Flash-induced photophosphorylation in chloroplasts with activated ATPase

Chloroplasts which were rapidly isolated from illuminated leaves showed activity of ATP hydrolysis at a level much higher than that of the dark control. Under the high-intensity illumination or under repetitive flash excitation, the activated chloroplasts synthesized more ATP than those with a low ATP hydrolysis activity. formed under repetitive flashes was smaller in the activated chloroplasts than in the inactive chloroplasts. The inhibition of ATP yield per flash by valinomycin or nigericin in the presence of K⁺ was stronger in the inactive chloroplasts than in the activated chloroplast. ATP synthesis in the activated chloroplasts seems to have a lower threshold.     

Estimation of H+-translocation stoicheiometry of mitochondrial ATPase by comparison of proton-motive forces with clamped phosphorylation potentials in submitochondrial particles

The proton-motive forces generated in submitochondrial particles by both hydrolysis of ATP and oxidation of succinate have been measured by flow dialysis and compared with the ambient phosphorylation potentials. It is concluded that three H⁺ are translocated for each ATP molecule hydrolysed or synthesised. By utilising rat liver mitochondria respiring with β-hydroxybutyrate as a new system for regeneration of ATP from ADP and P_i, phosphorylation potentials were clamped at a range of values by using mixtures of particles and mitochondria in various ratios. As the rate of ATP hydrolysis by the particles was lowered, the proton-motive force decreased only slightly except at the very lowest rates, these results paralleling earlier studies on the relation between rate of respiration-driven proton translocation and proton-motive force.     

Photophosphorylation associated with synchronous turnovers of the electron-transport carriers in chloroplasts

Two saturating single-turnover flashes spaced 100 ms apart are sufficient to achieve ATP formation in isolated chloroplast thylakoids. Two turnovers of the electron carriers result in the accumulation of about 7 nmol H⁺ / mg chlorophyll. Under the same conditions (i.e., ΔG_ATP = 38 kJ/mol) a solitary flash is inadequate to produce ATP. The electron flux from the third or any subsequent flash is coupled to ATP formation as efficiently as is observed in continuous light (i.e., ) and produces 0.8 molecules of ATP per coupling factor on each turnover. The yield of ATP per flash increases with declining temperature being largest near 4°C, the lowest value tested. The number of H⁺ accumulated per flash is independent of temperature so the greater yields of ATP near 4°C indicate that fewer H⁺ are existing the membrane via nonproductive pathways. The yield of ATP per flash near 4°C is largely independent of flash frequency between 1 and 30 Hz. When the formation of an electrical potential difference is prevented by adequate amounts of valinomycin and potassium the accumulated effects of about eight flashes are required before ATP formation is achieved (i.e., about 26 nmol H⁺/mg chlorophyll), indicating an average ΔpH/flash in excess of 0.3 units. In the presence of the exchange carrier nigericin, the electrical component of the driving force for ATP formation is enhanced at the expense of the ΔpH. In this case, ATP formation is efficiently coupled to electron flux only at flash frequencies rapid enough to allow a summation of the electrical field. These results clearly demonstrate that any processes which are prerequisites for ATP synthesis (i.e., activation of coupling factor or generation of Δp) are fulfilled by a remarkably small number of charge separations.     

The redox state of the NADP system in illuminated chloroplasts

Pyridine nucleotide levels were measured in intact spinach chloroplasts. The NADPH/NADP ratio was close to unity in darkened chloroplasts. On illumination, chloroplast NADP levels decreased rapidly. The decrease was more prominent at low than at high light intensities. In the presence of bicarbonate, NADP subsequently increased to reach a steady-state level. The kinetics of the increase were related in general, but not in detail, to the lag phase of photosynthesis. In the steady state, chloroplast NADP was sometimes, particularly during photosynthesis at high light intensities, less reduced in the light than in the dark. In the dark-light transition, phosphoglycerate reduction is driven by increases in the ratios NADPH/NADP and ATP/ADP. When photosynthesis accelerates after the initial lag phase, the NADPH/NADP ratio decreases and a high ratio of phosphoglycerate to triose phosphate becomes an important factor in driving carbon reduction. Under photosynthetic flux conditions, the redox state of the chloroplast NADP system appeared to be governed largely by the chloroplast ratio of phosphoglycerate to dihydroxyacetone phosphate and by the phosphorylation potential [ATP]/[ADP] [P_i]. The inhibitor of cyclic electron transport, antimycin A, increased reduction of the chloroplast NADP system. Even when reduction was almost complete in the presence of 5 μM antimycin A, photosynthesis was still significant at low light intensities. Electrons appeared to be effectively distributed between the cyclic electron-transport pathway and the noncyclic route to NADP at NADPH/NADP ratios as low as about 1. When bicarbonate was absent, the NADP system remained largely reduced in the light. The energy-transfer inhibitor, Dio-9, and uncouplers and agents which interfered with pH regulation of the Calvin cycle increased reduction of the NADP system while decreasing photosynthesis.     

Oxygen exchange associated with electron transport and photophosphorylation in spinach thylakoids

O₂ uptake in spinach thylakoids was composed of ferredoxin-dependent and -independent components. The ferredoxin-independent component was largely 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea (DCMU) insensitive (60%). Light-dependent O₂ uptake was stimulated 7-fold by 70 μM ferredoxin and both uptake and evolution (with O₂ as the only electron acceptor) responded almost linearly to ferredoxin up to 40 μM. NADP⁺ reduction, however, was saturated by less than 20 μM ferredoxin. The affinity of O₂ uptake for for O₂ was highly dependent on ferredoxin concentration, with $\text{K}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}\text{(O}{}_2\text{)}$ of less than 20 μM at 2 μM ferredoxin but greater than 60 μM O₂ with 25 μM ferredoxin. O₂ uptake could be suppressed up to 80% with saturating NADP⁺ and it approximated a competitive inhibitor of O₂ uptake with a K_i of 8–15 μM. Electron transport in these thylakoids supported high rates of photophosphorylation with NADP⁺ (600 μmol ATP/mg Chl per h) or O₂ (280 μmol/mg Chl per h) as electron acceptors, with $\text{ATP}\text{2}\text{e}$ ratios of 1.15–1.55. Variation in $\text{ATP}\text{2}\text{e}$ ratios with ferredoxin concentration and effects of antimycin A indicate that cyclic electron flow may also be occurring in this thylakoid system. Results are discussed with regard to photoreduction of O₂ as a potential source of ATP in vivo.     

Decay of membrane potential under phosphorylating conditions in chloroplasts with in vivo activated ATPase

(1) The relation between the membrane potential and phosphorylation was studied in chloroplasts rapidly prepared from illuminated spinach leaves (light chloroplasts) and from dark-adapted leaves (dark chloroplasts). Light chloroplasts had a higher ATP hydrolysis activity than dark chloroplasts. (2) In the presence of ADP or ATP, a rapidly decaying phase of the field-indicating 518 nm absorbance change with a half-time of 15 ms became apparent in addition to the slow phase with a half-time of more than 300 ms in either type of chloroplast. Under these conditions, light chloroplasts showed a larger rapid phase than dark chloroplasts. (3) The rapid phase was suppressed by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide and was assumed to reflect the dissipation of membrane potential due to proton movements inside the CF₁-CF₀ ATP synthetase. (4) A model for the proton movement in ATP synthetase is proposed.     

Factors affecting the development of the capacity for ATP formation in isolated chloroplasts

Full development of the capacity for ATP formation in isolated thylakoid membranes coincides with the beginning of illumination. Indeed, the yield of ATP per ms of illumination is about twice as great during the first 15 ms of high-intensity illumination as it is thereafter. The presence of valinomycin and K⁺ prevents the formation of a membrane potential (as indicated by the obliteration of most of the change in absorbance at 518 nm) and at the same time delays the formation of the capacity for ATP synthesis for many milliseconds. Presumably, phosphorylation is initially dependent on a rapidly formed membrane potential, whereas after a delay a ΔpH sufficient to drive ATP formation forms. The actual duration of this delay depends on the phosphoryl group transfer potential (i.e., ΔG_ATP) of the ATP-synthesizing reaction. If the delay in the presence of valinomycin and K⁺ represents the time required to develop a ΔpH capable of driving phosphorylation by itself, then the effect of ΔG_ATP on the duration of the delay suggests that the onset of phosphorylation is determined by the magnitude of the electrochemical potential of protons and not by factors affecting the activation of the coupling factor enzyme. The initial ATP formation, which is almost entirely dependent on the electrical potential, should not be affected by the electrically neutral exchange of cations catalyzed by nigericin. When the external pH is 7.0 this seems to be true, since the ATP synthesis which is initially sensitive to valinomycin and K⁺ is largely insensitive to nigericin and K⁺. However, when the external pH is 8.0 the response to nigericin is exactly the opposite and the ATP formation which is sensitive to valinomycin is also abolished by nigericin. These data suggest that there may be either an energetic requirement for both a ΔpH and membrane potential at alkaline pH or a non-energetic requirement for a minimum proton activity in the initiation of phosphorylation.     

Light-dependent reduction of hydrogen peroxide by intact spinach chloroplasts

Intact spinach chloroplasts, washed four times in buffered sorbitol to decrease catalase contamination, supported O₂ evolution in the dark at very low rates (less than 2 μmol/mg Chl per h) in the presence of low concentrations of H₂O₂ (0.25 mM); H₂O₂ was not significantly metabolished under these conditions. In the light, washed chloroplasts supported H₂O₂-dependent O₂ evolution at rates of 28–46 μmol/mg Chl per h in the presence of 0.1–0.25 mM H₂O₂; the concentration of H₂O₂ supporting 0.5V_max was estimated to be 25 μM. O₂ evolution in the light was associated with H₂O₂ consumption and ceased after the production of 0.45 mol per mol H₂O₂ consumed. Both O₂ evolution and H₂O₂ consumption were abolished by 5 μM 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea. Washed intact chloroplasts contained endogenous pools of GSH and ascorbate estimated at 10 and 33 mM, respectively. H₂O₂-dependent O₂ evolution in the light was associated with a decrease in these levels which increased as O₂ evolution gradually ceased. The results are consistent with the hypothesis that H₂O serves as eventual electron donor for the reduction of H₂O₂ in illuminated chloroplasts and that GSH/GSSG and ascorbate/dehydroascorbate serve as intermediate electron carriers. Preincubation of chloroplasts in the dark with 0.1 mM H₂O₂ abolished O₂ evolution in the light.     

Energy thresholds for ATP synthesis in chloroplasts

We have investigated the ATP synthesis associated with acid-base transitions in chloroplast lamellae under conditions which allow simultaneous control of the thermodynamic variables, ΔpH, membrane potential and ΔG_ATP. These variables have been directly imposed rather than simply inferred. Since the initiation of labeled P_i incorporation seems to measure accurately the initiation of net ATP synthesis, the following conclusions can be drawn: (1) The proton-motive force which is just sufficient for ATP synthesis provides almost exactly the required energy for ΔG_ATP if the efflux of three H⁺ is required for each ATP molecule formed. (2) The membrane potential and the ΔpH contribute to the proton-motive force in a precisely additive way. Thus, the threshold can be reached or exceeded by a ΔpH in the absence of a membrane potential, by a membrane potential in the absence of a ΔpH, or by any combination of membrane potential and ΔpH. With a large enough membrane potential, ATP synthesis occurs even against a small inverse ΔpH. In each instance the combined ΔpH and membrane potential necessary for initiation of ATP synthesis represent the same threshold proton-motive force.     

Effects of changes in the capacity for photosynthetic electron transfer and photophosphorylation on the kinetics of fluorescence induction in isolated chloroplasts

Chlorophyll fluorescence, 9-aminoacridine fluorescence and O₂ evolution have been measured in a chloroplast system reconstituted to simulate the induction kinetics observed in leaves. Transients in redox state and energy state, both of which control the yield of fluorescence, were seen to depend upon (a) light intensity, (b) electron-transfer rate as controlled by ferredoxin level, (c) the initial levels of ADP and phosphate and (d) the initial level of NADP. These factors were shown to interact to produce a range of fluorescence patterns. It is suggested that in vivo fluorescence transients in part are due to reduction and phoshorylation of the finite NADP and ADP pools that exist in the chloroplast prior to illumination.     

Regulation of photosynthesis in isolated spinach chloroplasts during orthophosphate limitation

The stromal concentration of orthophosphate in intact spinach chloroplasts (prepared in the absence of orthophosphate or pyrophosphate but supplied with both in the reaction medium) fell from a value of approx. 20 mM in the dark to a steady-state concentration of approx. 8 mM in the light. Chloroplasts illuminated in the absence of orthophosphate or pyrophosphate showed a similar trend. However, in this situation the stromal inorganic phosphate (P_i) concentration rapidly decreased from approx. 10 mM in the dark to a constant steady-state concentration of between 1.5 and 2.5 mM in the light. This P_i concentration was not further diminished (even though CO₂-dependent O₂ evolution had ceased) and was therefore considered to be stromal orthophosphate not freely available to metabolism. In the P_i-deficient chloroplasts the rate of photosynthesis declined rapidly after 1–2 min in the light such that CO₂-dependent O₂ evolution ceased with 5 min of the onset of illumination. The decline in O₂ evolution was accompanied by an increase in the transthylakoid ΔpH (as measured by 9-aminoacridine fluorescence quenching) and in the high-energy state, non-photochemical component of chlorophyll fluorescence quenching (q_E). Measurements of stromal metabolite concentrations showed that the ATP/ADP ratio was decreased in the P_i-deficient chloroplasts relative to chloroplasts illuminated in the presence of P_i. The stromal concentration of glycerate 3-phosphate was comparable in the P_i-deficient chloroplasts and those to which P_i had been supplied. Chloroplasts which were illuminated in P_i-free media showed a large accumulation of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate relative to those supplied with P_i, suggesting inhibition of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase under these conditions. When P_i was added to chloroplasts illuminated in the absence of P_i, both non-photochemical quenching (q_E), photochemical quenching (q_Q) and ΔpH increased. This suggests that electron transport was not limited by inability to discharge transthylakoid ΔpH. These observation are consistent with the hypothesis that P_i limitation results in decreased ATP production by the thylakoid ATP synthase. The data presented here show that there are multiple sites of flux control exerted by low stromal P_i in the chloroplast. At least three factors contribute to the inhibition of photosynthesis under phosphate limitation: (1) there appears to be a direct effect of P_i on the energy-transducing system; (2) there is direct inhibition of the Calvin cycle decreasing the ability of the pathway to act as a sink for ATP and NADPH; and (3) feedback inhibition of primary processes occurs either via ΔpH or the redox state of electron carriers. However, ΔpH does not appear to be a limiting factor, but rather an inability to regenerate NADP as electron acceptor is suggested. The addition of DCMU to chloroplasts during illumination in the absence of P_i for periods of up to 10 min showed that there was very little loss of variable fluorescence despite a 60% reduction in the capacity for O₂ evolution. This would suggest that photoinhibitory damage to Photosystem II was not the major cause of the inhibition of photosynthesis observed with low P_i.     

Potentiometric titration of Photosystem II fluorescence decay kinetics in spinach chloroplasts

The fluorescence yield of chloroplasts reflects the redox state of the electron acceptor of the Photosystem II reaction center, with increasing yield as the acceptor is reduced. Chemical reductive titrations of fluorescence yield in chloroplasts at room temperature indicate two distinct midpoint potentials, suggesting the possibility of Photosystem II electron acceptor heterogeneity. We have carried out a potentiometric titration of the fluorescence decay kinetics in spinach chloroplasts using a continuous mode-locked dye laser with low-intensity excitation pulses and a picosecond-resolution single-photon timing system. At all potentials the fluorescence decay is best described by three exponential components. As the potential is lowered, the slow phase changes 30-fold in yield with two distinct midpoint potentials, accompanied by a modest (3-fold) increase in the lifetime. The titration curve for the slow component of the fluorescence decay of spinach chloroplasts is best characterized by two single-electron redox reactions with midpoint potentials at pH 8.0 of +119 and ?350 mV, with corresponding relative contributions to the fluorescence yield of 49 and 51%, respectively. There is little change in the fast and middle components of the fluorescence decay. We found that the oxidized form of the redox mediator 2-hydroxy-1,4-naphthoquinone preferentially quenches the fluorescence, causing an anomalous decrease in the apparent midpoint of the high-potential transition. This effect accounts for a significant difference between the midpoint potentials that we observe and some of those previously reported. The selective effect of reduction potentials on particular fluorescence decay components provides useful information about the organization and distribution of the Photosystem II electron acceptor.     

Correlation between the activity of membrane-bound ATPase and the decay rate of flash-induced 515-nm absorbance change in chloroplasts in intact leaves,assayed by means of rapid isolation of chloroplasts

(1) The relationship between activation of the membrane-bound ATPase and the stimulation of dissipation of the flash-induced membrane potential by preillumination was studied in intact spinach leaves by measuring the ATPase activity of rapidly isolated chloroplasts and the decay of the flash-induced 515-nm absorbance change (ΔA₅₁₅) in intact leaves. (2) The decay of ΔA₅₁₅ was accelerated by preillumination. The ΔA₅₁₅ decay in leaves treated with N,N′-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) became slower and was not accelerated by preillumination. However, treatment with DCCD did not lower the intensity of delayed fluorescence. (3) Membrane-bound ATPase of chloroplasts which were rapidly isolated from the preilluminated leaves (90 s preparation time) showed a higher activity (over 200 μmol P_i/mg chlorophyll per h in the case of 2-min preillumination) than that of chloroplasts isolated from dark-adapted leaves. (4) The acceleration of ΔA₅₁₅ decay and the activation of ATPase showed similar dependences on illumination time in intact leaves. 3-(3′,4′-Dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea, carbonyl cyanide p-chlorophenylhydrazone and DCCD inhibited the activation of ATPase and the acceleration of the ΔA₅₁₅ decay by preillumination. (5) The ATPase activity of chloroplasts isolated from illuminated leaves showed a single exponential decay (‘dark inactivation in vitro’). The ATPase activity induced by illuminating the leaves became lower as the dark interval between illumination and the isolation of chloroplasts was increased (‘dark inactivation in vivo’). The time course of the decay of activity had a lag and showed a sigmoidal curve when plotted semilogarithmically. The decay had an apparent half-time of 25 min. (6) The recovery of the accelerated ΔA₅₁₅ decay in preilluminated leaves to the original slow rate showed a sigmoidal decay similar to that of the activity of ATPase in intact leaves with a half-time of about 23 min in the dark. (7) It was concluded that the decay rate of ΔA₅₁₅ reflected the chloroplast ATPase activity in intact leaves and that the ion conductance of thylakoid membrane was mainly determined by the H⁺ flux through the ATPase, the activity of which was increased after the formation of the high-energy state.     

Thiol modulation of the chloroplast protonmotive ATPase and its effect on photophosphorylation

Thiol modulation of the chloroplast protonmotive ATPase (CF₀-CF₁) by preillumination of broken chloroplasts in the presence of dithiothreitol (or preillumination of intact chloroplasts in the absence of added thiols) had the following effects on photophosphorylation. (1) When assayed at pH 8 and saturating light, the initial rate of photophosphorylation was increased by 10–40%. There was an accompanying increase in the rate of coupled electron transport with no significant change in the overall $\text{P}\text{2}\text{e}$ ratio. (2) On lowering the pH of the assay medium to pH 7, the stimulatory effect of thiol modulation on photophosphorylation and coupled electron flow was enhanced. At pH 7, there was also a small increase in $\text{P}\text{2}\text{e}$ ratio. (3) Addition of a non-saturating amount of uncoupler to the assay medium enhanced the stimulatory effect of thiol modulation on photophosphorylation. In the presence of 1 mM NH₄Cl, there was only a small increase in coupled electron flow and a correspondingly larger increase in $\text{P}\text{2}\text{e}$ ratio. (4) Lowering the light intensity, or inhibiting electron transport, diminished the stimulatory effect of thiol modulation on photophosphorylation, coupled electron transport and $\text{P}\text{2}\text{e}$ ratio. (5) Under all the above conditions, the ΔpH maintained across the thylakoid membrane was lower after thiol modulation, even when photophosphorylation markedly increased in rate. (6) Thiol modulation of CF₀-CF₁ increased the observed Michaelis constant for ADP (K_m(ADP)) and the apparent maximum rate (V_app of photophosphorylation by the same factor, so that ratio $\text{V}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>app</mtext>}}\text{K}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>m</mtext>}}$ was not altered. $\text{V}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>app</mtext>}}\text{K}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>m</mtext>}}$ was also unaffected by changing the medium pH, but was significantly decreased upon addition of uncouplers to the medium. These results indicate that the observed rate of ATP synthesis catalysed by thiol demodulated chloroplasts is limited kinetically by the fraction (α) of enzyme molecules that are active during photophosphorylation. A model based on a dual pH optimum requirement for activation of CF₀-CF₁ is presented to explain the dependence of α on ΔpH. Thiol modulation of CF₀-CF₁ is proposed to stimulate photophosphorylation by causing the enzyme to become active over a lower range of ΔpH, thereby reducing the kinetic limitation on ATP synthesis imposed by the activation process.     

Loose and tight binding of adenine nucleotides by membrane-associated chloroplast ATPase

Steady-state binding of adenine nucleotides by thylakoid membranes is measured by employing a centrifugation technique. By this method tightly bound nonexchangeable nucleotides can be discriminated from loosely bound, exchangeable nucleotides. Nucleotide binding requires membrane energization and is highly specific for medium ADP. In illuminated chloroplasts almost no exogenous AMP and only some ATP are incorporated, most being recovered as tightly bound nucleotides. In light-triggered chloroplasts, however, which are capable of hydrolyzing ATP, a high level of exchangeable nucleotides is found on the membranes. The sum of tightly bound and loosely bound nucleotides originating from medium ADP is about one per CF₁. The ratio between them decreases with increasing proton-motive force. Exchangeable nucleotides most probably represent the ligands involved in the catalytic process, as suggested from substrate specificity and the effect of a competitive inhibitor of photophosphorylation, naphthoyl ADP. This compound in a low concentration range supresses loose binding but not tight binding of medium ADP. Under phosphorylating conditions (presence of ADP, P_i and light), some of the tightly bound nucleotides exist as ATP even in the presence of a hexokinase system. The results are discussed in the context of the regulation of chloroplast ATPase by tight nucleotide binding.     

Properties of ATP-driven reverse electron flow in chloroplasts

1. The reverse reactions induced by coupled ATP hydrolysis were studied in spinach chloroplasts by measurements of the ATP-induced increase in chlorophyll fluorescence reflecting reverse electron flow, and of the ATP-induced decrease in 9-aminoacridine fluorescence, representing formation of the transthylakoidal proton gradient (ΔpH). ATP-driven reverse electron flow was kinetically analysed into three phases, of which only the second and third one were paralleled by corresponding phases in ΔpH formation. The rapid first phase and formation of a ΔpH occur also in the absence of the electron transfer mediator phenazine methosulfate.2. The rate and extent of the reverse reactions were measured at temperatures in the range from 0 to 30°C. The rate of formation of ΔpH and of reverse electron flow were faster at high temperatures, but the maximal extent of ΔpH and chlorophyll fluorescence increase were observed at the lowest temperature. Considering rate and extent of the ATP-stimulated reactions, a temperature optimum around 15°C was found. Light activation of the ATPase occurred throughout the range studied. At 0°C and in the presence of inorganic phosphate the activated state for ATPase was maintained for more then 10 min.3. The ATP-induced rise in chlorophyll fluorescence yield was found to be of similar magnitude as the rise induced by 3-(3,4-dichlorophenyl)-1,1-dimethylurea (DCMU), when both were measured with an extremely weak measuring beam. It is concluded, that both effects, although derived via distinctly different pathways, are limited by the same electron donating or electron accepting pool.