, multiple, non-perturbing fluorine-labeled amino acids can be incorporated throughout a protein to serve as reporters of conformational change. Such flexibility in labeling allows characterization of movement in protein regions that may not be accessible via other methods.     

Site-directed fluorescence studies of a prokaryotic ClC antiporter

Channels and transporters of the ClC family serve a variety of physiological functions. Understanding of their gating and transport mechanisms remains incomplete, with disagreement over the extent of protein conformational change involved. Using site-directed fluorescence labeling, we probe ClC-ec1, a prokaryotic ClC, for transport-related structural rearrangements. We specifically label cysteines introduced at several positions in the R helix of ClC-ec1 with AlexaFluor 488, an environment-sensitive fluorophore, and demonstrate that the labeled mutants show H+/Cl- transport activity indistinguishable from that of the wild-type protein. At each position that we examined we observe fluorescence changes upon acidification over the same pH range that is known to activate transport. The fluorescence change is also sensitive to Cl- concentration; furthermore, the Cl- and H+ dependencies are coupled as would be expected if the fluorescence change reflected a conformational change required for transport. Together, the results suggest that the changes in fluorescence report protein conformational changes underlying the transport process. Labeled transporters mutated to remove a glutamate critical to proton-coupled chloride transport retain pH-dependent fluorescence changes, suggesting that multiple residues confer pH dependence on the transport mechanism. These results have implications for models of transport and gating in ClC channels and transporters.     

Examining the Conformational Dynamics of Membrane Proteins in situ with Site-directed Fluorescence Labeling

Two electrode voltage clamp electrophysiology (TEVC) is a powerful tool to investigate the mechanism of ion transport1 for a wide variety of membrane proteins including ion channels², ion pumps³, and transporters⁴. Recent developments have combined site-specific fluorophore labeling alongside TEVC to concurrently examine the conformational dynamics at specific residues and function of these proteins on the surface of single cells.We will describe a method to study the conformational dynamics of membrane proteins by simultaneously monitoring fluorescence and current changes using voltage-clamp fluorometry. This approach can be used to examine the molecular motion of membrane proteins site-specifically following cysteine replacement and site-directed fluorophore labeling^5,6. Furthermore, this method provides an approach to determine distance constraints between specific residues^7,8. This is achieved by selectively attaching donor and acceptor fluorophores to two mutated cysteine residues of interest.In brief, these experiments are performed following functional expression of the desired protein on the surface of Xenopus leavis oocytes. The large surface area of these oocytes enables facile functional measurements and a robust fluorescence signal⁵. It is also possible to readily change the extracellular conditions such as pH, ligand or cations/anions, which can provide further information on the mechanism of membrane proteins⁴. Finally, recent developments have also enabled the manipulation of select internal ions following co-expression with a second protein⁹.Our protocol is described in multiple parts. First, cysteine scanning mutagenesis proceeded by fluorophore labeling is completed at residues located at the interface of the transmembrane and extracellular domains. Subsequent experiments are designed to identify residues which demonstrate large changes in fluorescence intensity (<5%)³ upon a conformational change of the protein. Second, these changes in fluorescence intensity are compared to the kinetic parameters of the membrane protein in order to correlate the conformational dynamics to the function of the protein¹⁰. This enables a rigorous biophysical analysis of the molecular motion of the target protein. Lastly, two residues of the holoenzyme can be labeled with a donor and acceptor fluorophore in order to determine distance constraints using donor photodestruction methods. It is also possible to monitor the relative movement of protein subunits following labeling with a donor and acceptor fluorophore.     

Errata

Abstract

Mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics is an unrivaled tool for studying complex biological systems and diseases in the post-genomic era. In recent years, MS has emerged as a powerful structural biological tool to characterize protein conformation and conformational dynamics. The advantages of MS in structural studies are most evident for membrane proteins such as GPCRs (G protein-coupled receptors), where other well-established structural methods such as X-ray crystallography and NMR remain challenging. For proteins with available high-resolution structures, MS-based structural strategies can provide valuable, previously inaccessible information on protein conformational changes and dynamics, protein motion/flexibility, ligand–protein binding, and protein–protein interfaces. In the past several years, we have developed and adapted a number of MS-based structural approaches, such as CDSiL-MS (Conformational changes and Dynamics using Stable-isotope Labeling and MS), CXMS (Crosslinking/MS) and HDXMS (Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange MS), to study protein structures and conformational dynamics in human β2-adrenegic receptor (β2AR) signaling. In this mini-review, we will highlight several examples demonstrating the power of MS in structural analysis to better elucidate the structural basis of GPCR signaling, particularly through the β-arrestin-mediated GPCR signaling pathway.     

Effects of nucleotide binding to LmrA: A combined MAS-NMR and solution NMR study

ABC transporters are fascinating examples of fine-tuned molecular machines that use the energy from ATP hydrolysis to translocate a multitude of substrates across biological membranes. While structural details have emerged on many members of this large protein superfamily, a number of functional details are still under debate. High resolution structures yield valuable insights into protein function, but it is the combination of structural, functional and dynamic insights that facilitates a complete understanding of the workings of their complex molecular mechanisms. NMR is a technique well-suited to investigate proteins in atomic resolution while taking their dynamic properties into account. It thus nicely complements other structural techniques, such as X-ray crystallography, that have contributed high-resolution data to the architectural understanding of ABC transporters. Here, we describe the heterologous expression of LmrA, an ABC exporter from Lactococcus lactis, in Escherichia coli. This allows for more flexible isotope labeling for nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies and the easy study of LmrA's multidrug resistance phenotype. We use a combination of solid-state magic angle spinning (MAS) on the reconstituted transporter and solution NMR on its isolated nucleotide binding domain to investigate consequences of nucleotide binding to LmrA. We find that nucleotide binding affects the protein globally, but that NMR is also able to pinpoint local dynamic effects to specific residues, such as the Walker A motif's conserved lysine residue.     

The dynamic duo: Combining NMR and small angle scattering in structural biology

Structural biology provides essential information for elucidating molecular mechanisms that underlie biological function. Advances in hardware, sample preparation, experimental methods, and computational approaches now enable structural analysis of protein complexes with increasing complexity that more closely represent biologically entities in the cellular environment. Integrated multidisciplinary approaches are required to overcome limitations of individual methods and take advantage of complementary aspects provided by different structural biology techniques. Although X‐ray crystallography remains the method of choice for structural analysis of large complexes, crystallization of flexible systems is often difficult and does typically not provide insights into conformational dynamics present in solution. Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) is well‐suited to study dynamics at picosecond to second time scales, and to map binding interfaces even of large systems at residue resolution but suffers from poor sensitivity with increasing molecular weight. Small angle scattering (SAS) methods provide low resolution information in solution and can characterize dynamics and conformational equilibria complementary to crystallography and NMR. The combination of NMR, crystallography, and SAS is, thus, very useful for analysis of the structure and conformational dynamics of (large) protein complexes in solution. In high molecular weight systems, where NMR data are often sparse, SAS provides additional structural information and can differentiate between NMR‐derived models. Scattering data can also validate the solution conformation of a crystal structure and indicate the presence of conformational equilibria. Here, we review current state‐of‐the‐art approaches for combining NMR, crystallography, and SAS data to characterize protein complexes in solution.     

Protonation of Glu135 Facilitates the Outward-to-Inward Structural Transition of Fucose Transporter

Major facilitator superfamily (MFS) transporters typically need to alternatingly sample the outward-facing and inward-facing conformations, in order to transport the substrate across membrane. To understand the mechanism, in this work, we focused on one MFS member, the L-fucose/H⁺ symporter (FucP), whose crystal structure exhibits an outward-open conformation. Previous experiments imply several residues critical to the substrate/proton binding and structural transition of FucP, among which Glu¹³⁵, located in the periplasm-accessible vestibule, is supposed as being involved in both proton translocation and conformational change of the protein. Here, the structural transition of FucP in presence of substrate was investigated using molecular-dynamics simulations. By combining the equilibrium and accelerated simulations as well as thermodynamic calculations, not only was the large-scale conformational change from the outward-facing to inward-facing state directly observed, but also the free energy change during the structural transition was calculated. The simulations confirm the critical role of Glu¹³⁵, whose protonation facilitates the outward-to-inward structural transition both by energetically favoring the inward-facing conformation in thermodynamics and by reducing the free energy barrier along the reaction pathway in kinetics. Our results may help the mechanistic studies of both FucP and other MFS transporters.     

High-Resolution NMR Reveals Secondary Structure and Folding of Amino Acid Transporter from Outer Chloroplast Membrane

Solving high-resolution structures for membrane proteins continues to be a daunting challenge in the structural biology community. In this study we report our high-resolution NMR results for a transmembrane protein, outer envelope protein of molar mass 16 kDa (OEP16), an amino acid transporter from the outer membrane of chloroplasts. Three-dimensional, high-resolution NMR experiments on the ¹³C, ¹⁵N, ²H-triply-labeled protein were used to assign protein backbone resonances and to obtain secondary structure information. The results yield over 95% assignment of N, H_N, CO, C_α, and C_β chemical shifts, which is essential for obtaining a high resolution structure from NMR data. Chemical shift analysis from the assignment data reveals experimental evidence for the first time on the location of the secondary structure elements on a per residue basis. In addition T _1Z and T₂ relaxation experiments were performed in order to better understand the protein dynamics. Arginine titration experiments yield an insight into the amino acid residues responsible for protein transporter function. The results provide the necessary basis for high-resolution structural determination of this important plant membrane protein.     

Molecular basis of negative co-operativity in rabbit muscle glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase

The interactions of rabbit muscle glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase with NAD⁺ and with its fluorescent derivative 1, N⁶-etheno-adenine dinucleotide were investigated using a variety of spectroscopic methods. These techniques included: difference spectroscopy, circular dichroism, fluorescence and circular polarized luminescence. It was found that the greatest structural change in the protein tetramer occurs upon binding of the first mole of coenzyme. We have also demonstrated that progressive structural changes occur at the adenine subsite in the NAD⁺ binding site as a function of coenzyme saturation. These conformational changes are probably responsible for the progressive decrease in the affinity towards the coenzyme. It was also found that every NAD⁺ molecule induces the same conformational change of the nicotinamide subsite. These results offer a molecular explanation for the negative co-operativity in the binding of the coenzyme, without a change in the catalytic power of the NAD⁺ site as a function of coenzyme saturation. These results also offer a new explanation for the fact that enzyme exhibits half-of-the-sites reactivity towards certain ligands and full-site reactivity towards others. It is suggested that those ligands interacting at the adenine subsite of the NAD⁺ binding site induce the half-of-the-sites reactivity.Our results support the view that both the negative co-operativity in coenzyme binding and half-of-the-sites reactivity are due to ligand-induced conformational changes on an a priori symmetric glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase molecule.     

Photoaffinity labeling combined with mass spectrometric approaches as a tool for structural proteomics

Protein chemistry, such as crosslinking and photoaffinity labeling, in combination with modern mass spectrometric techniques, can provide information regarding protein–protein interactions beyond that normally obtained from protein identification and characterization studies. While protein crosslinking can make tertiary and quaternary protein structure information available, photoaffinity labeling can be used to obtain structural data about ligand–protein interaction sites, such as oligonucleotide–protein, drug–protein and protein–protein interaction. In this article, we describe mass spectrometry-based photoaffinity labeling methodologies currently used and discuss their current limitations. We also discuss their potential as a common approach to structural proteomics for providing 3D information regarding the binding region, which ultimately will be used for molecular modeling and structure-based drug design.     

Analyzing Protein Dynamics Using Hydrogen Exchange Mass Spectrometry

All cellular processes depend on the functionality of proteins. Although the functionality of a given protein is the direct consequence of its unique amino acid sequence, it is only realized by the folding of the polypeptide chain into a single defined three-dimensional arrangement or more commonly into an ensemble of interconverting conformations. Investigating the connection between protein conformation and its function is therefore essential for a complete understanding of how proteins are able to fulfill their great variety of tasks. One possibility to study conformational changes a protein undergoes while progressing through its functional cycle is hydrogen-¹H/²H-exchange in combination with high-resolution mass spectrometry (HX-MS). HX-MS is a versatile and robust method that adds a new dimension to structural information obtained by e.g. crystallography. It is used to study protein folding and unfolding, binding of small molecule ligands, protein-protein interactions, conformational changes linked to enzyme catalysis, and allostery. In addition, HX-MS is often used when the amount of protein is very limited or crystallization of the protein is not feasible. Here we provide a general protocol for studying protein dynamics with HX-MS and describe as an example how to reveal the interaction interface of two proteins in a complex.        

Photoaffinity labeling combined with mass spectrometric approaches as a tool for structural proteomics

Protein chemistry, such as crosslinking and photoaffinity labeling, in combination with modern mass spectrometric techniques, can provide information regarding protein-protein interactions beyond that normally obtained from protein identification and characterization studies. While protein crosslinking can make tertiary and quaternary protein structure information available, photoaffinity labeling can be used to obtain structural data about ligand-protein interaction sites, such as oligonucleotide-protein, drug-protein and protein-protein interaction. In this article, we describe mass spectrometry-based photoaffinity labeling methodologies currently used and discuss their current limitations. We also discuss their potential as a common approach to structural proteomics for providing 3D information regarding the binding region, which ultimately will be used for molecular modeling and structure-based drug design.     

In Silico Analysis of Natural Resistance-Associated Macrophage Protein (NRAMP) Family of Transporters in Rice

In Oryza sativa (rice) there are seven members in the NRAMP (natural resistance- associated macrophage protein) family of transporter proteins. They have been identified as OsNRAMP1, OsNRAMP2, OsNRAMP3, OsNRAMP4, OsNRAMP5, OsNRAMP6 and OsNRAMP7. Several metal ions like Zn²⁺, Mn²⁺, Fe²⁺, Cd²⁺ etc. have been studied to be transported via NRAMP transporter proteins in rice plant. In spite of this, very little information is available regarding these transporters. Hence it is important to computationally predict and characterize the OsNRAMP family of transporters for studying and understanding their molecular insights in future studies. For this purpose, various in silico methods and tools were used for the characterization of OsNRAMP family of transporter proteins. Physico-chemical properties of the protein sequences were calculated, putative transmembrane domains (TMDs) and conserved motif signatures were determined and their interaction partners were predicted. 3D models of all the members of OsNRAMP transporters were generated using online structure prediction tool followed by their analysis. In silico microarray analysis was done to understand the expression pattern of these transporters in rice plant. Currently, only limited knowledge is available about the structural and functional aspects of these transporters, hence this study would provide more theoretical information about them.     

Integrating Molecular Models Into CryoEM Heterogeneity Analysis Using Scalable High-resolution Deep Gaussian Mixture Models

Resolving the structural variability of proteins is often key to understanding the structure–function relationship of those macromolecular machines. Single particle analysis using Cryogenic electron microscopy (CryoEM), combined with machine learning algorithms, provides a way to reveal the dynamics within the protein system from noisy micrographs. Here, we introduce an improved computational method that uses Gaussian mixture models for protein structure representation and deep neural networks for conformation space embedding. By integrating information from molecular models into the heterogeneity analysis, we can analyze continuous protein conformational changes using structural information at the frequency of 1/3 Å⁻¹, and present the results in a more interpretable form.     

Atomistic models of ion and solute transport by the sodium-dependent secondary active transporters

The recent determination of high-resolution crystal structures of several transporters offers unprecedented insights into the structural mechanisms behind secondary transport. These proteins utilize the facilitated diffusion of the ions down their electrochemical gradients to transport the substrate against its concentration gradient. The structural studies revealed striking similarities in the structural organization of ion and solute binding sites and a well-conserved inverted-repeat topology between proteins from several gene families. In this paper we will overview recent atomistic simulations applied to study the mechanisms of selective binding of ion and substrate in LeuT, Glt, vSGLT and hSERT as well as its consequences for the transporter conformational dynamics. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Membrane protein structure and function.     

Conformational entropy changes upon lactose binding to the carbohydrate recognition domain of galectin-3

The conformational entropy of proteins can make significant contributions to the free energy of ligand binding. NMR spin relaxation enables site-specific investigation of conformational entropy, via order parameters that parameterize local reorientational fluctuations of rank-2 tensors. Here we have probed the conformational entropy of lactose binding to the carbohydrate recognition domain of galectin-3 (Gal3), a protein that plays an important role in cell growth, cell differentiation, cell cycle regulation, and apoptosis, making it a potential target for therapeutic intervention in inflammation and cancer. We used ¹⁵N spin relaxation experiments and molecular dynamics simulations to monitor the backbone amides and secondary amines of the tryptophan and arginine side chains in the ligand-free and lactose-bound states of Gal3. Overall, we observe good agreement between the experimental and computed order parameters of the ligand-free and lactose-bound states. Thus, the ¹⁵N spin relaxation data indicate that the molecular dynamics simulations provide reliable information on the conformational entropy of the binding process. The molecular dynamics simulations reveal a correlation between the simulated order parameters and residue-specific backbone entropy, re-emphasizing that order parameters provide useful estimates of local conformational entropy. The present results show that the protein backbone exhibits an increase in conformational entropy upon binding lactose, without any accompanying structural changes.     

The structural basis of secondary active transport mechanisms

Secondary active transporters couple the free energy of the electrochemical potential of one solute to the transmembrane movement of another. As a basic mechanistic explanation for their transport function the model of alternating access was put forward more than 40 years ago, and has been supported by numerous kinetic, biochemical and biophysical studies. According to this model, the transporter exposes its substrate binding site(s) to one side of the membrane or the other during transport catalysis, requiring a substantial conformational change of the carrier protein. In the light of recent structural data for a number of secondary transport proteins, we analyze the model of alternating access in more detail, and correlate it with specific structural and chemical properties of the transporters, such as their assignment to different functional states in the catalytic cycle of the respective transporter, the definition of substrate binding sites, the type of movement of the central part of the carrier harboring the substrate binding site, as well as the impact of symmetry on fold-specific conformational changes. Besides mediating the transmembrane movement of solutes, the mechanism of secondary carriers inherently involves a mechanistic coupling of substrate flux to the electrochemical potential of co-substrate ions or solutes. Mainly because of limitations in resolution of available transporter structures, this important aspect of secondary transport cannot yet be substantiated by structural data to the same extent as the conformational change aspect. We summarize the concepts of coupling in secondary transport and discuss them in the context of the available evidence for ion binding to specific sites and the impact of the ions on the conformational state of the carrier protein, which together lead to mechanistic models for coupling.     

Solutes modify a conformational transition in a membrane transport protein

The bacterial outer-membrane vitamin B₁₂ transporter, BtuB, undergoes a dramatic order-to-disorder transition in its N-terminal energy-coupling motif (Ton box) upon substrate binding. Here, site-directed spin labeling (SDSL) is used to show that a range of solutes prevents this conformational change when ligand is bound to BtuB, resulting in a more ordered Ton box structure. For each solute examined, the data indicate that solutes effectively block this conformational transition through an osmotic mechanism. The molecular weight dependence of this solute effect has been examined for a series of polyethylene glycols, and a sharp molecular weight cutoff is observed. This cutoff indicates that solutes are preferentially excluded from a cavity within the protein as well as the protein surface. Furthermore, the sensitivity of the conformational change to solution osmolality is consistent with a structural model predicted by SDSL. When the Ton box is unfolded by detergents or mutations (rather than by ligand binding), solutes, such as polyethylene glycols and salts, also induce a more structured compacted conformation. These results suggest that conformational changes in this class of outer membrane transporters, which involve modest energy differences and changes in hydration, may be modulated by a range of solutes, including solutes typically used in protein crystallization.     

Planar substrate-binding site dictates the specificity of ECF-type nickel/cobalt transporters

The energy-coupling factor (ECF) transporters are multi-subunit protein complexes that mediate uptake of transition-metal ions and vitamins in about 50% of the prokaryotes, including bacteria and archaea. Biological and structural studies have been focused on ECF transporters for vitamins, but the molecular mechanism by which ECF systems transport metal ions from the environment remains unknown. Here we report the first crystal structure of a NikM, TtNikM2, the substrate-binding component (S component) of an ECF-type nickel transporter from Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis. In contrast to the structures of the vitamin-specific S proteins with six transmembrane segments (TSs), TtNikM2 possesses an additional TS at its N-terminal region, resulting in an extracellular N-terminus. The highly conserved N-terminal loop inserts into the center of TtNikM2 and occludes a region corresponding to the substrate-binding sites of the vitamin-specific S components. Nickel binds to NikM via its coordination to four nitrogen atoms, which are derived from Met1, His2 and His67 residues. These nitrogen atoms form an approximately square-planar geometry, similar to that of the metal ion-binding sites in the amino-terminal Cu²⁺- and Ni²⁺-binding (ATCUN) motif. Replacements of residues in NikM contributing to nickel coordination compromised the Ni-transport activity. Furthermore, systematic quantum chemical investigation indicated that this geometry enables NikM to also selectively recognize Co²⁺. Indeed, the structure of TtNikM2 containing a bound Co²⁺ ion has almost no conformational change compared to the structure that contains a nickel ion. Together, our data reveal an evolutionarily conserved mechanism underlying the metal selectivity of EcfS proteins, and provide insights into the ion-translocation process mediated by ECF transporters.