Neutral drift and polymorphism in gene-for-gene systems

Pathogens are a main driving force of the evolution of plants and animals. Being resistant to diseases confers a high selective advantage to hosts, yet many host–pathogen systems show a remarkable degree of polymorphism of host resistance and pathogen virulence. The most common explanation of this phenomenon is that both resistance and virulence genes are costly and that there is selection against those genes when they are unnecessary. Here, we use stochastic multi‐locus simulations to show that the origin and the maintenance of genetic polymorphism in plant–pathogen systems can be explained without costs. In multi‐locus gene‐for‐gene systems, temporal domination of a super pathogen can cause polymorphism in resistance through neutral drift. With an increasing number of susceptible alleles in the host population, pathogen types other than the super race are able to cause infections and invade the population, leading to higher pathogen diversity and in turn to higher host diversity.     

Two modes of host–enemy coevolution

The process of coevolution between host and enemy has traditionally been viewed as an evolutionary arms race between resistance and counterresistance. The arms-race metaphor of coevolution is widely accepted because it explains the evolution of many characters in species involved in host–enemy interactions. However, molecular work in plant–pathogen systems suggests a coevolutionary interplay between plant recognition of an attacking pathogen and pathogen evasion from recognition. We refer to this process as information coevolution, and contrast this with arms race coevolution to show that these two processes result in very different patterns of host resistance and enemy virulence at the population level. First, information coevolution results in a lower proportion of hosts that are susceptible to enemy attack within a population. Second, information coevolution produces a pattern of local maladaptation of enemy on host, a naturally occurring phenomenon that is difficult to explain under arms race coevolution. We then conduct a literature review to survey the empirical support for either mode of coevolution using the predicted patterns of host resistance and enemy virulence. Evidence supports both modes of coevolution in plant–enemy interactions, whereas no support is found for information coevolution in vertebrate–parasite and invertebrate–parasite systems.     

Spatial deployment of gene-for-gene resistance governs evolution and spread of pathogen populations

We formulate a spatially realistic population-genetic model for ascertaining the synergetic effect between genetic and spatial composition of the host population on the pathogen spread reinforced by evolutionary processes. We show that spatial arrangement of host genotypes is crucial to the efficacy of host genetic diversification. In particular, the reductive effect of multigenic resistance on the pathogen density can be produced by a random patterning of monogenic resistances. Random patterns can reduce both density and genetic diversity of the pathogen population and delay invasion promoted by sexual recombination. By contrast, patchy distributions diversify pathogen population and, hence, reduce the efficacy of resistance genes. The proposed approach provides theoretical support for studying fast emergence and spread of novel pathogen genotypes carrying multiple virulence genes. It has a practical applicability to design innovative strategies for the most appropriate deployment of plant resistance genes.     

Multiline varieties and disease control

Summary A general model for the evolution of pathogen populations on mixtures or multilines is developed. This model is used to extend previous analyses of the effects of the widespread cultivation of multilines on the evolution of virulence in obligate parasites to mixtures of lines carrying different numbers of resistance genes. It is concluded that the composition of an equilibrium pathogen population growing on a multiline may vary within wide limits and the prinicipal determinant of its composition is the number of components in the multiline and the resistance genes they carry. Other factors of importance are (i) the relative contribution made by each host class (with different numbers of resistance genes) to the pathogen spore pool each generation; (ii) the levels of stabilizing selection against unnecessary virulence genes; and (iii) the way in which unnecessary genes for virulence combine to reduce pathogen fitness. Conditions for the fixation of avirulent biotypes in the pathogen population and the evolution of a pathogen superrace are given for multilines of various compositions.Paper No. 9246 of the Journal Series of the North Carolina Agricultural Research Service, Raleigh, North Carolina. This investigation was supported in part by NIH Research Grant No. GM 11546 from the National Institute of General Medical Sciences     

Coevolutionary genetics of plants and pathogens

Summary The genetic polymorphism maintained by host-pathogen coevolution is analysed in a multilocus model. The model assumes gene-for-gene interactions of the type commonly observed between host plants and their fungal pathogens. Unstable (epidemic) systems maintain more resistance genes, fewer virulence genes, and less overall genetic diversity than stable (endemic) diseases. The stability of the system depends primarily on demographic parameters, such as the pathogen's intrinsic rate of increase, rather than genetic parameters, such as the costs of resistance and virulence. At equilibrium the model predicts that the number of resistance alleles in each host plant follows a binomial distribution that depends on the cost to the pathogen for carrying virulence alleles. Similarly, the number of virulence alleles in each pathogen spore follows a binomial distribution that depends on one minus the cost to the host for carrying resistance alleles. Data from wild populations match the predicted binomial distributions.     

Review of innate and specific immunity in plants and animals

Innate immunity represents a trait common to plants and animals, based on the recognition of pathogen associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) by the host pattern recognition receptors (PRRs). It is generally assumed that a pathogen strain, or race, may have elaborated mechanisms to suppress, or evade, the PAMP-triggered immunity. Once this plan was successful, the colonization would have been counteracted by an adaptive strategy that a plant cultivar must have evolved as a second line of defence. In this co-evolutionary context, adaptive immunity and host resistance (cultivar-pathogen race/strain-specific) has been differently selected, in animals and plants respectively, to face specialized pathogens. Notwithstanding, plant host resistance, based on matching between resistance (R) and avirulence (avr) genes, represents a form of innate immunity, being R proteins similar to PRRs, although able to recognize specific virulence factors (avr proteins) rather than PAMPs. Besides, despite the lack of adaptive immunity preserved plants from autoimmune disorders, inappropriate plant immune responses may occur, producing some side-effects, in terms of fitness costs of induced resistance and autotoxicity. A set of similar defence responses shared from plants and animals, such as defensins, reactive oxygen species (ROS), oxylipins and programmed cell death (PCD) are briefly described.     

A Dual Role for Microbial Pathogen-Derived Effector Proteins in Plant Disease and Resistance

Many proteins from plant pathogens affecting the interaction with the host plant have dual functions: they promote virulence on the host species and they function as avirulence determinants by eliciting defense reactions in host cultivars expressing the appropriate resistance genes. In viruses all proteins encoded by the small genomes can be expected to be essential for viral development in the host. However, in different plants surveillance systems have evolved that are able to recognize most of these proteins. Bacteria and fungi have specialized pathogenicity and virulence genes. Many of the latter were originally identified through the resistance gene-dependent elicitor activity of their products. Their role in virulence only became apparent when they were inactivated or transferred to different microbes or after their ectopic expression in host plants. Many microbes appear to maintain these genes despite their disadvantageous effect, introducing only few mutations to abolish the interaction of their products with the plant recognition system. This has been interpreted as been indicative of a virulence function of the gene products that is not impaired by the mutations. Alternatively, in particular in bacteria there is now evidence that pathogenicity was acquired through horizontal gene transfer. Genes supporting virulence in the donor organism's original host appear to have traveled along. Being gratuitous in the new situation, they may have been inactivated without loss of any beneficial function for the pathogen.     

植物病原物无毒基因及其功能

植物抗病基因与病原物无毒基因产物间直接或间接相互作用导致产生的基因对基因抗性是植物抗病性的重要形式。无毒基因已在多种植物病原物 ,包括真菌、细菌、病毒和卵菌等中得到克隆。绝大多数已克隆无毒基因之间 ,及其与已知蛋白之间 ,均无显著序列同源性。然而 ,多数已克隆植物抗病基因有较高序列一致性 ,产物往往具有相似的结构域。由序列一致性很高的抗病基因产物与没有明显序列同源性的无毒基因产物相互作用 ,介导产生的过敏性细胞坏死和抗病性 ,在产生速度、强度和组织特异性等方面均可能有显著差异。无毒基因具有双重功能 :在含互补抗病基因植物中表现无毒效应 ,而在不含互补抗病基因植物中显示小种、菌株、致病型、或种特异性毒性效应     

Evolution of linked avirulence effectors in Leptosphaeria maculans is affected by genomic environment and exposure to resistance genes in host plants

Brassica napus (canola) cultivars and isolates of the blackleg fungus, Leptosphaeria maculans interact in a 'gene for gene' manner whereby plant resistance (R) genes are complementary to pathogen avirulence (Avr) genes. Avirulence genes encode proteins that belong to a class of pathogen molecules known as effectors, which includes small secreted proteins that play a role in disease. In Australia in 2003 canola cultivars with the Rlm1 resistance gene suffered a breakdown of disease resistance, resulting in severe yield losses. This was associated with a large increase in the frequency of virulence alleles of the complementary avirulence gene, AvrLm1, in fungal populations. Surprisingly, the frequency of virulence alleles of AvrLm6 (complementary to Rlm6) also increased dramatically, even though the cultivars did not contain Rlm6. In the L. maculans genome, AvrLm1 and AvrLm6 are linked along with five other genes in a region interspersed with transposable elements that have been degenerated by Repeat-Induced Point (RIP) mutations. Analyses of 295 Australian isolates showed deletions, RIP mutations and/or non-RIP derived amino acid substitutions in the predicted proteins encoded by these seven genes. The degree of RIP mutations within single copy sequences in this region was proportional to their proximity to the degenerated transposable elements. The RIP alleles were monophyletic and were present only in isolates collected after resistance conferred by Rlm1 broke down, whereas deletion alleles belonged to several polyphyletic lineages and were present before and after the resistance breakdown. Thus, genomic environment and exposure to resistance genes in B. napus has affected the evolution of these linked avirulence genes in L. maculans.     

The Pseudomonas syringae avrRpt2 gene product promotes pathogen virulence from inside plant cells

Several bacterial avr genes have been shown to contribute to virulence on susceptible plants lacking the corresponding resistance (R) gene. The mechanisms by which avr genes promote parasitism and disease, however, are not well understood. We investigated the role of the Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato avrRpt2 gene in pathogenesis by studying the interaction of P. syringae pv. tomato strain PstDC3000 expressing avrRpt2 with several Arabidopsis thaliana lines lacking the corresponding R gene, RPS2. We found that PstDC3000 expressing avrRpt2 grew to significantly higher levels and often resulted in the formation of more severe disease symptoms in ecotype No-0 plants carrying a mutant RPS2 allele, as well as in two Col-0 mutant lines, cpr5 rps2 and coil rps2, that exhibit enhanced resistance. We also generated transgenic A. thaliana lines expressing avrRpt2 and demonstrated, by using several different assays, that expression of avrRpt2 within the plant also promotes virulence of PstDC3000. Thus, AvrRpt2 appears to promote pathogen virulence from within the plant cell.     

Coevolution at multiple spatial scales: Linum marginale–Melampsora lini – from the individual to the species

Coevolutionary processes are intrinsically spatial as well as temporal, and occur at many different scales. These range from single populations dominated by demographic and genetic stochasticity, to metapopulations in which colonisation/extinction dynamics have a large influence, and larger geographic regions where phylogenetic patterns and historical events become important. We present data for the genetically and demographically well-characterised plant host–pathogen interaction, the Linum marginale–Melampsora lini system, and use this to demonstrate the varying nature of resistance and virulence structure across these spatial scales. At the within population level, our results indicate considerable variability in resistance and virulence, but little evidence of coordinated changes in host and pathogen. Studies involving comparisons among multiple demes within a single metapopulation show that adjacent populations often have asynchronous disease dynamics and large differences in diversity and frequency of resistance and virulence phenotypes. Nevertheless, at this scale, there is also evidence of spatial structure in that more closely adjacent host populations are significantly more likely to have similar resistance phenotypes and mean levels of resistance. At larger scales, comparisons among adjacent metapopulations indicate that quantitative differences in host mating system and other life history features can have further major consequences for how host and pathogen variation is packaged. Finally, comparisons at continental and among host-species levels show variation consistent with specialisation and speciation in the pathogen. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Macrophage replication screen identifies a novel Francisella hydroperoxide resistance protein involved in virulence

Francisella tularensis is a gram-negative facultative intracellular pathogen and the causative agent of tularemia. Recently, genome-wide screens have identified Francisella genes required for virulence in mice. However, the mechanisms by which most of the corresponding proteins contribute to pathogenesis are still largely unknown. To further elucidate the roles of these virulence determinants in Francisella pathogenesis, we tested whether each gene was required for replication of the model pathogen F. novicida within macrophages, an important virulence trait. Fifty-three of the 224 genes tested were involved in intracellular replication, including many of those within the Francisella pathogenicity island (FPI), validating our results. Interestingly, over one third of the genes identified are annotated as hypothetical, indicating that F. novicida likely utilizes novel virulence factors for intracellular replication. To further characterize these virulence determinants, we selected two hypothetical genes to study in more detail. As predicted by our screen, deletion mutants of FTN_0096 and FTN_1133 were attenuated for replication in macrophages. The mutants displayed differing levels of attenuation in vivo, with the FTN_1133 mutant being the most attenuated. FTN_1133 has sequence similarity to the organic hydroperoxide resistance protein Ohr, an enzyme involved in the bacterial response to oxidative stress. We show that FTN_1133 is required for F. novicida resistance to, and degradation of, organic hydroperoxides as well as resistance to the action of the NADPH oxidase both in macrophages and mice. Furthermore, we demonstrate that F. holarctica LVS, a strain derived from a highly virulent human pathogenic species of Francisella, also requires this protein for organic hydroperoxide resistance as well as replication in macrophages and mice. This study expands our knowledge of Francisella's largely uncharacterized intracellular lifecycle and demonstrates that FTN_1133 is an important novel mediator of oxidative stress resistance.     

The social evolution of bacterial pathogenesis

Many of the genes responsible for the virulence of bacterial pathogens are carried by mobile genetic elements that can be transferred horizontally between different bacterial lineages. Horizontal transfer of virulence-factor genes has played a profound role in the evolution of bacterial pathogens, but it is poorly understood why these genes are so often mobile. Here, I present a hypothetical selective mechanism maintaining virulence-factor genes on horizontally transmissible genetic elements. For virulence factors that are secreted extracellularly, selection within hosts may favour mutant 'cheater' strains of the pathogen that do not produce the virulence factor themselves but still benefit from factors produced by other members of the pathogen population within a host. Using simple mathematical models, I show that if this occurs then selection for infectious transmission between hosts favours pathogen strains that can reintroduce functional copies of virulence-factor genes into cheaters via horizontal transfer, forcing them to produce the virulence factor. Horizontal gene transfer is thus a novel mechanism for the evolution of cooperation. I discuss predictions of this hypothesis that can be tested empirically and its implications for the evolution of pathogen virulence.     

Rates of evolution of avirulence phenotypes and DNA markers in a northwest European population of Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici

The effects of evolutionary processes in fungal pathogen populations may occur more rapidly and display larger effects in agricultural systems than in wild ecosystems because of human involvement by plant breeding and crop management. In this study, we analysed the rate of evolution in three lineages of a northwest European population of a biotrophic and asexual reproduced fungal pathogen, Puccinia striiformis f. sp. tritici, causing yellow rust on wheat. Pathogen samples were collected between 1975 and 2002 in the UK and Denmark, and assayed for 14 individual avirulence/virulence alleles and up to 234 amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) primer pairs producing approximately 17,000 AFLP fragments. The large number of fragments and a targeted sampling of isolates allowed a reconstruction of phylogenies in great detail, i.e. no homoplasy and a representation of sequential, evolutionary steps by pathogen samples. A recent, phenotypic loss of avirulence was observed at least once for loci corresponding to P. striiformis f. sp. tritici resistance Yr2, Yr3, Yr4, Yr7, Yr9, and Yr15, whereas Avr6 and Avr17 were lost independently in all three lineages, corresponding to 16 events of loss of avirulence (emergence of virulence). The opposite process, restoration of avirulence, was observed for Yr9 and Yr32. An interpretation of phenotypic changes within lineages as independent mutation events resulted in mutation frequencies from 1.4x10(-6) to 4.1x10(-6) per AFLP fragment (locus) per generation, whereas the effective rate by which a mutation from avirulence to virulence was established in the pathogen population, when subject to selection by host resistance genes, was approximately three orders of magnitude faster.     

Reliability of statistical analyses for estimating relative specificity in quantitative resistance in a model host-pathogen system

Summary The reliability of analyses of variance for evaluating host cultivar x pathogen isolate specificity in resistance controlled by polygenes with additive effects was tested with combinations of hypothetical host and pathogen genotypes in a model system. In each test, varying numbers of host and pathogen genotypes were combined in all combinations, the resulting disease severities were calculated according to the model, and those data were subjected to analysis of variance. The percentage of total variance accounted for by host x pathogen interaction decreased with increasing numbers of host and pathogen genotypes per test. Simulated selection for virulence among randomly generated pathogen genotypes increased the percentage of variance attributable to host x pathogen genotype interaction, but simulated selection for resistance among host genotypes decreased it. The percentage of variance accounted for by interaction was greatest when selection of resistant host genotypes was followed by selection of the most virulent pathogen genotype on each selected host genotype. When gene frequencies were varied in the model, the interaction variance was greatest at low frequencies of resistance genes and high frequencies of virulence genes, but the number of matches between genes for specific virulence and specific resistance was greatest for high frequencies of both resistance and virulence genes. A simplified method of analysis was developed to estimate the amount of specific resistance in a set of host genotypes inoculated in all combinations with a set of pathogen genotypes. This method, based on the variance of disease severity adjusted to remove general virulence, proved consistently accurate with varying numbers of genotypes in the set, varying numbers of loci for resistance and virulence, and varying frequencies of genes for resistance and virulence. The variance method is of comparable accuracy and is much simpler than the previously proposed methods based on regression analysis. Simulated selection for resistance in the host and for virulence in the pathogen population increased the accuracy of both the variance method and the regression method.     

Host Genetic Analysis by Using Puccinia recondita tritici Induced Mutants for Increased Virulence

Monogenic lines derived by recombination from Buck Manantial wheat, a cultivar which has durable resistance, were used as hosts to detect Puccinia recondita tritici induced mutants for increased virulence. After treatments with ethyl methane sulphonate on clone 66 of P. recondita 9 types of mutants were obtained at approximate frequencies of 1 × 10^?4 and host lines were grouped in 6 classes, No increase virulence was obtained against B. Manantial after 2 cycles of treatments, but different combinations of virulences were observed on monogenic lines derived from it. Simultaneity of occurrence of some mutational events suggests complexity of virulence genes in the pathogen. At least 4 genes for incompatibility are present in B. Manantial when confronted with clone 66 and 4 to 7 mutational points are recognized in the pathogen. The specific relationships tending to equate the number of genes in both organisms would not be a general rule. Durable resistance can be explained by a combination of several specific disease reaction genes for which the pathogen population has not been able to accumulate all the corresponding alleles for virulence.     

Theory of catastrophic diseases of cultivated plants

Genetically homogeneous plant populations generate selective pressures for pathogens to overcome host resistance. Once a pathogen strain has evolved which overcomes host resistance, a catastrophic collapse of genetically h homogeneous host population can result. The dynamics of such a collapse are discussed by means of a mathematical model. Also, a gametheoretical model shows that high density of the host population may lead to selection for maximum pathogen virulence rather than host-parasite commensalism. The evolution of mutant pathogens is compared with the evolution of insecticide resistance. While time frame estimates are intrinsically difficult to obtain, it is argued that industrial pollution may speed up the evolution of mutant pathogens and may have been responsible for a number of agricultural and horticultural epidemics. The theory may have implications for the clonal propagation of forests.     

Genome Analyses of an Aggressive and Invasive Lineage of the Irish Potato Famine Pathogen

Pest and pathogen losses jeopardise global food security and ever since the 19^th century Irish famine, potato late blight has exemplified this threat. The causal oomycete pathogen, Phytophthora infestans, undergoes major population shifts in agricultural systems via the successive emergence and migration of asexual lineages. The phenotypic and genotypic bases of these selective sweeps are largely unknown but management strategies need to adapt to reflect the changing pathogen population. Here, we used molecular markers to document the emergence of a lineage, termed 13_A2, in the European P. infestans population, and its rapid displacement of other lineages to exceed 75% of the pathogen population across Great Britain in less than three years. We show that isolates of the 13_A2 lineage are among the most aggressive on cultivated potatoes, outcompete other aggressive lineages in the field, and overcome previously effective forms of plant host resistance. Genome analyses of a 13_A2 isolate revealed extensive genetic and expression polymorphisms particularly in effector genes. Copy number variations, gene gains and losses, amino-acid replacements and changes in expression patterns of disease effector genes within the 13_A2 isolate likely contribute to enhanced virulence and aggressiveness to drive this population displacement. Importantly, 13_A2 isolates carry intact and in planta induced Avrblb1, Avrblb2 and Avrvnt1 effector genes that trigger resistance in potato lines carrying the corresponding R immune receptor genes Rpi-blb1, Rpi-blb2, and Rpi-vnt1.1. These findings point towards a strategy for deploying genetic resistance to mitigate the impact of the 13_A2 lineage and illustrate how pathogen population monitoring, combined with genome analysis, informs the management of devastating disease epidemics.     

Control of virulence gene expression by plant calcium in the phytopathogen Erwinia carotovora

Plant calcium can modulate a particular plant–pathogen interaction and have a decisive role in disease development. Enhanced resistance to the phytopathogenic enterobacterium Erwinia carotovora , the causal agent of bacterial soft rot disease, is observed in high-calcium plants. One of the main virulence determinants of E. carotovora , the PehA endopolygalacturonase, is specifically required in the early stages of the infection. Production of PehA was found to be dependent on the calcium concentration in the bacterial environment. An increase in extracellular calcium to mM concentrations repressed pehA gene expression without reducing or even enhancing expression of other extracellular enzyme-encoding genes of this pathogen. An increase in plant calcium levels could be correlated to enhanced resistance to E. carotovora infection and to an inhibition of in planta production of PehA. Ectopic expression of pehA from a calcium-insensitive promoter allowed E. carotovora to overcome this calcium-induced resistance. The results imply that plant calcium can constitute an important signal molecule in plant–pathogen interaction, which acts by modulating the expression of virulence genes of the pathogen.