The comparative susceptibilities of Pieris brassicae and P. rapae to a granulosis virus from P. brassicae

A comparison was made of the dosage-mortality responses of larvae of Pieris brassicae and P. rapae to infection by P. brassicae granulosis virus (GV). Bioassays with first, second, third, and fourth-instar larvae of both species revealed a marked difference in susceptibility between instars and between species. Median lethal dosages (LD₅₀s) for P. rapae larvae ranged from five capsules for the first instar to 662 capsules for the fourth instar. With P. brassicae, this range extended from 66 capsules to 2.3 × 10⁷ capsules. The time-mortality responses of the two species were similar when fed virus dosages equivalent to an LD₉₀. Median lethal times (LT₅₀s) ranged from 5 days for first-instar larvae to 7–8 days for fourth-instar larvae. A comparison between a long-established laboratory stock of P. brassicae and a stock recently acquired from the field showed no significant difference in their susceptibility to GV. The implications of the pronounced species differences in susceptibility to GV infection are discussed in relation to the potential field control of P. rapae and P. brassicae.     

Parasitism capacity and searching efficiency of Diaeretiella rapae parasitizing Brevicoryne brassicae on susceptible and resistant canola cultivars

Different cultivars of aplant species can affect the foraging and efficiency of natural enemies, both directly through physical and biochemical properties or indirectly through the herbivore's diet. In this study, the parasitism capacity and functional response of Diaeretiella rapae McIntosh were determined on the cabbage aphid, Brevicoryne brassicae (L.) reared on susceptible (Opera) and resistant (Okapi) canola cultivars under laboratory conditions at 25?±?1?°C, 60?±?5% RH and a16:8?h L:D photoperiod. The parasitoid exhibited Type II and Type III functional responses on the resistant and susceptible cultivars, respectively. The estimated value of searching efficiency (a) was 0.1637?±?0.1095?h^?1 on the resistant cultivar whereas its value was dependent on host density on the susceptible cultivar. The handling times (T_h) on the susceptible and resistant canola cultivars were 0.108?±?0.040 and 0.320?±?0.048?h, respectively. The net parasitism rate (C₀) of the parasitoid wasp varied from 128.09 hosts per parasitoid lifetime on the susceptible to 71.01hosts on the resistant canola cultivar. The transformation rate from host population to parasitoid offspring (Qp) was equal to 1 on both cultivars (C₀?=?R₀). The finite parasitism rate (ω) on the susceptible cultivar (0.819 hosts per parasitoid per day) was significantly higher than that on the resistant one (0.578 hosts per parasitoid per day). In conclusion, canola cultivars affected the performance of D. rapae in controlled small-scale laboratory experiments and compared with the susceptible cultivar, the resistant one had anadverseeffect on the efficiency of the parasitoid.     

A common pathway for metabolism of 4-hydroxybenzylglucosinolate in Pieris and Anthocaris (Lepidoptera: Pieridae)

Caterpillars of Pieris rapae L. (Lepidoptera: Pieridae) convert 4-hydroxybenzylglucosinolate (sinalbin) in brassicaceous plants into 4-hydroxybenzylcyanide sulfate (HBC sulfate), with 4-hydroxybenzylcyanide (HBC) as intermediate. This apparently serves as a detoxification, because alternative formation of a mustard oil is avoided. We confirmed the capacity of P. rapae to convert the intermediate HBC into HBC sulfate. Four additional Pieridae – Anthocaris cardamines L., Pieris virginiensis Harris, Pieris napi oleracea Edwards and Pieris brassicae L., likewise excreted HBC sulfate after ingesting leaves with topically added HBC or leaves naturally containing sinalbin and myrosinase, but not after ingesting control leaves devoid of HBC and sinalbin. We confirmed the capacity of the most distantly related pierid species (A. cardamines) for converting ingested (topically added) sinalbin into HBC sulfate. Larvae of two non-pierid Brassicaceae-feeding insects, the oligophagous sawfly Athalia rosae L. (Hymenoptera: Tenthrenidae) and the polyphagous moth Spodoptera frugiperda (Smith) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), did not excrete HBC sulfate after ingesting sinalbin-containing leaves or topically added HBC.     

How do Pieris rapae search for Brassicaceae host plants?

Pieris rapae curucivora Boisduval is a major cause of damage to important Brassicaceae vegetable crops. The method of host landing plant selection by adult females was investigated by covering cabbage (host) and lettuce (non-host) plants to block visual and/or olfactory signals, and also by using volatile extracts of both plants.     

Chemosensory basis of behavioural plasticity in response to deterrent plant chemicals in the larva of the Small Cabbage White butterfly Pieris rapae

Behavioural and electrophysiological responsiveness to three chemically different secondary plant substances was studied in larvae of Pieris rapae L. (Lepidoptera: Pieridae). Three groups of caterpillars were studied that during their larval development were exposed to different rearing diets: an artificial diet or one of two host-plants, cabbage, Brassica oleracea, or nasturtium, Tropaeolum majus. In dual-choice leaf disc assays, caterpillars reared on cabbage were strongly deterred by the phenolic chlorogenic acid, the flavonol glycoside naringin and the alkaloid strychnine. However, behavioural plasticity was found in caterpillars reared on nasturtium or artificial diet in that these did not discriminate against chlorogenic acid. Caterpillars reared on the artificial diet were also significantly less sensitive to naringin and strychnine in the behavioural assay. Electrophysiological studies of the maxillary sensilla styloconica revealed that the deterrent neuron in the medial sensillum, but not in the lateral sensillum, of cabbage-reared caterpillars was more sensitive than the same neuron type of caterpillars reared on nasturtium or artificial diet. We conclude that (1) the diet-induced behavioural habituation to deterrents can at least partly be explained by chemosensory desensitisation of a generalist type of maxillary deterrent neuron; (2) behavioural cross-habituation to the three structurally diverse deterrent compounds can be traced back to cross-sensitivity for these compounds in the same gustatory neuron.     

Demonstration of Cytotoxicity against Wasps by Pierisin-1: A Possible Defense Factor in the Cabbage White Butterfly

The cabbage white butterfly, Pieris rapae, produces pierisin-1, a protein inducing apoptosis of mammalian cells. In the present study, the biological activity of pierisin-1 as a protective agent against parasitic wasps for P. rapae was examined. Pierisin-1 caused detrimental effects on eggs and larvae of non-habitual parasitoids for P. rapae, Glyptapanteles pallipes, Cotesia kariyai and Cotesia plutellae at 1–100 µg/ml, levels essentially equivalent to those found in P. rapae larvae. In contrast, eggs and larvae of the natural parasitoid of P. rapae, Cotesia glomerata proved resistant to the toxicity of pierisin-1 through inhibition of pierisin-1 penetration of the surface layer. The expression level of pierisin-1 mRNA in the larvae of P. rapae was increased by parasitization by C. plutellae, whereas it was decreased by C. glomerata. In addition, C. plutellae was associated with elevation of activated pierisin-1 in the hemolymph. From these observations, it is suggested that pierisin-1 could contribute as a defense factor against parasitization by some type of wasps in P. rapae.     

Molecular cloning and expression patterns of FK506‐binding protein 12, an immunophilin from the cabbage butterfly,Pieris rapae

FK506‐binding protein (FK506BP) class belonging to immunophilin protein family has been known to play key roles in modulating T‐cell activation, regulation of cell cycle and protein folding. However, little is known about the involvement of FK506BP during viral pathogenesis in insect host. In this study, an attempt has been made to focus on the involvement of FK506BP in antiviral innate immunity, by cloning the full‐length cDNA of FK506BP12 (PrFK506BP12) from the cabbage butterfly, Pieris rapae. It comprised of 532 bp (excluding poly‐A tail) with a longest open reading frame (ORF) of 327 bp encoding 108 amino acids. In silico analysis of PrFK506BP12 ORF revealed a highly conserved FK506‐binding domain (FKBD). As expected, it showed high homology to other FK506BPs identified from Bombyx mori (92%), Manduca sexta (91%), Suberites domuncula (82%), Tribolium castaneum (81%) and Aedes aegypti (74%) . Expression of PrFK506BP12 was observed during developmental stages of P. rapae, but was pronounced in late pupal and adult stage. In addition, spatial expression pattern analysis indicated its high expression in the head and fat body. Furthermore, PrFK506BP12 mRNA was induced 12 h after LTA, Poly I:C treatment and 3h after Pieris rapae granulovirus (PrGV) treatment in carcass. It suggests that PrFK506BP12 appears to be involved in immune responses and also play an important role in the fat body, although it remains to be clarified about their precise role in response to granulovirus.     

Influences of plant species on life history traits of Cotesia rubecula (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) and its host Pieris rapae (Lepidotera: Pieridae)

The relative suitability of four plants was studied for larvae of Pieris rapae L. and its parasitoid Cotesia rubecula (Marshall). For unparasitized P. rapae, pupal dry weight and egg-pupa growth rate were higher on cabbage, radish and nasturtium than on Indian hedge mustard. Larval developmental rate and size were greatest for C. rubecula when its host was feeding on nasturtium. Wasp survival was not affected by the host insect/plant combination in which the parasitoid developed. These results indicate that the plant on which host larvae feed is an important factor in development of the parasitoid.     

Occurrence and accumulation of the granulosis virus of Pieris rapae in treated field plots

The granulosis virus of Pieris rapae, the imported cabbageworm (P. rapae GV), persisted in soil after application. Virus produced by epizootics of the disease in populations of the host accumulated in soil in nontreated plots with concentrations of the virus in soil and on foliage, being similar at harvest to concentrations in virus-treated plots. Also P. rapae GV produced in epizootics of the disease increased concentrations in soil of virus-treated plots and maintained substantial residues of the virus on the foliage. Little virus accumulated in plots treated with some chemical insecticides and Bacillus thuringiensis because few host larvae survived to support late-season epizootics. Small quantities of P. rapae GV were found in heads of cabbage harvested from plots in October, but these residues were not related to plot treatment.A study in which nontreated and virus-treated plots were replanted for 2 years after treatment indicated an increase in concentrations of P. rapae GV in surface soil in years following treatment. Concentrations of P. rapae GV in soil in virus-treated and nontreated plots were similar in the autumn of the year of treatment and in subsequent years of the study. Concentrations were nearly unchanged during the winter, were reduced by cultivation preparatory to planting in the spring, and increased with epizootics of the disease in host populations in summer and autumn.P. rapae GV disease was prevalent during September and October in populations of P. rapae larvae in plots in which substantial concentrations of the virus were found and contributed to late-season control of the pest insect.     

EFFECT OF PARASITIZATION BY THE PUPAL ENDOPARISITOID,PTEROMALUS PUPARUM (HYMENOPTERA: PTEROMALIDAE) ON HUMORAL IMMUNE REACTIONS OF PIERIS RAPAE (LEPIDOPETERA: PIERIDAE)*

Abstract Studies on the effect of parasitization by the endoparasitoid on host humoral immune reactions are carried out with the pupal endoparisitic wasp, Pteromalus puparum, and its host, Pieris rapae. Phenoloxidase (PO) activity of parasitized hosts hemolymph increased significantly at 12 h, day four and day five after parasitization. Hem‐agglutination activity of parasitized hosts hemolymph was always higher than that of wounded and unparasitized ones. Moreover, antibacterial activity of parasitized hosts hemolymph became more and more stronger, whilst wounded and unparasitized pupae only owned a weak antibacterial activity. It suggested that activities of humoral immune factors of Pieris rapae could be influenced to some degrees by P. puparum.     

Parasitism by Cotesia glomerata Induces Immunosuppression of Pieris rapae: Effects of Ovarian Protein and Polydnavirus

A gregarious endoparasitoid wasp, Cotesia glomerata, parasitizes the cabbage butterfly, Pieris rapae. During wandering larval stage for pupal metamorphosis, the parasitoid larvae egress from the parasitized host to form cocoons thus eventually leading to death of the host. This study focused on the effect of C. glomerata parasitization on cellular immune response of P. rapae. For this purpose, an ideal anticoagulant buffer was formulated to procure the hemocytes in native form with morphological, behavioral, and functional characteristics. The hemocytes selectively encapsulated only DEAE beads under in vitro conditions and a quantitative study revealed about 70% of the beads being encapsulated. On the other hand, calyx fluid from C. glomerata injected to P. rapae markedly inhibited the spreading ability of the hemocytes in a dose-dependent manner and also attenuated the in vitro encapsulation response of the hemocytes against the cationic bead. The calyx fluid contained polydnavirus as well as ovarian proteins. The isolated polydnavirus genome consisted of variously sized-segments with their unequal amounts. The P. rapae injected with the calyx fluid expressed several polydnaviral genes within 2 h. These results suggest that the immunosuppression of the parasitized P. rapae may be induced by the polydnaviral gene products as well as ovarian proteins.     

Nectar exploitation by herbivores and their parasitoids is a function of flower species and relative humidity

In conservation biological control, diversification of the agro ecosystem with flowering vegetation is seen as an important tool to support the broad range of predators and parasitoids that require nectar and pollen sources to survive and reproduce. In order to identify flowering plants that provide suitable food sources for natural enemies without supporting the pest species, we analyzed the exploitation of 19 flowering plants by two important lepidopteran cabbage pests, Pieris rapae and Plutella xylostella, and their hymenopteran parasitoids, Cotesia glomerata and Diadegma semiclausum. The experiments were conducted at 90% r.h., while Pieris rapae was tested both at 45% r.h. and at 90% r.h. At 45 ± 5% r.h., corresponding with field conditions at which P. rapae is predominantly active, the butterfly was unable to feed on a number of exposed floral nectar sources whose nectar was successfully exploited at 90% r.h. The broader nectar exploitation by P. rapae at the high humidity is presumably explained by the resulting decrease in nectar viscosity. When comparing D. semiclausum and its herbivorous host P. xylostella, the herbivore exploited a broader range of plants. However, those plants that benefited both the parasitoid and the herbivore had a much stronger effect on the longevity of the parasitoid. The results from the accessibility bioassay suggest that flowers where nectar is not accessible can have a negative impact on insect survival presumably by stimulating foraging without providing accessible nectar. Our results underline the importance of considering species-specific environmental conditions when fine-tuning the choice of nectar sources to be used in conservation biological control programs.     

Field evaluation of a granulosis virus for control ofPieris rapae [Lep.: Pieridae] in the United Kingdom

A purified granulosis virus isolated fromPieris brassicae (L.) was tested in the field against an introduced population ofPieris rapae (L.) larvae on cabbage (cv January King) in small experimental plots at Littlehampton, Sussex. Experiments were designed to compare the relative efficacy of single and multiple applications of virus (2.1×10¹² and 3.7×10¹² or 2.1×10¹⁴ and 3.7×10¹⁴ virus capsules/ha) in reducing numbers ofP. rapae larvae. An experiment was carried out in June 1978 and repeated in August to coincide approximately with the 2 natural generations ofP. rapae in southern England. Larval populations were monitored by regularin situ assessment of plants and by destructive sampling. Within 10 days of spraying virus there was a significant reduction in the mean larval population on all virus-treated plots compared with untreated controls. Sprays of 2.1×10¹⁴ and 3.7×10¹⁴ capsules/ha reduced larval numbers more quickly than 2.1×10¹² and 3.7×10¹²/ha treatments. In the 1st experiment, three sprays of virus at either 2.1×10¹² or 2.1×10¹⁴ capsules/ha gave no increase over the final level of control achieved by a single spray. However, in the 2nd experiment, a single spray of 3.7×10¹² capsules/ha did not significantly reduce the numbers of larvae. It is likely that this failure could be accounted for by a combination of the larger “natural” population ofP. rapae recorded midway through the 2nd experiment and the rapid inactivation of virus deposits which left little infectious virus to infect these larvae. Virus inactivation was so rapid that only 7–33 % of the initial virus deposits remained 1 day after application. These results suggest that further understanding of virus formulation, persistence and dosage rates are needed before such a virus can be used in a rational manner.     

A simple action treshold for timing applications of a granulosis virus to controlPieris rapae [Lep.: Pieridae]

Pieris rapae (L.) an important pest of cole crops in the northeastern United States, is susceptible to a granulosis virus,Pieris rapae GV (PrGV), that has been shown to be an effective control measure by researchers in several countries. As an alternative to weekly applications of virus to protect cabbage, we tested the use of an action threshold of one small (first-third instar) larva per plant. Results were compared with those obtained using the same threshold with permethrin, and with weekly applications of virus. Plots treated weekly with virus received 5 applications but the action threshold was exceeded only once. In all virus-treated plots, numbers of large (fourth-fifth instar) larvae remained below 0.35 per plant, and were lower at the end of the season (0.07 in plots treated weekly and 0.1 in plots treated once) than in either the untreated or permethrin-treated plots (0.5). In late August, numbers of large larvae in the check plots reached almost 3 per plant. At harvest the number of feeding holes over 0.3 cm in diameter in the 4 innermost frame and the 4 wrapper leaves were counted. Check plots differed from treated plots by an average of 124.2±6.5 holes per plant in the frame and wrapper leave; virus-treated plots had 51.1±6.9 holes more than the permethrin plots. The difference in overall damage between plots treated 5 times with virus during the season and those treated once was not significant. Plots treated once with virus had significantly more damage (7.6±2.7) to wrapper leaves than those treated five times and marketability ratings were somewhat lower, based on fresh market standards. There were no significant differences in head weight among the treatments. At harvest, a high proportion of larvae collected from the check plots were diseased (77% versus an average of 46% in the treated plots). Because of the high numbers of large larvae in the check plots in late August and the extensive damage to plants, we assumed that virus did not affect a significant number of larvae in these plots until late in the growing season. These results indicate the usefulness of PrGV in a cabbage IPM program and that the use of action thresholds can be highly effective, particularly when insect numbers only occasionally reach damaging levels. While cabbage treated with permethrin had the least amount of injury, that treated weekly with virus was not significantly different by fresh market standards, and all cabbages treated with virus met processing standards. For the fresh market, in which cosmetic standards are more important, PrGV may have to be used weekly or with an action threshold lower than one small larva per plant.      

An Evidence for Host Translation Inhibitory Factor Encoded in a Polydnavirus,Cotesia glomerata Bracovirus,Genome and Its Expression in Parasitized Cabbage White Butterfly,Pieris rapae

Polydnavirus is a DNA virus symbiotic to some endoparasitic wasps and plays a critical role in accomplishing successful parasitic life cycle of host wasps. Host translation inhibitory factor (HTIF) has been found in some polydnaviral genomes and performs parasitic functions leading to host immunosuppression and redirecting host nutrient usage to wasp development. The cabbage white butterfly, Pieris rapae, parasitized by a gregarious endoparasitoid, Cotesia glomerata, undergoes several physiological alterations including immune malfunctioning and failure of pupal metamorphosis. C. glomerata possesses its own symbiotic polydnavirus, C. glomerata bracovirus (CgBV). Its genome consisted of at least 12 segments in unequal amounts. Parasitized P. rapae hemolymph contained HTIF-like protein, which was determined through an immunoblotting assay using HTIF antibody of C. plutellae bracovirus (CpBV). RT-PCR using HTIF primers of CpBV produced an HTIF-like gene in P. rapae larvae parasitized by C. glomerata. Also, this HTIF-like gene was encoded in CgBV genome and its partial sequence of CgBV showed highly homology (98.5%) to amino acid sequence of an HTIF of CpBV, called CpBV15a. These results suggest that a common HTIF-like moiety may be shared among Cotesia-associated bracovirus.     

Interspecific egg load assessment of host plants by Pieris rapae butterflies

Egglaying responses of Pieris rapae L. butterflies to the oviposition deterring pheromone (ODP) of Pieris brassicae L. were studied in the laboratory. Choice experiments with ODP treated leaves and control leaves revealed that females perform a strong preference to lay their eggs on the control leaves. This preference is maintained even when during the experiment the control leaf becomes covered with a large number of conspecific eggs. Choice experiments with cabbage leaves with and without P. rapae eggs seem to indicate the absence of intraspecific egg load assessment of host plants in P. rapae. The deterrent effect of the ODP of P. brassicae to P. rapae females persists for at least 8 days. Behavioural observations suggest olfactory hairs as well as gustatory hairs to be involved in the perception of the ODP but electrophysiological recordings of the various chemoreceptors are necessary to confirm this. Finally the prospects of application of this pheromone/kairomone in cabbage pest control are discussed.

---

Appréciation de la charge interspécifique en oeufs sur la plante hôte par Pieris rapae

Résumé La réponse au laboratoire de P. rapae à la phéromone dissuadant la ponte (ODP) de P. brassicae a été étudiée par l'oviposition. Des expériences de choix entre des feuilles traitées à l'ODP et des témoins ont montré que les femelles préfèrent nettement les feuilles témoins. Cette préférence s'est maintenue même quand les feuilles témoins ont été recouvertes d'un grand nombre d'oeufs de P. rapae. Ceci peut indiquer l'absence chez P. rapae d'une évaluation de la charge de ses propres oeufs. L'effet dissuadant du ODP de P. brassicae sur les femelles de P. rapae persiste au moins 8 jours. Les observations comportementales suggèrent que des poils olfactifs aussi bien que des poils gustatifs sont impliqués dans la perception d'ODP mais une confirmation de cette hypothèse par enregistrements électrophysiologiques est nécessaire. Les perspectives d'utilisation de cette phéromone/kairomone dans la lutte contre les insectes du chou sont examinées.