Oncolytic virotherapy for cancer treatment: challenges and solutions

Advances in gene modification and viral therapy have led to the development of a variety of vectors in several viral families that are capable of replication specifically in tumor cells. Because of the nature of viral delivery, infection, and replication, this technology, oncolytic virotherapy, may prove valuable for treating cancer patients, especially those with inoperable tumors. Current limitations exist, however, for oncolytic virotherapy. They include the body's B and T cell responses, innate inflammatory reactions, host range, safety risks involved in using modified viruses as treatments, and the requirement that most currently available oncolytic viruses require local administration. Another important constraint is that genetically enhanced vectors may or may not adhere to their replication restrictions in long-term applications. Several solutions and strategies already exist, however, to minimize or circumvent many of these limitations, supporting viral oncolytic therapy as a viable option and powerful tool in the fight against cancer.     

Δγ₁134.5 herpes simplex viruses encoding human cytomegalovirus IRS1 or TRS1 induce interferon regulatory factor 3 phosphorylation and an interferon-stimulated gene response

The chimeric herpes simplex viruses (HSV) are Δγ₁34.5 vectors encoding the human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) IRS1 or TRS1 genes. They are capable of late viral protein synthesis and are superior to Δγ₁34.5 HSVs in oncolytic activity. The interferon (IFN) response limits efficient HSV gene expression and replication. HCMV TRS1 and IRS1 restore one γ₁34.5 gene function: evasion of IFN-inducible protein kinase R, allowing late viral protein synthesis. Here we show that, unlike wild-type HSV, the chimeric HSV do not restore another γ₁34.5 function, the suppression of early IFN signaling mediated by IFN regulatory factor 3 (IRF3).     

“Armed” oncolytic herpes simplex viruses for brain tumor therapy

Genetically engineered, conditionally replicating herpes simplex viruses type 1 (HSV-1) are promising therapeutic agents for brain tumors and other solid cancers. They can replicate in situ, spread and exhibit oncolytic activity via a direct cytocidal effect. One of the advantages of HSV-1 is the capacity to incorporate large and/or multiple transgenes within the viral genome. Oncolytic HSV-1 can therefore be “armed” to add certain functions. Recently, the field of armed oncolytic HSV-1 has drastically advanced, due to development of recombinant HSV-1 generation systems that utilize bacterial artificial chromosome and multiple DNA recombinases. Because antitumor immunity is induced in the course of oncolytic activities of HSV-1, transgenes encoding immunomodulatory molecules have been most frequently used for arming. Other armed oncolytic HSV-1 include those that express antiangiogenic factors, fusogenic membrane glycoproteins, suicide gene products, and proapoptotic proteins. Provided that the transgene product does not interfere with viral replication, such arming of oncolytic HSV-1 results in augmentation of antitumor efficacy. Immediate-early viral promoters are often used to control the arming transgenes, but strict-late viral promoters have been shown useful to restrict the expression in the late stage of viral replication when desirable. Some armed oncolytic HSV-1 have been created for the purpose of noninvasive in vivo imaging of viral infection and replication. Development of a wide variety of armed oncolytic HSV-1 will lead to an establishment of a new genre of therapy for brain tumors as well as other cancers.Key words: oncolytic virus therapy, gene therapy, herpes simplex virus, viral vectors, G47Δ, G207, antitumor immunity     

Ad 2.0: a novel recombineering platform for high-throughput generation of tailored adenoviruses

Recombinant adenoviruses containing a double-stranded DNA genome of 26–45 kb were broadly explored in basic virology, for vaccination purposes, for treatment of tumors based on oncolytic virotherapy, or simply as a tool for efficient gene transfer. However, the majority of recombinant adenoviral vectors (AdVs) is based on a small fraction of adenovirus types and their genetic modification. Recombineering techniques provide powerful tools for arbitrary engineering of recombinant DNA. Here, we adopted a seamless recombineering technology for high-throughput and arbitrary genetic engineering of recombinant adenoviral DNA molecules. Our cloning platform which also includes a novel recombination pipeline is based on bacterial artificial chromosomes (BACs). It enables generation of novel recombinant adenoviruses from different sources and switching between commonly used early generation AdVs and the last generation high-capacity AdVs lacking all viral coding sequences making them attractive candidates for clinical use. In combination with a novel recombination pipeline allowing cloning of AdVs containing large and complex transgenes and the possibility to generate arbitrary chimeric capsid-modified adenoviruses, these techniques allow generation of tailored AdVs with distinct features. Our technologies will pave the way toward broader applications of AdVs in molecular medicine including gene therapy and vaccination studies.     

MicroRNA-Mediated Suppression of Oncolytic Adenovirus Replication in Human Liver

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are important and ubiquitous regulators of gene expression that can suppress their target genes by translational inhibition as well as mRNA destruction. Cell type-specific miRNA expression patterns have been successfully exploited for targeting the expression of experimental and therapeutic gene constructs, for example to reduce pathogenic effects of cancer virotherapy in normal tissues. In order to avoid liver damage associated with systemic or intrahepatic delivery of oncolytic adenoviruses we have introduced the concept of suppressing adenovirus replication in hepatic cells by inserting target elements for the liver-specific miR122 into the viral genome. Here we show using ex vivo cultured tissue specimens that six perfectly complementary miR122 target sites in the 3′ untranslated region of the viral E1A gene are sufficient in the absence of any other genetic modifications to prevent productive replication of serotype 5 adenovirus (Ad5) in normal human liver. This modification did not compromise the replicative capacity of the modified virus in cancer tissue derived from a colon carcinoma liver metastasis or its oncolytic potency in a human lung cancer xenograft mouse model. Unlike wild-type Ad5, the modified virus did not result in increased serum levels of liver enzymes in infected mice. These results provide a strong preclinical proof of concept for the use of miR122 target sites for reducing the risk of liver damage caused by oncolytic adenoviruses, and suggest that ectopic miR122 target elements should be considered as an additional safety measure included in any therapeutic virus or viral vector posing potential hazard to the liver.     

Viral Vectors for Gene Delivery and Expression in the CNS

Viral vectors have emerged as an important tool for manipulating gene expression in the adult mammalian brain. The adult brain is composed largely of nondividing cells, and therefore DNA viruses have become the vehicle of choice for neurobiologists interested in somatic gene transfer. Recombinant viral vectors based upon adenovirus or herpes simplex virus have been created in which a gene essential for viral replication is removed and a gene of interest is inserted in the viral genome. While this eliminates pathogenicity due to viral replication, retention of viral genes and continued expression of these genes may limit the potential of the current generation of vectors. Defective viral vectors represent a different approach, in which only viral recognition signals are used to allow packaging of foreign DNA into a viral coat while eliminating the possibility of viral gene expression within target cells. The defective HSV vector has been used to transfer genes into the adult rat brain. This vector has also been used for analysis of the preproenkephalin promoterin vivo,and important regions of this promoter have been identified using this technique. A modification ofin situPCR has been developed as an adjunctive tool for sensitively documenting the presence of vector DNA within target cells duringin vivopromoter studies. Finally, the adenoassociated virus vector has been used as the first fully defective DNA viral vector, which also eliminates any contamination by helper viruses. This vector can transfer genes into the mammalian brain and has shown significant behavioral recovery in a rodent model of Parkinson's disease. Future work will undoubtedly result in still more diverse and improved vectors; however, these studies have documented the importance of viral vectors to both basic neurobiology and the potential treatment of neurologic disease.     

Novel AAV serotypes for improved ocular gene transfer

Some of the most successful gene therapy results have been obtained using recombinant viral vectors to treat animal models of inherited and acquired ocular diseases. Clinical trials using adenovirus vector systems have been initiated for two ocular diseases. Adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) represent an attractive alternative to adenoviral vector systems as they enable stable and long-term expression and can target a variety of different ocular cell types depending on the capsid serotype; recently clinical trails for congenital blindness was initiated with a vector-based AAV serotype 2. High levels of retinal gene transfer have been achieved using vectors based on AAV serotypes 1, 2, 4 and 5. This report compares the gene transfer efficacy and stability of expression of vector systems based on three novel AAV serotypes: AAV7, 8, 9, with the established vectors AAV1, 2, 5. We show here that AAV7 and 8 enable superior long-term transduction of retinal and also anterior chamber structures.     

Tumor-specific gene expression in hepatic metastases by a replication-activated adenovirus vector

Clinical applications of tumor gene therapy require tumor-specific delivery or expression of therapeutic genes in order to maximize the oncolytic index and minimize side effects. This study demonstrates activation of transgene expression exclusively in hepatic metastases after systemic application of a modified first-generation (E1A/E1B-deleted) adenovirus vector (AdE1-) in mouse tumor models. The discrimination between tumors and normal liver tissue is based on selective DNA replication of AdE1- vectors in tumor cells. This new AdE1- based vector system uses homologous recombination between inverted repeats to mediate precise rearrangements within the viral genome. As a result of these rearrangements, a promoter is brought into conjunction with a reporter gene creating a functional expression cassette. Genomic rearrangements are dependent upon viral DNA replication, which in turn occurs specifically in tumor cells. In a mouse tumor model with liver metastases derived from human tumor cells, a single systemic administration of replication activated AdE1- vectors achieved transgene expression in every metastasis, whereas no extra-tumoral transgene induction was observed. Here we provide a new concept for tumor-specific gene expression that is also applicable for other conditionally replicating adenovirus vectors.     

An oncolytic herpes simplex virus type 1 selectively destroys diffuse liver metastases from colon carcinoma.

Viruses used for gene therapy are usually genetically modified to deliver therapeutic transgenes and prevent viral replication. In contrast, replication-competent viruses may be used for cancer therapy because replication of some viruses within cancer cells can result in their destruction (oncolysis). Viral ribonucleotide reductase expression is defective in the HSV1 mutant hrR3. Cellular ribonucleotide reductase, which is scarce in normal liver and abundant in liver metastases, can substitute for its viral counterpart to allow hrR3 replication in infected cells. Two or three log orders more of hrR3 virions are produced from infection of colon carcinoma cells than from infection of normal hepatocytes in viral replication assays. This viral replication is oncolytic. A single intravascular administration of hrR3 into immune-competent mice bearing diffuse liver metastases dramatically reduces tumor burden. hrR3-mediated tumor inhibition is equivalent in immune-competent and immune-incompetent mice, suggesting that viral oncolysis and not the host immune response is the primary mechanism of tumor destruction. HSV1-mediated oncolysis of diffuse liver metastases is effective in mice preimmunized against HSV1. These results indicate that replication-competent HSV1 mutants hold significant promise as cancer therapeutic agents. Yoon, S. S., Nakamura, H., Carroll, N. M., Bode, B. P., Chiocca, E. A., Tanabe, K. K. An oncolytic herpes simplex virus type 1 selectively destroys diffuse liver metastases from colon carcinoma.     

“Armed” oncolytic herpes simplex viruses for brain tumor therapy

Genetically engineered, conditionally replicating herpes simplex viruses type 1 (HSV-1) are promising therapeutic agents for brain tumors and other solid cancers. They can replicate in situ, spread, and exhibit oncolytic activity via a direct cytocidal effect. One of the advantages of HSV-1 is the capacity to incorporate large and/or multiple transgenes within the viral genome. Oncolytic HSV-1 can therefore be “armed” to add certain functions. Recently, the field of armed oncolytic HSV-1 has drastically advanced, due to development of recombinant HSV-1 generation systems that utilize bacterial artificial chromosome and multiple DNA recombinases. Because antitumor immunity is induced in the course of oncolytic activities of HSV-1, transgenes encoding immunomodulatory molecules have been most frequently used for arming. Other armed oncolytic HSV-1 include those that express antiangiogenic factors, fusogenic membrane glycoproteins, suicide gene products, and proapoptotic proteins. Provided that the transgene product does not interfere with viral replication, such arming of oncolytic HSV-1 results in augmentation of antitumor efficacy. Immediate-early viral promoters are often used to control the arming transgenes, but strict-late viral promoters have been shown useful to restrict the expression in the late stage of viral replication when desirable. Some armed oncolytic HSV-1 have been created for the purpose of noninvasive in vivo imaging of viral infection and replication. Development of a wide variety of armed oncolytic HSV-1 will lead to an establishment of a new genre of therapy for brain tumors as well as other cancers.     

Generation of a conditionally replicating adenovirus based on targeted destruction of E1A mRNA by a cell type-specific MicroRNA

MicroRNAs have emerged as important players in tissue-specific mammalian gene regulation and have also been exploited in experimental targeting of gene expression. We have constructed a recombinant adenovirus that contains sequences complementary to the liver-specific microRNA 122 (miR122) in the 3′ untranslated region of the E1A gene. In Huh7 cells, which resemble normal hepatocytes in expressing high levels of miR122, this feature resulted in strongly reduced levels of E1A mRNA and protein. This property allowed us to generate a novel recombinant adenovirus that was severely attenuated in cells of hepatic origin but replicated normally in other cells. This strategy may be useful in circumventing liver toxicity associated with the systemic delivery of oncolytic adenoviruses. These data provide the first example of exploiting differential microRNA expression patterns to alter the natural tropism of a DNA virus. In addition, these results suggest that other microRNAs expressed in a tissue- or transformation-specific manner may also be used for the targeting of adenoviral replication and that the same principle may be applied to other viruses that have shown promise as oncolytic or gene delivery platforms.     

Non-invasive in vivo monitoring of trackable viruses expressing soluble marker peptides

Noninvasive methods are needed to study the kinetic properties of viruses in living organisms. Oncolytic viruses are used increasingly for cancer therapy but there is currently no satisfactory way to measure efficiency of tumor transduction, changing levels of viral gene expression or the timing of virus elimination. We therefore generated trackable oncolytic measles viruses expressing inert (nonimmunogenic, nonfunctional and accurately measurable) soluble marker peptides. The marker peptides did not compromise virus replication. Ex vivo and in vivo kinetics of the trackable viruses could be easily followed by measuring the concentrations of virally encoded marker peptides in culture supernatant or in serum. When mice bearing human tumor xenografts were challenged with the trackable viruses, distinct kinetic profiles of marker-gene expression could be correlated with distinct therapeutic outcomes. Oncolytic viruses expressing inert soluble marker polypeptides should greatly facilitate the rational development of effective, individually tailored cancer virotherapy.     

Oncolytic adenoviruses in anticancer therapy: Current status and prospects

Lytic virus infection results in production of a virus progeny and lysis of the infected cell. Tumor cells are usually more sensitive to virus infection. Studies indicate that viral oncolysis provides a promising alternative approach to cancer therapy. The ability of viruses to selectively kill cancer cells is long known, but construction of virus variants with an improved therapeutic potential was impossible until recent advances in virus and cell molecular biology and the development of modern methods for directed modification of viruses. Adenoviruses are one of the best studied models of oncolytic viruses. These DNA viruses are convenient for genetic manipulation and show minimal pathogenicity. The review summarizes the data on the directions and approaches to generation of highly efficient variants of oncolytic adenoviruses. The approaches include introduction of directed genetic modifications into the virus genome, accelerated selection of oncolytic virus variants following treatment with mutagens, the use of adenoviruses as vectors to introduce therapeutic gene products, optimization of viral delivery systems, minimization of the negative effects from the host immune system, etc. The dynamic development of studies in the field holds promise that many variants of oncolytic adenoviruses will find clinical application in the nearest future.     

MicroRNA-restricted transgene expression in the retina

Background

Gene transfer using adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors has been successfully applied in the retina for the treatment of inherited retinal dystrophies. Recently, microRNAs have been exploited to fine-tune transgene expression improving therapeutic outcomes. Here we evaluated the ability of retinal-expressed microRNAs to restrict AAV-mediated transgene expression to specific retinal cell types that represent the main targets of common inherited blinding conditions.

Methodology/Principal Findings

To this end, we generated AAV2/5 vectors expressing EGFP and containing four tandem copies of miR-124 or miR-204 complementary sequences in the 3′UTR of the transgene expression cassette. These vectors were administered subretinally to adult C57BL/6 mice and Large White pigs. Our results demonstrate that miR-124 and miR-204 target sequences can efficiently restrict AAV2/5-mediated transgene expression to retinal pigment epithelium and photoreceptors, respectively, in mice and pigs. Interestingly, transgene restriction was observed at low vector doses relevant to therapy.

Conclusions

We conclude that microRNA-mediated regulation of transgene expression can be applied in the retina to either restrict to a specific cell type the robust expression obtained using ubiquitous promoters or to provide an additional layer of gene expression regulation when using cell-specific promoters.     

Adenovirus E1B55K region is required to enhance cyclin E expression for efficient viral DNA replication

Adenoviruses (Ads) with E1B55K mutations can selectively replicate in and destroy cancer cells. However, the mechanism of Ad-selective replication in tumor cells is not well characterized. We have shown previously that expression of several cell cycle-regulating genes is markedly affected by the Ad E1b gene in WI-38 human lung fibroblast cells (X. Rao, et al., Virology 350:418-428, 2006). In the current study, we show that the Ad E1B55K region is required to enhance cyclin E expression and that the failure to induce cyclin E overexpression due to E1B55K mutations prevents viral DNA from undergoing efficient replication in WI-38 cells, especially when the cells are arrested in the G(0) phase of the cell cycle by serum starvation. In contrast, cyclin E induction is less dependent on the function encoded in the E1B55K region in A549 and other cancer cells that are permissive for replication of E1B55K-mutated viruses, whether the cells are in the S phase or G(0) phase. The small interfering RNA that specifically inhibits cyclin E expression partially decreased viral replication. Our study provides evidence suggesting that E1B55K may be involved in cell cycle regulation that is important for efficient viral DNA replication and that cyclin E overexpression in cancer cells may be associated with the oncolytic replication of E1B55K-mutated viruses.     

Human miR-3145 inhibits influenza A viruses replication by targeting and silencing viral PB1 gene

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) play an important role in the regulation of gene expression and are involved in many cellular processes including inhibition of viral replication in infected cells. In this study, three subtypes of influenza A viruses (pH1N1, H5N1 and H3N2) were analyzed to identify candidate human miRNAs targeting and silencing viral genes expression. Candidate human miRNAs were predicted by miRBase and RNAhybrid based on minimum free energy (MFE) and hybridization patterns between human miRNAs and viral target genes. In silico analysis presented 76 miRNAs targeting influenza A viruses, including 70 miRNAs that targeted specific subtypes (21 for pH1N1, 27 for H5N1 and 22 for H3N2) and 6 miRNAs (miR-216b, miR-3145, miR-3682, miR-4513, miR-4753 and miR-5693) that targeted multiple subtypes of influenza A viruses. Interestingly, miR-3145 is the only candidate miRNA targeting all three subtypes of influenza A viruses. The miR-3145 targets to PB1 encoding polymerase basic protein 1, which is the main component of the viral polymerase complex. The silencing effect of miR-3145 was validated by 3′-UTR reporter assay and inhibition of influenza viral replication in A549 cells. In 3′-UTR reporter assay, results revealed that miR-3145 triggered significant reduction of the luciferase activity. Moreover, expression of viral PB1 genes was also inhibited considerably (P value < 0.05) in viral infected cells expressing mimic miR-3145. In conclusion, this study demonstrated that human miR-3145 triggered silencing of viral PB1 genes and lead to inhibition of multiple subtypes of influenza viral replication. Therefore, hsa-miR-3145 might be useful for alternative treatment of influenza A viruses in the future.     

The Human Cytomegalovirus UL76 Gene Regulates the Level of Expression of the UL77 Gene

Background

Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) can be reactivated under immunosuppressive conditions causing several fatal pneumonitis, hepatitis, retinitis, and gastrointestinal diseases. HCMV also causes deafness and mental retardation in neonates when primary infection has occurred during pregnancy. In the genome of HCMV at least 194 known open reading frames (ORFs) have been predicted, and approximately one-quarter, or 41 ORFs, are required for viral replication in cell culture. In contrast, the majority of the predicted ORFs are nonessential for viral replication in cell culture. However, it is also possible that these ORFs are required for the efficient viral replication in the host. The UL77 gene of HCMV is essential for viral replication and has a role in viral DNA packaging. The function of the upstream UL76 gene in the HCMV-infected cells is not understood. UL76 and UL77 are cistons on the same viral mRNA and a conventional 5′ mRNA for UL77 has not been detected. The vast majority of eukaryotic mRNAs are monocistronic, i.e., they encode only a single protein.

Methodology/Principal Findings

To determine whether the UL76 ORF affects UL77 gene expression, we mutated UL76 by ORF frame-shifts, stop codons or deletion of the viral gene. The effect on UL77 protein expression was determined by either transfection of expression plasmids or infection with recombinant viruses. Mutation of UL76 ORF significantly increased the level of UL77 protein expression. However, deletion of UL76 upstream of the UL77 ORF had only marginal effects on viral growth.

Conclusions/Significance

While UL76 is not essential for viral replication, the UL76 ORF is involved in regulation of the level of UL77 protein expression in a manner dependent on the translation re-initiation. UL76 may fine-tune the UL77 expression for the efficient viral replication in the HCMV- infected cells.