Covariation of brain and skull shapes as a model to understand the role of crosstalk in development and evolution

Covariation among discrete phenotypes can arise due to selection for shared functions, and/or shared genetic and developmental underpinnings. The consequences of such phenotypic integration are far-reaching and can act to either facilitate or limit morphological variation. The vertebrate brain is known to act as an “organizer” of craniofacial development, secreting morphogens that can affect the shape of the growing neurocranium, consistent with roles for pleiotropy in brain–neurocranium covariation. Here, we test this hypothesis in cichlid fishes by first examining the degree of shape integration between the brain and the neurocranium using three-dimensional geometric morphometrics in an F₅ hybrid population, and then genetically mapping trait covariation using quantitative trait loci (QTL) analysis. We observe shape associations between the brain and the neurocranium, a pattern that holds even when we assess associations between the brain and constituent parts of the neurocranium: the rostrum and braincase. We also recover robust genetic signals for both hard- and soft-tissue traits and identify a genomic region where QTL for the brain and braincase overlap, implicating a role for pleiotropy in patterning trait covariation. Fine mapping of the overlapping genomic region identifies a candidate gene, notch1a, which is known to be involved in patterning skeletal and neural tissues during development. Taken together, these data offer a genetic hypothesis for brain–neurocranium covariation, as well as a potential mechanism by which behavioral shifts may simultaneously drive rapid change in neuroanatomy and craniofacial morphology.     

Retinoic acid causes abnormal development and segmental patterning of the anterior hindbrain in Xenopus embryos.

Retinoic acid is a very potent teratogen and has also been implicated as an endogenous developmental signalling molecule in vertebrate embryos. One of the regions of the embryo reliably affected by exogenously applied RA is the hindbrain. In this paper, we describe in detail the hindbrain of Xenopus laevis embryos briefly treated with various levels of RA at gastrula stages. Such treatments lead to development of embryos with loss of anterior structures. In addition, RA has a general effect on rhombomere morphology and specific effects on the development of the anterior rhombomeres. This effect is demonstrated using neurofilament antibodies, HRP staining and in situ hybridisation using a probe for expression of the Xenopus Krox-20 gene. Anatomically it is evident that the development of the hindbrain normally anterior to the otocyst (rhombomeres 1-4) is abnormal following RA treatment. Sensory and motor axons of cranial nerves V and VII form a single root and the peripheral paths of V and VII and IX and X are also abnormal, as is the more anterior location of the otocyst. These anatomical changes are accompanied by changes in the pattern of expression for the gene XKrox-20, which normally expresses in rhombomeres 3 and 5, but is found in a single band in the anterior hindbrain of treated embryos which standardly fail to generate the normal external segmental appearance. The results are discussed in terms of both the teratogenic and possible endogenous roles of RA during normal development of the central nervous system. We conclude that low doses of RA applied during gastrulation have specific effects on the anterior Xenopus hindbrain which appear to be evolutionarily conserved in the light of similar recent findings in zebrafish.     

Stuck on you: Meninges cellular crosstalk in development

The spatial and temporal development of the brain, overlying meninges (fibroblasts, vasculature and immune cells) and calvarium are highly coordinated. In particular, the timing of meningeal fibroblasts into molecularly distinct pia, arachnoid and dura subtypes coincides with key developmental events in the brain and calvarium. Further, the meninges are positioned to influence development of adjacent structures and do so via depositing basement membrane and producing molecular cues to regulate brain and calvarial development. Here, we review the current knowledge of how meninges development aligns with events in the brain and calvarium and meningeal fibroblast “crosstalk” with these structures. We summarize outstanding questions and how the use of non-mammalian models to study the meninges will substantially advance the field of meninges biology.     

Structure of the extraembryonic matrices around the benthic embryos of Patiriella exigua (Asteroidea) and their roles in benthic development: Comparison with the planktonic embryos of Patiriella regularis

The extracellular matrices (ECMs) surrounding the benthic embryos and larvae of the seastar Patiriella exigua and the planktonic embryos of Patiriella regularis were examined by transmission and scanning electron microscopy. Three ECMs surround unhatched embryos: An outer jelly coat, a fertilization envelope, and an inner hyaline layer. The ECMs of P. exigua are modified for supporting benthic development. The dense jelly coat attaches the embryo to the substratum, and the fertilization envelope forms a though protective case. In comparison, P. regularis has a less dense jelly coat and a thinner fertilization envelope. The hyaline layer of both species is comprised of three main regions: An intervillous layer overlying the epithelium, a supporting layer, and a coarse meshwork layer. Unhatched P. exigua have an additional outer amorphous layer that adheres to the fertilization envelope. As a result, the hyaline layer forms a continuous ECM that unites the embryonic surface with the fertilization envelope. Embryos of P. exigua removed from their fertilization envelopes lack the outer amorphous region, have a poorly developed hyaline layer, and do not develop beyond gastrulation. It appears that the substantial hyaline layer of P. exigua and its attachment to the fertilization envelope are essential for early development and that this ECM may function as a gelatinous cushioning layer around the benthic embryos. At hatching, the amorphous layer is discarded with the envelope. In contrast, an amorphous layer is absent from the hyaline layer of P. regularis. The demembranated embryos of this species have an ECM similar to that of controls and develop normally to the larval stage. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Roentgen cephalometric studies on skull development in rats. II. Normal and hypophysectomized males; sex differences

Growth of the skull in normal male rats of the Long-Evans strain has been studied by serial roentgen cephalometry (under anesthesia) from 27 to 280 days of age, and has been compared with the retardation following hypophysectomy and with growth data obtained on females in an earlier similar study. The dimensions measured represented major skull regions and segments, and in some instances allowed calculation of indices (e.g., neurocranial width/length ratio) which would show changing proportions. In general, the skull showed the more rapid and prolonged growth characteristic of male rats' skeletal development when compared with that of females. Viscerocranial (“facial”) length and width were notable in this respect. On the other hand, growth in neurocranial width and height ceased at a time and size much like that in females. Examination of the possibility that the adult female skull might correspond closely to that of an immature male disclosed that though this might be true for the neurocranium, facial dimensions showed distinctive sex differences. After hypophysectomy at 27 days of age males (as also females) showed marked reduction of growth but not complete cessation. Dimensional increases were between one-fifth and one-fourth of the normal gains. The ratios computed showed that the proportions of infancy were retained after early hypophysectomy.     

The effect of ethanol upon early development in mice and rats. VIII. The effect of chronic consumption of some beverages upon preimplantation development in rats

The effects of chronic consumption of some beverages (plum-brandy 24% and cognac 20%) upon preimplantation development in rats were studied. The control of possible effects was performed on day 5 by usual flushing, examination and photographying of oviductal and uterine embryos. In order to evaluate the effect of the beverage applied, the following criteria were used: mean litter size, migration of the embryos from the oviduct to the uterus, the developmental stage attained by the pre-implantation embryos and the appearance of pathological embryos. The main results were the following: both beverages applied influenced the preimplantation development; with respect to the developmental rate and to the induction of pathological changes, the effect of both beverages was similar (retardation and an increased, number of pathological morulae and blastocysts); a different action could be detected as to the mean litter size and to the migration of preimplantation embryos: plum-brandy reduced more substantially the mean litter size, whereas cognac had a more marked retarding effect upon the migration of embryos from the oviduct to the uterus: all the changes detected show a more or less marked "litter-effect". The present data were compared with the corresponding effects of chronic ethanol administration observed previously in our laboratory. No obvious potentiating effect of beverage congeners could be established. The findings are discussed in connection with other experimental models of alcohol embryo and fetopathy.     

Evolutionary strategies of odontocete brain development

The development of the brain was studied in several species of toothed whales (harbour porpoise, spotted dolphin, narwhal, and sperm whale). As embryos, odontocetes show the general mammalian bauplan. The olfactory bulb, lacking in adult toothed whales, forms in embryos but then disappears in early fetal development. In contrast, the terminal nerve persists and shows a great increase in neuron number. Some components of the limbic system are reduced while others grow to become relatively large. The pyramidal tract is inconspicuous. The auditory system and the extrapyramidal system show rapid size increase. In the sperm whale, growth of the telencephalic hemispheres relative to the size of the brain as a whole (telencephalization) and expansion of the cortical areas (neocorticalization) are greater than in other mammals. Increases in the diameters of the cranial nerves seem to be correlated with their presumed functional roles in the postnatal animal.     

The importance of cell contact for the proliferation of neuroblasts in culture and its stimulation by meningeal extract

The influence of cell density and cell contacts on the proliferation of neuroblasts in culture and its stimulation by meningeal extract were investigated. Dissociated brain cells from 6-day-old chick embryos were cultured under 3 different culture conditions to obtain dense or sparse brain cell cultures, as well as cultures of isolated neuronal cells. The proliferation of neuroblasts, shown by morphological observations, cell counts, determinations of DNA content and measurements of [³H]thymidine incorporation, was found to be the highest in cultures where cell density and cellular contacts were greatest. The addition of meningeal extract stimulated the multiplication of neuroblasts only in cultures where the cells were in closer contact with each other. The results suggested, therefore, that cell density and cell-cell interactions are of importance and favored neuroblast proliferation.     

The beneficial effect EDTA on development of mouse one-cell embryos in chemically defined medium.

An improved methology for culturing noninbred (ICR) mouse one-cell embryos is described. The successful development of one-cell embryos into blastocysts in chemically defined (Whitten's) medium was significantly enhanced by the presence of EDTA. More than 70% of ICR one-cell embryos developed into blastocysts in Whitten's medium in the presence of 10.8 μM EDTA, while, without EDTA, only 15–30% of embryos reached blastocyst stage. A concentration of 10.8 μM EDTA also promoted the development of 65–90% of inbred $\text{C57BL}\text{6}$ one-cell embryos in Whitten's medium. This beneficial role of EDTA is probably related to the chelation of some metal ion(s) other than Ca²⁺ or Mg²⁺.     

The embryonic rat parietal yolk sac. Changes in the morphology and composition of its basement membrane during development.

The basement membrane (Reichert's membrane) of the entire capsular portion of the parietal yolk sac of rat embryos was examined both morphologically and chemically at various stages of gestation. The overall microscopic and compositional analyses showed Reichert's membrane to be typical of basement membranes isolated from other tissues and species. However, with increasing gestational age (from 11.5 to 17.5 days) a number of changes involving Reichert's membrane were noted: 1. The thickness increased rapidly then declined, while the surface area increased tenfold; 2. The total protein content increased twenty-fold while the collagen content increased eight-fold. As a result, the relative collagen content declined significantly; 3. The changes in the amino acid and carbohydrate composition were consistent with the latter finding.The observations listed above were evaluated in light of their possible relevance to an understanding of the morphogenesis of basement membranes during development, and to the possible mechanisms involved in pathogenesis of basement membrane dysfunction.     

FGF/FGFR signaling coordinates skull development by modulating magnitude of morphological integration: evidence from Apert syndrome mouse models

The fibroblast growth factor and receptor system (FGF/FGFR) mediates cell communication and pattern formation in many tissue types (e.g., osseous, nervous, vascular). In those craniosynostosis syndromes caused by FGFR1-3 mutations, alteration of signaling in the FGF/FGFR system leads to dysmorphology of the skull, brain and limbs, among other organs. Since this molecular pathway is widely expressed throughout head development, we explore whether and how two specific mutations on Fgfr2 causing Apert syndrome in humans affect the pattern and level of integration between the facial skeleton and the neurocranium using inbred Apert syndrome mouse models Fgfr2(+/S252W) and Fgfr2(+/P253R) and their non-mutant littermates at P0. Skull morphological integration (MI), which can reflect developmental interactions among traits by measuring the intensity of statistical associations among them, was assessed using data from microCT images of the skull of Apert syndrome mouse models and 3D geometric morphometric methods. Our results show that mutant Apert syndrome mice share the general pattern of MI with their non-mutant littermates, but the magnitude of integration between and within the facial skeleton and the neurocranium is increased, especially in Fgfr2(+/S252W) mice. This indicates that although Fgfr2 mutations do not disrupt skull MI, FGF/FGFR signaling is a covariance-generating process in skull development that acts as a global factor modulating the intensity of MI. As this pathway evolved early in vertebrate evolution, it may have played a significant role in establishing the patterns of skull MI and coordinating proper skull development.     

Evolution of envelope-specific antibody responses in monkeys experimentally infected or immunized with simian immunodeficiency virus and its association with the development of protective immunity.

Previous studies of attenuated simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) vaccines in rhesus macaques have demonstrated the development of broad protection against experimental challenge, indicating the potential for the production of highly effective immune responses to SIV antigens. However, the development of this protective immune status was found to be critically dependent on the length of time postvaccination with the attenuated virus strain, suggesting a necessary maturation of immune responses. In this study, the evolution of SIV envelope-specific antibodies in monkeys experimentally infected with various attenuated strains of SIV was characterized by using a comprehensive panel of serological assays to assess the progression of antibodies in longitudinal serum samples that indicate the development of protective immunity. In parallel studies, we also used the same panel of antibody assays to characterize the properties of SIV envelope-specific antibodies elicited by inactivated whole-virus and envelope subunit vaccines previously reported to be ineffective in producing protective immunity. The results of these studies demonstrate that the evolution of protective immunity in monkeys inoculated with attenuated strains of SIV is associated with a complex and lengthy maturation of antibody responses over the first 6 to 8 months postinoculation, as reflected in progressive changes in antibody conformational dependence and avidity properties. The establishment of long-term protective immunity at this time in general parallels the absence of further detectable changes in antibody responses and a maintenance of relatively constant antibody titer, avidity, conformational dependence, and the presence of neutralizing antibody for at least 2 years postinoculation. In contrast to the mature antibody responses elicited by the attenuated SIV vaccines, the whole-virus and envelope subunit vaccines in general elicited only immature antibody responses characterized by poor reactivity with native envelope proteins, low avidity, low conformational dependence, and the absence of neutralization activity against the challenge strain. Thus, these studies establish for the first time an association between the effectiveness of experimental vaccines and the capacity of the vaccine to produce a mature antibody response to SIV envelope proteins and further indicate that a combination of several antibody parameters (including titer, avidity, conformational dependence, and virus neutralization) are superior to any single antibody parameter as prognostic indicators to evaluate candidate AIDS vaccines.     

The initial development of the human brain.

An account of the early development of the human brain has been prepared from the data available for the Carnegie Collection, as well as from published information from other sources. Although the site of the neural plate can be discerned at stage 7, the first visible indication of the nervous system is the neural groove in certain embryos of stage 8, in which the embryonic disc measures more than 1 mm and the notochordal process at least 0.3 mm. The progressive fusion of the neural folds during stage 10, and the closure of the rostral and caudal neuropores at stages 11 and 12, respectively, are detailed with further precision than hitherto. It is emphasized that the major subdivisions of the human brain do not begin as vesicles, but as enlargements of the open neural folds at stage 9. The relationships of the neuromeres to the otic region, the somites, and the neural crest are clarified and illustrated. The early appearance of the telencephalon medium (before cerebral vesicles have formed) is stressed, and the terminological implications for the subdivisions of the brain are discussed.     

Modifications in energy metabolism during the development of chick glial cells and neurons in culture

Developmental changes in lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), enolase, hexokinase (HK), malate dehydrogenase (MDH), and glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH) activities were measured in cultures of pure neurons and glial cells prepared from brains of chick embryos (8 day-old for neurons, 14 day-old for glial cells) as a function of cellular development with time in culture. The modifications observed in culture were compared to those measured in brain extracts during the development of the nervous tissue in the chick embryo and during the post-hatching period. A significant increase of MDH, GDH, LDH, and enolase activities are observed in neurons between 3 and 6 days of culture, whereas simultaneously a decrease of HK values occurs. In the embryonic brain between 11 and 14 days of incubation, which would correspond for the neuronal cultures to day 3 through 6, modifications of MDH, GDH, HK, and enolase levels are similar to those observed in neurons in culture. Only the increase of LDH activity is less pronounced in vivo than in cultivated cells. The evolution of the tested enzymatic activities in the brain of the chick during the period between 7 days before and 10 days after hatching is quite similar to that observed in cultivated glial cells (prepared from 14 day-old embryos) between 6 and 18 days of culture. All tested activities increased in comparable proportions. The modifications of the enzymatic profile indicate that some maturation phenomena affecting energy metabolism of neuronal and glial elements in culture, are quite similar to those occuring in the total nervous tissue. A relationship between the development of the energy metabolism of the brain and differentiation processes affecting neuroblasts and the glial-forming cells is discussed.     

p62/p56 are cortical granule proteins that contribute to formation of the cortical granule envelope and play a role in mammalian preimplantation development

The purpose of this study was to identify specific cortical granule protein(s) that form the cortical granule envelope and examine their role(s) in fertilization and preimplantation development. The polyclonal antibody A-BL2 was used to show that the cortical granules of mice, rats, hamsters, cows, and pigs contain a pair of proteins designated p62/p56. These proteins are released from hamster cortical granules at fertilization and contribute to formation of the cortical granule envelope, an extracellular matrix present in the perivitelline space of fertilized mammalian oocytes. P62/p56 were present in the cortical granule envelope throughout preimplantation development and were found in blastomere cortices of 4-cell to blastocyst stage embryos. Hamster oocytes fertilized in vivo in the presence of A-BL2 were all monospermic, suggesting that p62/p56 do not function in blocking polyspermy. Likewise treatment of morula to blastocyst stage hamster embryos with A-BL2 had no effect on the implantation of blastocysts. However, cleavage divisions were inhibited in vivo in a dose-dependent manner when fertilized oocytes or 2-cell embryos were treated with A-BL2. Inhibition of cell division was more pronounced in 2-cell embryos than in fertilized oocytes. This study identifies p62/p56 as cortical granule proteins that contribute to the formation of the cortical granule envelope and further supports the idea that after their release at fertilization, p62/p56 function in regulating preimplantation development at the level of oocyte and blastomere cleavage.     

Developmental biology of the meninges

The meninges are membranous layers surrounding the central nervous system. In the head, the meninges lie between the brain and the skull, and interact closely with both during development. The cranial meninges originate from a mesenchymal sheath on the surface of the developing brain, called primary meninx, and undergo differentiation into three layers with distinct histological characteristics: the dura mater, the arachnoid mater, and the pia mater. While genetic regulation of meningeal development is still poorly understood, mouse mutants and other models with meningeal defects have demonstrated the importance of the meninges to normal development of the calvaria and the brain. For the calvaria, the interactions with the meninges are necessary for the progression of calvarial osteogenesis during early development. In later stages, the meninges control the patterning of the skull and the fate of the sutures. For the brain, the meninges regulate diverse processes including cell survival, cell migration, generation of neurons from progenitors, and vascularization. Also, the meninges serve as a stem cell niche for the brain in the postnatal life. Given these important roles of the meninges, further investigation into the molecular mechanisms underlying meningeal development can provide novel insights into the coordinated development of the head.     

Beta1-class integrins regulate the development of laminae and folia in the cerebral and cerebellar cortex

Mice that lack all beta1-class integrins in neurons and glia die prematurely after birth with severe brain malformations. Cortical hemispheres and cerebellar folia fuse, and cortical laminae are perturbed. These defects result from disorganization of the cortical marginal zone, where beta1-class integrins regulate glial endfeet anchorage, meningeal basement membrane remodeling, and formation of the Cajal-Retzius cell layer. Surprisingly, beta1-class integrins are not essential for neuron-glia interactions and neuronal migration during corticogenesis. The phenotype of the beta1-deficient mice resembles pathological changes observed in human cortical dysplasias, suggesting that defective integrin-mediated signal transduction contributes to the development of some of these diseases.     

Comparative analysis of the development of the lizard,Liolaemus tenuis tenuis. II. A series of normal postlaying stages in embryonic development

In this work, we have completed a study of the development of the ovoviviparous lizard Liolaemus tenuis tenuis. Ovoviviparity in this lizard is a condition in which eggs are retained within the reproductive duct for about 60 days. During this period the phases of segmentation, gastrulation, neurulation, presomitic, and somitic embryos transpire. During the months of December and January the eggs are laid, and at this time the embryos are comparable to stage 27 Liolaemus gravenhorsti lizard embryos, or to stage 29 Calotes versicolor lizard embryos. Differentiation of the facial region occurs between Days 12 and 42 after egg laying. Limbs develop rapidly between the 8th and 23rd days. By 53 days the appendicular skeleton is completely formed. After 36 days the mesonephros begins to degenerate, and its function is gradually taken over by the developing metanephros. Newborn lizards do not possess an egg caruncle. During the period up to hatching, there is a great increase of liquid within the egg, presumably amniotic fluid. Cracks develop in the leathery shell shortly before hatching and are, perhaps, the first sign of the onset of hatching. Increase of liquid in the egg during postlaying development accounts for its increase in weight and change in shape. Weight of the embryo at hatching does not exceed 32% of the total weight of the egg.