Adaptive significance of gall formation for a gall-inducing aphids on Japanese elm trees

Insect galls are abnormal plant tissues induced by external stimuli from parasitizing insects. It has been suggested that the stimuli include phytohormones such as auxin and cytokinins produced by the insects. In our study on the role of hormones in gall induction by the aphid Tetraneura nigriabdominalis, it was found that feedback regulation related to auxin and cytokinin activity is absent in gall tissues, even though the aphids contain higher concentrations of those phytohormones than do plant tissues. Moreover, jasmonic acid signaling appears to be compromised in gall tissue, and consequently, the production of volatile organic compounds, which are a typical defense response of host plants to herbivory, is diminished. These findings suggest that these traits of the gall tissue benefit aphids, because the gall tissue is highly sensitive to auxin and cytokinin, which induce and maintain it. The induced defenses against aphid feeding are also compromised. The abnormal responsiveness to phytohormones is regarded as a new type of extended phenotype of gall-inducing insects.     

Manipulation of host plant cells and tissues by gall-inducing insects and adaptive strategies used by different feeding guilds

Biologists who study insect-induced plant galls are faced with the overwhelming diversity of plant forms and insect species. A challenge is to find common themes amidst this diversity. We discuss common themes that have emerged from our cytological and histochemical studies of diverse neotropical insect-induced galls. Gall initiation begins with recognition of reactive plant tissues by gall inducers, with subsequent feeding and/or oviposition triggering a cascade of events. Besides, to induce the gall structure insects have to synchronize their life cycle with plant host phenology. We predict that reactive oxygen species (ROS) play a role in gall induction, development and histochemical gradient formation. Controlled levels of ROS mediate the accumulation of (poly)phenols, and phytohormones (such as auxin) at gall sites, which contributes to the new cell developmental pathways and biochemical alterations that lead to gall formation. The classical idea of an insect-induced gall is a chamber lined with a nutritive tissue that is occupied by an insect that directly harvests nutrients from nutritive cells via its mouthparts, which function mechanically and/or as a delivery system for salivary secretions. By studying diverse gall-inducing insects we have discovered that insects with needle-like sucking mouthparts may also induce a nutritive tissue, whose nutrients are indirectly harvested as the gall-inducing insects feeds on adjacent vascular tissues. Activity of carbohydrate-related enzymes across diverse galls corroborates this hypothesis. Our research points to the importance of cytological and histochemical studies for elucidating mechanisms of induced susceptibility and induced resistance.     

Exogenous phytohormones and the induction of plant galls by insects

The mechanism of gall induction by insects has remained elusive. Previous studies have met with limited success in attempting to induce galls by injection or application of chemical compounds. To determine whether an exogenous source of phytohormones plays a role in gall induction, we injected cytokinin (CK), auxin (IAA), gibberellic acid (GA), and abscisic acid (ABA) in various concentrations, ratios, and combinations into leaf petioles of Capsicum annuum L. cv. California Wonder (Solanaceae). We found that CK + IAA injections lead to gall-like growth in C. annuum. GA enhanced and ABA inhibited gall growth except in the presence of GA. Isopentenyl adenine (IP) was the most effective type of CK at inducing growth. Our work is consistent with the hypothesis that exogenous CK + IAA produced and supplied by insects leads to gall induction. We hypothesize that insects have obtained the capability to induce galls via acquisition of the biosynthetic pathways to produce IAA and trans-zeatin family CKs through microbial symbiosis or lateral gene transfer.     

Red galls: the different stories of two gall types on the same host

• Several studies have suggested reasons why galls have conspicuous colours, but none of the ideas have been confirmed. However, what if the vibrant colours of some galls are explained simply by the effect of light exposure? This may lead to anthocyanin accumulation, functioning as a defence mechanism against the effects of high light.
• We studied the globoid galls induced by Cecidomyiidae (Diptera) on Qualea parviflora (Vochysiaceae), relating anthocyanin accumulation and chlorophyll fluorescence parameters to light incidence in abaxial and adaxial galls. We also tested if the anthocyanin accumulation patterns apply to another Cecidomyiidae‐induced gall morphotype (intralaminar) within the same plant.
• Adaxial galls are exposed to higher incident light, with more anthocyanin accumulation and therefore red coloration. In galls from angled leaves, the greater the angle of the leaf, the higher the difference between anthocyanins on the sun and shade sides of galls. Photosynthetic pigment concentrations did not differ between abaxial and adaxial galls. However, we found higher (F_m′ ? F′)/F_m′ and F_v/F_m in the abaxial galls. Conversely, NPQ and R_fd were higher in adaxial galls. Finally, the pattern of anthocyanin accumulation was not found in the intralaminar gall.
• Anthocyanin accumulation in galls functions as a photoprotective strategy, maintaining tissue vitality in regions exposed to high light conditions. However, this mechanism may vary even among galls within the same host, indicating idiosyncrasy when it comes to coloration in galls. To date, this is the first study to demonstrate quantitatively why the galls of a specific species may be coloured: the variation in light regimes creates differential anthocyanin accumulation, influencing coloration.

     

Why do many galls have conspicuous colors? A new hypothesis

Galls are abnormal plant growth induced by various parasitic organisms, mainly insects. They serve as “incubators” for the developing insects in which they gain nutrition and protection from both abiotic factors and natural enemies. Galls are typically armed with high levels of defensive secondary metabolites. Conspicuousness by color, size and shape is a common gall trait. Many galls are colorful (red, yellow etc.) and therefore can be clearly distinguished from the surrounding host plant organs. Here we outlined a new hypothesis, suggesting that chemically protected galls which are also conspicuous are aposematic. We discuss predictions, alternative hypotheses and experimental tests of this hypothesis.     

Life history of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Stenopsylla nigricornis</Emphasis> (Hemiptera: Psylloidea: Triozidae) and phytohormones involved in its gall induction

Many phytophagous insects have an ability to manipulate plant tissue and induce galls, but the mechanism is not yet fully understood. Some insects have multivoltine life cycles, and each generation induces galls on different plant species or different organs in the same host. Such host-use patterns are interesting study subjects to clarify the gall-inducing mechanisms of insects. We focused on a multivoltine and gall-inducing psyllid Stenopsylla nigricornis Kuwayama (Hemiptera: Psylloidea: Triozidae), which is associated with Symplocos lucida Sieb. (Symplocaceae). Based on periodic field surveys in Kyushu, Japan, S. nigricornis is revealed to have a bivoltine life history. Then, we revealed that the spring generation induces galls on leaves, while the autumn generation does so on flower buds and overwintering leaf buds. We also analyzed phytohormones in normal plant tissue, S. nigricornis nymphs, and their galls. As a result, nymphs were discovered to contain much higher concentrations of isopentenyladenosine and its possible precursor, isopentenyladenosine riboside than plant tissues, strongly suggesting that the phytohormone is involved in gall induction by S. nigricornis. Because flower bud galls contained significantly lower concentrations of abscisic acid (ABA) than normal flower bud, the autumn generation nymphs are considered to regulate the ABA level and to promote the earlier opening of host flower buds.     

致瘿昆虫对寄主植物生理和代谢的影响

虫瘿是致瘿昆虫刺激植物后诱导形成的畸形结构,是研究植物与昆虫协同进化的理想材料,同时致瘿昆虫通常还是重要的农林害虫.因此,研究致瘿昆虫对寄主植物的影响,一方面可进一步揭示致瘿昆虫与植物的关系,有助于揭示成瘿植物生长的一般过程;另一方面,了解成瘿植物对致瘿昆虫的响应有助于筛选植物抗性指标、抗性基因、敏感基因等,为抗性育种...     

The impact of kleptoparasitic invasions on the evolution of gall-size in social and solitary Australian Acacia thrips

Many species of gall-inducing Acacia thrips are attacked by kleptoparasitic thrips who enter the gall, destroy the occupants, and then use the gall for producing their own offspring. The hypothesis tested here is that pressure exerted by ldeptoparasites （genus Koptothrips） not only provoked the evolution of soldiers in the gall-inducing clade, but have also influenced the evolution of gall size and morphology. Various size dimensions of invaded galls were compared to those of uninvaded galls using data from six gall-inducing species and their kleptoparasites. For the non-social gall-inducing species （K. ellobus and K. nicholsoni） invaded galls showed no significant size differences from galls that had not been invaded. For the four social gall-inducingspecies （K. habrus, K. intermedius, K. waterhousei and K. morrisi） invaded galls were significantly narrower and/or shorter than uninvaded galls. Galls of social species that had not been invaded and contained adult soldiers were significantly larger than galls where soldiers were still at a larval stage, suggesting that gall size is related to gall age in these species. An hypothesis is proposed that links the timing of invasion by kleptoparasites to size of the host gall： induction of a smaller gall by host founders will reduce the period of vulnerability to invasion （before soldiers become adults） for social thrips by allowing foundresses in these smaller galls to begin laying soldierdestined eggs relatively sooner.     

Feeding by a gall-inducing caterpillar species alters levels of indole-3-acetic and abscisic acid in Solidago altissima (Asteraceae) stems

Various plant antagonists appear to alter phytohormone levels for their own benefit. Among insects, gall-inducing species appear to influence phytohormones and it is widely believed that they alter levels of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) to help produce their galls, but evidence exists for only a limited number of species. To further explore the role of phytohormones in gall formation, we measured levels of IAA and abscisic acid (ABA), a hormone involved in plant defenses and that can influence IAA, in tissues of control stems of Solidago altissima (Asteraceae) and those galled by Gnorimoschema gallaesolidaginis (Gelechiidae). This gall-inducing caterpillar species significantly altered the distribution of IAA in galls and the larvae themselves contained high concentrations of IAA. In contrast, the generalist caterpillar Heliothis virescens (Noctuidae) neither altered IAA nor accumulated significant concentrations of IAA, suggesting that G. gallaesolidaginis may have a distinctive influence over IAA. The gall-inducing caterpillars, particularly younger larvae, also contained high levels of ABA but did not increase levels of ABA, which is induced by herbivory of H. virescens. Because G. gallaesolidaginis also does not increase levels of other defense-related hormones, avoiding generalized plant defenses may facilitate gall induction and formation.     

Host Feeding by an Herbivore Improves the Performance of Offspring

Herbivores have developed diverse strategies to manipulate host plants for their own benefits. The gall induction by the maize orange leafhopper Cicadulina bipunctata is different from that by other gall-inducing insects in that the galls are induced not on feeding sites but appear on distant, newly developing leaves. In addition, adult C. bipunctata are highly mobile and seldom feed on gall tissue that they have induced. These mean that the gall induction by C. bipunctata is unlikely to contribute to the fitness of the inducer itself. The objective of this study was to determine whether manipulation of the host plant by this leafhopper has a subsequent benefit to offspring. Adults feeding on maize seedlings caused a partial change in the glucose content and a remarkable change in the accumulation of free amino acids in the gall tissue. Increases in emergence and developmental rates were observed in nymphs feeding on gall tissue induced by prior adult feeding. Such improvements were not evident in nymphs feeding on a C. bipunctata-resistant variety, which rarely displays galls after C. bipunctata feeding, nor on maize seedlings previously foraged by another leafhopper, Psammotettix striatus. The results indicate that gall tissue induced by adult C. bipunctata contribute to better performance of its offspring through improvement of the nutritional components of host plants.     

The gall-inducing habit has evolved multiple times among the eriococcid scale insects (Sternorrhyncha: Coccoidea: Eriococcidae)

The habit of inducing plant galls has evolved multiple times among insects but most species diversity occurs in only a few groups, such as gall midges and gall wasps. This phylogenetic clustering may reflect adaptive radiations in insect groups in which the trait has evolved. Alternatively, multiple independent origins of galling may suggest a selective advantage to the habit. We use DNA sequence data to examine the origins of galling among the most speciose group of gall-inducing scale insects, the eriococcids. We determine that the galling habit has evolved multiple times, including four times in Australian taxa, suggesting that there has been a selective advantage to galling in Australia. Additionally, although most gall-inducing eriococcid species occur on Myrtaceae, we found that lineages feeding on Myrtaceae are no more likely to have evolved the galling habit than those feeding on other plant groups. However, most gall-inducing species-richness is clustered in only two clades ( Apiomorpha and Lachnodius  +  Opisthoscelis ), all of which occur exclusively on Eucalyptus s.s . The Eriococcidae and the large genus Eriococcus were determined to be non-monophyletic and each will require revision.  © 2004 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2004, 83 , 441–452.     

Testing the nutrition hypothesis for the adaptive nature of insect galls: does a non‐adapted herbivore perform better in galls?

Abstract.  1. The nutrition hypothesis for the adaptive nature of galls states that gall-inducing insects control the nutrient levels in galls to their own benefit. Although the nutrition hypothesis is widely accepted, there have been few empirical tests of this idea.
2. A novel method is presented for testing the nutrition hypothesis that links manipulation of gall nutrient levels by the gall inducer to herbivore performance. The effects of adaptation and nutritional advantage are separated by using a herbivore that is adapted to a host plant susceptible to galling but one which never enters the gall environment.
3.  Hellinsia glenni (Cashatt), a plume moth (Pterophoridae) and one of its host plants provide an excellent system for testing the nutrition hypothesis because H. glenni larvae feed internally on the relatively nutrient-poor stems of a goldenrod, Solidago gigantea , but do not venture into the nutrient-rich galls induced on that plant by a tephritid fly, Eurosta solidaginis . The nutrition hypothesis was tested by transplanting early-instar H. glenni larvae into galls and stems of S. gigantea to determine if the larvae transplanted to galls would perform better compared with those larvae transplanted to stems.
4. The results support the nutrition hypothesis for the adaptive nature of galls. Hellinsia glenni achieved greater final mass in the gall environment compared with the final mass larvae achieved in the stem environment. There was also evidence that the quality of gall tissue is controlled by the gall inducer, which has not been previously demonstrated for mature E. solidaginis galls.     

Plant architecture and meristem dynamics as the mechanisms determining the diversity of gall-inducing insects

Plant architecture is considered to affect herbivory intensity, but it is one of the least studied factors in plant–insect interactions, especially for gall-inducing insects. This study aimed to investigate the influence of plant architecture on the speciose fauna of gall-inducing insects associated with 17 species of Baccharis. Five architectural variables were evaluated: plant height, number of fourth-level shoots, biomass, average level and number of ramifications. The number of galling species associated with each host plant species was also determined. To test the effects of plant architecture on gall richness at the individual level, we used another data set where the number of fourth-level shoots and gall richness were determined for B. concinna, B. dracunculifolia, and B. ramosissima every 3 weeks during 1 year. The average similarity between host species based on gall fauna was low (9%), but plants with the same architectural pattern tended to support similar gall communities. The most important architectural trait influencing gall richness at the species level was the number of fourth-level shoots, which is indicative of the availability of plant meristems, a fundamental tissue for gall induction and development. This variable also showed a positive correlation with gall richness at the individual level. We propose that variations in gall richness among host species are driven by interspecific differences in plant architecture via availability of young, undifferentiated tissue, which is genetically controlled by the strength of the apical dominance. Plant architecture should have evolutionary consequences for gall communities, promoting insect radiation among architecturally similar plants through host shift and sympatric speciation. We also discuss the role of plant architecture in the global biogeography of gall-inducing insects. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Red gall pigmentation: cytokinin stimulation is not everything

Recently, the nature of gall pigmentation phenomenon has gained interest, with different, and often contradicting, explanations and hypotheses. A recent, welcome contribution by Connor et al. (Arthropod–Plant Interact 6:489–495, 2012) suggested that gall pigmentation is a mere “fabricational noise” of the gall development, caused by the production of anthocyanin due to the accumulation of cytokinins and sugars. We propose that this perspective, although probably true in some systems, is an oversimplification of a more complex situation. We argue that since multiple pigments are likely to be involved in gall coloration, and since the link between cytokinins and pigmentation is not obligatory, this is an unlikely general explanation of gall pigmentation. The galling habit has evolved independently among numerous insect lineages and habitats, and therefore, the role of gall pigmentation may vary. It is the time to test the different hypotheses in the field.     

High mean relatedness among communally galling Tamalia aphids revealed by AFLP analysis

Cooperative or eusocial behavior occurs in gall-inducing insects, but the ecological and evolutionary contexts for these behaviors vary in their details. Foundresses of the manzanita leaf-gall aphid, Tamalia coweni, regularly share galls. Because aphids undergo parthenogenesis, communal foundresses are potential clone mates. Under the kin selection hypothesis, a high level of relatedness is predicted to lower genetically based conflict among females in a group and thereby favor communal gall occupation. We recorded the frequency of communal behavior in a population of T. coweni on its host plant, Arctostaphylos patula, and measured reproductive output in single- and multiple-occupant galls. Eleven percent of the 375 galls examined were communally occupied, with double-foundress galls the commonest class, up to a maximum of five foundresses within galls. Total productivity of communal galls (measured by numbers of offspring per gall) was higher than for single-foundress galls on a per-gall basis, but lower per capita. We genotyped foundresses with amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP)-PCR markers, to estimate relatedness among gall co-occupants and foundresses from randomly selected galls in the population. Analysis of genetic distance between communal foundresses revealed that relatedness among gall cohabitants was significantly higher, on average, than for foundresses drawn from the population at random (P < 0.001). Phylogenetic analysis using parsimony (PAUP) of the AFLP profiles indicated that half the foundresses sharing galls were most closely related to their gall mates. Our results are consistent with kin selection theory, and suggest that communal gall occupation in this species may be interpreted as cooperative behavior.     

Cytokinin antagonist activity of substituted phenethylamines in plant cell culture

A series of structurally related substituted phenethylamines shows extreme toxicity toward wild-type callus tissue cultures of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum), soybean (Glycine max), corn (Zea mays), and sunflower (Helianthus annuus L.), but tobacco crown gall cultures are resistant to the compounds. The essential components that result in toxicity of the phenethylamines include one aromatic hydroxyl and one primary aliphatic amino group. A series of attenuated crown gall cultures, generated by transformation of tobacco with various modified Agrobacterium strains, has been used to demonstrate that the resistance of crown galls to the phenethylamines is due to the expression in these tissues of isopentenyl transferase, a first step in cytokinin biosynthesis. The toxicity of the compounds to tissue cultures is very rapid, but can be overcome by prior exposure of the calli to exogenous cytokinin. Because of the relationships we have observed between cytokinins and these compounds, we propose that the substituted phenethylamines may represent a class of chemicals that can be used as specific probes to further an understanding of cytokinin metabolism in plant tissues.     

Biosynthetic pathway of the phytohormone auxin in insects and screening of its inhibitors

Insect galls are abnormal plant tissues induced by galling insects. The galls are used for food and habitation, and the phytohormone auxin, produced by the insects, may be involved in their formation. We found that the silkworm, a non-galling insect, also produces an active form of auxin, indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), by de novo synthesis from tryptophan (Trp). A detailed metabolic analysis of IAA using IAA synthetic enzymes from silkworms indicated an IAA biosynthetic pathway composed of a three-step conversion: Trp → indole-3-acetaldoxime → indole-3-acetaldehyde (IAAld) → IAA, of which the first step is limiting IAA production. This pathway was shown to also operate in gall-inducing sawfly. Screening of a chemical library identified two compounds that showed strong inhibitory activities on the conversion step IAAld → IAA. The inhibitors can be efficiently used to demonstrate the importance of insect-synthesized auxin in gall formation in the future.     

Histocytological aspects of four types of ambrosia galls on Machilus zuihoensis Hayata (Lauraceae)

Four types of prosoplasmatic galls induced by Daphnephila midges are found on leaves of Machilus zuihoensis, a species endemic to Taiwan: urn- and small urn-shaped, obovate, and hairy oblong galls. In addition to containing nutritive tissues, these galls are lined with fungal hyphae. The objective of this study was to describe and compare the structural organization of the various gall morphologies and to examine the ultrastructure of the nutritive and fungal cells lining the gall chambers. The morphology and ultrastructure of mature-stage galls were examined by light, scanning electron, and transmission electron microscopy. Diverse epidermal cell shapes and wax textures were observed in the leaves and galls of M. zuihoensis. In small urn-shaped, obovate, and hairy oblong galls vascular bundles extend from the gall base to near the centre of the gall top. In contrast, vascular bundles in urn-shaped galls are distributed in the gall wall and extend to close to the outer gall top. Trichomes were present only abaxially on leaves and on hairy oblong gall surfaces. Starch granules, tannins, and mucilage were distributed differently among the four gall types. Further, fungal mycelia spread in the interior gall wall and partially passed through the intercellular spaces of nutritive cells and reached the sclerenchyma. Histological analyses revealed that the surface structure of galls differs from that of the leaf and that the epidermal organization differs among the four gall types. Different types of leaf galls on the same plant have different patterns of tissue stratification and contain different ergastic substances. The results of this study will contribute to the understanding of tritrophic relationships and the complex interactions among parasitic gall-inducing insects, mutualistic fungi, and host plants.