A retrospective,dual‐isotope approach reveals individual predispositions to winter‐drought induced tree dieback in the southernmost distribution limit of Scots pine

Winter‐drought induced forest diebacks in the low‐latitude margins of species' distribution ranges can provide new insights into the mechanisms (carbon starvation, hydraulic failure) underlying contrasting tree reactions. We analysed a winter‐drought induced dieback at the Scots pine's southern edge through a dual‐isotope approach (Δ¹³C and δ¹⁸O in tree‐ring cellulose). We hypothesized that a differential long‐term performance, mediated by the interaction between CO₂ and climate, determined the fates of individuals during dieback. Declining trees showed a stronger coupling between climate, growth and intrinsic water‐use efficiency (WUEi) than non‐declining individuals that was noticeable for 25 years prior to dieback. The rising stomatal control of water losses with time in declining trees, indicated by negative Δ¹³C‐δ¹⁸O relationships, was likely associated with their native aptitude to grow more and take up more water (suggested by larger tracheid lumen widths) than non‐declining trees and, therefore, to exhibit a greater cavitation risk. Freeze‐thaw episodes occurring in winter 2001 unveiled such physiological differences by triggering dieback in those trees more vulnerable to hydraulic failure. Thus, WUEi tightly modulated growth responses to long‐term warming in declining trees, indicating that co‐occurring individuals were differentially predisposed to winter‐drought mortality. These different performances were unconnected to the depletion of stored carbohydrates.     

Root damage and water stress: treatments affecting the exploitation of the buds of common ash Fraxinus excelsior L., by larvae of the ash bud moth Prays fraxinella Bjerk. (Lep., Yponomeutidae)

Damage to the buds of the common ash (Fraxinus excelsior L.) by larvae of the ash bud moth Prays fraxinella Bjerk. was investigated in trees growing in the presence, or absence, of an adjacent ditch. The presence of a ditch was correlated with increased damage levels due to bud moth. Saplings were used in an experiment to compare the effects of artificial drought and root damage with those of ditches. Both root damage and drought elicited analogous responses to those observed in trees growing near a ditch, being associated with elevated levels of bud moth exploitation and reduced growth of shoots. There exists a documented link between ditches, root disturbance, and the dieback of hedgerow ash trees in Great Britain; the response of P. fraxinella to environmental disturbances associated with dieback is hypothesised to be evidence of the possible role of moth damage as a causal factor in dieback.     

Dieback of rural eucalypts: the effect of stress on the nutritional quality of foliage

Canopy dieback of Eucalyptus blakelyi trees is often associated with defoliation by insects: the foliage of trees with dieback is nutritionally superior for insects and is more heavily damaged by them. I investigated whether differences in the nutritional quality of foliage were genetically determined, or caused by environmental stress. In a series of glasshouse experiments, with seedlings and grafted plants derived from dieback and healthy populations of trees. I tested the influence of deprivation of nutrients, drought, waterlogging, saline waterlogging and addition of excess phosphate, on the nutritional quality of foliage. Differences in the foliar properties of plants from different genetic sources were not consistent with the differences between the source populations. Most of the environmental stresses applied caused a reduction in foliar quality (decreased water and nitrogen contents, and increased specific leaf weights). I hypothesize that the enhanced nutritional quality of the foliage of dieback trees is more likely to be a consequence of benign growing conditions (e.g. improved soil fertility) than of environmental stress. Field data for soil properties and the effect of drought on mature trees are consistent with this view.     

Dieback of rural eucalypts: Response of foliar dietary quality and herbivory to defoliation

Rural dieback of Eucalyptus blakelyi trees growing on pastoral properties near Canberra is associated with chronic defoliation by insects. In order to test the effect of defoliation on subsequent herbivory, I artificially defoliated three healthy trees by clipping their terminal branchlets. The foliage that regrew on the clipped trees was nutritionally superior to the foliage it replaced, and was much more heavily damaged by grazing insects. There was a transient increase in the tannin content of the regrowth foliage, but this was apparently ineffective in defending it from subsequent herbivory. Compared with the foliage on nearby E. blakelyi trees that also produced major flushes of leaf growth during the same period, the regrowth on the clipped trees had enhanced dietary qualities and suffered more insect damage. Leaf age contributed to many of the differences in dietary quality, but when adjustments were made for the effects of leaf age the same trends remained. Five of the nearby trees were suffering from the chronic insect grazing associated with rural dieback, and the other five appeared healthy. The dietary quality of regrowth foliage on the clipped trees was qualitatively more similar to that of foliage on the dieback trees. Thus the chronic herbivory associated with rural dieback may be partly self-perpetuating, given this positive feedback between defoliation and dietary quality, and an apparent absence of other effective controls on insect populations.     

Patch dieback of Colophospermum mopane in a dysfunctional semi‐arid African savanna

Abstract Patch dieback occurred in an almost monospecific Colophospermum mopane (Kirk ex Benth.) Kirk ex J. Léonard woodland in the Northern Province, South Africa, following severe droughts in 1988–1989 and 1991–1992. Discrete patches of dieback and adjacent paired areas of ‘healthy’ vegetation lost an average of 87 and 13% of basal area to mortality, respectively. Whole trees mostly died on ‘dead’ plots, while single‐stem mortality prevailed on ‘live’ plots. Tree mortality decreased with increasing stem number per tree. Patch dieback did not occur on sandy soils. On fine‐textured soils, variation in soil type, topography or slope did not affect dieback. Dieback was influenced by vegetation structure, soil surface condition and soil chemistry. Intense intertree competition, shown by self‐thinning occurring prior to dieback, was a precondition for dieback. Intertree competition had heightened during the 30 years prior to dieback because of an increase in woody cover. Dieback patches had changed from functioning as sinks of water and sediment to sources of these as a result of loss of perennial herbaceous cover, decreased water retention on bared surfaces, and accelerated erosion during 50 years of livestock ranching. Vegetation had thus become increasingly drought‐prone, exacerbated in places by soils with a high sodium concentration. Dieback had occurred because the water requirements of C. mopane could no longer be met during drought years on the dysfunctional patches.     

The decline of Greek fir (Abies cephalonica Loudon): Relationships with root condition

Abstract

The decline of Greek fir (Abies cephalonica Loudon) has been reported throughout Greece during the last three decades. The symptoms include crown dieback, needle discoloration and loss, death of twigs, branches or whole tree death. A number of causes for the fir decline have been proposed such as drought, climatic change, air pollution and pathogens or insects. Our studies have focused on the relationship between fir decline symptoms and root growth and condition. The crown and root condition of fir trees, at different stages of decline, were assessed and the results showed that root condition was related to needle loss and crown discoloration. Declining trees were characterized by a decreased portion of fine root biomass. No significant differences in total root length and number of roots for each root order were found. In conclusion, our studies showed that the crown condition of Greek firs is reflected on root condition.     

Variation in woody plant mortality and dieback from severe drought among soils, plant groups, and species within a northern Arizona ecotone

Vegetation change from drought-induced mortality can alter ecosystem community structure, biodiversity, and services. Although drought-induced mortality of woody plants has increased globally with recent warming, influences of soil type, tree and shrub groups, and species are poorly understood. Following the severe 2002 drought in northern Arizona, we surveyed woody plant mortality and canopy dieback of live trees and shrubs at the forest–woodland ecotone on soils derived from three soil parent materials (cinder, flow basalt, sedimentary) that differed in texture and rockiness. Our first of three major findings was that soil parent material had little effect on mortality of both trees and shrubs, yet canopy dieback of trees was influenced by parent material; dieback was highest on the cinder for pinyon pine (Pinus edulis) and one-seed juniper (Juniperus monosperma). Ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) dieback was not sensitive to parent material. Second, shrubs had similar mortality, but greater canopy dieback, than trees. Third, pinyon and ponderosa pines had greater mortality than juniper, yet juniper had greater dieback, reflecting different hydraulic characteristics among these tree species. Our results show that impacts of severe drought on woody plants differed among tree species and tree and shrub groups, and such impacts were widespread over different soils in the southwestern U.S. Increasing frequency of severe drought with climate warming will likely cause similar mortality to trees and shrubs over major soil types at the forest–woodland ecotone in this region, but due to greater mortality of other tree species, tree cover will shift from a mixture of species to dominance by junipers and shrubs. Surviving junipers and shrubs will also likely have diminished leaf area due to canopy dieback.     

The biomass of New England peppermint (Eucalyptus nova-anglica) in relation to insect damage associated with rural dieback

Two adjacent mature trees of New England peppermint (Eucalyptus nova-anglica) were harvested with the aid of a cherry picker to determine their biomass distribution and insect damage. One suffered from obvious symptoms of rural dieback and the other was healthy. Weights of foliage and wood were measured, and insect damage for all leaves and branches was quantified. For each tree 25% of the roots were extracted from the soil using a bulldozer and manual methods; they were then weighed and damage by insects estimated. The healthy tree lost more leaf surface area to insects (11% or 1.1 kg vs 9.2% or 0.3 kg); but the dieback tree had four times more wood affected by boring insects (19% cf. 5%); and only 20% root biomass remaining (92 kg cf. 488 kg). The accuracy of sampling techniques needed to measure defoliation and the consequences of insect damage to dieback of rural eucalypts are discussed.     

Drought and cold spells trigger dieback of temperate oak and beech forests in northern Spain

Dieback in temperate forests is understudied, despite this biome is predicted to be increasingly affected by more extreme climate events in a warmer world. To evaluate the potential drivers of dieback we reconstructed changes in radial growth and intrinsic water-use efficiency (iWUE) from stable isotopes in tree rings. Particularly, we compared tree size, radial-growth trends, growth responses to climate (temperature, precipitation, cloudiness, number of foggy days) and drought, and changes in iWUE of declining and non-declining trees showing contrasting canopy dieback and defoliation. This comparison was done in six temperate forests located in northern Spain and based on three broadleaved tree species (Quercus robur, Quercus humilis, Fagus sylvatica). Declining trees presented lower radial-growth rates than their non-declining counterparts and tended to show lower growth variability, but not in all sites. The growth divergence between declining and non-declining trees was significant and lasted more in Q. robur (15–30 years) than in F. sylvatica (5–10 years) sites. Dieback was linked to summer drought and associated atmospheric patterns, but in the wettest Q. robur sites cold spells contributed to the growth decline. In contrast, F. sylvatica was the species most responsive to summer drought in terms of growth reduction followed by Q. humilis which showed coupled changes in growth and iWUE as a function of tree vigour. Low growth rates and higher iWUE characterized declining Q. robur and F. sylvatica trees. However, declining F. sylvatica trees became less water-use efficient close to the dieback onset, which could indicate impending tree death. In temperate forests, dieback and growth decline can be triggered by climate extremes such as dry and cold spells, and amplified by climate warming and rising drought stress.     

Dieback of rural eucalypts: Does insect herbivory relate to dietary quality of tree foliage?

Foliar dietary quality, and the damage that insects caused to the foliage of dieback-affected and healthy Eucalyptus blakelyi trees, were monitored for 3 years, on pastoral properties in the Australian Capital Territory. Compared with healthy trees, the foliage of dieback trees was more heavily grazed by insects, and its dietary quality was generally superior. Some of the differences in dietary quality were related to the average age of the foliage of healthy and dieback trees. But when statistical models were used to equalize the effects of differences in leaf ages, leaves on dieback trees nonetheless tended to have lower specific weights, and were sometimes rounder and contained more nitrogen. Regression analyses of herbivory against each of the dietary quality variables showed that the only significant relationship that was consistent for both of the years monitored was for foliar nitrogen and herbivory for both dieback and healthy trees. In the first year, regressions between herbivory and specific leaf weight, shape, or sugar content were also significant, but only amongst the dieback trees. This may indicate that these relationships were a response to, rather than a primary cause of, the repeated high defoliation of the dieback trees. Multiple regression equations incorporating annual means of several quality variables explained a high proportion of the variance in annual herbivory, but were grossly different between years.     

Influence of nutrient versus water supply on hydraulic architecture and water balance in Pinus taeda

We investigated the hydraulic consequences of a major decrease in root‐to‐leaf area ratio (A_R:A_L) caused by nutrient amendments to 15‐year‐old Pinus taeda L. stands on sandy soil. In theory, such a reduction in A_R:A_L should compromise the trees’ ability to extract water from drying sand. Under equally high soil moisture, canopy stomatal conductance (G_S) of fertilized trees (F) was 50% that of irrigated/fertilized trees (IF), irrigated trees (I), and untreated control trees (C). As predicted from theory, F trees also decreased their stomatal sensitivity to vapour pressure deficit by 50%. The lower G_S in F was associated with 50% reduction in leaf‐specific hydraulic conductance (K_L) compared with other treatments. The lower K_L in F was in turn a result of a higher leaf area per sapwood area and a lower specific conductivity (conducting efficiency) of the plant and its root xylem. The root xylem of F trees was also 50% more resistant to cavitation than the other treatments. A transport model predicted that the lower A_R:A_L in IF trees resulted in a considerably restricted ability to extract water during drought. However, this deficiency was not exposed because irrigation minimized drought. In contrast, the lower A_R:A_L in F trees caused only a limited restriction in water extraction during drought owing to the more cavitation resistant root xylem in this treatment. In both fertilized treatments, approximate safety margins from predicted hydraulic failure were minimal suggesting increased vulnerability to drought‐induced dieback compared with non‐fertilized trees. However, IF trees are likely to be so affected even under a mild drought if irrigation is withheld.     

The role of psyllids (Hemiptera: Psyllidae) and bell miners (Manorina melanophrys) in canopy dieback of Sydney blue gum (Eucalyptus saligna Sm.)

Abstract The presence of the aggressive, colony-forming honeyeater, Manorina melanophrys (bell miner), in the canopies of unhealthy eucalypts has been well reported. There is, however, some debate as to the actual mechanisms producing these unhealthy trees. To investigate further some of the processes that may be contributing to this form of canopy dieback, two field trials were carried out in Olney State Forest, near Wyong, New South Wales. The study site contained Eucalyptus saligna (Sydney blue gum) with canopy dieback and was occupied by a large colony of bell miners. Close examination of the foliage revealed a large and diverse suite of phytophagous insects, including at least 16 species of psyllid (Hemiptera: Psyllidae). In the first trial, the use of bird exclusion cages over selected branches significantly improved leaf survival compared to leaves exposed to a relatively high density of bell miners. It is proposed that colonization by bell miners may interfere with the efficacy of both other insectivorous birds (through aggressive interspecific territoriality) and the invertebrate predators and parasitoids. Interference with such regulatory factors may enable some phytophagous insect populations to rise to sustained damaging levels. In the second trial, an insecticide application combined with reduced competition from the dense understorey and neighbouring trees was required to significantly improve trunk diameter and crown condition scores. After 12 months, neither treatment, by itself, significantly improved both growth measures. Possibly both treatments were required because the E. saligna trees were suffering from another source of stress (e.g. drought) in addition to the relatively high level of insect attack.     

Responses of riparian trees to interannual variation in ground water depth in a semi-arid river basin

We investigated the physiological and growth responses of native (Populus fremontii S. Wats. and Salix gooddingii Ball) and exotic (Tamarix chinensis Lour.) riparian trees to ground water availability at the free‐flowing Hassayampa River, Arizona, during dry (1997) and wet (1998) years. In the drier year, all species experienced considerable water stress, as evidenced by low shoot water potentials, low leaf gas exchange rates and large amounts of canopy dieback. These parameters were significantly related to depth of ground water (DGW) in the native species, but not in T. chinensis, in 1997. Canopy dieback was greater in the native species than in T. chinensis when ground water was deep in 1997, and dieback increased rapidly at DGW > 2·5–3·0 m for the native species. Analysis of combined data from wet and dry years for T. chinensis tentatively suggests a similar physiological sensitivity to water availability and a similar DGW threshold for canopy dieback. In 1998, shoot water potential and leaf gas exchange rates were higher and canopy dieback was lower for all species because of increased water availability. However, T. chinensis showed a much larger increase in leaf gas exchange rates in the wet year than the native species. High leaf gas exchange rates, growth when water is abundant, drought tolerance and the maintenance of a viable canopy under dry conditions are characteristics that help explain the ability of T. chinensis to thrive in riparian ecosystems in the south‐western United States.     

SURVIVAL OF SEVERE DROUGHT BY A NON-SPROUTING CHAPARRAL SHRUB

A 2-yr drought (1975-1977) in much of California provided unusually severe water stress on many native plant species. In this paper we evaluate the effects of this drought on Arctostaphylos viscida Parry, a common non-sprouting chaparral shrub in the foothills of the southern Sierra Nevada. At the peak of the drought, water potentials as low as –74 bars were measured. While only three of 90 shrubs sampled were killed by the drought, all but one showed signs of drought-induced dieback. First and second year post-drought twig growth was significantly greater on shrubs with 90% or greater branch mortality than on those suffering lesser dieback. In all cases, new growth occurred only on surviving branches. Midday water stress measurements showed little difference for shrubs exhibiting high and low levels of dieback. These results suggest that drought survival in Arctostaphylos viscida may depend on a mechanism where certain branches are sacrificed with the surviving ones preferentially receiving available resources. The possibility that this may involve the dieback of below ground roots and/or lack of production of new roots to compensate for lack of root turnover is supported by water stress measurements of adjacent fire damaged shrubs. Implications of possible specialized drought survival mechanisms in non-sprouting shrubs are explored.     

Live crown tops of Japanese cedar (Cryptomeria japonica) approach one another in height at urban forest sites

Since the 1980s, we have found Japanese cedar, Cryptomeria japonica (L. f.) D. Don, trees with crown tops affected by dieback in isolated urban forests on the low altitude plain. To clarify future growth of C. japonica in these forests, we investigated their growth, decline levels and water status. The live crown-top heights from the ground (LCTHs) per diameter at breast height (dbh) were lower in forests with C. japonica top dieback than in forests with no top dieback. Furthermore, in a forest with C. japonica top dieback, the LCTHs were similar between trees although dbh and decline levels were different. Moreover, water status near the top of the live foliage was very similar although decline levels were different, suggesting that in urban forests, where C. japonica top dieback is observed, the LCTH is subject of restriction. A sudden increase in temperatures since the 1980s may be restricting the LCTHs of C. japonica in urban forests. We conclude that LCTHs of C. japonica in urban forests are becoming lower and more equal in each forest. If temperature continues to increase, height restriction will become more severe and LCTHs of C. japonica in urban forests will become even lower.     

Does stand structure influence susceptibility of eucalypt floodplain forests to dieback?

Forest dieback is a worldwide problem that is likely to increase with climate change and increasing human demands for resources. Eucalyptus camaldulensis forests are an acute example of forest dieback, with 70% of the Victorian Murray River floodplain in some state of dieback. If we are to halt dieback in these floodplain forests, we need to understand what makes stands susceptible to dieback. Forest diebacks are often related to stand structure, with dieback more severe in senescent or high‐density stands. We determined whether certain stand structures make these forests more susceptible to dieback. We undertook an extensive survey of 176 stands across 100 000 ha of forest, covering the range of stand condition on this floodplain. Large and small trees (20‐, 40‐, 80‐ and 120‐cm diameter) showed a similar reduction in the probability of being alive with decreasing stand condition. A slight improvement in stand condition was found at higher densities and basal areas, which may reflect the higher productivity or younger age of these stands. Stand condition was moderately, positively correlated with longitude, with stand condition being higher in the east of the Murray River floodplain where flooding frequencies are currently higher. This suggests that dieback of these floodplain forests would be more effectively mitigated by increased water availability through flooding than by altering stand structure.     

Effects of a Severe Drought on Water and Nitrogen Use by Quercus ilex and Phyllyrea latifolia

A severe drought that took place in Spain and other Mediterranean countries in 1994 produced a dieback of Quercus ilex trees on south-facing conglomerates but only minor defoliations in trees on north-facing schists. The foliar ¹³C of damaged trees continued to decrease in the next two wet years probably indicating increasing water use efficiency, and their ¹⁵N continued to increase indicating progressive ecosystem N saturation and/or N losses whereas there were no significant changes in undamaged trees. Pre-drought ¹³C values were reached in the third year after the drought, but ¹⁵N values did not yet recover. Another co-occurring small tree, Phyllyrea latifolia, did not show any damage and gained dominance in the most affected stands.     

Weather underground: Subsurface hydrologic processes mediate tree vulnerability to extreme climatic drought

Drought extent and severity have increased and are predicted to continue to increase in many parts of the world. Understanding tree vulnerability to drought at both individual and species levels is key to ongoing forest management and preparation for future transitions in community composition. The influence of subsurface hydrologic processes is particularly important in water‐limited ecosystems, and is an under‐studied aspect of tree drought vulnerability. With California's 2013–2016 extraordinary drought as a natural experiment, we studied four co‐occurring woodland tree species, blue oak (Quercus douglasii), valley oak (Quercus lobata), gray pine (Pinus sabiniana), and California juniper (Juniperus californica), examining drought vulnerability as a function of climate, lithology and hydrology using regional aerial dieback surveys and site‐scale field surveys. We found that in addition to climatic drought severity (i.e., rainfall), subsurface processes explained variation in drought vulnerability within and across species at both scales. Regionally for blue oak, severity of dieback was related to the bedrock lithology, with higher mortality on igneous and metamorphic substrates, and to regional reductions in groundwater. At the site scale, access to deep subsurface water, evidenced by stem water stable isotope composition, was related to canopy condition across all species. Along hillslope gradients, channel locations supported similar environments in terms of water stress across a wide climatic gradient, indicating that subsurface hydrology mediates species’ experience of drought, and that areas associated with persistent access to subsurface hydrologic resources may provide important refugia at species’ xeric range edges. Despite this persistent overall influence of the subsurface environment, individual species showed markedly different response patterns. We argue that hydrologic niche segregation can be a useful lens through which to interpret these differences in vulnerability to climatic drought and climate change.     

Future vulnerability mapping based on response to extreme climate events: Dieback thresholds in an endemic California oak

Aim

This study presents a bioclimate modelling approach, using responses to extreme climate events, rather than historical distributional associations, to project future species vulnerability and refugia. We aim to illustrate the compounding effects of groundwater loss and climate on species vulnerability.

Location

California, USA.

Methods

As a case study, we used the 2012–2015 California drought and resulting extensive dieback of blue oak (Quercus douglasii). We used aerial dieback surveys, downscaled climate data and subsurface water change data to develop boosted regression tree models identifying key thresholds associated with dieback throughout the blue oak distribution. We (1) combined observed dieback–climatic threshold relationships with climate futures to anticipate future areas of vulnerability and (2) used satellite‐derived measurements of subsurface water loss in drought/dieback modelling to capture the mediating effect of groundwater on species response to climatic drought.

Results

A model including climate, climate anomalies and subsurface water change explained 46% of the variability in dieback. Precipitation in 2015 and subsurface water change accounted for 62.6% of the modelled probability of dieback. We found an interaction between precipitation and subsurface water in which dieback probability increased with low precipitation and subsurface water loss. The relationship between precipitation and dieback was nonlinear, with 99% of dieback occurring in areas that received <363 mm precipitation. Based on a MIROC_rcp85 future climate scenario, relative to historical conditions, 13% of the blue oak distribution is predicted to experience more frequent years below this precipitation threshold by mid‐century and 81% by end of century.

Main conclusions

As ongoing climate change and extreme events impact ecological processes, the identification of thresholds associated with observed dieback may be combined with climate futures to help identify vulnerable populations and refugia and prioritize climate change‐related conservation efforts.