Behind the wheel and under the hood: Functions of cyclin-dependent kinases in response to DNA damage

Cell division and the response to genotoxic stress are intimately connected in eukaryotes, for example, by checkpoint pathways that signal the presence of DNA damage or its ongoing repair to the cell cycle machinery, leading to reversible arrest or apoptosis. Recent studies reveal another connection: the cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) that govern both DNA synthesis (S) phase and mitosis directly coordinate DNA repair processes with progression through the cell cycle. In both mammalian cells and yeast, the two major modes of double strand break (DSB) repair – homologous recombination (HR) and non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) – are reciprocally regulated during the cell cycle. In yeast, the cell cycle kinase Cdk1 directly promotes DSB repair by HR during the G2 phase. In mammalian cells, loss of Cdk2, which is active throughout S and G2 phases, results in defective DNA damage repair and checkpoint signaling. Here we provide an overview of data that implicate CDKs in the regulation of DNA damage responses in yeast and metazoans. In yeast, CDK activity is required at multiple points in the HR pathway; the precise roles of CDKs in mammalian HR have yet to be determined. Finally, we consider how the two different, and in some cases opposing, roles of CDKs – as targets of negative regulation by checkpoint signaling and as positive effectors of repair pathway selection and function – could be balanced to produce a coordinated and effective response to DNA damage.     

Inactivation of the cyclin-dependent kinase Cdc28 abrogates cell cycle arrest induced by DNA damage and disassembly of mitotic spindles in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Eukaryotic cells may halt cell cycle progression following exposure to certain exogenous agents that damage cellular structures such as DNA or microtubules. This phenomenon has been attributed to functions of cellular control mechanisms termed checkpoints. Studies with the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe and mammalian cells have led to the conclusion that cell cycle arrest in response to inhibition of DNA replication or DNA damage is a result of down-regulation of the cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs). Based on these studies, it has been proposed that inhibition of the CDK activity may constitute a general mechanism for checkpoint controls. Observations made with the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, however, appear to disagree with this model. It has been shown that high levels of mitotic CDK activity are present in the budding yeast cells arrested in G2/mitosis as the result of DNA damage or replication inhibition. In this report, we show that a novel mutant allele of the CDC28 gene, encoding the budding yeast CDK, allowed cell cycle passage through mitosis and nuclear division in the presence of DNA damage and the microtubule toxin nocodazole at a restrictive temperature. Unlike the checkpoint-defective mutations in CDKs of fission yeast and mammalian cells, the cdc28 mutation that we identified was recessive and resulted in a loss of the CDK activity, including the Clb2-, Clb5-, and Clb6-associated, but not the Clb3-associated, CDK activities. Examination of several known alleles of cdc28 revealed that they were also, albeit partially, defective in cell cycle arrest in response to UV-generated DNA damage. These findings suggest that Cdc28 kinase in budding yeast may be required for cell cycle arrest resulting from DNA damage and disassembly of mitotic spindles.     

A plant solution to the CDK conundrum in the DNA damage response

To cope with DNA damage, proliferating cells have evolved sophisticated mechanisms including cell cycle arrest and activation of DNA repair. Paradoxically, various DNA damage response pathways are promoted by cyclin‐dependent kinase (CDK) activity, while cell cycle remains arrested. New work in The EMBO Journal shows that plant cells have evolved intricate ways to resolve this dilemma, by utilizing distinct and specialized CDKs for cell cycle progression and homologous recombination.     

Ambient particulate matter induces alveolar epithelial cell cycle arrest: role of G1 cyclins

We hypothesized that the ambient air pollution particles (particulate matter; PM) induce cell cycle arrest in alveolar epithelial cells (AEC). Exposure of PM (25microg/cm(2)) to AEC induced cells cycle arrest in G1 phase, inhibited DNA synthesis, blocked cell proliferation and caused decrease in cyclin E, A, D1 and Cyclin E- cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK)-2 kinase activity after 4h. PM induced upregulation of CDK inhibitor, p21 protein and p21 activity in AEC. SiRNAp21 blocked PM-induced downregulation of cyclins and AEC G1 arrest. Accordingly, we provide the evidence that PM induces AEC G1 arrest by altered regulation of G1 cyclins and CDKs.     

DNA damage invokes mismatch repair-dependent cyclin D1 attenuation and retinoblastoma signaling pathways to inhibit CDK2.

DNA-damage evokes cell cycle checkpoints, which function to maintain genomic integrity. The retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (RB) and mismatch repair complexes are known to contribute to the appropriate cellular response to specific types of DNA damage. However, the signaling pathways through which these proteins impact the cell cycle machinery have not been explicitly determined. RB-deficient murine embryo fibroblasts continued a high degree of DNA replication following the induction of cisplatin damage, but were inhibited for G(2)/M progression. This damage led to RB dephosphorylation/activation and subsequent RB-dependent attenuation of cyclin A and CDK2 activity. In both Rb+/+ and Rb -/- cells, cyclin D1 expression was attenuated following DNA damage. As cyclin D1 is a critical determinant of RB phosphorylation and cell cycle progression, we probed the pathway through which cyclin D1 degradation occurs in response to DNA damage. We found that attenuation of endogenous cyclin D1 is dependent on multiple mismatch repair proteins. We demonstrate that the mismatch repair-dependent attenuation of endogenous cyclin D1 is critical for attenuation of CDK2 activity and induction of cell cycle checkpoints. Together, these studies couple the activity of the retinoblastoma and mismatch repair tumor suppressor pathways through the degradation of cyclin D1 and dual attenuation of CDK2 activity.     

Role and regulation of p53 during an ultraviolet radiation-induced G1 cell cycle arrest.

p53 can play a key role in response to DNA damage by activating a G1 cell cycle arrest. However, the importance of p53 in the cell cycle response to UV radiation is unclear. In this study, we used normal and repair-deficient cells to examine the role and regulation of p53 in response to UV radiation. A dose-dependent G1 arrest was observed in normal and repair-deficient cells exposed to UV. Expression of HPV16-E6, or a dominant-negative p53 mutant that inactivates wildtype p53, caused cells to become resistant to this UV-induced G1 arrest. However, a G1 to S-phase delay was still observed after UV treatment of cells in which p53 was inactivated. These results indicate that UV can inhibit G1 to S-phase progression through p53-dependent and independent mechanisms. Cells deficient in the repair of UV-induced DNA damage were more susceptible to a G1 arrest after UV treatment than cells with normal repair capacity. Moreover, no G1 arrest was observed in cells that had completed DNA repair prior to monitoring their movement from G1 into S-phase. Finally, p53 was stabilized under conditions of a UV-induced G1 arrest and unstable when cells had completed DNA repair and progressed from G1 into S-phase. These results suggest that unrepaired DNA damage is the signal for the stabilization of p53, and a subsequent G1 phase cell cycle arrest in UV-irradiated cells.     

Role of p21WAF1 in the cellular response to UV

UV or g irradiation mediated DNA damage activates p53 and induces cell cycle arrest. Induction of cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor p21WAF1 by p53 after DNA damage plays an important role in cell cycle arrest after gamma irradiation. The p53 mediated cell cycle arrest has been postulated to allow cells to repair the DNA damage. Repair of UV damaged DNA occurs primarily by the nucleotide excision pathway (NER). It is known that p21WAF1 binds PCNA and inhibits PCNA function in DNA replication. PCNA is also required for repair by NER but there have been conflicting reports on whether p21WAF1 can inhibit PCNA function in NER. It has therefore been difficult to integrate the UV induced cell cycle arrest by p21 in the context of repair of UV damaged DNA. A recent study reported that p21WAF1 protein is degraded after low but not high doses of UV irradiation, that cell cycle arrest after UV is p21 independent, and that at low dose UV irradiation p21WAF1 degradation is essential for optimal DNA repair. These findings shed new light on the role of p21 in the cellular response to UV and clarify some outstanding issues concerning p21WAF1 function.     

Role of p21WAF1 in the Cellular Response to UV

UV or gamma irradiation mediated DNA damage activates p53 and induces cell cycle arrest. Induction of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p21WAF1 by p53 after DNA damage plays an important role in cell cycle arrest after gamma irradiation. The p53 mediated cell cycle arrest has been postulated to allow cells to repair the DNA damage. Repair of UV damaged DNA occurs primarily by the nucleotide excision pathway (NER). It is known that p21WAF1 binds PCNA and inhibits PCNA function in DNA replication. PCNA is also required for repair by NER but there have been conflicting reports on whether p21 can inhibit PCNA function in NER. It has therefore been difficult to integrate the UV induced cell cycle arrest by p21 in the context of repair of UV damaged DNA. A recent study reported that p21WAF1 protein is degraded after low but not high doses of UV irradiation, that cell cycle arrest after UV is p21 independent, and that at low dose UV irradiation p21 degradation is essential for optimal DNA repair. These findings shed new light on the role of p21 in the cellular response to UV and clarify some outstanding issues concerning p21 function.     

Radiation Dose-Dependent Maintenance of G2 Arrest Requires Retinoblastoma Protein

In response to ionizing radiation (IR), cell cycle checkpoints are activated to provide time for DNA repair. Several different checkpoint mechanisms have been elucidated. However, mechanisms that regulate the duration of cell cycle arrest are not understood. Previous studies have shown that the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor protein (RB) is required for radiation-induced G1 arrest. Working with primary fibroblasts derived from Rb+/+ and Rb-/- mouse embryos, we show that RB also regulates the duration of G2 arrest. The initial G2 checkpoint response is enhanced in Rb-/- cells due to a defect in G1 arrest. However, the permanent arrest in G2 induced by higher doses of IR does not occur in Rb-/- cells. Rb-/- cells either resumed proliferation or underwent apoptosis at IR doses that caused the majority of Rb+/+ cells to arrest permanently in G2. The prolongation of G2 arrest in Rb+/+ cells correlated with a gradual accumulation of hypophosphorylated RB. Thus, regulation of the RB function may be an important aspect in the maintenance of cell cycle checkpoints in DNA damage response.

Key Words:

RB phosphorylation, Ionizing radiation, DNA damage, G2 checkpoint, Mouse embryo fibroblasts     

Radiation dose-dependent maintenance of G(2) arrest requires retinoblastoma protein

In response to ionizing radiation (IR), cell cycle checkpoints are activated to provide time for DNA repair. Several different checkpoint mechanisms have been elucidated. However, mechanisms that regulate the duration of cell cycle arrest are not understood. Previous studies have shown that the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor protein (RB) is required for radiation-induced G1 arrest. Working with primary fibroblasts derived from Rb+/+ and Rb-/- mouse embryos, we show that RB also regulates the duration of G2 arrest. The initial G2 checkpoint response is enhanced in Rb-/- cells due to a defect in G1 arrest. However, the permanent arrest in G2 induced by higher doses of IR does not occur in Rb-/- cells. Rb-/- cells either resumed proliferation or underwent apoptosis at IR doses that caused the majority of Rb+/+ cells to arrest permanently in G2. The prolongation of G2 arrest in Rb+/+ cells correlated with a gradual accumulation of hypophosphorylated RB. Thus, regulation of the RB function may be an important aspect in the maintenance of cell cycle checkpoints in DNA damage response.     

Cell Cycle Activation in Postmitotic Neurons is Essential for DNA Repair

Increasing evidence indicates that maintenance of neuronal homeostasis involves theactivation of the cell cycle machinery in postmitotic neurons. Our recent findings suggestthat cell cycle activation is essential for DNA damage-induced neuronal apoptosis.However, whether the cell division cycle also participates in DNA repair and survival ofpostmitotic, terminally differentiated neurons, is unknown. Here, we tested thehypothesis that G1 phase components contribute to the repair of DNA and are involved inthe DNA damage response of postmitotic neurons. In cortical terminally differentiatedneurons, treatment with subtoxic concentrations of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) causedrepairable DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) and the activation of G1 components of thecell cycle machinery. Importantly, DNA repair was attenuated if cyclin-dependentkinases CDK4 and CDK6, essential elements of G0→G1 transition, were suppressed.Our data suggest that G1 cell cycle components are involved in DNA repair and survivalof postmitotic neurons.     

Speedy/Ringo C regulates S and G2 phase progression in human cells

Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) control cell cycle transitions and progression. In addition to their activation via binding to cyclins, CDKs can be activated via binding to an unrelated class of cell cycle regulators termed Speedy/Ringo (S/R) proteins. Although mammals contain at least five distinct Speedy/Ringo homologues, the specific functions of members of this growing family of CDK activators remain largely unknown. We investigated the cell cycle roles of human Speedy/Ringo C in HEK293 cells. Down-regulation of Speedy/Ringo C by RNA interference delayed S and G2 progression whereas ectopic expression had the opposite effect, reducing S and G2/M populations. Double thymidine arrest and release experiments showed that overexpression of Speedy/Ringo C promoted late S phase progression. Using a novel three-color FACS protocol to determine the length of G2 phase, we found that the suppression of Speedy/Ringo C by RNAi prolonged G2 phase by ~30 min whereas ectopic expression of Speedy/Ringo C shortened G2 phase by ~25 min. In addition, overexpression of Speedy/Ringo C disrupted the G2 DNA damage checkpoint, increased cell death and caused a cell cycle delay at the G1-to-S transition. These observations indicate that CDK-Speedy/Ringo C complexes positively regulate cell cycle progression during the late S and G2 phases of the cell cycle.     

Activation of the Cdc42p GTPase by cyclin-dependent protein kinases in budding yeast

Cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) trigger essential cell cycle processes including critical events in G1 phase that culminate in bud emergence, spindle pole body duplication, and DNA replication. Localized activation of the Rho-type GTPase Cdc42p is crucial for establishment of cell polarity during G1, but CDK targets that link the Cdc42p module with cell growth and cell cycle commitment have remained largely elusive. Here, we identify the GTPase-activating protein (GAP) Rga2p as an important substrate related to the cell polarity function of G1 CDKs. Overexpression of RGA2 in the absence of functional Pho85p or Cdc28p CDK complexes is toxic, due to an inability to polarize growth. Mutation of CDK consensus sites in Rga2p that are phosphorylated both in vivo and in vitro by Pho85p and Cdc28p CDKs results in a loss of G1 phase-specific phosphorylation. A failure to phosphorylate Rga2p leads to defects in localization and impaired polarized growth, in a manner dependent on Rga2p GAP function. Taken together, our data suggest that CDK-dependent phosphorylation restrains Rga2p activity to ensure appropriate activation of Cdc42p during cell polarity establishment. Inhibition of GAPs by CDK phosphorylation may be a general mechanism to promote proper G1-phase progression.     

Dual role of CDKs in DNA repair: to be, or not to be

The maintenance of genome integrity is essential for the regulation of cell proliferation and differentiation. DNA must be accurately duplicated and segregated to daughter cells at cell division, a process that is primarily regulated by cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs). During cell growth, however, it is inevitable that DNA breaks will occur due to endogenous and exogenous stresses. Interestingly, there is increasing evidence that the catalytic activities of CDKs play critical roles in the DNA damage response, especially in the case of damage repaired by the homologous recombination (HR) pathway. In this review, we outline current knowledge of CDK regulation and its roles both in the unperturbed cell cycle and in DNA damage responses, and discuss the physiological roles of CDKs in HR repair.     

Differential contribution of inhibitory phosphorylation of CDC2 and CDK2 for unperturbed cell cycle control and DNA integrity checkpoints

Inhibition of cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs) by Thr14/Tyr15 phosphorylation is critical for normal cell cycle progression and is a converging event for several cell cycle checkpoints. In this study, we compared the relative contribution of inhibitory phosphorylation for cyclin A/B1-CDC2 and cyclin A/E-CDK2 complexes. We found that inhibitory phosphorylation plays a major role in the regulation of CDC2 but only a minor role for CDK2 during the unperturbed cell cycle of HeLa cells. The relative importance of inhibitory phosphorylation of CDC2 and CDK2 may reflect their distinct cellular functions. Despite this, expression of nonphosphorylation mutants of both CDC2 and CDK2 triggered unscheduled histone H3 phosphorylation early in the cell cycle and was cytotoxic. DNA damage by a radiomimetic drug or replication block by hydroxyurea stimulated a buildup of cyclin B1 but was accompanied by an increase of inhibitory phosphorylation of CDC2. After DNA damage and replication block, all cyclin-CDK pairs that control S phase and mitosis were to different degrees inhibited by phosphorylation. Ectopic expression of nonphosphorylated CDC2 stimulated DNA replication, histone H3 phosphorylation, and cell division even after DNA damage. Similarly, a nonphosphorylation mutant of CDK2, but not CDK4, disrupted the G2 DNA damage checkpoint. Finally, CDC25A, CDC25B, a dominant-negative CHK1, but not CDC25C or a dominant-negative WEE1, stimulated histone H3 phosphorylation after DNA damage. These data suggest differential contributions for the various regulators of Thr14/Tyr15 phosphorylation in normal cell cycle and during the DNA damage checkpoint.     

CDK4/6 inhibitors induce replication stress to cause long‐term cell cycle withdrawal

CDK4/6 inhibitors arrest the cell cycle in G1‐phase. They are approved to treat breast cancer and are also undergoing clinical trials against a range of other tumour types. To facilitate these efforts, it is important to understand why a cytostatic arrest in G1 causes long‐lasting effects on tumour growth. Here, we demonstrate that a prolonged G1 arrest following CDK4/6 inhibition downregulates replisome components and impairs origin licencing. Upon release from that arrest, many cells fail to complete DNA replication and exit the cell cycle in a p53‐dependent manner. If cells fail to withdraw from the cell cycle following DNA replication problems, they enter mitosis and missegregate chromosomes causing excessive DNA damage, which further limits their proliferative potential. These effects are observed in a range of tumour types, including breast cancer, implying that genotoxic stress is a common outcome of CDK4/6 inhibition. This unanticipated ability of CDK4/6 inhibitors to induce DNA damage now provides a rationale to better predict responsive tumour types and effective combination therapies, as demonstrated by the fact that CDK4/6 inhibition induces sensitivity to chemotherapeutics that also cause replication stress.     

G(1)/S CDK is inhibited to restrain mitotic onset when DNA replication is blocked in fission yeast

Cyclin-dependent kinase (CDK) Tyr15 phosphorylation plays a major role in regulating G(2)/M CDKs, but the role of this phosphorylation in regulating G(1)/S CDKs is less clear. We have studied the regulation and function of Cdc2-Tyr15 phosphorylation in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe G(1)/S CDK Cig2/Cdc2. This complex is subject to high level Cdc2-Tyr15 phosphorylation inhibiting its kinase activity in hydroxyurea-treated cells blocked in S-phase. We show that this Tyr15 phosphorylation is required to maintain efficient mitotic checkpoint arrest, because Cig2 accumulates during the block and this accumulation can advance mitotic onset. This mitotic induction operates, at least in part, through activation of the normal G(2)/M CDK complex Cdc13/Cdc2. Thus, Tyr15 phosphorylation of G(1)/S CDK complexes is important in the checkpoint control blocking mitotic onset when DNA replication is inhibited.