The fluidity of chloroplast thylakoid membranes and their constituent lipids: A comparative study by ESR

Comparative measurements were made of the fluidity of chloroplast thylakoids, total membrane lipids and polar lipids utilizing the order parameter and motion of spin labels.No significant differences were found in the fluidity of membranes or total membrane lipids from a wild type and a mutant barley (Hordeum vulgare chlorina f₂ mutant) which lacks chlorophyll $\text{b}$ and a 25 000 dalton thylakoid polypeptide. Redistribution of intrinsic, exoplasmic face (EF) membrane particles by unstacking thylakoid membranes in low salt medium also had no effect on membrane fluidity. However, heating of isolated thylakoids decreased membrane fluidity.The fluidity of vesicles composed of membrane lipids is much greater than that of the corresponding membranes. Fluidity of the membranes, however, increased during greening indicating that the rigidity of the membranes, compared with that of total membrane lipids, is not caused by chlorophyll or its associated peptides. It is concluded that the restriction of motion in the acyl chains in the thylakoids is not caused by chlorophyll or the major intrinsic polypeptide but by some other protein components.     

Incorporation of sterol into chloroplast thylakoid membranes and its effect on fluidity and function

The sterol, cholesteryl hemisuccinate, has been incorporated into isolated thylakoid membranes of pea and lettuce chloroplasts in order to modify the fluidity of the lipid matrix. Changes in fluidity have been monitored using fluorescence polarization of the hydrophobic probe, 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene and the electron-spin-resonance, spin-label probe, 5-doxyl stearate. Both methods indicate that incorporation of increasing levels of sterol reduces the fluidity of the thylakoid lipid matrix. At room temperature the thylakoid lipid matrix is relatively fluid and the effect of increasing the viscosity is to inhibit partially the maximum rate of steady-state electron flow and reduce the dark rate of reduction of flash-oxidised cytochrome f. The results are discussed in terms of lipid fluidity influencing the rate of lateral diffusion of reduced plastoquinone from photosystem II to photosystem I.     

Chloroplast thylakoid membrane fluidity and its sensitivity to temperature

In order to investigate membrane fluidity, the hydrophobic probe, 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH), has been incorporated into intact isolated thylakoids and separated granal and stromal lamellae obtained from the chloroplasts of Pisum sativum. The steady-state polarization of DPH fluorescence was measured as a function of temperature and indicated that at physiological values the thylakoid membrane is a relatively fluid system with the stromal lamellae being less viscous than the lamellae of the grana. According to the DPH technique, neither region of the membrane, however, showed a sharp phase transition of its bulk lipids from the liquid-crystalline to the gel state for the temperature range -20° to 50° C. Comparison of intact thylakoids isolated from plants grown at cold (4°/7°C) and warm (14°/17° C) temperatures indicate that there is an adaptation mechanism operating which seems to maintain an optimal membrane viscosity necessary for growth. Using a modified Perrin equation the optimal average viscosity for the thylakoid membrane of the chill-resistant variety used in the study (Feltham First) is estimated to be about 1.8 poise.Abbreviations DPH 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene - Hepes N-(2-hydroxyethyl)-1-piperazineethanesulphonic acid     

Fluidity properties of isolated chloroplast thylakoid lipids

Chloroplast thylakoid lipids have been isolated free of photosynthetic pigments using a combination of high performance liquid and thin layer chromatography. The hydrophobic fluorescent probe, 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH) has been incorporated into aqueous dispersions of the isolated lipids in order to investigate dynamic and structural properties of the resulting bilayer membranes. Time dependent fluorescence anisotropy decays have been measured and analysed assuming the wobbling-in-cone model (Kinosita et al., Biophys J 20 (1977) 289–305). The DPH fluorescence lifetimes and the static and dynamic fluorescence anisotropy decay parameters for the probe in a total lipid mixture or in pure digalactosyldiacylglycerol (DGDG), changed in a predictable way with increasing temperature (10°–36°C). For a given temperature, it was found that the total lipid mixture was in general less ordered and showed greater dynamic motion as judged from DPH fluorescence anisotropy and compared with the pure DGDG system, although at 36°C differences in dynamic parameters were less evident. Overall the results obtained emphasize the highly fluid nature of thylakoid membrane lipids and give a basis for investigating how intrinsic proteins modify structural and dynamic properties of the in vivo membrane.     

Differences in membrane lipid composition and fluidity of transplanted grsl lymphoma cells, depending on their site of growth in the mouse

GRSL lymphoma cells were isolated from various growth sites in the host. The relative membrane lipid fluidities of these cells and of normal lymphoid cells were estimated by fluorescence polarization, using the probe diphenylhexatriene and by measuring the (free) cholesterol/phospholipid molar ratio in whole cells. The results indicate that the membrane fluidity (reciprocal of the lipid structural order) of the lymphoma cells increases in the order of their location: peripheral blood < spleen < mesenterial lymph node < ascites fluid. The membrane fluidities of normal lymphocytes from thymus, mesenterial lymph node and spleen were about the same, but higher than of peripheral blood lymphocytes, and between those of the lymphoma cells from lymph node and spleen. These results are confirmed by more extensive analysis on purified plasma membranes from the splenic and ascitic GRSL lymphoma cells and from normal splenocytes and thymocytes. The significantly higher lipid order parameter found in the GRSL plasma membrane isolated from the spleen as compared to those from the ascites cells could be fully explained by the differences measured in the major chemical determinants of the fluidity, i.e., the cholesterol/phospholipid ratio, the sphingomyelin content and the degree of saturation of the fatty acyl groups of the phospholipids. It was also found that the cholesterol/phospholipid ratio in erythrocyte membranes isolated from the peripheral blood of the tumor bearers was higher than in those from normal control mice. The observed differences in membrane fluidity between distinct subsets of tumor cells may be relevant to the sensitivity of these cells to immune attack or to drugs.     

Cryoprotectin protects thylakoids during a freeze-thaw cycle by a mechanism involving stable membrane binding

Chloroplast thylakoid membranes of higher plants are damaged by freezing both in vivo and in vitro. The resulting inactivation of photosynthetic electron transport has been related to transient membrane rupture, leading to the loss of soluble electron transport proteins and osmotically active solutes from the thylakoid lumen. We have recently purified and sequenced a protein from cold acclimated cabbage, that protects thylakoids from this freeze-thaw damage. The protein belongs to the WAX9 family of nonspecific lipid transfer proteins, but has no detectable lipid transfer activity. Conversely, other transport-active lipid transfer proteins show no cryoprotective activity. We show here that cryoprotectin binds to thylakoid membranes. Both cryoprotective activity and membrane binding were inhibited in the presence of specific sugars, most effectively by Glc-6-S. The binding of cryoprotectin to thylakoids reduced the fluidity of the membrane lipids close to the membrane/solution interface, but not in the hydrophobic core region. Using immobilized liposomes we could show that cryoprotectin was able to bind to pure lipid membranes.     

Fluorescence polarization and spin-label studies of the fluidity of stromal and granal chloroplast membranes

The lipid fluidity of thylakoid membrane regions separated by Yeda press and sonication methods has been investigated using diphenylhexatriene fluorescence polarization measurements and rotational correlation times derived from the ESR spectra of the spin-labels 5-doxyldecane and 12-doxylstearate. According to both techniques, stromal lamellae vesicles with essentially only Photosystem I activity were more fluid than the granal membranes. The differences in lipid fluidity between the two fractions were interpreted in terms of the ratio of the amounts of protein compared to lipid in the membranes. Stromal lamellae fractions contained lower protein/lipid ratios compared with the granal membranes.     

Effect of membrane fluidity on photosynthetic oxygen production reactions

The effect of changes of membrane fluidity on the oxygen evolving capability of isolated thylakoids was investigated. Alteration of the lipid phase fluidity was achieved by incorporation of the plant sterol stigmasterol. Incorporation of stigmasterol in the lipid bilayer of thylakoid membranes results in rigidization of the hydrophobic phase of thylakoid membranes and decreases the degree of packing of the lipid head groups. These changes of lipid order are accompanied by a reduction of oxygen evolution, measured with 1,4-benzoquinone as an electron acceptor, and by a more pronounced inhibition of PSI-mediated electron transport. By analysis of the parameters of oxygen flash yields and oxygen burst under continuous illumination it was shown that after treatment with stigmasterol: 1.) the number of active oxygen-evolving centres decreased; 2.) the remaining active oxygen-evolving centres were not affected in respect to the oscillation pattern; 3.) the contribution of the slow oxygen-evolving centres in oxygen burst yield was increased. The effect of stigmasterol was compared with the well-studied effect of cholesterol. Results were discussed in terms of determining the role of lipid order for the organization and functioning of the photosynthetic machinery.     

Structural consequences of genetically engineered saturation of the fatty acids of phosphatidylglycerol in tobacco thylakoid membranes. An FTIR study

The role of phosphatidylglycerol (PG) in protein-lipid interactions and membrane dynamics has been studied in the thylakoids of wild type and manipulated tobacco plants transformed with complementary DNAs for glycerol-3-phosphate acyltransferases (GPATs) from squash and Arabidopsis. The expression of the foreign enzymes resulted in the level of saturation of the PG molecules being higher in the squash and lower in the Arabidopsis transformants, as compared with the level in wild-type tobacco. For the analysis of fatty acyl chain dynamics in the thylakoid membranes, the nu(sym)CH(2) vibration bands of the infrared specta were decomposed into two components, corresponding to ordered and disordered fatty acyl chain segments. With this approach, it was shown that in squash GPAT-transformed tobacco thylakoids a rigid lipid domain exists below 25 degrees C. Above 25 degrees C, the dynamics of all thylakoid membranes were very similar, regardless of the manipulations. PG seems to tune the dynamics at the protein-lipid interface rather than to affect the structure of the proteins directly. Above 50 degrees C, the frequencies of the disordered nu(sym)CH(2) component bands were decreased. This lipid-related phenomenon correlated with protein denaturing. It is demonstrated that the protein aggregation appearing upon heat denaturing changes the conformational distribution of the disordered lipid population. The data also reveal that the protein stability does not depend on the fatty acid composition of the PG molecules; other lipids should provide the environment governing the protein stability in the thylakoid membrane. This is the first such detailed analysis of the infrared spectra of biological membranes that permits a differentiation between structurally different lipid populations within a membrane.     

Too rigid to fold: Carotenoid-dependent decrease in thylakoid fluidity hampers the formation of chloroplast grana

In chloroplasts of land plants, the thylakoid network is organized into appressed regions called grana stacks and loosely arranged parallel stroma thylakoids. Many factors determining such intricate structural arrangements have been identified so far, including various thylakoid-embedded proteins, and polar lipids that build the thylakoid matrix. Although carotenoids are important components of proteins and the lipid phase of chloroplast membranes, their role in determining the thylakoid network structure remains elusive. We studied 2D and 3D thylakoid network organization in carotenoid-deficient mutants (ccr1-1, lut5-1, szl1-1, and szl1-1npq1-2) of Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) to reveal the structural role of carotenoids in the formation and dynamics of the internal chloroplast membrane system. The most significant structural aberrations took place in chloroplasts of the szl1-1 and szl1-1npq1-2 plants. Increased lutein/carotene ratio in these mutants impaired the formation of grana, resulting in a significant decrease in the number of thylakoids used to build a particular stack. Further, combined biochemical and biophysical analyses revealed that hampered grana folding was related to decreased thylakoid membrane fluidity and significant changes in the amount, organization, and phosphorylation status of photosystem (PS) II (PSII) supercomplexes in the szl1-1 and szl1-1npq1-2 plants. Such changes resulted from a synergistic effect of lutein overaccumulation in the lipid matrix and a decreased level of carotenes bound with PS core complexes. Moreover, more rigid membrane in the lutein overaccumulating plants led to binding of Rubisco to the thylakoid surface, additionally providing steric hindrance for the dynamic changes in the level of membrane folding.

Increases in lutein/carotenoid ratios lead to decreased thylakoid fluidity and hamper grana folding due to carotenoid-dependent changes in both photosynthetic complexes and lipid matrix organization.     

Differences in membrane lipid composition and fluidity of transplanted GRSL lymphoma cells, depending on their site of growth in the mouse

GRSL lymphoma cells were isolated from various growth sites in the host. The relative membrane lipid fluidities of these cells and of normal lymphoid cells were estimated by fluorescence polarization, using the probe diphenylhexatriene and by measuring the (free) cholesterol/phospholipid molar ratio in whole cells. The results indicate that the membrane fluidity (reciprocal of the lipid structural order) of the lymphoma cells increases in the order of their location: peripheral blood less than spleen less than mesenterial lymph node less than ascites fluid. The membrane fluidities of normal lymphocytes from thymus, mesenterial lymph node and spleen were about the same, but higher than of peripheral blood lymphocytes, and between those of the lymphoma cells from lymph node and spleen. These results are confirmed by more extensive analysis on purified plasma membranes from the splenic and ascitic GRSL lymphoma cells and from normal splenocytes and thymocytes. The significantly higher lipid order parameter found in the GRSL plasma membrane isolated from the spleen as compared to those from the ascites cells could be fully explained by the differences measured in the major chemical determinants of the fluidity, i.e., the cholesterol/phospholipid ratio, the sphingomyelin content and the degree of saturation of the fatty acyl groups of the phospholipids. It was also found that the cholesterol/phospholipid ratio in erythrocyte membranes isolated from the peripheral blood of the tumor bearers was higher than in those from normal control mice. The observed differences in membrane fluidity between distinct subsets of tumor cells may be relevant to the sensitivity of these cells to immune attack or to drugs.     

Alterations in the physical state and composition of brush border membrane lipids of rat enterocytes during differentiation

The physical state of the membrane lipid of brush border membranes, prepared from rat small intestinal villus and crypt cells, was examined by steady-state fluorescence polarization using three lipid-soluble fluorophors. Membranes prepared from crypt cells were found to possess a higher lipid fluidity than those of villus cells with each probe. Analysis of the composition of these membranes revealed that those from crypt cells had lower ratios of cholesterol/phospholipid (mol/mol), protein/lipid (w/w), and saturated fatty acyl chains/unsaturated chains (w/w). Alterations in the levels of stearic (18:0) and oleic (18:1) acids were responsible for differences in the latter ratio. The results, therefore, demonstrate that alterations in the lipid composition and fluidity of brush border membranes of enterocytes occur during the process of differentiation.     

Factors altering the membrane fluidity of spinach thylakoid as determined by fluorescence polarization

Alterations in fluidity of thylakoid membranes isolated from spinach chloroplasts in response to sodium bisulfite (NaHSO₃), hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂), sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), bovine serum albumin (BSA), and free linoleic acid (LA) were investigated by means of a fluorescence polarization study with 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene as the fluorescence probe. A decrease in fluidity and an increase in microviscosity of membrane were caused by NaHSO₃ and H₂O₂ treatment. In contrast, SDS and BSA were found to increase thylakoid membranes fluidity and decrease microviscosity, in which the corresponding correlation coefficients were −0.9995 to −0.9516 (SDS) and −0.9359 (BSA), respectively. No changes in thylakoid membranes fluidity induced by free LA were found until its concentration above 5 mM where the polarization value (P value) declined (increased fluidity). The results suggest that the changes in thylakoids membrane fluidity might depend on the characteristics, mechanism and extent of the interactions between membrane components and compounds added.     

Lipid Saturation Induced Microviscosity Increase Has No Effect on the Reducibility of Flash-Oxidized Cytochrome f in Pea Thylakoids

Homogeneous catalytic hydrogenation was used to modify the level of fatty acid unsaturation of thylakoid membranes in the pea chloroplast. Fluidity alteration has been monitored simultaneously using the spin-label probe, 16-doxyl stearate. Even in the case of 30% hydrogenation, no change in the reduction rate of flash-oxidized cytochrome f was observed, in contrast to the fact that the same decrease in the double-bond content of the thylakoid membrane resulted in a pronounced inhibition in the full-chain electron transport. We conclude that the rate of lateral diffusion of reduced plastoquinone is unaffected by the lowering of the fluidity of the thylakoid lipid matrix.     

Localization and integration of thylakoid protein translocase subunit cpTatC

Thylakoid membranes have a unique complement of proteins, most of which are nuclear encoded synthesized in the cytosol, imported into the stroma and translocated into thylakoid membranes by specific thylakoid translocases. Known thylakoid translocases contain core multi-spanning, membrane-integrated subunits that are also nuclear-encoded and imported into chloroplasts before being integrated into thylakoid membranes. Thylakoid translocases play a central role in determining the composition of thylakoids, yet the manner by which the core translocase subunits are integrated into the membrane is not known. We used biochemical and genetic approaches to investigate the integration of the core subunit of the chloroplast Tat translocase, cpTatC, into thylakoid membranes. In vitro import assays show that cpTatC correctly localizes to thylakoids if imported into intact chloroplasts, but that it does not integrate into isolated thylakoids. In vitro transit peptide processing and chimeric precursor import experiments suggest that cpTatC possesses a stroma-targeting transit peptide. Import time-course and chase assays confirmed that cpTatC targets to thylakoids via a stromal intermediate, suggesting that it might integrate through one of the known thylakoid translocation pathways. However, chemical inhibitors to the cpSecA-cpSecY and cpTat pathways did not impede cpTatC localization to thylakoids when used in import assays. Analysis of membranes isolated from Arabidopsis thaliana mutants lacking cpSecY or Alb3 showed that neither is necessary for cpTatC membrane integration or assembly into the cpTat receptor complex. These data suggest the existence of another translocase, possibly one dedicated to the integration of chloroplast translocases.     

Changes in the Cationic Regulation of Structure and Function in Thylakoids Isolated from Wheat Seedlings Treated with BASF 13.338

When wheat seedlings (Triticum vulgare cf HD 2189) were grown in the presence of BASF 13.338 (4-chloro-5-[dimethylamino]-2-phenyl-3[2H]-pyridazinone), there was a decrease in the ratio of linolenic acid to linoleic acid in the thylakoid membrane lipids (JB St John 1976 Plant Physiol 57: 38) and an increase in the ratio of photosystem II to photosystem I (RM Mannan, S Bose 1984 Photochem Photobiol 41: 63). Accompanying these gross structural changes were alterations in the cationic regulation of structure and functioning of the thylakoid membranes: (a) Mg²⁺-induced increase in the room temperature fluorescence was totally absent; (b) Mg²⁺-induced increase in absorbance at 560 nm, indicative of granal stacking, was slightly higher in thylakoids isolated from the BASF 13.338 treated plants suggesting an increased degree of stacking; and (c) absorption changes in the red and Soret regions of the absorption spectrum, normally resulting from the addition of divalent cation or alkyl anion, or from osmotic shrinkage were almost totally absent in thylakoid membranes isolated from BASF 13.338 treated plants. These observations have been interpreted in terms of: (a) significant alterations in the lipid matrix of the thylakoids from treated plants, (b) absence of cation-induced reorganization of the pigment-protein complexes in the horizontal plane of the treated thylakoid membranes suspended in low salt medium, and (c) absence of dynamic changes even within the individual pigment-protein complexes of treated thylakoids.     

Lipid-protein interactions in thylakoid membranes of chilling-resistant and -sensitive plants studied by spin label electron spin resonance spectroscopy

Lipid-protein interactions in thylakoid membranes from lettuce, pea, tomato, and cucumber have been studied using spin-labeled analogues of the thylakoid membrane lipid components, monogalactosyl diglyceride and phosphatidylglycerol. The electron spin resonance spectra of the spin-labeled lipids all consist of two components, one corresponding to the fluid lipid environment in the membranes and the other to the motionally restricted lipids interacting with the integral membrane proteins. Comparison of the spectra from the same spin label in thylakoid membranes from different plants shows that the overall lipid fluidity in the membranes decreases with chilling sensitivity. Spectral subtraction has been used to quantitate the fraction of the membrane lipids in contact with integral membrane proteins. Thylakoid membranes of cucumber, a typical chilling-sensitive plant, have been found to have a higher proportion of motionally restricted lipids and a different lipid selectivity for lipid-protein interaction, as compared with those of pea, a typical chilling-resistant plant. This correlation with chilling sensitivity holds generally for the different plants studied. It seems likely that the chilling sensitivity in thylakoid membranes is not determined by lipid fluidity alone, but also by the lipid-protein interactions which could affect protein function in a more direct manner.     

Dual character of lipid composition of the envelope membrane of spinach chloroplasts

The envelope membrane was isolated from intact spinach chloroplastsby gentle osmotic treatment in a medium containing appropriateamounts of cations to prevent dissociation and fragmentationof the thylakoids. This treatment allowed us to separate effectivelythe envelope membranes from the thylakoids with one-step (0.6M/0.9 M) sucrose density gradient centrifugation. The envelope membrane contained both glyceroglycolipids andglycerophospholipids, as does the thylakoid membrane. Therewere, however, notable differences in the relative amounts oflipid components between these two membranes. The major glyceroglycolipidin the envelope membrane was digalactosyl diglyceride, whereasmonogalactosyl diglyceride was the major one in the thylakoid.The envelope membrane was characterized by a high content ofglycerophospholipids, as much as three-fold that in the thylakoidmembrane. Phosphatidyl choline, which is known to be minor inthe thylakoids and abundant in the microsomal and mitochondrialmembranes, was a major component, accounting for 50% of thetotal glycerophospholipids. The dual character of lipid compositionof the envelope membrane is discussed in terms of its chemicaland structural connection to the other intracellular membranesystems. (Received May 26, 1975; )     

Assembly of Two Subunits of the Cyanobacterial Photosystem I on the n-Side of Thylakoid Membranes

Photosystem I contains several peripheral membrane proteins that are located on either positive (luminal) or negative (stromal or cytoplasmic) sides of thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts or cyanobacteria. Incorporation of two peripheral subunits into photosystem I of the cyanobacterium Synechocystis species PCC 6803 was studied using a reconstitution system in which radiolabeled subunits II (PsaD) and IV (PsaE) were synthesized in vitro and incubated with the isolated thylakoid membranes. After such incubation, the subunits were found in the membranes and were resistant to digestion with proteases and removal by 2 molar NaBr. All of the radioactive proteins incorporated in the membrane were found in the photosystem I complex. The subunit II was assembled specifically into cyanobacterial thylakoid membranes and not into Escherichia coli cell membranes or thylakoid membranes isolated from spinach. The assembly process did not require ATP or proton motive force, and it was not stimulated by ATP. The assembly of subunits II and IV into thylakoid membranes isolated from the strain AEK2, which lacks the gene psaE, was increased two- to threefold. The incorporation of subunit II was 15 to 17 times higher in the thylakoids obtained from the strain ADK3 in which the gene psaD has been inactivated. However, assembly of subunit IV in the same thylakoids was reduced by 65%, demonstrating that the presence of subunit II is required for the stable assembly of subunit IV. Large deletions in subunit II prevented its incorporation into thylakoids and assembly into photosystem I, suggesting that the overall conformation of the protein rather than a specific targeting sequence is required for its assembly into photosystem I.     

Diffusion of a membrane protein, Tat subunit Hcf106, is highly restricted within the chloroplast thylakoid network

The thylakoid membrane forms stacked thylakoids interconnected by ‘stromal’ lamellae. Little is known about the mobility of proteins within this system. We studied a stromal lamellae protein, Hcf106, by targeting an Hcf106-GFP fusion protein to the thylakoids and photobleaching. We find that even small regions fail to recover Hcf106-GFP fluorescence over periods of up to 3 min after photobleaching. The protein is thus either immobile within the thylakoid membrane, or its diffusion is tightly restricted within distinct regions. Autofluorescence from the photosystem II light-harvesting complex in the granal stacks likewise fails to recover. Integral membrane proteins within both the stromal and granal membranes are therefore highly constrained, possibly forming ‘microdomains’ that are sharply separated.