Multiple roles of Notch signaling in cochlear development

Notch signaling inhibits hair cell differentiation, based on studies on mice deficient in Notch signaling-related genes and its downstream genes. However, the precise mechanisms of this inhibition are unknown because it is difficult to control the timing and duration of the suppression of Notch signaling. Here, we developed a novel in vitro culture and analysis method for mouse fetal cochleae and examined the roles of Notch signaling by its reversible inhibition through the use of Notch signaling inhibitors of gamma-secretase and TNF-alpha-converting enzyme. Notch inhibition with Notch signaling inhibitor treatment increases the number of cochlear hair cells, as observed in gene deletion experiments. We elucidated that this increase is regulated by the dichotomy between hair cells and supporting cells from common progenitors. We also propose other roles of Notch signaling in cochlear development. First, Notch signaling arrests the cell cycle of the cochlear epithelium containing putative hair cells and supporting cell progenitors because Notch inhibition with inhibitor treatment increases the number of 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU)-positive cells that can differentiate into hair cells or supporting cells. Second, Notch signaling is required for the induction of Prox1-positive supporting cells. Third, Notch signaling is required for the maintenance of supporting cells.     

Isolation and culture of hair cell progenitors from postnatal rat cochleae

Cochlear hair cells are a terminally differentiated cell population that is crucial for hearing. Although recent work suggests that there are hair cell progenitors in postnatal mammalian cochleae, isolation and culture of pure hair cell progenitors from a well-defined cochlear area have not been reported. Here we present an experimental method that allows isolation and culture of hair cell progenitors from postnatal rat cochleae. These progenitor cells are isolated from the lesser epithelial ridge (LER, or outer spiral sulcus cell) area of pre-plated neonatal rat cochlear segments. They express the same markers as LER cells in vivo, including ZO1, Islet1, Hes1, and Hes5. When these cells are induced to express Hath1, they show the potential to differentiate into hair cell-like cells. Interestingly, these cells can be lifted from monolayer cultures and maintained in aggregate cultures in which spheres can be formed. Hair cell progenitors in the spheres display their proliferating capability and express only epithelial markers. Furthermore, when these spheres are mixed with dissociated mesenchymal cells prepared from postnatal rat utricular whole mounts, and replated onto a collagen substratum, the epithelial progenitor cells are able to differentiate into cells expressing markers of hair cells and supporting cells in epithelial islands, which mirrors the inner ear sensory epithelium in vivo. Successful isolation and culture of hair cell progenitors from the mammalian cochlea will facilitate studies on gene expression profiling and mechanism of differentiation/regeneration of hair cells, which are crucial for repairing hearing loss.     

Cell cycle regulation in the inner ear sensory epithelia: Role of cyclin D1 and cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors

Sensory hair cells and supporting cells of the mammalian cochlea and vestibular (balance) organs exit the cell cycle during embryogenesis and do not proliferate thereafter. Here, we have studied the mechanisms underlying the maintenance of the postmitotic state and the proliferative capacity of these cells. We provide the first evidence of the role of cyclin D1 in cell cycle regulation in these cells. Cyclin D1 expression disappeared from embryonic hair cells as differentiation started. The expression was transiently upregulated in cochlear hair cells early postnatally, paralleling the spatiotemporal pattern of unscheduled cell cycle re-entry of cochlear hair cells from the p19^Ink4d/p21^Cip1 compound mutant mice. Cyclin D1 misexpression in vitro in neonatal vestibular HCs from these mutant mice triggered S-phase re-entry. Thus, cyclin D1 suppression is important for hair cell's quiescence, together with the maintained expression of cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors. In contrast to hair cells, cyclin D1 expression was maintained in supporting cells when differentiation started. The expression continued during the neonatal period when supporting cells have been shown to re-enter the cell cycle upon stimulation with exogenous mitogens. Thereafter, the steep decline in supporting cell's proliferative activity paralleled with cyclin D1 downregulation. Thus, cyclin D1 critically contributes to the proliferative plasticity of supporting cells. These data suggest that targeted cyclin D1 induction in supporting cells might be an avenue for proliferative regeneration in the inner ear.     

Cell Cycle,Differentiation and Regeneration: Where to Begin?

Hair cells, the sensory cells of inner ear, perform essential functions in hearing and balance. However, mammalian hair cells, like most of the CNS neurons, lack the capacity to regenerate. This is in sharp contrast to lower vertebrates in which hair cell regeneration occurs spontaneously through cell division of supporting cells, which leads to hearing restoration. It is believed that the lack of regeneration in mammals is, to a large degree, due to the block of cell cycle re-entry imposed by negative cell growth genes in the inner ear. Recent studies have identified retinoblastoma gene, a well-known tumor suppressor, as the key gene involved in cell cycle exit of inner ear sensory cells. In the inner ear of pRb conditional knockout mice, hair cells undergo continuous cell division, and at the same time differentiate and become functional. Cell division continues in early postnatal cochlea and adult vestibule. Remarkably, the vestibular hair cells without pRb survive, and function at both the cellular and system levels. The time course and effects of pRb inhibition shows that there is a separation between the roles of pRb in cell cycle exit, and subsequent maturation and apoptosis. Those studies reveal distinctly different roles of pRb in the cochlear and vestibular sensory epithelia. The review discusses additional areas to be studied for regeneration of mature hair cells, and highlights the importance of transient and reversible block of pRb function as one of the routes to be explored for regeneration.     

Dissection of Adult Mouse Utricle and Adenovirus-mediated Supporting-cell Infection

Hearing loss and balance disturbances are often caused by death of mechanosensory hair cells, which are the receptor cells of the inner ear. Since there is no cell line that satisfactorily represents mammalian hair cells, research on hair cells relies on primary organ cultures. The best-characterized in vitro model system of mature mammalian hair cells utilizes organ cultures of utricles from adult mice (Figure 1) ^1-6. The utricle is a vestibular organ, and the hair cells of the utricle are similar in both structure and function to the hair cells in the auditory organ, the organ of Corti. The adult mouse utricle preparation represents a mature sensory epithelium for studies of the molecular signals that regulate the survival, homeostasis, and death of these cells.Mammalian cochlear hair cells are terminally differentiated and are not regenerated when they are lost. In non-mammalian vertebrates, auditory or vestibular hair cell death is followed by robust regeneration which restores hearing and balance functions ^{7, 8}. Hair cell regeneration is mediated by glia-like supporting cells, which contact the basolateral surfaces of hair cells in the sensory epithelium ^{9, 10}. Supporting cells are also important mediators of hair cell survival and death ¹¹. We have recently developed a technique for infection of supporting cells in cultured utricles using adenovirus. Using adenovirus type 5 (dE1/E3) to deliver a transgene containing GFP under the control of the CMV promoter, we find that adenovirus specifically and efficiently infects supporting cells. Supporting cell infection efficiency is approximately 25-50%, and hair cells are not infected (Figure 2). Importantly, we find that adenoviral infection of supporting cells does not result in toxicity to hair cells or supporting cells, as cell counts in Ad-GFP infected utricles are equivalent to those in non-infected utricles (Figure 3). Thus adenovirus-mediated gene expression in supporting cells of cultured utricles provides a powerful tool to study the roles of supporting cells as mediators of hair cell survival, death, and regeneration.     

Notch Signaling Limits Supporting Cell Plasticity in the Hair Cell-Damaged Early Postnatal Murine Cochlea

In mammals, auditory hair cells are generated only during embryonic development and loss or damage to hair cells is permanent. However, in non-mammalian vertebrate species, such as birds, neighboring glia-like supporting cells regenerate auditory hair cells by both mitotic and non-mitotic mechanisms. Based on work in intact cochlear tissue, it is thought that Notch signaling might restrict supporting cell plasticity in the mammalian cochlea. However, it is unresolved how Notch signaling functions in the hair cell-damaged cochlea and the molecular and cellular changes induced in supporting cells in response to hair cell trauma are poorly understood. Here we show that gentamicin-induced hair cell loss in early postnatal mouse cochlear tissue induces rapid morphological changes in supporting cells, which facilitate the sealing of gaps left by dying hair cells. Moreover, we provide evidence that Notch signaling is active in the hair cell damaged cochlea and identify Hes1, Hey1, Hey2, HeyL, and Sox2 as targets and potential Notch effectors of this hair cell-independent mechanism of Notch signaling. Using Cre/loxP based labeling system we demonstrate that inhibition of Notch signaling with a γ- secretase inhibitor (GSI) results in the trans-differentiation of supporting cells into hair cell-like cells. Moreover, we show that these hair cell-like cells, generated by supporting cells have molecular, cellular, and basic electrophysiological properties similar to immature hair cells rather than supporting cells. Lastly, we show that the vast majority of these newly generated hair cell-like cells express the outer hair cell specific motor protein prestin.     

Building the mammalian cochlea — an overview

The mammalian cochlea is a highly intricate organ responsible for hearing. Numerous specialized cell types residing in the cochlear participate in processing and relaying sound information to the brain. In general, cells in the cochlea are divided into three major types: sensory, neural, and non-sensory. Sensory cells are a group of cells in the organ of Corti consisting of hair cells and supporting cells. Sensory hair cells play a primary role in detecting and processing sound in the form of vibrations. Neural cells are the neurons and glia in the spiral (cochlear) ganglion that relay the processed sound signals in the form of a neurotransmitter to the brain. Other non-sensory cells include all other cell types providing architectural and functional support. Building a functional cochlea requires tightly orchestrated, spatial and temporal regulation of gene expressions. Disruption of the normal gene expression patterns can cause developmental failure of the organ, which can lead to permanent hearing loss. Thus, comprehensive understanding of genes contributing to cochlear development is crucial for elucidating the pathological mechanisms of hearing loss. This article is intended to provide an overview of mammalian cochlear development, focusing on genes involved in its early patterning.     

Progressive hearing loss in mice lacking the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor Ink4d

Maintenance of the post-mitotic state in the post-natal mammalian brain is an active process that requires the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors (CKIs) p19Ink4d (Ink4d) and p27Kip1 (Kip1). In animals with targeted deletions of both Ink4d and Kip1, terminally differentiated, post-mitotic neurons are observed to re-enter the cell cycle, divide and undergo apoptosis. However, when either Ink4d or Kip1 alone are deleted, the post-mitotic state is maintained, suggesting a redundant role for these genes in mature neurons. In the organ of Corti--the auditory sensory epithelium of mammals--sensory hair cells and supporting cells become post-mitotic during embryogenesis and remain quiescent for the life of the animal. When lost as a result of environmental insult or genetic abnormality, hair cells do not regenerate, and this loss is a common cause of deafness in humans. Here, we report that targeted deletion of Ink4d alone is sufficient to disrupt the maintenance of the post-mitotic state of sensory hair cells in post-natal mice. In Ink4d-/- animals, hair cells are observed to aberrantly re-enter the cell cycle and subsequently undergo apoptosis, resulting in progressive hearing loss. Our results identify a novel mechanism underlying a non-syndromic form of progressive hearing loss in mice.     

Adaptive evolution in mammalian proteins involved in cochlear outer hair cell electromotility

Somatic electromotility in cochlear outer hair cells, as the basis for cochlear amplification, is a mammalian novelty and it is largely dependent upon rapid cell length changes proposed to be mediated by the motor-protein prestin, a member of the solute carrier anion-transport family 26. Thus, one might predict that prestin has specifically evolved in mammals to support this unique mammalian adaptation. Using codon-based likelihood models we found evidences for positive selection in the motor-protein prestin only in the mammalian lineage, supporting the hypothesis that lineage-specific adaptation-driven molecular changes endowed prestin with the ability to mediate somatic electromotility. Moreover, signatures of positive selection were found on the alpha10, but not the alpha9, nicotinic cholinergic receptor subunits. An alpha9alpha10-containing nicotinic cholinergic receptor mediates inhibitory olivocochlear efferent effects on hair cells across vertebrates. Our results suggest that evolution-driven modifications of the alpha10 subunit probably allowed the alpha9alpha10 heteromeric receptor to serve a differential function in the mammalian cochlea. Thus, we describe for the first time at the molecular level signatures of adaptive evolution in two outer hair cell proteins only in the lineage leading to mammals. This finding is most likely related with the roles these proteins play in somatic electromotility and/or its fine tuning.     

Deafness and cochlear fibrocyte alterations in mice deficient for the inner ear protein otospiralin

In the cochlea, the mammalian auditory organ, fibrocytes of the mesenchymal nonsensory regions play important roles in cochlear physiology, including the maintenance of ionic and hydric components in the endolymph. Occurrence of human deafness in fibrocyte alterations underlines their critical roles in auditory function. We recently described a novel gene, Otos, which encodes otospiralin, a small protein of unknown function that is produced by the fibrocytes of the cochlea and vestibule. We now have generated mice with deletion of Otos and found that they show moderate deafness, with no frequency predominance. Histopathology revealed a degeneration of type II and IV fibrocytes, while hair cells and stria vascularis appeared normal. Together, these findings suggest that impairment of fibrocytes caused by the loss in otospiralin leads to abnormal cochlear physiology and auditory function. This moderate dysfunction may predispose to age-related hearing loss.     

COUP-TFI controls Notch regulation of hair cell and support cell differentiation

The orphan nuclear receptor COUP-TFI (Nr2f1) regulates many aspects of mammalian development, but little is known about its role in cochlear hair cell and Deiter's support cell development. The COUP-TFI knockout (COUP-TFI(-/-)) has a significant increase in hair cell (HC) number in the mid-to-apical turns. The total number of hair cells is not increased over wild type, perhaps because of displaced hair cells and a shortened cochlear duct. This implicates a defect of convergent-extension in the COUP-TFI(-/-) duct. In addition, excess proliferation in the COUP-TFI(-/-) sensory epithelium indicates that the origin of the extra HCs in the apex is complex. Because loss-of-function studies of Notch signaling components have similar phenotypes, we investigated Notch regulation of hair cell differentiation in COUP-TFI(-/-) mice and confirmed misregulation of Notch signaling components, including Jag1, Hes5 and in a manner consistent with reduced Notch signaling, and correlated with increases in hair cell and support cell differentiation. The disruption of Notch signaling by a gamma-secretase inhibitor in an in vitro organ culture system of wild-type cochleae resulted in a reduction in expression of the Notch target gene Hes5 and an increase in hair cell differentiation. Importantly, inhibition of Notch activity resulted in a greater increase in hair cell differentiation in COUP-TFI(-/-) cochlear cultures than in wild-type cultures, suggesting a hypersensitivity to Notch inactivation in COUP-TFI(-/-) cochlea, particularly at the apical turn. Thus, we present evidence that reduced Notch signaling contributes to increases in hair cell and support cell differentiation in COUP-TFI(-/-) mice, and suggest that COUP-TFI is required for Notch regulation of hair cell and support cell differentiation.     

Isolating LacZ-expressing cells from mouse inner ear tissues using flow cytometry

Isolation of specific cell types allows one to analyze rare cell populations such as stem/progenitor cells. Such an approach to studying inner ear tissues presents a unique challenge because of the paucity of cells of interest and few transgenic reporter mouse models. Here, we describe a protocol using fluorescence-conjugated probes to selectively label LacZ-positive cells from the neonatal cochleae. The most common underlying pathology of sensorineural hearing loss is the irreversible damage and loss of cochlear sensory hair cells, which are required to transduce sound waves to neural impulses. Recent evidence suggests that the murine auditory and vestibular organs harbor stem/progenitor cells that may have regenerative potential. These findings warrant further investigation, including identifying specific cell types with stem/progenitor cell characteristics. The Wnt signaling pathway has been demonstrated to play a critical role in maintaining stem/progenitor cell populations in several organ systems. We have recently identified Wnt-responsive Axin2-expressing cells in the neonatal cochlea, but their function is largely unknown. To better understand the behavior of these Wnt-responsive cells in vitro, we have developed a method of isolating Axin2-expressing cells from cochleae of Axin2-LacZ reporter mice. Using flow cytometry to isolate Axin2-LacZ positive cells from the neonatal cochleae, we could in turn execute a variety of experiments on live cells to interrogate their behavior as stem/progenitor cells. Here, we describe in detail the steps for the microdissection of neonatal cochlea, dissociation of these tissues, labeling of the LacZ-positive cells using a fluorogenic substrate, and cell sorting. Techniques for dissociating cochleae into single cells and isolating cochlear cells via flow cytometry have been described. We have made modifications to these techniques to establish a novel protocol to isolate LacZ-expressing cells from the neonatal cochlea.     

Cell Division and Maintenance of Epithelial Integrity in the Deafened Auditory Epithelium

Quiescence is among the hallmarks of the sensory epithelium of the cochlea. When auditory sensory cells (hair cells) degenerate they are not replaced, and therefore hearing loss is permanent. Cochlear hair cells are susceptible to several types of lesions, including aminoglycoside antibiotics. The application of the aminoglycoside neomycin in the inner ear mimics cases of severe hair cell loss and leads to collapse of the cochlear epithelium. We now report that in mature guinea pig cochleae injected with neomycin, the remaining non-sensory cells undergo a robust proliferative response. p27Kip1, an inhibitor of cell cycle in the cochlea, was present in non-dividing cells and absent during mitosis. Dividing cells retained their tight junction complexes and maintained the structural confluence of the auditory epithelium during cell division. The plane of mitosis was invariably parallel to the luminal surface. These results indicate that the flat epithelium of the cochlea can down-regulate p27Kip1 and divide after a severe lesion and suggest that the cell divisions assist in maintaining the epithelial confluence throughout the cochlea. Presence of mitosis in the tissue presents therapeutic opportunities for gene transfer and stem cells therapies.     

Dynamic changes in hair cell stereocilia and cochlear transduction after noise exposure

The structures of cochlear transduction include stereocilia at the apical surface of hair cells and their connection to the tectorial membrane. The transduction site is one of the loci for noise-induced cochlear damage. Although stereocilia are susceptible to noise, it has been found that in the inner ears of avians, this fragile structure is largely self-repairing and is associated with recovery of hearing sensitivity after noise exposure, as observed in the difference between the temporal threshold shift (TTS) and the permanent threshold shift (PTS). In the mammalian cochleae, however, threshold shifts measured in the auditory brainstem responses (ABR) did not parallel the chronological changes in the stereocilia on hair cells. It is unclear how the morphological recovery of the stereocilia on the mammalian hair cells is correlated with the changes in cochlear transduction that can be assessed by measuring receptor potential. In the present study, guinea pigs were exposed to a broadband noise of 110 dB SPL for 2 h. Auditory sensitivity was evaluated using ABR and cochlear transduction was assessed using cochlear microphonics (CM). Stereocilia morphology was quantified at different time points after the noise and compared with the control. The noise produced a TTS of 55.69 ± 14.13 dB in frequency-averaged ABR thresholds. The threshold shift was reduced to 9.58 ± 11.75 dB SPL 1 month later with virtually no loss of hair cells. Damage to the stereocilia immediately after noise exposure was found to be associated with depression of CM amplitude. Virtually no abnormal stereocilia were observed 1 month after the noise in association with a fully recovered CM.     

The Notch ligands DLL1 and JAG2 act synergistically to regulate hair cell development in the mammalian inner ear

The mammalian auditory sensory epithelium, the organ of Corti, contains sensory hair cells and nonsensory supporting cells arranged in a highly patterned mosaic. Notch-mediated lateral inhibition is the proposed mechanism for creating this sensory mosaic. Previous work has shown that mice lacking the Notch ligand JAG2 differentiate supernumerary hair cells in the cochlea, consistent with the lateral inhibitory model. However, it was not clear why only relatively modest increases in hair cell production were observed in Jag2 mutant mice. Here, we show that another Notch ligand, DLL1, functions synergistically with JAG2 in regulating hair cell differentiation in the cochlea. We also show by conditional inactivation that these ligands probably signal through the NOTCH1 receptor. Supernumerary hair cells in Dll1/Jag2 double mutants arise primarily through a switch in cell fate, rather than through excess proliferation. Although these results demonstrate an important role for Notch-mediated lateral inhibition during cochlear hair cell patterning, we also detected abnormally prolonged cellular proliferation that preferentially affected supporting cells in the organ of Corti. Our results demonstrate that the Notch pathway plays a dual role in regulating cellular differentiation and patterning in the cochlea, acting both through lateral inhibition and the control of cellular proliferation.