Enhancing the Activity of a Protein by Stereospecific Unfolding: CONFORMATIONAL LIFE CYCLE OF INSULIN AND ITS EVOLUTIONARY ORIGINS*S??

A central tenet of molecular biology holds that the function of a protein is mediated by its structure. An inactive ground-state conformation may nonetheless be enjoined by the interplay of competing biological constraints. A model is provided by insulin, well characterized at atomic resolution by x-ray crystallography. Here, we demonstrate that the activity of the hormone is enhanced by stereospecific unfolding of a conserved structural element. A bifunctional β-strand mediates both self-assembly (within β-cell storage vesicles) and receptor binding (in the bloodstream). This strand is anchored by an invariant side chain (Phe^B24); its substitution by Ala leads to an unstable but native-like analog of low activity. Substitution by d-Ala is equally destabilizing, and yet the protein diastereomer exhibits enhanced activity with segmental unfolding of the β-strand. Corresponding photoactivable derivatives (containing l- or d-para-azido-Phe) cross-link to the insulin receptor with higher d-specific efficiency. Aberrant exposure of hydrophobic surfaces in the analogs is associated with accelerated fibrillation, a form of aggregation-coupled misfolding associated with cellular toxicity. Conservation of Phe^B24, enforced by its dual role in native self-assembly and induced fit, thus highlights the implicit role of misfolding as an evolutionary constraint. Whereas classical crystal structures of insulin depict its storage form, signaling requires engagement of a detachable arm at an extended receptor interface. Because this active conformation resembles an amyloidogenic intermediate, we envisage that induced fit and self-assembly represent complementary molecular adaptations to potential proteotoxicity. The cryptic threat of misfolding poses a universal constraint in the evolution of polypeptide sequences.How insulin binds to the insulin receptor (IR)² is not well understood despite decades of investigation. The hormone is a globular protein containing two chains, A (21 residues) and B (30 residues) (Fig. 1A). In pancreatic β-cells, insulin is stored as Zn²⁺-stabilized hexamers (Fig. 1B), which form microcrystal-line arrays within specialized secretory granules (1). The hexamers dissociate upon secretion into the portal circulation, enabling the hormone to function as a zinc-free monomer. The monomer is proposed to undergo a change in conformation upon receptor binding (2). In this study, we investigated a site of conformational change in the B-chain (Phe^B24) (arrow in Fig. 1A). In classical crystal structures, this invariant aromatic side chain (tawny in Fig. 1B) anchors an antiparallel β-sheet at the dimer interface (blue in Fig. 1C). Total chemical synthesis is exploited to enable comparison of corresponding d- and l-amino acid substitutions at this site, an approach designated “chiral mutagenesis” (3-5). In the accompanying article, the consequences of this conformational change are investigated by photomapping of the receptor-binding surface (6). Together, these studies redefine the interrelation of structure and activity in a protein central to the hormonal control of metabolism.Open in a separate windowFIGURE 1.Sequence and structure of insulin. A, sequences of the B-chain (upper) and A-chain (lower) with disulfide bridges as indicated. The arrow indicates invariant Phe^B24. The B24-B28 β-strand is highlighted in blue. B, crystal structure of the T₆ zinc insulin hexamer (Protein Data Bank code 4INS): ribbon model (left) and space-filling model (right). The B24-B28 β-strand is shown in blue, and the side chain of Phe^B24 is highlighted in tawny. The B-chain is otherwise dark gray; the A-chain, light gray; and zinc ions, magenta. Also shown at the left are the side chains of His^B10 at the axial zinc-binding sites. C, cylinder model of the insulin dimer showing the B24-B26 antiparallel β-sheet (blue) anchored by the B24 side chain (tawny circle). The A- and B-chains are shown in light and dark gray, respectively. The protomer at the left is shown in the R-state, in which the central α-helix of the B-chain is elongated (B3-B19 in the frayed R^f protomer of T₃R^f₃ hexamers and B1-B19 in the R protomer of R₆ hexamers). The three types of zinc insulin hexamers share similar B24-B26 antiparallel β-sheets as conserved dimerization elements.The structure of an insulin monomer in solution resembles a crystallographic protomer (Fig. 2A) (7-9). The A-chain contains an N-terminal α-helix, non-canonical turn, and second helix; the B-chain contains an N-terminal segment, central α-helix, and C-terminal β-strand. The β-strand is maintained in an isolated monomer wherein the side chain of Phe^B24 (tawny in Fig. 2A), packing against the central α-helix of the B-chain, provides a “plug” to seal a crevice in the hydrophobic core (Fig. 2B). Anomalies encountered in previous studies of insulin analogs suggest that Phe^B24 functions as a conformational switch (4, 7, 10-14). Whereas l-amino acid substitutions at B24 generally impair activity (even by such similar residues as l-Tyr) (15), a seeming paradox is posed by the enhanced activities of nonstandard analogs containing d-amino acids (10-12).

TABLE 1

Previous studies of insulin analogs